Composing your first instrumental track: GarageBand, Gridline, Cakewalk Sonar, Nota and BandLab Studio

On a Mac, GarageBand is the most complete free place to start. On Windows or Linux, Gridline, a free open-source studio with a large set of built-in instruments, is our Rising Star; on a Windows 11 PC with 16 GB of memory and an 8-core processor, Cakewalk Sonar scores slightly higher for you, and if you can only use a browser or a phone, choose BandLab Studio.

PRACTICAL PICKSPreferredPickOur Preferred PickA first track on a Mac$0

GarageBand

Three ways to enter notes without a controller, a large free library of instruments, drummers and loops, and a current Apple manual.

Mac only, and the current version needs macOS 15.6 or later. Apple’s guide documents importing MIDI files, not exporting them.

Why GarageBand is our Pick
PRACTICAL PICKSRisingStarOur Rising StarFree and open source, no account$0

Gridline

A free, open-source studio for Windows, Mac and Linux with a step sequencer, a piano roll with chord, strum and arpeggio tools, 178 built-in instruments and effects and a demo song made only from them.

It is a new, fast-changing 0.7 release from one main developer, and its installers are not signed, so Windows and macOS ask you to confirm the first launch.

Why Gridline earned Rising Star

Who is this article for? People writing their first original instrumental piece on a Mac or Windows PC, or on Linux, who will enter notes with a mouse or computer keyboard, use the instruments that come with the software and not pay to start.

About 37 min read

What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean

The quick list

All five are free to start. Compare what runs on your computer, what needs an account, where your project is kept, and which composing tools cost extra.

Software prices checked October 19 and 20, 2026, and again November 12. All five are free to use for a first track. Optional extra: BandLab Membership for Cakewalk Sonar and BandLab Studio. Gridline and Nota have no paid tier. Your computer must meet each program’s requirements.

The comparison at a glance

Compare how you enter notes, which instruments come included, what each needs from your computer and account, and how you keep and export your work.

Order follows our verdict for a first instrumental track: the Preferred Pick, the Rising Star, then the other three by our fixed criteria, not sound quality or ease of use, which we did not test. All tools remain selectable.

Free software for composing a first instrumental track
FeatureGarageBandGridlineCakewalk SonarNotaBandLab Studio
Best fitPreferred Pick: a first track on a Mac with macOS 15.6 or laterRising Star: free and open source on Windows, Mac or Linux, with no accountAlso consider: a Windows 11 PC with 16 GB of memory and an 8-core processor, for more extensive note editingFree and open source on Windows, Mac or Linux, with about 35 built-in instruments and effectsAlso consider: a browser or a phone only, with a BandLab account and 16-track projects
Runs on, checked October 19 to November 12, 2026Mac only; macOS 15.6 or laterWindows 10/11 (x64 and ARM64); macOS 11 or later; Linux and BSD systemsWindows 11; installs on Windows 10 but not officially supportedWindows 10/11 (x64 and ARM64); macOS 13 or later (Apple Silicon and Intel); LinuxA web browser on a computer, or BandLab’s iPhone and Android apps
Account and activationApple Account for the Mac App StoreNone; its installers are not signed, so Windows and macOS ask you to confirm the first launchFree BandLab account; license renews periodically through activationNone; its installers are not signed, so Windows and macOS ask you to confirm the first launchFree BandLab account; projects are stored online
Entering notes without a keyboard controllerDraw in the Piano Roll, type with Musical Typing or write in the Score EditorDraw in the piano roll, program the step sequencer, play the typing keyboard, or generate a chord progression that writes into a patternMulti-track piano roll and step sequencer; play BandLab instruments from the computer keyboardDraw in the piano roll, with one-click arpeggio, strum and ornament tools; play from the computer keyboard, a MIDI keyboard or a phoneDraw notes in the MIDI editor, then quantize or transpose them from the computer keyboard; Drum Machine for beats
Instruments in the free versionSoftware instruments, Drummer and Apple Loops; more patches, drummers and loops as free downloads178 built-in instruments and effects (52 instruments in its plug-in suite) and a demo song made only from themBandLab Instruments with limited free-tier access (sound banks download on first use) and XSampler; TTS-1 removedAbout 35 built-in instruments and effects, including subtractive, wavetable, FM, granular and physical-modelling synths and a drum machineMore than 400 virtual instruments, by BandLab’s count, a Drum Machine, a Sampler and BandLab Sounds loops
What costs extraNothing needed for this jobNothing; free softwareBandLab Membership: BandLab Sounds loops, Core Plugin Suite, more arranger tracksNothing; free softwareBandLab Membership: 32 tracks and other tools
Finished audio and MIDIAAC, MP3, AIFF or WAVE to your Mac or iCloud Drive; MIDI-file export not documentedWAV, FLAC, MP3, Ogg and M4A rendering and MIDI-file export, according to its README and release notesWAV, MP3 and FLAC, per its help centerMaster or stems as WAV (16-bit, 24-bit or 32-bit float); MIDI files can be imported, MIDI export is not documentedMix as 16-bit WAV or M4A; single tracks as WAV or MIDI
Release and stability record10.4.14 on April 22, 2026; Apple lists 10.4.15; last security fix January 2025Version 0.7.5 on November 12, 2026; first commit October 18 and twelve releases since October 22, four of them betasRegular 2026 updates; the previous free Cakewalk stopped activating in 2025Version 0.59.2 on November 8, 2026; first commit August 25, 2026 and 17 releases; its maker expects rough edgesHelp articles updated through September 2026; BandLab ended activations of its older free Cakewalk in 2025

Free software for composing an original instrumental track on your own computer: entering notes, using included instruments, keeping an editable project and exporting audio. Public-source research checked October 19 and 20, 2026, and again on November 12: no installs, accounts, listening or project tests by us. All five are free to start; paid extras are optional. Keep both the project and an exported audio file. Next substantive review: December 18, 2026, or sooner after a major release or a change to account or activation terms.

All features and sources 16 criteria

Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.

Composing and sounds

Show 6 criteria
Composing and sounds
FeatureGarageBandGridlineCakewalk SonarNotaBandLab Studio
Best fitPreferred Pick: a first track on a Mac with macOS 15.6 or laterRising Star: free and open source on Windows, Mac or Linux, with no accountAlso consider: a Windows 11 PC with 16 GB of memory and an 8-core processor, for more extensive note editingFree and open source on Windows, Mac or Linux, with about 35 built-in instruments and effectsAlso consider: a browser or a phone only, with a BandLab account and 16-track projects
Entering notes without a keyboard controllerDraw in the Piano Roll, type with Musical Typing or write in the Score EditorDraw in the piano roll, program the step sequencer, play the typing keyboard, or generate a chord progression that writes into a patternMulti-track piano roll and step sequencer; play BandLab instruments from the computer keyboardDraw in the piano roll, with one-click arpeggio, strum and ornament tools; play from the computer keyboard, a MIDI keyboard or a phoneDraw notes in the MIDI editor, then quantize or transpose them from the computer keyboard; Drum Machine for beats
Instruments in the free versionSoftware instruments, Drummer and Apple Loops; more patches, drummers and loops as free downloads178 built-in instruments and effects (52 instruments in its plug-in suite) and a demo song made only from themBandLab Instruments with limited free-tier access (sound banks download on first use) and XSampler; TTS-1 removedAbout 35 built-in instruments and effects, including subtractive, wavetable, FM, granular and physical-modelling synths and a drum machineMore than 400 virtual instruments, by BandLab’s count, a Drum Machine, a Sampler and BandLab Sounds loops
Building and arranging sectionsRegions, arrangement markers, tempo and transposition tracksPlaylist of pattern, audio and automation clips; a song can change meter; mixer with sends and groupsUnlimited audio, MIDI and instrument tracks; one arranger track on the free tierAn arrangement timeline and a clip-launching Session grid, plus a Modular view for patching modulationUp to 16 tracks and 15 minutes per project on the free tier
Adding instruments from other makersAudio Units onlyVST3, CLAP, VST2, Audio Units and LV2, depending on the systemVST2 and VST3, per independent listingsVST3 on every platform and Audio Units on macOS; free plug-ins install from its settingsBandLab’s own instruments and effects; no third-party plug-ins documented
What costs extraNothing needed for this jobNothing; free softwareBandLab Membership: BandLab Sounds loops, Core Plugin Suite, more arranger tracksNothing; free softwareBandLab Membership: 32 tracks and other tools
Sources for composing and sounds

GarageBand, checked October 19 and November 12, 2026: user guide, Piano Roll notes, Musical Typing, more sounds and loops and Audio Units. Gridline, checked November 12: README and releases. Cakewalk Sonar, checked October 19 and November 12: Sonar, tiers, BandLab Instruments and TTS-1 removal, with plug-in formats from Bedroom Producers Blog, October 12, 2026. Nota, checked November 12: README and releases. BandLab Studio: Creation features, checked November 12, and, as archived copies, getting started, limits and keyboard shortcuts, with the BandLab blog, June 24, 2024. Documented features, not tests of sound or ease of use.

Access, saving and risk

Show 10 criteria
Access, saving and risk
FeatureGarageBandGridlineCakewalk SonarNotaBandLab Studio
Runs on, checked October 19 to November 12, 2026Mac only; macOS 15.6 or laterWindows 10/11 (x64 and ARM64); macOS 11 or later; Linux and BSD systemsWindows 11; installs on Windows 10 but not officially supportedWindows 10/11 (x64 and ARM64); macOS 13 or later (Apple Silicon and Intel); LinuxA web browser on a computer, or BandLab’s iPhone and Android apps
Computer neededA Mac that runs macOS 15.6; 731.9 MB app plus optional sound downloadsNo minimum published on the pages we readMinimum 8-core processor and 16 GB of memory; 5 GB diskNo minimum published on the pages we readNo minimum published; runs in the browser
Account and activationApple Account for the Mac App StoreNone; its installers are not signed, so Windows and macOS ask you to confirm the first launchFree BandLab account; license renews periodically through activationNone; its installers are not signed, so Windows and macOS ask you to confirm the first launchFree BandLab account; projects are stored online
Editable project.band package; compress before moving through non-Apple storageLocal .gridline files; a crash recovery that offers your project back; MIDI files and FL Studio projects in and out.cwp projects; Cakewalk by BandLab projects open in SonarLocal projects; every save is kept as a version you can return to or branch fromStored in BandLab’s cloud with saved revisions; no downloadable project file documented
Finished audio and MIDIAAC, MP3, AIFF or WAVE to your Mac or iCloud Drive; MIDI-file export not documentedWAV, FLAC, MP3, Ogg and M4A rendering and MIDI-file export, according to its README and release notesWAV, MP3 and FLAC, per its help centerMaster or stems as WAV (16-bit, 24-bit or 32-bit float); MIDI files can be imported, MIDI export is not documentedMix as 16-bit WAV or M4A; single tracks as WAV or MIDI
Release and stability record10.4.14 on April 22, 2026; Apple lists 10.4.15; last security fix January 2025Version 0.7.5 on November 12, 2026; first commit October 18 and twelve releases since October 22, four of them betasRegular 2026 updates; the previous free Cakewalk stopped activating in 2025Version 0.59.2 on November 8, 2026; first commit August 25, 2026 and 17 releases; its maker expects rough edgesHelp articles updated through September 2026; BandLab ended activations of its older free Cakewalk in 2025
Who makes itAppleOne developer (GitHub account lolitemaultes); Claude is listed as a contributorBandLab Technologies, part of Caldecott Music GroupEgor Khindikaynen (Ambertape) and nine other contributors; most of the code was written with AI assistanceBandLab Technologies, part of Caldecott Music Group
Learning resourcesCurrent Apple user guide for 10.4.14A guide for each feature in the project’s docs folder, a demo song and a showcase videoHelp center updated October 2026 and a long Sonar reference guideA user manual in English and Russian, a feature list and a demo videoHelp center, an in-app tutorial and BandLab video tutorials
License terms to knowIncluded sounds usable in your own music, not resold as samplesGPL-3.0 open-source software; bundled libraries keep their own licensesBandLab terms of September 9, 2026 include binding arbitration, with a 30-day opt-outAGPL-3.0 open-source softwareBandLab terms of September 9, 2026 include binding arbitration, with a 30-day opt-out
Data and privacyApp Store label: a user ID not linked to you, for app functionalityNo account; its update check never installs by itself; optional live collaboration is peer to peer and encrypted but can open ports on your routerPrivacy policy of April 20, 2023 covers device identifiers and personalised advertising with consentNo account; it checks for updates itself; an optional local server lets an AI assistant work in an open project, off by defaultPrivacy policy of April 20, 2023 covers device identifiers and personalised advertising with consent
Sources for access, saving and risk

GarageBand Mac App Store listing, export, project packages, release notes, license and security note; Gridline README, releases and security advisories page; Cakewalk Sonar requirements, export, end of Cakewalk by BandLab, BandLab terms and privacy; Nota README and releases; BandLab Studio file formats (archived copy) and Creation features. No software was installed, activated or run. A project file does not carry external instruments, samples or licenses to another computer.

What matters when choosing

GarageBand is our Practical Pick for someone writing a first original instrumental piece on a Mac that runs macOS 15.6 or later. It is free from Apple and gives you three ways to enter notes without a keyboard controller: draw them in the Piano Roll, play them on the computer keyboard with Musical Typing, or write them in the Score Editor. Its software instruments, Drummer and Apple Loops, with more patches, drummers and loops available as free downloads, give a first track the widest starting palette among the installed programs in this comparison, and Apple’s user guide is current for version 10.4.14. The most important compromise is the platform. GarageBand runs only on a Mac, the current Mac App Store version needs macOS 15.6 or later, and Apple’s guide documents importing MIDI files but not exporting them. Mac App Store listing, GarageBand user guide, Musical Typing, free sounds and loops

Our Rising Star is Gridline, a free, open-source music studio for Windows, Mac and Linux. It scored highest of the newer tools we found under the same criteria, and its lead is narrow: Gridline (3.73) is ahead of Cakewalk Sonar (3.65), Nota (3.63), Waveform Free (3.55) and BandLab Studio (3.53) by less than a quarter of a point. There is no account to create, and its README documents a step sequencer, a piano roll with chord, strum and arpeggio tools, a chord progression editor, 178 built-in instruments and effects and a demo song made only from them, and its README and release notes describe WAV, FLAC, MP3, Ogg, M4A and MIDI-file export. Its main limit is how new it is: its first commit is dated October 18, 2026 and its first release with downloads, version 0.6.0, October 22; version 0.7.5 arrived on November 12 after a dozen releases, the project has one main developer, and its installers are not signed, so Windows and macOS ask you to confirm the first launch. Gridline README, releases

If your Windows 11 PC has at least 16 GB of memory and an 8-core processor, consider Cakewalk Sonar. For a reader whose computer meets those minimums, its free tier scores slightly above Gridline, because the hardware condition no longer counts against it: it has the most extensive note editing here, with a multi-track piano roll and step sequencer, BandLab instruments you can play from the computer keyboard, and the largest help center. It needs a free BandLab account and periodic online activation, and BandLab stopped activating its previous free Cakewalk in 2025. On a computer below those minimums, or on a Mac too old for GarageBand, Gridline scored highest. Sonar requirements, Sonar free tier

Nota is the other newer tool to consider. It is a free, open-source studio for Windows, Mac and Linux with about 35 built-in instruments and effects, a piano roll with one-click arpeggio and strum tools, playing from the computer keyboard and every saved version kept. Like Gridline, it is new and still rough: its first commit is dated August 25, 2026, it is at version 0.59.2, its maker says to expect rough edges, and most of its code was written with AI assistance. Nota README

If you can only use a browser or a phone, choose BandLab Studio. BandLab’s free browser and phone studio offers more than 400 instruments, by BandLab’s count, but needs an account, keeps your editable projects in BandLab’s cloud and limits a free project to 16 tracks and 15 minutes; among browser and phone tools it scored highest. openDAW, a free, open-source studio that runs in a browser with no account or installation, scored lower, and its projects live in your browser’s storage, so export a project bundle or back up to your own cloud account. Waveform Free, which needs a Tracktion account, scored 3.55; it runs on Windows, macOS and Linux and exports audio and MIDI, but typing notes on the computer keyboard is part of its $50 MIDI Producer expansion. BandLab Studio limits, archived July 11, 2026, openDAW manual, project management, Waveform Free features, expansions

Disclosure: Practical Picks is researched and written with Claude, an AI model made by Anthropic. Nota advertises an optional, off-by-default connection that lets an AI assistant such as Claude work in an open project, Gridline lists an optional connection for AI assistants, and Waveform’s optional Assistant works with your own API key (two independent reviews name Anthropic and OpenAI), a ChatGPT subscription or a local model. We have no relationship with Anthropic, Tracktion or the makers of Gridline and Nota, and AI features carried no weight in this comparison. Nota README, MusicTech review, Tracktion features

These are researched judgments from documentation, release records and public reports checked October 19 and 20 and November 12, 2026. We did not install any software, compose or play anything, or judge how the instruments sound. Three conditions would change our recommendation: no Mac, or a Mac that cannot run macOS 15.6 (choose Gridline); a Windows 11 PC that meets Sonar’s minimums when you want deeper note editing (consider Sonar); or a computer you cannot install software on (consider BandLab Studio or openDAW in a browser). Whichever you choose, keep both the editable project and an exported audio file. They solve different problems, and neither carries the external instruments, samples or licenses another computer would need.

GarageBand

Preferred Pick · a first track on a Mac

$0Free · macOS 15.6 or later

Choose GarageBand if your Mac runs macOS 15.6 or later. It offers the most ways to enter notes without a controller, the largest included sound library among the installed programs here and a current manual, at no cost.

Reasons to choose it

  • Draw notes, type them on the computer keyboard or write them in notation
  • Free downloadable instruments, drummers and Apple Loops
  • Current Apple user guide and regular updates

What to watch

  • Mac only, and the current version needs macOS 15.6 or later
  • Apple’s guide documents importing MIDI files, not exporting them
  • Loads Audio Units plug-ins only, not VST

Apple’s GarageBand guide for version 10.4.14 documents software instrument tracks, a Piano Roll Editor where you add notes with the pointer, a Score Editor for notation, Drummer, Apple Loops, arrangement markers and automation curves. Musical Typing (Command-K) turns the computer keyboard into a playable instrument, with keys for octave, velocity, pitch bend and sustain, so you can enter and record notes without buying a controller. User guide, adding notes, Musical Typing

Apple says more patches, drummers and Apple Loops may be available after installation, through GarageBand > Sound Library > Download All Available Sounds, and that some tasks prompt you to download missing content. We verified the US Mac App Store listing on October 19, 2026: free from Apple Inc., version 10.4.14 of April 22, 2026, 731.9 MB, requiring macOS 15.6 or later. Apple’s release notes also list a version 10.4.15 that fixes take folders that could not be closed; the US store page still showed 10.4.14. Get more sounds and loops, Mac App Store listing, release notes

Read the full GarageBand analysis and sources

Choose another tool if your Mac cannot run macOS 15.6. Waveform Free supports macOS 13 or later, and LMMS publishes builds for much older Macs. GarageBand’s guide documents Audio Units plug-ins only, so plan on Audio Units versions of any outside instrument, and expect each plug-in to bring its own compatibility and license questions. This article does not cover GarageBand for iPhone or iPad. Audio Units plug-ins

The finished file and the project are separate things. Export Song to Disk writes AAC, MP3, AIFF or WAVE to your Mac or iCloud Drive. The editable project is a .band package, and Apple recommends compressing it before moving it through a non-Apple device or service. The guide documents importing MIDI files; we found no MIDI-file export in it, which matters if you plan to move your notes to another program later. Apple’s 10.4.12 notes say the undo history is now kept when you save. Export songs, compress a project, release notes

GarageBand’s license covers Apple-branded hardware, requires an Apple Account for the App Store, and lets you use the included sounds in your own original music but not redistribute them as samples or sound libraries. The App Store privacy label, read October 19, 2026, lists a user ID collected but not linked to you, for app functionality; Apple’s general privacy policy also applies. Apple’s last GarageBand security note covers 10.4.12 (January 30, 2025), which fixed a flaw that let a crafted image run code (CVE-2024-44142). Keep the app updated. GarageBand license, Apple privacy policy, security note for 10.4.12

Used GarageBand? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Gridline

Rising Star · free and open source, no account

$0Open source (GPL-3.0) · Windows, Mac and Linux

Why Rising Star? Gridline, a free, open-source studio first committed on October 18, 2026, scored highest of the newer tools under our fixed criteria. Its README documents a step sequencer, a piano roll with chord, strum and arpeggio tools, a chord progression editor, 178 built-in instruments and effects and a demo song made only from them, for Windows, Mac and Linux, with no account. It is a fast-changing 0.7 release from one main developer, and its installers are not signed.

Consider Gridline if you want a free studio with a large set of built-in instruments and no account on Windows, Mac or Linux, and you accept a new, fast-changing program whose installers Windows and macOS will ask you to confirm.

Reasons to choose it

  • No account or payment; Windows 10/11, macOS 11 or later and Linux
  • Step sequencer, piano roll with chord, strum and arpeggio tools, and a chord progression editor
  • 178 built-in instruments and effects, a demo song made only from them, and WAV, FLAC, MP3, Ogg, M4A and MIDI-file export, according to its README and release notes

What to watch

  • Version 0.7.5; twelve releases since October 22, four of them betas, from one main developer
  • Installers are not signed, so Windows and macOS ask you to confirm the first launch
  • No independent review was found, and the project lists no minimum computer

Gridline is a free, open-source (GPL-3.0) music studio for Windows, macOS and Linux. Its README describes a channel rack with a step sequencer, a piano roll, a playlist and a mixer, and the downloads need no account. Its repository’s first commit is dated October 18, 2026 and its first release with downloads for every desktop system, version 0.6.0, October 22; version 0.7.5 followed on November 12. README, releases, earliest commits

Choose it if you want to build a track from a large set of included sounds without paying or signing up, on Windows, a Mac or Linux. The README documents four ways to enter notes without a controller: draw them in the piano roll, which has scale highlighting and quantize, chop, strum, arpeggiate and randomize tools; program them in the step sequencer; play them on the typing keyboard, which its release notes say has a keyboard layout setting; or pick a key, generate or type a chord progression and write it into a pattern. It lists 178 built-in instruments and effects, with 52 instruments and 69 effects in its plug-in suite, among them wavetable, six-operator FM, additive and sampler instruments and drum pads. A 4:25 demo song, made only from the built-in instruments, effects and automation, opens as a project you can take apart. Gridline also loads VST3, CLAP, VST2, Audio Unit and LV2 plug-ins, depending on the system. README

Read the full Gridline analysis and sources

The strongest reason not to choose it is how new it is and how it is made. Version 0.7.5 is a point release on top of 0.7.4. Twelve releases appeared between October 22 and November 12, four of them betas, which the update check offers only if you tick a box, and the 0.7.5 notes describe a redesigned main synthesizer. The contributor list shows one human developer and Claude, an AI assistant. The builds are not signed by Apple or Microsoft, so Windows SmartScreen asks you to choose More info, then Run anyway, and macOS needs a right-click Open on first launch. We found no independent review and no published minimum computer; its security page listed no advisories on November 12. Releases, README

Projects are .gridline files on your computer. The 0.7.3 notes say crashes and freezes now explain themselves and offer your project back, and a project can be exported as an FL Studio loop package. Its release notes describe WAV exports, MP3, Ogg and AAC encoding and MIDI files going both ways. The README’s command-line renderer lists WAV, FLAC, MP3, Ogg and M4A; check the export dialog in the app before you rely on one. Live collaboration is optional: it connects computers directly with end-to-end encryption and can open ports on your router. The update check offers new versions and never installs anything by itself. The README also lists an optional connection for AI assistants, which carried no weight here. Release notes, README

Used Gridline? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Cakewalk Sonar

Also consider · a Windows 11 PC with 16 GB of memory and an 8-core processor

$0Free tier · BandLab account

Choose Cakewalk Sonar if your Windows 11 PC has at least 16 GB of memory and an 8-core processor, you want the most extensive note editing here, and you accept signing in to BandLab to keep it activated. For a reader whose PC meets those minimums it scores slightly above Gridline.

Reasons to choose it

  • Multi-track piano roll and step sequencer
  • BandLab instruments you can play from the computer keyboard
  • The largest help center and reference guide here

What to watch

  • Windows 11 only; 16 GB of memory and an 8-core processor minimum
  • BandLab account and periodic activation
  • Free tier gets limited access to BandLab instruments and no BandLab Sounds loops

Cakewalk Sonar is BandLab’s successor to Cakewalk by BandLab, and it has had a free tier since June 2025. The product page documents a multi-track piano roll, a built-in step sequencer and articulation maps. BandLab’s comparison, updated October 18, 2026, lists unlimited audio, MIDI and instrument tracks, ProChannel and AudioSnap in the free tier, with one arranger track; BandLab Membership adds BandLab Sounds loops, the Core Plugin Suite and other tools. Sonar, free and membership tiers, Bedroom Producers Blog, June 23, 2025

The strongest reason not to choose it is what it asks of your computer and account. BandLab lists Windows 11 (it installs on Windows 10, which is not officially supported), an 8-core or native ARM64 processor and 16 GB of memory as minimums, plus an internet connection to install, authorize and update. You sign in with a free BandLab account. The product FAQ says the free license is “currently indefinite” but, like the paid one, needs periodic renewal through online or offline activation. Requirements, first-time setup, Sonar FAQ

Read the full Cakewalk Sonar analysis and sources

Instruments changed in 2026. Sonar 2026.04 added BandLab Instruments, which download their sound banks the first time you load them and can be played from the computer keyboard; Sonar maps new MIDI tracks to them when no MIDI device is connected. The free tier has limited access to them, per the product page, and the General MIDI synth TTS-1 is no longer included. An internal sampler, XSampler, is in both tiers. BandLab Instruments in Sonar, TTS-1 removal, Sonar

Your work stays usable when BandLab changes its products, but access depends on its account system. BandLab says Cakewalk by BandLab is “fully sunsetted” and can no longer be activated, while its .cwp projects open in Sonar. The Sonar FAQ gives two different dates for the end of those activations, August 1 and December 31, 2025. Sonar exports WAV, MP3 and FLAC through File > Export > Audio, and its help center, updated through October 2026, is backed by a long Sonar reference guide. Cakewalk by BandLab ended, export, Sonar FAQ

BandLab’s terms of use (September 9, 2026) include binding arbitration and a class-action waiver, with a 30-day opt-out. Its privacy policy, current as of April 20, 2023, covers device identifiers and personalised advertising where you consent. BandLab also offers Cakewalk Next, a simpler free app for Windows and Mac with the same account requirement and the same 16 GB, 8-core minimum; we did not evaluate it in this comparison. Choose Gridline if your PC falls below Sonar’s minimums or runs Windows 10. BandLab terms, BandLab privacy policy, Next requirements

Used Cakewalk Sonar? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Nota

Free and open source · Windows, Mac or Linux

$0Open source (AGPL-3.0) · Windows, Mac and Linux

Consider Nota if you want a free studio with about 35 built-in instruments and effects and no account, and you accept a young program that its maker says still has rough edges.

Reasons to choose it

  • No account or payment; Windows 10/11, macOS 13 or later and Linux
  • Piano roll with one-click arpeggio, strum and ornament tools, and playing from the computer keyboard or a phone
  • Every saved version is kept, and the master or stems export as WAV

What to watch

  • Version 0.59.2; first committed August 25, 2026, with weekly releases and, in its maker’s words, rough edges
  • Installers are not signed, so Windows and macOS ask you to confirm the first launch
  • MIDI-file export is not documented, and most of the code was written with AI assistance

Nota is a free, open-source (AGPL-3.0) music studio for Windows 10 and 11, macOS 13 or later and Linux, made by Egor Khindikaynen, who goes by Ambertape, and nine other contributors. Its first commit is dated August 25, 2026; it had made 17 releases by November 8, when version 0.59.2 appeared. There is no account. README, releases, earliest commits

Choose it if you want a free studio with a broad built-in sound set and several ways to enter notes. The README lists a piano roll with quantize and velocity and one-click arpeggio, strum and ornament tools, playing from the computer keyboard, a MIDI keyboard or a phone, about 35 built-in instruments and effects (subtractive, wavetable, FM, granular and physical-modelling synths, a drum machine and more), chord and scale tools, and an arrangement timeline with a clip-launching Session grid. It loads VST3 plug-ins on every platform and Audio Units on macOS, and installs some free plug-ins from its settings. README

Read the full Nota analysis and sources

The strongest reason not to choose it is how young and fast-moving it is. The README says Nota is “young and moving fast” and to “expect rough edges”, releases come about weekly, and the installers are not signed, so Windows and macOS ask you to confirm the first launch. The maker says most of the code was written with AI assistance. We did not read its manual or security page, and we found no independent review. README, releases

Every save is kept as a version you can return to or branch from. The master or stems export as WAV at 16-bit, 24-bit or 32-bit float, and MIDI files can be dragged in; we found no documented MIDI-file export. The README also advertises an optional, off-by-default local server that lets an AI assistant such as Claude work in an open project, which carried no weight here. README

Used Nota? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

BandLab Studio

Also consider · a browser or a phone only

$0Free · BandLab account

Choose BandLab Studio if you can only use a browser or a phone: among the tools that run there it scored highest. It offers a large included sound library, and you accept signing in, 16-track projects and keeping your editable work in BandLab’s cloud.

Reasons to choose it

  • More than 400 virtual instruments, by BandLab’s count, plus a Drum Machine and loops
  • Works in a web browser and in iPhone and Android apps
  • Exports the mix as WAV or M4A and single tracks as WAV or MIDI

What to watch

  • Free BandLab account needed; projects are stored in BandLab’s cloud
  • Free projects are limited to 16 tracks and 15 minutes
  • No downloadable project file documented

BandLab Studio is BandLab’s free, cloud-based workstation, used in a web browser or in BandLab’s iPhone and Android apps. BandLab says it offers more than 400 virtual instruments, from pianos and guitars to drum pads and synthesizers, along with a Drum Machine, a Sampler and its BandLab Sounds library of royalty-free loops. You draw notes in its MIDI editor and can quantize or transpose them from the computer keyboard. A free project holds up to 16 tracks and 15 minutes; a paid Membership raises the track limit to 32. Getting started, archived September 17, 2026, track and length limits, archived July 11, 2026, keyboard shortcuts, archived July 11, 2026, BandLab blog, June 24, 2024

Choose it if you want a large included sound palette on any computer, want to continue a sketch on your phone, and are comfortable signing in and keeping your projects in BandLab’s cloud. BandLab says up to 50 people can collaborate on one project. Creation features

Read the full BandLab Studio analysis and sources

The strongest reason not to choose it is that your editable project lives on BandLab’s servers. You need a free BandLab account to open the Studio, BandLab describes it as cloud-based with free cloud storage, and we found no downloadable project file. The web Studio exports the whole mix as a 16-bit WAV or M4A file and single tracks as WAV or MIDI files, so you can keep the notes and the audio if you later leave. Import and export formats, archived July 11, 2026, Creation features

BandLab Technologies also makes Cakewalk Sonar, and the same terms of use (September 9, 2026, with binding arbitration and a 30-day opt-out) and privacy policy (April 20, 2023) apply. In 2025 it stopped activating its older free Cakewalk by BandLab program, a reminder that a company can retire a product its users rely on. BandLab also offers AI tools such as SongStarter; they carried no weight here. BandLab’s help center refused automated reading on October 20, 2026, so we read archived copies from July and September 2026. BandLab terms, BandLab privacy policy, Cakewalk by BandLab ended

Used BandLab Studio? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Which product are we missing?

Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.

Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.

Suggest a product

Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.

No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.

What people are saying

Outside reports point to specific questions, not rankings. A 2022 GarageBand discussion describes instruments that appeared in the list but made no sound, which matches Apple’s note that some content has to be downloaded first. A 2023 Waveform discussion shows a new user mistaking the registration step for a paid export feature. A 2024 LMMS report names 1.2.2 and crashes on save; the author later said the problem was fixed without naming a cause. These were last read September 6, 2026 and are individual, unverified reports.

When Sonar’s free tier appeared in June 2025, users in a KVR Audio forum thread reported a “Continue Evaluation” prompt with a short timer and an expiry date a month ahead, and suspected that periodic reactivation would continue; another called the free tier “pretty generous”. BandLab now describes the free license as indefinite with periodic renewal. MusicTech’s Waveform 14 Pro review praised the free edition’s core features as “excellent value” and flagged bugs in version 14. We found no independent user reports on Reason Free yet. Coverage of openDAW in August 2026, before its 1.0 release, described a working but unfinished studio; Time To House said it was not yet ready to replace Ableton or Logic for professional work, and Midnight Rebels warned classrooms that they would be testing software its developer had not called finished. We found no reports of lost openDAW projects in its GitHub issues on October 20. For Gridline and Nota we found no independent review, so their own README and release notes are the only evidence behind this article’s statements about them.

Our October 19 search for security notices, lawsuits, regulator actions, shutdowns and outages involving the first five products and their companies, and our October 20 search covering openDAW and BandLab Studio, found nothing beyond the items in this article that changed our conclusions. A search that finds nothing is not proof that nothing exists.

How we researched

This is public-source research. We did not install, activate or run any software, create accounts, play or compose music, or judge sound quality. No vendor supplied access, payment or input, and we use no affiliate links. We first compared GarageBand, Waveform Free and LMMS on September 6, 2026, rechecked every material claim for GarageBand, Waveform Free, Cakewalk Sonar, LMMS and Reason Free on October 19, 2026, added openDAW and BandLab Studio on October 20, and on November 12, 2026 rechecked prices and plan pages for every product we scored, release pages, the newcomer search below, and our November 12 check of Gridline’s and Nota’s release records and Gridline’s security page. We checked versions, platforms and requirements, accounts and activation, included instruments, paid gates, saving and export, licenses, privacy terms, ownership and published problems. We read vendor product pages, user guides and help centers (some help-center pages through their public data feeds or archived copies because the web pages blocked automated reading), source code, release records, license and privacy documents, Apple’s security notes, the National Vulnerability Database, press coverage and user discussions.

We wrote this for someone composing a first original instrumental piece on their own computer, entering notes with a mouse or computer keyboard and using the instruments that come with the software, without paying. We fixed five criteria and their weights before comparing: composing with the included sounds (30%), free access and platform reach (20%), keeping and finishing your work (20%), stability and maintenance (15%) and learning resources (15%). The access criterion counts two things equally: what the job costs over three years and how freely you can get the program running. We priced every product for the same job over three years: one track of up to 16 tracks and 15 minutes, drawn with the mouse or played on the computer keyboard, using only included instruments. Every product we priced is free for that job, so price did not separate them; paid extras are listed beside each product. GarageBand scored highest, 4.40 out of 5, even with its Mac-only reach counted against it. Gridline (3.73) comes next, narrowly ahead of Cakewalk Sonar (3.65), Nota (3.63), Waveform Free (3.55) and BandLab Studio (3.53). Among Windows tools, giving composing tools more weight keeps Gridline ahead with Sonar second. For a reader whose Windows 11 PC meets Sonar’s minimums, Sonar scores slightly above Gridline, which is why we name it. Among tools that run in a browser or on a phone, BandLab Studio scored highest, and on a Mac too old for GarageBand, on Linux or on a Windows PC below Sonar’s minimums, Gridline did.

On October 20 and again on November 12, 2026 we searched for newer entrants, using launch sites, GitHub topic pages and release records, Hacker News launches and searches, maker sites and the tools screened earlier. We counted a tool as newer only if its first public release, commit or launch post is dated within the past two years, since November 12, 2024, and its maker is not already a maker of music software. Gridline qualifies: its repository’s first commit is dated October 18, 2026, its first release October 22, and its security page listed no advisories. It scored highest, 3.73, and is our Rising Star. Nota also qualifies (first commit August 25, 2026), and so does openDAW (first shown publicly on February 9, 2025). Furnace, a chiptune tracker first released in December 2021, and Bespoke, a modular synthesizer with public builds from 2020, are older than two years. LYNX SHARE calls itself an alpha. The newest free tiers, Reason Free, MPC 3 Beats, Cakewalk Next, LUNA and Fender Studio, come from makers that already sell music software, which we treat as alternatives rather than newcomers. Launch lists also show other 2025 and 2026 tools that we did not check, including several browser studios, a modular synthesizer workstation and AI music generators; the generators write music for you rather than helping you write your own. Two we did read are below.

The products below are outside our chart. We scored each on the same fixed weights, and the totals are out of 5. Some of the scores, for tools whose pages we could read only in part, have low confidence.

openDAW (3.43). openDAW is a free, open-source music studio that runs in a browser on Windows, Mac or Linux, with no account or installation. It was first shown publicly in February 2025 (a Hacker News launch thread of February 9) and its 1.0 launch event was set for October 3, 2026; the project has shipped updates weekly since. Its manual documents a note editor, step recording, an on-screen keyboard, about eleven built-in instruments, about sixteen instruments and effects that run in the browser and loop collections from Loopmasters and ModeAudio. Projects are kept in your browser’s private storage, which clearing site data erases, so export a project bundle or set up backup to your own cloud account; we found no documented MIDI-file export. The project is led by André Michelle, who built Audiotool, and its repository listed no published security advisories on November 12. It scored 0.30 below Gridline, mainly on keeping work (browser storage, no documented MIDI-file export) and on composing, where we found no documented typing-keyboard note entry. Manual, project management, repository, project newsletter, Hacker News search, November 12, 2026

Waveform Free (3.55). Waveform Free is Tracktion’s free edition, for Windows 10 and 11, macOS 13 or later and, per Tracktion, Linux. It lets you draw notes, build step patterns and generate arpeggio, chord, bass and melody patterns, and its edition table includes audio and MIDI export in the free version. You need a free Tracktion account to install it; it lists four instruments (version 14.1 adds a built-in synth, Attracktive), and typing notes on the computer keyboard, the chord tools and clip automation are part of the $50 MIDI Producer expansion, with a $30 Synth Pack for more instruments. A September 2026 review of Waveform 14 Pro, which shares the same program, reported glitches, including a plugin crash that closed the whole application. Version 14 added an optional AI Assistant that uses your own API key, a ChatGPT subscription or a local model. Features, edition table, expansions, account sign-up, MusicTech review

LMMS (3.40). LMMS is free, open-source (GPL-2.0) software with a Piano Roll, a Beat/Bassline Editor, a Song Editor, a mixer, built-in synthesizers and a SoundFont player, with no account or activation and the lowest requirements here (a 2-core processor and 1 GB of memory). Its last stable release, 1.2.2, dates from July 2020, and its Mac builds are for Intel Macs. The 1.3.0 alpha of September 6, 2026 adds Apple Silicon builds, but projects saved in it cannot be reopened in earlier versions and the project warns that crashes may happen. The stable release exports WAV or OGG and loads Windows VST plug-ins, which do not work on a Mac. Downloads, releases, stable manual

Reason Free (3.43). Reason Free, launched on August 27, 2026, puts a General MIDI sound set, a drum designer and two synthesizers into a free Reason Rack plugin and a 16-track version of the Reason DAW. It needs a free Reason Studios account and a “fast and stable” internet connection, and has to go online at least once a month to stay authorized; if authorization lapses, the Reason 12 manual says, Reason switches to a demo mode that cannot export audio. Reason Studios has been owned by LANDR since January 2026, and Reason+ costs $169 a year. We found no independent record of the free tier’s use yet. Reason Free, offline use, Mix, January 6, 2026

Furnace (3.20). Furnace is a free, open-source chiptune tracker for Windows, macOS and Linux, first released in December 2021, whose sounds are emulated sound chips you build yourself, entered on a pattern grid from the computer keyboard. It scores low on composing for a reader who wants a conventional piano roll and ready-made instruments. Repository, releases

Audiotool (3.20). Audiotool is a free browser studio with unlimited tracks and modular cable routing that keeps projects online and needs a sign-up. We could not confirm its note entry or export options, so this score has low confidence. Audiotool compared with BandLab

MPC Beats (3.18). Akai’s MPC Beats, now called MPC 3 Beats, is a free desktop program with 16 tracks and three built-in instruments, TubeSynth, Electric and Bassline, and it needs an inMusic Profile sign-in. We could not confirm its export options, so this score has low confidence. MPC Beats

Soundtrap (3.15). Soundtrap’s free plan is a browser studio with a smaller sound set than its paid plans, which start at about $9.59 a month billed yearly; it needs an account. We could not confirm its note entry or export options, so this score has low confidence. Soundtrap pricing

Bespoke (2.95). Bespoke is a free, open-source modular synthesizer for Windows, Mac and Linux, in development since 2011 with public builds since 2020, designed for jamming and exploration with less of a focus on a global timeline. Bespoke, releases

Cakewalk Next. BandLab’s simpler free app for Windows and Mac has the same account requirement and the same 16 GB, 8-core minimum as Sonar; we did not evaluate it because we found little documentation on its note entry and export.

LYNX SHARE. This open-source studio for Windows, Mac and Linux describes itself as an alpha, “not yet a replacement for a daily-driver DAW”, so we did not count it as available for this job. README

Riffrail. This browser sequencer, shown on Hacker News in January 2026, loaded only a drum-pad grid for us and had no documentation we could read, so we could not judge it.

Magda (3.25). Magda is a free, open-source (GPL-3.0) studio with AI chat built in (you bring your own API key), shown on Hacker News on March 17, 2026, with build badges for Windows, macOS and Linux, a public beta, version 1.0.0-beta.2, of November 7, 2026, and commits as recent as November 10. It passes our tests of newness, availability and safety: its README lists a piano roll with pitch-bend and controller lanes, a drum grid, a session view and a plug-in browser, and its commit messages name a Magda Sampler, a family of compiled synths “MAGDA ships”, an arpeggiator, strum and step-sequencer devices and playing instruments from the computer keys. It needs no account, and we found no advisory, though we did not read its security page. We scored it on the same fixed weights, and it finished below Gridline and Nota: its instrument count is not stated, the README explains how to build it from source and we did not read its release downloads, and we read no documentation beyond the README. Its commits are co-authored with Claude, the maker’s own use of the tool. Repository

Xequence2. Xequence2 is a browser sequencer shown on Hacker News on September 27, 2026. The only page we could read is a demo build whose menus describe clip editing, MIDI-file import and export and audio export; it names no included instrument list, documentation or maker. Its maker’s launch post describes a demo build based on the maker’s existing Xequence 2 iOS app, not a released product, so we did not count it as available. Demo

We left out several other widely used tools for stated reasons. FL Studio’s free trial will not reopen saved projects until you buy an edition, from $99. Ableton Live Lite and Cubase LE come bundled with hardware or other products. Universal Audio’s LUNA and Avid’s Pro Tools Intro are built around recording and mixing audio, with more limited MIDI tools or track counts, and the score editor MuseScore Studio suits people who write in notation. Logic Pro and other paid workstations are outside a free first track.

ToolPublic sourcesWhat remains uncertain
GarageBandMac App Store listing, user guide, release notes, license, security notes, privacy label.Whether 10.4.15 has reached every store; MIDI-file export; how much Sound Library content a first track needs.
GridlineREADME, release notes for the releases shown (October 22 to November 12, 2026), earliest commits, security advisories page.The list of export formats in the app, the documentation folder, how it behaves on your computer, and sound quality.
Cakewalk SonarProduct page and FAQ, help-center articles on tiers, requirements, setup, instruments, export and Cakewalk by BandLab, BandLab terms and privacy policy, launch coverage and forum reports.Which BandLab instruments the free tier includes, how often activation must renew, and the exact end date of the previous product’s activations.
BandLab StudioHelp-center articles on getting started, limits, keyboard shortcuts and file formats (archived copies, July and September 2026), Creation features page, BandLab blog, BandLab terms and privacy policy.The current help-center text (live pages refused automated reading), which instruments and loops a free account includes, offline use, and behavior on a reader’s computer.
NotaREADME, release notes for the releases shown, earliest commits.The first release date, the user manual and feature list, security advisories, MIDI-file export, and how it behaves on your computer.

None of this establishes how the instruments sound, how easy each program is to learn or how reliably it runs on your computer. Next substantive review is due December 18, 2026, or sooner after a major release or a change to account or activation terms. Found a changed price, requirement or condition? Contact the editors.

Sources and evidence

Sources were checked October 19, 2026 unless another date is given. Vendor material establishes documented features, requirements and terms, not behavior on your computer. Reviews and forum posts are attributed opinions, not representative samples.

Products outside the chart:

This is a researched comparison, not a product review. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.