A music subscription for one listener: Spotify, Deezer, Amazon Music and YouTube Music

Spotify costs $1 a month more than Apple Music, but if you stop paying it keeps your playlists on its free tier. Deezer saves on annual billing, Amazon includes an audiobook each month, and YouTube Music adds videos and fan uploads.

PRACTICAL PICKSPreferredPickOur Preferred PickOne listener across devices$12.99/mo

Spotify Premium Individual

Plays across phones, computers and compatible connected speakers, includes lossless and 15 audiobook hours, and keeps your playlists and saved music on the free tier if you cancel.

Its lead is narrow because the other services’ library-retention evidence is less explicit. $1 a month more than Apple Music. Usage data is shared for tailored ads unless you opt out, and Discovery Mode can weight some recommendations.

Why Spotify is our Pick
Newcomer assessment

No Rising Star selected

CodaMusic has an Android listing and current prices, but its app already existed in 2019; the announced Winamp subscription is due in 2027.

CodaMusic’s Windows and Mac availability is unclear; Cantilever and Nina Protocol could not be checked.

Who is this article for? One US listener choosing, keeping or switching a paid music streaming subscription for a phone, a computer and connected speakers. Individual plans only; not family, student or bundled plans.

About 20 min read

What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean

The quick list

Start with Spotify for a library you can keep using when you pause. One listener on an individual plan: compare the monthly price, then where each service plays and what you keep if you stop paying.

Recurring US individual plans checked November 2, 2026. Excludes trials, student, duo, family and bundled plans, sales tax and audio hardware. Annual plans require upfront payment. We could not confirm suitable US prices for Tidal, Pandora or iHeart.

The comparison at a glance

Compare recurring prices, where each service plays, download limits and what happens to your library when you stop paying.

Spotify leads for one listener across devices, followed by Deezer, Amazon Music Unlimited and YouTube Music among scored services. Its lead is narrow because other services’ library-retention evidence is less explicit.

US individual music streaming subscriptions
FeatureSpotifyDeezerAmazon Music UnlimitedYouTube Music
Where it fitsOur Pick: one listener across phone, computer and speakers who may pauseAnnual savings, Flow mixes and uploaded MP3 filesAmazon devices, HD audio and an included audiobookOfficial songs, videos, live recordings and fan uploads
US individual monthly price$12.99 Premium Individual$11.99 Premium$12.99 Unlimited without Prime$11.99 Individual
Yearly billing optionNone shown for Premium Individual$107.99 upfront for 12 monthsNo non-Prime annual option shown; $155.88 for 12 monthly payments$119.99 upfront for 12 months; does not automatically renew
Weighted assessment / 53.853.553.473.43
Where it playsMobile, desktop and web apps; Spotify Connect to compatible speakers and TVsPhone, tablet, desktop and web; selected home devices and speakersAndroid, iOS, Windows, Mac and web; Fire devices and compatible Echo and Sonos speakersSmartphones, laptops, tablets, smart TVs; Sonos and Google Assistant speakers
Published audio formatUp to 24-bit/44.1 kHz FLAC, including compatible Connect devicesHigh-fidelity audio included; resolution ceiling not confirmedHD and Spatial Audio advertised; What Hi-Fi documents Ultra HD contentCompressed audio; What Hi-Fi describes 256 kbps
Downloads for travel10,000 tracks on each of up to 5 devices; online every 30 daysDownloads included with Premium; recheck interval not confirmedDownloads for travel documented by PCMag; recheck interval not confirmedDownloads included with Premium; recheck interval not confirmed
If you stop payingSwitches to Free; playlists and saved music stayAccount-based cancellation; free tier exists; playlist retention not confirmedCancel in Amazon Music Settings at term end; playlist retention not confirmedCancel through Paid Membership page; free listening exists; playlist retention not confirmed
Moving a library inTune My Music in the mobile app; sign in to the old serviceHomepage offers music transfer; matching completeness unverifiedLibrary transfer completeness not confirmedTune My Music lists transfer support; matching completeness unverified
Listening data and recommendationsUsage data shared for tailored ads (opt-out setting); Discovery Mode commission can weight songsListening history and advertising-related processing; privacy controlsActivity-based recommendations and interest-based ads under Amazon privacy noticeGoogle activity collection, personalized advertising and account controls
Main reason to choose another$1 a month more than Apple Music; ad-related data processing unless you opt outAnnual payment upfront; less explicit retention guidance than SpotifySame non-Prime monthly price as Spotify; less explicit playlist-retention guidanceNo lossless playback; less explicit retention guidance than Spotify

Spotify is our recommendation for one listener across devices who may pause. Individual US prices checked November 2, 2026; other Spotify evidence checked October 19, 2026. Spotify’s lead is narrow because other services’ library-retention evidence is less explicit. Annual plans require upfront payment; travel downloads remain conditional on paying.

All features and sources 16 criteria

Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.

Price, library and listening

Show 7 criteria
Price, library and listening
FeatureSpotifyDeezerAmazon Music UnlimitedYouTube Music
Where it fitsOur Pick: one listener across phone, computer and speakers who may pauseAnnual savings, Flow mixes and uploaded MP3 filesAmazon devices, HD audio and an included audiobookOfficial songs, videos, live recordings and fan uploads
US individual monthly price$12.99 Premium Individual$11.99 Premium$12.99 Unlimited without Prime$11.99 Individual
Yearly billing optionNone shown for Premium Individual$107.99 upfront for 12 monthsNo non-Prime annual option shown; $155.88 for 12 monthly payments$119.99 upfront for 12 months; does not automatically renew
Cost assessment / 53.363.753.363.65
Weighted assessment / 53.853.553.473.43
Discovery and library toolsDiscover Weekly, Release Radar, mixes, DJ, artist snooze, Autoplay offFlow mixes, playlists, radio, podcasts and MP3 uploads via websiteOn-demand catalog, mixes, podcasts and one audiobook each monthPersonalized mixes alongside official tracks, videos and fan uploads
Distinct included or extra benefit15 audiobook hours a monthUpload MP3s from a computer to listen elsewhereOne audiobook each month; Prime discount requires separate membershipVideos, live performances and fan uploads alongside official songs
Sources for price, library and listening

Prices checked November 2, 2026: Spotify, Deezer, YouTube Music, Amazon Music Unlimited. US direct individual plans, excluding tax, trials, bundles and hardware. Annual plans require upfront payment. Scores use the least expensive suitable billing option. Spotify’s lead is narrow because other services’ library-retention evidence is less explicit.

Playback, travel and ownership

Show 5 criteria
Playback, travel and ownership
FeatureSpotifyDeezerAmazon Music UnlimitedYouTube Music
Where it playsMobile, desktop and web apps; Spotify Connect to compatible speakers and TVsPhone, tablet, desktop and web; selected home devices and speakersAndroid, iOS, Windows, Mac and web; Fire devices and compatible Echo and Sonos speakersSmartphones, laptops, tablets, smart TVs; Sonos and Google Assistant speakers
Published audio formatUp to 24-bit/44.1 kHz FLAC, including compatible Connect devicesHigh-fidelity audio included; resolution ceiling not confirmedHD and Spatial Audio advertised; What Hi-Fi documents Ultra HD contentCompressed audio; What Hi-Fi describes 256 kbps
Downloads for travel10,000 tracks on each of up to 5 devices; online every 30 daysDownloads included with Premium; recheck interval not confirmedDownloads for travel documented by PCMag; recheck interval not confirmedDownloads included with Premium; recheck interval not confirmed
Library or download warningReinstalling or an out-of-date app can remove downloadsCheck the exact speaker model; download ceiling not confirmedCheck the exact speaker and supported formats; download ceiling not confirmedRecordings and uploads can become unavailable; download ceiling not confirmed
What you can keepSubscription downloads are not owned filesSubscription access; uploaded MP3 originals remain yoursPurchased music is separate from subscription catalog accessSubscription downloads are conditional access rather than owned files
Sources for playback, travel and ownership

Spotify device and download evidence checked October 19, 2026: Spotify benefits, Connect. November 2, 2026: Deezer features, YouTube plans and devices, Amazon offer, PCMag comparison, What Hi-Fi comparison. Published formats do not establish audible superiority.

Switching, leaving and data

Show 4 criteria
Switching, leaving and data
FeatureSpotifyDeezerAmazon Music UnlimitedYouTube Music
Moving a library inTune My Music in the mobile app; sign in to the old serviceHomepage offers music transfer; matching completeness unverifiedLibrary transfer completeness not confirmedTune My Music lists transfer support; matching completeness unverified
If you stop payingSwitches to Free; playlists and saved music stayAccount-based cancellation; free tier exists; playlist retention not confirmedCancel in Amazon Music Settings at term end; playlist retention not confirmedCancel through Paid Membership page; free listening exists; playlist retention not confirmed
Listening data and recommendationsUsage data shared for tailored ads (opt-out setting); Discovery Mode commission can weight songsListening history and advertising-related processing; privacy controlsActivity-based recommendations and interest-based ads under Amazon privacy noticeGoogle activity collection, personalized advertising and account controls
Main reason to choose another$1 a month more than Apple Music; ad-related data processing unless you opt outAnnual payment upfront; less explicit retention guidance than SpotifySame non-Prime monthly price as Spotify; less explicit playlist-retention guidanceNo lossless playback; less explicit retention guidance than Spotify
Sources for switching, leaving and data

What matters when choosing

Spotify Premium Individual is our Practical Pick for one US listener who wants a single paid music service on a phone, a computer and connected speakers, and wants to keep a usable library if they ever stop paying. It costs $12.99 a month, $1 more than Apple Music. What separates it is what happens after you commit. If you cancel, Spotify says your account moves to its free, ad-supported service at the end of the paid period and you keep your playlists and saved music. Apple says that when an Apple Music subscription expires, catalog songs and playlists built from them stop being available. Premium also includes lossless playback up to 24-bit/44.1 kHz on its apps and on compatible Spotify Connect speakers, and 15 hours a month of audiobook listening. Spotify leads the scored alternatives, with a narrow lead because the others’ library-retention terms are less explicit. The main compromises are price and data. Paying removes audio ads, but Spotify’s privacy policy still describes sharing usage data with advertising partners for tailored ads unless you turn that off, and its Discovery Mode lets artists and labels pay Spotify a commission on streams to have songs weighted in some personalized recommendations. Spotify plans, Spotify cancellation, Apple cancellation, Premium benefits, privacy policy, how recommendations work

If you live mostly in Apple’s ecosystem, keep your own music files, or want a lower monthly price, choose Apple Music. It costs $11.99 a month and includes its Classical app, Spatial Audio and lossless up to 24-bit/192 kHz, though resolutions above 48 kHz need an external converter on iPhone, iPad and most Macs. Its Sync Library puts your own files alongside the catalog on every signed-in device, but Apple says it is not a backup service. Read its exit terms before you build a large library: catalog playlists stop working when the subscription lapses. Apple Music plans, lossless requirements, Sync Library

Choose Deezer for annual savings and MP3 uploads, or YouTube Music for videos and fan recordings. Deezer Premium is $107.99 a year paid upfront; YouTube Music Premium is $119.99 for 12 months. Both also offer $11.99 monthly plans. Neither gives the same explicit playlist-retention assurance as Spotify in the material we could read. Deezer plans, YouTube Music plans, checked November 2, 2026.

Our prices are the recurring US individual plans checked November 2, 2026. They exclude introductory trials, student, duo and family plans, bundles such as Apple One, sales tax and the hardware some audio features need. A library built around your own music files or Apple devices favors Apple Music; buying high-resolution albums favors Qobuz. For a tight budget and uninterrupted listening, Deezer’s $107.99 annual prepayment is the lowest confirmed yearly cost here, followed by YouTube Music’s $119.99 for 12 months. Apple’s monthly billing totals $143.88 a year. If you prefer to pay month by month, Apple, Deezer and YouTube Music each cost $11.99, $1 less than Spotify; annual savings require paying upfront. Before you move, search for several favorite albums, including the exact editions you want. A catalog total does not prove a particular recording is available, and Apple’s own transfer instructions warn that some songs arrive as alternate versions or not at all. No subscription download in this comparison is a music file you own. Apple transfer review

Disclosure: Practical Picks articles are researched and written with AI, currently Anthropic’s Claude. Spotify makes an official Claude connector. We have no relationship with Spotify or Anthropic over this article, and these Claude links carried no weight in our judgment. Spotify announcement

Spotify

Preferred Pick · one listener across devices

$12.99/moPremium Individual · monthly

Choose Spotify Premium Individual for one paid music service across phone, computer and connected speakers, especially if you might pause: cancelling drops you to the free tier with your playlists and saved music intact.

Reasons to choose it

  • Keeps playlists and saved music on the free tier after you cancel
  • Spotify Connect plays to compatible speakers, displays and TVs
  • Lossless up to 24-bit/44.1 kHz and 15 audiobook hours a month included

What to watch

  • $1 a month more than Apple Music
  • Usage data shared for tailored ads unless you opt out
  • Discovery Mode lets labels pay a commission to weight some recommendations

Spotify Premium Individual costs $12.99 a month for one account after a one-month free trial for people who have not tried Premium. It includes ad-free music, downloads, lossless playback up to 24-bit/44.1 kHz FLAC on mobile, desktop and tablet apps and on compatible Spotify Connect devices, and 15 hours a month from its audiobook subscriber catalog. Those hours are not unlimited audiobooks; more time costs extra. Spotify Connect lets one device control playback on another, such as a phone running a speaker, smart display or TV, but each device must be compatible and not every one supports lossless, so check the exact model first. US plans, Premium benefits, Spotify Connect

The deciding reason to choose it is the exit. When you cancel, Premium stays until your next billing date and the account then switches to Spotify’s free service, which keeps your playlists and saved music. You lose Premium features such as downloads and ad-free listening, but the library you built remains usable, which matters if you might pause for a few months or try another service. If a phone carrier or other partner bills your plan, you cancel through that partner. Cancel Premium

Read the full Spotify analysis and sources

Spotify documents more ways to shape recommendations than the others: Discover Weekly, Release Radar, mixes, its DJ feature, the option to snooze an artist for 30 days and the option to turn off Autoplay. That gives an existing listener good reasons to stay if those tools already work. It does not show that a new listener will like its suggestions more than Apple’s or Qobuz’s. Spotify also says commercial considerations may influence recommendations. When an artist or label turns on Discovery Mode for a song, Spotify adds that signal to personalized listening sessions and takes a commission on those streams; it says Discovery Mode is not active in its editorial playlists. How Spotify recommendations work, updated March 12, 2026

Downloads are for travel, not an archive. Spotify allows up to 10,000 tracks on each of up to five devices, and you must go online at least once every 30 days to keep them. Reinstalling the app, letting it fall out of date or adding a sixth device can remove downloads. Source: Spotify’s download guidance, checked October 19, 2026.

Moving a library in uses Tune My Music inside Spotify’s mobile app. You sign in to the other service and allow access, then choose what to transfer; Spotify sends import problems to Tune My Music’s support. We found no published matching rate, so check the result against your source library. Import your playlists

Spotify’s privacy policy, effective July 1, 2026, covers streaming history, searches, playlists, prompts typed into its AI features and device information. It describes sharing usage data with advertising partners so they and Spotify can show more relevant ads on Spotify and elsewhere online, which some state laws treat as “sharing or selling”; a Tailored Ads setting lets you opt out. Paying for Premium removes audio ads, not that processing. Spotify privacy policy

Used Spotify? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Deezer

Also consider · annual savings and MP3 uploads

$11.99/moPremium · $107.99 paid annually

Choose Deezer Premium for lower annual cost, Flow mixes and a library that can include uploaded MP3s.

Reasons to choose it

  • Lowest confirmed annual price among these four services
  • On-demand music, travel downloads and high-fidelity audio
  • Upload MP3s through the website

What to watch

  • Annual billing means paying a year upfront
  • Playlist retention after cancellation is not clearly documented
  • Check your exact connected speaker model

Deezer Premium costs $11.99 a month or $107.99 paid for a year, the lowest confirmed annual price among these four services. Its November 2, 2026 US offer includes on-demand, ad-free listening, travel downloads and high-fidelity audio. The free tier lacks those paid features, so it does not replace Premium for this listener. The annual payment buys a year of access; cancelling does not promise a refund for unused months. US plans, terms, articles 7–8, checked November 2, 2026.

Choose it if you like its Flow mixes or want to bring MP3 files into your streaming library. PCMag describes uploading MP3s through the website and then listening from other devices; it also describes music, radio and podcasts. Deezer lists phone, tablet and desktop access and casting to selected home devices. Check your speaker model before paying for a year. Deezer devices and features, PCMag comparison, checked November 2, 2026.

Read the full Deezer analysis and sources

Spotify remains our choice if keeping a usable library through a subscription break is your priority. Deezer provides account-based cancellation and a free service, but the pages we could read do not give the same explicit assurance about keeping your playlists after cancellation. Its privacy notice covers listening history and advertising-related processing; cheaper does not mean private. Terms, privacy notice, updated September 2025, checked November 2, 2026.

Used Deezer? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Amazon Music Unlimited

Also consider · Amazon devices and an audiobook

$12.99/moUnlimited Individual · monthly without Prime

Choose Amazon Music Unlimited for compatible Amazon and Sonos devices, HD audio and an included audiobook each month.

Reasons to choose it

  • On-demand catalog, HD and Spatial Audio
  • Desktop, mobile, web and compatible connected speakers
  • One audiobook each month included

What to watch

  • Prime discount needs a separate membership
  • Playlist retention after cancellation is not clearly documented
  • Check the exact speaker and supported audio formats

Amazon Music Unlimited costs $12.99 a month without Prime, or $155.88 over a year of monthly payments. Its US offer advertises 100 million songs on demand, HD and Spatial Audio, and one audiobook each month. The $11.99 Prime price requires a separate membership; we do not assume you already have one. The introductory 30-day trial is not the recurring cost. Amazon offer, checked November 2, 2026.

What Hi-Fi documents Android and iOS apps, Windows and Mac desktop apps or web playback, Fire devices and compatible Echo and Sonos speakers. PCMag describes downloads for travel. Check your exact speaker and playback setup before assuming every audio format will work. These are published capabilities, not our listening results. What Hi-Fi comparison, PCMag comparison, checked November 2, 2026.

Read the full Amazon Music Unlimited analysis and sources

You can cancel a direct subscription in Amazon Music Settings, with effect at the end of the paid term; payments are generally nonrefundable. Purchased music and subscription access are distinct. We could not confirm the same explicit promise Spotify makes about keeping a usable playlist library after cancellation. Amazon’s privacy notice covers activity-based recommendations and interest-based advertising. Choose Spotify if its documented free fallback matters more than Amazon’s device and audiobook offering. Amazon Music terms, sections 1.5 and 5.3, privacy notice, checked November 2, 2026.

Used Amazon Music Unlimited? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

YouTube Music

Also consider · videos, live recordings and fan uploads

$11.99/moIndividual · $119.99 for 12 months upfront

Choose YouTube Music Premium when music videos and recordings outside the standard album catalog matter more than lossless playback.

Reasons to choose it

  • Official recordings alongside videos and fan uploads
  • Downloads and background listening included
  • Annual plan does not renew automatically

What to watch

  • Compressed audio rather than lossless
  • Playlist retention after cancellation is not clearly documented
  • Google collects activity data for personalization and advertising

YouTube Music Premium combines official releases with videos, live performances and material uploaded by fans. Its US individual offer is $11.99 a month or $119.99 for 12 months paid upfront; the annual plan does not renew automatically. Premium adds ad-free music, downloads and background listening. The free service cannot cover this listener’s travel and background-play needs. Music Premium plans, checked November 2, 2026.

Choose it when recordings outside a conventional album catalog matter more than lossless playback. YouTube lists smartphones, laptops, tablets and smart TVs; What Hi-Fi describes Sonos and Google Assistant speaker support and compressed 256 kbps audio. Neither source guarantees that a particular upload or recording will stay available. Plans and devices, What Hi-Fi comparison, checked November 2, 2026.

Read the full YouTube Music analysis and sources

You can cancel through the Paid Membership page. Monthly access continues through the paid period, normally without a refund for unused days. Its free listening service is useful when you stop paying, but we could not confirm a playlist-retention promise equivalent to Spotify’s. Google’s privacy policy covers activity collection and personalized advertising, with account controls and export options; Premium removes music ads rather than all data processing. Paid-service terms, section 4, Google privacy, checked November 2, 2026.

Used YouTube Music? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Which product are we missing?

Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.

Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.

Suggest a product

Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.

No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.

What people are saying

Public user reports are a check on vendor claims, not a satisfaction score. A March 2026 Spotify community discussion contains complaints about repetitive recommendations alongside replies describing good discoveries. A September 2026 Apple Music discussion shows confusion about what survives a subscription break; we rely on Apple’s cancellation policy for the consequence, not commenters’ conflicting accounts. Spotify recommendations discussion, Apple Music cancellation discussion

An August 2026 Qobuz discussion raises concerns about travel playlists and cellular data use, which we could not verify. A January 2026 Tom’s Guide first-person account preferred Qobuz’s recommendations to Spotify’s. That challenges any claim of a universal Spotify discovery advantage without establishing the opposite. Qobuz community discussion read September 7, 2026; Tom’s Guide account

These are a small, self-selected sample, read on September 7, 2026, with incomplete plan and device context; all four sources were still reachable on October 19. We did not compile app-store star averages. Our October 19 search for newer complaints, outages, lawsuits and regulatory actions involving the three services found nothing that changed these conclusions; a search that finds nothing is not proof that nothing exists.

How we researched

This is public-source research. We did not create accounts, sign in, subscribe, install apps, play or download music, connect a library or contact the companies. No company supplied access, payment or review of these conclusions, and the links are not affiliate links. We first compared these services on September 7, 2026 and rechecked the material claims on October 19, 2026: prices and trials, included features, device lists, lossless conditions, travel limits, transfer tools, cancellation and account-deletion terms, and privacy policies. Where a page shows a publication or update date, the article gives it.

We initially chose three services for one US listener paying for music: the largest discovery-focused service, Apple’s service with its synced library, and a smaller service built around albums and high-resolution downloads. We judged them on everyday listening fit, recurring cost, device reach and playback conditions, what you keep when you stop paying, and data and recommendation terms. We fixed those criteria and their weights before comparing the services. Giving more weight to price and privacy and less to leaving narrows the gap to Apple Music, and a library of your own files favors Apple Music; it remains an alternative for those priorities. The November 2, 2026 comparison also considers Deezer, Amazon Music Unlimited and YouTube Music under the same criteria. Spotify remains our recommendation: its documented free fallback matters more for this reader than the annual savings elsewhere. Deezer is next for annual value, followed by Amazon Music Unlimited for its device and audiobook offering, then YouTube Music for its mix of recordings. Family and student plans remain outside this comparison.

On November 2, 2026 we examined current vendor offers, a Google Play search for CodaMusic, and the PCMag and What Hi-Fi streaming comparisons alongside our October 19 launch research. No Rising Star is selected. CodaMusic now advertises $11.99 a month and has an Android listing, but its app existed in 2019; a later full-catalog launch does not establish a new product. Its terms mention desktop applications without establishing availability on both Windows and Mac. Winamp’s announced subscription is due in 2027, while its current homepage describes a player and artist services. We could not check Nina Protocol’s current site or Cantilever’s current offer. CodaMusic, Android search, CodaMusic terms, Winamp, checked November 2, 2026.

Apple Music Individual scores 3.34/5 and remains a useful alternative for Apple devices and your own music files. At $11.99 a month ($143.88 over a year), it shares the lower monthly price of Deezer and YouTube Music, while their annual prepayment costs less. Sync Library puts your files alongside the catalog; keep your originals because Apple says it is not a backup. Classical, Spatial Audio and lossless up to 24-bit/192 kHz are included, with an external converter needed above 48 kHz on iPhone, iPad and most Macs. Catalog songs and playlists stop being available when the subscription lapses, and the retention grace period is unspecified. Apple Music, price checked November 2, 2026; Sync Library, lossless, cancellation, privacy, other evidence checked October 19, 2026.

Qobuz Studio remains worth considering for album listeners who buy high-resolution downloads. Its US price is $12.99 monthly or $129.99 annually, confirmed November 2, 2026. It scores 3.21/5 for this listener, behind Spotify (3.85), Deezer (3.55), Amazon Music Unlimited (3.47) and YouTube Music (3.43). Its 2,000-song playlist limit and conflicting reinstall guidance remain drawbacks. Download and back up purchases before deleting the account: deletion ends access to redownload them. LiveOne Premium, at $10.99 monthly, scores 2.93: on-demand listening and downloads are included, but its public terms do not establish a comparable library fallback. Qobuz Studio, Qobuz terms, section 12, LiveOne plans, LiveOne terms, prices checked November 2, 2026; Qobuz feature and deletion evidence checked October 19, 2026.

We could not confirm suitable US prices for Tidal, Pandora or iHeart. SoundCloud Go+ publishes $11.99 monthly; its privacy policy describes listening-data collection, advertising and opt-outs, but we could not confirm its exit terms. These services have no overall score here. Spotify leads all scored alternatives when we give price differences either more or less influence; its lead is narrow because the other services’ library-retention evidence is less explicit. Pandora offer, SoundCloud Go+, SoundCloud privacy, checked November 2, 2026.

ToolPublic sourcesWhat remains uncertain
SpotifyUS plans, Premium benefits, Connect, downloads, import, cancellation, recommendations page and July 2026 privacy policy.Personal recommendation quality, lossless support on a given speaker, import completeness and reliability.
Apple MusicUS plans and device list, July 2026 price report, lossless, Sync Library, transfer, cancellation, privacy notice and September 2026 media terms.Length of the post-cancellation grace period, audible benefit on your equipment and transfer completeness.
QobuzNovember 2 Studio offer; October 19 device, travel-download, playlist, transfer and cancellation evidence.Whether downloads survive a reinstall, transfer completeness and Connect support for a given model.
DeezerNovember 2 US offer, homepage, terms, privacy and PCMag comparison.Playlist retention after cancellation and compatibility with your speaker.
Amazon Music UnlimitedNovember 2 US offer, Music terms, privacy, PCMag and What Hi-Fi comparisons.Playlist retention after cancellation and compatibility with your speaker.
YouTube MusicNovember 2 individual plans, paid-service terms, Google privacy and What Hi-Fi comparison.Playlist retention after cancellation and availability of a particular recording.
Newer servicesNovember 2 CodaMusic homepage, Android search, terms and Winamp homepage; October 19 launch research.CodaMusic desktop availability; current Cantilever and Nina Protocol offers. No newer service earned a recommendation.

None of this establishes sound quality, recommendation quality, catalog completeness for a particular album or reliability in use. Next substantive review is due January 17, 2027, or sooner after a material price, policy or feature change. Found a changed price or term? Contact the editors.

Sources and evidence

Sources were checked October 19, 2026 unless another date is given. November 2, 2026 checks cover the additional services and pricing described above; other incumbent evidence remains from October 19. Company pages establish published offers and terms, not performance. Prices are public US offers, not completed checkouts. Community posts are attributed experiences, not representative samples.

This is a researched comparison, not a product review. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.