Newsletter platforms for an independent writer: Magic Pages, Synaps Media, Buttondown and Ghost(Pro)
Magic Pages runs Ghost with paid memberships for $14.50 a month and lets you take a full backup to any Ghost host. Buttondown is cheaper at 1,000 subscribers, and Kit is free up to 10,000 subscribers if you never charge.
Magic Pages
Managed Ghost hosting with a website, newsletters and paid memberships at one price, no cut of subscription revenue, and complete backups you can move to any Ghost host.
A three-person host whose sites were down about nine hours in January 2026, and its lead over Buttondown is narrow.
Why Magic Pages is our PickTeam behind Magic Pages? Get your award badge
Synaps Media
A Dutch managed Ghost host, open to the public since early 2025, with paid memberships, up to 3,000 members and 6,000 emails a month on its $9 plan billed yearly.
Two people run it, and its terms let it end your access at any time without notice.
Why Synaps Media earned Rising StarWho is this article for? Independent writers and small publishers sending a regular newsletter to hundreds or a few thousand readers, who want a web archive and may charge for subscriptions later.
About 37 min read
What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean
The quick list
Prices for 1,000 subscribers with paid subscriptions available, at the cheaper of yearly or monthly billing. Compare what each takes when readers pay and what you keep when you leave.
USD for 1,000 subscribers with paid subscriptions available, plan prices checked November 12, 2026, excluding Stripe processing fees and tax. Magic Pages and Synaps Media showed us US dollars and may show another currency elsewhere. Magic Pages’ $14.50 is its monthly price ($145 a year); Synaps Media’s $9 and Ghost(Pro)’s $29 are monthly prices when billed yearly. Buttondown’s $9 is its monthly price. Other services we compared are described in “How we researched”.
The comparison at a glance
Compare price at 1,000 and 5,000 subscribers, what each service takes when readers pay, who controls the Stripe account and what you keep when you leave.
Order follows our verdict for an independent writer’s newsletter, not measured deliverability or growth. The four services shown are our top four; the others we compared are described in “How we researched”.
Hides matching answers for the selected tools. Unknowns and unverified claims stay visible.
| Feature | Magic Pages | Synaps Media | Buttondown | Ghost(Pro) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: a full Ghost publication with paid memberships at one low price | Rising Star: the lowest price for Ghost, if a two-person host suits you | Also consider: a newsletter-first service with nothing to maintain | Ghost from its own maker, at more than twice the price for paid subscriptions |
| Free plan | None; 14-day trial without a card, limited to 100 emails | None; 14-day trial without a card that does not convert by itself | Up to 100 subscribers | None; Starter from $15/month billed yearly cannot take payments |
| 1,000 subscribers, paid subscriptions available | $14.50/month ($145/year); unlimited members and 10,000 emails a month | $9/month billed yearly ($11.50 monthly) on Basic; $18.50 to send from your own domain | $9/month ($90/year) | Publisher $29/month billed yearly ($348/year), or $35 monthly |
| 5,000 subscribers | $265/year at most: $145 plus extra sends at $5 per 10,000, about two packs a month | About $25/month: Premium $18.50 billed yearly plus extra email credits | $29/month ($290/year); adds automations and own-domain archive | Publisher $75/month, or $756/year |
| Fee on paid subscriptions | None beyond Stripe fees (vendor: “never takes a cut”) | No fee listed; Stripe fees apply | None beyond Stripe fees | 0% from Ghost; Stripe fees apply |
| Stripe account and paying readers | Ghost connects a Stripe account you own; Ghost’s import can link existing paying members | Ghost connects a Stripe account you own | Connect an account you already own; vendor says subscriptions stay with you | Connect a Stripe account you own; Ghost uses the same account to take over Substack subscribers |
| Web archive or site | Full Ghost website on your own domain; any theme | Full Ghost website on your own domain; custom themes | Hosted archive; own domain from the $29 tier | Full Ghost website; custom themes from Publisher |
| Subscriber export | Ghost members CSV with labels and subscription status | Ghost members CSV with labels and subscription status | CSV with subscriber type, unsubscribe date, tags and metadata | Members CSV inside a one-zip export with content and media; link lasts 7 days |
| Cancelling and closing | Download full backups any time; data deleted 14 days after cancelling (help) or within 30 (terms) | Full-site export offered; terms do not say how long data is kept; no refunds | Account deletion is immediate and does not cancel readers’ Stripe subscriptions | Fees not refunded; you are responsible for your own backups |
| Published service terms | Full terms (October 19, 2026); Austrian law; 99.9% uptime promise with credits | Short terms (April 3, 2026); may end access without notice; Dutch law | Website terms only; DPA published; no billing or closure terms found | Full terms; no refunds unless Ghost decides otherwise |
Hosted newsletter services for an independent writer sending a weekly issue to hundreds or a few thousand readers. Plan prices checked November 12, 2026; other facts October 19 and 20; next review December 18, 2026, or sooner after a material change. Prices are USD unless stated and exclude Stripe processing fees and tax. This is public-source research: no accounts, sends, payments or migrations. Exports do not establish that automations, websites or paying subscribers move successfully.
All features and sources 18 criteria
Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.
Cost at 1,000 and 5,000 subscribers
Show 5 criteria
| Feature | Magic Pages | Synaps Media | Buttondown | Ghost(Pro) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: a full Ghost publication with paid memberships at one low price | Rising Star: the lowest price for Ghost, if a two-person host suits you | Also consider: a newsletter-first service with nothing to maintain | Ghost from its own maker, at more than twice the price for paid subscriptions |
| Free plan | None; 14-day trial without a card, limited to 100 emails | None; 14-day trial without a card that does not convert by itself | Up to 100 subscribers | None; Starter from $15/month billed yearly cannot take payments |
| 1,000 subscribers, paid subscriptions available | $14.50/month ($145/year); unlimited members and 10,000 emails a month | $9/month billed yearly ($11.50 monthly) on Basic; $18.50 to send from your own domain | $9/month ($90/year) | Publisher $29/month billed yearly ($348/year), or $35 monthly |
| 5,000 subscribers | $265/year at most: $145 plus extra sends at $5 per 10,000, about two packs a month | About $25/month: Premium $18.50 billed yearly plus extra email credits | $29/month ($290/year); adds automations and own-domain archive | Publisher $75/month, or $756/year |
| What raises the bill | Newsletter sends above 10,000 a month, billed automatically; no member limit | More than 3,000 members on Basic; sends above the plan’s monthly credits, which you buy in advance | Active subscribers; features that need a higher tier; more than one full-list email a day | Member count; paid subscriptions need Publisher |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for cost at 1,000 and 5,000 subscribers
Plan prices checked November 12, 2026: Magic Pages pricing and extra emails; Synaps Media pricing and newsletter credits; Buttondown pricing, with the plan table read from its calculator on October 19; Ghost(Pro) pricing and its published price table. USD at yearly billing where it is cheaper, monthly where stated; excluding processing fees and tax. A weekly issue means about 4,300 sends a month at 1,000 subscribers and 21,700 at 5,000.
Charging readers
Show 3 criteria
| Feature | Magic Pages | Synaps Media | Buttondown | Ghost(Pro) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fee on paid subscriptions | None beyond Stripe fees (vendor: “never takes a cut”) | No fee listed; Stripe fees apply | None beyond Stripe fees | 0% from Ghost; Stripe fees apply |
| Plan needed to charge | Its one plan ($14.50) | Basic ($9) | $9 tier | Publisher ($29 billed yearly) |
| Stripe account and paying readers | Ghost connects a Stripe account you own; Ghost’s import can link existing paying members | Ghost connects a Stripe account you own | Connect an account you already own; vendor says subscriptions stay with you | Connect a Stripe account you own; Ghost uses the same account to take over Substack subscribers |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for charging readers
Magic Pages trial and memberships; Synaps Media home page; Ghost and Stripe and member import; Buttondown Stripe integration and paid subscriptions. Moving paying subscribers was not tested.
Publishing and growth
Show 5 criteria
| Feature | Magic Pages | Synaps Media | Buttondown | Ghost(Pro) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Web archive or site | Full Ghost website on your own domain; any theme | Full Ghost website on your own domain; custom themes | Hosted archive; own domain from the $29 tier | Full Ghost website; custom themes from Publisher |
| Automations | Ghost automations, in beta | Ghost automations, in beta | $29 tier | Ghost automations, in beta |
| Built-in list growth | Ghost recommendations and the social web (ActivityPub) | Ghost recommendations and the social web (ActivityPub) | None; referrals and integrations only | Recommendations, Ghost’s Explore directory and the social web |
| Distinctive capability | Downloadable database and content backups; personal support | Lowest price here for Ghost; discounts for several sites | Markdown editor; export API including Stripe records | Run by the non-profit behind Ghost; one-zip export with media |
| Remove platform branding | No host branding documented; any Ghost theme, including your own | No host branding documented; custom themes on both plans | $79 tier | Whitelabel on every plan; custom themes from Publisher |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for publishing and growth
Magic Pages and its sending domain help; Synaps Media pricing; Ghost(Pro) pricing; Buttondown features and pricing. Documented features, not measured growth.
Export, leaving and support
Show 5 criteria
| Feature | Magic Pages | Synaps Media | Buttondown | Ghost(Pro) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Subscriber export | Ghost members CSV with labels and subscription status | Ghost members CSV with labels and subscription status | CSV with subscriber type, unsubscribe date, tags and metadata | Members CSV inside a one-zip export with content and media; link lasts 7 days |
| Cancelling and closing | Download full backups any time; data deleted 14 days after cancelling (help) or within 30 (terms) | Full-site export offered; terms do not say how long data is kept; no refunds | Account deletion is immediate and does not cancel readers’ Stripe subscriptions | Fees not refunded; you are responsible for your own backups |
| Published service terms | Full terms (October 19, 2026); Austrian law; 99.9% uptime promise with credits | Short terms (April 3, 2026); may end access without notice; Dutch law | Website terms only; DPA published; no billing or closure terms found | Full terms; no refunds unless Ghost decides otherwise |
| Support access | Email and chat from a three-person team in European business hours; one business day promised | Email and live chat from a two-person team | Email support; new accounts reviewed before sending (1–3 business days) | Email support; priority on Business |
| Delivery claims and recent incidents | Vendor says 98% reach inboxes, no method; sites down about 9 hours January 29, 2026, about 200 sites for 4.5 hours May 19, and 84 sites for 12 to 56 minutes October 20 | No delivery figure; image uploads partly failing for 4 hours October 1, 2026; a newsletter is not delivered if you run out of credits | Testimonials only; September 9, 2026 sending delayed about two hours | No delivery figure; September 24, 2026 shared-sending abuse disrupted email |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for export, leaving and support
Magic Pages backups, data after cancelling, terms, service level agreement and post-mortems for January 29, May 19 and October 20, 2026; Synaps Media terms, team, newsletter credits and status history; Ghost exports, Ghost terms and Ghost status; Buttondown subscriber export, deleting data, terms, DPA, account review and September 9 postmortem. Delivery figures are vendor claims; incidents are not comparable failure rates.
What matters when choosing
Magic Pages is our Practical Pick for an independent writer who wants a publication website with the newsletter, may charge later and is comfortable with a small host. It runs Ghost, the open-source publishing software, for you. Its one plan, listed to us on November 12 at $14.50 a month or $145 a year, includes a website on your own domain, unlimited members, paid memberships and 10,000 newsletter emails a month. Extra emails cost $5 per 10,000, so a weekly issue to 5,000 readers costs $265 a year at most. Magic Pages says it takes no cut of membership revenue; payments go through a Stripe account you own. You can download full database and content backups at any time, and because Ghost is open source, another Ghost host or Ghost(Pro) can run the same site. The compromises are about the company. Magic Pages is a three-person Austrian sole proprietorship that launched in 2023. Its own post-mortems say its customer sites were down for about nine hours on January 29, 2026, that about 200 sites were down for four and a half hours on May 19, and that 84 sites were down for 12 to 56 minutes on October 20. Its lead over Buttondown is narrow, 4.05 to 3.95 on our five-point scale. It holds whether price counts for less or for more in our scoring, and no other service here leads at either end, but it rests on our judgment that a full Ghost site and a complete, portable backup outweigh Buttondown’s lower starting price and steadier record: scoring Ghost’s publishing fit half a point lower would put Buttondown first. Magic Pages pricing, trial and memberships, backups, January post-mortem, May post-mortem, October post-mortem
Synaps Media is our Rising Star. A Dutch Ghost host that opened to the public in early 2025, after a private launch in spring 2024, it is the cheapest way here to run Ghost with paid memberships: $9 a month billed yearly ($11.50 month to month) for up to 3,000 members and 6,000 emails, or $18.50 billed yearly for unlimited members and sending from your own domain. Its limits are plain. Two people run it, its terms let it end your access at any time without notice, and they do not say what happens to your data afterwards. Newsletter credits are prepaid, and an issue is not delivered if you run out. Keep your own exports. Synaps Media pricing, terms, team and launch, newsletter credits
If you want a newsletter service with no website to look after, choose Buttondown. Its calculator lists $9 a month up to 1,000 subscribers and $29 up to 5,000, with paid subscriptions included. It takes no share beyond Stripe’s fees, connects to a Stripe account you already own, and has run since 2017; its September 2026 post-mortems describe a 20-minute and a two-hour incident. Its public terms cover only use of the website. If you will not charge readers and want to pay nothing, look at Kit first. Its Free plan covers up to 10,000 subscribers with unlimited broadcasts, forms and a newsletter site; if you do charge through Kit, it takes 3.5% plus 30 cents per transaction. Kit scored just behind our top four, and “How we researched” gives its score and those of Substack, WordPress.com, Steady, MailerLite, beehiiv and Mailchimp. Ghost(Pro) runs the same software as our Pick, from the Ghost Foundation, but taking payments needs its Publisher plan at $29 a month billed yearly for 1,000 members ($35 month to month). Disclosure: Practical Picks is researched and written with Anthropic’s Claude. Kit, MailerLite and beehiiv advertise connections that let Claude and other AI assistants work with your account; we found no such connection advertised by Magic Pages, Synaps Media, Buttondown or Ghost(Pro). We have no relationship with any of these companies or with Anthropic, and AI features carried no weight in this comparison. Buttondown pricing, Buttondown Stripe connection, Kit Free plan, Kit pricing, Ghost(Pro) pricing, beehiiv MCP guide, MailerLite pricing page
Deliverability is the claim we can least check. We found no independent, comparable measurement of inbox placement for these services. Delivery-rate figures, such as Magic Pages’ “98% of newsletters land in inboxes”, and phrases like “optimized deliverability” are vendor claims, and customer testimonials are not measurements. Status records show that problems happen everywhere. On August 21, 2026 an upstream provider fault left about a fifth of beehiiv’s large publications with 4–8% of an issue undelivered until beehiiv resent them. On September 9 Buttondown’s sending was delayed for about two hours, with no data lost, according to Buttondown. On September 24 abuse of Ghost(Pro)‘s shared sending system disrupted email delivery for sites without their own sending domain. These are incident reports, not failure rates. beehiiv status history, Buttondown postmortem, Ghost status
Our prices assume a weekly issue, yearly billing where it is cheaper and paid subscriptions switched on. We checked plan prices again on November 12, 2026; other facts were checked October 19 and 20. Magic Pages and Synaps Media showed us prices in US dollars and may show another currency elsewhere; prices exclude Stripe’s processing fees, which are 2.9% plus 30 cents for US cards, and sales tax. Three conditions would change our recommendation: a newsletter you will never charge for and want free (choose Kit), list growth through a recommendation or advertising network (compare Substack, Kit and beehiiv), or a wish for no website to maintain and a longer company record (choose Buttondown). Customer data already flowing into Mailchimp from a store is a fourth. Before moving an established list, export a sample that includes unsubscribed readers and keep your original issue files. Move paying subscribers as a separate, deliberate step, so nobody is billed twice.
Magic Pages
Preferred Pick · a full Ghost publication at one price
Choose Magic Pages for a newsletter with a full website that may charge later: Ghost with paid memberships, no cut of your revenue, and complete backups you can move to any Ghost host. Accept a small company with three outages in 2026.
Reasons to choose it
- $14.50 a month with unlimited members and 10,000 emails
- Paid memberships through your own Stripe account, no host fee
- Download full database and content backups at any time
What to watch
- Sites down about nine hours on January 29, 2026
- A three-person sole proprietorship; support in European hours
- Its lead over Buttondown is narrow
Magic Pages is a managed host for Ghost, the open-source publishing software that the Ghost Foundation also sells as Ghost(Pro); the two companies are not connected. You get Ghost’s editor, scheduling, a website with any theme on your own domain, member sign-ups and newsletters, while Magic Pages handles updates, backups and email sending. Since March 2026 it has sold one plan. On November 12 its pricing page listed it at $14.50 a month, $145 a year, or $440 once for a “lifetime” plan that it releases in limited numbers each month; it listed $15, $150 and $450 on October 20, and its March announcement gave the monthly price as €13 and says checkout converts it. The plan includes unlimited members and staff and 10,000 newsletter emails a month. More cost $5 per 10,000, prepaid or billed automatically at the end of the cycle. A weekly issue to 1,000 readers needs about 4,300 emails a month, which the plan covers, so it costs $145 a year; to 5,000 readers it needs about 21,700, which adds about two packs a month, for $265 a year at most. The 14-day trial needs no card but sends only 100 emails. Pricing, email allowance, October 8, 2026, extra emails, July 25, 2026, March 2026 plan change, lifetime plans
Paid memberships use Ghost’s own Stripe connection, so payments go to a Stripe account you own. Magic Pages says it “never takes a cut”; you pay card processing only. Ghost’s help says that a writer moving from Substack keeps the same Stripe account, and its member import links existing paying subscribers by their Stripe customer ID. The same route should let paying members follow you to another Ghost host, though we have not seen it done. Newsletters can come from your own address once your custom domain is connected; Magic Pages sends through a subdomain such as send.yourdomain.com behind the scenes. Trial and memberships, July 25, 2026, Ghost and Stripe, Ghost member import, sending domain, August 23, 2026
Read the full Magic Pages analysis and sources
Leaving is the strongest part of the case. From the customer portal you can download the database and the content folder from any restore point it keeps, one a day for a week, one a week for a month and one a month for three months, or take a fresh backup before a big change. Ghost’s own export gives your posts as JSON and your members, with labels and subscription status, as a CSV. Those files can run on another Ghost host or on your own computer. If you cancel, Magic Pages deletes your data after 14 days according to its help, or within 30 days according to its terms, so export first. Backups, October 6, 2026, Ghost exports, data after cancelling, terms
Choose another tool if you need a long company record or support around the clock. Magic Pages e.U. is the sole proprietorship of its founder, Jannis Fedoruk-Betschki, registered in Austria at the regional court in Wels. Two part-time staff joined in early 2026, and support works in European business hours, with a one-business-day response promised in its terms. Those terms, updated October 19, 2026, make fees non-refundable after the trial, promise a month’s notice of major changes, apply Austrian law and route plan payments through Paddle as the seller. Monthly and yearly plans carry a 99.9% uptime promise, with a credit of 5% of the monthly fee for each full hour beyond it. Its data processing agreement lists servers in Germany. The founder decides what he hosts: in October 2024 he declined a writer’s political blog that he was “not comfortable with”, citing his acceptable use policy, in a public reply on Ghost’s forum. Terms, service level agreement, data processing agreement, September 7, 2026, continuity plan, July 25, 2026, Ghost forum thread
Its record shows the cost of a small operation. On January 29, 2026, after a network fault in its server cluster, customer sites failed from about 13:30 to 22:45 UTC. On May 19 and 20 a failing drive took about 200 sites down for four and a half hours because no alert fired; Magic Pages says no customer data was lost and that it has added monitoring. On October 20 a network problem at its hosting provider, Hetzner, took 84 sites completely down for 12 to 56 minutes, left 260 more unable to load uncached pages or Ghost Admin for 19 minutes, and briefly restarted about 1,320 others; it says nothing already saved was lost. It published post-mortems for all three, and for earlier outages in 2024 and 2025. Ghost itself had a heavy security year, with about 70 advisories dated 2026 on its project page. One flaw, fixed in February, was later used against more than 700 Ghost sites that had not been updated, according to CybelAngel, so prompt updates matter. Magic Pages says it deploys new Ghost releases about an hour and a half after they appear, and its own site ran Ghost 6.71, the then-current release, when we checked on October 20. January post-mortem, May post-mortem, October post-mortem, updates, May 14, 2026, Ghost security advisories, CybelAngel, May 26, 2026
Used Magic Pages? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Synaps Media
Rising Star · a newcomer worth considering
Why Rising Star? Open to the public since early 2025, Synaps Media runs Ghost with paid memberships from $9 a month, the lowest price here for Ghost, and keeps Ghost’s full exports. Its two-person team and short terms are the limits. This is not our broader Ready to Rock endorsement.
Consider Synaps Media if price matters most and you want Ghost’s website, memberships and exports. It opened to the public in early 2025 and two people run it, so keep your own exports.
Reasons to choose it
- $9 a month, billed yearly, for up to 3,000 members and 6,000 emails
- Paid memberships through your own Stripe account
- Daily backups and full-site export
What to watch
- Own-domain sending and over 3,000 members need the $18.50 plan
- Its terms allow ending your access without notice
- Two-person team; public only since early 2025
Synaps Media is a managed Ghost host run by Triofan, a Dutch sole proprietorship that Murat Çorlu founded in 2024. Its founder says it launched privately in spring 2024 and opened to the public in early 2025, which is why it counts as a newcomer here. On November 12 Basic cost $9 a month billed yearly, or $11.50 month to month, for up to 3,000 members and 6,000 newsletter emails a month, with custom themes, daily backups and full-site export. Premium cost $18.50 billed yearly, or $23 month to month, and adds unlimited members, 12,000 emails and sending from your own domain. Extra emails cost $7 per 10,000 or $63 per 100,000, are bought in advance and expire after a year. Prices exclude VAT; we saw euros on October 20 and dollars on November 12. A weekly issue to 1,000 readers fits Basic at $9 a month; 5,000 readers need Premium and extra credits, about $25 a month. The 14-day trial needs no card and does not turn into a paid plan by itself. Pricing, newsletter credits, September 23, 2026, custom sending domain, January 31, 2026, about, imprint, launch thread, January 2025
Choose it if price matters most and you want Ghost’s website, memberships and exports. Synaps advertises paid memberships and subscriptions, which run through Ghost’s connection to a Stripe account you own. Its pricing lists no transaction fee, though we found no explicit statement that it takes none. Ghost’s members CSV and content export work here as on any Ghost site, so the way out is the same as our Pick’s. Its founder also sends fixes to Ghost itself; one he described on Ghost’s forum shipped in Ghost 6.36. Home page, Ghost exports, Ghost forum thread
Read the full Synaps Media analysis and sources
Its limits are the company and the paperwork. One full-time and one part-time person run it, by its own account. Its terms, last updated April 3, 2026, are short: payments are non-refundable, Dutch law applies, and Synaps may end your access “at any time, with or without cause, with or without notice”, in a clause that ends “for any violation of these Terms”. They do not say how long your data is kept after an account ends, so keep your own exports. Sending from your own domain, or more than 3,000 members, needs the $18.50 plan. Credits are prepaid: if you run out, your post is still published but the newsletter is not delivered until you buy more. Its status page records two partial failures on October 1, 2026, four hours for image uploads and six hours for its backup service, and we found no independent review. Like our Pick, it depends on prompt Ghost updates; its own site ran Ghost 6.71, the then-current release, on October 20. Terms, team and pricing, November 28, 2025, status history
Used Synaps Media? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Buttondown
Also consider · a newsletter-first service
Choose Buttondown for a regular newsletter with no website to maintain: $9 a month at 1,000 subscribers with paid subscriptions included, no cut of your revenue and paying readers kept in your own Stripe account.
Reasons to choose it
- $9 a month up to 1,000 subscribers, paid subscriptions included
- No share of subscription revenue; connects to a Stripe account you own
- Export records unsubscribes, tags and metadata
What to watch
- Free only up to 100 subscribers
- No recommendation or advertising network
- Public terms cover the website, not billing or account closure
Buttondown is a writing-first newsletter service with a Markdown or rich-text editor, a hosted archive, scheduling and sending from your own domain. It is free for the first 100 subscribers. After that, its calculator lists $9 a month up to 1,000 subscribers, $29 up to 5,000 and $79 up to 10,000; yearly billing costs ten times the monthly price. The $9 tier includes paid subscriptions, tagging and segmentation, analytics, RSS-to-email, comments and attachments. The $29 tier adds automations, sponsorship tools, multiple newsletters and an archive on your own domain; removing Buttondown’s branding needs the $79 tier. The page labels these features as add-ons, but its calculator raises the bill to the tier a feature needs rather than adding each listed amount. An earlier version of this comparison treated each extra as a separate $9 charge. We read the plan table from the calculator on October 19, not from a checkout, so confirm your own quote. Prices assume no more than one email a day to your whole list. Pricing
Choose it if you want a newsletter with no website to maintain: $9 a month at 1,000 subscribers with paid subscriptions included, no share of payments, and a service running since 2017. Choose another tool if you want the platform to grow your list for you. Buttondown has no recommendation network or advertising marketplace like Kit’s or beehiiv’s. New accounts, and accounts that import a list, are reviewed before they can send; Buttondown says most reviews take one to three business days. Plan for that before a launch date. Account review
Read the full Buttondown analysis and sources
Paid subscriptions run through Stripe only. You can connect a Stripe account you already have, and Buttondown says it takes no cut beyond card fees. It also says customers and their subscriptions live in your own Stripe account, so you keep them if you move. Each newsletter needs its own Stripe account, and Stripe’s test mode is not supported. Buttondown also says it can take over paying subscribers from beehiiv, Ghost or Substack through the same Stripe account. beehiiv’s and Ghost’s own documentation describe beehiiv’s Stripe arrangement differently, so treat a move from beehiiv as unresolved. Stripe integration, paid subscriptions, paid subscription docs
Leaving is well documented. The subscriber CSV includes each person’s subscriber type, subscription and unsubscription dates, tags, metadata, referrer and sign-up IP address. The export API can also return emails, events, comments and Stripe records, and automations can run regular exports. Deleting an account is immediate and does not cancel your readers’ Stripe subscriptions, so cancel or move them first. Deleted data stays in backups for up to two days. Subscriber export, export API, periodic exports, deleting data
The paperwork is thin. Buttondown’s terms of service govern use of the website under Delaware law and say nothing about billing, refunds, suspension or data after an account closes. Its data processing agreement commits it to delete or return personal data when the service ends and to give 30 days’ notice of new subprocessors. Buttondown, LLC describes itself as a profitable, self-funded team founded in 2017; that is its own statement. It publishes postmortems: on September 1, 2026 its dashboard and default-domain archives were down for about 20 minutes, and on September 9 the dashboard was slow and sending delayed for about two hours. Customer quotes on its pricing page praise its deliverability; they are testimonials, not measurements. Terms, data processing agreement, privacy, September 1 postmortem, September 9 postmortem
Used Buttondown? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Ghost(Pro)
Ghost from its maker · paid plans cost more
Consider Ghost(Pro) if you want Ghost run by the Ghost Foundation itself and will pay more than twice our Pick’s price to take payments.
Reasons to choose it
- Run by the non-profit behind Ghost
- One-zip export with members, content and media
- No transaction fee; unlimited newsletter sends
What to watch
- Starter ($15) cannot take payments
- Fees not refunded; backups are your responsibility
- Shared sending disrupted on September 24, 2026
Ghost(Pro) is the hosted service of the Ghost Foundation, the non-profit behind the open-source software that our Pick and Rising Star run. Its Starter plan, $15 a month billed yearly ($180 a year, or $18 month to month) for up to 1,000 members, cannot take payments. Paid subscriptions, tips and multiple tiers need Publisher: $29 a month billed yearly ($348 a year, or $35 month to month) at 1,000 members, and $756 a year ($75 month to month) at 5,000. Ghost takes no transaction fee; Stripe’s fees still apply. Every plan includes unlimited newsletter sends, any custom domain, recommendations and a listing in Ghost’s Explore directory. Pricing and plan limits, about the Ghost Foundation
Choose it over our Pick if you would rather pay the software’s maker than a small host. You get the same editor, website and memberships, and Ghost(Pro) applies security updates for you. That matters in a year with about 70 published Ghost advisories; CybelAngel reported that Ghost(Pro) sites were patched automatically against the flaw later used on more than 700 sites. Leaving is as good as on our Pick. Ghost’s export help says one export from Ghost(Pro) produces a single zip with posts, members and their subscription status, post analytics, themes and all media, through an emailed link that lasts seven days. Paying members stay in a Stripe account you own. Exports, Stripe, CybelAngel, May 26, 2026, Ghost security advisories
Read the full Ghost(Pro) analysis and sources
Choose another tool if price decides it. At 1,000 members Publisher costs $348 a year against Magic Pages’ $145, and at 5,000 members $756 against $265, nearly three times as much. The terms are firm: fees are charged in advance and are not refundable unless Ghost decides otherwise, and you are “solely responsible for securing and backing up” your content. Ghost’s status page recorded an email delivery problem on September 24, 2026, caused by abuse of its shared sending system; sites with their own sending domain were not affected. Terms, status history
Used Ghost(Pro)? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Which product are we missing?
Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.
Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.
Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.
No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.
What people are saying
Public reports are a check on vendor claims, not a measured satisfaction score. The newest and most consistent theme is beehiiv’s October price change. Creators quoted by The Verge, as relayed by PPC Land, objected to paying more while ad income fell. One publisher called beehiiv a bargain next to Substack for some, but not for many others, especially smaller publishers outside the US. PPC Land, October 8, 2026
For the two Ghost hosts the public record is thin. A Ghost forum thread about Magic Pages, opened in May 2024, holds mostly favorable posts from customers, the founder’s own updates during an April 2025 outage, and one writer’s October 2024 complaint that he declined to host their political blog; he replied that he decides what runs under his name. Synaps Media’s launch thread on the same forum, from January 2025, is mostly questions that its founder answered. We found no press coverage or independent review of either host. Magic Pages thread, Synaps Media thread
The older sample we read on September 6, 2026 is mixed. TechRadar’s February 22, 2026 Mailchimp review praises its marketing features and criticizes the shrinking free plan. Its May 6 Kit review praises automation but describes free-plan and fee terms that differ from Kit’s current pages, so we rely on Kit’s pages. Its April 29 beehiiv review praises the publishing and monetization combination and criticizes layout flexibility. An August 2026 Reddit thread reports a Kit sequence becoming unavailable on the free plan, which Kit’s current help now explains as a paid feature. An August 2024 Hacker News discussion of Buttondown mixes praise with objections to the cost of extras; its prices are out of date. TechRadar on Mailchimp, TechRadar on Kit, TechRadar on beehiiv, Reddit thread, Hacker News discussion
None of this shows how often an ordinary newsletter meets these problems. Review publications may earn affiliate commissions, and community posts are individual accounts.
How we researched
This is public-source research. We did not create accounts, sign in, send email, take payments, contact support or move a list. No vendor supplied access, payment or editorial input. We first compared Buttondown, Kit, beehiiv and Mailchimp on September 6, 2026 and rechecked every material claim on October 19: plans and prices, paid-subscription fees, who controls the Stripe account, export contents, terms, incidents and delivery claims. On October 20 we added Magic Pages, Synaps Media, Ghost(Pro), Substack and MailerLite and checked the same points for each. On November 12 we checked every plan price again, scored cost the same way for every service, and added WordPress.com and Steady. beehiiv’s website refused plain automated requests; we read its pricing, help and terms pages through a page-fetching service it did serve, and checked its prices against independent sources. Buttondown’s and MailerLite’s price tables load by script, and we read them from the pages’ own code or in a browser; Ghost(Pro)‘s price table we read from its page code again on November 12. Mailchimp’s calculator shows a price for 500 contacts only, so its price at 1,000 and 5,000 contacts remains unconfirmed. Magic Pages’ status page also loads by script, so for its record we relied on its own post-mortems.
We judged the services for one reader: an independent writer sending a weekly newsletter to between a few hundred and a few thousand people, who wants a web archive and may charge later. We fixed five criteria and their weights before scoring: publishing fit (25%), cost at 1,000 and 5,000 subscribers (20%), paid-subscription terms (20%), export and leaving (20%), and terms, support and incident record (15%). The cost score compares each service’s three-year cost at each list size, on the cheaper of yearly or monthly billing, with the typical cost among comparable services: free scores 5, the typical price 3.5 and double the typical price about 2.6. Revenue shares such as Substack’s 10% count under paid-subscription terms, not cost, so they are not counted twice. On our five-point scale Magic Pages scored 4.05, Buttondown 3.95, Ghost(Pro) 3.86, Synaps Media 3.85, Kit 3.83, Substack 3.58, WordPress.com 3.53, Steady 3.43, MailerLite 3.22 and beehiiv 2.84. Mailchimp has no total: no price for 1,000 or 5,000 contacts was shown to us, and even with a perfect cost score it would reach only about 3.1. Magic Pages’ lead over Buttondown is smaller than one step on our heaviest criterion, so we call it narrow. It stayed first when we made price count for less or for more, when we priced every service month to month, when we doubled the number of issues, and when we assumed readers pay $4,800 a year and counted each service’s share of it. Buttondown would lead if we scored Ghost’s publishing fit half a point lower. For a newsletter you will never charge for, Kit comes out ahead of Magic Pages, 4.10 to 3.96, and Kit costs nothing, which is why we name Kit for that case.
We searched for new entrants again on November 12, 2026, through Hacker News launch posts since November 2024, vendor pages and the alternatives pages of Buttondown and Ghost. To count as a newcomer a product’s first public release has to be within the last 24 months, which means on or after November 12, 2024. Synaps Media qualifies: its founder describes a private launch in spring 2024 and a first public announcement in January 2025, and it appeared on Hacker News in February 2025. That rests on the founder’s own account, because we could not read earlier archived copies of its site. Magic Pages, launched in 2023, is older than 24 months, so it competes for the Pick but not for the Rising Star. Letterbird and LetterBucket, both launched in 2026, are newsletter services, but neither names a company or a responsible person in the pages we read, and we do not recommend a service that holds your subscriber list without an identifiable operator. Hyvor Post, launched in December 2025, has no paid subscriptions. Picoletter has no paid subscriptions. Paragraph, founded in 2022, now sells an AI publishing agent for companies. Markdown Ninja publishes too little readable plan and payment detail to score. Older Ghost hosts, Midnight (May 2019) and DigitalPress (January 2020), fall outside the window, and PikaPods needs your own Mailgun account to send newsletters. Other launches we found were self-hosted tools, newsletter readers, link-curation or group-letter services, or had no product page. beehiiv, launched in 2021, is an established service here. New features from beehiiv, Kit and Ghost count as incumbents’ features, not newcomers. Our adverse search covered breach, outage, lawsuit, regulator and acquisition terms for each service and its company, on October 19 and, for the services added later, on October 20 and November 12.
We also checked that widely used options were either compared or set aside for a reason. We added Ghost(Pro), Substack and MailerLite on October 20, and WordPress.com and Steady on November 12. We set aside Flodesk, a design-led email-marketing service: it offers recurring payments only on its top plan, and we found no hosted newsletter archive on its pricing page.
The services outside our top four, in order of score:
Kit (3.83). Its Free plan covers up to 10,000 subscribers with unlimited broadcasts, forms and landing pages, tagging and segmentation, a newsletter site, and digital products and subscriptions. You are enrolled in its Creator Network, which you can switch off. Sequences, visual automations and RSS campaigns need a paid plan; Creator costs $390 a year at 1,000 subscribers. If you charge readers, Kit takes 3.5% plus 30 cents per transaction, including card processing (it describes its own share as 0.6%), through a Stripe connected account set up through Kit, and we could not establish whether paying subscribers can move to another platform without signing up again. The export is a CSV; Kit’s steps start from confirmed subscribers, so include other statuses if you need opt-out history, and links expire after five days. Kit Inc. is an Idaho company whose terms require individual arbitration unless you opt out. Free plan, pricing, terms, export guide, September 4, 2026, privacy, October 9, 2026
Substack (3.58). Free at any list size; if you turn on paid subscriptions it keeps 10% of each payment, and Stripe adds its card fee and 0.7% for recurring billing. A custom domain costs a one-time $50. Payments go to a Stripe account in your name, one per publication, and Ghost’s help says writers moving from Substack keep that account; we did not test a move. Its export makes a zip of posts, subscriber list and statistics; the list alone exports as a CSV without names. In February 2026 Substack told users that an unauthorized party had accessed email addresses, phone numbers and internal data in October 2025, and that passwords and payment details were not accessed. What Substack costs, Stripe setup, export the list, June 4, 2026, Security Affairs, February 5, 2026
WordPress.com (3.53, low confidence). Its Personal plan costs $4 a month billed yearly ($9 month to month), removes WordPress.com’s own advertising and allows unlimited subscribers and unlimited newsletter sends; a free plan exists but shows ads. Paid newsletters use a Stripe account you connect, and WordPress.com takes a share by plan: 10% on Free, 8% on Personal, 4% on Premium, 2% on Business. Its newsletter page says you can export posts and your subscriber list; we did not test a move. We read its pricing, newsletter and paid-newsletter pages only. Pricing, newsletters, paid newsletters and fees
Steady (3.43, low confidence). A German membership and newsletter platform, run by Steady Media GmbH, that is free to start and takes a 10% commission once you earn; Steady bills your members and pays you out, so you do not hold the customer relationship the way you do with your own Stripe account. We read only its pricing, newsletter and legal pages, and not its export, support or status pages. Pricing, newsletters, legal policy
MailerLite (3.22). An email-marketing service with a drag-and-drop editor, automations and simple websites. Paid subscriptions need Comfort, $19 a month at 1,000 subscribers and $49 at 5,000, or $17.10 and $44.10 billed yearly, and it bills only active subscribers. Subscriptions are sold through Stripe payment blocks and MailerLite says it takes 0% of sales; its documentation describes selling the subscription, not restricting web posts to paying readers. A newsletter archive block shows at most 50 sent campaigns, and subscribers export by status; newsletters export one at a time as PDFs. Its status page records a critical outage on February 27, 2026, and in January 2024 attackers who tricked a support employee reached 117 customer accounts, all connected with cryptocurrency, according to MailerLite’s statement to Decrypt. Pricing page, selling with Stripe, April 15, 2026, newsletter archive, March 7, 2025, exporting subscribers, April 14, 2026, terms, September 22, 2026, status history, Decrypt, January 24, 2024
beehiiv (2.84). A publication website with recommendation and advertising networks. It renamed and repriced its plans on October 1, 2026: Free covers up to 2,500 subscribers without paid subscriptions, and Lite, which adds them, costs $49 a month billed yearly ($59 month to month) at 1,000 subscribers and $1,140 a year at 5,000, according to an independent check. beehiiv takes 0% of paid-subscription revenue; Stripe’s fee still applies. Its help says a new Stripe account is created through its setup and an existing one cannot be connected, and Ghost’s migration guide says that account cannot be reused on another platform; those are competitors’ documents, so we treat them as credible but unconfirmed. Its terms make fees non-refundable and say beehiiv need not keep your data after you cancel. The price change drew public complaints, and on August 21 an upstream provider fault left about a fifth of large publications with part of an issue undelivered until beehiiv resent it. Pricing, independent price check, Stripe account types, July 8, 2026, Ghost’s beehiiv guide, terms, October 6, 2026, PPC Land, October 8, 2026, status history
Mailchimp (no total). A general marketing service rather than a publishing tool, strongest when customer data already flows into it from a store. Its Free plan allows 250 contacts and 500 sends a month without scheduling; on November 12 its page listed Essentials at $13 a month and Standard at $20 for 500 contacts, and showed no price for 1,000 or 5,000. We found no native paid-newsletter feature, and subscribed, unsubscribed and non-subscribed contacts all count toward your plan. Its account export is the most complete record of opt-outs here. In January 2023 Mailchimp disclosed unauthorized access to an internal support tool affecting 133 accounts; that is a historical disclosure, not evidence of a current breach. Pricing, contact types and billing, account exports, incident notice
| Tool | Public sources | What remains uncertain |
|---|---|---|
| Magic Pages | Pricing page (November 12, 2026), help on email allowance, sending domain, backups, data retention and updates, terms, service level agreement, data processing agreement, 2026 post-mortems (January 29, May 19, October 20), Ghost help and security advisories. | Inbox placement; support quality; its status history beyond its own post-mortems; whether extra emails can be capped; a paid-member move between Ghost hosts. |
| Synaps Media | Pricing page (November 12, 2026), home page, help on newsletter credits, sending domain and team, terms (April 3, 2026), imprint, status history, Ghost forum thread. | Whether it charges any transaction fee; how long data is kept after an account ends; whether any public release came before 2025; long-term reliability. |
| Buttondown | Pricing calculator, Stripe and paid-subscription docs, export and deletion docs, account review, website terms, DPA, September 2026 postmortems. | A service agreement covering billing, refunds and closure; the exact quote at checkout; an incident report listed on its blog that we did not open; inbox placement. |
| Ghost(Pro) | Pricing page and its published price table (November 12, 2026), Ghost help on Stripe, member import and exports, terms, status history, security advisories, CybelAngel report. | Inbox placement on shared sending; support quality. |
| Kit | Pricing page, Free-plan help, September 2026 export guide, terms, October 2026 privacy policy. | Whether paying subscribers can leave without re-subscribing; Creator price above 1,000 subscribers. |
| Substack | Help on costs, Stripe, exports, deletion and custom domains; terms of use; Security Affairs report. | Whether exports include unsubscribed readers; a paid-subscriber move in practice. |
| WordPress.com | Pricing, newsletter and paid-newsletter pages (November 12, 2026). | Renewal terms; export of paid subscribers; sending from your own domain; incident record. |
| Steady | Pricing, newsletter and legal pages (November 12, 2026). | Export, support and incident record; custom-domain options. |
| MailerLite | Pricing page, help on Stripe selling, archive, blogs, custom domains, exports, cancelling and deletion, terms (September 22, 2026), status history, Decrypt report. | Whether paid subscribers move cleanly to another service; inbox placement; the February 2026 root cause; prices at 1,000 and 5,000 subscribers come from an October reading of its price table. |
| beehiiv | Pricing page, October 2026 Stripe, troubleshooting and export help, October 2026 terms, status history, independent price checks, Ghost’s migration guide. | How a paid-subscriber move away works in practice; what existing customers pay after renewal; the 5,000-subscriber price comes from an independent source. |
| Mailchimp | Pricing page (November 12, 2026), contact billing help, export documentation, terms, DPA, 2023 incident notice. | Prices at 1,000 and 5,000 contacts; any native paid-newsletter route. |
Nothing here establishes inbox placement, sending speed, support quality or a successful migration. Next substantive review is due December 18, 2026, after beehiiv’s renewal pricing takes effect, or sooner if a plan or term changes. Found a changed price or term? Contact the editors.
Sources and evidence
Sources were checked October 19, 2026 for Buttondown, Kit, beehiiv and Mailchimp, October 20, 2026 for Magic Pages, Synaps Media, Ghost(Pro), Substack and MailerLite, and November 12, 2026 for plan prices and the WordPress.com, Steady and newcomer pages, unless another date is given. Vendor pages establish what is offered and promised, not how the service performs. Prices are USD unless stated and exclude processing fees and tax.
- Magic Pages: pricing; about; email allowance, October 8, 2026; extra emails, July 25, 2026; sending domain, August 23, 2026; own Mailgun account not needed, July 25, 2026; trial and memberships, July 25, 2026; backups, October 6, 2026; data after cancelling, December 11, 2025; lifetime plans, July 26, 2026; updates, May 14, 2026; continuity plan, July 25, 2026; terms, October 19, 2026; service level agreement; data processing agreement, September 7, 2026; March 2026 plan change; post-mortems for January 29, May 19 and October 20, 2026. User discussion: Ghost forum thread, 2024 to 2026.
- Synaps Media (prices before VAT; euros on October 20, dollars on November 12): pricing; home page; about; imprint, August 2026; terms, April 3, 2026; team and pricing, November 28, 2025; newsletter credits, September 23, 2026; custom sending domain, January 31, 2026; status history. User discussion: Ghost forum launch thread, January 2025.
- Buttondown: pricing; features; paid subscriptions; Stripe integration; paid subscription docs; account review; subscriber export; export API; periodic exports, April 15, 2025; deleting and recovering data; terms; data processing agreement; privacy; postmortems for September 1 and September 9, 2026.
- Kit: pricing; Free plan; export guide, September 4, 2026; terms, September 5, 2025; privacy, October 9, 2026.
- Ghost(Pro) and the Ghost software: pricing and its published price table; about the Ghost Foundation; connecting Stripe; importing members; exports; terms; status history; security advisories; releases. Independent: CybelAngel, May 26, 2026.
- Substack: what Substack costs, September 29, 2026; custom domains, October 1, 2026; Stripe setup, August 24, 2026; one Stripe account per publication, December 29, 2024; export posts, December 12, 2023; export the list, June 4, 2026; delete a publication, April 11, 2024; terms of use, October 6, 2026. Independent: Security Affairs, February 5, 2026.
- MailerLite: pricing page, read October 20, 2026; paid newsletter subscriptions; paid newsletter comparison; selling with Stripe, April 15, 2026; newsletter archive, March 7, 2025; blogs, October 30, 2023; custom domains, May 26, 2026; exporting subscribers, April 14, 2026; newsletter as PDF, August 25, 2026; cancelling, June 16, 2026; deleting your account, July 6, 2026; terms, September 22, 2026; status history. Independent: Decrypt, January 24, 2024.
- beehiiv (read through a page-fetching service; plain automated requests were refused): pricing; Stripe account types, July 8, 2026; paid subscription troubleshooting, October 9, 2026; Stripe setup, October 1, 2026; exports, October 9, 2026; terms, October 6, 2026; privacy; MCP guide; status history. Independent: price check, October 9, 2026; PricingSaaS plan change record, October 2, 2026; PPC Land, October 8, 2026. Competitor documentation: Ghost’s beehiiv migration guide; Magic Pages migration toolkit, December 2025.
- Mailchimp: pricing; integrations; contact types; account exports; terms; DPA; privacy; January 2023 incident statement; third-party price summary, September 15, 2026.
- WordPress.com (November 12, 2026): pricing; newsletters; paid newsletters and fees.
- Steady (November 12, 2026): pricing; newsletters; legal policy.
- Newcomers screened on October 20 and November 12, 2026: Hyvor Post pricing; Paragraph pricing and writers page; Markdown Ninja repository; Picoletter pricing and repository; Letterbird; LetterBucket pricing and terms; Midnight about page; DigitalPress launch thread, January 2020; PikaPods Ghost notes; Synaps Media on Hacker News, February 2025. Set aside: Flodesk pricing.
- Outside evidence, read September 6, 2026: the three TechRadar reviews, Reddit thread and Hacker News discussion linked in What people are saying.
This is a researched comparison, not a product review. Links are not affiliate links. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.