Small architecture diagrams written as text: Mermaid Live Editor and three alternatives
Mermaid Live Editor is our recommendation among four free browser tools: its text also renders on GitHub, GitLab and Obsidian. Choose arch-lab for C4 text and canvas editing, nomnoml for compact UML-style diagrams or D2 for layout control.
Mermaid Live Editor
Free, open-source and account-free. PNG and SVG downloads are built in your browser, and the same text renders on GitHub, GitLab and Obsidian.
Keeps only 30 autosaved edits, so save your text. SVGs can break in some desktop software. Open only links you trust.
Why Mermaid Live Editor is our PickTeam behind Mermaid Live Editor? Get your award badge
No Rising Star selected
None of the newer candidates met every requirement for a free, anonymous browser editor with image and editable-source handoff.
Hosted access, first-release dates or operator evidence could not be established for the newer candidates.
Who is this article for? One person writing a small software architecture diagram as text in a browser, who wants to keep the editable source and hand over a PNG or SVG without installing anything or creating an account.
About 22 min read
What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean
The quick list
Start with Mermaid Live Editor for reusable text and an image. All four compared tools are free and need no account; choose the alternatives for C4 text and canvas editing, UML-style notation or layout control.
The four compared browser routes are $0 with no account; Mermaid and D2 evidence dates from October 19, 2026, and arch-lab and nomnoml from November 5, 2026. We could not confirm hosted prices for Oxdraw, Vellum or mermaid.design.
The comparison at a glance
Four free browser tools for diagram text. Compare the handoff, where the text renders later, data handling and upkeep.
Mermaid Live Editor leads for reusable source and an image, followed by arch-lab, nomnoml and D2 Playground. Its 0.65 lead over arch-lab is not narrow. Order follows our weighted assessment for this reader; image quality and uptime were not measured.
Hides matching answers for the selected tools. Unknowns and unverified claims stay visible.
| Feature | Mermaid Live Editor | arch-lab | nomnoml | D2 Playground |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Our assessment / 5 | 4.45 · Preferred Pick | 3.80 | 3.70 | 3.60 · Also consider for layout |
| Best fit | Preferred Pick · editable Mermaid text for documentation, plus a quick PNG or SVG | C4 text, drill-down presentation and canvas editing | Compact UML-style diagrams; keep source inside the SVG | Comparing layouts before exporting a PNG or SVG |
| Where the text renders later | GitHub, GitLab and Obsidian draw it natively | No native .alab rendering in GitHub, GitLab or Obsidian; Mermaid conversion has limits | Not natively in GitHub, GitLab or Obsidian; library and Kroki available | Not natively on GitHub, GitLab or Obsidian; GitLab only if an admin enables Kroki |
| Where your diagram goes | Stays in your browser, per the maker; image links, Kroki and Mermaid.ai send it out | Local parsing and rendering per maker; optional Markdown image sends model to server; expiry sends hash | Client-side editor and browser storage, per repository | Drawn in your browser; the address carrying it reaches the host |
| Main caution | Save your text; open only trusted links; check SVGs in desktop apps | Beta format not frozen; no native docs-host rendering; optional image sends source to server | Open report of broken SVG export; keep source and check the image | Keep your .d2 file; hosting depends on donations |
Mermaid and D2 evidence was checked October 19, 2026. arch-lab and nomnoml documentation and maintenance records were checked November 5, 2026. Results from our earlier hands-on check on October 1, 2026, made before we adopted our research-only method, appear only in the product sections and image captions. No row measures image quality, uptime, accessibility or speed.
All features and sources 15 criteria
Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.
The handoff
Show 6 criteria
| Feature | Mermaid Live Editor | arch-lab | nomnoml | D2 Playground |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Our assessment / 5 | 4.45 · Preferred Pick | 3.80 | 3.70 | 3.60 · Also consider for layout |
| Best fit | Preferred Pick · editable Mermaid text for documentation, plus a quick PNG or SVG | C4 text, drill-down presentation and canvas editing | Compact UML-style diagrams; keep source inside the SVG | Comparing layouts before exporting a PNG or SVG |
| Text language and licence | Mermaid (MIT) | .alab beta format; MIT source | nomnoml (MIT) | D2 (MPL-2.0) |
| PNG and SVG | Downloads built in your browser; optional image links through mermaid.ink | Maker documents PNG at 2x and SVG downloads | PNG or SVG with editable source embedded | Export or copy in your browser; code notes downloads fail on mobile |
| Keeping the source | Edit link holds the text after #; last 30 autosaved edits in browser storage | .alab text, JSON and Mermaid export; share link carries model after # | Source download, share link and SVG that can reopen as text | Text encoded in a ?script= address; no saved history |
| Layout control | ELK by default since Mermaid 12; other layouts by setting | C4 and other canvas edits write positions or order into text; themes | Direction, spacing, nested nodes and custom styles | Dagre, ELK and TALA, all open source |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for the handoff
Additional columns checked November 5, 2026: nomnoml editor, nomnoml repository, nomnoml issues, arch-lab FAQ, arch-lab repository. Incumbent sources checked October 19, 2026: Mermaid Live Editor guide, Live Editor export code, Mermaid 12.0.0 release, D2 Playground repository, Playground export code, TALA announcement.
Where the text and diagram go
Show 4 criteria
| Feature | Mermaid Live Editor | arch-lab | nomnoml | D2 Playground |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Where the text renders later | GitHub, GitLab and Obsidian draw it natively | No native .alab rendering in GitHub, GitLab or Obsidian; Mermaid conversion has limits | Not natively in GitHub, GitLab or Obsidian; library and Kroki available | Not natively on GitHub, GitLab or Obsidian; GitLab only if an admin enables Kroki |
| Where your diagram goes | Stays in your browser, per the maker; image links, Kroki and Mermaid.ai send it out | Local parsing and rendering per maker; optional Markdown image sends model to server; expiry sends hash | Client-side editor and browser storage, per repository | Drawn in your browser; the address carrying it reaches the host |
| Published data statement | Data-security note on mermaid.live only; Mermaid.ai policy (2024) does not mention the editor | FAQ explains local rendering, fragment sharing and remote-image request logs; implementation not audited | Repository describes local storage without a persistence guarantee | No Playground-specific policy found |
| Security record, 2026 | Editor fix April 10; nine Mermaid advisories in May and August, all fixed | No demonstrated serious flaw in inspected evidence; dependency audit not performed | No published repository advisories; dependency audit not completed | No published advisories found |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for where the text and diagram go
Additional columns checked November 5, 2026: nomnoml editor, nomnoml repository, nomnoml issues, arch-lab FAQ, arch-lab repository. Incumbent sources checked October 19, 2026: GitHub diagrams, GitLab Markdown, GitLab Kroki integration, Obsidian formatting, Live Editor data-security note, Mermaid.ai privacy policy, Mermaid advisories, Live Editor advisory. The makers’ data statements are their own claims; none was audited.
Upkeep, exit and price
Show 5 criteria
| Feature | Mermaid Live Editor | arch-lab | nomnoml | D2 Playground |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Steward | Open-source project; editor links to Mermaid Chart’s Mermaid.ai | Raksit Nongbua; MIT repository | Daniel Kallin and contributors; MIT source | Nonprofit under Hack Club since September 2026; maintainer time limited |
| Latest release seen | Mermaid 12.2.0, October 13, 2026 | Human maintenance October 7, 2026; first public release unknown | 1.7.0, December 14, 2024; human commit May 30, 2026 | D2 0.9.0, September 7, 2026 |
| Route out if the site ends | Open-source editor with a Docker image | Keep .alab text or JSON; public MIT source; no hosting guarantee | Keep nomnoml text; public renderer source | Open source with local-running instructions |
| Price and account | $0, no account; saving to Mermaid.ai needs one | $0, no account; FAQ says no paid tier, trial or usage limit | $0, no account; public editor downloads | $0, no account |
| Main caution | Save your text; open only trusted links; check SVGs in desktop apps | Beta format not frozen; no native docs-host rendering; optional image sends source to server | Open report of broken SVG export; keep source and check the image | Keep your .d2 file; hosting depends on donations |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for upkeep, exit and price
Additional columns checked November 5, 2026: nomnoml editor, nomnoml repository, nomnoml issues, arch-lab FAQ, arch-lab repository. Incumbent sources checked October 19, 2026: Live Editor repository, D2 nonprofit announcement, D2 sponsor page, D2 releases.
What matters when choosing
Mermaid Live Editor is our Practical Pick for writing a small software architecture diagram as text in a browser, keeping the editable source and handing someone a PNG or SVG. It is free and needs no account. Its open-source code builds the PNG and SVG downloads in your browser, and the data-security note on mermaid.live says diagrams stay in the page address and your browser’s storage unless you choose an external service, such as its image links, Kroki or “Save to Mermaid Chart”. What sets it apart is what happens to the text afterwards: GitHub, GitLab and Obsidian draw Mermaid diagrams from the same text, so the source you keep can live in your documentation and still render there. Live Editor guide, export code, data-security note, GitHub diagrams
Know three compromises before you rely on it. The editor keeps only the last 30 autosaved edits, in browser storage, so save the Mermaid text yourself. Its SVGs depend on browser features, and some desktop programs such as Inkscape and PowerPoint do not draw them correctly. And Mermaid published nine security advisories in May and August 2026 about crafted diagrams and settings, all fixed in versions older than the one the editor now uses, so open only diagrams and edit links you trust. Use the editor at mermaid.live: the “never leave your browser” note appears only on that address, and the editor also links to Mermaid.ai, an account-based service with its own policy. Mermaid advisories, SVG issue
Also consider D2 Playground if layout control matters more than where the text renders. It offers three layout engines, including TALA, which its makers open-sourced in September 2026, and it exports PNG and SVG in the browser. GitHub, GitLab and Obsidian do not draw D2 natively, though, and the company that funded D2 announced in September 2026 that it was shutting down; the project now runs as a nonprofit under Hack Club, and its lead maintainer says his time will be limited. Keep your .d2 text: the Playground holds your diagram only in its page address. D2 nonprofit announcement, TALA is open source
PlantUML suits teams that already write PlantUML, especially on GitLab, which draws it natively. For anything confidential, run it yourself: the public server’s “Online Server” link still switched to an unencrypted http:// address on October 19, 2026, and PlantUML’s own FAQ warns that public-server traffic goes over HTTP and recommends a local server for sensitive diagrams. PlantUML FAQ
Mermaid remains our recommendation at 4.45 out of 5, followed by arch-lab at 3.80, nomnoml at 3.70 and D2 Playground at 3.60. Its 0.65 lead over arch-lab is not narrow under our scoring criteria. This recommendation covers ordinary, non-sensitive diagrams, not confidential system maps.
We have not selected a Rising Star: none of the newer candidates met every requirement for this free, anonymous browser task. We could not confirm hosted prices for Oxdraw, Vellum or mermaid.design.
Disclosure: Practical Picks articles are researched and written with AI, currently Anthropic’s Claude. Mermaid Chart, the company behind Mermaid.ai, whose links appear in the Live Editor, offers an official Claude connector that opens diagrams in the Live Editor. We have no relationship with Mermaid Chart or Anthropic over this article, and these Claude links carried no weight in our judgment. Mermaid Chart Claude app
Mermaid Live Editor
Preferred Pick · editable source and image
Choose Mermaid Live Editor for a small, non-sensitive diagram you want to export as PNG or SVG and keep as text that GitHub, GitLab and Obsidian can draw.
View full sizeEarlier hands-on check, October 1, 2026, before our research-only method: our synthetic four-part diagram exported as PNG from that day’s Live Editor build (Mermaid version not recorded). Mermaid 12 changed default layout and colours, so a current export may look different. Source
Reasons to choose it
- PNG and SVG downloads built in your browser
- The same text renders on GitHub, GitLab and Obsidian
- Very active project; 2026 security fixes shipped
What to watch
- Keeps only the last 30 autosaved edits
- SVGs can break in some desktop software
- Links to account-based Mermaid.ai; open only trusted links
You type Mermaid code in one panel and see the diagram update in the other. The Actions panel saves the result as PNG, SVG or Markdown, and you can copy the image. The guide says edits are autosaved every minute, only the last 30 are viewable, and history is stored in the browser only. The editor’s code shows that the PNG and SVG download buttons build the files in your browser; the separate image-link buttons beside them, and the Kroki link, send your diagram to outside services. A maintainer wrote in May 2023 that the editor stores nothing itself and keeps your data in the browser and in the address after the # sign, which browsers do not send to the web server. Guide, Actions code, maintainer statement
The text is the part worth keeping. GitHub renders Mermaid in Markdown files, issues and pull requests, and suggests checking which Mermaid version it runs; GitLab and Obsidian also draw Mermaid code blocks. A small architecture diagram can use a flowchart, where a database gets a cylinder shape, or Mermaid’s dedicated architecture diagram type. Mermaid 12, released September 10, 2026, made the ELK layout engine the default for flowcharts and changed the default colours and look, so older diagrams can re-lay out; its release notes give the setting that restores the old appearance. GitHub diagrams, GitLab Markdown, Obsidian formatting, Mermaid 12.0.0
Read the full Mermaid Live Editor analysis and sources
Choose another tool if your diagram must open cleanly in desktop drawing or slide software. A long-running Mermaid issue explains that its SVGs place label text in browser-only elements and rely on CSS variables, which programs such as Inkscape and rsvg-convert do not support; maintainers closed it in October 2025 to consolidate it with other issues. Users report that turning off HTML labels helps in some cases. Export a PNG for slides if in doubt. SVG issue, desktop SVG report
Mind the address and the prompts. The code shows the “Your diagrams never leave your browser” note only on mermaid.live, where it says the editor is a client-side app hosted on GitHub Pages and collects anonymous usage data with self-hosted analytics it describes as privacy-friendly. The same code includes a chooser that can offer new visitors Mermaid.ai’s editor, and a “Save diagram” link goes to Mermaid.ai, an account-based service outside this comparison. Mermaid.ai’s privacy policy, effective September 13, 2024, does not mention the Live Editor. Share links contain your full diagram, so use only non-sensitive content. Data-security note, editor chooser code, Mermaid.ai privacy policy
Mermaid’s security record calls for care with diagrams from other people. The Live Editor fixed a cross-site scripting flaw on April 10, 2026 that could be triggered by a crafted configuration in a link or GitHub Gist. Mermaid itself published four advisories on May 11, 2026, fixed in 11.15.0, and five on August 4, 2026, fixed in 11.16.1, covering CSS and HTML injection, prototype pollution and diagrams that hang the page; most are rated moderate. Two August 2025 cross-site scripting flaws, one in architecture diagrams that GitHub rates critical and one in sequence-diagram labels, were fixed in 11.10.0; the second also reached other tools that convert Mermaid diagrams. The editor’s current code specifies Mermaid 12.2.0. None of this affects text you write yourself, but do not open unknown edit links. Live Editor advisory, Mermaid advisories, August 2026 example
In an earlier hands-on check on October 1, 2026, before we adopted our research-only method, the Live Editor build of that day (Mermaid version not recorded) rendered our four-part example, downloaded a nonblank PNG and an SVG containing all four labels, and restored the exact text from its edit link in a fresh browser. That check supports, but did not decide, this recommendation.
Used Mermaid Live Editor? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
arch-lab
C4 text and canvas editing
Choose arch-lab for C4 diagrams you can drill into, reposition and export while keeping editable text.
Reasons to choose it
- PNG, SVG, .alab text and JSON exports
- Canvas positions and order written into the text
- Share links carry the model in the URL fragment
What to watch
- Beta .alab format is not frozen
- No native .alab rendering in GitHub, GitLab or Obsidian
- Optional Markdown images send source to a server; hosting is not guaranteed
Choose arch-lab if you want architecture text with a diagram you can drill into and reposition. Its FAQ describes a free browser editor with no account, paid tier or usage limit. It documents C4 models, sequence diagrams and other notations, PNG and SVG downloads, editable .alab text and JSON, plus links carrying the model after the # in the address. For supported notations, dragging on the canvas writes positions or order back into the text. These are the maker’s documented capabilities, not results of our own product test. FAQ, repository, checked November 5, 2026.
Keep the .alab file. Its beta format is not yet frozen, and GitHub, GitLab and Obsidian do not render it natively. The maker documents Mermaid import and export with notation-specific limits; conversion does not make every model interchangeable. The FAQ says parsing, layout and rendering happen in your browser. Its optional Copy markdown image sends the model to the site’s rendering server in a request address that can appear in logs; optional link expiry sends a hash for signing. Use ordinary, non-sensitive diagrams, and share the local-rendering link rather than a remote image when that distinction matters. We have not audited the implementation. FAQ, checked November 5, 2026.
Read the full arch-lab analysis and sources
The MIT repository names Raksit Nongbua and shows human maintenance on October 7, 2026. Source and file exports offer a route out if hosting ends, without a hosting guarantee. arch-lab ranks second at 3.80 out of 5. Its first public release date is unknown, so it is ineligible for Rising Star; that uncertainty does not remove it from this comparison. Repository, FAQ, checked November 5, 2026.
Used arch-lab? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
nomnoml
Compact UML-style diagrams
Choose nomnoml for a compact UML-style diagram and an SVG that keeps the editable source inside it.
Reasons to choose it
- PNG, SVG and source downloads
- Reopen an exported SVG to recover the text
- Browser storage and custom styling
What to watch
- No native rendering in GitHub, GitLab or Obsidian
- Open report of broken SVG export
- Browser storage has no persistence guarantee
Choose nomnoml if you want a small UML-style diagram with a straightforward way to keep the editable text. Its public browser editor offers PNG, SVG with embedded source, source downloads and a shareable link. It says an exported SVG can be reopened to recover the text. Its repository describes a client-side live preview with browser storage and documents database shapes, nested nodes, direction, spacing and custom styles. Editor, repository, checked November 5, 2026.
The syntax is nomnoml’s own, without Mermaid’s native reach across GitHub, GitLab and Obsidian. Keep a text copy as well as the image; the repository gives no guarantee that browser storage will preserve your diagram. An open August 2026 issue is titled “Webapp: Exports broken SVG”, so PNG is the safer handoff when an SVG recipient cannot check it. The issue listing does not establish the cause or frequency. Issue list, checked November 5, 2026.
Read the full nomnoml analysis and sources
Daniel Kallin and contributors publish the source under MIT. The latest tagged release shown is 1.7.0 from December 14, 2024, while a human source change is dated May 30, 2026: the release date alone does not make the project abandoned. Its advisory page lists no published advisories; that is not a security audit. Releases, repository, advisories, checked November 5, 2026.
Used nomnoml? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
D2 Playground
Also consider · layout control
Choose D2 Playground when comparing layouts matters more than having the text render on GitHub, and keep your .d2 file yourself.
View full sizeEarlier hands-on check, October 1, 2026, before our research-only method: our synthetic diagram in D2 0.9.0 (d2.js 0.1.34) with the default Dagre layout. Source
Reasons to choose it
- Dagre, ELK and TALA layouts in the browser
- PNG and SVG export or copy
- Open source, with local-running instructions
What to watch
- Not rendered natively by GitHub, GitLab or Obsidian
- Its funding company announced its shutdown in September 2026
- Diagram held only in the page address
The Playground compiles and draws D2 entirely in your browser, according to its repository. Its layout menu offers Dagre, ELK and TALA. TALA was a paid layout engine until September 7, 2026, when D2’s lead maintainer released it under the same open-source licence as D2 and bundled it into D2 0.9.0; his announcement points readers to the Playground to try it and says it runs entirely client-side. The export menu saves or copies PNG and SVG, though a note in the code says downloads do not work on mobile. A database can be drawn as a cylinder and a job queue as a queue shape. Playground repository, export code, TALA is open source, D2 releases
Keep your text yourself. The Playground writes the encoded diagram into a ?script= parameter in its address; unlike Mermaid’s # fragment, that part of the address is sent to the hosting service when the page loads. Its code saves only the theme in browser storage, and a request to store diagrams locally has been open since April 2023. We found no privacy policy specific to the Playground. Vercel hosts it through its open-source program. Editor code, local storage request
Read the full D2 Playground analysis and sources
The main reason to hesitate is reach and continuity. GitHub’s documentation lists Mermaid, GeoJSON, TopoJSON and ASCII STL as the diagram syntaxes it renders; D2 is not among them, and GitLab draws D2 only if an administrator enables its Kroki integration. On September 5, 2026, the lead maintainer wrote that the company funding D2 was shutting down, that D2 would continue as an independent nonprofit project fiscally sponsored by Hack Club, and that his own time would be limited. He says the next phase “will be driven by AI” and that the project will not run server features. D2’s sponsor page says donations keep d2lang.com and the Playground online. Releases continued, with 0.9.0 on September 7. The Playground’s source and local-running instructions give you an exit if the hosted site goes away. Announcement, sponsor page, GitHub diagrams, GitLab Kroki integration
The official Playground dates from December 2022, so we treat it as an established alternative rather than a newcomer. D2 v0.1.2
In an earlier hands-on check on October 1, 2026, before we adopted our research-only method, the Playground then showing D2 0.9.0 and d2.js 0.1.34 exported nonblank PNGs and SVGs containing all four labels in both the Dagre and ELK layouts, which produced different arrangements, and its link restored the exact text. We did not try TALA.
Used D2 Playground? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Which product are we missing?
Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.
Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.
Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.
No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.
What people are saying
We found no representative user-rating sample for this task. In an October 2025 Hacker News discussion of a newer Mermaid-based tool, commenters named native GitHub rendering as Mermaid’s main strength and said its layout struggles as diagrams grow; one wrote that D2 is better “but it’s not supported by GitHub”, and another found PlantUML’s layout hard to tune in large diagrams. In a September 2026 discussion of D2’s move to nonprofit status, one user recalled the Playground appearing to be down months earlier, and reactions to the AI-driven development plan were mixed. A long-running Mermaid issue describes SVGs that break in desktop software, a PlantUML report describes a diagram that fails on its new site, and older D2 Playground issues mention a memory leak and unclear error messages. These are opinions and leads, not measured failure rates. October 2025 discussion, D2 nonprofit discussion, Mermaid SVG issue, PlantUML report, D2 Playground issues
How we researched
This is public-source research. For this comparison we did not use any of these tools, create accounts or contact their makers; we read documentation, release notes, source code in public repositories, security advisories, issue trackers and public discussions on October 19, 2026, and additional editor and newcomer evidence on November 5, 2026. Where a page could not be read directly, we relied on the project’s source code or said so.
In an earlier hands-on check on October 1, 2026, before we adopted our research-only method on October 3, we entered the same synthetic four-part diagram (a browser client, an API service, a database and a job queue) into Mermaid Live Editor, D2 Playground and PlantUML Server in an anonymous browser. We checked PNG and SVG output for those three tools and exact source restoration from edit links for Mermaid and D2. The other tools were assessed from documentation. That check is kept here only as dated, bounded history; it did not decide the Pick. The images on this page come from it. Earlier check record, October 1, 2026
We wrote this for one person who writes a small software architecture diagram as text in a browser, wants to keep the source, and must hand over a PNG or SVG, without installing anything or creating an account. Before scoring, we set three entry conditions (browser text editing with no install or account, PNG or SVG at no charge, and a product that is available and not being shut down) and fixed five weighted criteria: the handoff itself, meaning preview, export and source sharing (30%); where the same text renders later (20%); where your diagram goes and the security record (20%); upkeep and the route out if the service ends (20%); and layout control (10%). Mermaid Live Editor leads with 4.45 out of 5, followed by arch-lab at 3.80, nomnoml at 3.70 and D2 Playground at 3.60. Its lead over arch-lab is 0.65, greater than the largest criterion weight of 0.30, so it is not narrow. Layout control is where D2 is strongest, and that is the basis of our “Also consider”.
We revisited newcomers on November 5, 2026 using dated launch discussions and the GitHub diagrams-as-code topic. Oxdraw’s repository documents image export and a share button holding source in the link’s fragment. We could not establish free access to the hosted editor, so it does not qualify for this recommendation. Its issue list includes bidirectional-pattern and image-upload rendering reports. Oxdraw repository, issues, newcomer discovery, checked November 5, 2026.
PlantUML Server scores 3.45 and remains useful if your team already writes PlantUML, but its public route sends source to a server and its FAQ warns about HTTP and occasional tracing. PlantText’s free editor adds local file storage and image links but relies on a PlantUML server; it scores 3.50. Kroki publishes a privacy policy and offers a live text editor. It scores 3.55; its policy says encoded diagram source in request addresses can remain in access logs for less than 30 days. GraphvizOnline also scores 3.55 and offers PNG/SVG downloads and a choice of Graphviz engines for DOT text. It wins its tie with Kroki on the most heavily weighted criterion, the handoff. Keep DOT separately; no editor-specific privacy commitment was found, and its issue history includes interface and share-link problems. GraphvizOnline editor, repository, issues, checked November 5, 2026. Edotor offers PNG, SVG and source downloads but scores 3.35, with less evidence about upkeep and data handling. These tools sit outside the four shown above. PlantUML FAQ, checked October 19, 2026; PlantText, Kroki, Kroki privacy policy, Edotor, checked November 5, 2026.
Structurizr and LikeC4 still lack confirmed browser image export; Ilograph’s anonymous image handoff is unconfirmed. Eraser and Fourlayer require accounts. Mermaid.ai is the account-based service linked from the Live Editor. Line9’s homepage calls its viewer free, but its licence restricts free use to personal, non-commercial work, which does not cover ordinary work diagrams. SimpleMermaid and mermaid.design describe capable editors, but their legal pages identify no responsible person or legal entity, and we could not check their processing claims against published source. arch-lab is included among the four compared tools; its unknown first public release date prevents a Rising Star award. Line9 homepage, licence, SimpleMermaid terms, mermaid.design terms, arch-lab FAQ, arch-lab source, checked November 5, 2026.
Reladraw links a browser playground but documents image output through its command-line tool, not browser download controls. Beautiful Mermaid’s playground did not provide enough readable detail to establish image handoff. Merview and mdview describe Markdown viewing without a confirmed PNG or SVG handoff; Grafly and DrillFlow do not establish this text-first workflow. lini links a browser compiler, but its browser image handoff is unconfirmed; Shumoku documents command-line and library rendering rather than a hosted text editor. No directory-based newcomer search was possible because the directory pages could not be read. Reladraw source, lini source, Shumoku source, checked November 5, 2026.
OpenFlowKit documents free browser text editing, PNG/SVG and editable source links; it scores 4.00. Its first public release and responsible operator could not be established from the available documents. Moxie Docs’ free Mermaid editor scores 3.75, but we could not establish its operator or check its browser-only processing claim against published implementation. Vellum documents editable YAML, PNG/SVG and recovery, scoring 3.80, but we could not confirm free anonymous hosted access. arch-lab remains second at 3.80; its unknown first release date affects only Rising Star eligibility. None receives an award. OpenFlowKit source, releases, Moxie Docs editor, Vellum source, arch-lab FAQ, checked November 5, 2026.
| Tool | Public sources | What remains uncertain |
|---|---|---|
| Mermaid Live Editor | Official guide, editor source code (export, data-security note, editor chooser), maintainer statement, Mermaid 12 release notes, security advisories, GitHub, GitLab and Obsidian documentation, Mermaid.ai privacy policy. | Whether the editor chooser or Mermaid.ai links change what anonymous users see; how analytics data is handled in practice; SVG behaviour in your desktop software. |
| nomnoml | Editor, repository, releases, advisory page and issue list checked November 5, 2026. | SVG-export defect details; no storage or uptime guarantee. |
| arch-lab | FAQ and MIT repository checked November 5, 2026; named maintainer and October human maintenance. | First public release date, beta-format stability, processing implementation and future hosting. |
| Newer candidates | Dated launch discussions and public documentation checked November 5, 2026. | Unconfirmed hosted access for Oxdraw and Vellum; first-release and operator evidence for other candidates. |
| D2 Playground | Playground repository and source code, D2 releases, nonprofit and TALA announcements, sponsor page, issue tracker, user discussion. | Hosted uptime, how long donations fund hosting, what the host logs from addresses, mobile downloads. |
None of this establishes image quality, accessibility, speed or uptime. The four compared routes cost nothing; paid plans and self-hosting are outside this comparison. Next substantive review is due January 17, 2027, or sooner if a security, ownership or hosting change affects one of these tools. Found a changed policy or feature? Contact the editors.
Sources and evidence
Incumbent sources checked October 19, 2026; additional editor, pricing and newcomer sources are dated November 5, 2026 beside the relevant claims. Mermaid: Live Editor guide, Live Editor repository, export code, data-security note, editor chooser code, maintainer statement, Live Editor advisory, Mermaid advisories, Mermaid 12.0.0 release, SVG issue, Mermaid.ai privacy policy. D2: Playground repository, releases, nonprofit announcement, TALA announcement, sponsor page. PlantUML: server documentation, FAQ, news, releases, server repository. Rendering in documentation: GitHub, GitLab, Obsidian. Results described as an earlier hands-on check come from our October 1, 2026 record, made before our research-only method. Makers’ documents establish stated features and policies; issue reports and discussions do not establish how often problems occur. No vendor supplied access, payment or editorial input, and our links carry no affiliate tracking.
This private draft has no publication date or owner approval.
Images are exports of one synthetic four-part diagram from our earlier hands-on check on October 1, 2026, made before we adopted our research-only method. They show each tool’s output at that date, not current appearance or quality. The diagram engines belong to their respective projects. Earlier check record, October 1, 2026.
