Plan your own retirement without an adviser: Owl, firenum, BridgeToFI, Bullseye, Fidelity and MaxiFi
Owl, free and open source, optimises taxes, Roth conversions and Social Security together. firenum, new in 2026, is a free browser planner for couples; Fidelity is free with fewer controls; MaxiFi costs $149 a year from an identified company.
Owl
Owl works out withdrawals, Roth conversions and Social Security claiming ages together, with federal and state income tax, IRMAA, ACA premiums and RMDs, and tests your plan with historical back-testing and Monte Carlo simulation. It is free, and you can inspect its code.
No company or support desk stands behind it, its hosted copy keeps nothing between sessions so you save scenario files yourself, and its interface is technical. Its lead over the next products is narrow.
Why Owl is our PickTeam behind Owl? Get your award badge
firenum
firenum plans for a couple with separate retirement dates and Social Security claims, yearly federal and state tax, Roth ladders and RMDs, and tests plans against 500 random markets and every US start year since 1872, with no account needed.
It is new and unreviewed, no independent record confirms its company, it does not model Medicare premiums or guardrails, and it loads a Reddit ad pixel if you accept cookies and plans to earn adviser referral fees; its lead over the next newcomer is narrow.
Why firenum is our Rising StarWho is this article for? A US couple or single person, about 45 to 65, who wants to plan retirement themselves: Social Security timing, withdrawals, taxes, Roth conversions and how a plan holds up in bad markets. Not for financial advisers or people buying managed investing or advice.
About 30 min read
What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean
The quick list
Costs for one couple over three years, read November 19, 2026. Three-year costs range from $0 to $447.
US dollar prices before tax, read November 19, 2026. Owl, firenum, BridgeToFI and Bullseye Retirement are free. Fidelity’s planner is free with a Fidelity login. MaxiFi Premium costs $149 a year ($447 over three years); MaxiFi Standard costs $109 a year but has no stress test.
The comparison at a glance
Compare what each retirement planner costs for one couple over three years, how it handles Social Security, taxes and bad markets, and what it does with your data.
Order follows our verdict for a couple planning their own retirement, not measured accuracy. All tools remain selectable.
Hides matching answers for the selected tools. Unknowns and unverified claims stay visible.
| Feature | Owl | firenum | BridgeToFI | Bullseye Retirement | Fidelity Planning & Guidance Center | MaxiFi Planner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: free, open-source planning that optimises taxes, Roth conversions and Social Security together | Rising Star: a free browser planner for couples; new in 2026 | Not labelled: the highest score, but it names no operator | Not labelled: a full feature list, but it names no operator | Also consider: free, from a large regulated firm, with fewer controls | Also consider: a paid planner from an identified company, built around lifetime spending |
| Cost for one couple over three years | $0 (free, open source) | $0 (“no account needed and nothing behind a paywall”) | $0 (“free forever”) | $0 (“Free forever”) | $0 (needs a Fidelity login) | $447 (Premium, $149 a year; the $109 Standard plan has no stress test) |
| Where it runs and where your plan is kept | Browser (the hosted copy runs on its host’s servers and keeps nothing; you save scenario files) or your own computer with Python or Docker | Browser; plans in your browser, or synced with a free account; Android app | Browser; your plan stays in your browser | Browser; your plan is kept in an online account | Browser, inside your Fidelity account | Browser; your plan is kept in your MaxiFi account |
| Who runs it | Martin-D. Lacasse and The Owl Authors (open-source project, no company) | firenum LLC, Wyoming (registered-agent address; no independent record found) | Not named (“BridgeToFI’s principal owner”) | Not named (“Bullseye and its creators”) | Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC (FINRA CRD 7784) | Economic Security Planning, Inc., Providence, Rhode Island |
| Stress tests | Historical back-testing and Monte Carlo (17 return models) | 500 random markets and every US start year since 1872 | Monte Carlo and a historical stress test (1929, 1966, 1973, 2000) | 1,000 simulated markets; no historical test found | Monte Carlo probability of success; no historical test | Monte Carlo range of living standards (Premium); no historical test |
| Advertising and selling to you | Hosted app “does not store or forward any information” | Optional Reddit advertising pixel; emails will suggest an adviser’s plan review that pays firenum 20% | Says it does not sell your data or share it with advertisers | Says your data is encrypted and never sold | Some website sharing may count as a “sale” for advertising; affiliates may market products to you | “We don’t sell your data, offer financial products, or manage assets” |
| Our score (out of 5) | 4.83 | 4.73 | 4.90 (operator not named) | 4.90 (low confidence; operator not named) | 4.35 | 3.93 |
For a married couple in the United States, both 55, planning to retire at 62 to 65 with 401(k) or IRA, Roth, taxable and cash accounts, a small pension and Social Security, keeping one plan up to date for three years with at least four saved scenarios. Sources checked November 19, 2026; next review December 24, 2026, or sooner after a price or terms change. Feature claims are the vendors’ own; we did not use, buy or test any planner. Order follows our verdict, not measured accuracy. Planners give estimates from your inputs, not advice.
All features and sources 17 criteria
Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.
Price and fit
Show 6 criteria
| Feature | Owl | firenum | BridgeToFI | Bullseye Retirement | Fidelity Planning & Guidance Center | MaxiFi Planner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: free, open-source planning that optimises taxes, Roth conversions and Social Security together | Rising Star: a free browser planner for couples; new in 2026 | Not labelled: the highest score, but it names no operator | Not labelled: a full feature list, but it names no operator | Also consider: free, from a large regulated firm, with fewer controls | Also consider: a paid planner from an identified company, built around lifetime spending |
| Cost for one couple over three years | $0 (free, open source) | $0 (“no account needed and nothing behind a paywall”) | $0 (“free forever”) | $0 (“Free forever”) | $0 (needs a Fidelity login) | $447 (Premium, $149 a year; the $109 Standard plan has no stress test) |
| Where it runs and where your plan is kept | Browser (the hosted copy runs on its host’s servers and keeps nothing; you save scenario files) or your own computer with Python or Docker | Browser; plans in your browser, or synced with a free account; Android app | Browser; your plan stays in your browser | Browser; your plan is kept in an online account | Browser, inside your Fidelity account | Browser; your plan is kept in your MaxiFi account |
| Who runs it | Martin-D. Lacasse and The Owl Authors (open-source project, no company) | firenum LLC, Wyoming (registered-agent address; no independent record found) | Not named (“BridgeToFI’s principal owner”) | Not named (“Bullseye and its creators”) | Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC (FINRA CRD 7784) | Economic Security Planning, Inc., Providence, Rhode Island |
| Account linking | None (manual entry) | None (manual entry) | None (manual entry) | Not required | Optional; manual accounts allowed | None (manual entry only) |
| Our score (out of 5) | 4.83 | 4.73 | 4.90 (operator not named) | 4.90 (low confidence; operator not named) | 4.35 | 3.93 |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for price and fit
Prices in US dollars before tax, read November 19, 2026: Owl GitHub repository; firenum how it makes money and About; BridgeToFI calculator and terms; Bullseye landing page and terms; Fidelity methodology and FINRA BrokerCheck; MaxiFi pricing and terms. Scores use criteria and weights fixed before scoring. See How we researched.
Planning
Show 4 criteria
| Feature | Owl | firenum | BridgeToFI | Bullseye Retirement | Fidelity Planning & Guidance Center | MaxiFi Planner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Social Security | Own, spousal and survivor benefits; optimises claiming ages from 62 to 70 | Claim at 62 to 70 for each person, with spousal top-up; break-even calculator | Claim age for you and your partner; break-even chart | Claim age per person on its adviser pages; personal app not checked | Start age from 62 to 70 that you enter; a separate Social Security Benefit Calculator compares claiming ages | Finds the best filing strategy for you and your spouse |
| Taxes and Roth conversions | Federal and state (50 states and DC), capital gains, NIIT, IRMAA and ACA; Roth conversions optimised | Federal, state (all 50) and payroll tax every year; Roth conversion ladder | 2026 federal brackets (or a flat rate) and state tax; Roth conversion ladder | Federal and state taxes; Roth conversion strategies | Federal, state and local as an effective rate each year; modelled Roth conversions | Federal, state, FICA and Medicare Part B IRMAA; Roth conversion optimiser (Premium) |
| Withdrawal order | Optimised, or taxable accounts first | Taxable first, proportional, or your own order | Priority you set for each account (spend first, backup, locked until 59½) | Drawdown order on its adviser pages; personal app not checked | “Predetermined order” | Roth first, last or in proportion; optimised order |
| Healthcare costs | Medicare IRMAA surcharges and ACA premiums | ACA credit before 65; Medicare is your own expense line; no IRMAA found | Pre-Medicare costs; Medicare Part B and D premiums | Medicare Part B and D, and IRMAA | Medicare premiums; health-care inflation schedule from 4.9% | Medicare Part B and IRMAA; Part D not modelled |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for planning
Vendor documentation, read November 19, 2026: Owl modelling capabilities; firenum planner guide and reference; BridgeToFI calculator and changelog; Bullseye landing page and for advisers; Fidelity methodology and retirement tools; MaxiFi how it works and Medicare help. Feature claims are the vendors’ own; nothing was used or tested.
Stress tests and scenarios
Show 3 criteria
| Feature | Owl | firenum | BridgeToFI | Bullseye Retirement | Fidelity Planning & Guidance Center | MaxiFi Planner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stress tests | Historical back-testing and Monte Carlo (17 return models) | 500 random markets and every US start year since 1872 | Monte Carlo and a historical stress test (1929, 1966, 1973, 2000) | 1,000 simulated markets; no historical test found | Monte Carlo probability of success; no historical test | Monte Carlo range of living standards (Premium); no historical test |
| Saved scenarios | Saved as files on your computer and loaded again | Up to 5 plans, compared in a table | Saved as files; side-by-side comparison is in its adviser portal | Side by side on its adviser pages; personal limit not stated | No saved scenarios to compare | Alternative profiles compared with your base plan |
| Flexible spending | Flat or “smile” spending profile; no guardrails found | No guardrails found | Flexible spending with guardrails | Not found on its public pages | None found | Adjusts spending to markets in its Monte Carlo (Premium) |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for stress tests and scenarios
Owl GitHub repository; firenum planner guide; BridgeToFI changelog; Bullseye landing page; Fidelity methodology and The Finance Buff review; MaxiFi Living Standard Monte Carlo and alternative profiles.
Your data and the tool’s future
Show 4 criteria
| Feature | Owl | firenum | BridgeToFI | Bullseye Retirement | Fidelity Planning & Guidance Center | MaxiFi Planner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Advertising and selling to you | Hosted app “does not store or forward any information” | Optional Reddit advertising pixel; emails will suggest an adviser’s plan review that pays firenum 20% | Says it does not sell your data or share it with advertisers | Says your data is encrypted and never sold | Some website sharing may count as a “sale” for advertising; affiliates may market products to you | “We don’t sell your data, offer financial products, or manage assets” |
| Export and reports | Financial profile workbook download; reports page | CSV export and import of each plan | Save to file; “My FI Report” | “Download your financial data” | PDF plan snapshot, according to reviewers | PDF and Excel reports |
| Latest update we found | Code change November 12, 2026; release October 28, 2026 | Guides updated November 10, 2026; no changelog | Version 2.6, October 2026 | Articles dated to November 16, 2026 | Methodology uses 2026 limits | Includes the 2025 tax law; privacy policy updated September 28, 2026 |
| AI connections | MCP server for Claude and other AI apps; optional self-hosted assistant | MCP server and API (“Add to Claude”) | None found | “Ask Bullseye” assistant; provider not named | None found | None found |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for your data and the tool’s future
Owl README privacy section and changelog; firenum privacy and developers; BridgeToFI privacy and changelog; Bullseye privacy and articles; Fidelity privacy policy; MaxiFi home page and pricing. Statements are the vendors’ own; we did not inspect their systems.
What matters when choosing
Owl is our Practical Pick for a US couple who want to plan retirement themselves, for free. It is open-source software (GPLv3) by Martin-D. Lacasse and other contributors. Rather than only simulating one plan, it uses optimisation to work out withdrawals, Roth conversions and Social Security claiming ages together, with federal and state income tax for all 50 states and DC, capital gains, the net investment income tax, Medicare IRMAA surcharges, ACA premiums and required minimum distributions built in. You can stress-test a plan with historical back-testing or Monte Carlo simulation. You run it in a browser on its hosted copy, which works on your figures on its host’s servers (Streamlit Community Cloud) during the session, or on your own computer with Python or Docker. Its README says the hosted app “does not store or forward any information. All data entered is lost after a session is closed”, so you save each scenario as a file on your computer and load it again next time. It has no company, no support desk and no spending guardrails, and its interface is more technical than the paid apps. Read November 19, 2026. Owl on GitHub, modelling capabilities
Under the criteria and weights we fixed before scoring, Owl scored 4.83 out of 5. Three products scored higher or close behind it, and our rules let none of them be the Pick: BridgeToFI and Bullseye Retirement (4.90 each) do not name the person or company that runs them, and RetirementIQ (4.75), a $29 browser app, names a company for which we found no address or independent record. firenum came next at 4.73. By our rule Owl’s leads over RetirementIQ (0.08) and firenum (0.10) are narrow: each is smaller than the weight of our heaviest criterion. Against firenum, the lead rests on how the two treat your data (firenum’s optional Reddit advertising pixel and its plan to earn referral fees from an adviser) against Owl having no company behind it. Owl stayed the Pick when we weighted price more gently or more steeply; weighted more gently, RetirementIQ would score just above Owl but still could not be the Pick.
firenum is our Rising Star. It is a free browser planner from firenum LLC, a Wyoming company, launched on Hacker News in early 2026. It plans for a couple with separate retirement dates, Social Security claims from 62 to 70 with a spousal top-up, federal, state and payroll tax every year, Roth conversion ladders, RMDs and ACA credits, and tests each plan against 500 random markets and every US start year since 1872. You can set the withdrawal order yourself, keep up to five plans and compare them in a table, and export each plan as a spreadsheet file. It needs no account; plans stay in your browser unless you create a free account to sync them. It scored 4.73. Its main limits: it is new and unreviewed, and no independent record confirms the company, whose address is a registered agent’s; it does not model Medicare premiums or IRMAA, or spending guardrails; and if you accept cookies it loads a Reddit advertising pixel, while account emails will suggest a paid plan review from an adviser who pays firenum 20%. Its lead over AI Retirement Income Planner (4.54) is narrow, and it depends on RetirementIQ’s first release, which we could not date: if RetirementIQ were shown to be new since November 2024, it would take this award. firenum, how it makes money, privacy
Consider Fidelity’s Planning & Guidance Center if you want a free planner from a large, regulated firm. It models a couple, Social Security start ages from 62 to 70, federal, state and local taxes by account type, Roth conversions, Medicare premiums, RMDs and pensions, and gives a Monte Carlo probability of success. But it withdraws in a “predetermined order”, sets inflation for you, has no historical test or spending rule, and does not keep saved scenarios to compare. You need a Fidelity login, and Fidelity’s affiliates may use your information to market their products. Methodology
Consider MaxiFi Planner if you want a paid, company-run planner built around Social Security and lifetime spending. MaxiFi Premium costs $149 a year ($447 over three years); the $109 Standard plan has no stress test. It is from Economic Security Planning, Inc., the company of economist Laurence Kotlikoff, takes manual entries only and says “We don’t sell your data, offer financial products, or manage assets.” Its Monte Carlo reports a range of living standards rather than a success rate, it has no historical test, and it renews automatically. Pricing, how it works
BridgeToFI and Bullseye Retirement scored highest but are not labelled. Both are free and offer every feature we looked for, or nearly. BridgeToFI runs in your browser and keeps your plan there; Bullseye keeps your plan in an online account. Neither says who runs it: BridgeToFI’s terms refer only to its “principal owner”, and Bullseye’s to “Bullseye and its creators”. With your full financial picture involved, we do not recommend either until that is clear.
Disclosure: Practical Picks is researched and written with Claude, made by Anthropic. Several planners here connect to Claude: Owl and firenum offer connectors (MCP servers) that let your own Claude app run plans, and so do Retirology, Boldin and QuantCalc; Retirement Scenario Explorer’s AI Advisor and ReadyAimRetire’s assistant are powered by Anthropic; AI Retirement Income Planner, RetirementIQ and RetireNavigator Studio accept your own Anthropic key; Origin says its AI Advisor uses Claude; Plan With Clarity uses Claude; Teapot lets advisers connect Claude; Retirement Figures suggests pasting a plan into Claude or ChatGPT; and Quicken’s help pages offer an “Open in Claude” link. We have no relationship with Anthropic or any of these companies. AI features carried no weight in our scoring.
Every planner here gives estimates from your own inputs and assumptions, not advice, and they disagree: the same plan can show different chances of success in different tools. Check the assumptions before you act on any result.
Owl
Preferred Pick · free, open-source planning that optimises taxes and Social Security together
Choose Owl if you want the most thorough free planning we found from code you can inspect. It optimises withdrawals, Roth conversions and Social Security claiming ages together, with federal and state tax, IRMAA, ACA premiums and RMDs, and tests plans with historical back-testing and Monte Carlo.
Reasons to choose it
- Optimises Roth conversions and claiming ages 62 to 70
- Federal and state tax for all 50 states and DC, with IRMAA
- Historical back-testing and Monte Carlo
What to watch
- No company or support desk behind it
- Hosted copy runs on its host’s servers and keeps nothing: you save scenario files yourself
- Technical interface; no spending guardrails
Owl is a retirement planner published as open-source code under the GPLv3 licence by “Martin-D. Lacasse and The Owl Authors”. It costs nothing: the hosted app, the Docker image and the source are all free. Its README describes it as a tool to “optimize withdrawal strategies rather than merely simulate them, finding the mathematically best sequence of decisions across all accounts simultaneously.” It was last updated on November 12, 2026, with releases through October 28, 2026, and the repository lists no security advisories. Owl on GitHub, security advisories, releases on PyPI
Choose Owl if you are comfortable with a detailed, technical tool and want the most thorough free planning we found from a source you can inspect. It models a household with “one sheet per person”; taxable, tax-deferred (401(k) and IRA), Roth and HSA accounts; “Social Security — own, spousal, and survivor benefits; optional optimization of claiming age (monthly resolution, 62–70)”; “Roth conversions — amounts and timing co-optimized with spending and bequest goals”; pensions and annuities with survivor fractions; and RMDs. Taxes cover “federal + state income tax (all 50 states + DC), LTCG brackets, NIIT, Medicare IRMAA, and ACA premiums”. You can test a plan with “historical back-testing, Monte Carlo simulation with sequence-of-returns risk, or fixed rates derived from historical averages”, using 17 return models, including a “user” option for your own fixed rates. The hosted app offers a workbook download of your financial profile and a reports page. These are the project’s own descriptions. Modelling capabilities, changelog
Read the full Owl analysis and sources
What to weigh before choosing it
- No company stands behind it. Support is through GitHub issues or the maintainer’s email; there is no support desk or service promise. It says it is “for educational and research purposes only” and that “accuracy of results is not guaranteed”.
- The hosted copy works on your figures on its host’s servers (Streamlit Community Cloud) while you use it, and keeps nothing between sessions: “All data entered is lost after a session is closed. However, you can choose to download selected parts of your own data to your computer before closing the session.” You keep your scenarios as files and reload them, or install Owl on your own computer with Python or Docker.
- Its optimiser decides spending and withdrawals; it has a flat or “smile” spending profile but no spending guardrails or cut-after-a-crash rule that we found.
- Its interface is technical, and we could not view the hosted app with our research tools, so this assessment rests on its documentation and code repository.
- Its optional Docker images still carry some unfixed high-severity findings in their Debian base packages, according to a commit note; this concerns self-hosting with Docker, not the hosted app.
Owl is maintained in a public repository with named maintainers, and its README says the hosted app “does not store or forward any information”. That is how we confirmed who is behind it; it is not evidence of a company or of long-term support. Owl on GitHub
Used Owl? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
firenum
Rising Star · a free browser planner for couples, new in 2026
Consider firenum if you want a free planner with couples planning, yearly federal and state tax, Roth conversion ladders and both random and historical stress tests, without signing up. You can set the withdrawal order, keep five plans and export each one.
Reasons to choose it
- Couples, claim ages 62 to 70, spousal top-up
- 500 random markets and every US start year since 1872
- Your own withdrawal order; up to 5 plans compared
What to watch
- New in 2026; no independent record of its company
- No Medicare or IRMAA modelling; no guardrails
- Optional Reddit ad pixel; plans adviser referral fees
firenum is a suite of free retirement and early-retirement calculators from firenum LLC, which its About page describes as “a Wyoming limited liability company” at a Sheridan, Wyoming address that many companies use as a registered agent’s. Its maker introduced it on Hacker News about nine months before our research (about February 2026), saying most calculators “required uploading my entire financial life”; an Android app followed in August 2026. firenum says “The Fire Planner and every calculator are free, with no account needed and nothing behind a paywall. That is permanent.” About, how it makes money, Hacker News post (mirror)
Choose firenum if you want a free planner with couples planning, real tax calculations and both kinds of stress test, without creating an account. Its pages say you can “Plan as a couple, each with a retirement date”, “Claim at 62 to 70, spousal top-up” and get “Federal, state and payroll tax every year, all 50 states. Roth ladder, RMDs, ACA credits”. It tests plans against “500 random markets” and “Every US start year since 1872”. Withdrawal order can be “Taxable First”, “Proportional” or a custom order you set account by account. “Keep up to 5 plans in the plan menu”, compare them in a table, and use “File ▸ Export this plan (CSV)” to keep a copy. A separate Social Security break-even calculator compares claiming ages. These are firenum’s own descriptions. Home page, planner guide, planner reference
Read the full firenum analysis and sources
What to weigh before choosing it
- It is new and unreviewed. We found one comment on its launch post and no independent reviews. We could not find a register record confirming firenum LLC, and its address is a registered agent’s, not an office.
- Healthcare is modelled only before 65 (the ACA credit); “Medicare after 65 stays your own healthcare line”, and we found no IRMAA. It has no spending guardrails.
- If you accept cookies, it loads Google Analytics, Microsoft Clarity session replays and “the Reddit Pixel to measure whether our Reddit ads bring visitors”, which sends Reddit page visits. It says it never shows ads on its site and does not sell your numbers. Privacy
- Its business model is referrals: “The plan review is sold by a fee-only, SEC-registered investment adviser, and the adviser pays firenum 20% of the price for the referral”, and account emails include “a note when a review of your plan makes sense”. It says no adviser has signed yet and it “earns nothing today”; the emails can be turned off.
- Without an account, plans live only in your browser; clearing it deletes them. With a free account they sync through Cloudflare, “replicated worldwide”. “Delete account” removes everything.
- It publishes no changelog; its guides were last updated between October 13 and November 10, 2026.
Used firenum? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
BridgeToFI
Not labelled · the highest score, from an operator it does not name
BridgeToFI scored highest, with partner Social Security, federal brackets and state tax, Roth ladders, Medicare costs, guardrails, Monte Carlo and historical stress tests, all in your browser. Its terms name no person or company, so we do not label it.
Reasons to choose it
- Every planning feature we looked for
- Plan stays in your browser
- Monte Carlo and historical stress tests
What to watch
- Names no person or company
- Saving several plans means keeping files
- Aimed at early retirees
BridgeToFI is a free browser calculator, first released in December 2025 and updated to version 2.6 in October 2026. It says “BridgeToFI is free forever” and “In the free calculator all calculations happen locally in your browser, and your financial data is stored only in your browser’s localStorage. There is no account and nothing to upload.” It scored 4.90, tied for the highest. BridgeToFI, changelog
It covers a partner with a separate retirement age and Social Security claim age, a choice of “Flat Rate” or “2026 Fed Brackets” for tax with married-filing-jointly brackets, state tax, Roth conversion ladders, pre-Medicare and Medicare costs, RMDs, pensions, a Social Security break-even chart, flexible spending with guardrails, Monte Carlo simulation and a “Historical Stress Test (1929, 1966, 1973, 2000 scenarios)”. You keep plans by saving them to a file.
Read the full BridgeToFI analysis and sources
What to weigh before choosing it
- Its terms name no person or company, only “BridgeToFI’s principal owner”, and it offers a contact form only. Because you would enter your whole financial picture, and its code is not public, we do not label it.
- It is aimed at early retirees bridging the years before retirement accounts can be tapped, so some settings assume that goal.
- Saving more than one plan means keeping files yourself; side-by-side comparison is part of its adviser portal.
Used BridgeToFI? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Bullseye Retirement
Not labelled · a full feature list and an unnamed operator
Bullseye Retirement offers a free online planner with yearly projections for a couple, federal and state tax, Roth conversion strategies, Medicare and IRMAA, and 1,000 simulated markets. Its pages name only "Bullseye and its creators", and its personal app is behind a sign-in, so we do not label it.
Reasons to choose it
- Free, with Medicare and IRMAA modelling
- Roth conversion strategies
- 1,000 simulated markets
What to watch
- Names no person or company
- Plan kept in an online account
- Personal app features could not be checked
Bullseye Retirement offers a free account (“Free forever. No credit card required”) that shows “your whole retirement, year by year, with taxes, Medicare costs and 1,000 simulated markets”, for you and your spouse, with federal and state taxes, required distributions, Roth conversion strategies, Medicare Part B and D and IRMAA, and an AI assistant. Its earliest dated pages are from January 2025. It scored 4.90, tied for the highest, but with low confidence: its personal app and FAQ are behind a sign-in, so several features could not be checked. Bullseye Retirement, for advisers
What to weigh before choosing it
- Its privacy policy and terms name only “Bullseye and its creators”; we found no company, person or address. It keeps your plan in an online account, says your financial data is encrypted and never sold, and does not name its AI provider. That is why we do not label it. Privacy, terms
- Some features we saw, such as setting a separate claim age for each person and comparing scenarios side by side, are described on its adviser pages; we could not confirm they work the same way in the personal app.
Used Bullseye Retirement? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Fidelity Planning & Guidance Center
Also consider · free, from a large regulated firm, with fewer controls
Consider Fidelity if you want a free planner from a firm you can easily identify. It models a couple, Social Security start ages, taxes by account type, Roth conversions, Medicare and RMDs, with a Monte Carlo chance of success, but it fixes the withdrawal order and inflation and keeps no scenarios to compare.
Reasons to choose it
- Free, from a FINRA-registered firm
- Taxes by account type, Roth conversions, Medicare
- Monte Carlo probability of success
What to watch
- Predetermined withdrawal order; inflation set for you
- No historical test or saved scenarios
- Affiliates may market products to you
Fidelity’s Planning & Guidance Center is a free planner offered by Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC, a FINRA-registered broker-dealer (CRD 7784), or its adviser affiliate. It scored 4.35. Its methodology says it plans for “you and the ‘spouse/planning partner’”; estimates Social Security from “the retirement age and Social Security start age you enter” (62 to 70); estimates “federal, state, and local individual income taxes on … distributions from tax-exempt and tax-deferred retirement plans, modeled Roth conversions” as an effective rate from your projected taxable income each year; adds Medicare premiums with a health-care inflation schedule starting at 4.9%; and enforces RMDs. It reports a Monte Carlo probability of success, and Fidelity offers a separate Social Security Benefit Calculator to compare “monthly and lifetime benefits at different ages”. Methodology, retirement tools, FINRA BrokerCheck
Choose it if you want a free, simpler planner from a firm you can easily identify, and you are happy to work within its assumptions.
Read the full Fidelity Planning & Guidance Center analysis and sources
What to weigh before choosing it
- Expenses are paid “by withdrawing from the assigned accounts in a predetermined order”; general inflation is the “Tool’s general inflation rate of 2.5%”, and for health-care inflation it “does not allow you to change this inflation rate”.
- Its stress test is Monte Carlo only, with no historical test or spending rule, and it does not keep scenarios to compare; reviewers compare saved PDFs. Taxes are an effective-rate estimate, and Fidelity says the tool “should not be used for tax-planning”.
- You need a Fidelity login. Fidelity’s own pages do not say whether you can register without opening an account; a Fidelity account is free to open.
- Its privacy policy says some website sharing may count as a “sale” or “sharing” for advertising under California law, and that affiliates may use your information to market products to you. Privacy policy
- Harry Sit of The Finance Buff, who has used it for three years, calls it a “High-Level Model, Not Tactical”. The Finance Buff
Used Fidelity Planning & Guidance Center? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
MaxiFi Planner
Also consider · a paid planner from an identified company
Consider MaxiFi if you want a company-run planner with support, built around lifetime spending: it finds a Social Security strategy for both spouses, calculates federal, state, FICA and IRMAA taxes, and in Premium adds a Monte Carlo range and a Roth conversion optimiser. It costs $447 over three years.
Reasons to choose it
- Social Security strategy for both spouses
- Federal, state, FICA and IRMAA taxes
- Manual entry; says it does not sell your data
What to watch
- $447 over three years for Premium
- No historical test; Monte Carlo shows a range, not a success rate
- Yearly plans renew automatically
MaxiFi Planner is a browser planner from Economic Security Planning, Inc., the company of Boston University economist Laurence Kotlikoff, which its terms place in Providence, Rhode Island; InvestmentNews has named Kotlikoff as the company’s president. It scored 3.93: its features are strong, but our cost score rates $447 over three years as expensive against the many free and low-cost planners here. Terms, InvestmentNews
Choose MaxiFi if you want a company-run planner with support and you value its approach: it “Finds the best Social Security filing strategy to get the highest benefits for you and your spouse”, calculates “Federal, State, and FICA Taxes” and Medicare Part B IRMAA, handles Roth and non-Roth accounts, RMDs, pensions and annuities, lets you compare “alternative profiles”, and exports reports as PDF or Excel. Premium ($149 a year) adds “Living Standard Monte Carlo” and a “Roth Conversion Optimizer”; the $109 Standard plan has no stress test. It takes manual entries only and says “We don’t sell your data, offer financial products, or manage assets.” Pricing, how it works
Read the full MaxiFi Planner analysis and sources
What to weigh before choosing it
- Its Monte Carlo shows a range of living standards rather than a chance of success, and it has no historical test. It “does not currently model Medicare Part D premiums”. Medicare help
- Plans are yearly only, and subscriptions bought since December 26, 2024 renew automatically; refunds are “generally” given within 30 days, at the company’s discretion. One licence covers one household. Renewal, order terms
- Harry Sit of The Finance Buff, who paid for it, finds “the standard reports more useful than the Monte Carlo reports”. The Finance Buff
Used MaxiFi Planner? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Which product are we missing?
Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.
Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.
Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.
No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.
What people are saying
We found few independent, first-hand reports for the newer tools: none for Owl, BridgeToFI or Bullseye, and for firenum a single comment on its launch post. Some review and forum sites we tried (Bogleheads, Trustpilot, Product Hunt) were not available to our research tools.
On paid planners in general, seven people in a ChooseFI forum thread started in October 2026 compared tools. One, JoeQ17, warned that the same inputs give “different results” in different tools (“Projectionlab and Boldin were much more conservative”); another, John Dovey, wrote that a paid subscription “in the $100-150 range annually is well worth it for a DIYer”. On free planners from investment firms, Rob Berger wrote in November 2026 that Empower uses its free dashboard “as a marketing tool” and calls users, though it honoured his request to stop; another reviewer counted “about a dozen calls in the first month”. These are individual experiences, not measured rates. ChooseFI thread, Rob Berger on Empower
How we researched
This is public-source research. We did not install, buy or test any planner, create accounts, or enter any financial details. No company supplied access or payment. On November 19, 2026, we read vendors’ pricing, help, methodology, legal and privacy pages, code repositories and changelogs, regulator and business records, press coverage and user reviews.
We fixed the reader and the job first: a married couple in the United States, both 55, planning to retire at 62 to 65, with two 401(k) or IRA accounts, a Roth IRA, a taxable brokerage account, cash, a paid-off home, a small pension and Social Security, who keep one plan up to date for at least three years and want at least four saved scenarios to compare (retire at 62 or 65, claim Social Security at 62, 67 or 70, convert to Roth or not). A product had to pass five tests to be scored: a year-by-year projection for two people with separate ages; Social Security for both spouses with a claiming age you choose; different tax treatment of taxable, tax-deferred and Roth accounts, with a federal income tax estimate rather than one flat rate; a Monte Carlo or historical stress test with a success rate or range; and self-serve access with a published price or free, in a browser or on both Windows and Mac. Adviser-only software and advice services were out.
We then fixed five criteria and their weights before scoring. Planning depth counts for 30%: Roth conversions, your own withdrawal order, state tax, healthcare costs, RMDs, pensions and a comparison of Social Security claiming ages. Stress tests and scenarios count for 15%: both Monte Carlo and historical tests, saved scenarios to compare, your own return and inflation assumptions, and flexible spending rules. Three-year cost counts for 25%. Help, reports and continuity count for 10%. Financial data privacy and control counts for 20%: no required account linking, no sharing for advertising, no use of your data to sell advice, a data export, account deletion and a named company. Every criterion except cost starts at 5 and loses half a point for each documented gap (one point for a required account link or no release in a year); a feature we could not find in documentation we read in full counted as a gap, but facts we could not establish were not deducted. Cost uses a market-relative formula: the median three-year cost of the 21 priced products that passed was $49, so a free tool scores 5, a $49 tool 3.5, and anything over about $262 the minimum of 1. That is why paid planners score low here: many capable planners are free or cost under $50 once. Owl and firenum kept their awards when we weighted price more gently or more steeply. Totals are rounded half up to two decimals.
Scored but not charted (totals out of 5): RetirementIQ 4.75 ($29 once if you buy in the first two weeks, $39 in weeks three and four of its 30-day trial and $49 after it, from RetIQ Studio LLC; we found no address or independent record for the company, and its earliest dated version is from 2025, so we could not date its first release), Retirology 4.65 (a desktop app for macOS, Windows and Linux, first released May 10, 2026, from $19 once; its pages name no company or person), AI Retirement Income Planner 4.54 ($45.99 list for a file that runs offline, first released May 2026, from an individual trading as WebNomad Studio; the second-highest newcomer), PortfolioPilot 4.50 (free; its Social Security and Roth optimisers are paid; in 2024 the SEC fined its maker, Global Predictions, $175,000 for false claims about artificial intelligence), Retirement Scenario Explorer 4.38 ($79 once for saved scenarios; built by one named developer), QuantCalc 4.38 ($49 once; runs simulations on its own servers; it names only “M I Trading, a company in the European Union”, with no legal form or address), Empower 4.13 (free; fixed withdrawal order, flat state tax, no Roth conversion modelling; its terms let it call and text you with offers for its own and its affiliates’ products, and a free consultation “may result in an offer to enroll in our wealth management services”), ReadyAimRetire 4.00 ($115 a year), WealthTrace 4.00 ($289 a year for Deluxe, needed for Roth scenarios and your own withdrawal order; no refunds), Retirement Figures 3.95 ($79 a year list for Plus; names no company), Pralana Online 3.90 ($199 then $159 a year for its Family Plan, since the single plan holds three scenarios; no refunds), MyPlanIQ MyPlanner 3.75 ($99.95 a year; flat state tax), FIREproof 3.75 ($10 a month for Pro; run by a single-operator business), ProjectionLab 3.75 ($129 a year; its privacy policy allows advertising partners to target ads) and Boldin 3.65 ($168 a year; Monte Carlo only, and its state privacy statement lets advertising technology companies collect data “in exchange for non-monetary consideration”).
Not scored because they failed a test: Origin (its own blog says its forecast does not distinguish taxable, pre-tax and Roth accounts, which conflicts with its help guide); Plan With Clarity (its home page promises tax brackets, its terms say it “assumes a single tax rate”); Vanguard’s and Schwab’s calculators, Quicken Simplifi, Kubera and Monarch (no account-type taxes or stress test); NerdWallet’s calculator (no stress test); SmartAsset’s calculator (plans to 95 “regardless of your spouse’s age”, no stress test); Merrill’s calculator (replaces pre-tax income, with no account-type taxes); T. Rowe Price’s calculator (no Roth); Flexible Retirement Planner and Quicken’s Lifetime Planner (a single average tax rate); cFIREsim, FireCalc and FI Calc (no account types or taxes); Open Social Security (Social Security only); OnTrajectory and Teapot (Social Security for each spouse not shown); RetirePro (one person only); RightCapital, eMoney, Income Lab and Holistiplan (for advisers only); Wealthfront’s planning (“free for active clients” of its investing service); Integers (free for 90 days, then an unpublished price); and RetireNavigator Studio (paid licences are requested by form and issued by hand).
Newcomers: on November 19, 2026, we searched launch sites, GitHub, Hacker News, alternatives lists, press and forums for planners first released since November 19, 2024, and screened about 70 names. Eligible for the Rising Star after passing our five tests and our safety checks: firenum (4.73, the Rising Star), AI Retirement Income Planner (4.54), Retirement Scenario Explorer (4.38) and FIREproof (3.75). BridgeToFI (4.90) and Retirology (4.65) are new but name no person or company, so they did not pass our safety check; Bullseye’s first release could not be dated and its operator is unnamed; RetirementIQ (4.75) and QuantCalc could not be dated, and RetirementIQ would take the Rising Star if its first release were shown to be on or after November 19, 2024. Ignidash does not yet plan for couples, and several others offered no Monte Carlo or historical test or ran on only one platform.
Pages we could not read: Product Hunt, Trustpilot, Bogleheads, OpenCorporates and some business register, trademark and review pages returned access errors (HTTP 403), and Hacker News pages another error (we used mirror copies). We could not view the apps of Owl, Bullseye and several others, or search the Wyoming, Massachusetts, Rhode Island and Texas business registers, which need a browser.
| Tool | Public sources | What remains uncertain |
|---|---|---|
| Owl | GitHub repository and README, modelling capabilities, changelog, tags, security advisories, PyPI releases. | How the hosted app looks and performs; long-term maintenance by a small team. |
| firenum | Home page, planner guide and reference, About, privacy, terms, how-we-make-money and plan review pages, developer and MCP pages, Hacker News mirror. | A register record for firenum LLC; independent reviews; whether the adviser referral starts. |
| BridgeToFI | Calculator page, FAQ, changelog, terms, privacy policy. | Who runs it; how many scenarios the free calculator keeps without files. |
| Bullseye Retirement | Landing page, adviser page, articles list, privacy and terms. | Who runs it; which features the personal app offers; when it was first released. |
| Fidelity Planning & Guidance Center | Methodology, key limitations, FAQ and tools pages, privacy policy, FINRA BrokerCheck, The Finance Buff review. | Whether non-customers can use it without opening an account; whether each spouse gets a separate claiming age. |
| MaxiFi Planner | Pricing, features, help centre articles, terms, order terms, privacy and security pages, InvestmentNews, The Finance Buff review. | Which features sit in Standard and Premium (the pricing grid uses images); whether a free trial exists; a register record for the company. |
| Other products | Vendors’ pricing, legal and help pages, regulator records, reviews, and the newcomer search records in our research notes. | Most features are vendor claims; several newer tools’ operators are known only by a brand. |
Sources and evidence
Sources were read on November 19, 2026 unless another date is given. Vendors’ pages show what they offer and say, not how well it works. Reviews and forum posts are individual experiences.
- Owl: GitHub repository and README; modelling capabilities; changelog; security advisories; PyPI.
- firenum: home page; planner guide; planner reference; About; privacy, October 2026; terms, November 2026; how it makes money, November 2026; plan review; developers and MCP; Hacker News post (mirror).
- BridgeToFI: calculator; changelog; terms; privacy.
- Bullseye Retirement: landing page; for advisers; articles; privacy; terms.
- Fidelity: retirement analysis methodology; key limitations and assumptions; FAQ; privacy policy; FINRA BrokerCheck; The Finance Buff review.
- MaxiFi: pricing; how it works; Living Standard Monte Carlo; renewal; order terms; Medicare Part B help; terms; InvestmentNews; The Finance Buff review, updated August 26, 2025.
- Products scored but not charted: Retirology; RetirementIQ; AI Retirement Income Planner updates; PortfolioPilot pricing and SEC release 2024-36; QuantCalc pricing; Retirement Scenario Explorer; Empower terms and planner methodology; WealthTrace pricing and terms; ReadyAimRetire pricing; Retirement Figures pricing; Pralana Online; FIREproof pricing; ProjectionLab pricing and privacy; MyPlanIQ Retirement Essentials; Boldin pricing and state privacy statement.
- Products that failed a test: Origin FAQ post; Plan With Clarity; Integers terms; RetireNavigator Studio.
- User reports: ChooseFI forum, October 5, 2026; Rob Berger on Empower, November 2, 2026.