Private group messaging for adult friends: Signal, Threema, WhatsApp and Element
Signal keeps a friends’ group chat end-to-end encrypted for free, as long as everyone registers with a phone number. Threema Private avoids phone numbers if everyone pays, WhatsApp encrypts groups but Meta collects usage data, and Element works on every computer but keeps room details on its servers. We found no newer app that qualifies as a Rising Star.
Signal
Group messages end-to-end encrypted by default, free on phones and computers, from a service that says it keeps no record of who is in which group.
Every member registers with a phone number. Desktop needs the phone online every 30 days, and history survives a lost phone only with backups turned on.
Why Signal is our PickTeam behind Signal? Get your award badge
No Rising Star selected
We found no newer private messenger that qualifies. SimpleX Chat was first released in 2022, more than two years ago, and White Noise, a newer app with no phone number, could not be shown to have been first released within the last two years.
Newer apps we could not check fully may qualify later; this is not a claim that none does.
Who is this article for? Adults setting up a private group chat with friends or family on a mix of Android phones, iPhones and computers, who want the messages kept from the service provider. Not workplace or high-risk security advice.
About 34 min read
What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean
The quick list
Compare what each member pays, what they register with and whether the group’s messages are end-to-end encrypted.
Cost for each member, checked October 19, 2026 (WhatsApp and Element on October 20; Threema’s Google Play price on November 12), from vendor pages and US app-store listings, before tax. Signal, WhatsApp and Element are free; Threema Private is a one-time purchase per app store; Signal’s media backup is an optional subscription. Prices differ by country and store.
The comparison at a glance
Compare whether group messages are end-to-end encrypted, what members register with and pay, how computers depend on the phone and what history survives a lost phone.
Order follows our verdict for a group of adult friends, not measured security or reliability. All tools remain selectable.
Hides matching answers for the selected tools. Unknowns and unverified claims stay visible.
| Feature | Signal | Threema Private | Element | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: encrypted group chat for adult friends who accept phone registration | Also consider: everyone will buy the app and wants no phone number | Encrypted groups when everyone already uses it and accepts Meta’s data collection | Free encrypted chat on every device, if the group accepts setup and server metadata |
| Default private-group messages | End-to-end encrypted | End-to-end encrypted, with forward secrecy on phones | End-to-end encrypted with the Signal protocol, per WhatsApp | End-to-end encrypted by default, per Element; server admins can turn the default off |
| Registration identifier | Phone number; a username lets others contact you without it | Random Threema ID; phone and email optional | Phone number; usernames rolling out since June 2026 hide it from non-contacts | Username on a chosen server; email optional on matrix.org |
| Cost for each member | Free; optional media backup $1.99/month | One-time purchase per app store: $6.99 App Store, $7.49 Google Play (US) | Free | Free app and matrix.org account |
| Using a computer | Desktop app needs the phone online at least every 30 days | Stable desktop needs the phone online; 2.0 beta works independently, with limits | Windows, Mac and web work without the phone online; phone must be used every 14 days | Desktop and web apps work on their own; each new device should be verified |
| History on a new phone | Opt-in Secure Backups restore text and 45 days of media with a recovery key | Threema Safe restores ID, contacts and groups, not chats; data backup on the same OS | Cloud backup, end-to-end encrypted if you set a passkey, password or 64-digit key | Encrypted history stays on the server; a new device reads it after verification or with a 48-character recovery key |
| Readable archive | No readable chat export found in Signal’s documentation | Encrypted ZIP per chat; cannot be imported again | Text export per chat; cannot be imported again | HTML chat export in the web and desktop apps |
| 2026 security record | FBI/CISA: phishing for verification codes and backup recovery keys; app encryption not broken | August DDoS outage, no data breach reported; ownership changed in January | Zero-click takeovers of iPhones left on iOS 16 (2025 flaws, patched); lawsuit alleging staff access dismissed | Several High-severity advisories in 2026 for its web app, iPhone app and encryption library |
Ordinary adult friends using a private group across phones and computers, not workplace or high-risk use. Signal, Threema, WhatsApp and Element checked October 19 and 20, 2026, with Threema’s Google Play price and Signal’s backup page rechecked November 12; next review December 18, 2026, or sooner after a material change. Unknown means unresolved, not absent. Prices are US store listings or vendor pages and exclude taxes. Order follows our verdict for this group, not measured security, delivery or reliability.
All features and sources 20 criteria
Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.
Joining and using the group
Show 10 criteria
| Feature | Signal | Threema Private | Element | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: encrypted group chat for adult friends who accept phone registration | Also consider: everyone will buy the app and wants no phone number | Encrypted groups when everyone already uses it and accepts Meta’s data collection | Free encrypted chat on every device, if the group accepts setup and server metadata |
| Default private-group messages | End-to-end encrypted | End-to-end encrypted, with forward secrecy on phones | End-to-end encrypted with the Signal protocol, per WhatsApp | End-to-end encrypted by default, per Element; server admins can turn the default off |
| Registration identifier | Phone number; a username lets others contact you without it | Random Threema ID; phone and email optional | Phone number; usernames rolling out since June 2026 hide it from non-contacts | Username on a chosen server; email optional on matrix.org |
| Cost for each member | Free; optional media backup $1.99/month | One-time purchase per app store: $6.99 App Store, $7.49 Google Play (US) | Free | Free app and matrix.org account |
| Phones and computers | Android, iPhone, iPad; Windows, Mac, Linux desktop | Android, iPhone; Windows, Mac, Linux desktop and web | Android, iPhone, iPad, Android tablets; Windows and Mac apps, web | Android, iPhone; Windows, Mac, Linux desktop and web |
| Using a computer | Desktop app needs the phone online at least every 30 days | Stable desktop needs the phone online; 2.0 beta works independently, with limits | Windows, Mac and web work without the phone online; phone must be used every 14 days | Desktop and web apps work on their own; each new device should be verified |
| Linked devices | Up to 5; unlinked after 45 days inactive; may include a second Android phone or iPhone | 2.0 beta: one phone plus up to two computers; no messages from before linking | Up to 4; disconnected after 30 days inactive | No limit stated; Element plans to shut unverified devices out of encrypted chats |
| What the service records about groups | No record of memberships, titles or avatars, per Signal | Servers do not know group composition, per Threema | Not documented in the pages we read; collects usage and interaction data and shares it with Meta companies | Room names, topics and memberships in plain text on servers, per Element; copied to members’ servers |
| Documented group size | 1,000 | 256 | 1,024 | Not checked here |
| Group controls | Link or QR invite, admin approval, member removal, who may send or edit | Groups managed on members’ devices; creator handover not established here | Admin permissions, resettable invite links; anyone with a link can join | Invite-only or link rooms, power levels, admins choose whether new members see history |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for joining and using the group
Checked October 19, 2026: Signal download, terms and privacy, usernames, groups and linked devices, the help pages read through Signal’s public help-center interface; Threema FAQ, desktop beta, app privacy, cryptography whitepaper, June 26, 2026, pricing, App Store and Google Play, price rechecked November 12, 2026. Checked October 20, 2026: WhatsApp linked devices, groups, group safety, privacy policy and usernames, BleepingComputer, June 29, 2026; Element help, downloads, device verification, updated September 2026 and room metadata, September 30, 2025. Store prices are US listings and can differ by country.
History, recovery and payment
Show 6 criteria
| Feature | Signal | Threema Private | Element | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| History on a new phone | Opt-in Secure Backups restore text and 45 days of media with a recovery key | Threema Safe restores ID, contacts and groups, not chats; data backup on the same OS | Cloud backup, end-to-end encrypted if you set a passkey, password or 64-digit key | Encrypted history stays on the server; a new device reads it after verification or with a 48-character recovery key |
| Readable archive | No readable chat export found in Signal’s documentation | Encrypted ZIP per chat; cannot be imported again | Text export per chat; cannot be imported again | HTML chat export in the web and desktop apps |
| File-size limit | Not stated in Signal’s documentation | 100 MB | Not checked here | Not checked here |
| Inactive accounts and devices | Linked devices unlink after 45 days; phone must check in every 30 days | Beta desktop: open each device weekly, per Threema | Linked devices log out if the phone is unused for over 14 days | Not checked here |
| Switching phone platform | Device-to-device transfer does not cover Android to iPhone; Secure Backups cross-platform not established | Buy again; chats and media cannot move to another OS | Android to a new or reset iPhone with Apple’s Move to iOS, group chats included | History follows the account; verify the new device or use the recovery key |
| Paid cancellation | Cancel the backup subscription in the app store; deleting the backup is separate | Nothing recurring; shop purchases generally nonrefundable | Nothing to cancel | Nothing to cancel on a free account |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for history, recovery and payment
Signal Secure Backups, edited October 4, 2026, backup and transfer and linked devices; Threema FAQ and shop terms; WhatsApp encrypted backup, Android to iPhone, export and linked devices; Element key storage and recovery and history sharing, May 13, 2026. Backup, cloud sync and readable export are different jobs. Documentation does not show that any restore, migration or export is complete.
Encryption evidence, security record and ownership
Show 4 criteria
| Feature | Signal | Threema Private | Element | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Encryption design and outside review | Signal Protocol, published; academic formal analysis (2016); post-quantum ratchet added October 2025 | Published whitepaper; ETH Zurich found weaknesses in 2023, vendor says addressed; Ibex forward secrecy | Signal protocol, per WhatsApp; its encryption design was not assessed for this comparison | Published Matrix encryption; sender-spoofing flaws in its encryption library disclosed in 2025 and 2026 |
| 2026 security record | FBI/CISA: phishing for verification codes and backup recovery keys; app encryption not broken | August DDoS outage, no data breach reported; ownership changed in January | Zero-click takeovers of iPhones left on iOS 16 (2025 flaws, patched); lawsuit alleging staff access dismissed | Several High-severity advisories in 2026 for its web app, iPhone app and encryption library |
| Operator and ownership | Signal Messenger, LLC; nonprofit Signal Technology Foundation | Threema AG, Switzerland; owned by Comitis Capital since early 2026 | WhatsApp LLC, part of Meta Platforms | Apps by Element (UK); matrix.org server run by the Matrix.org Foundation C.I.C. |
| Content access by the provider | Cannot decrypt messages, per its terms | Cannot read messages between Private users, per its policy; Broadcast IDs excepted | Cannot read personal messages, per WhatsApp; usage data shared with Meta companies | Cannot read encrypted messages, per Element; matrix.org logs IP addresses for up to 180 days |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for encryption evidence, security record and ownership
Signal legal, protocol documentation, private group system, post-quantum ratchet, October 2, 2025, formal analysis and FBI/CISA advisory, June 26, 2026; Threema whitepaper, ETH Zurich summary, Threema response, August 2026 outage and ownership; WhatsApp encryption, privacy policy, iOS 16 takeovers, Security Affairs, May 25, 2026 and lawsuit, CyberInsider; Element web, iPhone, Android and encryption library advisories and matrix.org privacy notice. Published designs and past reviews are not a current audit of the apps.
What matters when choosing
Signal is our Practical Pick for a small group of adult friends who want their group messages end-to-end encrypted and are each willing to register with a phone number. It is free on Android, iPhone and iPad, with desktop apps for Windows, Mac and Linux. Group messages are end-to-end encrypted by default, Signal says its service keeps no record of group memberships, titles or avatars, and its protocol is published and has been studied by outside cryptographers. The compromises are specific: everyone registers with a phone number, the desktop app depends on the phone coming online at least every 30 days, and old messages come back on a new phone only if the member turned on Signal’s optional backup beforehand and kept its recovery key. Terms and privacy, groups, linked devices, Secure Backups
We selected no Rising Star. SimpleX Chat, first released in January 2022, is older than our two-year limit for newcomers. White Noise, a free app for iPhone and Android with no phone number, email address or real name and MLS group encryption, is the strongest newer app we found, but the pages we read do not show when it was first released, and it also has no computer app or backup. Both are described under How we researched. White Noise home page, SimpleX Chat first release, January 12, 2022
If some members will not give a phone number, look at Threema Private. Its group messages are also end-to-end encrypted, and a Threema ID needs no phone number or email address. Everyone has to buy the app once, $6.99 on the US App Store (October 19, 2026) or $7.49 on Google Play (November 12, 2026), and buy it again after switching between Android and iPhone. Its stable desktop app needs the phone online, and the newer desktop app that works on its own is still a beta without forward secrecy. WhatsApp also end-to-end encrypts group messages and has the most complete backup and phone-switching tools here, but Meta collects usage data and shares it with its other companies; it suits a group that already uses it. Element, free and the strongest end-to-end encrypted app here on computers, keeps room names and memberships on its servers in plain text. Telegram is a different kind of choice. Its private groups are Cloud Chats, encrypted between each device and Telegram’s servers but not end to end, and its privacy policy lets it analyse cloud-chat messages to stop spam. That fails this article’s main requirement, although Telegram remains the easiest messenger we looked at for long searchable history, very large groups and use in a browser; it is described under How we researched. Threema FAQ, Threema pricing, App Store listing, Google Play listing, WhatsApp encryption, WhatsApp privacy policy, Element room metadata, Telegram FAQ, Telegram privacy policy
Encryption protects messages on their way between members’ devices. It does not stop a member from forwarding a message, photographing a screen or leaving an export on a shared computer, and it does not protect an account whose owner hands over a code. In 2026 the FBI and CISA warned that Russian intelligence officers were posing as messaging-app support to collect verification codes, PINs and, in a June update with sample messages impersonating Signal, backup recovery keys from officials, journalists and other high-value targets; the advisory says the apps’ encryption was not broken. Agree as a group that nobody shares a code, PIN or recovery key in a chat, whoever seems to be asking. FBI and CISA advisory, June 26, 2026
This comparison is for ordinary adults coordinating privately, for example eight friends arranging a regular games evening, some on phones and some on computers. It is not advice for workplaces, minors or people facing targeted surveillance. Prices are US store listings or vendor pages checked October 19 and 20, 2026 (Threema’s Google Play price on November 12), before taxes. Two conditions would change our recommendation: members who will not register a phone number (choose Threema Private if all will buy it, White Noise if everyone is on a phone and accepts having no backup, or SimpleX Chat if everyone will keep their own backups) or a group that values cloud history and browser access more than end-to-end encryption (Telegram). Whatever you choose, decide early who keeps a copy of anything the group cannot afford to lose.
Signal
Preferred Pick · encrypted group chat for adult friends
Choose Signal when every member will register with a phone number and you want the group’s messages end-to-end encrypted by default, free, on phones and computers. Ask members to turn on Secure Backups and never share the recovery key.
Reasons to choose it
- Group messages end-to-end encrypted by default
- Free on Android, iPhone, iPad, Windows, Mac and Linux
- Signal says its service keeps no record of group memberships or titles
What to watch
- Every member registers with a phone number
- Desktop needs the phone online at least every 30 days
- A lost phone keeps its history only if backups were on and the key was kept
Signal is free and its group chats are end-to-end encrypted without any setting to change. Signal’s terms say it cannot decrypt the content of messages or calls and that it queues end-to-end encrypted messages on its servers for delivery to devices that are temporarily offline. For a group, it documents invitations by link or QR code, optional administrator approval for people joining by link, removing members, and control over who may send messages, start calls or edit the group’s details, for up to 1,000 members. Signal says its service has no record of group memberships, titles, avatars or other attributes, a design it described in December 2019 alongside a paper later presented at the ACM CCS 2020 security conference. Terms and privacy, group chats, private group system, paper
The encryption evidence is stronger than a marketing claim but is not an audit of today’s apps. The Signal Protocol is publicly documented, and academic researchers published a formal security analysis of it in 2016. In October 2025 Signal added a post-quantum ratchet that it designed with formal-verification specialists from Cryspen, who worked alongside Signal rather than as independent auditors. The reason to choose another app is the phone number: every member registers with one, and the desktop app depends on that phone. Protocol documentation, formal analysis, post-quantum ratchet, October 2, 2025
Read the full Signal analysis and sources
Phone numbers and usernames
Signal’s terms require a phone number to register, and verification codes come from Signal or third-party providers. A username lets someone start a chat without being given your number. By default, people who already know your number can find you on Signal, but your number is not shown on your profile unless they have it saved. You can stop people finding you by number, which Signal warns makes the app harder for friends to use. None of this makes an account anonymous. Terms, phone-number privacy and usernames
Computers and linked devices
The desktop app needs Signal installed on a phone first. Up to five devices can be linked to the phone; Signal’s help page, edited September 15, 2026, lists computers, iPads, iPhones and Android phones or tablets. The phone must come online at least every 30 days or its linked devices are unlinked, and a linked device is also unlinked after 45 days without use. Linking can copy all chats and the last 45 days of media, and only the registered phone can link a device again. A member who wants to use only a laptop for months should know about the 30-day check-in. Download, linked devices
Turn on backups before a phone is lost
Secure Backups are opt-in. The free tier includes all text messages and the last 45 days of media; a paid tier, $1.99 a month on Signal’s English help page, stores up to 100 GB of media. The archive is end-to-end encrypted with a 64-character recovery key that Signal says never leaves your device, so without it nobody, Signal included, can restore the backup. View-once messages and messages due to disappear within 24 hours are left out, and backups cannot be merged. Cancelling the paid subscription in Google Play or the App Store is a separate step from turning the backup off and deleting it. Signal’s older transfer page still lists a lost phone and a switch between Android and iPhone as cases it cannot restore; we read that as applying when no Secure Backup exists, and we did not establish whether a backup made on one platform restores on the other. Secure Backups, edited October 4, 2026, backup and transfer
The recovery key is now a target. The June 2026 FBI and CISA update describes fake support messages telling targets to enable backups and paste the recovery key into the chat. With it, the attackers could read the account’s past individual and group messages and take the account over, and the old key still works against a new account on the same number until a new key is generated in Settings. Generating a new key does not undo a backup already downloaded. FBI and CISA advisory, June 26, 2026
What we could not establish
Signal’s documentation does not describe a readable chat export or state a file-size limit, so the chart marks both as not documented rather than missing. Its combined terms and privacy page is still dated May 25, 2018. It describes limited technical data, optional contact discovery and lawful disclosures, and states that Signal does not sell, rent or monetize personal data. That is a published commitment, not something we audited. The page names Signal Messenger, LLC and describes Signal as a 501(c)(3) nonprofit. Terms and privacy
Used Signal? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Threema Private
Also consider · no phone number needed
Choose Threema Private when some members will not register a phone number and all of them will buy the app. Use the stable desktop app unless everyone accepts the beta’s limits.
Reasons to choose it
- No phone number or email required
- Group messages end-to-end encrypted, with forward secrecy on phones
- One purchase, no subscription
What to watch
- Every member pays, and pays again to switch between Android and iPhone
- Stable desktop needs the phone online; the independent desktop app is a beta
- Chats cannot move to another phone platform
Threema Private is sold for private use, for a one-time price that depends on the store and country. Threema’s own pricing page shows USD 6.00 and says the price depends on the app store and country; the US listings showed $6.99 on the App Store on October 19 and $7.49 on Google Play on November 12, 2026. Threema says there are no recurring charges, but licences cannot move between app stores, so a member who switches between Android and iPhone pays again, and chats and media cannot be moved to the other system. An organiser can give the app: Android licence keys from the Threema Shop, or an App Store gift on iPhone. Phone number and email are optional, and the app identifies each person by a random Threema ID. Pricing, FAQ, App Store listing, Google Play listing, app privacy policy
Threema’s app policy says messages, media and calls between Private users are end-to-end encrypted and that it cannot access their content; messages to special Broadcast IDs are the stated exception. Its cryptography whitepaper, dated June 26, 2026, says group messages are encrypted separately for each member, its servers do not know which groups exist, and its Ibex forward-secrecy protocol now also protects group messages, except when the multi-device feature is on. ETH Zurich researchers published attacks on Threema’s earlier protocol in January 2023, and Threema said the issues had been addressed. Those are dated findings and a vendor response, not a current audit. App privacy policy, extended policy, cryptography whitepaper, ETH Zurich summary, Threema response
Read the full Threema Private analysis and sources
Stable desktop or beta
The stable desktop app and web client act as an extension of the phone and need it connected. Threema 2.0 for desktop, still a beta, works without the phone online and supports one phone plus up to two Windows, Mac or Linux computers. Threema lists its limits: the phone app must stay installed, each device should be opened online about once a week, messages from before linking do not appear, forward secrecy is not supported in the beta, full customer support is not offered for it, and it is available only in English and German. We would not offer the beta to a member who expects the stable app’s protections without discussing those points. Desktop beta, FAQ, whitepaper, multi-device limits
Backups and exports are separate
Threema Safe backs up a member’s ID, contacts, group memberships and settings, not chats or media. To keep conversations, use a data backup or export a chat. An export is an encrypted ZIP with the chat as text and optional media, and it cannot be imported back into Threema. Files are limited to 100 MB. We did not establish how group administration passes to someone else if the creator leaves. FAQ
Purchase terms, data handling and ownership
The Threema Shop’s terms say prices are set in Swiss francs including any VAT, paid services are generally non-refundable, and the software is licensed, not sold; app-store purchases follow each store’s rules. The app policy lists push tokens kept for 180 days, temporary IP-address processing, purchase receipts kept for 30 days without a link to the ID, and optional phone or email stored only in one-way encrypted form. Phone verification uses Swiss providers, or Twilio for users outside Switzerland and the EU, and group calls pass IP addresses through a Dutch hosting provider. Shop terms, app privacy policy
Ownership changed at the start of 2026, when Afinum sold Threema to the German investment firm Comitis Capital. Threema says its management, headquarters and servers remain in Switzerland and that Swiss law primarily governs Threema AG’s service. In mid-August 2026, DDoS attacks made Threema unavailable for four hours one evening and caused brief interruptions the next morning, according to its August 14 report. Threema added upstream filtering and promised an incident history on its status page. An outage is not a data breach, and Threema’s report describes none. Ownership, outage report
Used Threema Private? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Encrypted groups everyone may already use · run by Meta
Consider WhatsApp when the whole group already uses it and accepts that Meta collects usage data. Group messages are end-to-end encrypted, and so are backups if each member sets a backup passkey, password or key.
Reasons to choose it
- Group messages end-to-end encrypted by default
- Free; Windows and Mac apps and the web work without the phone online
- Documented Android-to-iPhone transfer and a readable chat export
What to watch
- Every member registers with a phone number
- Meta collects usage and interaction data and shares it with its other companies
- Backups to a Google account are end-to-end encrypted only if turned on
WhatsApp, owned by Meta, is free on Android and iPhone, with apps for iPad, Android tablets, Windows and Mac and a web version. WhatsApp says it protects personal messages, including in groups, with end-to-end encryption based on the Signal protocol, so that nobody outside the chat, WhatsApp included, can read them. Groups hold up to 1,024 members. Admins set permissions and can reset invite links, and WhatsApp warns that anyone with a group link can join and pass it on. Every member registers with a phone number. Usernames, which hide the number from people who have not saved it, opened for reservation on June 29, 2026 and are reaching countries gradually. End-to-end encryption, keeping groups safe, groups, linked devices, usernames, BleepingComputer, June 29, 2026
WhatsApp has the most complete history tools here. Backups go to the cloud and are end-to-end encrypted when a member protects them with a passkey, password or 64-digit key; for backups to a Google account that is optional. WhatsApp is also testing its own backup storage, which it says is always end-to-end encrypted. Chats, group chats included, move from Android to a new or reset iPhone with Apple’s Move to iOS app, and a chat can be exported as text, though not imported again. Up to four linked devices work without the phone online, but they log out if the phone goes unused for more than 14 days. Encrypted backup, Android to iPhone, export, linked devices
Read the full WhatsApp analysis and sources
Why it is not our pick
The difference from Signal is what the service learns. WhatsApp’s privacy policy, in the version we were served (effective January 4, 2021), says it collects usage and log information, including how members interact with others and the time, frequency and duration of those interactions. It shares information with other Meta companies. Signal documents a group system that keeps memberships off its servers; we found no comparable WhatsApp document. In January 2026 users from several countries sued Meta, claiming its staff could read messages. Meta called the claim fiction, and CyberInsider reports that a judge dismissed the case because the plaintiffs had not supplied enough facts. In 2026 criminals took over WhatsApp accounts on iPhones still running iOS 16 by combining an Apple flaw and a WhatsApp flaw, both fixed in 2025. Keeping phones updated is the defence. Privacy policy, lawsuit, CyberInsider, iOS 16 takeovers, Security Affairs, May 25, 2026
Used WhatsApp? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Element
Free on every device · servers keep room metadata
Consider Element when members want full use on computers and synced encrypted history without a phone number, and someone in the group will look after device verification and recovery keys. Accept that the servers see room names and memberships.
Reasons to choose it
- End-to-end encrypted by default, per Element
- Desktop and web apps work without a phone
- Encrypted history reaches new devices after verification or with a recovery key
What to watch
- Room names, topics and memberships stored in plain text on servers
- Several High-severity security advisories in 2026
- Lose every device and the recovery key, and old messages cannot be decrypted
Element is a free messaging app built on Matrix, an open network of independently run servers. Most people sign up on matrix.org, which the Matrix.org Foundation, a UK community interest company, runs. An account needs a username; an email address is optional on matrix.org, and phone numbers are no longer accepted. Element says it provides end-to-end encryption by default, and its help adds that messages are encrypted only in rooms with encryption turned on. Apps run on iPhone and Android, where Element X is the current app and the older Element app is still offered, and on Windows, Mac, Linux and the web; the desktop and web apps work without a phone. Encrypted history stays on the server, so a new device can read it once it is verified, or once the member enters a 48-character recovery key. Since May 2026 a room admin can also let new members read earlier messages. Help, downloads, device verification, updated September 2026, history sharing, May 13, 2026, matrix.org privacy notice
The trade-off is what the servers keep and a busy security record. Element says a room’s name, topic and other details are stored on the server in plain text, unlike its messages. The matrix.org privacy notice says the server records room memberships, logs IP addresses for up to 180 days, and copies usernames, display names and messages to the servers of other members. Element and the Matrix project published several High-severity advisories in 2025 and 2026. They include flaws that let a server administrator, or another sender, disguise who sent an encrypted message, and, on October 16, 2026, a web-app flaw that a malicious link could use to log a member out and lose the encryption keys kept in the browser. Element also plans to shut devices that were never verified out of encrypted chats; the date has been postponed, and Element promises a month’s notice. Room metadata, September 30, 2025, web advisories, iPhone app advisories, encryption library advisories
Used Element? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Which product are we missing?
Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.
Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.
Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.
No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.
What people are saying
User reports and incident records test vendor claims; they are not failure rates. An August 2024 report on Telegram’s bug tracker describes an HTML export of an old supergroup that missed messages the JSON export included. It concerns one version and group, so check any export before relying on it. We read no user reviews of White Noise. Report
Signal’s account of the 2022 Twilio incident says registration details for about 1,900 users were potentially exposed and one user reported that their account was re-registered, without exposure of message history. Twilio separately documented the employee-phishing attack behind it. Like the 2026 FBI and CISA warnings, it shows account takeover through codes and providers rather than broken message encryption. Signal account, Twilio report, FBI and CISA advisory
ETH Zurich’s January 2023 Threema findings and Threema’s response are described in the Threema analysis, as is its August 2026 outage. Australia’s eSafety Commissioner began civil-penalty proceedings against Telegram in July 2026 over alleged failures to remove terrorist material; when we read the court register on September 6 the case was before the court, and its pages did not load for our check on October 19. These are allegations about moderation, not a judgment or a finding about private-group encryption. Our October 19 search for newer incidents, regulatory actions and lawsuits found nothing that changed these conclusions; a search that finds nothing is not proof that nothing exists. eSafety release, July 30, 2026, case register
How we researched
This is public-source research. We did not create accounts, install apps, buy licences, send messages, link devices, make backups or test exports. No vendor supplied access or payment. We first compared these apps on September 6, 2026 and rechecked the material claims on October 19, 2026: encryption of group messages, registration, prices, desktop dependence, backup and export, policies, ownership and incidents. Signal’s help pages did not load for automated requests, so we read the same articles through Signal’s public help-center interface, which also shows when each was last edited. Australia’s eSafety pages timed out, so their content is as read on September 6. On October 20, 2026 we added SimpleX Chat, WhatsApp and Element from their own documentation, app-store listings, code repositories, a company register, security disclosures and press reports. On November 12, 2026 we rechecked what each app costs, Signal’s backup plans, Threema’s price and Element’s security advisories, searched again for newer apps and added White Noise from its own pages, release notes and code repository. WhatsApp’s website and security advisories page would not load for our check that day, so its record is as read on October 20.
The original comparison covered three apps: a free end-to-end encrypted messenger, a paid messenger that needs no phone number, and a large cloud-based messenger. We set one threshold, default end-to-end encryption for group messages, then weighed group privacy, how easily every member can join, use on computers, history and recovery, and the security and ownership record. We fixed those criteria and their weights before comparing the apps. What each member pays counts inside the joining criterion: every app here is free except Threema Private, a one-time purchase for each member, and because only one app costs anything we could not place that price against a market price, so we do not give Threema Private a single total. Telegram scored well on convenience but does not meet the threshold. Requiring that no member gives a phone number would leave Threema Private, Element, SimpleX Chat and White Noise; giving more weight to computers and history narrows the gap to Telegram but does not overcome the threshold. On those fixed weights, out of 5, Signal scored 4.17, WhatsApp 3.79, Element 3.72, SimpleX Chat 3.58, Telegram 3.42 and White Noise 3.13. Threema Private ranks between second and fourth depending on how its one-time price is weighed, ahead of SimpleX Chat either way.
On October 20 we added WhatsApp, the most widely used end-to-end encrypted messenger, under the same weights. It meets the threshold, is free and has the strongest backup and phone-switching tools here, but scored below Signal on privacy, because Meta collects usage and interaction data, and on its security record. Signal’s lead over WhatsApp, 0.38, is larger than one step on our heaviest criterion, so we do not call it narrow. We also added Element, which meets the threshold and is the strongest encrypted option here on computers, but scored lower on privacy, because its servers keep room names, topics and memberships in plain text, and on its security record. We set aside Apple’s iMessage because Android members cannot use it, Discord because it does not end-to-end encrypt text messages, and texting over RCS between Android and iPhone because its end-to-end encryption began only as a carrier-dependent beta in May 2026, with group chats not described. We could not confirm that Facebook Messenger end-to-end encrypts group chats by default, so we did not score it.
We searched for new entrants on October 19 and 20, 2026 and again on November 12 through Hacker News searches limited to the last two years, GitHub topic pages, Privacy Guides’ messenger list, app-store listings, code repositories and each app’s own pages. We count an app as a newcomer only if its first public release, a public alpha or beta included, was within the last two years, which on November 12, 2026 means November 12, 2024 or later. SimpleX Chat, first released on January 12, 2022, no longer qualifies. White Noise is the strongest app that otherwise qualifies, but an app with no dated first release cannot be a newcomer, and we could not date it, so we selected no Rising Star. No other newer app we checked cleared our requirements either, as the paragraphs below explain. This is a bounded search, not a claim that no qualifying newcomer exists.
SimpleX Chat. SimpleX Chat is a free messenger from SimpleX Chat Ltd, a London company. Its first public release was on January 12, 2022, with earlier versions in 2021, so it is older than our two-year limit and cannot be our Rising Star; it scored 3.58 on the fixed weights, fifth. It remains the only app here that gives a mixed group end-to-end encrypted chat with no phone number, email address, username or account, free on Android, iPhone and computers. Each message is sent separately to every member, which SimpleX says suits smaller groups, and its relays keep no user profiles and delete messages on delivery or after 21 days. Trail of Bits reviewed its cryptography code in 2022 and its protocol design in 2024. The limits: there is no automatic backup, so a member who loses a phone without exporting first loses every chat and group; a computer runs a separate profile or uses the phone’s only on the same local network; a critical flaw in its command-line version, a separate text-only program, took about two months to fix, and the researchers do not report it in the phone or desktop apps; attackers took over its official X account for about three hours in December 2025; and the pages we read do not say how SimpleX Chat Ltd relates to SimpleX Chat, Inc., which began equity crowdfunding in 2026. Its App Store listing showed 281 ratings on November 12. Choose it, instead of Threema Private or White Noise, if everyone will keep their own backups and some members use computers. Privacy policy and conditions, first release, January 12, 2022, Wikipedia, design review, 2024, command-line flaw disclosure, May 10, 2026, linking phone and desktop, managing data, releases, App Store listing
Telegram. Telegram’s FAQ says Cloud Chats, which include private and group chats, use server-client encryption, while its end-to-end encrypted Secret Chats are one-to-one conversations tied to one device, so a private group cannot be end-to-end encrypted and Telegram does not meet our main requirement; it scored 3.42. Its privacy policy, updated August 21, 2026, says it stores cloud-chat messages and files on its servers, may use automated algorithms on cloud-chat messages to stop spam and phishing, and may disclose a suspect’s IP address and phone number after a valid judicial order. What it offers instead is convenience: free use, history synchronised across phones, computers and a browser, search, groups of up to 200,000 members, files of up to 2 GB, and desktop export to HTML or JSON. Premium is optional, its price varies by country and store, and it is cancelled with the provider you paid. Accounts are deleted after 18 months offline by default. Choose Telegram only if the group values cloud history and browser access more than end-to-end encryption. Researchers reported weaknesses in its MTProto encryption in 2021, which Telegram fixed. Australia’s eSafety Commissioner began civil-penalty proceedings in July 2026 over alleged moderation failures; that is an allegation, not a finding about group encryption. FAQ, privacy policy, terms, Premium FAQ, export announcement, 2018, MTProto analysis, eSafety release, July 30, 2026
White Noise. White Noise is a free, open-source messenger supported by the Internet Privacy Foundation, a nonprofit, together with OpenSats, the Human Rights Foundation and And Other Stuff. It is on the App Store for iPhone and on Android through Zapstore, Google Play or GitHub, and asks for no phone number, email address or real name; members connect by exchanging a profile link, a QR code or a public key. Group messages are end-to-end encrypted with MLS, an open internet standard built for group chat, on top of the open Marmot protocol. Independent relay servers on the Nostr network carry the encrypted messages and can see connection details such as IP addresses, media servers hold encrypted media, and the app’s code is published, so its encryption claims can be checked. Admins add and remove group members. The limits: there is no computer app, though its repository notes mention Mac and Linux versions in development; using one identity on a second device is not supported yet; and the key alone is not a backup of message history, so we expect a member who loses a phone to lose the chats. Version 0.3.0, released on February 23, 2026, deleted all local data on upgrade, and a March 23 release fixed unreliable message delivery for members who followed many accounts. The first app’s repository was archived on October 12, 2026 after development moved to separate iPhone, Android, Mac and Linux repositories, which we did not read, and its makers call White Noise a work in progress. Least Authority completed an audit of its Rust backend in April 2026: ten issues, four medium and six low, all listed as resolved at its March 31 verification review. Earlier reviews of the protocol and of the MDK library were not read; search results reported that the MDK review found, among other things, missing admin-authorization checks, and we did not establish whether they were fixed. White Noise scored 3.13 on our fixed weights, behind Signal’s 4.17 mainly on computers and history. We could not select it as Rising Star because no page we read dates its first public release: the earliest date we found is version 0.3.0 on February 23, 2026, whose notes refer to earlier versions. If that release was on or after November 12, 2024, it would qualify. Practical Picks is researched and written with Claude; White Noise advertises connectors that let AI agents, including Anthropic’s Claude Code, join a chat, and we gave that feature no weight. Home page, frequently asked questions, download page, version 0.3.0 notes, March 23 release notes, repository notes, backend repository, Least Authority audit post, April 7, 2026, final audit report, April 1, 2026, security advisories page
Convos. Convos, from XMTP Labs, was first released in September 2025 and is free on iPhone, iPad and Android. Every chat is a group chat with an AI agent in it, which the group can set to listen, chat or pause. Its Google Play listing says it is secured by XMTP, but no page we read says its group messages are end-to-end encrypted by default or publishes how its encryption works, so we did not consider it for Rising Star. It has no computer app and would have scored 2.98 on our fixed weights. App Store listing, Google Play listing
Keet. Keet is a peer-to-peer messenger with no company server. A Hacker News post about it is dated January 2024, so it is older than our two-year limit, and its security page still publishes neither a design for the encryption of group rooms nor an audit, so we could not check its encryption claims. Keet security FAQ
Radar. Radar, launched in July 2026 by the Cake Wallet team, is a Signal-based app for iPhone and Android built around Bitcoin payments. Its store listings and website describe chats and payments but not group chat, so we did not consider it. Radar, Google Play listing
Other apps we set aside. Germ is iPhone only, Bitchat is a Bluetooth chat for people nearby, and the public code of Port has not been updated since September 2025. X’s XChat and Zoho’s Arattai are products of established companies, not newcomers. Session, Olvid, Delta Chat, Wire and Briar were first released before our two-year limit. We did not score Wire, Session, Delta Chat, Olvid, Viber or Messenger: the pages we read for them did not show how they compare, and they are on the list for our next review. Hobby projects that appeared in Hacker News searches, such as Wisp, OpenDescent and Kiyeovo, appeared only as titles and links, with nothing showing iPhone and Android apps with group chat, so we did not check them further. Germ, Bitchat, Port, Privacy Guides
| Tool | Public sources | What remains uncertain |
|---|---|---|
| Signal | Terms and privacy, group, linked-device, username, backup and transfer help, protocol documentation, formal analyses, FBI and CISA advisory. | Readable export, file-size limit, cross-platform backup restore, delivery and restore success in practice. |
| Threema Private | Pricing, US store listings, FAQ, desktop beta page, app and extended privacy policies, June 2026 cryptography whitepaper, shop terms, ownership page, outage report. | Whether the beta suits every member, group creator handover, plans under the new owner, export completeness. |
| Encryption, group, group-safety, linked-device, backup, transfer and export help; privacy policy; press on usernames, the dismissed lawsuit and iOS 16 takeovers. | What it records about groups, its encryption whitepaper and regulatory record (not assessed), backup restore success. | |
| Element | Help center, downloads, pricing, blog posts on room metadata, device verification and history sharing, matrix.org privacy notice, GitHub advisories for the web app, mobile apps and encryption library. | Whether every 2026 advisory is fixed in the apps members install, group-size and file limits, account inactivity rules, when device verification becomes mandatory. |
None of this establishes message delivery, backup restores, export completeness or security in practice. Next substantive review is due December 18, 2026, or sooner if a material feature, price or policy changes. Found a changed term? Contact the editors.
Sources and evidence
Sources were checked October 19, 2026 unless another date is given. Signal’s backup plans, Threema’s price, Element’s advisories and every app’s cost were rechecked on November 12, 2026. Vendor documentation establishes documented features and published commitments, not observed behavior. Bug reports and incident records are attributed accounts, not representative samples.
- Signal (help pages read through Signal’s public help-center interface): download; terms and privacy, May 25, 2018; usernames and phone-number privacy; group chats; linked devices, edited September 15, 2026; Secure Backups, edited October 4, 2026; backup and transfer, edited October 3, 2026; protocol documentation; private group system; post-quantum ratchet.
- Threema: pricing; Private FAQ; desktop beta; app privacy; extended app privacy; cryptography whitepaper, June 26, 2026; shop terms; ownership; website privacy note; US store listings: App Store and Google Play.
- SimpleX Chat, checked October 20, 2026: privacy policy and conditions of use, revised April 20, 2026; technical details and limitations; secret groups; managing data; desktop downloads; first release, January 12, 2022; Trail of Bits review, November 8, 2022; linking phone and desktop, November 25, 2023; device migration, March 23, 2024; design review, October 14, 2024; channels, consortium and crowdfunding, April 30, 2026; releases; advisories; US store listings: App Store and Google Play; Companies House record.
- White Noise, checked November 12, 2026: home page; frequently asked questions; download page; version 0.3.0 release notes, February 23, 2026; version 2026.3.23 release notes; releases; repository tags and notes, archived October 12, 2026; app repository; backend repository and releases, archived August 5, 2026; security advisories page; Least Authority audit post, April 7, 2026; Least Authority final audit report, April 1, 2026.
- WhatsApp, checked October 20, 2026: end-to-end encryption; keeping groups safe; groups; linked devices; encrypted backup; Android to iPhone; export; privacy policy, effective January 4, 2021.
- Element, checked October 20, 2026: help; downloads; pricing; room metadata, September 30, 2025; device verification, November 19, 2025, updated September 2026; history sharing, May 13, 2026; matrix.org privacy notice; advisories for Element Web, Element X iOS, Element X Android and the Matrix Rust SDK.
- Telegram: FAQ; privacy, updated August 21, 2026; terms; Premium FAQ; export announcement, 2018.
- Also read November 12, 2026: Signal terms and privacy, Signal blog and Signal on Wikipedia; Threema pricing and Google Play listing; WhatsApp App Store listing; Element pricing and Element Web advisories; Telegram Premium FAQ; SimpleX Chat on Wikipedia; Convos releases; Radar App Store listing; Keet; Wire pricing and Wire downloads; Session; Delta Chat; Olvid; Viber and Viber on Wikipedia; Messenger on Wikipedia; GitHub topic pages and Hacker News searches for newer apps.
- Outside analysis and records: formal analysis of the Signal Protocol, 2016; Signal private group system paper; MTProto analysis, 2021; ETH Zurich Threema findings, January 2023 and Threema response; FBI and CISA advisory I-062626-PSA, June 26, 2026; Threema outage, August 14, 2026; Signal Twilio incident and Twilio report; Telegram export bug report, August 2024. Read October 20, 2026: Trail of Bits SimpleX listing; SimpleX command-line flaw, CVE-2026-52103, May 10, 2026; SimpleX X account incident, Hackread, December 9, 2025; SimpleX Hacker News discussion; WhatsApp usernames, BleepingComputer, June 29, 2026; WhatsApp lawsuit, CyberInsider; WhatsApp iOS 16 takeovers, Security Affairs, May 25, 2026; Discord encryption; Google on encrypted RCS; Keet terms and Keet security FAQ. Read September 6, 2026: eSafety release and proceedings register.
This is a researched comparison, not a product review. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.