Project boards for a small team: Notion, ClickUp, Freedcamp, Smartsheet and more

Notion gives a small team dependent dates, free limited-access guests and a full export beside its written pages. ClickUp runs it close as a board-first tool, and we did not select a Rising Star this time.

PRACTICAL PICKSPreferredPickOur Preferred PickTasks beside written pages and databases$50/mo

Notion

Dependencies that can shift later dates, free guests who see only what you share, and an export that keeps comments, for $10 per member billed yearly.

It is a general workspace, so a team that wants only cards on a board has more to learn.

Why Notion is our Pick
Newcomer assessment

No Rising Star selected

Plane, our October choice, first launched in late 2022 and no longer counts as new. The one newer hosted board we found, kan.bn, names no legal entity or address for the company that runs it.

No researched newer tool established its release date, availability, core-task evidence and operator together.

Who is this article for? Small teams of about five people, at work, in a nonprofit or in a volunteer group, running ordinary shared projects on a board with owners, due dates and the occasional outside contributor.

About 32 min read

What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean

The quick list

Five members on the plan each team would need, billed yearly. Compare the price, then how each handles dependent dates, outside contributors and leaving.

List prices for five members and one outside contributor, checked November 12, 2026, in US dollars before tax. Billed yearly, where monthly billing costs more. Three-year costs hold today’s price constant: Notion $1,800, ClickUp $1,620, Smartsheet $1,620 and Freedcamp $268. Our arithmetic, not quotes. Excludes add-ons and AI credits. ClickUp’s pricing page also shows a regular price of $12 for Core. Freedcamp’s free plan caps files at 10 MB.

The comparison at a glance

Compare what each board costs a team of five, how it handles dependent dates and outside contributors, and what you keep when you leave.

Order follows our verdict for a small team running ordinary projects: our Pick first, then ClickUp, a close second, then Freedcamp and Smartsheet. It is not measured speed or ease of use. All tools remain selectable.

Project boards for a team of about five
FeatureNotionClickUpFreedcampSmartsheet
Best fitPreferred Pick: tasks beside written pages and databases, with dependent dates and free guestsClose second: a board-first team that plans around dates and invites outside helpThe lowest paid price, with free guest collaborators; dates and fields cost moreSpreadsheet-style plans with dependent dates and free Contributors; no free plan
Free plan for a team of fiveBuilt for individuals: limited blocks for teams of two or more; 5 MB per file; 10 guestsUnlimited members and guests; 60 MB of files in total; guests get full edit rights onlyUnlimited users, projects and storage; 10 MB per file; no table view or subtasksNo free plan; a trial only
Five people on the plan this team needs$50/month billed yearly (Plus), $1,800 over three years$45/month billed yearly (Core), $1,620 over three years; monthly price not stated$7.45/month yearly or $12.45 monthly (Pro), $268 over three years; the free plan caps files at 10 MB$45/month billed yearly (Pro), $1,620 over three years
Dependent datesDependencies that can shift later dates and keep the gap between themEvery plan; optional automatic reschedulingBusiness plan, in the Gantt viewPro: a change to a predecessor adjusts dependent dates
Outside contributorFree guests reach only the pages they are invited to; permission levels from full access to viewCore: free view-only guests; 13 permission-set guest seats for five membersPro: free guest and read-only collaborators; permissions by project and groupFree Contributors can view, comment, upload and respond to requests; editing Guests need Business
ExportPage, database or workspace as HTML with comments, Markdown with CSV, or PDF; link expires after 7 daysAdmins: task CSV with descriptions, checklists and commentsXLS export; backups on Business and upExcel, PDF or Google Sheets; groupings, summary rows and attachments left out
Main thing to watchPlus needed for teams; a general workspace with more to learn; AI-agent risksPlans changing; reported slowness; 60 MB free storageDependencies, Gantt and custom fields need Business ($37.45 for five)No free plan; free editing guests need Business ($19)

Public-source research for a team of about five running ordinary projects on a shared board; no accounts, boards, invitations, automations or payments. Prices checked November 12, 2026; other facts as read October 19 and 20, 2026. Next review December 18, 2026, or sooner after a material change. Prices are list prices in US dollars before tax; yearly prices need a year’s payment; three-year costs hold today’s price constant. Unknown means unresolved, not absent.

All features and sources 19 criteria

Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.

Plans and price for a team of five

Show 6 criteria
Plans and price for a team of five
FeatureNotionClickUpFreedcampSmartsheet
Best fitPreferred Pick: tasks beside written pages and databases, with dependent dates and free guestsClose second: a board-first team that plans around dates and invites outside helpThe lowest paid price, with free guest collaborators; dates and fields cost moreSpreadsheet-style plans with dependent dates and free Contributors; no free plan
Free plan for a team of fiveBuilt for individuals: limited blocks for teams of two or more; 5 MB per file; 10 guestsUnlimited members and guests; 60 MB of files in total; guests get full edit rights onlyUnlimited users, projects and storage; 10 MB per file; no table view or subtasksNo free plan; a trial only
Entry paid plan, per person per monthPlus: $10 billed yearly; Business $20Core: $9 billed yearly for new workspaces (page also shows a regular price of $12)Pro: $1.49 yearly / $2.49 monthly; Business (Gantt, custom fields) $7.49 / $8.99Pro: $9 billed yearly / $12 monthly; Business $19 billed yearly
Five people on the plan this team needs$50/month billed yearly (Plus), $1,800 over three years$45/month billed yearly (Core), $1,620 over three years; monthly price not stated$7.45/month yearly or $12.45 monthly (Pro), $268 over three years; the free plan caps files at 10 MB$45/month billed yearly (Pro), $1,620 over three years
How seats are countedEvery member is billed; guests are free and reach only the pages they are invited toEach member; guests beyond the included guest seats add a member seatActive users only; read-only and guest collaborators free on paid plansPaid Members only, 1 to 10 on Pro; unlimited free Contributors
Refunds and renewalRenews automatically until you cancel; refunds for mistaken sign-ups, and some regions’ laws give moreFull refund within 30 days of a first purchase; yearly plans need 30 days’ notice to cancel or cut usersRefund only within 7 days of a yearly renewal, less a fee; downgrades leave creditsCancellation and refund terms not read
Sources for plans and price for a team of five

Checked November 12, 2026: ClickUp pricing and new plans; Notion pricing; Freedcamp pricing and billing FAQ; Smartsheet pricing. ClickUp terms and Freedcamp terms as read in October.

Planning and dates

Show 5 criteria
Planning and dates
FeatureNotionClickUpFreedcampSmartsheet
Views on the plan aboveTable, board, timeline, calendar and list views of any databaseBoard, list, table and calendar; Gantt on CoreKanban, list and calendar; table on Pro; Gantt on BusinessGantt, table, board and calendar on Pro; timeline on Business
Dependent datesDependencies that can shift later dates and keep the gap between themEvery plan; optional automatic reschedulingBusiness plan, in the Gantt viewPro: a change to a predecessor adjusts dependent dates
Custom fieldsCustom properties on every planCore (trial on Free)BusinessColumns of many types on Pro; rich formulas
Automation allowanceDatabase automations on paid plans, no run allowance stated; @remind remindersFree 100; Core 1,000 actions a monthNot documented in what we readPro: 250 automations a month, including reminders
File limitsFree: 5 MB per file; paid: up to 5 GB per fileFree: 60 MB in total; paid: unlimitedFree: 10 MB; Pro: 25 MB; Business: 100 MB per fileNot stated on the pricing page
Sources for planning and dates

Guests and sharing

Show 3 criteria
Guests and sharing
FeatureNotionClickUpFreedcampSmartsheet
Outside contributorFree guests reach only the pages they are invited to; permission levels from full access to viewCore: free view-only guests; 13 permission-set guest seats for five membersPro: free guest and read-only collaborators; permissions by project and groupFree Contributors can view, comment, upload and respond to requests; editing Guests need Business
Read-only peopleCan view and Can comment levelsCore: unlimited free view-only guestsFree read-only collaborators on paid plansContributors can view and comment; no separate read-only licence listed for Pro
Private projectsOnly people invited on a page or database; closed teamspaces and row-level limits need BusinessPrivate Spaces, Folders and Lists shared with named peoplePermissions by project and group on paid plansNot read in detail
Sources for guests and sharing

Leaving, data and company record

Show 5 criteria
Leaving, data and company record
FeatureNotionClickUpFreedcampSmartsheet
ExportPage, database or workspace as HTML with comments, Markdown with CSV, or PDF; link expires after 7 daysAdmins: task CSV with descriptions, checklists and commentsXLS export; backups on Business and upExcel, PDF or Google Sheets; groupings, summary rows and attachments left out
If you stop payingPaid features run to the end of the billing period; Free limits then applyPaid plan runs to the end of the cycle; free limits then apply; export firstReturns to Free; paid-feature data hidden, not deleted; inactive free accounts can be deleted after a yearNot read; backups only on Business and Enterprise
AI and data termsSays customer data is never used to train AI models; annual SOC 2 and ISO 27001 auditsSays its AI providers may not train on customer data; does not sell data2018 privacy policy: “not in the business of selling” data; no AI terms foundPrivacy notice offers an opt-out from sharing personal data for advertising
Security and company recordSeptember 2025 AI-agent data-leak research; a June 2026 claim of 110 million records for sale, called fabricated by NotionApril 2026: 893 customer emails exposed in feature-flag settings; fixedNo incident found; 2019 terms exclude all liabilityTaken private by Blackstone and Vista Equity Partners in January 2025
CompanyNotion Labs, Inc.Mango Technologies, Inc. (ClickUp)Freedcamp, Inc.Smartsheet, owned by Blackstone and Vista Equity Partners
Sources for leaving, data and company record

What matters when choosing

Notion is our Practical Pick for a small team, about five people, that runs ordinary shared projects on a board and keeps its tasks beside written pages: owners, due dates, a few statuses and the occasional outside contributor. Any database can be shown as a table, board, timeline or calendar, and when one task is blocked by another, Notion can shift the later item’s dates automatically. Guests are free and see only the pages you share with them, and you can export everything, including comments. Plus, the plan a team needs, costs $10 per member a month billed yearly, $50 for five, which is $1,800 over three years. The free plan limits teams of two or more and caps files at 5 MB. The main limit is that Notion is a general workspace, so a team that wants only cards on a board has more to learn; its AI agents have also drawn security research, and a June 2026 claim that its user records were for sale was called fabricated by Notion. Notion pricing, dependencies, sharing and permissions, export

The lead is narrow. ClickUp is a close second, and the better choice if you want a board-first tool. It scored 3.78 out of 5 against Notion’s 3.82, a gap smaller than the weight of our most heavily weighted criterion, and the gap rests largely on a half-point judgment about exports. Notion stayed ahead when we counted price differences more and less heavily, by 0.04 to 0.06. ClickUp’s free plan has no member limit, and every plan includes board, list and calendar views and task dependencies that can move later dates when an earlier task slips. Its first paid plan for new workspaces, Core, costs $9 per member a month billed yearly, or $45 for five, which is $1,620 over three years. Core adds unlimited storage, custom fields, Gantt charts, and guests whose access you can limit, including free view-only guests. The most important compromise is uncertainty about the plan itself: ClickUp is moving customers to new plans, its pricing page shows Core’s “regular price” as $12 and does not state a monthly price, and price changes for moved workspaces start no earlier than January 2027. Check the price at checkout. Freedcamp came third, at 3.67, then Smartsheet at 3.60. ClickUp pricing, new plans, dependencies, guest roles

We did not select a Rising Star this time. Plane, which we named in October, no longer qualifies: its first public release was in late 2022, more than two years ago, so it is no longer a newer tool under our rule. The one newer tool we found that is available now and shows boards with owners and due dates, kan.bn, first released in June 2025, names only “Open Engineering” as its operator, with no legal entity or address, which we require of a service that stores your team’s data. Worklenz and Huly, the next best, were first released in 2024 and 2021.

We weighed many other products. Freedcamp has the lowest paid price here, and Smartsheet suits spreadsheet-style plans. Trello, Basecamp, Plane, Asana, monday.com, Jira, Zoho Projects, Plaky and the rest are described, with their prices, in How we researched below. Freedcamp pricing, Smartsheet pricing

Disclosure: Practical Picks articles are researched and written with AI, currently Anthropic’s Claude. Notion, our Pick, offers a connector for Claude, ClickUp’s AI features listed Claude among their models when we checked on October 19, and Smartsheet’s plans list a way to work with Smartsheet from within Claude. We have no relationship with any of these companies or with Anthropic over these products, and AI features carried no weight in our judgment.

Our prices are list prices checked November 12, 2026, in US dollars per person per month before tax, for five members on the plan each team would need; each team also has one outside contributor, which is free on every plan here except where we say a seat is needed. Yearly prices require paying for a year, and monthly billing costs more. Totals are our arithmetic, not quotes, and exclude add-ons and AI credits; three-year costs hold today’s price constant. Three conditions would change our recommendation. If you want to stay on a free plan, choose ClickUp: its Free Forever plan allows unlimited members and guests, but it holds only 60 MB of files in total and cannot limit what guests do, so check that against your files. Notion’s free plan limits teams, and Freedcamp’s caps files at 10 MB. If price matters more than dependent dates and permissions, Freedcamp Pro costs $7.45 a month for five, Trello Standard $25 and Plaky $19.95. If you want a board-first tool with dependent dates for a team that does not need written pages, choose ClickUp. Whichever you choose, export your project data before you downgrade or cancel. Every service here limits what its exports include.

Notion

Preferred Pick · tasks beside written pages and databases

$50/moPlus · $10 per member, billed yearly

Choose Notion when your team wants tasks, dependent dates and written pages in one workspace, with free guests who see only what you share and an export that keeps comments.

Reasons to choose it

  • Dependencies that can shift later dates, with board, timeline and calendar views
  • Free guests who reach only the pages they are invited to
  • Export of a page, database or workspace with comments

What to watch

  • Free plan limits teams of two or more and caps files at 5 MB
  • A general workspace, so more to learn than a plain card board
  • AI agents have drawn security research

Notion is a workspace for pages and databases made by Notion Labs, Inc., a San Francisco company that Wikipedia says was founded in 2013 and whose own terms name it as the operator. Any database can be shown as a table, board, timeline or calendar, with custom properties, sub-items and dependencies. When one task is blocked by another, Notion can shift the later item’s dates and keep the gap between them, and an @remind mention sets a reminder. The free plan is for individuals: teams of two or more run into a limit on blocks, files are capped at 5 MB and it allows 10 guests. Plus, for small teams, costs $10 per member a month billed yearly, so five members cost $50 a month, or $1,800 over three years. It allows files up to 5 GB, longer page history and more guests; Business costs $20 per member. We took $10 as the yearly price; the page also says yearly billing saves up to 20%. Pricing, dependencies, reminders

Choose Notion when your tasks belong beside written pages and databases, and the team will keep everything in one place. It scored highest here, 3.82, because it has dependencies with date shifting, page-level guest access and a broad export. Its lead over ClickUp, 0.05, rests largely on a half-point judgment about exports. Notion is also a general workspace, so a team that wants only cards on a board has more to learn than in Trello or ClickUp.

Read the full Notion analysis and sources

Outside contributors

Guests are free and are external collaborators outside your organization; they can reach only the pages and databases they are invited to. Access levels run from full access to “Can edit content” (create and edit records and their properties, but not the database’s structure), “Can comment” and “Can view”. Setting a page or database to “Only people invited” keeps it from everyone else, while pages in a default teamspace are open to the whole workspace. Closed teamspaces and limiting people to the rows assigned to them need Business. On Free, 10 guests are allowed. Sharing and permissions, pricing

Leaving and your data

You can export a page, a database or the whole workspace at any time, as HTML with comments, as Markdown with a CSV file for each database, or as PDF. A workspace export includes uploaded files and arrives as a link that expires after seven days. Notion says you cannot recreate a workspace by uploading the export again, so treat the files as a record you keep; relations, permissions and automations would have to be rebuilt by hand in any other product. Your plan renews automatically until you cancel, and you keep paid features until the end of the billing period. Notion’s refund policy covers mistaken sign-ups, and some regions’ laws give more. Export, pricing FAQ

Data terms and security record

Notion says it undergoes annual SOC 2, ISO 27001, ISMAP and BSI C5 audits, publishes its reports in a Trust Center along with a security exhibit and a list of subprocessors, and that customer data “is never used to train AI models by Notion or its subprocessors”. In September 2025 researchers showed that hidden text in a PDF could make Notion’s AI agents send workspace data out; Notion said it had upgraded its detection and now asks users to approve suspicious links. That matters only if you use its AI features. On July 29, 2026 Notion said a June claim that 110 million user records were for sale was fabricated and that it found no evidence of a breach. Security, Simon Willison, September 19, 2025, Notion security update

Used Notion? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

ClickUp

Close second · a board-first team that plans around dates

$45/moCore · $9 per member, billed yearly

Choose ClickUp when your team wants dates that move together, outside contributors with limited access and one plan that covers both, and you can check the current price at checkout.

Reasons to choose it

  • Dependencies with optional rescheduling on every plan
  • Free view-only guests and permission-set guest seats on Core
  • Admins can export tasks with comments to CSV

What to watch

  • Plans are changing; Core’s monthly price is not stated and it lists a regular price of $12
  • Free plan: 60 MB of files in total and full-edit guests only
  • Long-running user complaints about slowness

ClickUp’s free plan, Free Forever, allows unlimited members and guests, with board, list, table and calendar views, task dependencies, reminders and 100 automation actions a month. Its limits are real for a working team. All files share 60 MB of storage, custom fields and Gantt charts are trials, and free-plan guests can only be given full edit rights. Core, the first paid plan for new workspaces, costs $9 per member a month billed yearly. It adds unlimited storage, custom fields, Gantt charts, 1,000 automation actions a month, and guests with limited or view-only access. Five members cost $45 a month. Pricing, storage limits, reminders

What separates it from the others is that one plan covers the whole job. Dependencies are on every plan: one task can block another, and with rescheduling switched on, moving an earlier task’s due date moves the dependent task’s dates by the same amount. Trello has no built-in dependencies, and monday.com reserves them for its $19 Pro plan. Asana includes them on Starter, but at $10.99 a person. Choose another tool if your team wants the simplest possible board. ClickUp offers many more features and settings than this job needs, and its own feedback board carries long-running complaints about slowness (see What people are saying). We could not measure either. Dependencies

Read the full ClickUp analysis and sources

Plans and prices are changing

ClickUp’s help center, updated October 16, 2026, says workspaces are being moved to new plans that include AI features, that new workspaces start on them, and that pricing and packaging are subject to change. Workspaces that are moved keep their price until a date in their notice. Price changes start no earlier than January 2027, at renewal. On November 12 the pricing page listed Free Forever, Core at $9 billed yearly with a “regular price” of $12, Business at $17 and a custom Enterprise plan, and no longer showed the older Unlimited plan. It still did not state Core’s monthly-billing price, so confirm the plan and its price at checkout. Even at $12, five people would cost $60 a month, which would not change its place in our ranking. Yearly plans renew for twelve months unless you give notice of a cancellation or a reduction in users at least 30 days before the renewal date. ClickUp offers a full refund within 30 days of a first paid purchase. Intro to pricing, pricing, terms, section 1.12

Outside contributors

On paid plans, view-only guests are free and unlimited. Guests whose permissions you set can view, comment, edit or fully edit only the items you share with them. Core includes five of these guest seats for the first member and two more for each member you add, so a five-member workspace has 13. Inviting another such guest after that adds a paid member seat. People who use your organization’s email domain cannot be guests. On the free plan, guests can only have full permissions on what you share. Guest roles, pricing per role

Leaving and your data

Owners and admins can export task data to CSV on the free and paid plans ClickUp’s help lists. The file includes task descriptions, statuses, dates, assignees, checklists, comments and links to attachments. Exports of individual list and table views are limited on Free and Core, and Docs are exported one at a time. ClickUp’s terms say that if it ends your access, your content is no longer accessible through your account, so export before you cancel. ClickUp’s AI FAQ, which we read through search indexing, says its contracts with AI providers prohibit them from training on customer data. Its privacy policy, effective June 2, 2026, says it does not sell data. Export task data, export limits by plan, terms, section 3.2, AI FAQ, privacy policy

An April 2026 security lapse

On April 27, 2026, ClickUp published an account of a lapse that a security researcher had disclosed publicly that day. Its feature-flag settings, readable through a public key in its website code, contained 893 customer email addresses and one customer’s API token. The token had been live since October 7, 2025. ClickUp says a January 2025 bug-bounty report did not lead it to review those settings. It also says it removed the addresses and invalidated the token within about 16 hours, and that no workspace content, passwords or billing data were affected. It says its logs showed no malicious access beyond the researcher’s own. The independent report is eSecurity Planet’s of April 28. This shows a process failure that ClickUp says it has fixed, not a current exposure. ClickUp’s account, eSecurity Planet report

Used ClickUp? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Freedcamp

Lowest paid price · fewer planning tools

$7.45/moPro · $1.49 per user, billed yearly

Consider Freedcamp if the lowest paid price and free guest collaborators matter most and you can do without dependencies, Gantt charts and custom fields, which need its $7.49 Business plan.

Reasons to choose it

  • Lowest paid price here: $7.45 a month for five
  • Free read-only and guest collaborators on paid plans
  • Free plan with unlimited users, projects and storage

What to watch

  • Gantt, dependencies and custom fields need Business
  • Privacy policy from 2018 and terms from 2019
  • Refunds only within 7 days of a yearly renewal

Freedcamp, Inc., of Santa Barbara, California, offers a free plan with unlimited users, projects, tasks and storage, the storage subject to fair use, with kanban, list and calendar views, milestones and time tracking. Pro costs $1.49 per user a month billed yearly or $2.49 monthly, so five people cost $7.45 or $12.45. It adds a table view, subtasks, recurring tasks, two-factor sign-in and 25 MB files; Free caps files at 10 MB. Business, at $7.49 billed yearly, adds Gantt charts, custom fields and statuses, weekly backups and 100 MB files. Freedcamp’s own feature page describes dependencies, date shifting and automatic scheduling in the Gantt view. Freedcamp bills only for users who were active during a billing period. Five people cost $268 over three years on Pro. Pricing, features, billing FAQ

Choose Freedcamp when cost decides and a board, list and calendar are enough. Start and due dates reach people through a daily recap email, which each person can switch to weekly or off. It is not our Pick because dependent dates, Gantt charts and custom fields need Business, which costs $37.45 a month for five, and its terms and privacy policy predate its current product. It scored 3.67, third. Notifications

Read the full Freedcamp analysis and sources

Outside contributors

On paid plans, read-only and guest collaborators are free and do not count as active users; Freedcamp describes them as suited to clients and colleagues who only need to observe work or occasionally comment. Permission settings, which can limit what each person does in each part of a project, work by groups on Free and by projects and groups on paid plans. Two-factor sign-in comes with the paid plans. Collaborators, permissions, two-factor sign-in, updated August 31, 2026

Leaving and your data

Freedcamp lists import and export in XLS format, and weekly backups come with Business and daily ones with Enterprise. If you downgrade, data from paid features is hidden, not deleted, and returns if you subscribe again; data is deleted 90 days after an account is deleted. Its terms, effective April 27, 2019, let it delete free accounts with no activity for 365 days, a week after notice, so a team that drops to the free plan must keep using it. Refunds are given only if you cancel within seven days after a yearly renewal, less a fee of $50 or 6%, whichever is greater, and downgrades leave non-refundable credits. The terms exclude Freedcamp’s liability for any amount. Its privacy policy, effective May 10, 2018, says Freedcamp is not in the business of selling your data; it does not mention the AI tool that Cloudwards reports on the Business plan. We found no reported breach. Billing FAQ, updated August 22, 2026, terms, privacy policy

Used Freedcamp? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Smartsheet

Spreadsheet-style plans · no free plan

$45/moPro · $9 per member, billed yearly

Consider Smartsheet if your team thinks in spreadsheets, wants dependent dates and Gantt views, and has outside people who only need to view, comment and respond.

Reasons to choose it

  • Dependent dates, Gantt, board and calendar views on Pro
  • Unlimited free Contributors who can view, comment and respond
  • 250 automations a month, including reminders

What to watch

  • No free plan, only a trial
  • Editing guests need Business at $19 a member
  • Exports leave out groupings, summary rows and attachments

Smartsheet is a work-management service whose plans are built on sheets that can be shown as Gantt, table, board or calendar views. Its Pro plan costs $9 per member a month billed yearly, or $12 monthly, for 1 to 10 members, so five members cost $45 a month, or $1,620 over three years. Pro adds unlimited sheets, forms and reports, 250 automations a month and unlimited free Contributors: people who can view, comment, upload attachments, respond to update requests and submit forms. There is no free plan, only a trial. Business, at $19 per member billed yearly, starts at three members and adds free Guests who can edit and comment, a timeline view and workload tracking. Pricing

Choose Smartsheet when your team already thinks in spreadsheets and wants dependent dates without a per-guest charge for people who only need to respond. On Pro, a change to a row’s predecessor adjusts the dates of the rows that depend on it, and automations can send reminders. It scored 3.60, fourth, because there is no free plan, free outside people on Pro can respond but not freely edit, and exports leave things out. Dependencies

Read the full Smartsheet analysis and sources

Outside contributors

Contributors are free and unlimited on Pro: they can view, comment, upload attachments, respond to update requests and submit forms. Guests, who are outside your organization’s email domains and can edit and comment, come free only with Business at $19 per member. We did not read how sharing is scoped to individual sheets in detail. Pricing

Leaving and your data

Pro can export sheets, reports, workspaces and folders to Excel, PDF or Google Sheets; groupings, summary rows and attachments are not included, and backups come only with Business and Enterprise. We did not read what happens to your data after you cancel. Export

Data terms and company record

Blackstone and Vista Equity Partners completed an $8.4 billion take-private purchase of Smartsheet in January 2025. Smartsheet’s privacy notice, updated May 20, 2026, offers an opt-out from sharing personal data for advertising. Privacy notice, PE Hub, January 22, 2025

Used Smartsheet? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Which product are we missing?

Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.

Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.

Suggest a product

Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.

No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.

What people are saying

User reports are a check on vendor claims, not a measure of satisfaction or reliability. Trello’s 2025 redesign drew a strong reaction. The Register reported a community thread of almost 200 posts, mostly complaints, and users comparing the change to Windows 8. Atlassian said it understood the frustration but would keep the new direction. That shows how existing users reacted, not how well Trello works for a new team. The Register, August 6, 2025

ClickUp’s public feedback board has a “SLOWNESS” post from August 29, 2023 with about 1,100 votes. ClickUp marked it completed in March 2024 after a performance update, but commenters were still reporting slowness as late as April 2026. These reports come from self-selected users, some with large workspaces, and do not measure speed for a five-person team. Review-platform summaries indexed by search on October 19 repeat speed and feature overload as common complaints. We could not open those pages, so we did not rely on them. ClickUp feedback board

An Asana user described a disabled cancellation control and support errors, and an account carrying a staff name asked for a ticket. We did not verify the outcome, and one report cannot show how often this happens. A Plaky review on Cloudwards, displayed as updated July 2026, still said that paid plans and automations were missing, which Plaky’s current pages contradict, so we did not use its feature judgments or score. The site discloses commissions. We found no matched review sample that supports a fastest, easiest or most reliable winner across these tools. Asana cancellation report, read September 6, 2026, Plaky review

How we researched

This is public-source research. We did not create accounts, sign in, build boards, invite people, run automations, test notifications or exports, or pay for any plan. No vendor supplied access or payment, and affiliate availability played no part. We first compared Trello, Asana and Plaky on September 6, 2026. On October 19, 2026 we rechecked prices, plan limits, guest rules, exports, cancellation terms and data terms, and added ClickUp, monday.com and Jira. Some help centers did not load for our automated checks, so we read ClickUp’s and monday.com’s help articles through their public help-center interfaces, which return the same text, and Asana’s dependency availability comes from search indexing. On October 20 we evaluated Basecamp, Freedcamp, Zoho Projects, Notion, Smartsheet and other tools our earlier pass had set aside. On November 12, 2026 we read every price again from the maker’s own pricing page, worked out what each product costs a team of five with one outside contributor over three years, and checked again which tools count as newer. Freedcamp’s pricing page now loads, which confirms the prices and plan contents we had taken from independent copies in October. Basecamp’s plans changed in that time, and its figures here are the November ones. Where we relied on an earlier reading, the article gives its date.

We chose these products for a team of about five people running ordinary projects on a shared board. We judged them on fit for that job (25%), cost for five people and an outside contributor over three years (25%), guest and sharing rules (20%), exports and what happens when you leave (15%), and terms, data handling and company record (15%). We fixed those criteria and weights before scoring and gave AI features no weight. Notion scored 3.82 out of 5, ClickUp 3.78, Freedcamp 3.67 and Smartsheet 3.60; Zoho Projects was a hair behind at 3.59, then Plane 3.57, Trello 3.54, Asana 3.52, monday.com 3.49 and Basecamp 3.43. Notion is our Pick on the highest total. Its lead over ClickUp is narrow: 0.05 at our standard weighting, 0.06 if price differences count for less and 0.04 if they count for more, and it rests on a half-point judgment about exports. ClickUp’s lead over Freedcamp is also narrow: 0.11 at our standard weighting and about 0.01 if price differences count for more. Counting price differences more heavily moves Zoho Projects into the top four ahead of Smartsheet.

The other products, with their scores. Zoho Projects, 3.59: its Premium plan, at $4 per user a month billed yearly, includes Gantt charts and dependencies, but clients are a paid add-on, task custom fields need Enterprise, and its free plan stops at five users and three projects. Plane, 3.57: timeline dependencies, project-scoped guests and work-item exports at $6 per seat, but due-date reminders need its $13 Business plan, guests cannot edit, and on September 28, 2026 it published a batch of at least 20 security advisories, several rated High; the ones we checked were fixed in a July release, and one Medium-rated flaw was still open in October. Trello, 3.54: a free plan for up to ten collaborators and ten boards and Standard at $5 per member a month billed yearly, good if cards moving across a few lists tell the whole story, but with no built-in dependencies, calendar and timeline views only on Premium at $10, and Atlassian saying publicly that it is refocusing Trello on individual productivity and pointing teams that need project management to Jira (Computerworld). Asana, 3.52: timeline, Gantt and dependencies on Starter at $10.99, no refunds, and free guests only inside company-domain organizations. monday.com, 3.49: guests kept apart on Standard at $12 a seat, but dependencies need Pro at $19, seats come in buckets and its pricing page shows an AI-credit charge offset by a monthly discount whose renewal terms are not stated. Basecamp, 3.43: a flat price and clients kept apart, but no dependencies, custom fields or Gantt chart, and since its plans changed, five members and a client need Pro at $79 a month. Jira, 3.35: a free plan for ten users where every user is an admin with no guests, Standard at $9.70 per user a month, and Atlassian’s AI data defaults on Free and Standard. Taskade scored 3.37, Microsoft Planner 3.35 (dependencies need Planner Plan 1, at $10 per user a month billed yearly), Huly 3.35, Wrike 3.24 (sold in groups of five seats), MeisterTask 3.09 (Pro at $13 per user a month) and Plaky 2.98 (businesses only, no guests or dependencies yet, CSV export of Table view only). We also looked at Todoist, Worklenz, Upbase and kan.bn on what we could read; none could reach ClickUp’s total. We could not confirm paid prices for Nifty and Teamwork.com because their pricing pages did not load, so we did not score their cost; at any price their makers have listed, they would still trail ClickUp. Self-hosted open-source boards need your own server, so we left them out for this reader.

We searched again for newer project boards for this reader, on November 12, 2026, using Hacker News, open-source directories, GitHub release histories, vendor pages and a recent list of open-source Trello alternatives. We counted a tool as newer if its first public release was on or after November 12, 2024, not counting renamings, and not from an established maker of this kind of software; we then required it to be available now as a hosted service, to run on Windows and Mac (a web app counts), to show boards with owners and due dates in its own documentation, and to pass a safety check that includes a named operator for any service that stores your data. Plane, our Rising Star in October, was founded in November 2022 and, as TechCrunch reported in November 2023, had been live for about a year by then, so it no longer counts as new. Huly’s releases date from November 2021 and Worklenz’s from May 2024. Upbase gives no release date. Kan.bn, first released on June 2, 2025, is the only newer hosted tool that shows boards with owners and due dates, and its terms and privacy policy name only “Open Engineering” as operator, with no legal entity or address. Kanba, Kaneo and It’s a Plan are self-hosted only, and Fizzy comes from 37signals, the maker of Basecamp. Our adverse searches, on October 19 and, for the tools added later, on October 20, covered news, security, outage, lawsuit, regulator and insolvency terms for each product and its company.

ToolPublic sourcesWhat remains uncertain
ClickUpPricing page (read November 12, 2026), help articles on new plans, guests, dependencies, exports and storage, terms, privacy policy, April 2026 security account, feedback board, San Diego Union-Tribune report.Core’s monthly price and its price after January 2027, speed for a small workspace, export completeness.
NotionPricing page and terms index (read November 12, 2026), help on dependencies, reminders, sharing and permissions and export, security page and update (read October 20), Wikipedia.Whether the half-point export judgment holds; how its AI agents behave; the agreements themselves, which we did not read beyond the index.
FreedcampPricing page (read November 12, 2026), collaborator and feature pages, help on billing, notifications and two-factor sign-in, terms (2019) and privacy policy (2018).What the XLS export includes; its dated terms and privacy policy.
SmartsheetPricing page (read November 12, 2026), help on dependencies and export, privacy notice (May 20, 2026), PE Hub report.What happens to data after cancellation, how sharing is scoped, the exact Pro export contents.
Other productsPricing pages read November 12, 2026 for every product named above except Nifty and Teamwork.com; the October reading of terms, help articles, privacy policies and reports for each.Nifty and Teamwork.com prices; Basecamp’s billing basis; ClickUp’s and monday.com’s renewal prices.

None of this establishes that invitations, reminders or automations work as documented, or that an export restores a project. Next substantive review is due December 18, 2026, or sooner if a plan or term changes. Found a changed price or rule? Contact the editors. See Our methods.

Sources and evidence

Sources were checked October 19, 2026, or October 20, 2026 for Plane, Basecamp, Freedcamp, Notion, Smartsheet and the other tools first assessed that day, and prices again on November 12, 2026, unless another date is given. Vendor material establishes documented offers and terms, not working results. Community posts and reviews are attributed experiences, not representative samples.

This is a researched comparison, not a product review. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.