Reader review and badge rules
Share what happened when you used a tool. Helpful praise and criticism are both welcome.
What we accept
Write about your own recent experience. Explain the task, plan and platform you used. Choose a display name that does not impersonate anyone. Do not include private information, promotional links, threats, harassment or unrelated material.
Employees, owners, affiliates and compensated reviewers may not submit customer ratings. Do not create extra accounts to repeat a rating. Vendors can contact us to request a clearly identified response or correction.
How moderation works
Email confirmation comes first. Automated checks screen for spam, duplication, exposed personal information, abuse and suspected manipulation. Submissions that pass can be published automatically once this service launches. Uncertain cases stay private for editorial moderation.
AI assists moderation but cannot prove that an experience happened. Email verification does not verify a purchase or product use. The same rules apply to favorable and unfavorable reviews, including reviews of our picks and related businesses.
Reports trigger investigation, not automatic removal. We may temporarily hide content that exposes private information or presents a serious risk. We do not silently rewrite the meaning of a review. Contact us to report a review, request an edit or deletion, or appeal a moderation decision. Include the product and review link, but do not send passwords or payment details.
How reader ratings work
Stars are optional and chosen by the reviewer. One active eligible rating per account and product counts toward the arithmetic mean. We show the combined score after 10 eligible ratings, rounded to one decimal place, alongside the count and distribution. This threshold does not establish statistical reliability.
Pending, removed, insider and incentivized contributions do not count. Reviews appear newest first. Updated ratings replace earlier ratings rather than adding another vote. Reader satisfaction is separate from our editorial recommendations and is never adjusted because of payment.
Free badge usage
Businesses may display the supplied badge for the matching product at no charge. The badge links to its review page so visitors can inspect the evidence. Keep that link and the nofollow attribute. Do not alter the score, hide the review count, or describe the badge as an editorial award or verified-customer certification.
Rating badges must use our hosted image. Do not download, screenshot or self-host a rating badge. The image URL stays the same when published ratings change; a new submission does not change the badge until it passes moderation and is published. Below 10 eligible ratings the hosted badge displays an invitation to leave a review, without a score. Static editorial badges such as “Read our review” may be downloaded when offered.
Invite all customers on the same terms. Do not offer incentives, pre-screen for satisfaction, direct only happy customers here, or pressure people to remove criticism. Using a badge does not buy coverage, affect moderation, or guarantee search visibility. We may withdraw badge permission for misuse.
Review privacy
Your display name, experience, selected rating, platform, plan and dates can be public. Your email address stays private and is used for verification and review administration. Do not put sensitive details in the public fields.
We store submissions and moderation records on our infrastructure. Automated moderation may process review text; email addresses are excluded from model screening. Security records help detect repeated abuse. Before intake opens, the published privacy notice will specify retention periods, processor details and how to exercise data rights. During the private preview, the submission form is disabled.
Badge claims and checks
Use a badge only for the product it names. “Read our review” and “See our comparison” identify coverage, not endorsement. A “Best for” badge must retain its exact qualifying use and our hosted image; do not crop it into an unqualified claim or keep a frozen copy after the recommendation changes.
We can inspect known placements and investigate reports. Missing browser information or a page we cannot access is not proof of misuse. Badge enforcement does not change editorial scores or genuine reader ratings. Report badge misuse or contact us to request a correction to a finding.