Saving recipes and planning the shopping: RecipeSage, Recipe Shelf, Paprika and two more
RecipeSage is free on any phone or computer and exports your whole collection, but one developer runs it as a hobby. Paprika 4 scores higher and would be our Pick once its company is independently confirmed. Our Rising Star, Recipe Shelf, is a newer app from one developer whose legal pages name no company.
RecipeSage
A free, open-source recipe keeper for any browser, phone or computer, with scaling, aisle-grouped shopping lists, shared meal plans, a copy that opens without a connection and an export of the whole collection.
One developer runs it as a hobby; it is a web app only with no App Store app, free imports are capped daily and its hosting location is not stated. Paprika scores higher (4.18 against 3.90) and would be our Pick once its company is independently confirmed.
Why RecipeSage is our PickTeam behind RecipeSage? Get your award badge
Recipe Shelf
An independent developer’s recipe organizer, first public by January 2026, that saves from more than 270 sites, scales servings, builds aisle-grouped shopping lists and syncs between iPhone, iPad, Android and the web.
Its privacy notice and terms name no company and say images, text and video go to AI providers; it lists an export without saying what it contains; unlimited recipes cost $49.99 a year on Standard.
Why Recipe Shelf earned Rising StarWho is this article for? Adults organizing recipes they have permission to save, who want to scale them, build shopping lists, share with a household and keep a copy. No nutrition or diet advice.
About 39 min read
What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean
The quick list
Prices for an iPhone and one computer, then how each handles household sharing and whether you can take a readable copy of your recipes with you.
US App Store, Google Play and vendor-site prices checked November 12, 2026, before tax and without sales. Paprika is free to download and Premium is $14.99 a year at an introductory price; RecipeSage and Cook are free (Cook Cloud sync is optional from EUR 4.99 a month); Recipe Shelf is free to 50 recipes and $49.99 a year on Standard for unlimited recipes; Umami sells monthly, yearly and lifetime access at prices it shows only inside the app.
The comparison at a glance
Compare prices on the devices you use, household sharing, how recipes get in and whether you can take a readable copy with you.
Order follows our verdict for this reader: our Pick, our Rising Star, then the other three by score; Paprika scores higher than our Pick but is not yet our Pick because its company is not independently confirmed. It reflects documented features and prices, not measured import accuracy or reliability. All tools remain selectable.
Hides matching answers for the selected tools. Unknowns and unverified claims stay visible.
| Feature | RecipeSage | Recipe Shelf | Paprika | Cook | Umami |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: every feature free on any device, with a full export; a web app run by one developer as a hobby | Rising Star: a newer app that is the same on iPhone, Android and the web; one developer, and its legal pages name no company | Also consider: scores higher, and would be our Pick once its company is independently confirmed; one app on iPhone, Mac, Windows and Android with family accounts and a readable export | Also consider: plain-text recipe files you own, on phones and computers; you write recipes in a markup language | Also consider: a household sharing recipe books on iPhone, Android and the web, with a whole-collection export |
| Published US price | Free; optional contributions raise the daily import allowance and add image extras | Free to 50 recipes; Basic $1.99 a month (100 recipes); Standard $4.99 a month or $49.99 a year (unlimited recipes); planning and shopping lists on paid plans | Free to download (50 recipes, no sync); Premium $14.99 a year at an introductory price, 7-day trial | Free apps and editor; optional Cook Cloud sync from EUR 4.99 a month | 30 days free, then monthly, yearly or lifetime; prices shown only in the app (US store lists $0.99 a month to $59.99 lifetime) |
| A phone and one computer | $0 on any phone and computer; on iPhone it is the web app added to the home screen | Web plus the iPhone app on one account: $49.99 a year on Standard for unlimited recipes | One Premium subscription covers iPhone, Mac, Windows and Android: $14.99 a year at the introductory price; the free tier is one device and 50 recipes | $0: iPhone and Android apps and Cook Editor on Mac and Windows, with a folder you sync yourself | One purchase covers the phone apps and the web app, for up to five family members; price shown in the app |
| Household library | Separate accounts; meal plans and shopping lists shared with edit rights; recipes shared as copies or profile links | Basic and Standard share a recipe by link; a Family plan is named but its sharing is not described | Premium family accounts: each person has their own login and everyone shares one collection, grocery list and meal plan; you and five others | No household sharing documented; a folder you share yourself is the only route | Up to five family members with their own accounts on one subscription; you invite them to shared recipe books, meal plans and grocery lists |
| Keeping an external copy | Whole collection to JSON-LD, plain text or PDF (RecipeSage documentation); meal plans not exported | An export is listed on both paid plans and survives cancelling; formats not described | Export of a cookbook, a category or everything to HTML or Paprika’s recipe format; cookbooks round-trip | Your recipes are plain-text files in your own folder | “Export all recipe books” (Umami FAQ); PDF, Markdown, HTML, plain text or Recipe JSON Schema (store listing) |
| Without a connection | Collection cached and searchable without a connection; lists and plans editable; read-only if the server is down | Not documented | Recipes are stored on each device | Works without an account or a connection; recipes are files on your device | Not documented |
| Where recipes and scans go | On the developer’s hosted service, location not stated, with a copy cached in your browser; text, photo and PDF imports and the assistant send content to an AI provider through OpenRouter | On Recipe Shelf’s servers; photos, text, video and voice go to AI providers including OpenAI; analytics and advertising tracking named in its privacy notice | On the device and, with Premium, on Paprika’s cloud servers; analytics and crash-reporting services named in the privacy policy | Files in a folder on your own devices; batch imports from other apps pass through the maker’s converter and photo imports through an unnamed model | On Strange Quark’s servers; its 2022 privacy policy does not say where they are hosted or how scans are processed |
| Announced changes and open issues | Desktop app and Cook Mode new in August 2026; meal-plan export and shared recipe editing requested, not built | Who runs it, what its export contains and how the Family plan shares are not described | Paprika 4 was released November 6, 2026; the price after the introductory year is not stated | Managing recipes inside the phone app arrived in version 0.13.0 in October 2026; the app is not yet at version 1 | Price for a new buyer not published outside the app |
Organizing recipes you have permission to save. Sources checked October 19, 2026; prices, plans, platforms and the Paprika 4 release rechecked November 12, 2026 (some readings are dated in the article); next review December 18, 2026. Prices are US store and vendor prices before tax and without sales; Paprika figures are for Paprika 4. This is public-source research: documentation does not establish import accuracy, sync reliability or complete restoration from an export. No nutrition, diet or food-safety advice. Order follows our verdict for this reader.
All features and sources 19 criteria
Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.
Price, platforms and getting recipes in
Show 7 criteria
| Feature | RecipeSage | Recipe Shelf | Paprika | Cook | Umami |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: every feature free on any device, with a full export; a web app run by one developer as a hobby | Rising Star: a newer app that is the same on iPhone, Android and the web; one developer, and its legal pages name no company | Also consider: scores higher, and would be our Pick once its company is independently confirmed; one app on iPhone, Mac, Windows and Android with family accounts and a readable export | Also consider: plain-text recipe files you own, on phones and computers; you write recipes in a markup language | Also consider: a household sharing recipe books on iPhone, Android and the web, with a whole-collection export |
| Published US price | Free; optional contributions raise the daily import allowance and add image extras | Free to 50 recipes; Basic $1.99 a month (100 recipes); Standard $4.99 a month or $49.99 a year (unlimited recipes); planning and shopping lists on paid plans | Free to download (50 recipes, no sync); Premium $14.99 a year at an introductory price, 7-day trial | Free apps and editor; optional Cook Cloud sync from EUR 4.99 a month | 30 days free, then monthly, yearly or lifetime; prices shown only in the app (US store lists $0.99 a month to $59.99 lifetime) |
| A phone and one computer | $0 on any phone and computer; on iPhone it is the web app added to the home screen | Web plus the iPhone app on one account: $49.99 a year on Standard for unlimited recipes | One Premium subscription covers iPhone, Mac, Windows and Android: $14.99 a year at the introductory price; the free tier is one device and 50 recipes | $0: iPhone and Android apps and Cook Editor on Mac and Windows, with a folder you sync yourself | One purchase covers the phone apps and the web app, for up to five family members; price shown in the app |
| Devices | Web app in any browser, installable on iPhone and Android; desktop app for Windows, Mac and Linux wraps the web version | iPhone, iPad, Android and the web; no Mac or Windows app | iPhone, iPad, Mac, Android, Windows; Apple Watch app | iPhone, iPad and Android apps; Cook Editor for Mac, Windows and Linux | iPhone, iPad, Android; any computer through the web app; no Mac or Windows app |
| Free or trial limit | Everything free; a daily allowance covers clipping, imports and photo and PDF reading | Free: 50 recipes, no ads; lists and planning need a paid plan; 14-day trial of every feature | Free: 50 recipes, no sync, one grocery list and one cookbook, no time limit | Free for files, recipe-site imports, scaling, lists and meal plans; photo and social imports and sync need Cook Cloud | 30-day trial; afterwards you can view and export but not add |
| Getting recipes in | Typing, websites and a browser extension, photos, PDFs and documents, imports from many apps; social posts by screenshot or pasted text | More than 270 recipe sites, share sheet from Safari, TikTok and Instagram, photos, video, pasted text, typing; Paprika and Recipe Keeper libraries | Typing and websites through a built-in browser or share sheet; Premium adds scanning, social video and copied text | Typing and unlimited imports from recipe sites; photo and social-video imports need Cook Cloud | Typing, recipe sites and a Chrome extension, Instagram, TikTok and Facebook posts, photo and PDF scanning |
| Where recipes and scans go | On the developer’s hosted service, location not stated, with a copy cached in your browser; text, photo and PDF imports and the assistant send content to an AI provider through OpenRouter | On Recipe Shelf’s servers; photos, text, video and voice go to AI providers including OpenAI; analytics and advertising tracking named in its privacy notice | On the device and, with Premium, on Paprika’s cloud servers; analytics and crash-reporting services named in the privacy policy | Files in a folder on your own devices; batch imports from other apps pass through the maker’s converter and photo imports through an unnamed model | On Strange Quark’s servers; its 2022 privacy policy does not say where they are hosted or how scans are processed |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for price, platforms and getting recipes in
US prices read November 12, 2026, before tax: Paprika plans, release announcement and US listing; Recipe Shelf pricing, about and US listing; RecipeSage home page, contributions, install options and legal and privacy; Cook app page and pricing; Umami product, US listing, FAQ and privacy. Other countries, sales and checkout not checked.
Planning, shopping and cooking
Show 7 criteria
| Feature | RecipeSage | Recipe Shelf | Paprika | Cook | Umami |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quantities | Scaling by multiplier, target yield or one ingredient; metric/imperial conversion | Scale servings and switch units | Serving scaling and metric/US unit conversion | Scale by servings, multiplier or one ingredient; every quantity updates | Serving slider documented in the FAQ; unit conversion not documented |
| Shopping lists | Combined items grouped by aisle; lists shared with edit rights | Combined list from the week’s plan, grouped by aisle, on paid plans; one list for a party plan | Combines matching items; grouped by aisle or recipe; multiple lists with Premium; pantry | Built from recipes, grouped by aisle or recipe with your own aisle file; share or export | Recipe ingredients to shared lists, grouped by aisle or by recipe |
| Meal planning | Calendar with drag and drop and repeating items; shared with collaborators | Weekly calendar on paid plans | Day, week or month views; reusable menus; calendar feeds with Premium | Meal plans are files written in Cook Editor on a computer; the list reaches the phone | Calendar by week or month, shared with collaborators |
| Without a connection | Collection cached and searchable without a connection; lists and plans editable; read-only if the server is down | Not documented | Recipes are stored on each device | Works without an account or a connection; recipes are files on your device | Not documented |
| Household library | Separate accounts; meal plans and shopping lists shared with edit rights; recipes shared as copies or profile links | Basic and Standard share a recipe by link; a Family plan is named but its sharing is not described | Premium family accounts: each person has their own login and everyone shares one collection, grocery list and meal plan; you and five others | No household sharing documented; a folder you share yourself is the only route | Up to five family members with their own accounts on one subscription; you invite them to shared recipe books, meal plans and grocery lists |
| While viewing a recipe | Cook Mode: screen stays awake, check-off, scaling, large adjustable text | Hands-free cooking mode with timers | Cook mode that reads steps aloud and takes voice commands, timers, ingredient check-off, screen stays on | Step-by-step mode with large text and timers | Ingredient checklist and step-by-step directions |
| Other documented features | Open source; self-hosting for personal use; public Discover catalogue; kitchen converters | Party planning, collections and tags, ingredient swaps, per-serve nutrition | Pantry with expiry dates, advanced and saved searches, duplicate finder, Apple Watch app; nutrition with Premium | Open-source plain-text format, editor and command-line tools; apps free to download | Public recipe links readable without the app; tags and recipe ratings |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for planning, shopping and cooking
Documented capabilities, not observed behavior: Paprika guide; Recipe Shelf home page and US listing; RecipeSage features, release notes and sharing; Cook app page; Umami FAQ and store description. Undocumented does not mean unavailable.
Keeping a copy, leaving and open questions
Show 5 criteria
| Feature | RecipeSage | Recipe Shelf | Paprika | Cook | Umami |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Keeping an external copy | Whole collection to JSON-LD, plain text or PDF (RecipeSage documentation); meal plans not exported | An export is listed on both paid plans and survives cancelling; formats not described | Export of a cookbook, a category or everything to HTML or Paprika’s recipe format; cookbooks round-trip | Your recipes are plain-text files in your own folder | “Export all recipe books” (Umami FAQ); PDF, Markdown, HTML, plain text or Recipe JSON Schema (store listing) |
| Other apps documenting import of its export | Tandoor | None found | AnyList, Crouton, RecipeSage, Vanilla Cookbook, Recipe Shelf | None found; the files are plain text | None found |
| After you commit | Export any time; open source and self-hostable; the hosted service carries no guarantee | Export is listed and survives cancelling; terms name no company and are dated December 1, 2026 | Export any time; terms let Paprika change features; what happens above 50 recipes if a subscription ends is not documented | Files stay yours; apps and editor are free; Cook Cloud is an optional paid add-on | View and export stay available without a subscription; terms let Strange Quark end the agreement at any time |
| Announced changes and open issues | Desktop app and Cook Mode new in August 2026; meal-plan export and shared recipe editing requested, not built | Who runs it, what its export contains and how the Family plan shares are not described | Paprika 4 was released November 6, 2026; the price after the introductory year is not stated | Managing recipes inside the phone app arrived in version 0.13.0 in October 2026; the app is not yet at version 1 | Price for a new buyer not published outside the app |
| Strongest reason to choose another tool | You want native apps that keep recipes on the device, or a company standing behind the service | You want a named company, a documented export or an app with a longer record | You want everything free, or you do not want a subscription | You do not want to edit recipes in a markup language, or you need household sharing | You want recipes stored on your own device, confirmed use without a connection or a price you can see before installing |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for keeping a copy, leaving and open questions
Paprika export, family accounts and terms, terms and privacy; Recipe Shelf pricing, terms, privacy notice and listing; RecipeSage export, FAQ on hosting and self-hosting, legal and privacy and Tandoor’s RecipeSage import; Cook app page and version history; Umami backup and terms; importer documentation from AnyList, RecipeSage and Vanilla Cookbook. A documented import route is not a verified restoration.
What matters when choosing
RecipeSage is our Practical Pick for someone who wants one place to save recipes they have permission to keep, scale them, turn them into a shopping list, share plans with a household and keep a readable copy if they ever leave, without paying. It is an open-source recipe keeper that one developer, Julian Poyourow, has run since 2018. Every feature is free with no recipe cap, on any phone or computer: it works in any browser, installs to the home screen of an iPhone or Android phone, and has a desktop app that wraps the same web version. It documents scaling with unit conversion, aisle-grouped shopping lists, meal plans and shopping lists that other accounts can edit, a copy kept in your browser so it opens without a connection, and an export of the whole collection to JSON-LD, plain text or PDF. It scored 3.90 out of 5. Paprika scores higher, 4.18, and would be our Pick once an independent source confirms who stands behind it (see below); until then RecipeSage stays the Pick. RecipeSage’s lead over the next-best free option, Cook (3.75), is narrow. Its limits: one developer runs it as a hobby with no service guarantee; it is a web app only, with no App Store app; free accounts have a daily cap on imports and scans; it does not say where its servers are; and its privacy policy, updated October 8, 2026, says imports from text, photos and PDFs, and the cooking assistant, send your content to an AI service through OpenRouter. RecipeSage, export, legal and privacy, install options
Recipe Shelf is our Rising Star for someone who wants a newer app that works the same on iPhone, Android and the web. An independent developer in Sydney introduced it publicly by January 2026. It saves recipes from more than 270 sites, from the share sheet in Safari, TikTok and Instagram, from photos and from pasted text, scales servings and converts units, builds a shopping list grouped by aisle from the week’s plan, and syncs between iPhone, iPad, Android and the web. The first 50 recipes are free; unlimited recipes cost $49.99 a year on its Standard plan. It scored 2.51 out of 5, well below RecipeSage’s 3.90. It is the only newer app we found that met all our conditions, so treat it as one to watch, not as a better choice. Its main limits are that its privacy notice and terms name no company and leave the postal address blank, and say your images, text, video and voice recordings go to AI providers including OpenAI and that tracking tools are used for advertising; that it lists an export without saying what the export contains; that its paid plans share a recipe only by link, with a Family plan named but not described; and that one person runs it. Recipe Shelf, pricing, about, US listing
Paprika scores higher than RecipeSage, and would be our Practical Pick once its company is independently confirmed. Until then, consider it for someone who wants one app on an iPhone and a computer, with scaling, shopping lists, meal plans, a household that shares one collection and a readable copy if they ever leave. Hindsight Labs LLC, a company that names itself and a Honolulu, Hawaii address in Paprika’s terms, released Paprika 4 to everyone on November 6, 2026. It is free to download on iPhone, iPad, Mac, Android and Windows, and the free version keeps 50 recipes on one device. Premium, $14.99 a year at an introductory price with a 7-day trial, adds unlimited recipes, sync between devices and family accounts: each person gets their own login, everyone shares one collection, grocery list and meal plan, and a family can include you and five others. Paprika documents scaling and unit conversion, a cook mode that reads steps aloud, aisle-grouped grocery lists, a pantry and menus, and an export of any cookbook or category to browser-readable HTML or to its own recipe format, which several other apps import. Its limits sit beside that: a new buyer needs the subscription to go past 50 recipes, the guide does not say what happens to a larger collection if the subscription ends, the price after the introductory year is not stated, and Paprika 4 is days old. On our fixed criteria it scored 4.18 out of 5 against 3.90 for RecipeSage, but we have not been able to confirm the company from an independent source, which a Pick requires, so RecipeSage stays our Pick for now. Paprika’s lead is narrow: the gap shrinks to 0.21 if price counts for more. It rests on Paprika’s family accounts, which we know only from Paprika’s own guide, and on the fact that RecipeSage is free. It would reverse if Paprika charged more than about $84 a year after the introductory year, or more than about $47 if price counts for more. Paprika, Paprika 4 release, plans, guide
If you want plain-text recipe files that you own, consider Cook. Cook keeps each recipe as a text file in a folder you choose, on iPhone, Android, Mac, Windows and Linux. The apps and the editor are free, with unlimited imports from recipe sites, scaling, aisle-grouped shopping lists and step-by-step cooking; syncing and photo or video imports come with an optional Cook Cloud subscription from EUR 4.99 a month. You write recipes and meal plans in a markup language, it documents no household sharing, and one person builds it. It scored 3.75. Cook, pricing
If your household wants separate accounts on shared recipe books on iPhone, Android and the web, consider Umami. Strange Quark, a small California company, released it around 2022. One subscription, with prices shown only inside the app, covers up to five family members with their own accounts, and the FAQ documents exporting every recipe book. It scored 3.73. Its limits are a price you cannot see in advance and a collection kept on the company’s servers under a 2022 privacy policy that does not say where. Umami, FAQ, US listing
Prices are US App Store, Google Play and vendor-site prices checked November 12, 2026, before tax and without sales. We priced one reader with an iPhone and one computer over three years, using the cheapest plan that holds about 200 recipes with scaling and shopping lists. RecipeSage and Cook are free for that reader, and several options outside the chart cost less than Paprika over three years: KitchenOwl and ReciMe (free), Crouton Plus ($24.99 once) and Copy Me That ($12 a year). AnyList Complete for a household ($14.99 a year) costs about the same as Paprika. All are covered in “How we researched”. This comparison covers organizing recipes you have permission to save; it gives no nutrition, diet or food-safety advice. Five conditions would change our recommendation: native apps on every device, family accounts and a company behind the service, if you accept a subscription (consider Paprika, once its company is independently confirmed), a household that plans and shops together and wants separate logins without a subscription for each person (consider AnyList), a household on a mix of iPhones and Android phones that wants separate accounts on shared recipe books (consider Umami), recipes you can read in any text editor (consider Cook), or a newer app that is the same on iPhone, Android and the web, if you accept legal pages that name no company (consider Recipe Shelf). Whichever you choose, keep the original source, compare imported quantities and steps against it, and export a copy after any large import.
RecipeSage
Preferred Pick · every feature free, with a full export
Choose RecipeSage when you want every feature free on any phone and computer and an export of the whole collection, and you accept a web app hosted by one developer in his spare time.
Reasons to choose it
- Free with no recipe cap in any browser, phone or computer
- Whole-collection export to JSON-LD, text or PDF; open source
- Documented scaling, unit conversion and use without a connection
What to watch
- Run by one developer as a hobby, with no service guarantee
- A web app only, with no App Store app; free imports capped daily
- Imports and the assistant send content to an AI provider through OpenRouter; hosting location not stated; Paprika scores higher
RecipeSage is an open-source recipe keeper, meal planner and shopping list built and hosted by Julian Poyourow, a software developer in southern California, who says it is a hobby rather than a business. Its first release was in March 2018. It is one web app everywhere: you use it in a browser, add it to the home screen of an iPhone through Safari or of an Android phone through Chrome, or install the desktop app for Windows, Mac or Linux, which RecipeSage describes as the same web version, relying on the cloud with a fallback for when you have no connection. There is also an Android listing on Google Play; we found no App Store app. Everything is free with no recipe cap. Monthly, yearly or one-time contributions add high-resolution and multiple images per recipe and a larger daily allowance for clipping, imports and photo and PDF reading; the contribution page did not show amounts. Home page, install options, contributions, release notes
Its documented workflow is as broad as any here. Recipes come in from websites, a browser extension, photos, PDFs and other documents, and imports from Paprika, Mela, Crouton, Recipe Keeper and many other apps; Instagram and similar posts need a screenshot or pasted text, because those platforms block importers. You can scale by a multiplier, to a target yield or around one ingredient and convert between metric and imperial; shopping lists combine items and group them by aisle; meal plans have repeating items. Cook Mode keeps the screen awake. The collection is kept in your browser as well, so it stays searchable without a connection and readable if the server is down, and lists and plans can be edited without a connection. Release notes, FAQ
Read the full RecipeSage analysis and sources
Keeping a copy is well documented. Settings exports the whole collection to JSON-LD, a structured recipe format RecipeSage can import again, plain text or PDF, and Tandoor, another recipe manager, documents importing RecipeSage’s export. Meal plans are not exported; a request for that has been open since July 2026. The code is public and can be self-hosted for personal, non-commercial use, which RecipeSage’s FAQ offers as the answer if it ever stops hosting the service. Export, Tandoor import, meal-plan export request
Household sharing is partial. Each person has their own account, and you can add others as collaborators with edit rights on a meal plan or shopping list. Recipes, though, are shared one at a time or through a profile link, and the recipient gets a copy; a request for jointly edited shared recipes has been open since 2022. Choose Paprika or Umami if one shared library matters. Sharing, shared-recipe editing request
The main reason to hesitate is who runs it and where your content goes. The terms, updated October 8, 2026, provide the software “AS IS” and say contributions do not guarantee service. The privacy policy says analytics run on RecipeSage’s own Matomo server with anonymised IP addresses and that nothing is shared with third parties except where the law requires or for AI features. Those features now include creating a recipe from text, photos, PDFs or documents, nutrition fill, text and image imports and the cooking assistant, and they send what you provide to OpenRouter, which passes it to an AI provider; recipes you publish to Discover are also checked by AI services. The policy does not say where the servers are. The repository lists no security advisories, and the latest release on GitHub is version 4.1.5. Legal and privacy, security advisories, releases
Used RecipeSage? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Recipe Shelf
Rising Star · a newcomer worth watching
Why Rising Star? First public by January 2026 from an independent developer in Sydney, Recipe Shelf is the only newer app we found that passed all four of our conditions: available now on iPhone, iPad, Android and the web, shown by its own pages to do the job, and no unfixed serious flaw found, with an operator named in the App Store. It scored well below our Pick on our fixed criteria. Its trade-offs are a privacy notice and terms that name no company, an export it does not describe, sharing by link only on the plans we priced and a price of $49.99 a year for unlimited recipes. This is not our broader Ready to Rock endorsement.
Consider Recipe Shelf when you want a newer app that works the same on iPhone, Android and the web, and you accept a product run by one developer whose legal pages name no company.
Reasons to choose it
- Saves from more than 270 sites, share sheets, photos, video and pasted text
- Scales servings, converts units, builds aisle-grouped lists from a weekly plan
- Free plan keeps 50 recipes with no ads and no weekly import limits
What to watch
- Its privacy notice and terms name no company; images, text and video go to AI providers; advertising tracking is named
- An export is listed but its formats are not described; the paid plans share a recipe by link only
- One independent developer; a new product with no independent reviews
Recipe Shelf is a recipe organizer built and sold by an independent developer in Sydney; the App Store lists the seller as Rachelle Rathbone and the app says it is “Made in Sydney by an independent developer”. The developer introduced it in a Hacker News post dated January 6, 2026, writing “I’m Rachelle - I built Recipe Shelf”, and its iPhone app was updated the day before we checked. It runs on iPhone, iPad, Android and the web, and recipes sync between them; there is no Mac or Windows app, but the website works on any computer. Recipes come in from more than 270 sites, from Safari, TikTok and Instagram through the share sheet, from photos of cookbook pages, from cooking videos, from pasted text and by typing. It scales servings, switches units, plans a week on a calendar, builds an aisle-grouped shopping list from the plan, and has a hands-free cooking mode with timers. Home page, about, US listing
Choose it if you want a newer app and are willing to check its terms yourself. The free plan keeps 50 recipes with no ads and no weekly import limits. Basic costs $1.99 a month or $19.99 a year and keeps 100 recipes, with recipe sharing, export and image uploads. Standard, the plan its pricing page describes as “Plan, shop and cook”, adds unlimited recipes, advanced search and nutrition and costs $4.99 a month or $49.99 a year; planning and shopping lists are on paid plans, and every new account gets a 14-day trial of every feature. Its terms say subscriptions renew automatically and that you will be asked to agree to any price increase before it applies. Pricing, terms
Read the full Recipe Shelf analysis and sources
We read its privacy notice and terms, and they are thin. Neither names a company or a person, the notice leaves its postal address blank, and the terms carry a last-updated date of December 1, 2026, which is after the day we read them. The notice says photos, text, video and voice recordings you add may go to AI providers “including OpenAI”, that analytics and advertising tracking tools are used, and that uploaded videos are deleted right after processing and meal photos stay private to you. The only identification of who runs it is the developer’s name in the App Store listing and her Hacker News post. The pricing page and terms list an export under the paid plans, and its home page says you can still view and export recipes after you cancel, but not in which formats or how much. A Family plan is named, and the paid plans themselves share a recipe by link; how the Family plan shares is not described. Its App Store page had too few ratings to show a summary, and the one Hacker News thread about it, with seven comments, raised no complaints. We found no other independent review, and we searched only Hacker News for problems. It is a new product from one person, and we scored it on what its own pages say. Privacy notice, terms, Hacker News launch thread
Used Recipe Shelf? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Paprika
Also consider · scores higher; our Pick once its company is confirmed
Consider Paprika, which scores higher than our Pick and would be our Pick once its company is independently confirmed, when you want one subscription that covers your iPhone and computer, family accounts that give each person a login on one shared collection, and an export you can read in any browser.
Reasons to choose it
- Premium family accounts: own logins on one shared collection, grocery list and meal plan
- Export to HTML or Paprika’s recipe format; AnyList, Crouton, RecipeSage and others import it
- Scaling, unit conversion, voice cook mode, pantry and aisle-grouped lists
What to watch
- A subscription is needed past 50 recipes; the price after the introductory year is not stated
- What happens above 50 recipes if the subscription ends is not documented
- Its company is not yet confirmed by an independent source; Paprika 4 was released November 6, 2026
Paprika 4 is free to download on iPhone, iPad, Mac, Android and Windows, and one subscription covers every device. The free version keeps 50 recipes on a single device, with no sync, one grocery list and one cookbook. Premium costs $14.99 a year at an introductory price and starts with a 7-day trial. It unlocks unlimited recipes, sync, family accounts, scanning of cookbook pages, saving from social video, importing copied text, nutrition and calendar feeds. People who bought an earlier Paprika get the standard version, with unlimited recipes and sync, free, and a $9.99 a year Premium price; a new reader gets neither, so we priced Premium. Paprika 4 release, November 6, 2026, plans, US listing, home page
The everyday workflow is broad. You save recipes from websites through a built-in browser or the share sheet, or type them. Paprika scales servings and converts between metric and US units, crosses off ingredients, runs timers, and has a cook mode that reads steps aloud and takes voice commands. Grocery lists combine matching items and group them by aisle or recipe, a pantry tracks what you have, and meal plans cover a day, week or month with reusable menus. Guide: scaling, cook mode, groceries and meals
Read the full Paprika analysis and sources
Keeping a copy is the best documented here. Settings exports a chosen cookbook or category, or everything, to HTML, which any browser opens, or to Paprika’s recipe format, and a recipe format export records each recipe’s cookbook so it restores into the same cookbooks. Paprika imports its own format and several others, including Copy Me That and MacGourmet files. AnyList, Crouton, RecipeSage and Vanilla Cookbook document importing Paprika’s export, and Recipe Shelf’s store listing says it can bring a whole Paprika library across. A documented route is not proof that every field transfers, and we did not restore an export. Export guide, AnyList import, RecipeSage import, Vanilla Cookbook import
Household sharing now fits most households. A family account lets everyone in the household use the same collection with their own login, so anyone can add a recipe, check off groceries or plan the week. The owner invites and removes members, and members do not buy their own subscription. It needs Premium, and members share one whole collection rather than choosing what to share. Premium also lets you send single recipes or cookbooks to other Paprika users. Family accounts
The main reasons to hesitate are cost and continuity. Past 50 recipes a new reader pays every year, and Paprika states only the introductory price, so what you pay in the second and third year is unknown. Sync now stores your collection on Paprika’s servers, and the guide does not say what happens to a collection above 50 recipes if the subscription ends; export first and keep the export current. Paprika’s terms, last modified November 4, 2026, say updates may remove features and that the company may end the agreement if it stops supporting the software. The privacy policy of September 29, 2026 says analytics and crash-reporting services may collect information about you and your device. Paprika 4 was released six days before we checked it, so we have no record of how it behaves over time. Terms, privacy policy
Why it is not our Pick yet. RecipeSage was already our Pick, and we change a Pick only to a product whose company we can confirm independently, not only from its own pages. Paprika’s terms and privacy policy name Hindsight Labs LLC and give a Honolulu, Hawaii address, and the App Store lists the same name as seller, but the seller line comes from the company’s own enrolment. We tried the Hawaii business register and a Better Business Bureau search; neither returned a record we could read. When an independent record confirms the company, Paprika becomes our Pick, because it scores higher on the criteria we set. Apple developer listing
Used Paprika? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Cook
Also consider · plain-text recipes you own
Consider Cook when you want recipes as plain-text files in a folder you control, on phones and computers, and you are comfortable writing them in a markup language.
Reasons to choose it
- Every recipe is a plain-text file in your own folder
- Free apps and editor with unlimited imports from recipe sites
- Scales by servings or one ingredient; aisle-grouped lists; step-by-step cooking
What to watch
- You write recipes and meal plans in a markup language
- No household sharing documented; the phone app is not yet at version 1
- Photo and social imports and sync need a paid Cook Cloud plan
Cook is the recipe app and editor for Cooklang, an open recipe markup language, built and run by one person, Alexey Dubovskoy, with no investors. Every recipe is a plain-text .cook file in a folder on your device. The iPhone, iPad and Android apps are free and work without an account or a connection; Cook Editor for Mac, Windows and Linux is free and open source. The apps read the same folder you sync yourself through iCloud Drive, Dropbox, Nextcloud or Syncthing, or you can pay for Cook Cloud, which syncs between devices from EUR 4.99 a month. Apps, App Store listing, pricing
Choose it if you would rather have recipes you can open in any text editor, today and in fifty years, than a service. Imports from recipe sites are free and unlimited. The app scales any recipe up or down, by servings, a multiplier or one ingredient, builds shopping lists grouped by aisle or recipe with your own aisle file, and has a step-by-step cooking mode with large text and timers. Importing from photos, YouTube, TikTok and Instagram needs a Cook Cloud plan, with 50 of each a month on the lower one. Apps, pricing
Read the full Cook analysis and sources
The cost is effort. You write and edit recipes in a markup language, meal plans are files you write in Cook Editor on a computer, and managing recipes inside the phone app only arrived in version 0.13.0 in October 2026, so the app is not yet at version 1. It documents no household sharing beyond a folder you share yourself. Batch imports from other apps pass through the maker’s converter, and photo imports go through a vision model the pages do not name. App Store version history, pricing
Used Cook? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Umami
Also consider · a household sharing recipe books
Consider Umami when several people want their own accounts on shared recipe books across iPhone, Android and a computer browser, and you want a documented export of every recipe book.
Reasons to choose it
- Up to five family members with their own accounts on one subscription
- Exports every recipe book as PDF, Markdown, HTML, text or recipe data
- Imports from recipe sites, social posts, photos and PDFs
What to watch
- A subscription is needed to add recipes after 30 days; prices shown only in the app
- Recipes are held on a small company’s servers under a vague 2022 privacy policy
- Unit conversion and use without a connection are not documented
Umami is a recipe manager from Strange Quark, LLC, a small California company whose developer answers store reviews himself. It runs on iPhone, iPad and Android, and on any computer through the umami.recipes website; there is no Mac or Windows app. Recipes come in from typing, from recipe sites through its in-app browser or a Chrome extension, from Instagram, TikTok and Facebook posts, and from photos and PDFs. You tag them, plan meals on a calendar and build grocery lists grouped by aisle or by recipe, and the FAQ documents adjusting servings before you add a recipe to a list. The first 30 days are free. After that you need a monthly, yearly or lifetime purchase to add anything new. Umami shows its prices only inside the app; the US App Store lists purchases from $0.99 a month to $59.99 for lifetime access without saying which a new buyer will see. Product page, US listing, Google Play, FAQ
Choose it for the household model. One subscription can be shared with up to five family members, each with their own account, and they join the recipe books, meal plans and grocery lists you invite them to; sharing the subscription does not share the books by itself. The service also documents a way out: “Export all recipe books” in the app’s settings makes a personal backup, and the store listing names PDF, Markdown, HTML, plain text and Recipe JSON Schema, a structured recipe format, as export formats. Umami says that without a subscription you can still view and export the recipes you already added. We found no other recipe app that documents importing Umami’s export, and we did not export a collection. Backup and family members, export formats
Read the full Umami analysis and sources
Your collection lives on Strange Quark’s servers, not on your device. The privacy policy, last updated June 11, 2022, does not say where recipes are stored, which services host them or how photo and PDF scans are processed. The App Store privacy label lists contact details, user content, identifiers and diagnostics as linked to you and no tracking, and the Google Play listing says no data is shared with third parties. The terms let Strange Quark end the agreement “at any time, with or without notice, for any reason.” Keep a recent export. Umami does not document unit conversion, use without a connection or a desktop app. Privacy policy, terms
Used Umami? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Which product are we missing?
Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.
Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.
Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.
No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.
What people are saying
Public user reports are a check on vendor claims, not a measure of satisfaction. The sample we read is small and self-selected, and none of these reports is an independent review of a whole product.
Umami’s App Store reviews dated November 2024 and October 2025 describe changing the servings and having quantities follow, and one says imports from Paprika work. Its Google Play reviews from March to June 2026 praised importing and the shared family membership; one put the success rate for social-media recipes at about 70 percent, and another said recipes with separate parts were merged. RecipeSage’s Google Play reviews from April to August 2026 praised syncing between devices and the pace of updates; one said photo text recognition sometimes fails and uploaded photos come out blurry. Recipe Shelf’s App Store page had too few ratings to show a summary, and we read no reviews of Paprika 4, Cook or Recipe Shelf that describe using them over time. A January 2025 Google Play review of Recipe Keeper, marked helpful by 130 people, says household sharing means giving another person your account login, and a 2024 discussion objected to the cost of buying that app for several platforms. A June and July 2026 Crouton thread reported missing tags and folders after export and import, and an AnyList household discussion praised shared grocery use; we read those threads on September 6, 2026. Reddit blocked our automated check afterwards, so we could not see later replies.
Our searches for newer complaints, outages, breaches, lawsuits, regulatory actions and ownership changes involving Paprika, AnyList, Recipe Keeper, Crouton, Umami, Strange Quark and RecipeSage, run on October 19 and 20, 2026, found nothing that changed these conclusions; we did not repeat them on November 12 and ran none for Recipe Shelf or Cook beyond the pages we read. A search that finds nothing is not proof that nothing exists. We used no aggregate star rating.
How we researched
This is public-source research. We did not install apps, create accounts, sign in, buy access, import or scan recipes, connect household devices or test exports. No vendor provided access or payment for this work. We first compared these tools on September 6, 2026, rechecked the material claims on October 19 and 20, and rechecked prices, plans, platforms and Paprika’s release on November 12, 2026, from vendor sites, store listings, help and legal pages, release notes and code repositories. Reddit threads are as read on September 6.
We fixed the criteria and weights before comparing the tools: the everyday recipe workflow (25%), keeping a copy and leaving (25%), household sharing (15%), cost on the devices you use (15%) and data handling and continuity (20%). We gave AI features no weight because they are not this reader’s job. For cost we priced one reader with an iPhone and one computer over three years and about 200 recipes, using the cheapest plan that covers that, and applied the same method to every product we could price. Mela’s price was not shown on the pages we read, so it has no cost score.
Paprika scores highest at every weighting we tried except one. More weight on keeping a copy, on data handling, on household sharing or on everyday workflow keeps Paprika first; with cost at 30% of the score RecipeSage is narrowly first (4.08 against 4.07), and with household sharing at 35% Umami is second. We name RecipeSage as our Pick, not Paprika, only because a Pick needs a company confirmed by an independent source and Paprika’s is not yet (see the Paprika section). Paprika’s household score rose this month because Paprika 4 added family accounts, and its data score fell because sync is now the paid core and the guide does not say what a lapse means for a large collection.
On November 12 we searched again for newer recipe organizers, those first released since November 12, 2024, through Hacker News, GitHub, App Store and Google Play pages and the makers’ sites. Umami, our earlier Rising Star, does not qualify now: its privacy policy is dated June 11, 2022 and its App Store record shows a 2023 copyright and release 2.88 by November 2024, so it was first released before the window. Recipe Shelf met all four conditions, narrowly: it is a newcomer (first public by January 2026), it is available now on iPhone, iPad, Android and the web, its own pages show it doing the job, and we found no unfixed serious flaw. Its operator is a named individual, not an identified company, so we hold the award loosely. It is the only candidate that qualified. Koriander, a free web app launched in April 2026 that scored 3.13, names no company or person in its privacy policy or terms, so we could not identify who runs a service that holds your recipes. SayChef (2.42), a voice recipe app first posted in July 2026 at $59.99 a year, names no operator on the page we read, and we never fetched its legal pages. Cooky is free on iPhone and the web but its page describes no shopping list or meal plan. Recipe One, CookPal and ReciPath are phone apps with no computer route, Mangerate and Recipe Organizer by Vima are iPhone and iPad only, Cooksync syncs recipes to Obsidian or Notion and is not a place to keep them, and ingrdnt and Trott are extractors of recipes from social video that describe no lists or scaling. Recipe Ninja’s and GoRecipeHub’s websites did not load, so we could not check them. We never fetched pages for ReciAI, ReciBites, Kitcha, Pantree and RecipeBee, whose launch dates are unknown, so none can be a newcomer. Cook, KitchenOwl, Pestle, ReciMe and Mela were first released in 2021 or 2022, so they are too old to count as newcomers, and Mela has had no update since June 2025. Mealie and other self-hosted tools have no maker-run service, so we did not treat them as available to this reader. A publisher’s app from the owner of long-established recipe sites is an established company’s product.
We also scored established options and left them out of the chart because each scored below the four in it: Recipe Keeper (3.49 out of 5), Crouton (3.36), KitchenOwl (3.35), Copy Me That (3.29), AnyList (3.26), Plan to Eat (3.14), Tandoor’s hosted plans (3.11), Pestle (3.09), ReciMe (2.85), BigOven (2.39) and Samsung Food (2.29). Tandoor, Pestle, ReciMe, Mela
AnyList is free on iPhone and Android for shared lists and a recipe collection, with a limit of five recipe imports from websites; Complete costs $9.99 a year for one person or $14.99 for a household (we priced the household plan) and adds unlimited imports, scaling, the meal calendar and the web and Mac apps. Each household member keeps a separate login on one shared library and calendar, and a deletion by one member removes the recipe for everyone. We found no way to export the whole library. Its privacy policy was last revised in January 2021. Recipe Keeper suits someone digitizing printed or handwritten recipes on Android or Windows as well as Apple devices: Pro costs $19.99 on iPhone and iPad and $29.99 on Mac, Android and Windows prices were not shown, a household shares one login, and scanned pages go to a third-party text-recognition service that may keep them. Two other recipe managers document importing its export, but Recipe Keeper’s own pages do not describe it. Crouton suits an all-Apple household: Plus costs $24.99 once and Discover, which adds AI import, $14.99 a year; it keeps recipes on the device and in your own iCloud, shares through iCloud, cannot restore a deleted recipe, and its Mac app has an open sync and crash problem. We could not establish which plan includes household sharing or what the free plan allows. AnyList Complete, AnyList cancellation, Recipe Keeper, Recipe Keeper iPhone listing, Crouton, Crouton US listing
Copy Me That is free for 40 recipes, then $1 a month or $12 a year, lets you export, and has a household share one login; Plan to Eat costs $49 a year after a 14-day trial and exports the whole recipe book as a spreadsheet; Samsung Food is free for saving recipes but adjusting servings needs Food+ at $59.99 a year, and we found no way to export; BigOven has the largest recipe catalogue, but its App Store privacy label lists location and identifiers used for third-party advertising. Copy Me That, Plan to Eat pricing, Samsung Food listing, BigOven listing
We checked what each computer app needs to run, because an outdated built-in browser engine weakens security, and applied the same rule to every app we read in October. RecipeSage’s desktop app is built on Electron 44 and Cook Editor on an Electron 44 line, versions still receiving security updates on October 20; Umami and Recipe Shelf run in your own browser. We did not recheck what Paprika 4 for Windows needs. RecipeSage desktop package
| Tool | Public sources | What remains uncertain |
|---|---|---|
| Paprika | Home page, release announcement, plan, family-account, export and scaling guide, US App Store and Google Play listings, November 2026 terms and September 2026 privacy policy, importer documentation from AnyList, RecipeSage and Vanilla Cookbook. | The price after the introductory year; what happens above 50 recipes if the subscription ends; how Paprika 4 behaves over time; whether every field survives an export and import. |
| Recipe Shelf | Home, pricing and about pages; privacy notice and terms; US App Store listing and version history; a January 2026 Hacker News thread. | Who runs it (no company is named); what its export contains; how the Family plan shares; independent reviews and problems beyond Hacker News. |
| RecipeSage | Home page, install, contribution, legal and privacy pages; documentation on export, sharing and the FAQ; release notes; code repository, releases and security advisories; two feature requests; Google Play listing and reviews; Tandoor’s import documentation. | Where the hosted service runs; how large the free daily import allowance is; how a one-person hobby service holds up over years; whether a full export restores completely. |
| Cook | Cooklang app page, Cook pricing page and the US App Store listing with its version history. | How household sharing would work; how the unfinished phone app develops; what the photo-import model does with images; whether recipe files written in the markup language open cleanly elsewhere. |
| Umami | Product page, FAQ, June 2022 privacy policy and terms; US App Store and Google Play listings, version history and store reviews. | Current prices for new buyers; whether unit conversion and use without a connection work; where recipes are hosted and how scans are processed; whether a full export restores in another app; how a one-developer company holds up over years. |
None of this establishes import accuracy, scaling arithmetic, sync reliability, accessibility or that an export restores completely. Next substantive review is due December 18, 2026, or sooner when Paprika states its price after the introductory year or Recipe Shelf names who runs it. Found a changed price or term? Contact the editors.
Sources and evidence
Prices, plans, platforms and the Paprika 4 release were rechecked on November 12, 2026; other sources were read on the dates given, many on October 19 and 20, 2026. Vendor material establishes documented offers, features and terms, not observed product behavior. Store prices are US prices before tax; other countries differ. Importer documentation from other recipe managers shows a published import route, not a verified restoration. Community posts are attributed experiences, not representative samples. No affiliate links are used.
- Paprika (Hindsight Labs LLC; Apple developer listing): home page; release announcement, November 6, 2026; plans; user guide, one page; iPhone and iPad listing; Mac listing; Google Play listing; terms, November 4, 2026; privacy policy, September 29, 2026.
- Recipe Shelf (independent developer, Sydney; seller named in the App Store listing): home page; pricing; about; privacy notice; terms; US App Store listing and version history; Hacker News launch thread, January 6, 2026.
- RecipeSage (Julian Poyourow, Garden Grove, California, per Google Play): home page; install options; contributions; terms, privacy, sharing and refund policies, October 8, 2026; documentation on export, sharing, the FAQ and release notes; code repository, releases, security advisories, desktop package, read October 20, 2026, feature requests 2515 and 782; Google Play listing and reviews, read October 20, 2026; Tandoor import documentation.
- Cook (Alexey Dubovskoy): app page; pricing; US App Store listing and version history.
- Umami (Strange Quark, LLC; developer details on Google Play give a Sacramento, California address, read October 20, 2026): product; FAQ; privacy, June 11, 2022; terms; US App Store listing, version history and reviews; Google Play listing, data safety and reviews.
- AnyList (Purple Cover, Inc.): Free and Complete compared; Complete; cancellation; read October 19, 2026: shared recipes and meal plan, Paprika import, privacy, January 18, 2021.
- Recipe Keeper (Tudorspan Limited, Oxfordshire, England): product; iPhone and iPad listing; Mac listing; Google Play listing; read October 19, 2026: privacy, Google Play review, January 11, 2025.
- Crouton (Crouton LLC; owned by Combustion): product; US listing; read October 19, 2026: import troubleshooting, iCloud sync and recovery, privacy, April 21, 2025.
- Established apps scored but not charted: Copy Me That home page and US listing; Plan to Eat pricing; Samsung Food (Foodient Ltd) US listing; BigOven (Lakefront Software) US listing; Tandoor home page and hosted plans; Pestle plans and US listing; ReciMe home page and US listing; Mela home page; KitchenOwl, as read October 20, 2026 (its site returned an error on November 12).
- Newer apps checked for the Rising Star: Koriander (home, pricing, privacy, terms); SayChef (home); Cooky (home); Recipe One (home); CookPal (US listing); Mangerate (US listing); Cooksync (home); ReciPath (README); Hacker News searches for recipe managers, organizers and apps since November 2024; the GitHub recipe-manager topic.
- Independent importer documentation: RecipeSage imports from Paprika; Vanilla Cookbook import formats.
- Currency: euro prices converted at the European Central Bank reference rate of 1.1081 US dollars to the euro on November 12, 2026.
- Community evidence, read September 6, 2026 unless stated: Reddit Crouton export thread, June to July 2026 and AnyList household use; App Store reviews of Umami, November 2024 and October 2025.
This is a researched comparison, not a product review. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.