Full-service payroll for a few employees: Gusto, OnPay, Patriot, Homebase and Square

Choose Gusto Simple for a few employees in one state: it documents its provider-error remedy and the records you keep after leaving. Consider OnPay when a second state is likely.

PRACTICAL PICKSPreferredPickOur Preferred PickA few employees in one stateLast confirmed $79/mo

Gusto Simple

Defined remedy for its own missed deposits or filings, an employer data agreement and records you keep after cancelling, for a few employees in one state.

One state only: a second state means Plus at $80 + $12 per person. Basic support; state registration costs extra.

Why Gusto Simple is our Pick
Newcomer assessment

No Rising Star selected

The payroll candidates considered did not establish the recent independent release and complete terms needed for a recommendation.

No candidate established the recent independent release and complete evidence needed for this recommendation.

Who is this article for? Owners of a US business with a few W-2 employees who want a payroll service to calculate, deposit and file payroll taxes. Not tax or legal advice.

About 28 min read

What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean

The quick list

Start with Gusto Simple for five employees paid monthly in one state. Compare the normal price, then what each provider promises when its own tax work fails and what you keep when you leave.

Normal monthly subscriptions for five employees paid every month, one state and one location, last confirmed October 19, 2026, with OnPay and Patriot checked again November 5. We could not confirm Gusto’s current price. Homebase’s offer counts the owner toward its five-person limit and requires setup and first payroll by its stated deadlines; normal rates are shown. Our arithmetic, not quotes. Excludes wages, employer taxes, benefits premiums, promotions, sales tax and exceptional fees.

The comparison at a glance

Compare normal fees, what each contract says when the provider’s own tax work fails, employee-data terms and the records you keep when leaving.

Gusto Simple is our choice for a few employees in one state; OnPay is the alternative for more than one state. The remaining services show different cost and workflow tradeoffs. All tools remain selectable.

US full-service payroll for five employees in one state
FeatureGustoOnPayPatriot Full Service PayrollHomebase PayrollSquare Payroll
Best fitPreferred Pick: a few employees in one state (Simple)More than one state at the entry priceLower one-state subscription, if you accept its contract termsHourly teams already scheduling in Homebase; confirm fees and data terms firstLower employee subscription; compare the error remedy and records terms
Normal monthly subscriptionSimple $49 + $6 per active employeeEssentials $49 + $6 per paid employeeFull Service $37 + $5 per employee paidPayroll $49 + $6 per paid employee; platform plan separate$35 + $6 per employee paid
Five employees paid monthly, one state/locationLast confirmed $79/month$79/month$62/month$79/month on free Basic$65/month
Five employees, add a second state$140/month: requires Plus at $80 + $12 per person$79/month: every state included$74/month: additional state $12Lists all 50 states and DC; multi-location needs same EIN and pay scheduleConfirm required jurisdictions; employee payroll plan
When the provider’s own tax work failsRemits tax and pays penalties directly arising from its defined failure; you must mitigateRemits tax received and pays penalties from its negligent errorPricing page promises penalties and interest for its glitch; agreement has no matching clause, caps liability at 5% of 12 months’ feesNo payroll-specific remedy found in public termsNo comparable provider-error penalty remedy in published payroll terms
Correction chargesStatus-dependent; reversal attempted, not assuredPost-approval corrections are special handling; fees may apply, amounts unpublishedAmendments: Q1–3 $100/quarter; Q4 $150; data fixes quotedFee schedule: $200 per amendment filing; payroll page says amendments includedCorrection rates not established in the public payroll terms
Employee data termsEmployer DPA: service provider role; subprocessors and some improvement usesPrivacy policy permits sharing personal information, including financial data, with marketing partners; terms promise confidentialityJune 29, 2026 policy: financial/identity data, service providers, analyticsIdentifiable submitted data may be used to train AI modelsProcesses employee data for employer; affiliated promotions and service providers
Leaving and recordsNo notice period; admins keep forms, reports and past payrolls30 days’ prior written notice; employer access after cancellation not documentedRead/download access; agreement allows deletion one year after termination noticeSeparation form; 15-day export window from notice under general agreementKeep your own archive; retained employer access not promised in terms

US employee payroll administration. OnPay and Patriot prices and Homebase’s general agreement checked November 5, 2026; other sources checked October 19, 2026 unless stated. Gusto’s current price could not be confirmed; Homebase’s offer depends on owner count and setup/start dates; items marked as read September 7 could not be retrieved again. Next review December 18, 2026, or earlier after a material change. Five-employee totals assume all five are paid every month, in one state and one location, at normal monthly rates. They exclude wages, employer taxes, premiums, promotions, sales tax and exceptional charges. This is public-source research: documentation does not establish account approval, successful payment, legal compliance or security. Square pricing, payroll terms, general terms and employee privacy read November 5, 2026: pricing, payroll terms, general terms, employee privacy. See the evidence section for user reports and historical regulatory records.

All features and sources 24 criteria

Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.

Price, plan and eligibility

Show 8 criteria
Price, plan and eligibility
FeatureGustoOnPayPatriot Full Service PayrollHomebase PayrollSquare Payroll
Best fitPreferred Pick: a few employees in one state (Simple)More than one state at the entry priceLower one-state subscription, if you accept its contract termsHourly teams already scheduling in Homebase; confirm fees and data terms firstLower employee subscription; compare the error remedy and records terms
Normal monthly subscriptionSimple $49 + $6 per active employeeEssentials $49 + $6 per paid employeeFull Service $37 + $5 per employee paidPayroll $49 + $6 per paid employee; platform plan separate$35 + $6 per employee paid
Five employees paid monthly, one state/locationLast confirmed $79/month$79/month$62/month$79/month on free Basic$65/month
Five employees, add a second state$140/month: requires Plus at $80 + $12 per person$79/month: every state included$74/month: additional state $12Lists all 50 states and DC; multi-location needs same EIN and pay scheduleConfirm required jurisdictions; employee payroll plan
Billing unitEach onboarded active employee, paid or notEach employee included in a pay runEach employee paidEach employee paidEmployee plan; contractor-only pricing does not cover this job
Current promotions (not in totals)Contractor-only plan closed to new customers October 1, 2026First month free30 days free, then 50% off for 3 months6 months free for eligible teams; owner counted in five-person limit; setup and start deadlines applyNo promotional savings assumed
Time and HR boundariesSimple adds time off from October 2026; time tracking on PlusHR add-on $15 + $2/employee; time tracking $15 + $4/employeeTime and HR each $6 + $2/employeeBasic: one location, up to ten employees; larger platform plans add costNo paid accounting subscription included or required by listed payroll price
Setup before the first paydayHistory, authorizations and funding checks; state registration extraState tax registration included, per vendor; documents due at least ten business days before processingComplete Full Service tax setup and deposit qualificationMigration help and historical records; US and industry eligibility checksLinked verified ACH-enabled US business bank account and reporting-agent authorization
Sources for price, plan and eligibility

Checked October 19, 2026: Gusto plans and October changes, confirmed through search indexing and independent captures by UsagePricing and PricingSaaS; OnPay pricing, billing unit and terms; Patriot pricing and payroll; Homebase pricing and payroll. Totals are our arithmetic, not quotes.

Recurring work and records

Show 7 criteria
Recurring work and records
FeatureGustoOnPayPatriot Full Service PayrollHomebase PayrollSquare Payroll
Payroll runsUnlimited runsUnlimited runs and schedulesUnlimited runs; Auto PayrollUnlimited runs; payroll from Homebase timesheetsPayroll calculation, payments and tax reporting
Direct-deposit timingPlan dependent; next-day included on Plus; Instant Pay $100 per payroll on SimpleTwo or four business days after risk reviewFour-day standard; two-day for qualifying customersTwo-day for qualified companies; next-day payroll listedOrdinary bank pay; optional expedited employee access has separate terms
Benefits distinctionConnected benefits services; premiums and extras separateBenefits integrations; insurance premiums not includedHealth benefit integration; not full benefits administration401(k) deduction only: no remittance or reporting to the retirement providerThird-party services have separate terms
Hourly-team distinctionTime tracking on Plus; time off on SimpleTime tracking add-on or integrationOptional time productMultiple rates and tips; Tip Manager $25 per locationOvertime and sick pay may need manual adjustments for local rules
Reports and exportPayroll reports; mapped general-ledger CSVReport designer; CSV, PDF and XLSPayroll details CSV/PDF; QuickBooks exportStandard export under general agreement; format and restore path not documentedKeep your own copies; employee requests may be fulfilled at Square’s discretion
Employee access after you leavePaystubs and forms remainYear-end forms described as lifetime accessLifetime employee portal, per help pageEmployee app access documented; duration after you leave not establishedContinued employee access not guaranteed in payroll terms
Ordinary support versus upgradesBasic support; priority $30 + $3 per personPhone, email and chat, 9 a.m.–8 p.m. weekdays; live HR $65/monthFree US-based routine support; amendments and fixes chargedLive support 7 a.m.–7 p.m. CentralSupport response under a tax notice not established
Sources for recurring work and records

Errors, cancellation and data responsibilities

Show 9 criteria
Errors, cancellation and data responsibilities
FeatureGustoOnPayPatriot Full Service PayrollHomebase PayrollSquare Payroll
When the provider’s own tax work failsRemits tax and pays penalties directly arising from its defined failure; you must mitigateRemits tax received and pays penalties from its negligent errorPricing page promises penalties and interest for its glitch; agreement has no matching clause, caps liability at 5% of 12 months’ feesNo payroll-specific remedy found in public termsNo comparable provider-error penalty remedy in published payroll terms
Correction chargesStatus-dependent; reversal attempted, not assuredPost-approval corrections are special handling; fees may apply, amounts unpublishedAmendments: Q1–3 $100/quarter; Q4 $150; data fixes quotedFee schedule: $200 per amendment filing; payroll page says amendments includedCorrection rates not established in the public payroll terms
Other exceptional feesState registration and Instant Pay extra; Business Compliance $85/month per state on annual contract (optional)Mailed year-end form $10; self-print freePast or future tax months $37 eachFunding failure $125; failed quarterly refile $200; mailed form $3 eachOptional expedited employee transfer to debit card costs 1.75%; Cash App transfer free
General liability limitNot confirmed from current termsSix months of service charges, outside the tax remedy5% of fees paid in the previous 12 monthsPayroll-specific terms not foundGeneral terms limit liability; no comparable payroll penalty remedy established
Leaving and recordsNo notice period; admins keep forms, reports and past payrolls30 days’ prior written notice; employer access after cancellation not documentedRead/download access; agreement allows deletion one year after termination noticeSeparation form; 15-day export window from notice under general agreementKeep your own archive; retained employer access not promised in terms
Remaining tax filingsNon-switching election: $100 federal + $100/state + $5 per W-2 or 1099Agree successor responsibility; exit filing charges not publishedChoose a filing end date; extra months billed upfrontConflict: $200 per filing versus $200 year-end continuation; get written scopeConfirm successor responsibility before leaving
Employee data termsEmployer DPA: service provider role; subprocessors and some improvement usesPrivacy policy permits sharing personal information, including financial data, with marketing partners; terms promise confidentialityJune 29, 2026 policy: financial/identity data, service providers, analyticsIdentifiable submitted data may be used to train AI modelsProcesses employee data for employer; affiliated promotions and service providers
Contracting identityGusto, Inc.OnPay, LLC in published terms and privacy policyPatriot Software, LLC and affiliated payment entitiesPioneer Works, Inc. and Homebase Services, LLCBlock, Inc.; Square Payroll, Inc. as reporting agent
Decision-changing caveatSingle-state plan; basic support; state registration and priority support extraRead the privacy policy and exit terms before uploading recordsPersonal guaranty by the signer; check supported tax jurisdictionsFee conflicts, 401(k) not remitted, AI data permissionConfirm local requirements and retain records before cancelling
Sources for errors, cancellation and data responsibilities

What matters when choosing

Gusto Simple is our Practical Pick for a US business with a few W-2 employees in one state that wants the provider to calculate, deposit and file its payroll taxes. Its last confirmed price was $49 a month plus $6 per active employee, or $79 for five, the same as OnPay’s entry plan. What separates it is the paperwork around a problem. Its payroll terms define what Gusto pays when it misses a deposit or filing it was responsible for. Its employer data agreement treats employee records as data it processes for you. Its help center documents the records you keep and the filing charges you face after you cancel. The most important compromise is the state limit: Simple covers one state, and a second state means Plus at $80 plus $12 per person, or $140 for five. Gusto plans, payroll terms, cancellation

If you pay employees in more than one state, look at OnPay first. Its $49 plus $6 per paid employee plan includes every state and, by its own description, state tax registration, so five employees across two states still cost $79. Read two terms before choosing it: the contract requires 30 days’ written notice to leave, and its October 5, 2026 privacy policy permits sharing personal information, which it defines to include financial data, with marketing partners. Patriot Full Service has a confirmed one-state subscription of $62 for five employees. Its pricing page promises to cover penalties and interest caused by its own glitch, but its subscription agreement contains no matching clause, caps its liability at 5% of a year’s fees and makes the person who signs for a company a personal guarantor. Homebase Payroll suits hourly teams already scheduling in Homebase, but its fee pages conflict and its policies permit AI training on identifiable data, so get both answered in writing first. OnPay pricing, OnPay terms, OnPay privacy, Patriot pricing, Patriot agreement, Homebase payroll

None of these services removes your own responsibility. The IRS says employers remain responsible for depositing federal employment taxes when they use a payroll provider, and that the arrangement decides whether liability is shared or shifted. Every contract here also leaves penalties caused by your own wrong or late information with you. This is a software comparison, not tax, legal or employee-classification advice. IRS guidance, page reviewed October 10, 2026

We could not confirm Gusto’s current price on November 5, 2026. Homebase’s small-team offer counts the owner toward its five-person eligibility limit and has setup and first-payroll deadlines; our comparison uses its normal rate.

Our prices assume five employees paid every month, one business, one location and one state, at normal monthly rates checked October 19, 2026. They exclude promotions, wages, employer taxes, benefits premiums, sales tax and exceptional fees, and they are our arithmetic, not quotes. Gusto bills each onboarded active employee whether or not that person is paid in a month; OnPay, Patriot and Homebase bill employees included in a pay run. Three conditions would change our recommendation: a second state (choose OnPay), a need for the lowest subscription with acceptance of Patriot’s contract (choose Patriot), or an hourly team already scheduling in Homebase once its fees and data terms are confirmed in writing. Before signing with any provider, confirm the jurisdictions it will file in, your first approved pay date, its correction charges and who files the quarter and year-end returns if you leave mid-year. Keep your own copies of payroll reports and filed forms.

Disclosure: Practical Picks articles are researched and written with AI, currently Anthropic’s Claude. Gusto makes an official Claude connector. We have no relationship with Gusto or Anthropic over this article, and these Claude links carried no weight in our judgment. Gusto connector

Gusto

Preferred Pick · a few employees in one state

$79/moSimple · $49 + $6 per active employee

Choose Gusto Simple for one-state, full-service payroll when you want a defined provider-error remedy, an employer data agreement and documented records after you cancel.

Reasons to choose it

  • Last confirmed five-employee price matched OnPay
  • Payroll terms define what Gusto pays for its own missed deposit or filing
  • Admins keep forms, reports and past payrolls after cancelling

What to watch

  • One state only; a second state means Plus at $140 for five
  • Basic support; priority support and state registration cost extra
  • Bills every active employee, paid or not

Gusto Simple includes full-service payroll in one state, unlimited payroll runs and automatic federal, state and local tax filing, with basic support. Gusto says its October 1, 2026 plan changes added features without changing prices, and its contractor-only plan closed to new customers that day. An independent capture of the change lists expenses, time off and new-hire check-ins as additions to Simple. Priority support costs $30 a month plus $3 per person, state tax registration is priced separately, and Instant Pay on Simple costs $100 per payroll. Understanding Gusto plans, October plan changes, capture of the change, priority support, pricing

Choose another tool if you already pay in two states or expect to soon. Plus costs $80 plus $12 per person, so five employees cost $140, against $79 at OnPay. Gusto’s new Business Compliance add-on is $85 a month per state on an annual contract for Simple and Plus; it is optional and not in our totals. Because Gusto bills each active employee, a seasonal business pays for employees who stay on the roster in months they are not paid. Gusto plans, October plan changes

Read the full Gusto analysis and sources

The payroll terms define the remedy narrowly. If Gusto misses a remittance or filing deadline after you submitted compliant payments, it remits the tax and reimburses or pays the penalties directly arising from that failure. You must make prompt, reasonable efforts to reduce penalties, and Gusto is not liable for penalties caused by inaccurate or incomplete payroll information. That is a defined commitment, not a promise that every tax problem is Gusto’s to fix. Payroll terms, August 2025 version

Corrections depend on timing. Gusto’s help distinguishes an unprocessed payroll you can edit or cancel from money already debited. A reversal is an attempt, not an assured recovery, and later fixes can need support or a benefits provider. Change, cancel or reverse a payroll

Leaving is better documented than at OnPay. Gusto says admins keep access to company forms, reports, employee information and past payrolls after cancelling, and employees keep access to their paystubs and forms. If you are not switching providers and want Gusto to keep filing, it lists $100 for federal forms, $100 per state and $5 per W-2 or 1099, as an all-or-nothing election. Cancelling does not close your state tax accounts. There is no pause, and cancelling after the fifth of a month, or after running payroll that month, bills the full month. Agree the handover with a new provider; cancelling is not proof that it has taken the work on. Cancellation and remaining filings, closing state accounts

Gusto’s employer data processing addendum describes Gusto as a service provider processing employer-supplied personal data. It permits subprocessors bound by written terms and certain service-improvement and aggregated uses, so it is not a promise of no secondary use. Its general privacy notice is a separate document. We could not retrieve the current text of either on October 19, 2026. A third-party tracker’s summary indicates an August 29, 2026 revision of the privacy notice about advertising-related “sale” or “sharing” of identifiers and website usage data; that summary is a lead, not the policy text, so recheck the notice before relying on it. Employer DPA, privacy notice, tracker summary

Regulatory records show historical money-transmission licensing matters. Texas’s August 2018 consent order imposed $118,419.02; Gusto neither admitted nor denied violations, and the commissioner noted its good-faith inquiry. Connecticut’s June 2021 order resolved a licensing allegation for a $10,000 penalty and $3,750 in back fees, noting Gusto’s voluntary application and no related complaints. Gusto lists current Texas and Connecticut licenses. These records are not findings about today’s payroll accuracy or evidence of current unlicensed operation. Texas order 2018-023, Connecticut order, Connecticut bulletin, Gusto licenses

Used Gusto? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

OnPay

Also consider · more than one state

$79/moEssentials · $49 + $6 per paid employee

Choose OnPay when you pay employees in more than one state and can accept its exit notice and privacy terms after asking how they apply to payroll records.

Reasons to choose it

  • Every state included at the entry price
  • State tax registration included, per OnPay
  • Phone, email and chat support 9 a.m.–8 p.m. weekdays

What to watch

  • 30 days’ prior written notice to leave
  • Employer access after cancellation not documented
  • Privacy policy permits sharing personal information with marketing partners

OnPay’s Payroll Essentials plan costs $49 a month plus $6 per paid employee. The company says it includes payroll in every state with automatic state tax registration, unlimited pay runs and schedules, year-end forms, and phone, email and chat support from 9 a.m. to 8 p.m. on weekdays. Five employees cost $79 whether they are in one state or several, which makes it the better choice than Gusto when a second state is likely. OnPay currently offers the first month free; that is not in our totals. OnPay pricing

Its main drawback for an owner is leaving. The terms continue the service until either side gives 30 days’ prior written notice, and we found no public OnPay document describing employer access to the account after cancellation. OnPay says employees can download their year-end forms for life. Export your reports, which download as CSV, PDF or XLS, before you give notice. Terms, section 10, pricing help, report exports

Read the full OnPay analysis and sources

The contract’s tax remedy is similar in scope to Gusto’s. For OnPay’s negligent failure to perform the payroll-tax service, it remits the taxes it received and reimburses or pays the resulting penalties. Penalties caused by your inaccurate information are yours, corrections requested after approval count as “special handling” that may cost extra, and other liability is capped at six months of service charges. The pricing page’s “error-free guarantee” is marketing language; we rely on the contract. Terms, sections 2, 7 and 13, pricing page

A processed pay run can be cancelled without charge until 11:30 p.m. Eastern on the business day before funds are drafted. Deposit timing is two or four business days, set by OnPay’s risk review after it verifies your bank account. Pricing help, processing turnaround

Plan boundaries have moved. HR tools, including PTO requests and approvals, are an add-on at $15 plus $2 per employee; time tracking is $15 plus $4 per employee; live HR advice is $65 a month. OnPay’s own help article still describes one price that includes all features, so rely on the current pricing page. Mailed year-end forms cost $10 each; self-printing is free. Pricing, pricing help

Check the data terms before uploading employee records. OnPay’s privacy policy, updated October 5, 2026, calls itself enterprise-wide, defines personal information to include Social Security and bank account numbers, and permits sharing personal information with affiliates, strategic partners and third-party marketers, who may use it for their own business purposes. Its terms separately require OnPay to hold client data in strict confidence, with an exception where it reasonably believes you consented. We could not establish how the two documents apply to employee payroll records. This is a permission in a policy, not evidence that any payroll data has been shared; ask OnPay in writing before signing. Both documents name OnPay, LLC. Privacy policy, terms, section 13

Used OnPay? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Patriot Full Service Payroll

Lower one-state price · read the contract

$62/moFull Service · $37 + $5 per employee paid

Consider Patriot Full Service when the lowest subscription matters most and you accept its liability cap and personal guaranty.

Reasons to choose it

  • Confirmed $62 subscription for five employees in one state
  • Published amendment prices
  • Read/download access and employee portal after cancelling

What to watch

  • Agreement has no clause matching its penalty promise
  • Signer personally guarantees company debts to Patriot
  • Agreement allows deletion one year after termination notice

Patriot Full Service Payroll costs $37 a month plus $5 per employee paid, or $62 for five, and files and deposits federal, state and local payroll taxes, including year-end filings. Each additional state is $12 a month. Routine US-based support is free on weekdays. Compare Full Service, not Basic, because Basic leaves tax filing to you. A current promotion offers 30 days free and half price for three months; it is not in our totals. Patriot pricing, support fees

The reason to hesitate is the gap between its promise and its contract. The pricing page says Patriot will “take care of any penalties and interest in the unlikely event of a glitch on our end.” The subscription agreement we read has no matching clause. It makes you responsible for penalties from your errors, limits Patriot’s total liability to 5% of the fees you paid in the previous 12 months, and says a person who signs for a company personally guarantees amounts the company owes Patriot. We are describing published terms, not offering an opinion on how they would be enforced. Pricing page, subscription agreement, sections 13, 14.7 and 15

Read the full Patriot Full Service Payroll analysis and sources

Patriot publishes its correction prices. Amended Full Service returns are $100 per quarter for quarters one to three and $150 for quarter four, data corrections are estimated by complexity, and filing for past or future months is $37 per month. Ordinary support does not cover that work. Premium support fees, July 7, 2026

When you cancel, you choose when tax filing ends: the cancellation date, or the end of the month, quarter or year. Patriot bills the base price upfront for each extra month it files. Its September 8, 2026 help page says employers can still log in to download reports, tax activity and forms, and employees keep lifetime portal access. The agreement says access becomes read-only and that Patriot need not keep your data more than one year after termination notice, so download what you need within that year. Cancellation help, agreement, section 21, payroll details report

Standard direct deposit takes four days; two-day deposit is for qualifying customers. Time tracking and HR are each $6 plus $2 per employee. Its privacy policy, dated June 29, 2026 when we read it on September 7, covers financial and identity data, service providers and analytics, with retention exceptions. The policy loads in an embedded viewer, and we could not retrieve it again on October 19. Payroll features, privacy policy

Used Patriot Full Service Payroll? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Homebase Payroll

Hourly teams on Homebase · clarify first

$79/moPayroll · $49 + $6 per paid employee

Consider Homebase Payroll only if its scheduling link matters and Homebase confirms, in writing, which fees apply and how payroll data is used.

Reasons to choose it

  • Payroll from Homebase scheduling and timesheets
  • Free Basic platform for one location, up to ten employees
  • Multiple pay rates and tips

What to watch

  • Amendment fee conflicts with “amendments included”
  • 401(k) deductions are not remitted to the plan
  • Policy permits AI training on identifiable data

Homebase Payroll connects payroll to Homebase’s scheduling and timesheets. It costs $49 a month plus $6 per paid employee, so five cost $79 on the free Basic platform, which covers one location and up to ten employees. The pricing page also shows “$29 per month for teams up to 5” but the offer terms specify $29 plus $6 per employee paid after six free months, for eligible teams. The five-person eligibility limit includes the owner, setup must finish by December 15, 2026 and the first payroll must run by January 20, 2027. Confirm that you qualify before relying on it. Homebase is offering six months of free payroll and its Plus plan; that is not in our totals. The base fee was $39 when we checked on September 7, and a pricing tracker records several changes since July. Platform pricing, payroll page, pricing history, offer terms, read November 5, 2026

Choose another tool unless the scheduling link is worth resolving three questions. First, fees: the payroll page says amendments are included, while the July 14, 2026 fee schedule lists $200 per amendment filing. Second, retirement: the August 12, 2026 FAQ says a 401(k) deduction can be set up, but Homebase does not remit it or report it to your retirement provider. Third, data: the privacy policy effective August 18, 2026 says data submitted through the service may be used to train AI models, including data linked to specific individuals, with safeguards described in its agreement. That is a permission, not evidence that particular records were used. Payroll page, fee schedule, payroll FAQ, privacy policy

Read the full Homebase Payroll analysis and sources

The July 14 fee schedule also lists $200 per failed quarterly refiling, $125 per funding failure, $200 per post-cancellation filing and $3 per mailed tax form. The July 10 cancellation guide describes a $200 year-end continuation fee instead. Payroll cancellation requires a separation form, and other paid Homebase plans are separate. The general customer agreement gives accounts in good standing 15 days from termination notice to export data, subject to service-specific terms, and we found no complete payroll-specific agreement. The fee and cancellation help pages did not provide readable content on November 5, so their content is as of September 7. We read the general customer agreement again on November 5; its 15-day export window remains, subject to service-specific terms. Fee schedule, cancellation guide, customer agreement, sections 4, 6 and 11

Multiple locations can share one payroll only if they use the same EIN and the same pay schedule and frequency. Homebase lists payroll in all 50 states and Washington, D.C., two-day deposit for qualified companies, next-day payroll and live support from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. Central. Tip Manager is $25 per location monthly. Payroll page, platform pricing

Used Homebase Payroll? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Square Payroll

Lower subscription · compare remedies

$65/moEmployee payroll · $35 + $6 per employee paid

Consider Square when the lower subscription matters and you accept its narrower documented protections for provider errors and retained records.

Reasons to choose it

  • $65 monthly subscription for five employees
  • Payroll calculation, payments and related tax reporting
  • No paid accounting dependency in the listed employee price

What to watch

  • No comparable provider-error penalty remedy established
  • Local overtime and sick-pay rules can need manual adjustments
  • Retained employer archive not promised in terms

Square lists employee payroll at $35 a month plus $6 per employee paid, or $65 for five. Its contractor-only price does not cover this W-2 job. The payroll service calculates pay, makes payments and handles related tax reporting; you need a verified ACH-enabled US business bank account and reporting-agent authorization. These are documented capabilities, not evidence that a particular payroll will succeed. Pricing, payroll terms, read November 5, 2026.

Consider it when its lower subscription matters and you accept the narrower documented protections. We found no provider-error penalty remedy comparable to Gusto’s or OnPay’s in the published payroll terms. Square also warns that overtime, sick pay and other local requirements can need manual adjustments. Keep your own archive: the terms say Square may fulfill former employees’ information requests at its discretion, to the extent it retained the records, rather than promise continued employer access. Payroll terms, general terms, read November 5, 2026; the general terms apply to new signups from October 27 and all sellers from November 12.

Read the full Square Payroll analysis and sources

Its employee privacy notice says it does not sell or share the information collected to provide services on the employer’s behalf. The payroll agreement still authorizes affiliated offers in employee communications and sharing with third-party services you choose; some add-on promotions cannot be turned off. That combination merits reading before uploading employee records. Employee privacy, payroll terms, read November 5, 2026.

Used Square Payroll? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Which product are we missing?

Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.

Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.

Suggest a product

Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.

No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.

What people are saying

Public user reports are a check on vendor claims, not a measured reliability score. The community material we read on September 7, 2026 is mixed. A discussion comparing Gusto and Homebase describes satisfaction with ordinary Gusto payroll and a preference for Homebase’s hourly workflow, while also mentioning reporting limits. A separate Gusto thread alleges difficult tax corrections and escalation. These accounts show reported experiences, not comparative failure rates. Referral offers and vendor replies appear in this category, so we did not count every favorable comment as independent support. Gusto/Homebase discussion, Gusto correction complaints

An OnPay accounting-community contributor praises long-term support, while BBB complaints include correction and cancellation disputes; some show resolved status, and an August 2026 tax complaint had an investigation response rather than a documented completed correction. Patriot discussions praise routine use but also report onboarding restrictions, and its BBB responses confirm that some accounts were declined under its terms. None of this shows how often an eligible small employer meets these problems. OnPay discussion, OnPay complaints and responses, Patriot discussion, Patriot responses

Homebase’s BBB record includes a concrete case: in July 2026 the company acknowledged a delayed Indiana withholding penalty payment, said it had paid it, and the customer accepted the resolution. That supports taking notice escalation seriously, not a conclusion that Homebase filings are generally late. Our October 19 search for newer complaints, incidents, regulatory actions and lawsuits involving the four providers found nothing that changed these conclusions; a search that finds nothing is not proof that nothing exists. Complaint, response and resolution

How we researched

This is public-source research. We did not create accounts, sign in, enter employee information, run payroll, connect a bank, contact support, file taxes or test exports. No provider supplied access or payment for this work. We first compared these four services on September 7, 2026 and rechecked the material claims on October 19, 2026: prices, plan limits, promotions, contract remedies, correction and exit fees, record access after cancellation and data terms. Where a source could not be retrieved again, the article says so and gives the date we last read it. Gusto’s website did not load for our automated check on October 19, so we confirmed its current plan terms through Gusto’s own help-center articles as indexed by search and through independent captures of its pricing page dated September 21 and October 5, 2026. Homebase’s fee and cancellation help pages, and Patriot’s privacy policy, are carried from September 7. We read Homebase’s customer agreement again on November 5. We also checked the available pricing and product documentation for a wider set of payroll services on November 5.

We chose the original four services for a five-employee, one-state business that wants full-service payroll: two widely used full-service providers, a lower-cost full-service provider and a scheduling platform with payroll for hourly teams. We judged them on fit for that job, normal cost, what the contract says when the provider’s own filing fails, terms for employee data, and what you keep and owe when you leave. We fixed those criteria and their weights before comparing the services. Giving more weight to a second state favors OnPay; giving more weight to the lowest price narrows the gap to Patriot but does not overcome its contract terms in our judgment. We also considered ADP RUN, Paychex Flex, QuickBooks Workforce Payroll, Square Payroll, Justworks Payroll, SurePayroll, Wave Payroll, Rippling, Deel US Payroll, Warp, Xero Payroll and Zoho Payroll. Some providers require a quote; others did not provide the payroll contract or complete price terms we needed. Square joins the comparison because its $65 monthly subscription offers a lower price, with weaker documented protections for provider errors and retained records. We cannot give a complete score or final order to services with unresolved prices or contract terms. Gusto remains our recommendation on the documented remedy, data agreement and retained records described above. Square pricing, Square payroll terms, both read November 5, 2026.

We searched for new entrants through launch announcements, trade press, launch communities, pricing trackers and recommendation lists on October 19, then revisited the candidates’ product documentation on November 5, 2026. No Rising Star is selected. Xero’s offering is powered by Gusto, an incumbent payroll provider; a new integration does not establish an independent newcomer. Zoho’s US edition has a December 2024 announcement, but we could not establish the product’s first public release or complete payroll-specific terms. Warp’s first public release date is also unconfirmed, and its contract requires cyber insurance in addition to the subscription. Deel and Justworks are established payroll vendors. We have no evidence of a new qualifying candidate beyond those considered here; this does not show that none exists. Our October 19 adverse search covered news, outage, breach, lawsuit and regulator terms for the original four providers and their legal entities. We have not completed an equivalent independent search for the additional services.

Newcomer documentation read November 5, 2026: Xero Payroll, Zoho Payroll, Warp pricing and employer terms.

ToolPublic sourcesWhat remains uncertain
Square PayrollNovember 5 pricing, payroll terms, general terms and employee privacy.Correction charges, retained employer archive and support response under a tax notice.
Newcomer assessmentOctober 19 discovery and November 5 product documentation.Earliest release and payroll-specific terms for Zoho and Warp; no qualifying endorsement established.
GustoPlan and October 2026 change articles, priority support, cancellation and correction help, payroll terms, employer DPA, regulator orders.Current primary pricing and privacy text, support response under a tax notice, migration completeness.
OnPayPricing page, terms, October 2026 privacy policy, pricing, turnaround, report and export help.Employer access after cancellation, how its privacy policy applies to employee records, special-handling charges.
Patriot Full Service PayrollPricing and payroll pages, subscription agreement, support fees, September 2026 cancellation help, September 7 privacy reading.Whether the pricing-page penalty promise binds, current privacy text, account approval for a given business.
Homebase PayrollPricing and payroll pages, August 2026 privacy policy, September 7 readings of fees, FAQ and cancellation guide; customer agreement read November 5.Which fee applies, eligibility for the small-team offer, a payroll-specific contract and actual AI data use.

None of this establishes correct calculations, on-time deposits, successful filings or security in practice. Next substantive review is due December 18, 2026, before year-end forms and January price changes, or sooner if a material term changes. Found a changed fee or term? Contact the editors.

Sources and evidence

Sources were checked October 19, 2026 unless another date is given. Pricing pages for OnPay and Patriot, Homebase pricing and its customer agreement, and the additional product documentation linked above were read November 5, 2026. Provider material establishes documented offers and terms, not successful operation. Community posts and BBB reports are attributed experiences, not representative samples.

This is a researched comparison, not a product review. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.