Android authenticator apps that survive a lost phone: Ente Auth, Proton Authenticator, Aegis and 2FAS
Ente Auth gives the most dependable way back to your codes after losing a phone: an end-to-end encrypted copy you restore by signing in, plus encrypted backup files. Proton Authenticator is a close second, and Aegis suits people who want an app that never goes online.
Ente Auth
An optional free account keeps an end-to-end encrypted copy of your codes that returns when you sign in on a new Android phone or an iPhone, with encrypted local backups as a second route.
Keep the account password and recovery key away from the phone, and never keep the Ente account’s own 2FA code only in Ente Auth.
Why Ente Auth is our PickTeam behind Ente Auth? Get your award badge
No Rising Star selected
Proton Authenticator, released in July 2025, is the strongest newer app, but Proton has offered a password manager with a built-in code generator since 2023. The other newer apps we found are outside our rules.
We cannot name a Rising Star until a newer app from a maker new to authenticators meets our availability and safety conditions.
Who is this article for? Android users choosing a free app for the six-digit sign-in codes many websites use, who want to keep those codes if the phone is lost, broken or replaced.
About 30 min read
What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean
The quick list
All four are free. Compare where the off-phone copy of your codes lives, what you need to restore it and what a move to an iPhone takes.
All four apps are free to download and use; we found no paid plan for any of them, and checked each price on November 12, 2026. The real costs are setup time and keeping a password, recovery key or backup file somewhere other than the phone.
The comparison at a glance
Compare where each app keeps an off-phone copy of your codes, what you need to get them back and what moving to an iPhone takes.
Order follows our verdict for keeping codes after a lost phone, not a measured security ranking. The four highest-scoring apps are charted; other apps we scored are described under How we researched. All tools remain selectable.
Hides matching answers for the selected tools. Unknowns and unverified claims stay visible.
| Feature | Ente Auth | Proton Authenticator | Aegis Authenticator | 2FAS Auth |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: codes you can restore on a new Android phone or an iPhone | Second choice: encrypted sync and scheduled backups, in an app released July 2025 | Also consider: Android only, an app that never goes online | Backup in your own Google Drive, if you set the backup password |
| App charge | Free | Free | Free | Free (licence terms, June 2025) |
| Off-phone copy | Optional end-to-end encrypted sync | Optional end-to-end encrypted sync; scheduled backups to a folder you choose, off by default | Automatic encrypted backups to a folder you choose; off by default | Optional Google Drive sync (Android only) |
| If the phone is lost | Sign in on the new device, or import an encrypted export | Sign in to the Proton account on the new device, or import a backup with its password | Import a backup you copied off the phone, with its password | Turn sync on with the same Google account, plus the backup password if set |
| Backup protection | Sync end-to-end encrypted; local backups and exports password-encrypted | Sync end-to-end encrypted; backups password-encrypted from version 1.3.2, per release notes (product page wording differs) | Vault and backups always encrypted; optional separate backup password | Password optional; files without one are readable |
| Moving to an iPhone | Sign in on the iPhone app | Sign in on the iPhone app | No iPhone app; export to another app | Export a file, import it on the iPhone app |
| Security record, checked November 12, 2026 | Audits published 2023 and 2025; server advisory fixed July 2026 | No published audit yet; no advisory on the Android code; iPhone log flaw fixed August 2025 | High-severity icon-pack advisory fixed in 3.4.3, September 2026 | No published advisory; 2023 study finding, current status unknown |
Documentation-based comparison of free Android authenticator apps for keeping codes after a lost or replaced phone; not a security ranking. No app was installed, no code enrolled and no backup restored. Keep each service’s own recovery codes separately from your authenticator backup. Sources checked October 19, 2026 (Proton Authenticator October 20), with prices, current releases and security advisories rechecked November 12, 2026; next review due December 18, 2026, or sooner after a material change.
All features and sources 19 criteria
Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.
Daily use and eligibility
Show 7 criteria
| Feature | Ente Auth | Proton Authenticator | Aegis Authenticator | 2FAS Auth |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: codes you can restore on a new Android phone or an iPhone | Second choice: encrypted sync and scheduled backups, in an app released July 2025 | Also consider: Android only, an app that never goes online | Backup in your own Google Drive, if you set the backup password |
| App charge | Free | Free | Free | Free (licence terms, June 2025) |
| Account needed | No; free Ente account only for sync | No; free Proton account for sync on Android | No; the app has no internet access | No 2FAS account; Google account for Drive sync |
| Codes without a connection | Documented | Documented | Documented | Documented |
| Platforms | Android, iPhone, Windows, macOS, Linux, web | Android, iPhone, Windows, macOS, Linux | Android only | Android, iPhone |
| Minimum Android | Android 7, per source build file | Android 8.1, per F-Droid build | Android 6, per source build file | Android 9 from version 6.0 |
| App lock | App lock; does not re-encrypt stored data, per Ente | Biometrics or PIN | Vault password; biometrics | 4- or 6-digit PIN; biometrics after PIN |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for daily use and eligibility
Checked October 19, 2026, with prices, current releases and advisories rechecked November 12: Ente Auth, use without an account and Android build file; Proton (checked October 20) Authenticator, FAQs and F-Droid listing; Aegis features, FAQ and build file; 2FAS overview, tutorial, licence terms and version 6.0 notes; and November 12 rechecks of each app’s own page and Play listing. Developer documentation, not device tests.
Backups, a lost phone and moving to an iPhone
Show 7 criteria
| Feature | Ente Auth | Proton Authenticator | Aegis Authenticator | 2FAS Auth |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Off-phone copy | Optional end-to-end encrypted sync | Optional end-to-end encrypted sync; scheduled backups to a folder you choose, off by default | Automatic encrypted backups to a folder you choose; off by default | Optional Google Drive sync (Android only) |
| If the phone is lost | Sign in on the new device, or import an encrypted export | Sign in to the Proton account on the new device, or import a backup with its password | Import a backup you copied off the phone, with its password | Turn sync on with the same Google account, plus the backup password if set |
| Backup protection | Sync end-to-end encrypted; local backups and exports password-encrypted | Sync end-to-end encrypted; backups password-encrypted from version 1.3.2, per release notes (product page wording differs) | Vault and backups always encrypted; optional separate backup password | Password optional; files without one are readable |
| Automatic local backups | Password-encrypted; five most recent kept | Daily, weekly or monthly to a folder you choose; password-protected | Encrypted, on each change, to a chosen folder; Android cloud backup optional | None automatic; file export recommended after changes |
| Export for another app | Password-encrypted export | Export file; imports from six named apps | Encrypted or plain-text export | .2fas file; password optional |
| Moving to an iPhone | Sign in on the iPhone app | Sign in on the iPhone app | No iPhone app; export to another app | Export a file, import it on the iPhone app |
| Recovery trap to avoid | Ente account’s own 2FA code kept only in Ente Auth; relying on a device backup | Proton account’s own 2FA code kept only in this app; no saved recovery phrase | Backup left on the phone; forgotten backup password | Forgotten backup password makes the Drive copy unusable |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for backups, a lost phone and moving to an iphone
Ente export and local backups, use without an account and lockout guidance; Proton backup help, Android release notes, backup settings in the source and account recovery; Aegis FAQ, backup settings text and 3.3 notes; 2FAS Drive sync, moving devices, backup safety and forgotten password; and each app’s release notes read again November 12. No backup, restore or import was attempted. Keep a working way into your accounts before changing apps or phones.
Developer, privacy and security record
Show 5 criteria
| Feature | Ente Auth | Proton Authenticator | Aegis Authenticator | 2FAS Auth |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Security record, checked November 12, 2026 | Audits published 2023 and 2025; server advisory fixed July 2026 | No published audit yet; no advisory on the Android code; iPhone log flaw fixed August 2025 | High-severity icon-pack advisory fixed in 3.4.3, September 2026 | No published advisory; 2023 study finding, current status unknown |
| Published outside audit | Cure53 and Symbolic Software, 2023; Cure53 server test, 2025 | None yet; Proton says audits will follow | None found | None found |
| Developer | Ente Technologies, Inc. (Delaware) | Proton AG (Switzerland) | Beem Development; legal entity not established | Two Factor Authentication Service, Inc. (Delaware) |
| Source code | AGPL-3.0 | GPL-3.0 | GPL-3.0 | GPL-3.0 source; separate licence terms for the app |
| Data handling, as stated | Account email, IP, device identifiers, crash reports | Optional anonymous data sharing; crash reports in Play build; F-Droid flags tracking | States no data collected; no internet permission in source | Codes stay on device; Firebase crash reports, can be disabled |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for developer, privacy and security record
Ente privacy policy, 2023 audit, 2025 audit and server advisory; Proton security model, Android advisories, Android build file, Play listing and F-Droid listing, BleepingComputer; Aegis advisory, privacy and licence; 2FAS privacy, licence terms and source; USENIX Security 2023 paper. Advisory pages for all four apps were read again November 12. Audit summaries are the developer’s account. Policies are statements, not traffic audits.
What matters when choosing
Ente Auth is our Practical Pick for an Android user who wants to keep their two-factor codes when the phone is lost, broken or replaced. It is free and open source. You can use it without an account, but its optional free account keeps an end-to-end encrypted copy of your codes that you get back by signing in on a new Android phone, an iPhone, a computer or the web. It can also keep automatic, password-encrypted backups on the phone and make encrypted export files that you can import without signing in. Ente says outside auditors reviewed its encryption design and client code in 2023 and tested its server in 2025. The most important compromise is that the account becomes the thing you must not lose. Write down its password and the recovery key it gives you, and do not keep the Ente account’s own two-factor code only inside Ente Auth: Ente itself warns that this can lock you out. Ente Auth, use without an account and local backups, Ente’s lockout warning, 2023 audit, 2025 audit
Proton Authenticator is our second choice, and we name no Rising Star this time. Proton released it in July 2025, and it scored 4.20 out of 5 on the same criteria, against 4.40 for Ente Auth, a narrow lead for our Pick, smaller than one point on our most heavily weighted criterion. It does not qualify as a newer entrant because Proton already makes a password manager with a built-in authenticator, so a standalone app from that maker is not a new kind of product; no other newer app we found qualified either. Like our Pick, it is free and open source, works without an account, and can keep an end-to-end encrypted copy of your codes that comes back when you sign in to a free Proton account on a new Android phone, an iPhone or a computer. It can also write automatic backups to a folder you choose, which Proton’s Android release notes say are password-protected. Its main limits are that Proton has not yet published an independent audit of the app, and that F-Droid flags it for tracking even though Proton advertises no trackers. Proton Authenticator, Android release notes, F-Droid listing
If you want an app that never goes online, choose Aegis Authenticator instead. It is Android only, its FAQ says it has no internet access, and its vault and automatic backups are always encrypted. The catch is that backups stay off until you turn them on, you must get the backup file off the phone yourself, and there is no iPhone version. 2FAS Auth backs up to your own Google Drive and has an iPhone app, but set its optional backup password: its own help says a backup file without one leaves your secret keys readable. Google Authenticator, with more than 100 million Google Play installs, needs the least setup if your Google account is already your recovery plan, but Google documents encryption in transit and at rest, not end-to-end encryption, and a code you delete on one synced device is deleted everywhere; it scored below the four apps in the chart and is described under How we researched. Aegis features, Aegis FAQ, 2FAS tutorial, Google Authenticator help
An authenticator backup protects the codes, not your accounts. Keep each service’s own recovery codes too, and keep at least one way into the account that holds your backup (Ente, Proton, Google or your cloud storage) that does not depend on the phone you might lose. One condition would change our recommendation: if a rule against any online account or network access outweighs easy recovery for you, Aegis is the better fit. These are documentation-based judgments, first checked October 19 and 20, 2026 and rechecked on November 12, 2026 for prices, current releases, security advisories and newer apps. We did not install any app, enrol any code or restore any backup.
Ente Auth
Preferred Pick · getting codes back after a lost phone
Choose Ente Auth when you want to get your codes back by signing in on a new Android phone or an iPhone, with encrypted backup files as a second route. Keep the account password and recovery key away from the phone.
Reasons to choose it
- End-to-end encrypted sync to Android, iPhone, desktop and web
- Automatic password-encrypted local backups and encrypted exports
- Outside audits published in 2023 and 2025
What to watch
- The Ente account and its recovery key become what you must not lose
- A device backup alone may not bring codes back; sign in or import
- Account data such as email, IP and crash reports is collected
Ente Auth is a free, open-source authenticator from Ente Technologies, Inc., announced in December 2022, with apps for Android, iPhone, Windows, macOS, Linux and the web. You can start with “Use without backups”, which keeps codes on one device, or create a free Ente account, which syncs an end-to-end encrypted copy to every device you sign in on. Ente says only you hold the keys to that copy. For this reader the account is the point: if the phone disappears, you sign in on the replacement and your codes come back. Ente Auth, launch announcement, December 9, 2022, privacy policy, updated October 16, 2026
Choose something else if you will not keep an account password and a recovery key safely away from the phone. Ente’s help says the recovery key gets you back in if you forget the password and can bypass the account’s own two-factor check. It also warns that storing the Ente account’s two-factor code inside Ente Auth can leave you needing Ente Auth to log into Ente Auth. Email verification is off by default in the Auth app to avoid a similar loop through your email provider. Lockout guidance
Read the full Ente Auth analysis and sources
The app also offers copies that do not need the account. Automatic local backups are encrypted with a password you set, and the app keeps the five most recent. Encrypted exports use Argon2id and XChaCha20-Poly1305, and Ente says you can import one without signing in; its command-line tool can decrypt them. These matter most when you use Ente without an account. Ente’s help says the key for that no-account vault lives in the phone’s secure storage, is not reliably carried over by device transfers or operating-system backups, and cannot be recovered by Ente. Copy a backup or encrypted export somewhere other than the phone and keep its password. Use without an account, export format and local backups
Ente reports two outside reviews. In March 2023 Cure53 and Symbolic Software audited its architecture and source code; Ente says the only high-severity finding, weak passwords allowed in its web app, was fixed and verified. The post says the review covered all clients but does not name Auth separately. A Cure53 test of Ente’s server and infrastructure, sponsored by CERN and published in November 2025, covered Auth because it shares that server. Ente says 12 of the 15 issues found were fixed during the audit; its post does not say what happened to the other three. In July 2026 Ente published an advisory, GHSA-2hxj-953x-c2vw, for a server flaw that let an accepted emergency contact skip the account owner’s recovery notice period. It was fixed in the July 9, 2026 server release and required the account owner to have accepted that contact first. These are Ente’s and its auditors’ findings, not our test. 2023 audit, 2025 audit, server advisory
User reports on Ente’s tracker point to the same weak spot as its documentation. An open January 2025 issue describes about 25 codes vanishing on an iPhone until the user signed out and back in. In a May 2026 comment on another open issue, an Ente team member said an iPhone restored from an iCloud backup cannot read its codes because the encryption key is not part of that backup. On a new device, sign in or import an encrypted export rather than relying on a device backup. The Android app requires Android 7 or later, according to its source build file. Ente’s privacy policy lists your account email, IP address, device identifiers and anonymised crash reports among the data it collects, and its Play listing says the app may collect personal information. Vanished codes report, restore report and reply, Android build file, Play listing
Used Ente Auth? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Proton Authenticator
Second choice · encrypted sync and scheduled backups
Choose Proton Authenticator when you want codes that come back by signing in on a new Android phone, an iPhone or a computer, plus scheduled backups to a folder you choose. Save the Proton recovery phrase away from the phone and set a backup password.
Reasons to choose it
- End-to-end encrypted sync to Android, iPhone and computers
- Daily, weekly or monthly backups, password-protected per Proton
- Imports from six named apps; export available
What to watch
- No published independent audit yet
- F-Droid flags tracking despite Proton’s no-trackers claim
- The Proton account and its recovery phrase become what you must not lose
Proton Authenticator is a free, open-source authenticator from Proton AG, the Swiss company behind Proton Mail and Proton Pass. Proton released it on July 31, 2025, for Android, iPhone, Windows, macOS and Linux, more than two and a half years after Ente Auth. It is second overall for this reader, and it clears our safety checks for an app that holds sign-in secrets: an identifiable company, public source code, no published security advisory and releases within the past year. We do not call it a Rising Star because Proton has offered a password manager with a built-in code generator, Proton Pass, since 2023, which makes this an app from an established maker of the same kind of software. You can use it without an account. On Android, syncing codes between devices needs a free Proton account; Proton says the synced copy is encrypted on your device with AES-256-GCM under keys that Proton cannot read. Choose it if you want the same kind of sign-in recovery as our Pick, perhaps from a company you already use, and can accept the limits below. Proton Authenticator, FAQs, security model, October 29, 2025, TechCrunch, July 31, 2025
It offers two routes back after a lost phone. Signed in, your codes return when you sign in to the same Proton account on the replacement. Without the account, the Android app can write automatic backups to a folder you choose, daily, weekly or monthly; they are off until you turn them on. Proton’s Android release notes say password-protected backups arrived in version 1.2.0 and that encrypted backups were enforced from version 1.3.2 (October 31, 2025), and Proton says it derives the backup key from your password with Argon2. Its product page still says encrypted backups come “when using your Proton Account or on iOS”, so confirm that the app asks you for a backup password. As with any backup on the phone, copy it somewhere else. Backup help, Android release notes, backup settings in the source
Read the full Proton Authenticator analysis and sources
The Proton account then becomes the thing you must not lose. Proton separates resetting your password from decrypting your data: a recovery email or phone resets the password but, alone, leaves earlier encrypted data unreadable, while the 12-word recovery phrase does both. Save the phrase away from the phone. Proton also presents this app as the place for your Proton account’s own two-factor code; if that code lives only here, a lost phone can stand between you and the account that holds your synced copy, the same loop Ente warns about. That is our reading of the design, not a Proton warning. Proton may delete a free account after 12 months without activity, and using a Proton app while signed in counts as activity. Account recovery, terms, section 3, October 9, 2026
Switching is well covered. Proton lists imports from Google Authenticator, 2FAS, Aegis, Bitwarden Authenticator, Ente Auth and LastPass Authenticator, says you can export your codes, and moving to an iPhone means signing in on the iPhone app. The app locks with biometrics or a PIN, and the F-Droid build needs Android 8.1 or later. Proton Authenticator, Play listing, F-Droid listing
Its security record is short. Proton says the app “will undergo regular independent security audits”, but we found no published audit of it. GitHub lists no security advisory for the Android code, and the Android repository has its public issue tracker switched off, so user reports are not visible there. In launch week the iPhone app wrote full code secrets into its local debug logs; Proton fixed that in iPhone version 1.1.1 within days and said the logs never left the device. The report concerned the iPhone app only. Android releases have continued, most recently 1.3.10 on July 22, 2026, and we found no newer release, advisory or audit on November 12. Android advisories, BleepingComputer, August 4, 2025, Android release notes
Proton’s privacy claims need care. The product page promises “no ads, no trackers” and “no data collection”, but the Play listing says the app may collect personal information, version 1.3.0 added a setting for anonymous data sharing, and the build file adds Sentry crash reporting to the Play version. F-Droid builds its own version without those parts and still flags it for tracking, saying users are “fingerprinted even if not using the online features”; it also notes that the app contacts Proton’s servers to check for experimental features. We could not establish what is sent. Separately, a cooling failure at Proton’s Frankfurt datacenter took Proton’s services down overnight from August 26 to 27, 2026; codes are generated on the phone, and Proton’s report does not name this app. Play listing, F-Droid listing, Android build file, incident report, August 28, 2026
Used Proton Authenticator? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Aegis Authenticator
Also consider · Android only, never goes online
Choose Aegis when keeping your codes away from any online account matters more than easy recovery. Turn on automatic backups and get a copy off the phone yourself.
Reasons to choose it
- No internet access, per its FAQ and app manifest
- Vault and backups always encrypted
- Encrypted or plain-text export for moving to another app
What to watch
- Backups are off until you turn them on and copy them off the phone
- No iPhone app
- Update to 3.4.3: earlier versions had a high-severity icon-pack flaw
Aegis is a free, open-source Android authenticator from Beem Development. Its vault is encrypted with AES-256-GCM and unlocked with a password or biometrics, and it offers screenshot prevention and tap-to-reveal. Its FAQ says the app has no internet access and there are no plans to add it, and its published app manifest requests no internet permission. Choose it when keeping your codes away from any online account matters more to you than easy recovery. Features, FAQ
The compromise is that recovery is your job. In the current source, automatic backups and Android’s own cloud backup are both off by default, although the app shows a reminder when changes are not backed up. Both kinds of backup are only available for an encrypted vault. To get a copy off the phone you need a cloud app that fully supports Android’s file picker (the FAQ names Nextcloud, and version 3.3 added single-file backups for providers such as Google Drive), a sync tool such as Syncthing, or Android’s cloud backup. There is no iPhone app, and the FAQ rules one out, so a move to an iPhone means exporting to a different app. Backup settings in the source, version 3.3 notes, FAQ
Read the full Aegis Authenticator analysis and sources
Know which password opens your backup. By default it is the vault password, as the FAQ says, but Aegis now also offers an optional separate password for backups and exports. An open September 2025 report on version 3.4.1 describes setting up that separate password as confusing, with a restored backup that did not behave as the user expected until they followed a workaround. Another open request asks for clearer instructions on restoring a backup saved through a cloud app. Confirm which password protects your backup before you depend on it. Separate-password report, restore-instructions request
On September 6, 2026 Aegis published a high-severity advisory, GHSA-fw8c-jmjv-q6xf. A maliciously crafted icon pack could overwrite the app’s internal files, including the vault, if a user imported it. Versions 2.0 to 3.4.2 were affected and version 3.4.3 fixes it. Update, and import icon packs only from sources you trust. Advisory, version 3.4.3 notes
The app needs Android 6 or later according to its build file, is licensed under GPLv3 and has no paid plan. Its privacy policy says it collects no data from your device and uses the camera only to scan QR codes; that is the developer’s statement, not a traffic audit. We could not establish a registered legal entity behind Beem Development or any support commitment. Build file, license, privacy policy, Play listing
Used Aegis Authenticator? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
2FAS Auth
Backup in your own Google Drive · set the password
Consider 2FAS Auth when you want backups in a Google account you already manage and an iPhone app for later. Set the backup password and keep it somewhere other than the phone.
Reasons to choose it
- Google Drive sync restores codes with the same Google account
- Android and iPhone apps, with a file route between them
- PIN, biometrics and hidden codes
What to watch
- Without a password, its backup files leave secret keys readable
- A forgotten backup password makes the Drive copy unusable
- Version 6.0 needs Android 9 or later
2FAS Auth, from Two Factor Authentication Service, Inc., is free under its June 27, 2025 licence terms, works without a connection and without a 2FAS account and has Android and iPhone apps. On Android it can sync to a hidden app folder in your Google Drive. To restore, you turn sync back on and choose the same Google account. Consider it when you would rather keep the backup in a Google account you already manage than open another account. Overview, Google Drive sync, licence terms
Set the optional backup password. 2FAS says its backup has standard security and recommends adding password encryption, but it does not describe how a Drive copy without a password is stored. Its tutorial says a backup file without a password leaves your secret keys readable. If you forget the password, the Drive backup cannot be opened; you delete it and start a new one. Drive sync only works between Android devices, so moving to an iPhone means exporting a file and importing it there. Backup safety, forgotten password, tutorial, moving between devices
Read the full 2FAS Auth analysis and sources
The app can be locked with a four- or six-digit PIN, with biometrics available once a PIN is set, and can hide codes until tapped. The tutorial says a forgotten PIN cannot be restored. Version 6.0, released September 29, 2026, is a redesign that raises the minimum to Android 9; anyone still on version 2.x must first update to 5.6.0 to keep their data. Version 6.1.0, on October 19, 2026, added more import options. Tutorial, version 6.0 notes, version 6.1.0 notes
The privacy policy says authentication data stays on your device and is never sent to 2FAS servers, and describes Firebase Crashlytics crash reports, which you can switch off in device settings. The licence terms make you responsible for backups, say the company cannot recover lost codes and cap its liability at US$50. The source code is published under GPLv3, while the app’s licence terms restrict reverse engineering; these are separate documents and we offer no legal view on how they interact. Privacy policy, June 27, 2025, licence terms, source
We found no published security advisory for the Android app. A 2023 academic study reported a cloud-backup weakness in the 2FAS version it examined (3.11.0); we could not establish whether or when it was resolved. That is a historical finding, not evidence of a current flaw. USENIX Security 2023 paper
Used 2FAS Auth? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Which product are we missing?
Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.
Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.
Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.
No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.
What people are saying
Privacy Guides, an independent privacy-advice site, recommends Ente Auth and Aegis on its multi-factor authentication page (dated May 7, 2026). Its criteria are public source code, no need for an internet connection, and cloud sync that is optional and end-to-end encrypted. That is another editorial judgment that agrees with ours, not a test result. Privacy Guides
User reports show where recovery goes wrong, not how often. On Ente’s tracker, the open reports above describe codes that needed a fresh sign-in after an iPhone restore or a keychain error. On Aegis’s tracker, users ask about separate backup passwords and restoring cloud-folder backups. A 2022 Reddit discussion raises 2FAS’s dependence on the Google account that holds its backup, which current 2FAS help confirms. A more recent thread reports difficulty moving codes out of Google Authenticator into another app; its explanation is unverified and not our finding. We read both threads on September 6, 2026. Reddit: 2FAS backup, Reddit: leaving Google Authenticator
A 2023 USENIX Security study examined backup and security behaviour in older versions of Google Authenticator (5.10), Aegis (2.0.3) and 2FAS (3.11.0). Its findings describe those versions, not today’s apps. Our October 19, 2026 search of the US vulnerability database, GitHub security advisories, news and legal sources found the two advisories described above and no lawsuit, regulator action or store removal involving these apps or their developers. Our October 20 search for Proton Authenticator and Proton AG found the 2025 iPhone logging flaw described above and nothing further. On November 12, 2026 the advisory pages for Ente Auth, Proton Authenticator, Aegis and 2FAS showed nothing new. A search that finds nothing is not proof that nothing exists. No store ratings, download counts or vendor testimonials influenced our judgments. Publisher page, paper
How we researched
This is public-source research. We did not install any app, create accounts, enrol codes, make or restore backups, or test imports. No developer supplied access or payment, and no commercial arrangement influenced which apps we chose or how we judged them. We first compared Aegis, 2FAS and Google Authenticator on September 6, 2026. On October 19, 2026 we rechecked every change-sensitive claim (price, platforms, minimum Android versions, backup and sync behaviour, policies and licences) against current help pages, release notes, published source code and store listings, and searched again for security advisories, incidents and legal or regulatory records. That pass added Ente Auth, which the first version had not evaluated even though it has been available since 2022 and is independently recommended for this job. It also found the September 2026 Aegis advisory, the 2FAS 6.0 release and its new Android 9 minimum, a new Google privacy policy and the separate Aegis backup-password setting. On October 20, 2026 we searched again for newer authenticators, researched Proton Authenticator in full and scored other widely used authenticators on the same criteria. On November 12, 2026 we checked each app’s price on its own page and Google Play listing (all four are free, with no paid plan), read the current releases and security advisory pages again, searched again for newer apps and re-checked Proton Authenticator against our newer-app conditions. We read vendor documentation, terms and policies, release notes, published source code, store and F-Droid listings, GitHub’s advisory pages and independent reporting.
The reader is someone on Android who wants ordinary six-digit sign-in codes and wants to keep them if the phone is lost, broken or replaced. Before comparing the apps we fixed five criteria and their weights: getting codes back after losing the phone (30%), protection of codes in the app and in backups (20%), switching phones or moving to an iPhone (20%), security record and transparency (20%), and the developer’s data handling and continuity (10%). Price is not one of the criteria because every app here is free. Ente Auth scored 4.40 out of 5, ahead of Proton Authenticator (4.20), Aegis (3.80) and 2FAS (3.75), and it led under every reasonable reweighting we tried. Its lead over Proton Authenticator is 0.20, smaller than one point on our most heavily weighted criterion, so we call it narrow. It rests on Ente’s two published audits, where Proton has none yet, on Ente’s consistent documentation of encrypted backups, and on Ente’s public issue tracker, where Proton’s Android code has none. Aegis is the choice when a rule against any online account or network access matters more to you than easy recovery, which is why it is our use-specific alternative: it is the only app in our chart whose published manifest requests no internet permission.
On November 12, 2026 we searched again for newer authenticators, those first released since November 12, 2024, through Google Play and F-Droid listings, GitHub topic pages, Hacker News launch posts, an independent privacy-advice list and the candidates we screened in October. We found no newer app that qualifies, so we name no Rising Star. Proton Authenticator is the strongest newer app and meets the other conditions: its Android release notes list version 1.0.0 on July 31, 2025; it is available now on Google Play and F-Droid; Proton’s documentation, release notes and published code show it doing the job; and Proton AG is identifiable, publishes the code, and has no security advisory or unfixed serious flaw we could find. It fails the first condition: Proton Pass, its password manager with a built-in authenticator, has offered these codes for more than two years, and we treat a new app from an established maker of the same kind of software as not new, as we did for Bitwarden Authenticator (2024), whose own manager already holds these codes and whose help page says it stores codes in an unencrypted database on the phone. Open Authenticator, an open-source app by Hugo Delaunay, an independent developer, had a Google Play listing with user reviews by September 2024, so it is no longer a newer entrant; it also limits free sync to six codes, and its own pages disagree on whether synced codes are stored encrypted (about 2.95). Flauth, listed on F-Droid since January 2026, and Mauth, a beta, are distributed through F-Droid and GitHub rather than Google Play, which our thresholds require; Flauth also exports plain-text files (about 2.80). Reloado Auth, a newer F-Droid app with optional synced storage, names no company or person behind the service that would hold your codes, so it fails our safety check and we did not score it. Ente Auth (2022), 2FAS and Aegis (both 2019) were all available before November 2024.
We also scored widely used established authenticators on the same criteria, from public pages and with lower confidence than the four in the chart; none would overtake the Pick. Stratum, formerly Authenticator Pro (about 3.60), is an open-source Android app with encrypted backups to cloud storage or the phone, no internet access and no iPhone version; it sits 0.15 below 2FAS Auth, and we did not read its backup FAQ. Twilio Authy (about 2.95) keeps backups encrypted with a password you choose, and Twilio confirmed in July 2024 that attackers had used an unauthenticated endpoint to identify phone numbers linked to Authy accounts. Duo Mobile (about 2.95) backs up through Google with a recovery password and cannot restore across platforms. Microsoft Authenticator (about 2.75) backs up to a personal Microsoft account until January 2027, then through Google One backup, and cannot restore an iPhone backup on Android or the reverse.
Google Authenticator (3.30) is free, comes from Google LLC, needs Android 6.0 or later and generates codes without a connection. Signed in, it syncs your codes to your Google account and brings them back when you sign in on a new device; used without an account, codes stay on one phone. Google says it encrypts the codes in transit and at rest but does not describe end-to-end encryption or a separate backup password, deleting a synced code deletes it from every synced device, and without sync a move to a new phone needs the old phone for a QR-code export; if the old phone is gone, Google’s help says you must set up each service again. Security researchers presenting “Pixnapping” at ACM CCS in October 2025 showed a malicious Android app reading its codes in under 30 seconds on Pixel 6 to 9 and Galaxy S25 phones (CVE-2025-48561); it is an Android weakness, not specific to this app, and we did not establish the current fix status, so keep Android security updates installed whichever app you use. Google’s privacy policy covers many services and does not list what this app sends in each mode. It has more than 100 million Google Play installs and needs the least setup, but it scored below the four apps in the chart, so it has no chart column or section: choose it only if your Google account is already your recovery plan. Authenticator help, Play listing, Pixnapping research, privacy policy
| Tool | Public sources | What remains uncertain |
|---|---|---|
| Ente Auth | Product page, help pages on use without an account, export and lockout, privacy policy, Ente’s 2023 and 2025 audit posts, server advisory, Android build file, tracker issues, Play listing. | Whether the 2023 audit examined the Auth app itself, the three unlisted 2025 findings, how often device restores leave codes unreadable. |
| Aegis Authenticator | README, FAQ, release notes, settings text and build file in the source, advisory, tracker issues, licence, privacy policy, Play listing. | Current behaviour of the separate backup password, which cloud apps deliver backups reliably, the developer’s legal entity. |
| 2FAS Auth | Product page, help on Drive sync, moving devices, app settings and backup safety, privacy policy, licence terms, source repository, version 6.0 notes, Play listing. | How a Drive backup without a password is stored, whether the 2023 study’s finding was fixed, how version 6.0 behaves in wide use. |
| Proton Authenticator | Product page, FAQs and backup help, security-model post, Android release notes, backup settings and build file in the source, GitHub advisory page, Play and F-Droid listings, Proton’s terms, account-recovery help and outage report, TechCrunch and BleepingComputer (October 20); release notes, advisory page, Play and F-Droid listings, product page and FAQ read again November 12. | Whether Android backups were ever written without a password, what the tracking F-Droid flags sends, when an independent audit will be published. |
| Google Authenticator and other authenticators screened | Authenticator help, Play listing, Google’s privacy policy and terms and the Pixnapping research page; Open Authenticator’s site, FAQ, terms, release list and Play listing; Flauth’s and Mauth’s code and F-Droid listings; Reloado Auth’s F-Droid listing; Bitwarden Authenticator help; Stratum’s code, releases, advisory page and Play listing; Authy, Microsoft Authenticator and Duo Restore help and Play listings; Twilio’s backup post and SecurityWeek (October 20); Privacy Guides, F-Droid searches, GitHub topic pages and Hacker News launch posts (November 12). | Scores for these are indicative. Whether Google’s synced codes are end-to-end encrypted, the current Pixnapping fix status, Stratum’s scheduled-backup documentation and any operator behind Reloado Auth were not established. |
None of this establishes that a backup will restore on your phone. Next substantive review is due December 18, 2026, or sooner if a backup, sync, security or policy change warrants it. Found a changed fact? Contact the editors.
Sources and evidence
Sources were checked October 19, 2026 unless another date is given; pages marked November 12, 2026 were read again that day. Developer material establishes documented features and policies, not that they work as described. Audit summaries are the developer’s account of the audit. Community posts are attributed experiences, not representative samples.
- Ente Auth: product page; launch announcement, December 9, 2022; use without an account; export format and local backups; lockout guidance; 2023 cryptography audit post; 2025 Cure53 audit post; privacy policy, October 16, 2026; server advisory GHSA-2hxj-953x-c2vw, July 28, 2026; Android build file; tracker issues 4667 and 7282; Play listing, updated October 5, 2026.
- Aegis Authenticator: overview; features; FAQ; backup settings text; build file; release notes 3.3 and 3.4.3, September 6, 2026; advisory GHSA-fw8c-jmjv-q6xf; issues 1721 and 1728; licence; privacy policy; Play listing, updated September 6, 2026.
- 2FAS Auth: overview; Google Drive sync; moving between devices; app tutorial; backup safety; forgotten backup password; privacy policy, June 27, 2025; licence terms, June 27, 2025; Android source; version 6.0 notes, September 29, 2026; Play listing, updated October 6, 2026.
- Google Authenticator: Authenticator help; Play listing, updated July 21, 2026; privacy policy, effective October 16, 2026; terms, United States version effective July 30, 2026.
- Proton Authenticator, checked October 20, 2026: product page; FAQs; backup help; security model, October 29, 2025; Android release notes; backup settings in the source; Android build file; Android advisories; Play listing, updated July 24, 2026; F-Droid listing; terms, October 9, 2026; account recovery; incident report, August 28, 2026; TechCrunch, July 31, 2025; BleepingComputer, August 4, 2025.
- Newer and other authenticators, checked October 20, 2026: Open Authenticator site, FAQ, privacy policy, April 22, 2026, releases and developer page; Flauth code and F-Droid listing; Mauth code and F-Droid listing; Bitwarden Authenticator help; Stratum code and Play listing, updated May 8, 2026; Microsoft Authenticator backup help; Duo Restore guide; Twilio’s Authy backup post and SecurityWeek, July 4, 2024; first releases: Aegis 1.0, September 8, 2019 and 2FAS 2.1.8 on APKMirror, December 17, 2019.
- Rechecked November 12, 2026: Ente Auth product page, releases, advisories and Play listing; Proton Authenticator product page, FAQs, Android release notes, advisories, Play listing, F-Droid listing and TechCrunch, July 31, 2025; Aegis releases, advisories and Play listing; 2FAS overview, releases, advisories and Play listing; Google Authenticator help and Play listing.
- Newer and other authenticators, rechecked November 12, 2026: Open Authenticator site, FAQ, last updated April 6, 2026, terms, release list and Play listing; Flauth code and F-Droid listing; Mauth code and F-Droid listing; Reloado Auth F-Droid listing; FreeOTP+ code; Bitwarden Authenticator help and Play listing; Stratum code, releases, advisories and Play listing; Authy site and Play listing; Duo Mobile page, Duo Restore guide and Play listing; Microsoft Authenticator page, backup help and Play listing; F-Droid search for authenticators, GitHub topics totp-authenticator and authenticator-app, and Hacker News searches for authenticator apps, open-source TOTP and Android 2FA apps.
- Independent research and recommendations: Pixnapping research page (ACM CCS, October 2025); USENIX Security 2023 publisher page and paper; Privacy Guides multi-factor authentication page, read again November 12, 2026.
- Community discussions, read September 6, 2026: Reddit 2FAS backup and leaving Google Authenticator.
This is a researched comparison, not a product review. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.