Password managers for one person's everyday accounts: Bitwarden, Proton Pass, 1Password and Keeper
Bitwarden is free on every device and the easiest to leave, as long as you prepare a way back in. Proton Pass adds email aliases and a recovery phrase you control, 1Password is the paid choice for regaining access on your own, and Keeper is a paid alternative with a recovery phrase.
Bitwarden
Unlimited passwords, passkeys and devices on the Free plan, read-only offline access, and the fullest export options here. Premium adds emergency access for $19.80 a year.
Bitwarden cannot reset a forgotten master password: prepare a trusted contact, a second logged-in device or an unlocking passkey.
Why Bitwarden is our PickTeam behind Bitwarden? Get your award badge
No Rising Star selected
Bramble, a free manager with no account, scored well, but its security advisories list one critical and three high-severity items and we could not confirm that its current releases are free of them. The other newer managers we found did not cover a computer and both kinds of phone, or were not new.
We have not found a newer manager we can recommend for keeping your passwords.
Who is this article for? One person choosing a password manager for their own everyday accounts on a computer and a phone, not a family or workplace.
About 36 min read
What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean
The quick list
One person, a computer and a phone. Compare what is free, what paying adds and what happens if you forget your main password.
Published US prices for one person, checked November 12, 2026, before any tax. Bitwarden Premium is billed annually at $19.80. Proton Pass Plus is $23.88 for the first 12 months, then $35.88 a year. 1Password’s $35.88 first year is a promotion for new customers buying from 1Password.com; it renews at $47.88. Keeper Personal is $42.99 a year, billed annually in advance.
The comparison at a glance
Compare free plans, paid prices, offline access, what happens if you forget your main password and how to move your passkeys out.
Order follows our verdict for one person’s everyday accounts, not a security ranking. The chart shows the four highest-scoring managers we can recommend; all remain selectable.
Hides matching answers for the selected tools. Unknowns and unverified claims stay visible.
| Feature | Bitwarden | Proton Pass | 1Password Individual | Keeper |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: a free vault synced to every device, with Premium for emergency access | Also consider: email aliases alongside your vault and a recovery phrase you control | Also consider: cost does not decide it and you want to regain access on your own | No label: a paid manager with unlimited devices and a 24-word recovery phrase |
| Free plan | Unlimited passwords and devices, passkeys, sharing with one person, encrypted export | Unlimited logins and devices, passkeys, ten aliases, two vaults | None; 14-day trial | No free plan listed on its pricing page |
| Paid price, checked November 12, 2026 | Premium $19.80 a year, billed annually, before tax | Pass Plus $23.88 for the first 12 months, then $35.88 every 12 months | $47.88 a year; $35.88 first year for new customers buying direct | Personal $42.99 a year, billed annually in advance; Family $91.99 a year for five people |
| Offline access | Read-only in an app that is already unlocked, on every plan | Paid plans, per Proton’s guides; its web-app change log says all users since version 1.34.1 | Items available after they sync to the device | Not described in the pages we read |
| If you forget the main password | Bitwarden cannot reset it; use a trusted contact, a logged-in device or an encryption-enabled passkey prepared earlier | The 12-word recovery phrase resets the password and restores data; email or phone alone resets without old data | A recovery code made earlier plus your account email sets a new password and Secret Key | A 24-word recovery phrase made at first sign-in resets the master password; without it and the password, support cannot help and you start a new account; biometric sign-in on a signed-in device can also reset it |
| Moving passkeys out | Included in JSON exports; direct transfer on iOS 26+ and Android 10+ | Not stated in Proton’s export guide | Only by direct transfer from iOS 26+ or Android 14+; not in desktop export | Passkeys are vault records; the export guide does not say whether they are included |
| 2026 security record | ETH Zurich and USI paper reports 12 attacks if servers turn malicious; Bitwarden says 7 fixed or in progress, 3 accepted. Malicious command-line package on npm for about 90 minutes on April 22 | Not in that paper. Recurity Labs audit, January to April: findings mostly low, per Proton and IT-Connect. Desktop code now uses Electron 44, supported until March 1, 2027 | Same paper reports 6 attacks; 1Password says no new attack vectors and a known key-verification limit remains | Lists FedRAMP High, ISO 27001 and SOC 2 certifications and quarterly third-party penetration tests (vendor claims). We read no independent audit report and found no 2025 or 2026 vulnerability record in our October 20 search |
One person’s everyday accounts on a computer and a phone, not a family or workplace. Bitwarden, Proton Pass and 1Password have apps for Windows, macOS, Linux, iPhone, Android and the main browsers; Keeper has apps for Windows 11 and later, macOS, Linux, iPhone and Android, plus a web vault and browser extensions. Public-source research with prices and plans checked November 12, 2026 and most help pages checked October 19 and 20: no accounts, installs, stored credentials, exports or recovery attempts by us, and no security audit of our own. Keep your old manager until you have checked that what you moved arrived, and keep a way into your recovery email that does not depend on the vault. Next substantive review: December 18, 2026, or sooner after a price, plan or security change.
All features and sources 14 criteria
Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.
Everyday use and cost
Show 7 criteria
| Feature | Bitwarden | Proton Pass | 1Password Individual | Keeper |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: a free vault synced to every device, with Premium for emergency access | Also consider: email aliases alongside your vault and a recovery phrase you control | Also consider: cost does not decide it and you want to regain access on your own | No label: a paid manager with unlimited devices and a 24-word recovery phrase |
| Free plan | Unlimited passwords and devices, passkeys, sharing with one person, encrypted export | Unlimited logins and devices, passkeys, ten aliases, two vaults | None; 14-day trial | No free plan listed on its pricing page |
| Paid price, checked November 12, 2026 | Premium $19.80 a year, billed annually, before tax | Pass Plus $23.88 for the first 12 months, then $35.88 every 12 months | $47.88 a year; $35.88 first year for new customers buying direct | Personal $42.99 a year, billed annually in advance; Family $91.99 a year for five people |
| What paying adds | Built-in authenticator codes, 5 GB attachments, emergency access, security reports | Built-in authenticator, unlimited aliases, attachments, emergency access, dark web monitoring; offline access per Proton’s guides | The whole product: autofill, authenticator codes, Watchtower alerts, 1 GB storage, travel mode | Unlimited passwords and devices, sharing, passkeys, fingerprint or Face ID login; Family adds emergency access and 10 GB of files; BreachWatch ($26.99) and file storage (from $13.99) are yearly add-ons |
| Offline access | Read-only in an app that is already unlocked, on every plan | Paid plans, per Proton’s guides; its web-app change log says all users since version 1.34.1 | Items available after they sync to the device | Not described in the pages we read |
| Email aliases | Connects to outside alias services | Built in: ten free, unlimited on Pass Plus | Not part of the Individual plan we documented | Not part of the Personal plan we documented |
| Account rules to know | No inactivity deletion found in the terms; 30-day refund on paid plans | Free accounts unused for 12 months may be deleted after three email notices; 30-day refund | Automatic renewal; trial billing details can convert to a charge | Fees are billed a year in advance and are nonrefundable; ending renewal needs 30 days’ written notice; prices may change at renewal with notice |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for everyday use and cost
Checked November 12, 2026: Bitwarden plans and terms; 1Password personal pricing and terms; Keeper personal pricing and terms; Proton Pass plans, desktop and offline guide, web-app change log and terms. Checked October 19, 2026: Bitwarden offline use, 1Password sync and Proton’s offline announcement. Published US prices, not checkout quotes. The 1Password and Proton Pass first-year prices are promotions for new customers. Taxes may apply.
Recovery and leaving
Show 4 criteria
| Feature | Bitwarden | Proton Pass | 1Password Individual | Keeper |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| If you forget the main password | Bitwarden cannot reset it; use a trusted contact, a logged-in device or an encryption-enabled passkey prepared earlier | The 12-word recovery phrase resets the password and restores data; email or phone alone resets without old data | A recovery code made earlier plus your account email sets a new password and Secret Key | A 24-word recovery phrase made at first sign-in resets the master password; without it and the password, support cannot help and you start a new account; biometric sign-in on a signed-in device can also reset it |
| Trusted-contact access | Premium account holder; contact can be on Free; view or takeover after your chosen wait | Paid plans; up to five contacts, both with Proton Mail addresses; wait of 1 to 30 days | No trusted-contact route documented for Individual | Keeper’s guide describes up to five contacts and a delay of up to three months for consumer accounts, but its price page lists emergency access under Family only |
| Moving passkeys out | Included in JSON exports; direct transfer on iOS 26+ and Android 10+ | Not stated in Proton’s export guide | Only by direct transfer from iOS 26+ or Android 14+; not in desktop export | Passkeys are vault records; the export guide does not say whether they are included |
| Export formats | CSV, JSON, encrypted JSON (account- or password-protected), ZIP with attachments | PGP-encrypted ZIP, unencrypted ZIP or CSV; not from the mobile apps | CSV (login and password items only) or unencrypted 1PUX, desktop apps | CSV, JSON, PDF and an encrypted KeePass .kdbx file from the web vault and desktop app; mobile export not described |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for recovery and leaving
Bitwarden forgotten master password, emergency access and export; 1Password recovery codes, forgotten password and export; Proton account recovery, emergency access and export, all checked October 19, 2026, November 12. Documented routes, not recoveries or transfers we performed. A file a manager can export is not proof another manager imports every item.
Security, service and operator
Show 3 criteria
| Feature | Bitwarden | Proton Pass | 1Password Individual | Keeper |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 security record | ETH Zurich and USI paper reports 12 attacks if servers turn malicious; Bitwarden says 7 fixed or in progress, 3 accepted. Malicious command-line package on npm for about 90 minutes on April 22 | Not in that paper. Recurity Labs audit, January to April: findings mostly low, per Proton and IT-Connect. Desktop code now uses Electron 44, supported until March 1, 2027 | Same paper reports 6 attacks; 1Password says no new attack vectors and a known key-verification limit remains | Lists FedRAMP High, ISO 27001 and SOC 2 certifications and quarterly third-party penetration tests (vendor claims). We read no independent audit report and found no 2025 or 2026 vulnerability record in our October 20 search |
| Service incidents, 2026 | Short identity and API errors on September 15 and 29; none since then, only planned maintenance | Global outage August 27 and reduced capacity September 1, both affecting Pass; none for Pass since | Sign-in and sync outages April 14 and 27; recovery-code failure June 24; high error rate October 16 to 20 | Not checked for this comparison |
| Operator | Bitwarden Inc.; 8bit Solutions LLC, named in the terms, is its subsidiary | Proton AG; aliases partly run through SimpleLogin SAS | AgileBits Inc., doing business as 1Password | Keeper Security, Inc., Chicago, Illinois, named in its terms |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for security, service and operator
ETH Zurich and USI paper abstract, revised August 12, 2026; Bitwarden’s response; Bitwarden command-line incident statement; 1Password’s review; Proton’s audit summary and IT-Connect’s report; Proton’s desktop code and Electron’s support schedule, checked November 12; status histories for Bitwarden, 1Password and Proton, checked November 12; Keeper’s security page and terms, November 12; Bitwarden privacy, 1Password privacy and Proton Pass privacy. Security research describes attacks under stated assumptions, not breaches. Status pages list what each company chose to report.
What matters when choosing
Bitwarden is our Practical Pick for one person who wants their passwords and passkeys on every device without paying. Its Free plan covers unlimited passwords and devices, apps for Windows, macOS, Linux, iPhone, Android and the main browsers, passkey storage, sharing with one other person and encrypted export. An app that is already unlocked keeps working read-only without a connection, on every plan. Premium costs $19.80 a year, billed annually before tax, and adds built-in authenticator codes, file attachments and emergency access for a trusted contact. The most important compromise is recovery. Bitwarden cannot reset a forgotten master password and offers individuals no code that replaces it, so set up one of its routes before you need it: a trusted contact (Premium), a second device that stays logged in, or a passkey enabled to unlock your vault. Bitwarden plans, offline use, forgotten master password
The lead is narrow, and we want to say so. Under the criteria and weights we fixed before scoring, Bitwarden scored 4.00 out of 5, Proton Pass 3.78 and 1Password Individual 3.68. Bitwarden’s lead over Proton Pass is less than a quarter of a point whichever way price is weighed, because both are free. If a price gap counts for less than we set it, 1Password closes to 3.82 against Bitwarden’s 4.00, and if recovery counts for much more, or price for nothing, 1Password scores higher than Bitwarden. We keep Bitwarden as the Pick because it is the only one of these that is free on every device, works read-only offline on every plan and has the most complete way to leave, and we say in each section what would make another choice better.
Bitwarden’s 2026 record needs reading alongside that. Researchers from ETH Zurich and USI reported 12 attacks against Bitwarden that would work if its servers turned malicious, more than against any of the other three managers they studied; Bitwarden says seven are resolved or being fixed and three are design decisions it accepts. In April, a malicious copy of its command-line tool sat on the npm package registry for about 90 minutes; Bitwarden says only people who installed that copy were affected and found no evidence that vault data was at risk. A new chief executive took over in February, and in May he wrote that Bitwarden “will always have a free version”. Disclosure: Practical Picks is researched and written with Anthropic’s Claude. Bitwarden publishes a connector that lets AI assistants, Claude among them, work with a vault. We have no relationship with Bitwarden or Anthropic, and AI features carried no weight in this comparison. Research paper, Bitwarden’s response, command-line incident statement, CEO post, May 18, 2026, Bitwarden’s AI connector
We are not naming a Rising Star this time. Bramble, a free open-source manager with no account that keeps your vault on your own devices and syncs them directly, scored well on our criteria, but its GitHub page lists four published security advisories, one critical and three high severity, and it does not say which versions each affects or which release fixes it. We could not confirm that its current extension, desktop and phone apps are free of them, so we are not recommending it until that is settled. The other newer managers we found did not cover a computer and both kinds of phone, or were not new. Bramble security advisories
Proton Pass is the one to choose if you want email aliases alongside your vault. Its Free plan includes ten hide-my-email aliases, unlimited logins, devices and passkeys, and a 12-word recovery phrase that both resets your password and restores your data. Built-in authenticator codes and emergency access need Pass Plus, which costs $23.88 for the first 12 months and then $35.88 a year; Proton’s own pages disagree on whether a free account works offline. Proton may delete free accounts left unused for 12 months, and a datacenter failure took Pass offline with Proton’s other services on August 27. If aliases count for as much as the vault, Proton Pass scores higher than Bitwarden. Proton Pass plans, Proton recovery methods, Proton terms
Choose 1Password Individual instead if cost does not decide it and you want to be able to regain access on your own. It has no free plan. It costs $47.88 a year since a March 2026 price rise, or $35.88 for the first year if you are a new customer buying directly. A recovery code you generate in advance, plus access to your account email, lets you set a new password without involving another person. Its desktop export leaves out passkeys and is not encrypted. 1Password plans, 1Password recovery codes, 1Password export
Keeper is the fourth manager we compare in full, and the one to consider if you want a paid manager with a recovery phrase. Its Personal plan costs $42.99 a year, billed a year in advance, and its terms make fees nonrefundable. It lists unlimited passwords and devices, passkeys, a 24-word recovery phrase and an encrypted KeePass export. It scored 3.46 out of 5, a little ahead of Google Password Manager (3.45) and well behind the three above, and our reading of it rests on fewer pages than theirs: we read no independent audit, status page or security advisory page for it. Keeper plans, Keeper terms, Keeper recovery
These are researched judgments from public documentation, status pages, security research and reporting, with prices, plans, status pages and the newer-manager search checked November 12, 2026 and most help pages checked October 19 and 20. We did not create accounts, install apps, store credentials or attempt a recovery. Two conditions would change our recommendation: if cost does not matter and you want a recovery code you can use on your own, choose 1Password; if aliases matter as much as the vault, choose Proton Pass. Whichever you choose, do not keep the only working sign-in for your recovery email inside the vault it is meant to rescue, and keep your old manager until you have checked that what you moved arrived.
Bitwarden
Preferred Pick · a free vault on every device
Choose Bitwarden for passwords and passkeys synced to every device at no cost, with the most complete way to move out. Bitwarden cannot reset a forgotten master password, so set up a trusted contact, a second logged-in device or an unlocking passkey first.
Reasons to choose it
- Free plan covers unlimited devices, passkeys and encrypted export
- Read-only offline access in an unlocked app, on every plan
- Emergency access and authenticator codes for $19.80 a year
What to watch
- No code that replaces a forgotten master password
- 12 attacks reported in a 2026 malicious-server study; 3 accepted by design
- New leadership in 2026 says changes are coming
Bitwarden’s Free plan lists unlimited passwords and devices, browser, mobile and desktop apps, passkey management, sharing with one other user, Bitwarden Send, notes, cards and identities, password and username generators, encrypted export and an integration with outside email-alias services. Premium is $1.65 a month billed annually at $19.80, taxes not included; it adds the built-in authenticator, 5 GB of attachments, emergency access, security reports and priority support. The pricing page on November 12 still shows these figures. Bitwarden’s terms offer a 30-day refund on paid plans. Plans, terms
Offline access is read-only and only works in an app that is already unlocked. You can read and copy what was synced, but you cannot add or edit items, attachments or Sends, or import, until you reconnect; offline use is not a way to sign in on a new device. That covers a flight or a server outage, not a week of editing. Bitwarden’s status page shows short incidents on September 15 (identity errors for about 80 minutes) and September 29 (API errors for about 40 minutes), and only planned maintenance since. GitHub lists no published security advisories for its apps, and its latest desktop release, 2026.10.4, came out on November 5. Offline use, status history, client releases, client advisories
Read the full Bitwarden analysis and sources
Recovery is the decision to plan for. Bitwarden says it has “no way to access, retrieve, or reset your master password”. Its routes all depend on preparation: another device or browser that is still logged in, approving a login from a registered device, a passkey registered with encryption enabled, your password hint, or emergency access. If none works, you must delete the account and start again, losing what was stored. Emergency access needs a Premium account holder; the trusted contact can be on Free. View access shows your whole individual vault, including attachments; takeover sets a new master password and removes your two-step login methods once the wait you chose has passed or you approve. Forgotten master password, emergency access
Bitwarden documents the most complete way out of the three. Individual vaults export to CSV, JSON, encrypted JSON or a ZIP with attachments. Only the JSON formats carry cards, identities, passkeys and SSH keys. A password-protected encrypted export can be imported into any Bitwarden account with that password, while an account-restricted one only returns to the account that made it. On iOS 26 or later and Android 10 or later, the apps can also send items straight to another app that supports the FIDO Credential Exchange Protocol. Bitwarden warns that passkeys created before version 2024.3.1 should not be treated as long-term backups. No export includes trash, Sends or items owned by an organization. Export
The ETH Zurich and USI paper, last revised August 12, 2026, models a fully malicious server and reports 12 attacks on Bitwarden, ranging from integrity violations to full compromise of an organization’s vaults, and says most allow passwords to be recovered; the authors say remediation is underway. Bitwarden’s February 16 response counts ten issues (the paper splits them into twelve), rates them medium and low, and says seven “have been resolved or are in active remediation” and three are “intentional design decisions”; it does not say which. That model assumes Bitwarden’s own servers are hostile, not that any vault was breached. Paper abstract, Bitwarden’s response
On April 22, 2026, a malicious version 2026.4.0 of the Bitwarden command-line tool was served through npm for about 90 minutes as part of a wider supply-chain attack, and recorded as CVE-2026-42994. The Hacker News reported that the code stole developer credentials on machines that installed it, and that Bitwarden counted 334 downloads. Bitwarden said, “If you do not use the Bitwarden command line interface you were not affected,” and released 2026.4.1. The US vulnerability database also lists several 2026 flaws in Bitwarden’s server that concern organization features, such as CVE-2026-60104, fixed in server 2026.6.0; none describes exposure of a personal vault. Bitwarden statement, The Hacker News, April 23, 2026, CVE-2026-42994, CVE-2026-60104
Watch the company as well as the software. It’s FOSS reported in May that Bitwarden changed its chief executive in February and its finance chief in April without announcements, and that “Always free” briefly disappeared from its personal product page, which an employee attributed to a marketing oversight. The new chief executive, Mike Sullivan, wrote on May 18 that Bitwarden “will always have a free version”, called open source “the foundation”, and said “There will be changes.” Bitwarden Inc. operates the service; its terms, still dated June 1, 2017, name 8bit Solutions LLC and now state that it is wholly owned by Bitwarden Inc. The privacy policy, last revised April 2024, separates encrypted vault contents from administrative data such as contact details and item counts. It’s FOSS, May 19, 2026, CEO post, terms, privacy
Choose 1Password if regaining access on your own matters more than price, and Proton Pass if you want aliases built in.
Used Bitwarden? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Proton Pass
Also consider · email aliases with your vault
Choose Proton Pass when you want hide-my-email aliases alongside your passwords and a recovery phrase you control. Save the 12-word recovery phrase, and plan on Pass Plus if you need authenticator codes, emergency access or reliable offline access.
Reasons to choose it
- Ten free aliases; unlimited on Pass Plus
- Recovery phrase resets the password and restores data
- Unlimited logins, devices and passkeys on Free
What to watch
- Authenticator codes and emergency access need Pass Plus; free offline access unconfirmed
- Unused free accounts can be deleted after 12 months
- Pass Plus is $23.88 for the first year, then $35.88
Proton launched Pass to everyone on June 28, 2023, after a spring beta, so it entered this market years after Bitwarden and 1Password and no longer counts as one of the newest managers. Proton Pass Free lists unlimited logins, notes and cards, unlimited devices, browser, mobile and desktop apps, passkeys, alerts for weak and reused passwords, two vaults shared with up to two people and ten hide-my-email aliases. Pass Plus is shown as $1.99 a month; the page says “Billed at $23.88 for the first 12 months, then renews at $35.88 every 12 months”, and it adds unlimited aliases, the built-in authenticator, attachments, item sharing, dark web monitoring and emergency access. When we read the page on October 19 it showed $35.88 for 12 months with no first-year discount. Proton’s terms, last modified October 9, 2026, renew at the then-current price and allow a refund within 30 days of a first purchase. Choose it if you want email aliases with your passwords and a recovery phrase you control, and you can accept the limits below. Plans, terms, TechCrunch, June 28, 2023
Proton’s recovery design is the clearest here. It separates resetting your password from decrypting your data. The 12-word recovery phrase does both. A recovery email or phone resets the password but, alone, leaves data created before the reset unreadable unless you remember the old password; a recovery file, a device data backup or contact-assisted recovery restores data but needs a reset method beside it. Set up the phrase and one other method while you can still sign in. Account recovery
Read the full Proton Pass analysis and sources
Emergency access is a paid, account-level permission. You can name up to five contacts; both of you need Proton Mail addresses. You choose a wait of 1 to 30 days, after which access is granted unless you deny it, and the guide describes access to the whole Proton account, not one vault. Emergency access
Offline access on a free account is not settled. Proton’s 2024 announcement says the apps work offline “with a paid plan”, and its desktop guide, read again on November 12, still says “Paid users can even access the app offline” and that offline access is automatic and cannot be switched off. But the change log for Proton’s Pass web app says version 1.34.1 added “offline mode for all users”, and the current plan table no longer lists offline access as a paid feature. Until Proton’s guides agree, count on offline access only with Pass Plus. That mattered on August 27, 2026, when a cooling failure at Proton’s Frankfurt datacenter took Proton’s services offline for about two hours; Proton’s status page lists the browser extensions and the desktop and mobile apps among affected components, and 9to5Mac names Pass. A further disruption on September 1 left services at reduced capacity for several hours. Proton says no data was lost, and its status page lists no incident for Pass since. Offline announcement, June 6, 2024, desktop guide, incident report, status history, 9to5Mac, August 26, 2026
A free account needs occasional use. Proton reserves the right to delete free accounts inactive for 12 months, including passwords in Proton Pass, after warning emails to your recovery address 30, 15 and 7 days beforehand; signing in once a year counts as activity, and paid accounts are exempt. Terms, section 3
Export works from the browser extension, web app and Windows app, not the mobile apps. You can choose a PGP-encrypted JSON file in a ZIP with a passphrase, an unencrypted ZIP or a CSV; another manager needs the encrypted file decrypted first. The guide does not say whether passkeys, attachments or aliases are included, and we found no Proton documentation of direct Credential Exchange transfer. Export
Proton says Recurity Labs tested the browser extensions, mobile and desktop apps and command-line tool from January to April 2026, found “no remote exploits” and “no encryption bypasses”, and that desktop memory-handling issues were resolved in a retest. IT-Connect, summarizing the published report, counted eight issues in the first phase, mostly low impact, with a medium Android issue fixed in version 1.39.2 and an iOS fix developed but not deployed. The report itself did not load for our automated reading. CyberInsider rated that unfixed iOS issue low severity. Proton Pass was not among the managers in the ETH Zurich paper, so there is no comparable malicious-server analysis. One weakness we noted in October has eased: the desktop app was built on version 39 of Electron, the framework that bundles the Chromium browser engine, which stopped receiving security fixes on May 4, 2026. The code on Proton’s main branch now builds the desktop app on Electron 44, which Electron supports until March 1, 2027, and Chocolatey lists desktop version 1.43.0. GitHub listed no published security advisories for Proton’s Android, iOS or web and desktop code on October 20. Proton’s account, May 12, 2026, IT-Connect, May 13, 2026, CyberInsider, May 13, 2026, desktop app code, Electron support schedule, Chocolatey listing, web app change log
Proton AG operates the service. The Pass privacy policy, last modified July 31, 2025, says vault data and metadata are encrypted but alias addresses are not, and that alias functions partly run through SimpleLogin SAS; the general privacy policy was last modified May 12, 2026. Choose Bitwarden for documented offline access on a free plan and the lowest paid price, and 1Password for one paid plan with everything included. Pass privacy policy, general privacy policy
Used Proton Pass? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
1Password Individual
Also consider · regain access on your own
Choose 1Password Individual when cost does not decide it and you want a recovery code that, with your email, lets you set a new password without a second device or another person.
Reasons to choose it
- Reusable recovery code for individual accounts
- Authenticator codes and offline access included
- Apps for every major platform, including watchOS
What to watch
- No free plan; price rose in March 2026
- Desktop export omits passkeys and is unencrypted
- Sign-in outages in April and a recovery-code failure in June 2026
1Password Individual has no free plan, only a 14-day trial without a card. The personal pricing page, read again on November 12, shows $3.99 a month billed yearly, or $2.99 for the first 12 months for new customers buying from 1Password.com; that is $47.88 a year regularly and $35.88 in a first promotional year. The regular price rose from $35.88 on March 27, 2026, applying to existing customers at their next renewal, according to 1Password’s email to customers as published by 9to5Mac. The plan includes apps for macOS, iOS, watchOS, Windows, Android and Linux, browser extensions, autofill, 1 GB of storage, item sharing with people who do not use 1Password, Watchtower alerts, passkeys and travel mode. Personal pricing, 9to5Mac, February 24, 2026
The recovery code is the reason to pay. You generate it in the apps or on 1Password.com beforehand. With it and access to your account email, you can set a new account password and receive a new Secret Key, the second secret 1Password uses alongside your password; you keep your data, sign in again on each device, and two-factor authentication stays on. The code stays valid after use. 1Password blocks recovery shortly after a recent sign-in, so wait an hour after creating a code before relying on it. Bitwarden has nothing equivalent for individuals; Proton’s recovery phrase is the comparable route. Recovery codes, published August 17, 2026
Read the full 1Password Individual analysis and sources
If you have neither a code nor a signed-in device, 1Password’s guide says individuals must start over; it does not offer to decrypt a vault. Keep the Emergency Kit, which holds your Secret Key, where you can reach it without 1Password. We found no trusted-contact route for Individual accounts; family organizers and team administrators have their own recovery arrangements. 1Password’s status page records one failure of this route: on June 24, 2026, some users trying to restore access with a recovery code got an error for about 1 hour 45 minutes before a fix. Forgotten password, published May 14, 2026, status history
Leaving takes more planning. The desktop apps export CSV, which covers only login and password items and omits custom fields, security questions and linked items, or 1PUX, which keeps more but is unencrypted. Passkeys export only from the iOS app on iOS 26 or later, or the Android app on Android 14 or later, through Credential Exchange to another app that supports it; a computer-only user needs to create new passkeys elsewhere. The guide does not say whether attachments are exported. Export, published August 28, 2026
Items are available offline after they have synced to a device; the guide does not establish signing in to a new device offline. The status page records sign-in and sync outages on April 14 (about 35 minutes of impact, per the postmortem) and April 27 (about 86 minutes, when all web services were affected), and a “High error rate on 1Password.com” incident that began on October 16 and was resolved on October 20. Sync, published August 25, 2026, status history
The ETH Zurich and USI paper reports six attacks on 1Password under its malicious-server model. 1Password’s February 16 review says it found no new attack vectors beyond limitations already in its security design white paper, including that users cannot robustly verify that a sharing recipient’s public key is genuine; it describes no shipped fix for that. We found no 2025 or 2026 entry for 1Password in the US vulnerability database. 1Password distributes penetration-test reports through its Trust Center, which we did not read. Ars Technica reported in 2023 that 1Password detected suspicious activity in its internal Okta account. Paper abstract, 1Password review, security assessments, Ars Technica, October 2023
AgileBits Inc., doing business as 1Password, operates the service. Its privacy notice, effective December 29, 2025, covers account, support and usage data separately from encrypted vault contents. The terms, last updated September 12, 2024, renew subscriptions automatically, let you cancel through your account or support, and allow a charge when a trial with entered billing details ends. Choose Bitwarden if cost decides it, and Proton Pass if aliases matter. Privacy, terms
Used 1Password Individual? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Keeper
No label · a paid manager with a recovery phrase
Choose Keeper if you want a paid manager with unlimited devices, a 24-word recovery phrase and an encrypted KeePass export, and you accept paying a year in advance with no refund. Keep the recovery phrase: without it and your master password, Keeper support cannot get you back in.
Reasons to choose it
- Unlimited passwords and devices, with passkeys on Android 14 and iOS 17 or later
- 24-word recovery phrase, and biometric sign-in can reset the master password
- Exports CSV, JSON, PDF or an encrypted KeePass file from the web vault and desktop app
What to watch
- Fees are billed a year in advance and are nonrefundable
- Emergency access is listed under the Family plan only
- We read no independent audit, and no status or advisory page
Keeper’s Personal plan costs $42.99 a year, shown as $3.58 a month and billed annually. The pricing page lists unlimited password storage, unlimited devices and sync, unlimited secure password sharing, fingerprint and Face ID login, unlimited identity and payment storage, the web app and browser extensions, and 24/7 support. We found no free plan on the page. The Family plan, $91.99 a year for five people, adds 10 GB of file storage and lists emergency access; BreachWatch dark web alerts ($26.99 a year) and extra file storage (from $13.99 a year) are add-ons. Keeper’s terms say subscription fees are “billed and collected annually in advance” and that “all fees are nonrefundable”, that prices may change at the next renewal on prior written notice, and that you can decline to renew with at least 30 days’ written notice before the renewal date; we count the nonrefundable year’s prepayment against its cost. Its download page lists apps for macOS, Windows (the desktop app needs Windows 11 or later), Linux, iPhone and Android. Plans, terms, downloads
Keeper’s guide says passkeys saved in the vault work across browsers and operating systems and are stored as vault records with a creation date, username and site. Passkeys on phones need Android 14 or iOS 17 or later. We read nothing on offline use, so we cannot say how Keeper behaves without a connection. Passkeys
Read the full Keeper analysis and sources
Recovery depends on a phrase you make in advance. At first sign-in Keeper prompts you to generate a 24-word recovery phrase, created on your device, which resets your master password. If you forget the password and lose the phrase, Keeper says its support cannot help, and consumer customers must create a new account; if you can still sign in with Face ID or Touch ID on a device, you can reset the master password from settings. Keeper’s emergency-access guide describes up to five trusted contacts and a wait of up to three months, for consumer accounts, but the pricing page lists emergency access only under Family, and we could not reconcile the two, so count on it only with Family. Recovery, emergency access
You can export from the web vault or desktop app as CSV, JSON, PDF or an encrypted KeePass (.kdbx) file protected by a password you choose; the CSV and JSON files can be imported back into Keeper. The guide does not say whether passkeys are included, and it describes no export from the mobile apps. Export
Keeper Security, Inc., of Chicago, Illinois, is the operator named in its terms. Its security page lists FedRAMP High, ISO 27001, 27017 and 27018, SOC 2 and FIPS 140-3 validation and says third parties including NCC Group and CyberTest run quarterly penetration tests; those are the company’s claims. We read no independent audit report, no status history and no security advisory page, and our October 20 search found no 2025 or 2026 vulnerability record for it, so its security and service record is scored with less certainty than the three above. Choose Bitwarden if cost decides it, Proton Pass if aliases matter, and 1Password if you want one plan with a recovery code and a monthly option. Security
Used Keeper? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Which product are we missing?
Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.
Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.
Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.
No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.
What people are saying
Public reports help check vendor claims; they are not a measured reliability score. WIRED’s September 2025 review of Proton Pass reported friction with notification defaults and background locking on mobile; those are its reviewer’s observations at that time, last read September 6, 2026, and the page carries buying links. WIRED review
A July 31, 2026 report on Bitwarden’s issue tracker said page-load autofill stopped working in browser extension 2026.7.0. Another user said it worked for them, Bitwarden staff could not reproduce it, and the report was closed on August 3, so we do not treat it as a confirmed defect. Issue 22189
It’s FOSS described Bitwarden users as worried in May 2026 about unannounced leadership changes and the brief removal of “Always free” from its product page; Bitwarden’s chief executive replied publicly that the free version will stay. Proton’s own report on its late-August outage blames maintenance its datacenter operator carried out overnight without notice, says some servers were destroyed by heat, and promises database resilience work by the end of 2026. It’s FOSS, Proton incident report
Our October 19 searches of news, vulnerability databases, GitHub security advisories, status pages and regulator and court-record coverage found no breach of customer vaults, and no 2026 lawsuit or regulator action involving Bitwarden, AgileBits or Proton, beyond what this article reports. On November 12 the Bitwarden, 1Password and Proton status pages showed no new incident that touched a vault. Federal court-record search sites blocked our automated access in October, so that check is incomplete, and a search that finds nothing is not proof that nothing exists.
How we researched
This is public-source research. We did not create accounts, install apps or extensions, store credentials, buy plans, export data or attempt a recovery. No company gave us access, payment or input, and we use no affiliate links. We first compared Bitwarden, 1Password and Proton Pass on September 6, 2026, and rechecked every material claim on October 19, 2026: plans, prices, recovery and emergency access, offline access, export, terms and privacy dates. On October 20 we added Google Password Manager and searched for newer managers. On November 12, 2026 we read the pricing pages and plan terms for every manager below, the status pages and release pages for the three we compare in full, and searched again for newer managers. We read vendor documentation, terms and status pages, the ETH Zurich and USI paper’s abstract, the US vulnerability database and GitHub security advisories, public code and release records, and independent reporting.
We wrote this for one person choosing a manager for their own everyday accounts across a computer and a phone, not for a family or a workplace. We fixed five criteria and their weights before scoring: everyday fit across devices, including free-plan limits and offline access (25%); total cost (20%); recovery from a forgotten password or lost device (25%); exporting and moving out (15%); and security and service record (15%). For cost we priced the cheapest plan that does the basic job, passwords and passkeys synced between a computer and a phone, over three years, and compared each price with the typical price among the thirteen managers whose prices we could read. A free plan that does that job costs nothing; authenticator codes and emergency access are scored under fit and recovery, not cost. Bitwarden scored highest, 4.00 out of 5, ahead of Proton Pass (3.78) and 1Password (3.68). Weighting recovery much more heavily puts 1Password ahead of Bitwarden (3.76 against 3.73), and so does ignoring cost (3.90 against 3.68); adding email aliases as a criterion puts Proton Pass ahead (3.96 against 3.78). Those conditions are behind the 1Password and Proton Pass recommendations above, and they are why we call Bitwarden’s lead narrow. Keeper (3.46) and Google Password Manager (3.45) follow; Keeper’s lead over Google is small, and both scores rest on fewer pages than the first three. Keeper is in the chart as the fourth highest-scoring manager we can recommend; Google Password Manager is not.
On November 12, 2026 we searched again for newer password managers, those whose first public release was within about two years of that date, through launch coverage, GitHub, Hacker News, directory and alternatives lists and the Privacy Guides recommendations, and we checked the earlier candidates again. Proton Pass, last time’s Rising Star, launched in 2023, so it no longer counts as new. AliasVault, an open-source password and email-alias manager, published its first release on GitHub, a pre-release 0.1.0 dated June 17 (the page shows no year; we put it in 2024 because its first public code dates from May 2024, before 0.1.0, and its public beta in December 2024 came after 0.8.0, dated 25 November), so it is outside the window; it scored about 3.00 because it cannot help you back in after a forgotten master password and has no independent audit yet. ExpressKeys, ExpressVPN’s password manager, began inside ExpressVPN in November 2023 and needs an ExpressVPN Advanced plan, $117.32 for the first 28 months and then $119.95 a year; it scored about 3.00. PearPass’s developer still says the app is paused from active development, so it is not offered for the job. Sesame, a free open-source manager that opened a public beta in August 2026, is a Windows beta with syncing switched off, and Cryptex Vault’s page lists a web app, a Chromium extension and an Android app but no iPhone app, so neither covers a computer and both kinds of phone. Bramble, an open-source manager whose public code starts in May 2026 and whose launch post on Hacker News is dated July 2, 2026, runs on Windows and macOS through its extension and on iPhone and Android, and its documentation shows the job; with no vault held by a company it would score 3.53 on our criteria. But its GitHub security advisories page lists four published advisories: one critical (peer-to-peer sync pairing in all clients, July 29, 2026) and three high severity (autofill transport, August 8; domain matching and the autofill picker, both October 10). The page does not say which versions each affects or which release fixes it, and we do not recommend a newer manager while a critical or high-severity advisory may affect its current release, so we could not show that the current releases, the Chromium extension 1.38.0 and desktop app 0.17.0 among them, are clear of them. We have therefore not named a Rising Star and will look again once those advisories show which versions are fixed. We read no independent audit or report of it, and its README describes a single engineer. Bitdefender’s and Cloaked’s pages did not show enough to judge a newer entrant, and Bitdefender’s SecurePass followed the company’s earlier password manager. We looked at several other 2025 and 2026 projects only as titles in search results and did not open them: PassForgePro, Bastion Enclave, CarryPass, CyberVault, Password Encrypted Manager, Syncarly, Vault Local and Seal. Those described local-only or browser-only designs without syncing between a computer and a phone.
We also scored widely used established managers on the same criteria, from public pages and with less certainty than the first three in the chart. Google Password Manager (3.45) is free, built into Android and Chrome, and fills in iPhone apps through Chrome; it falls just outside the chart because Google holds the encryption key by default, you can only export passwords to a file with no encrypted option, and on a computer it fills only inside Chrome. Keeper (3.46) is described in its own section above. RoboForm (3.35) limits its free plan to one device and charges $19.90 for the first year of Premium, then $29.88. Dashlane (3.24) has no free plan and charges $5.42 a month billed annually for Premium. Zoho Vault (3.10) lists a free plan with unlimited passwords, passkeys and devices and offline access, but we read only its pricing page. ExpressKeys and AliasVault (about 3.00 each) are described above. LastPass (2.85) limits its free plan to one device type and charges $3.00 a month billed annually for Premium. Enpass (2.65) limits its free plan to 25 items and shows conflicting Premium prices, $23.99 and $47.99 a year. NordPass’s price page blocked our automated reader, and Bitdefender’s SecurePass page showed no prices, so we could not price them. Apple’s Passwords app has no Android app, KeePassXC and KeePassDX have no phone and computer apps of their own that work together, and Samsung Pass is a Samsung Galaxy feature, so we did not score them for this reader. We could not read a Microsoft Edge page this time and did not score it.
| Tool | Public sources | What remains uncertain |
|---|---|---|
| Bitwarden | Pricing, offline, recovery, emergency-access and export help; terms and privacy; status history and client releases and advisories (November 12); ETH Zurich and USI abstract and Bitwarden’s response; command-line incident statement, CVE records and The Hacker News; chief executive’s post and It’s FOSS. | Which three ETH findings Bitwarden accepts, what “changes” the new leadership plans, whether direct transfer carries every item type. |
| Proton Pass | Pricing (November 12), recovery, emergency-access, export and desktop guides; offline announcement; terms and privacy policies; status history and incident report; Proton’s audit summary, IT-Connect and CyberInsider; launch coverage; web-app change log, desktop code, Chocolatey listing and Electron’s support schedule. | The full Recurity report, whether a free account works offline, passkey and attachment export. |
| 1Password Individual | Personal pricing and terms (November 12), recovery-code, forgotten-password, export and sync guides; privacy; status history; 1Password’s ETH review; 9to5Mac on the price rise. | Attachment export, the full Trust Center reports, how quickly recovery works under pressure. |
| Keeper | Personal pricing and terms, recovery, emergency-access, passkey and export guides, security page and download page (November 12); October 20 reviews. | Offline behavior, whether the Personal plan includes emergency access (its guide and price page differ), whether passkeys are included in exports, any independent audit, status history and advisories, incidents since October. |
| Other managers screened | Google’s, RoboForm’s, Dashlane’s, Zoho’s, LastPass’s, Enpass’s, ExpressVPN’s and Bitdefender’s pricing or product pages (November 12); AliasVault’s repository and advisories; Bramble’s README, releases and security advisories and its Hacker News launch listing; PearPass’s repository; Sesame and Cryptex Vault pages; October 20 pages and reviews for the rest. | Scores for these are lower-certainty. Which Bramble versions its four advisories affect, and whether they are fixed, is not shown. NordPass’s price page blocked our automated reader; Bitdefender’s and Norton’s pages showed no prices; no Microsoft Edge page loaded. |
None of this establishes autofill reliability, successful recovery or security in operation. Next substantive review is due December 18, 2026, or sooner after a price, plan or security change. Found something that has changed? Contact the editors.
Sources and evidence
Sources were checked November 12, 2026 where marked, otherwise October 19 or 20, 2026 as noted. Vendor documentation establishes what a company promises, not how its service behaves for you. Security research describes attacks under stated assumptions, not breaches. Community and press reports are attributed observations.
- Bitwarden: plans, November 12; offline use; forgotten master password; emergency access; export; terms, effective June 1, 2017, November 12; privacy, revised April 2024; status history, November 12; client releases and advisories, November 12; ETH Zurich response, February 16, 2026; command-line incident statement, April 23, 2026; CVE-2026-42994 and CVE-2026-60104, read through the database’s public interface; chief executive’s post, May 18, 2026; AI connector; issue 22189.
- 1Password: personal pricing, November 12; recovery codes, August 17, 2026; forgotten password, May 14, 2026; export, August 28, 2026; sync, August 25, 2026; privacy, effective December 29, 2025; terms, September 12, 2024, November 12; status history, November 12; ETH Zurich review, February 16, 2026; security assessments.
- Proton Pass: plans, November 12; account recovery; emergency access; export; desktop and offline guide, November 12; offline announcement, June 6, 2024; terms, October 9, 2026, November 12; Pass privacy policy, July 31, 2025; privacy policy, May 12, 2026; status history, November 12; August 27 incident report; audit summary, May 12, 2026; checked November 12, 2026: web-app change log, desktop app code, Chocolatey listing, Electron support schedule; checked October 20, 2026: security advisories for Android, iOS and web and desktop.
- Other managers, checked November 12, 2026: Google Password Manager and Chrome help; RoboForm prices; Dashlane personal prices; LastPass prices; Enpass prices; Zoho Vault prices; ExpressVPN prices; Bitdefender SecurePass; Apple Passwords; AliasVault prices, code and advisories; PearPass desktop code; Bramble README and repository, releases, security advisories and Hacker News launch listing, July 2, 2026; Sesame report, RuntimeWire, August 28, 2026; Cryptex Vault; KeePassDX; Privacy Guides; OpenAlternative, Bitwarden alternatives. Checked October 20, 2026 and not reread: Bitwarden desktop 2026.10.0 code; ExpressKeys announcement, February 5, 2026, 9to5Mac, November 6, 2023 and CyberInsider, July 6, 2026; Bitdefender, March 9, 2022; TechRadar on NordPass, June 25, 2019; Apple Windows export; Tom’s Guide on NordPass; PCWorld on RoboForm, September 5, 2025; Dashlane, August 5, 2025; The Register on LastPass, December 11, 2025; Macworld on Enpass, June 23, 2025; Samsung Pass; Google’s account recovery, on-device encryption, passkeys and PIN and CVE-2026-11695.
- Keeper, checked November 12, 2026: personal and family prices; terms of use; master password reset and account recovery; emergency access; passkeys; vault export; security; downloads.
- Research and reporting: Zero Knowledge (About) Encryption, IACR ePrint 2026/058, revised August 12, 2026 (abstract; the full paper blocked automated retrieval); The Hacker News, April 23, 2026; It’s FOSS, May 19, 2026; 9to5Mac on 1Password prices, February 24, 2026; 9to5Mac on Proton’s outage, August 26, 2026; IT-Connect on the Proton Pass audit, May 13, 2026; WIRED, September 2025, last read September 6, 2026; Ars Technica, October 2023, last read September 6, 2026; TechCrunch on the Proton Pass launch, June 28, 2023 and CyberInsider on the Proton Pass audit, May 13, 2026, read October 20, 2026.
This is a researched comparison, not a product review. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.