Employee records, time off and onboarding for a small company: Zoho People, HRGrove, TalentHR and Homebase
Zoho People is our Pick, narrowly ahead of cheaper TalentHR: records, time-off policies and onboarding with a pre-joining portal for 20 people at $1,200 a year. HRGrove is a 2026 newcomer with built-in e-signatures and a new-hire portal, at $159 a month for 20 people.
Zoho People
Workforce includes the employee database and files, time-off policies with approvals and employee balances, onboarding checklists and a portal where new hires fill in details and sign documents before they join, per Zoho.
Its lead over TalentHR is narrow (4.47 against 4.44) and would reverse if price counted for a little more; e-signature needs a connected service, and Zoho may use anonymized data to improve its algorithms.
Why Zoho People is our PickTeam behind Zoho People? Get your award badge
HRGrove
An HR system first released in 2026 that says its Full plan includes leave requests and approvals, PTO balances for each employee, onboarding checklists, a new-hire portal and built-in e-signatures.
It is a product first released this year with no independent reviews, no phone app and no security audit of its own, and at $159 a month for 20 people it costs about 60% more than the Pick billed yearly.
Why HRGrove earned Rising StarWho is this article for? The owner, office manager or first HR person at a US company of about 20 employees that runs payroll elsewhere and wants employee records, time off and onboarding in one system.
About 23 min read
What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean
The quick list
Prices read November 16, 2026, for the cheapest plan that covers records, time off and onboarding for 20 employees.
Published US prices, read November 16, 2026, before tax. Zoho People Workforce is $5 per user a month billed yearly ($1,200 a year for 20) or $6 monthly. HRGrove Full is $39 a month plus $6 per employee ($159 a month for 20). TalentHR Essential is $2 per user a month with a 15-user minimum ($40 a month for 20); Premium, with document signing, is $4. Homebase All-in-One is $120 a month per location for unlimited employees on its website and $99.95 in its Google Play listing.
The comparison at a glance
Compare what each system costs over three years for 20 employees, how it handles time off and new hires, what it may do with employee data, and who runs it.
Order follows our verdict for a 20-person US company, not measured ease of use. All tools remain selectable.
Hides matching answers for the selected tools. Unknowns and unverified claims stay visible.
| Feature | Zoho People | HRGrove | TalentHR | Homebase |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: records, time off and fuller onboarding for 20 people at $1,200 a year; narrow lead | Rising Star: 2026 newcomer with e-signatures and a new-hire portal on one plan | Accrual policies and onboarding tasks for $40 a month; signing on Premium | HR paperwork alongside shift scheduling, unlimited employees per location |
| Price for this job | Workforce: $5/user/month billed yearly or $6 monthly; $3 Essential HR has no time off | Full: $39/month + $6/employee, billed monthly | Essential: $2/user/month (15-user minimum); Premium $4 | All-in-One: $120/location/month (Google Play lists $99.95) |
| Three-year cost we scored, 20 employees | $3,600 | $5,724 | $1,440 | $4,320 |
| Accrual and balances | Days credited per period, reset and carry-forward; employees see their balances | PTO balance in each employee’s portal; accrual rules not found | Accrual policies and prorated allowances; employee view of balances not stated | PTO policies that track accruals and balances |
| Before day one | Pre-onboarding portal for details and documents | New-hire portal | Not found | Not stated |
| Signing documents | Acknowledge in the product; e-signature through Zoho Sign or another service | Built-in e-signatures | Document signing on Premium ($4) | Verify and e-sign paperwork |
| Employee data and AI | “Anonymized crops of service data” improve its algorithms; no opt-out found | AI runs on Anthropic’s Claude; SSNs and passwords not sent | AI uses OpenAI and AWS Bedrock; no identifying data allowed in AI tools | May train AI models on data “linked to specific individuals”; no opt-out found |
| Who runs it | Zoho Corporation (US), Pleasanton, California | DataSpark Tech LLC (Texas); no address published | Epignosis LLC, Delaware | Pioneer Works, Inc., San Francisco |
For a US company of about 20 employees that runs payroll elsewhere. Sources checked November 16, 2026; next review December 21, 2026, or sooner after a price or plan change. Features are each maker’s own description; we did not test how any system works. Store ratings were read on November 16, 2026. Public-source research: no accounts, trials or purchases.
All features and sources 19 criteria
Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.
Price and time off
Show 6 criteria
| Feature | Zoho People | HRGrove | TalentHR | Homebase |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: records, time off and fuller onboarding for 20 people at $1,200 a year; narrow lead | Rising Star: 2026 newcomer with e-signatures and a new-hire portal on one plan | Accrual policies and onboarding tasks for $40 a month; signing on Premium | HR paperwork alongside shift scheduling, unlimited employees per location |
| Price for this job | Workforce: $5/user/month billed yearly or $6 monthly; $3 Essential HR has no time off | Full: $39/month + $6/employee, billed monthly | Essential: $2/user/month (15-user minimum); Premium $4 | All-in-One: $120/location/month (Google Play lists $99.95) |
| Three-year cost we scored, 20 employees | $3,600 | $5,724 | $1,440 | $4,320 |
| Time-off requests and approval | Yes, approve from email or the app | Leave request workflows; managers approve | Yes, with multiple approvers | Managers approve requests in the app |
| Accrual and balances | Days credited per period, reset and carry-forward; employees see their balances | PTO balance in each employee’s portal; accrual rules not found | Accrual policies and prorated allowances; employee view of balances not stated | PTO policies that track accruals and balances |
| Who’s off | Leave calendar, syncs with Office 365 or Google Calendar | Holiday calendar; PTO calendar in the portal | Calendar and matrix views | Team-wide time-off dashboard |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for price and time off
Prices in USD read November 16, 2026, taxes excluded: Zoho People US plan comparison (PDF), leave policy help and leave management; HRGrove pricing and employee portal; TalentHR pricing; Homebase pricing and Google Play.
Records and onboarding
Show 7 criteria
| Feature | Zoho People | HRGrove | TalentHR | Homebase |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Employee records | Employee database, employee files and uploads, custom form fields | People directory and document storage; custom fields not found | Emergency contacts, documents, custom fields | Document storage; records built around scheduling |
| Employee self-service | Self-service tabs employees can view and edit | Self-serve portal: PTO, pay stubs, documents | Employee self-service portal | Not found |
| Export your data | Exports can be password-protected; file format not named | “Export everything” as a file; 30 days after you leave | “Export data” and custom exports; format not named | “Standard export tools”; 15 days after termination notice |
| Phone apps | iPhone 4.3 (172 ratings); Android 3.7 (5.7K reviews) | None found; mobile-friendly website | iPhone 4.5 (30 ratings); Android 1K+ downloads | iPhone 4.8 (98K); Android 4.5 (26.1K) |
| Onboarding checklist | Checklist tasks and onboarding on Workforce | Task checklists | Onboarding task automation | Onboarding packets |
| Before day one | Pre-onboarding portal for details and documents | New-hire portal | Not found | Not stated |
| Signing documents | Acknowledge in the product; e-signature through Zoho Sign or another service | Built-in e-signatures | Document signing on Premium ($4) | Verify and e-sign paperwork |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for records and onboarding
Zoho People self-service help, form and export help, candidate onboarding, document acknowledgement and Google Play; HRGrove home, pricing, about and terms; TalentHR pricing, App Store and Google Play; Homebase pricing, licence agreement and Google Play.
Where employee data goes
Show 3 criteria
| Feature | Zoho People | HRGrove | TalentHR | Homebase |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Employee data and AI | “Anonymized crops of service data” improve its algorithms; no opt-out found | AI runs on Anthropic’s Claude; SSNs and passwords not sent | AI uses OpenAI and AWS Bedrock; no identifying data allowed in AI tools | May train AI models on data “linked to specific individuals”; no opt-out found |
| Selling or advertising | “Never sold your information ... for advertising” | “We do not sell personal information” | “We do not sell your personal information or Content” | Targeting cookies; may sell “Data Products” built from your data |
| Security certification | ISO/IEC 27001 certification; SOC 2 Type 2 report | None of its own; hosts are certified | None named; hosted on AWS | None found |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for where employee data goes
Zoho privacy policy and compliance; HRGrove privacy policy and security; TalentHR privacy policy, AI terms and security; Homebase privacy policy and licence agreement.
Operator, terms and record
Show 3 criteria
| Feature | Zoho People | HRGrove | TalentHR | Homebase |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who runs it | Zoho Corporation (US), Pleasanton, California | DataSpark Tech LLC (Texas); no address published | Epignosis LLC, Delaware | Pioneer Works, Inc., San Francisco |
| Cancelling | Downgrade to free or give 7 days’ notice before renewal | Cancel in settings; no refunds for part months | Cancel in the portal; yearly refund in first 3 months less 10% | Cancel by logging in; fees non-refundable |
| Record to know | Android reviews (2026) report check-in problems | First released 2026; no independent reviews found | 30 App Store ratings | Terms let it train AI on identifiable employee data |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for operator, terms and record
Zoho terms, contracting entities and California privacy notice; HRGrove terms and about; TalentHR terms; Homebase licence agreement.
What matters when choosing
Zoho People is our Preferred Pick for a US company of about 20 employees that wants its employee records, time off and onboarding out of spreadsheets, but its lead is narrow. Its Workforce plan costs $5 per user a month billed yearly, or $6 month to month: $100 a month, $1,200 a year, for 20 people (prices read November 16, 2026, before tax). Zoho’s US plan comparison puts custom time-off policies, time-off approvals, the employee database and files, candidate and employee onboarding, and checklist tasks on that plan. Zoho’s help pages say employees can see their leave balance and apply for leave from their self-service page, and that new hires get a separate onboarding portal before they join, where they fill in their details and sign documents. You can ask employees to acknowledge a policy document inside Zoho People. Zoho People US plan comparison (PDF), self-service help, candidate onboarding help, document acknowledgement help
Its drawbacks: time off is not on its cheaper plans, e-signature is not built in, and Zoho may use your data to improve its AI. Zoho’s $3 Essential HR plan has onboarding but no time-off policies or approvals, so this job needs Workforce. Zoho’s plan page also shows an older, cheaper table (Essential HR at $1.25 with time off); Zoho’s own US PDF of the same page shows only the prices above, which we used. Signing documents needs Zoho Sign or another e-signature service connected to Zoho People. Zoho’s privacy policy allows “anonymized crops of service data” to be used to improve its algorithms and your organization’s data to be used for models specific to your organization; we found no opt-out. Its Android app has 3.7 stars from about 5,700 reviews, and recent reviews complain about attendance check-in. We found no CSV or Excel export format named on the pages we read, though Zoho describes password-protecting exported files. Zoho People scored 4.47 out of 5 against 4.44 for TalentHR, which would come first if price counted for a little more in our formula. Zoho People plan comparison, privacy policy, Google Play listing, form and export help
HRGrove is our Rising Star. It is an HR system first released in 2026 by DataSpark Tech LLC, a Texas company named in its terms. Its Full plan costs $39 a month plus $6 per employee, $159 a month for 20 people, and HRGrove says it includes leave requests with approvals, PTO balances in each employee’s portal, onboarding checklists, a new-hire portal and built-in e-signatures. Its main limits: it is a product first released this year with no independent reviews we could find, no phone app in the App Store or Google Play, and no security audit of its own, and at its monthly price of $159 for 20 people it costs about 60% more than the Pick billed yearly ($100 a month), or about a third more if its annual option is available. It scored 3.99. HRGrove pricing, terms, about
Consider TalentHR if price matters most: its Essential plan is $2 per user a month ($40 for 20 people) with accrual policies and onboarding tasks, and document signing is on Premium at $4. Consider Homebase if your staff work shifts and you already schedule them there: All-in-One is $120 a month per location for unlimited employees, but its terms let it train AI models on data linked to individual employees.
Choose something else if you want one company to run payroll and HR together: OnPay, Gusto and Justworks sell HR tools with payroll, which our payroll comparison covers. BambooHR, a widely used HR system, charges a flat $250 a month on its Core plan for companies of 25 or fewer, two and a half times the Pick, and scored 3.89. If you mainly need to hire, see our applicant tracking comparison.
Disclosure: Practical Picks is researched and written with Claude, an AI model made by Anthropic. Zoho, the maker of our Pick, offers Zoho MCP for Zoho People, which it says lets AI agents “like GPT, Claude, and Gemini” work with your Zoho data. HRGrove, our Rising Star, says its AI features are “powered by Claude AI” and names Anthropic as its AI provider. BambooHR (beta), Deel and Gusto offer connections to Claude, Factorial runs an MCP server that AI models such as Claude can use, and Day Off, a leave tracker we set aside, offers to connect AI agents like Claude. AI features carried no weight in this comparison, and we have no relationship with any of these companies. Zoho MCP for Zoho People, HRGrove privacy policy, BambooHR Claude connector, Deel connector for Claude, Gusto MCP
Zoho People
Preferred Pick · records, time off and onboarding for 20 people at $1,200 a year
Choose Zoho People if you want employee records, time-off policies with approvals and balances, onboarding checklists and a pre-joining portal for new hires, for $1,200 a year for 20 people. Its lead over TalentHR is narrow, signing needs a connected e-signature service, and Zoho may use anonymized data to improve its algorithms.
Reasons to choose it
- Time-off policies, approvals and employee-visible balances
- Onboarding checklists and a portal for new hires before they join
- ISO/IEC 27001 certification and a SOC 2 Type 2 report, per Zoho
What to watch
- Time off needs Workforce ($5); the $3 plan has none
- E-signature only through Zoho Sign or another service
- Uses anonymized crops of data to improve its algorithms; no opt-out found
Zoho People is an HR system from Zoho. For US customers, Zoho’s terms point to its contracting entity, Zoho Corporation (US), under California law, and Zoho’s California privacy notice gives Zoho Corporation’s address at 4141 Hacienda Drive, Pleasanton, California. Workforce costs $5 per user a month billed yearly or $6 billed monthly. Zoho’s free plan covers three users and its $3 Essential HR plan has no time-off policies, so neither fits this job. For 20 employees we scored $3,600 over three years at the yearly price. Zoho People US plan comparison (PDF), contracting entities, California privacy notice
Choose it if you want every core HR task covered, with the fullest onboarding we found at this price. Zoho’s US plan comparison puts the employee database, organization and employee files, employee file uploads, custom time-off policies, time-off approvals, candidate and employee onboarding and checklist tasks on Workforce, and iPhone and Android apps are available. Its help pages describe leave types where you set how many days are credited, when balances reset and whether unused leave carries forward. Employees see their balance and apply for leave from their self-service page, which has tabs they “can view and edit”; managers approve from email or the app, and the leave calendar syncs with Office 365 or Google Calendar. New hires get a pre-onboarding portal where they “fill in their personal, professional, and education details, and sign the required documents”. You can add your own fields to forms and require employees to acknowledge a document by a deadline. Zoho lists ISO/IEC 27001 certification and a SOC 2 Type 2 report. These are Zoho’s descriptions; we did not use the product. Leave policy help, leave management, self-service help, onboarding overview, compliance
Read the full Zoho People analysis and sources
Choose something else if price matters most, if you need signatures inside the HR system without paying for another service, or if you object to your data improving a vendor’s AI. TalentHR covers time off and onboarding tasks for $40 a month for 20 people, against Zoho’s $100. On Zoho, signing goes through an e-signature integration. Zoho’s privacy policy says it has “never sold your information to someone else for advertising”, but allows anonymized crops of service data to improve its algorithms, with no opt-out. Plans renew automatically unless you downgrade to the free plan or tell Zoho at least seven days before the renewal date, and price increases apply only after your current billing cycle. Its iPhone app has 4.3 stars from 172 ratings and its Android app 3.7 from about 5,700 reviews. Zoho People plan comparison, privacy policy, terms, App Store listing
Used Zoho People? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
HRGrove
Rising Star · 2026 newcomer with e-signatures and a new-hire portal
Consider HRGrove if you want built-in e-signatures, onboarding checklists, a new-hire portal and PTO balances in one plan and are comfortable being an early customer. It is a product first released in 2026 with no independent reviews, no phone app and no security audit of its own, at $159 a month for 20 people.
Reasons to choose it
- E-signatures, new-hire portal and task checklists on Full, per HRGrove
- PTO balance and requests in each employee’s portal
- “Export everything”, including time-off history, as a file
What to watch
- First released 2026; no independent reviews or register record found
- No App Store or Google Play app found
- No security audit or certification of its own
HRGrove is a web-based HR system run by DataSpark Tech LLC, which its terms name and place under Texas law; the terms give an email address but no street address, and we found no business-register record for the company. Its about page says it was “Built in 2026”, with core hiring, onboarding, time tracking and the employee portal shipped in early 2026, and its blog has posts from August and September 2026. The Full plan costs $39 a month plus $6 per employee, billed monthly: $159 a month for 20 people, which we scored at $5,724 over three years. A Basic plan ($19 plus $4 per employee) is described only as “Core HR & hiring”, so we could not tell whether it covers time off and onboarding. Pricing, terms, about, blog
Choose it if you want e-signatures, onboarding checklists and a new-hire portal in one plan and are comfortable being an early customer. HRGrove’s pricing lists “E-signatures built-in, New hire portal, Task checklists” and “PTO tracking & balances, Holiday calendar, Leave request workflows” on Full. Its employee portal page shows each employee’s PTO balance, time-off requests and documents, and managers approve requests. Its about page says you can “export everything”, including employees, documents and time-off history, as a file from Settings, and its terms keep exports available for 30 days after you leave. Its privacy policy says “We do not sell personal information”, and that Social Security numbers, passwords and payment data are not sent to its AI provider, Anthropic. These are vendor claims; we found no independent reviews. Pricing, employee portal, about, privacy policy, security
Read the full HRGrove analysis and sources
Choose something else if you want a proven company, a phone app or a low price. HRGrove’s security page says it “hasn’t pursued its own formal security audit or certification”; the SOC 2 badge on its pricing page refers to its hosting providers. We found no App Store or Google Play app; the portal is a mobile-friendly website. We did not find accrual rules or a separate sick-leave policy on its own pages. Its pricing page says no card is needed for the 30-day trial, while its terms say a payment method is required. Its terms describe monthly billing with no refunds for part months, although its pricing calculator shows an annual option with two months free; we used the monthly price. Price changes come with 30 days’ notice, and disputes go to binding arbitration in Texas with a class-action waiver, which you can opt out of by email within 30 days. Much of the product (hiring, performance, shift scheduling) goes beyond this job. Security, terms, pricing
Used HRGrove? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
TalentHR
Also consider · accrual policies and onboarding tasks for $40 a month
Consider TalentHR if price matters most: accrual policies, custom fields, document storage and onboarding tasks for $40 a month for 20 people, and it would be our Pick if price counted for a little more. Document signing needs Premium at $4 per user, and it names no SOC 2 or ISO 27001 certification.
Reasons to choose it
- Accrual policies, calendar view and multiple approvers on Essential
- Custom fields, emergency contacts and employee documents
- iPhone and Android apps
What to watch
- Document signing only on Premium ($4)
- No step for new hires before day one found
- No security certification named
TalentHR is made by Epignosis LLC, a US company registered in Delaware according to its terms, which also name Epignosis UK Limited; Epignosis UK publishes its phone apps. Its prices are in US dollars: Free covers up to 10 users, Essential is $2 per user a month and Premium $4, paid plans need at least 15 users, and the page offers a 20% saving on yearly billing without showing which figure is displayed. We scored Essential at $1,440 over three years for 20 people. Pricing, terms
Choose it if you want a simple, low-cost HR system with time-off policies and onboarding tasks. Its plan table lists accrual policies, prorated allowances, custom leave types, a calendar view and multiple approvers; an employee database with emergency contacts and custom fields; employee document storage; data export; onboarding task automation and welcome emails; and an employee self-service portal, all on Essential. It has iPhone and Android apps, the iPhone one rated 4.5 from 30 ratings. Its privacy policy says “We do not sell your personal information or Content”. Pricing, privacy policy, App Store listing
Read the full TalentHR analysis and sources
Choose something else if you need signatures on the cheap plan or audited security. Document signing is listed only on Premium ($4, or $80 a month for 20 people). We did not find a step for new hires before their first day or a statement that employees see their own balances, and its security page names AWS hosting and encryption but no SOC 2 or ISO 27001 certification for TalentHR. Its AI features use OpenAI and AWS Bedrock. You can cancel in its portal; a yearly plan cancelled in the first three months earns a pro-rated refund less a 10% fee. Pricing, security, AI terms, terms
Used TalentHR? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Homebase
Also consider · HR paperwork alongside shift scheduling
Consider Homebase if your staff work shifts and you want PTO accruals, onboarding packets and e-signed paperwork in the app they already use, for $120 a month per location. Its terms let it train AI models on data linked to individual employees and sell data products built from your data.
Reasons to choose it
- PTO policies that track accruals and balances
- Onboarding packets with e-signed paperwork
- Unlimited employees per location
What to watch
- May train AI on data linked to specific employees; no opt-out found
- Records built around scheduling; no self-service edits found
- No security certification found
Homebase is run by Pioneer Works, Inc., a Delaware corporation in San Francisco. Its All-in-One plan costs $120 per location a month for unlimited employees, and is the plan whose card lists “Employee onboarding without payroll” and “HR & compliance”. The pricing page has a yearly option that saves 20% but did not show which figure was displayed, and its Google Play listing gives All-in-One as $99.95 a month; we scored $120, or $4,320 over three years. Pricing, end-user licence agreement, Google Play listing
Choose it if your team works shifts and you want HR paperwork in the same app your staff already use. Homebase lists PTO policies that “automatically track accruals and balances”, a team-wide time-off dashboard, onboarding packets for new hires, “Verify & e-sign employee paperwork” and employee document storage, and its app lets managers approve time-off requests. Its apps have 4.8 stars from about 98,000 App Store ratings and 4.5 from about 26,100 Google Play reviews. You can cancel by logging in. Pricing, Google Play listing
Read the full Homebase analysis and sources
Choose something else if you care what happens to employee data. Homebase’s privacy policy says “We may use data submitted through the Services to train, test, and improve our AI models. This may include data linked to specific individuals”, and its licence agreement has the account owner authorize training on content that identifies employees and lets Homebase license or sell “Data Products” built from data derived from your content to third parties. We found no opt-out for the company. Its privacy policy also describes advertising cookies and a right to opt out of sharing for cross-context behavioural advertising. Its employee records are built around scheduling; we did not find custom fields, employee self-service edits or a CSV export, or a step for new hires before day one. Fees are non-refundable. Privacy policy, end-user licence agreement
Used Homebase? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Which product are we missing?
Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.
Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.
Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.
No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.
What people are saying
We read outside sources to test our assumptions, not to score satisfaction. Recent Google Play reviews of Zoho People (September and October 2026) describe attendance check-in failing or the camera blurring during check-in; Zoho replied to both. A 2021 App Store review of BambooHR says its calendar and “out today” view leave out the person looking at it. A 2022 Google Play review of Homebase says some information, such as requested and approved days off, is easier to see on the full website than in the app. TalentHR’s iPhone app has 30 ratings. We found no independent reviews of HRGrove. We could not read G2, Capterra, GetApp or Trustpilot, so this is not a representative sample. Zoho People on Google Play, BambooHR on the App Store, Homebase on Google Play
BambooHR took its platform offline in the United States, Canada and Ireland for several hours in October 2026 as a precaution against PHP2Shell, a pair of critical flaws in PHP; HCAmag reported on October 22 that BambooHR “has not said that any customer data was accessed”. HCAmag, October 22, 2026
How we researched
This is public-source research carried out on November 16, 2026. We did not create accounts, start trials or buy plans, and no company supplied access or payment. We read each product’s pricing page, help centre, terms, privacy policy, security page and App Store and Google Play listings, plus independent reporting and court records.
We chose systems for one job: a US company of about 20 employees, with one administrator and three managers who approve time off, that runs payroll elsewhere and wants employee records with documents and self-service, time-off requests with accruing balances, and onboarding checklists with documents to read or sign, plus a way to export its data. A product had to cover those on the plan we priced, run in a web browser and be sold to US companies; one that sells HR tools only with its own payroll had the payroll cost counted. For price we counted three years at the cheapest such plan billed for 12 months or less, before tax. Before scoring we fixed six criteria and weights: three-year cost (25%), time off (20%), employee records (20%), onboarding (15%), where employee data goes (10%) and the operator and its record (10%). Cost was scored against the median three-year cost of the eleven priced products, $4,320.
We also scored Sesame HR (3.99: Essential is $4.25 per employee a month in its plan table, though its plan card shows $3.75; onboarding and one digital signature per employee a month are included, custom fields are not), Sage HR (3.80: $6 per employee a month for Core HR and leave; its app lists onboarding tasks and e-signed documents, but we found no accrual rules or balances, and its terms would not load), BambooHR (3.89: Core is a flat $250 a month for 25 or fewer employees; it lists time-off accruals, approvals, employee balances and a calendar, pre-onboarding packets and e-signatures, but its AI terms let it train models on your data for your account and it may share data for cross-context advertising), Deel HR (3.75: HR Core is $5 per person a month; we found no accrual rules, balances or e-signature on its pages, and it says it may share data with advertising partners for targeted ads), OnPay (3.71: $49 a month plus $6 per worker for payroll, plus $15 and $2 per worker for the HR add-on that brings time-off requests, $224 a month for 20 people; you must use its payroll and give 30 days’ written notice to leave) and Justworks (3.58: $50 a month plus $8 per employee, and you must use its payroll). Gusto’s own pages would not load for us; an independent October 2026 review puts time-off request management on its Plus plan at $80 a month plus $12 per person, so even with full marks outside price it could reach only 4.30. Connecteam’s HR price did not display; its free plan stops at 10 users, and it could overtake our Pick only if it cost less than $24 over three years. Rippling ($8 per employee plus an unpublished base fee), Factorial (“starts at $8 per user”, modules by quote), Personio, HiBob, Humaans, OrangeHRM, TriNet (whose software-only product is being wound down) and GoCo have no published price for this job, so they could not be scored; nor could payroll-led suites such as ADP, Paychex, Paycor, Paylocity and Paycom, which we did not research. Patriot (payroll from $17 a month plus $4 per worker, HR add-on $6 plus $2 per employee) and Square Payroll ($35 plus $6 per person) did not show time-off requests on the pages we read. Breathe is built and priced for UK employers.
For the Rising Star we searched Product Hunt, GitHub, app stores and recent coverage for HR systems first released since November 16, 2024. HRGrove qualified. OnBordly names no company or person and its terms and privacy pages return errors; Natant is in private beta; Skapp (released February 2025) does not show onboarding checklists or employee documents; Armano dates from 2023; QuickBooks Workforce comes from Intuit, an established payroll company; SimplyPTO and Day Off track leave only.
We confirmed the Pick’s operator: Zoho’s terms point US customers to Zoho Corporation (US), its California privacy notice gives Zoho Corporation’s Pleasanton address, and Bloomberg Law’s report of a California federal court ruling names Zoho Corporation as a party alongside Zoho Corporation Pvt. Ltd. and Zoho Technologies Corporation.
| Tool | Public sources | What remains uncertain |
|---|---|---|
| Zoho People | US plan-comparison PDF and plan page, leave, self-service, onboarding, acknowledgement and form help, terms, privacy policies, contracting-entity and compliance pages, App Store and Google Play listings, Bloomberg Law. | The export file format; whether its leave crediting covers every accrual rule you need; why its plan page still shows an older, cheaper table; a register entry for Zoho Corporation (US). |
| HRGrove | Pricing, home, features, employee portal, about, blog, terms, privacy and security pages. | Who runs the company beyond its name (no register record found); accrual rules; what the Basic plan includes; how it will be supported over time. |
| TalentHR | Pricing and plan table, home, terms, privacy policy, AI terms, security page, App Store and Google Play listings. | Whether the displayed price is the monthly or yearly rate; whether new hires get access before day one (its help centre would not load). |
| Homebase | Pricing page, licence agreement, website terms, privacy policies, App Store and Google Play listings. | Which features each plan includes (the plan marks did not load); whether $120 is the monthly or yearly rate. |
| Others | Pricing, terms, privacy and store pages for each product named above; BambooHR, Sage HR and Sesame HR pricing, terms and store pages; OnPay pricing, HR add-on guide, terms and privacy policy; Patriot and Square Payroll pricing; Deel and Rippling court filing; TriNet annual report; Companies House; tech.co on Gusto. | Gusto’s own terms and features; Connecteam’s HR price; Sage HR’s terms, privacy policy and leave details; which BambooHR plan includes onboarding. |
None of this measures how easy any system is to use. Next substantive review is due December 21, 2026, or sooner if prices or plans change. Found a changed price or term? Contact the editors.
Sources and evidence
Sources were checked November 16, 2026, unless another date is given. Vendor material establishes documented features, prices and terms; we did not test any product.
- Zoho People: Zoho MCP for Zoho People; US plan comparison (PDF); plan comparison page; leave management; leave policy help; self-service help; onboarding overview; candidate onboarding help; document acknowledgement help; form and export help; compliance; terms; contracting entities; privacy policy; California privacy notice; App Store listing; Google Play listing; Bloomberg Law.
- HRGrove: pricing; home; employee portal; about; blog; terms; privacy policy; security.
- TalentHR: pricing; home; terms; privacy policy; AI terms; security; App Store listing; Google Play listing.
- Homebase: pricing; end-user licence agreement; privacy policy; App Store listing; Google Play listing.
- Other products: OnPay pricing, pricing help, HR add-on guide, HR software, terms and privacy policy; Patriot pricing; Square Payroll pricing; Deel HRIS, terms, privacy policy and connector for Claude; Justworks pricing, terms and privacy policy; Gusto tech.co pricing review, October 16, 2026 and MCP documentation; Connecteam pricing and terms; BambooHR pricing, onboarding, terms, AI addendum, California privacy notice, App Store listing and Claude connector; Rippling pricing; Factorial pricing and MCP; Sage HR US price simulator, App Store listing and Google Play listing; Sesame HR pricing, terms and privacy policy; Day Off home page; TriNet 2025 annual report; Breathe pricing.
- Independent records: Rippling v. Deel complaint, N.D. Cal. 3:25-cv-02576; HCAmag on BambooHR, October 22, 2026.
This is a researched comparison, not a product review. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.