Free second-opinion malware scans on Windows: ESET Online Scanner, Malwarebytes, HouseCall and ClamShield

ESET Online Scanner adds a second vendor’s detection to Microsoft Defender at no cost and without a classic install. ESET remains our recommendation when your antivirus comes from another vendor. Malwarebytes suits Windows on Arm. HouseCall offers another free second opinion; ClamShield is our Rising Star for configurable local scans. ESET’s lead is narrow.

PRACTICAL PICKSPreferredPickOur Preferred PickA second opinion alongside Defender$0

ESET Online Scanner

Our narrow preference: a free scan with ESET’s own detection, not the Microsoft intelligence your PC already uses, with full, quick and custom scans and an optional monthly check.

Current version needs 64-bit Windows. It keeps app data and logs unless you choose to delete them, and its policy covers update statistics, including IP and MAC address.

Why ESET Online Scanner is our Pick
PRACTICAL PICKSRisingStarOur Rising StarConfigurable local ClamAV and YARA scans$0

ClamShield

Full, folder, file and process scans with signature updates and quarantine. Its security policy says Defender changes require an explicit user setting or action; leave those and optional exclusions off. Its installer is self-signed, so Windows may warn before it runs; do not click past the warning, and use ESET Online Scanner if Windows blocks it.

More engine, rule and cleanup upkeep than ESET; enabling cloud checks can upload unknown files.

Why ClamShield is our Rising Star

Who is this article for? Windows 10 and 11 users who already run maintained antivirus, usually Microsoft Defender, and want an occasional free second-opinion scan. Not incident response, business cleanup or a replacement for antivirus.

About 26 min read

What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean

The quick list

Choose ESET Online Scanner for a second opinion alongside Defender. All four scans are free for personal use. Compare whose detection each adds to the antivirus you already have, what stays on your PC and what each sends to its vendor.

The four scans compared here cost nothing for personal use. ESET, HouseCall and ClamShield’s free offers were checked November 4, 2026; Malwarebytes’ personal-use evidence was checked October 19. Other candidates’ prices and limits are discussed in our research notes below. Paid security suites and trials are separate from these free scans.

The comparison at a glance

Compare whose detection each scanner adds, which scans are free, what stays on your PC, what it sends to its vendor and which Windows PCs it runs on.

ESET is our narrow preference alongside Defender. The alternatives suit different needs; this order does not rank measured detection, speed or safety. ClamShield is our Rising Star for configurable local scans. All tools remain selectable.

Free on-demand malware scanners for Windows
FeatureESET Online ScannerMalwarebytesTrend Micro HouseCallClamShield
Best fitPreferred Pick: a free second opinion alongside Microsoft DefenderWindows 11 on Arm, or a scanner you keep installedAnother free second opinion; ESET remains our narrow preferenceRising Star: configurable local scans; keep Defender changes and exclusions off
Price for this use$0; paid ESET HOME Security trial is separate$0 Free plan; Threat Scan, scheduling and real-time protection are paid$0 for scanning and removal$0 local core; optional paid signatures not needed
Whose detectionESET detection modules, downloaded before scanningMalwarebytes detection databasesTrend Micro detection; comparative performance not establishedClamAV and YARA; optional VirusTotal not required
Free scan typesFull, quick and customCustom (chosen folders; optional rootkit check of the system drive); Quick free in the plan table, paid in the scan guideQuick, full and customFull, folder, file and process
Free repeat scansMonthly quick check on a day and time you chooseOne opt-in monthly scan; other schedules paidNo free schedule documentedScheduling documented; keep real-time features off for this use
What stays on your PCApp data, shortcut and logs until you choose to delete them; needs 400 MB freeInstalled app with extra free tools; 1 GB disk and 4 GB memoryDownloaded Windows program; retained files and cleanup not establishedInstalled app, local service, engines, rules and retained ProgramData state
Data sent to the vendorUpdate statistics including IP and MAC address, kept up to 4 years; hash lookups on by default per license; samples opt-inInstall ID, settings, Windows Security status and detections; some statistics can be turned offProduct-specific collection not establishedLocal scans; VirusTotal disabled by default; enabling cloud checks can upload unknown files
Windows and processors64-bit Windows; Arm not documentedWindows 10 and 11, including Windows 11 on Arm; S mode offWindows download; current processor support not establishedWindows installer; precise OS and processor matrix not established

ESET remains our narrow preference for a second opinion alongside Defender. HouseCall product claims checked November 4, 2026: https://www.trendmicro.com/en_us/forHome/products/housecall.html. Personal Windows use alongside maintained antivirus; not incident response, business cleanup or an antivirus replacement. None of the four scans from a browser, despite ESET’s product name. Incumbent sources checked October 19, 2026; ClamShield documentation and security policy checked November 4, 2026: https://github.com/orloxgr/ClamShield/blob/main/SECURITY.md and https://github.com/orloxgr/ClamShield. “Not documented” means we found no public statement, not that the feature is absent. No detection, speed or false-positive ranking: independent labs test these vendors’ full products, not these free scanners. Keep your antivirus running; an optional scan that fails is not a reason to turn it off. No scan proves a PC clean. Next review December 18, 2026, or sooner after a material product or security change.

All features and sources 26 criteria

Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.

Fit, cost and supported systems

Show 8 criteria
Fit, cost and supported systems
FeatureESET Online ScannerMalwarebytesTrend Micro HouseCallClamShield
Best fitPreferred Pick: a free second opinion alongside Microsoft DefenderWindows 11 on Arm, or a scanner you keep installedAnother free second opinion; ESET remains our narrow preferenceRising Star: configurable local scans; keep Defender changes and exclusions off
Price for this use$0; paid ESET HOME Security trial is separate$0 Free plan; Threat Scan, scheduling and real-time protection are paid$0 for scanning and removal$0 local core; optional paid signatures not needed
Overall assessment3.95/5 · narrow preference3.68/53.70/53.73/5
Main compromise64-bit only; keeps data until you delete itWhole-system scan is paid; larger installLess detail on data collection, cleanup and recoveryEngine/rule upkeep and more complex settings; optional Defender changes must stay off
Whose detectionESET detection modules, downloaded before scanningMalwarebytes detection databasesTrend Micro detection; comparative performance not establishedClamAV and YARA; optional VirusTotal not required
Version and currency4.0.1.0, released July 9, 20265.7.3 (component package 167.0.5780), released October 15, 2026Current build not establishedPublic beta 1.4.5, November 4, 2026
Windows and processors64-bit Windows; Arm not documentedWindows 10 and 11, including Windows 11 on Arm; S mode offWindows download; current processor support not establishedWindows installer; precise OS and processor matrix not established
License and useHome Edition for private, non-commercial use; support at ESET’s discretionFree Home license for personal, non-commercial use; not servers or business devicesFree scanning and removal advertised; detailed free-tool terms not readableGPL local core; no required paid signatures
Sources for fit, cost and supported systems

Checked October 19, 2026: ESET guide, version list, changelog, FAQ, US page and license; Microsoft Safety Scanner and security intelligence updates; Malwarebytes plan table, requirements, release list and license. A Windows version on a compatibility list is not continued Windows support.

Scans and updates

Show 8 criteria
Scans and updates
FeatureESET Online ScannerMalwarebytesTrend Micro HouseCallClamShield
Free scan typesFull, quick and customCustom (chosen folders; optional rootkit check of the system drive); Quick free in the plan table, paid in the scan guideQuick, full and customFull, folder, file and process
Keeping detection currentUpdates modules before scanning; can run without internet later if data is kept, but modules ageInternet needed for app, component and database updatesCurrent definition update process not establishedClamAV signature updates and separately maintained YARA Forge rules
Unwanted-software controlsPotentially unwanted, suspicious and potentially unsafe applicationsChoose how unwanted programs and modifications are treated in Custom ScanNo equivalent user setting documentedOptional rule profiles; broader rules can increase false positives
Rootkit checkAnti-stealth included, per ESETCustom Scan only, with the whole system drive selectedNo separate setting documentedProcess scans; no equivalent anti-stealth claim established
ArchivesOptional archive scanning in custom scansNo archive-specific setting documentedNo archive-specific setting documentedClamAV/YARA controls; exact archive settings not established
Free repeat scansMonthly quick check on a day and time you chooseOne opt-in monthly scan; other schedules paidNo free schedule documentedScheduling documented; keep real-time features off for this use
Continuous protectionNonePaid or trial onlyNot a replacement for maintained antivirusOptional shield; not required for this manual-scan use
Running beside your antivirusESET says it runs alongside any antivirus; its 2022 FAQ suggests pausing other protection, which we do not adviseFree plan adds no real-time protectionTrend Micro says no need to remove existing antivirusDefender changes require user action; leave pause and compatibility exclusions off
Sources for scans and updates

Results, quarantine and records

Show 5 criteria
Results, quarantine and records
FeatureESET Online ScannerMalwarebytesTrend Micro HouseCallClamShield
After a detectionResolved and unresolved lists; restart to clean unresolved itemsQuarantine with restore and permanent deleteThreat removal advertised; precise remediation controls not establishedQuarantine and exception flows documented
Default quarantineDetected items quarantined by defaultAutomatic quarantine on by defaultDefaults not documentedExact default not established
Automatic release of false positivesNot documentedOn by default: items later judged benign leave quarantineNot documentedNo automatic release documented
Restoring filesRestore cleaned files; quarantined files cannot be deleted one by oneRestore, optionally excluding the item from future scansRecovery interface not establishedQuarantine/restore documented; not independently exercised
Scan recordsLog appended after each scan, in the user Temp folderDetection History in the appThreat report advertisedLocal logs and scan results; diagnostics redact credentials
Sources for results, quarantine and records

ESET results and quarantine and logs and quarantine defaults, 2022 FAQ; Microsoft result and error handling and log location; Malwarebytes quarantine defaults. No quarantine, restore or removal was performed. Another scanner not flagging a file is not a reason to restore it.

Account, data and leaving

Show 5 criteria
Account, data and leaving
FeatureESET Online ScannerMalwarebytesTrend Micro HouseCallClamShield
What stays on your PCApp data, shortcut and logs until you choose to delete them; needs 400 MB freeInstalled app with extra free tools; 1 GB disk and 4 GB memoryDownloaded Windows program; retained files and cleanup not establishedInstalled app, local service, engines, rules and retained ProgramData state
Account or emailNo account; emailed results optionalFree onboarding not established; first-run scan bundle asks for email; free VPN needs an accountNo account requirement stated on product pageNo account for local core; optional VirusTotal needs a key
Data sent to the vendorUpdate statistics including IP and MAC address, kept up to 4 years; hash lookups on by default per license; samples opt-inInstall ID, settings, Windows Security status and detections; some statistics can be turned offProduct-specific collection not establishedLocal scans; VirusTotal disabled by default; enabling cloud checks can upload unknown files
Privacy choicesOpt in or out of the customer experience program and detection feedback at setupOpt out of some usage and threat statisticsProduct-specific choices not establishedCloud checks off by default; file upload can follow enabled cloud scan
Removing itTick “Delete application data on closing”; folders remain while files are quarantinedUninstall through Windows; does not cancel a subscriptionCleanup steps not establishedDocumented uninstall cleanup; review retained quarantine and local data first
Sources for account, data and leaving

What matters when choosing

ESET Online Scanner is our Practical Pick for a Windows 10 or 11 user who already runs maintained antivirus, usually the Microsoft Defender built into Windows, and wants an occasional free second-opinion scan. It is a free ESET program you download and run, not a classic installation, and it gives no ongoing protection. What separates it is whose detection it adds. Microsoft says its own Safety Scanner uses the same security intelligence version as Microsoft Defender, so on a PC that already runs Defender it repeats the same detection. ESET’s scanner downloads ESET’s own detection modules and offers full, quick and custom scans at no cost, optional checks for unwanted, suspicious and potentially unsafe applications, and an optional free monthly quick check. ESET says it can run alongside any existing antivirus. ESET guide, ESET FAQ, Safety Scanner, Microsoft antivirus FAQ

ESET’s lead is narrow: HouseCall also offers free quick, full and custom scans alongside your existing antivirus, but its public documentation leaves more questions about data collection and cleanup. ESET remains our recommendation for a second opinion alongside Defender.

ClamShield is our Rising Star at 3.73/5: configurable local ClamAV/YARA scanning with documented user control over Defender changes. Leave those changes and optional exclusions off. It needs more engine, rule and cleanup upkeep than ESET, our narrow preference at 3.95/5. ClamShield security policy (checked November 4, 2026).

The most important compromises are platform and leftovers. The current 4.0 line, version 4.0.1.0 from July 9, 2026, runs only on 64-bit Windows, and we found no ESET statement that it supports Windows on Arm. It keeps application data, a shortcut and logs until you tick “Delete application data on closing”, and its privacy policy covers update statistics, including IP and MAC addresses, kept for up to four years. It is not a no-upload tool. Version list, changelog, removal, privacy policy

If your PC runs Windows 11 on Arm, or you want a scanner that stays installed with a detection history, choose Malwarebytes. Its free plan includes Custom Scan and a monthly scan, but its whole-system Threat Scan and general scheduling are paid, its own pages disagree on whether Quick Scan is free, and the free app brings extra tools, including since September 2026 a VPN that needs a Malwarebytes account. Malwarebytes plans, requirements

A completed scan reports what that tool detected in the places it looked. It does not prove a PC clean or that your accounts are safe, and this comparison is not a guide to handling an active compromise. We did not download or run any scanner. Independent labs test these vendors’ full security products, not these free scanners, so we publish no detection, speed or false-positive ranking. Microsoft says Safety Scanner does not replace antivirus, and ESET says its scanner gives no continuous protection. Microsoft scope, ESET FAQ

Download scanners only from the vendors’ own pages. Our search for new scanners turned up code-hosting repositories that use established security brands’ names for “setup guides” and downloads. Do not turn off your antivirus or click past a security warning to run an optional scan: Microsoft warns that a PC without another active security product is vulnerable if Defender is disabled, and ESET’s 2022 FAQ suggestion to pause other real-time protection for speed is one we do not recommend. If you typed passwords on a PC you suspect, ESET advises changing them from a known-safe device. Microsoft antivirus FAQ, ESET scanner page

Disclosure: Practical Picks articles are researched and written with AI, currently Anthropic’s Claude. Malwarebytes makes an official Claude connector for checking links and messages. We have no relationship with Malwarebytes or Anthropic over this article, and these Claude links carried no weight in our judgment. Malwarebytes connector

ESET Online Scanner

Preferred Pick · a second opinion alongside Defender

$0Free · 64-bit Windows, no classic install

Choose ESET Online Scanner for an occasional free check by a different vendor’s detection than the Microsoft Defender built into Windows. Every scan type is free, and you can delete its data when you close it.

Reasons to choose it

  • Adds ESET’s detection to Defender’s, which Safety Scanner shares
  • Full, quick and custom scans, with optional checks for unwanted, suspicious and unsafe apps
  • Optional free monthly quick check and no account

What to watch

  • Current version runs on 64-bit Windows only; Arm support not documented
  • Keeps app data and logs until you choose to delete them; quarantined files keep its folders
  • Update statistics, including IP and MAC address, kept up to four years

ESET Online Scanner is a Windows program, despite its name, not a browser page that scans your PC remotely. You download it from ESET, confirm the Windows administrator prompt, accept the terms, choose whether to join ESET’s customer experience program and its detection feedback system, then pick a full, quick or custom scan. It needs 400 MB of free disk space. The free scanner is separate from the 30-day ESET HOME Security Premium trial promoted on the same US page. We verified on October 19, 2026 that ESET lists version 4.0.1.0, released July 9, 2026, with full support. Scanner guide, US page, version list

Its strongest reason to choose it is a second vendor’s detection at no cost. ESET’s FAQ says the scanner downloads ESET’s modules before scanning and includes ESET’s anti-stealth technology for rootkits. Custom scans let you choose locations and add checks for suspicious applications, such as programs compressed with packers, potentially unsafe applications, such as legitimate remote-administration tools that can be misused, and archives. Those categories are not the same as confirmed malware. The strongest reason not to choose it is platform: version 4.0 removed 32-bit support, and we found no ESET statement about Windows on Arm. ESET’s US page still links to a separate 32-bit download, and we did not establish which version it delivers. ESET FAQ, scanner guide, changelog, US page

Read the full ESET Online Scanner analysis and sources

The optional periodic scan is a quick check of often-infected areas, not a repeat of a full scan. It runs monthly on a day and time you choose, needs the scanner to run as administrator and works only if you keep its application data. ESET’s help explains how to change the schedule but not how to turn it off. If you keep the data, ESET’s 2022 FAQ says the scanner can run without internet access after its first module update; its modules then age. Periodic scan, ESET FAQ

Results separate resolved detections from unresolved ones, and ESET says you must restart to clean the unresolved items. Detected items go to quarantine by default. You can restore cleaned files, but you cannot delete individual quarantined files; ESET says to remove the scanner and run it again. The 2022 FAQ says each scan appends to a log in your user account’s Temp folder, which is hidden by default. Quarantine, ESET FAQ

Leaving takes a deliberate step. Tick “Delete application data on closing” at the end of the first scan, or later in Settings; some parts, such as the Start menu shortcut, go only after a restart. The 2022 FAQ adds that if any files are in quarantine, the scanner’s folders under your user profile are not removed. Decide what to do with quarantined files before you clean up. Removal, ESET FAQ

Check the data terms before you run it. The scanner’s privacy policy covers update and other statistics, including operating system, hardware, installation and license IDs, IP and MAC addresses and configuration, kept for up to four years. It says feedback samples and their metadata are meant to be collected without identifying you, but that personal data can be included by accident. The scanner’s license, effective October 19, 2021, says reputation lookups using one-way hashes are on by default, that feedback can be turned on, and that you can turn these functions off. ESET’s 2022 FAQ says the scanner does not use this LiveGrid system, while the current guide names LiveGrid as a setup choice. We could not establish exactly what version 4.0.1 sends by default. Emailed results are optional. Privacy policy, license, ESET FAQ, scanner guide

The license names ESET, spol. s r.o., of Bratislava, Slovakia. It limits the Home Edition to private, non-commercial use, provides the software “as is”, makes technical support discretionary and ends your right to use a version at its end-of-life date. ESET’s changelog lists a DLL hijacking fix in version 3.4.7; that is a reason to use the current release, not evidence of a flaw in it. We found no ESET security advisory naming the Online Scanner since our September review. License, changelog, ESET advisories

Used ESET Online Scanner? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Malwarebytes

Also consider · Windows on Arm, or a scanner you keep

$0Free plan · Custom Scan; Threat Scan paid

Choose Malwarebytes when your PC runs Windows 11 on Arm, or when you want a non-Microsoft scanner that stays installed with a detection history. Use its free Custom Scan; the whole-system Threat Scan is a paid feature.

Reasons to choose it

  • Windows 11 on Arm support documented
  • Custom Scan of chosen folders, with an optional rootkit check of the system drive
  • Free monthly scan, plus a detection history you can restore from

What to watch

  • Threat Scan and general scheduling need a subscription; its pages conflict on Quick Scan
  • Full installed app with extra tools: 1 GB disk, 4 GB memory
  • Automatically releases items it later judges to be false positives

Malwarebytes for Windows is an installed app; without a subscription it scans only when you ask. Its Free vs Paid table, last edited October 5, 2026, lists Quick and Custom scans as free, Threat Scan as paid, scheduled scans as paid apart from one free monthly scan, and all real-time protection as paid. Threat Scan is the scan of common system locations that Malwarebytes recommends for a whole-device check, so a free user relies on Custom Scan, where you choose folders, and the monthly scan. Its June 30, 2026 scan-type guide still says Quick Scan is paid on Windows; we cannot tell which page is current without installing the app. The latest release is 5.7.3, from October 15, 2026. Plan table, scan types, Custom Scan, monthly scan, release list

Its strongest reasons to choose it are Arm support and a record you keep. Malwarebytes documents support for Windows 11 on Arm, needs Windows 10 or 11 with 4 GB of memory, 1 GB of disk space and S mode turned off, and keeps a Detection History where you can restore or permanently delete quarantined items. The strongest reason not to choose it is size: the free plan installs a broader app, with privacy controls, firewall control, a file shredder, Scam Guard and, from version 5.7.0 on September 8, 2026, a free VPN, rolling out gradually, with 10 GB every 30 days that needs a Malwarebytes account. We are not recommending turning off S mode. Requirements, quarantine, plan table, version 5.7.0, free VPN

Read the full Malwarebytes analysis and sources

Custom Scan also lets you decide how potentially unwanted programs and modifications are treated. Rootkit scanning is available only there, and only with the whole system drive selected; Malwarebytes warns that it adds significant time and that results are more likely to be false positives. The free monthly scan is opt-in, and its prompt calls it “a full scan once a month”. Custom Scan, rootkits, monthly scan

Quarantine has a default worth knowing. Automatic quarantine is on, and so is automatic release of items Malwarebytes later judges benign. When you restore an item yourself, you can also exclude it from future detections, which changes what later scans check. Do not restore something only because another scanner did not flag it. We could not establish what happens to quarantined items when you uninstall. Quarantine

Setup help is written for subscribers: it covers activation with an account, license key or code, and a one-time first-run scan bundle that asks for your email. We could not establish every prompt a free user sees or whether installation starts a trial. The license says trials last 30 days unless Malwarebytes specifies otherwise, and that the free Home license covers personal, non-commercial use, not servers or devices used for business. Uninstalling through Windows does not cancel a paid subscription. Installation, license, uninstall

The privacy policy, last updated August 26, 2026, says the software creates an identifier at install time and collects license details, operating system, language, processor architecture, information from Windows Security, program settings and data about detected malware and unwanted programs. It says IP addresses are used for approximate location but not stored, that some usage and threat statistics can be turned off in certain products, and that Malwarebytes does not sell personal data for money. Turning off statistics does not stop all collection. Privacy policy

Two historical records have limits. In January 2021 Malwarebytes disclosed limited access to internal email by the attacker behind the SolarWinds breach and said its production software was not affected. Enigma Software sued Malwarebytes in 2017 over its classification of Enigma’s programs; after a June 2024 order denied a renewed motion to dismiss, the parties jointly dismissed the case and Malwarebytes’ counterclaims with prejudice on October 14, 2024, each paying its own costs. That ended the case without a court finding of liability. Neither record is evidence about today’s free scan. Incident disclosure, June 2024 order, joint stipulation of dismissal

Used Malwarebytes? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Trend Micro HouseCall

Alternative · Trend Micro detection alongside your antivirus

$0Free · quick, full and custom scans

HouseCall offers a different vendor’s detection without removing your existing antivirus. ESET remains our preference for its clearer documentation of controls, data and cleanup.

Reasons to choose it

  • Free scanning and removal
  • Quick, full and custom scans
  • Trend Micro says it works alongside existing antivirus

What to watch

  • Product-specific data collection could not be established
  • Cleanup and quarantine recovery are unclear
  • Current processor support is not established

HouseCall is a Windows program you download from Trend Micro, despite the “online scan” name. Its product page says it detects and cleans malware for free, offers quick, full and custom scans, and works with existing antivirus without requiring its removal. Those documented scan choices make it a credible alternative to ESET for a PC already protected by Defender. We checked the page on November 4, 2026. HouseCall

Choose it if you want Trend Micro’s detection and these scan choices. ESET remains our preference because its documentation gives a clearer account of scan controls, retained data and removal. HouseCall’s page does not establish exactly what it uploads, what remains after use, quarantine recovery, or current Windows processor support. We could not read its linked product privacy terms. Treat its speed and protection promises as vendor claims: we have no comparable detection, speed or false-positive results for this scanner. Keep your everyday antivirus running.

Used Trend Micro HouseCall? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

ClamShield

Rising Star · configurable local scans

$0Free local core · optional cloud services separate

Choose ClamShield for local ClamAV and YARA scans with more control over engines and rules. Keep Defender pause, compatibility exclusions and cloud uploads off for this use. Its self-signed installer may trigger a Windows warning; do not click past it, and use ESET if Windows blocks it.

Reasons to choose it

  • Full, folder, file and process scans
  • Free local core with signature updates and quarantine
  • Security policy makes Defender changes user-enabled

What to watch

  • More engine, rule and cleanup upkeep than ESET
  • Enabling cloud checks can upload unknown files
  • Installer equivalence and detection performance not independently verified

ClamShield is a Windows public beta that combines ClamAV and YARA with full, folder, file and process scans, quarantine and signature updates. Its free local core needs no paid signature service or VirusTotal account. Choose it if you want control over those engines and are comfortable maintaining rules and reviewing findings. It scores 3.73/5 against ESET’s 3.95; ESET remains our narrow preference for a simpler occasional check. Documentation, releases (checked November 4, 2026).

Keep your existing antivirus running. ClamShield’s security policy says it requests Defender changes only when a user enables the relevant setting or action; its compatibility exclusions are optional. Leave Defender pause, exclusions and cloud uploads off for this local second-opinion use. VirusTotal is disabled by default, but enabling the on-demand cloud check can upload unknown files; local scanning does not require it. Security policy, settings and cloud documentation (checked November 4, 2026).

Read the full ClamShield analysis and sources

Its installer is signed with the project’s own self-signed certificate, not one Windows trusts, so Windows may show a security warning when you run it. Do not click past that warning; if Windows blocks the installer, use ESET Online Scanner instead. The main compromise is upkeep: an installed application, local service, separately maintained engines and rules, and retained scan/quarantine data. Its documentation describes uninstall cleanup; confirm what you need from quarantine first. The maker describes security audits and release checks, but we have not independently verified those checks or installer equivalence. Third-party issue reports mention false positives, without establishing a representative error rate. No published advisory in its listing is not proof of security. These are reasons to review findings carefully, not turn off protection or assume every flag is malware. Cleanup documentation, reported issues, advisory listing (checked November 4, 2026).

Used ClamShield? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Which product are we missing?

Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.

Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.

Suggest a product

Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.

No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.

What people are saying

Public reports are a check on vendor documentation, not a measured failure rate. From August 18, 2026, users reported Microsoft Defender scans crashing, and Windows Central’s coverage of those reports included Safety Scanner. Microsoft told BleepingComputer on August 19 that it had fixed the problem in security intelligence 1.457.236.0 or later. Microsoft did not name Safety Scanner, and we could not verify how the scanner behaved; current downloads use later intelligence. Windows Central, August 2026, BleepingComputer, August 19, 2026

In August 2026 Malwarebytes users asked where the rootkit option had gone; a vendor reply pointed to the Custom Scan change, which its help confirms. ESET reports include older confusion over quarantine and cleanup and a 2026 complaint of an interface showing no text. We read these on September 7, 2026; Reddit did not load for our automated check on October 19. They show that problems were reported, not how often they happen. We did not adopt community suggestions to disable protection, edit the registry or delete security files by hand. Malwarebytes discussion, older ESET quarantine discussion, ESET interface report

Our October 19 search for newer complaints, security advisories, incidents, lawsuits and regulatory actions involving the three scanners and their makers found nothing that changed these conclusions. ESET’s recent advisories concern other ESET products, and the Enigma case had already ended in 2024. A search that finds nothing is not proof that nothing exists.

How we researched

This is public-source research. We did not download, install or run any scanner, handle malware samples, create accounts, submit files or test removal. No vendor supplied access, payment or input, and we use no affiliate links. We first compared these three scanners on September 7, 2026, and rechecked every material claim on October 19, 2026: versions, free and paid scan gates, supported Windows versions and processors, scan controls, quarantine defaults, removal, privacy terms and licenses. Malwarebytes’ help center did not load for our automated check, so we read the same articles through its public help-center feed, which returns the published text and edit dates. AV-Comparatives’ test pages returned a server error on October 19, so that test is cited as read on September 7.

We wrote this for someone who already has maintained antivirus and wants an occasional free check from a second tool. We fixed five criteria and their weights before comparing: second-opinion value, meaning whose detection the tool adds and which scans it offers (30%); cost for the same personal scanning task (20%); what stays on the PC and how you remove it (20%); data handling (15%); and supported Windows versions and processors (15%). ESET Online Scanner remains our recommendation. Its total is 3.95/5, compared with HouseCall’s 3.70, Malwarebytes’ 3.68 and Safety Scanner’s 3.48. ClamShield scores 3.73/5, making ESET’s lead narrow. ESET still leads the original three when the existing antivirus is non-Microsoft (3.95 versus Safety Scanner’s 3.93), and when footprint gets 35% of the weight (3.88 versus 3.80). Giving Windows on Arm support 30% of the weight favors Malwarebytes among those three (3.90 versus ESET’s 3.55 and Safety Scanner’s 3.40).

Microsoft Safety Scanner scores 3.48/5 for our main reader. Its portability remains useful if you need a scan that installs nothing: download a fresh executable before each scan, then delete it afterwards. It expires ten days after download; its log remains, and Microsoft documents no schedule, quarantine manager or scanner-specific data collection. It shares Defender’s security intelligence, so it repeats that detection on a Defender-protected PC. ESET still leads when the existing antivirus comes from another vendor. Safety Scanner, scan modes and privacy reference, troubleshooting (checked October 19, 2026).

Independent labs do not test these free scanners. AV-TEST’s March–April 2026 report covers Malwarebytes Premium 5.5 with all its protection layers, and AV-Comparatives’ March 2026 malware protection test covers Malwarebytes Premium, ESET HOME Security Essential and Microsoft Defender Antivirus. We do not transfer those results to the scanners.

On November 4, 2026 we checked public product pages and code-hosting listings for additional options. HouseCall belongs in this comparison: Trend Micro documents free quick, full and custom scans that work alongside existing antivirus. Norton says Power Eraser stopped working on April 30, 2026. F-Secure Online Scanner still tells users to uninstall other antivirus first, which conflicts with keeping your protection running. Kaspersky’s utility fits the scanning task, but US restrictions on its provision and updates make it unsuitable for our US readers. HouseCall, Norton retirement, F-Secure, US Commerce Department (checked November 4, 2026).

We could not confirm suitable ongoing personal-use prices for Emsisoft Emergency Kit, HitmanPro, Zemana AntiMalware, Comodo Cleaning Essentials or Blade Antivirus. Gridinsoft advertises a $39.95 annual Standard plan for up to two home PCs, but its paid scan is not one of the free options compared here. Dr.Web CureIt! scores 3.55/5 on documented features; its free download requires name, email and agreement to send scan and PC configuration statistics, while its full personal license and coexistence details remain unclear. ClamWin scores 3.23/5, but its current supported engine and usable installer remain unclear. Warden scores 3.60/5: it documents local manual scans with Defender kept on, but broader signatures require additional rules or a separate ClamAV installation. OpenSecurity scores 3.30/5; its local CLI/WPF scans require more manual content maintenance. Emsisoft, HitmanPro, Zemana, Gridinsoft, CureIt download, ClamWin, Warden, OpenSecurity (checked November 4, 2026).

ClamShield is our Rising Star. Its public beta documents local ClamAV/YARA scans and quarantine. Its security policy says Defender changes require an explicit user setting or action, and compatibility exclusions are optional: leave both off for this use. Warden and OpenSecurity also document the core task but score lower; Blade’s ordinary-use license and safety details remain unclear, and pyguard-scanner’s bundled database contains only EICAR and a placeholder. Launch-directory pages could not be read, so this search used repository pages and our earlier candidate records. ClamShield security policy, Warden, OpenSecurity, Blade, pyguard-scanner (checked November 4, 2026).

ToolPublic sourcesWhat remains uncertain
ESET Online ScannerScanner guide, periodic scan, quarantine and removal help, version list, changelog, 2022 FAQ, scanner privacy policy and license, US product page, ESET advisories.Arm support, what the US 32-bit link delivers, what version 4.0.1 sends by default, full cleanup when files are quarantined, detection accuracy.
Microsoft Safety ScannerDownload and requirements page, security intelligence page, troubleshooting help, Exchange tooling documentation, antivirus FAQ.What the scanner sends to Microsoft, its executable license, Arm support, scan completion in current builds, detection accuracy.
Trend Micro HouseCallProduct page: free scanning and removal, quick/full/custom choices, works with existing antivirus; checked November 4, 2026.Product-specific collection, cleanup and recovery, current processor support and detection accuracy.
ClamShield and other newcomersDocumentation and releases, ClamShield security policy, advisory listing and third-party issue reports; checked November 4, 2026.Actual detection, defaults and installer equivalence are not independently verified; Blade license/safety and pyguard ordinary detection coverage do not support recommendation.
MalwarebytesPlan table, scan-type, Custom Scan, rootkit, monthly scan, quarantine, requirements, install and uninstall help, release notes, license, privacy policy, court records.Whether Quick Scan is free, free onboarding and any trial, quarantine after uninstall, detection accuracy of the free scan.

None of this establishes that any scanner finds or removes malware on your PC. Next substantive review is due December 18, 2026, or sooner after a change to free scan gates, supported systems, privacy terms or a security advisory. Found a changed version or term? Contact the editors.

Sources and evidence

Incumbent sources were checked October 19, 2026 unless another date is given. Additional product and newcomer sources were checked November 4, 2026. Vendor material establishes documented features and terms, not detection or removal performance. Community posts are attributed experiences, not representative samples.

This is a researched comparison, not a product review. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.