AI image generators for website illustrations: Adobe Firefly, Ideogram and Midjourney
Choose Firefly Standard for private website illustrations with Adobe’s own models, which it says were trained on licensed content. Ideogram is stronger for lettering and wide headers; Midjourney charges $60 a month for privacy.
Adobe Firefly Standard
Our choice for work that stays private unless you share it, with unlimited use of Adobe’s own models, Generative Fill and Generative Expand.
Adobe’s training and commercial-use statements cover its own models; partner models spend 2,000 monthly credits. Help lists a 2000 × 2000 download maximum.
Why Adobe Firefly is our PickTeam behind Adobe Firefly Standard? Get your award badge
No Rising Star selected
Reve offers a paid training opt-out, but its suitable price and private-generation settings are unclear. Lovart’s terms give users output ownership but do not identify a responsible legal entity or establish private-generation defaults.
Neither has an endorsement for private website illustrations while these questions remain open.
Who is this article for? People making original decorative illustrations for their own website in a browser, from a brief and references they have the right to use. Not legal advice; confidential client work and developer APIs are out of scope.
About 22 min read
What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean
The quick list
Start with Firefly Standard for private website illustrations; choose Ideogram for lettering or wide headers, or consider Midjourney for series styling. These are each service’s least expensive private plans among the three compared here.
Monthly US list prices before tax, for the lowest plan that keeps new images private by default. Excludes promotions and extra credits. Yearly billing, paid upfront, costs less at Ideogram ($180) and Midjourney ($576 for Pro). Midjourney Basic is $10 a month if public work is acceptable. Ideogram’s prices were confirmed October 29, 2026; Adobe’s and Midjourney’s could not be confirmed again and remain as checked October 19.
The comparison at a glance
Compare what it costs to keep work private, the controls for revising an illustration, and the rights and training terms behind the output.
Start with Firefly for private website illustrations, then Ideogram for lettering and Midjourney for series styling. All tools remain selectable.
Hides matching answers for the selected tools. Unknowns and unverified claims stay visible.
| Feature | Adobe Firefly | Ideogram | Midjourney |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: private website illustrations made with Adobe’s own models | Lettering in the artwork and very wide headers | Keeping a series in one style, if public work or $60/month is acceptable |
| Lowest plan that keeps new images private | Standard: $9.99/month, billed monthly | Plus: $20/month, or $180/year | Pro: $60/month, or $576/year |
| What the allowance covers | Unlimited standard features with Adobe models; 2,000 credits for partner models and premium features | 2,400 credits; Ideogram models continue in a slower queue, but edits, references and upscales need credits | Pro: 30 fast GPU hours; unlimited Relax images from Standard up |
| Default visibility | Saved to your history; gallery and public links are separate steps (vendor statements) | Plus: private until you publish; free plan is public | Public unless Stealth (Pro/Mega); public Discord channels always visible |
| Training and your content | Adobe says its models use licensed and public-domain content, and it does not train on user content | Uses prompts and uploads to improve products; no training opt-out described | No training statement found in terms; perpetual license to inputs and outputs |
| Series and style control | Uploaded or supplied style reference with an intensity control | Up to 10 style references, presets and palettes, on Ideogram 3.0 only | Image style references and reusable codes; version-sensitive |
| Changing the crop or a region | Generative Fill; Generative Expand to a preset or freeform shape | Studio: extend, select area and AI edit; masks in Precise Edit | Editor: regenerate erased regions, resize the canvas, layers |
| Main compromise | Licensed-training and commercial-use statements cover Adobe’s models, not partner models | Data-use terms; series styling sits on the older 3.0 model | Privacy costs $60/month; edits of uploads are public without it |
Ideogram’s prices were confirmed October 29, 2026; Adobe’s and Midjourney’s could not be confirmed again and remain as checked October 19. Hosted image generators for original website illustrations. Sources checked October 19, 2026; Adobe help pages blocked automated retrieval and are cited from search indexing or our September 7 reading. Next review December 1, 2026, or sooner after a material plan, model or policy change. Prices are US list prices before tax, promotions and extra credits. This is public-source research: no images were generated, so documented controls do not establish image quality, style consistency, spelling accuracy or the rights position of any output.
All features and sources 16 criteria
Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.
Price, plan and allowance
Show 6 criteria
| Feature | Adobe Firefly | Ideogram | Midjourney |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: private website illustrations made with Adobe’s own models | Lettering in the artwork and very wide headers | Keeping a series in one style, if public work or $60/month is acceptable |
| Lowest plan that keeps new images private | Standard: $9.99/month, billed monthly | Plus: $20/month, or $180/year | Pro: $60/month, or $576/year |
| Cheapest paid plan and its catch | Standard is also the cheapest paid plan | Plus is the cheapest plan sold; free-plan images are public | Basic: $10/month, but new work is public |
| What the allowance covers | Unlimited standard features with Adobe models; 2,000 credits for partner models and premium features | 2,400 credits; Ideogram models continue in a slower queue, but edits, references and upscales need credits | Pro: 30 fast GPU hours; unlimited Relax images from Standard up |
| Other companies’ models inside | Google, OpenAI, FLUX, Ideogram and Runway models, for credits | GPT Image and Nano Banana as premium models; two free partner models | None documented; Midjourney models only |
| Billing and cancelling | Monthly: refund within 14 days; annual billed monthly charges 50% of the remainder | Cancel five days before renewal; no refunds | Renews automatically; ownership of output survives cancelling |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for price, plan and allowance
Checked October 19, 2026. US list prices before tax and promotions; credits are not comparable image counts. Firefly plans, partner-model rates, through search indexing and subscription terms; Ideogram plans and credits, models, cancelling and refunds; Midjourney plans and terms. Fits are our editorial judgments.
Revision and website output
Show 5 criteria
| Feature | Adobe Firefly | Ideogram | Midjourney |
|---|---|---|---|
| Series and style control | Uploaded or supplied style reference with an intensity control | Up to 10 style references, presets and palettes, on Ideogram 3.0 only | Image style references and reusable codes; version-sensitive |
| Changing the crop or a region | Generative Fill; Generative Expand to a preset or freeform shape | Studio: extend, select area and AI edit; masks in Precise Edit | Editor: regenerate erased regions, resize the canvas, layers |
| Editable lettering | Equivalent text extraction not established | Layerize Text beta; decorative lettering may fail | Equivalent text extraction not established |
| Shapes for web layouts | 1:1, 4:3, 3:4, 16:9; 9:16 on Image 4 and 4 Ultra; freeform Expand | Ideogram 4.0: up to 3:1 and 23:9 at 2K | Aspect-ratio parameter and custom ratios in the Editor |
| Download size and format | Help lists JPG/PNG up to 2000 × 2000; Image 5 4 MP claim unreconciled | JPEG, PNG or WEBP, 1K–8K; above original size is a paid upscale | V8.2 square: 2048 × 2048 HD or 1024 SD; transparent PNG of an edit |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for revision and website output
Documented controls, not output tests. Adobe help through search indexing on October 19 or our September 7 reading: style reference, Generative Expand, aspect ratios and technical requirements; TechCrunch on Image 5. Ideogram image settings, Studio, Layerize Text and download. Midjourney Style Reference, Editor, image size and aspect ratio. Not established means we found insufficient evidence, not that a feature is absent.
Rights, training and visibility
Show 5 criteria
| Feature | Adobe Firefly | Ideogram | Midjourney |
|---|---|---|---|
| Default visibility | Saved to your history; gallery and public links are separate steps (vendor statements) | Plus: private until you publish; free plan is public | Public unless Stealth (Pro/Mega); public Discord channels always visible |
| Training and your content | Adobe says its models use licensed and public-domain content, and it does not train on user content | Uses prompts and uploads to improve products; no training opt-out described | No training statement found in terms; perpetual license to inputs and outputs |
| Commercial use and rights | Non-beta output usable commercially; indemnity only for eligible enterprise customers | Commercial use allowed; output may not be unique | Ownership subject to others’ rights; companies over $1M revenue need Pro/Mega |
| Outside record | FTC 2024 subscription complaint; Adobe announced a DOJ settlement in March 2026, denying wrongdoing | No lawsuit, breach or regulator action found in the October 19 search | Consolidated studio copyright suits pending; allegations only |
| Main compromise | Licensed-training and commercial-use statements cover Adobe’s models, not partner models | Data-use terms; series styling sits on the older 3.0 model | Privacy costs $60/month; edits of uploads are public without it |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for rights, training and visibility
Adobe approach to generative AI, Firefly FAQ, generation history, FTC case and Adobe statement; Ideogram sharing, terms and privacy policy; Midjourney Stealth, Editor visibility, terms and court docket. Vendor statements about visibility and training are not audits. Nothing here is a legal clearance.
What matters when choosing
Adobe Firefly Standard is our Practical Pick for someone making original decorative illustrations for their own website from a written brief and references they have the right to use. At the $9.99 monthly price checked October 19, it was the least expensive of these three plans for keeping new work private by default. Adobe says paid plans include unlimited use of standard features such as Generate Image, Generative Fill and Generative Expand with its own Firefly models, which is what you need to make room beside a subject or reshape an image for a phone. Adobe also says it trained those models on licensed material, such as Adobe Stock, and public-domain content, and that it does not train Firefly on user content. The most important compromise is that those statements describe Adobe’s own models. The partner models sold inside Firefly, such as Google’s Nano Banana and Black Forest Labs’ FLUX, spend from the plan’s 2,000 monthly credits, and Adobe leaves it to you to decide whether a partner model suits your project. Firefly plans, Adobe’s approach to generative AI, Firefly FAQ
If lettering is part of the artwork, or you need a very wide header, look at Ideogram Plus first. It costs $20 a month or $180 a year, keeps new images private until you publish them, and now includes 2,400 credits a month. Its 4.0 model offers shapes as wide as 3:1 at 2K, and a beta Studio tool turns generated lettering into editable text. Read its data terms before choosing it: Ideogram’s privacy policy says it uses prompts and uploaded images to improve and develop its products and describes no opt-out. Midjourney suits keeping a series in one style, with image style references and reusable style codes, but new work is public unless you pay $60 a month for Pro, and its terms give Midjourney a perpetual license to what you upload and create. Ideogram plans and credits, Ideogram privacy policy, Midjourney plans, Midjourney terms
None of these services gives you legal clearance for an image. All three allow commercial use of output, and each leaves responsibility for infringing content with you. Ideogram’s terms warn that your output may not be unique, Adobe offers intellectual-property indemnification only to eligible enterprise customers, and Midjourney is defending copyright suits brought by Disney, Universal and Warner Bros. Discovery, which are allegations, not findings. “Original” in this comparison means a new image made for your brief, not an exclusive or rights-cleared one. This is a software comparison, not legal advice. Ideogram terms, section 2, Firefly plans, case 2:25-cv-05275
Our prices are US list prices before tax, promotions and extra credits; Ideogram’s prices were confirmed October 29, 2026, while Adobe’s and Midjourney’s could not be confirmed again and remain as checked October 19. Three conditions would change our recommendation: lettering or very wide headers (choose Ideogram), a series whose look matters more than privacy or price (choose Midjourney), or work that would run mostly through partner models, where Firefly’s credits run out quickly. Adobe holds its MAX conference on November 10–12, 2026, where it introduced Firefly Image 5 a year earlier, so check the plan page before you subscribe. Before paying for any of them, write a small acceptance brief: a wide scene, its phone crop and a related second illustration. Count rejected attempts as well as accepted ones, and keep downloaded masters, prompts and settings outside the service.
Disclosure: Practical Picks articles are researched and written with AI, currently Anthropic’s Claude. Adobe’s Claude plugin includes Firefly, and Ideogram documents adding Ideogram to Claude. We have no relationship with Adobe, Ideogram or Anthropic over this article, and these Claude links carried no weight in our judgment. Adobe for Claude, Ideogram MCP
Adobe Firefly
Preferred Pick · private website illustrations
Choose Firefly Standard for private website illustrations made mainly with Adobe’s own models, when you value Adobe’s statements on licensed training data and no training on your content.
Reasons to choose it
- Work is not shared unless you choose to, according to Adobe’s documentation
- Unlimited Generate Image, Generative Fill and Generative Expand with Adobe models
- Adobe says it trains its models on licensed and public-domain content, not user content
What to watch
- Partner models spend credits and lack Adobe’s training assurances
- Help lists a 2000 × 2000 download maximum
- Annual plan billed monthly charges 50% of the remainder if you cancel early
Firefly Standard costs $9.99 a month, billed monthly, with 2,000 generative credits. Adobe says every paid plan includes unlimited use of standard features such as Generate Image, Generative Fill and Generative Expand; credits pay for premium features, including partner-model output, and do not roll over. Pro costs $19.99 with 4,000 credits. On October 19 Adobe was advertising a year of unlimited generations on some partner models with its larger plans, and a discount on its two largest plans ending October 21. Those offers are not in our comparison. Firefly plans
For revisions, Adobe documents style references, which you upload or pick from a supplied set and weight with an intensity control, and Generative Expand, which extends an image to a preset ratio or a freeform boundary you drag, with an optional prompt for the new area. Those are the controls that matter when a hero image needs space for a headline or a different shape on a phone. They are documented features, not evidence that a second illustration will match the first. Style reference, Generative Expand
Read the full Adobe Firefly analysis and sources
Choose another tool if most of your work would run through partner models. Adobe’s partner-model help page, as indexed by search on October 19, listed Nano Banana 2 at 20 credits per 1K generation and GPT Image 2 at 5 to 60 credits depending on quality, with some rates marked as limited-time. At 20 credits, Standard’s allowance covers about 100 generations a month. Adobe says user content in its apps is not used to train partner models either, but its training and commercial-safety statements describe Firefly models, and it says partner-model suitability is the creator’s responsibility. Content Credentials can record that an image came from a partner model. Partner models in Adobe products, Adobe’s approach
Adobe’s FAQ says output from non-beta features can be used commercially, and beta output can too unless the product says otherwise, although beta output is not eligible for indemnification. The plan page offers indemnification for select output only to eligible enterprise customers, not to a Standard subscriber. Content from Adobe Stock contributors is part of the training set under their contributor agreements. None of this is a legal clearance for a particular image. Firefly FAQ, Firefly plans
Adobe’s help says Firefly saves your generations to a generation history in your Adobe cloud storage, and it describes a public link and a Firefly Community gallery submission as separate steps you choose. Adobe reviews gallery submissions and may use the image, prompt and profile name in marketing. A community expert on Adobe’s forum, who is not an Adobe employee, said in October 2025 that generations are visible only to you unless you create them on a Board others can open or submit them to the gallery. Adobe’s help pages do not state the default in those words, and we did not audit storage, deletion or staff access. Generation history, submit your work, community answer, October 27, 2025
Check the output size before designing around it. Adobe’s technical requirements list JPG and PNG downloads with a 2,000 × 2,000 pixel maximum, while TechCrunch reported in October 2025 that Firefly Image 5 generates at up to 4 megapixels natively. We could not reconcile the two. Adobe’s aspect-ratio guide, read September 7 and rechecked in a browser on October 19, lists 1:1, 4:3, 3:4 and 16:9, with 9:16 noted for Image 4 and Image 4 Ultra. Adobe’s help pages did not load for our automated check on October 19, so these Adobe help details come from search-indexed text or our September 7 reading. Technical requirements, TechCrunch, October 28, 2025, aspect ratios
Pick the billing option deliberately at checkout. Adobe’s subscription terms, effective August 1, 2026, refund a month-to-month plan within 14 days of the first order; after that, payments are non-refundable and service runs to the end of the billing month. An annual plan billed monthly charges 50% of the remaining commitment if you cancel after 14 days. The FTC’s 2024 complaint alleged that Adobe did not adequately disclose that fee and made cancelling difficult. Adobe said on March 13, 2026 that it had finalized a settlement with the Justice Department, paying $75 million and providing $75 million in free services, while denying wrongdoing. The FTC’s case page still showed the matter as pending, last updated July 2024, when we checked. Subscription terms, FTC case 222 3055, Adobe statement
Used Adobe Firefly? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Ideogram
Also consider · lettering and wide headers
Choose Ideogram Plus when generated lettering or very wide header shapes matter, and you have read and accept its data-use terms.
Reasons to choose it
- Header shapes up to 3:1 at 2K
- Beta tool turns generated lettering into editable text
- Private until you publish; slower queue after credits run out
What to watch
- Uses prompts and uploads to improve products; no training opt-out described
- Style references and presets only on the older 3.0 model
- Cancel five days before renewal; no refunds
Ideogram Plus costs $20 a month, or $180 a year ($15 a month), with 2,400 credits a month. Independent pricing trackers record the increase from 1,000 credits in early October 2026 at unchanged prices. On Plus and higher plans, new images stay private until you publish them; on the free plan everything is public. When credits run out, Plus keeps generating with Ideogram’s own models in a slower queue, but edits, upscales, reference-image generations and partner models still need credits. Plans and credits, page verified October 15, 2026, PricingSaaS, share and publish
It has two specific reasons to choose it. Ideogram 4.0 offers wide shapes such as 23:9 and 3:1 at 2K, which suit website headers. Studio’s Layerize Text, a beta tool, finds lettering in an image and turns it into editable text layers, so you can change the wording without generating again. Ideogram says curved, decorative or embedded lettering is harder to detect and that exact font matching isn’t guaranteed, so keep essential headings as real page text. Image settings, Layerize Text
Read the full Ideogram analysis and sources
Its series controls sit on its older model. Style presets, color palettes and up to 10 style reference images work only with Ideogram 3.0; Ideogram 4.5 instead takes up to five reference images to edit or combine. Studio, which replaced the old Canvas editor, handles inpainting, extending a layer and text, though some layer tools need a paid plan. Downloads come as JPEG, PNG or WEBP from 1K to 8K, and sizes above the original are upscales that cost credits. Ideogram also runs partner models, including OpenAI’s GPT Image 2.5 and Google’s Nano Banana, as premium options. Models, Studio, download
A pricing tracker recorded that Ideogram 4.0 images at 2K cost 1, 2 or 3 credits each, depending on quality, after an August 2026 cut, and that the October credit increase left per-image costs unchanged. On that basis, 2,400 credits would cover roughly 800 to 2,400 such images before edits or upscales. That is our arithmetic from a third-party capture, not a quote; Ideogram shows the cost before each run. UsagePricing, August 25, 2026, UsagePricing, October 5, 2026
The terms, last revised August 14, 2024, claim no ownership of your output and do not restrict commercial use, but warn that output may not be unique. They give Ideogram a license to your inputs and outputs to operate, improve and promote its services, and keep private content out of other users’ remixing. The privacy policy, last revised January 15, 2025, says Ideogram uses prompts and uploaded images to improve and develop its products and lists model training among its uses of some information. We could not establish whether personal-plan content trains Ideogram’s models. The terms name Ideogram AI while the site footer names Ideogram, Inc. Terms, privacy policy
Cancel at least five days before renewal. Ideogram’s help page now states that rule from its terms, which resolves the conflict we noted in September with the pricing page’s “cancel at any time” wording. There are no refunds, including for partly used periods. After you leave, existing private images stay private, and new images on the free plan are public. Cancelling your subscription, refunds
Used Ideogram? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Midjourney
Series styling · public unless you pay $60/month
Consider Midjourney when carrying one style across a series matters most, and you accept public work on Basic or pay $60 a month for Pro.
Reasons to choose it
- Image style references and reusable style codes
- Editor resizes the canvas, regenerates regions and works in layers
- 2048 × 2048 HD square images on V8.2
What to watch
- New work and V8 edits of uploads are public without Stealth
- Perpetual license to Midjourney over inputs and outputs
- Studio copyright suits pending; allegations only
Midjourney Basic costs $10 a month with 200 minutes of fast GPU time, Standard costs $30 and adds unlimited image generation in the slower Relax mode, and Pro at $60 is the cheapest plan with Stealth mode, which keeps new work off the public website. Annual plans cost 20% less, paid upfront: $576 a year for Pro. Plans renew automatically. A company with more than $1 million in yearly revenue, or an employee of one, must subscribe to Pro or Mega to own its output. Comparing plans, updated May 18, 2026, terms, section 4
Its strength is carrying one look across a series. Style references apply the look of images you supply to new prompts, and style codes reapply a look from Midjourney’s style library or one you build with its Style Creator. Midjourney documents several style-reference versions that interpret the same reference differently, so record the model version and settings with each accepted image. The browser Editor regenerates erased regions, resizes the canvas to a new aspect ratio and combines images as layers, and it downloads the original or a transparent PNG of the current edit. At the default square shape, V8.2 makes 2,048 × 2,048 HD or 1,024 × 1,024 SD images. Style Reference, Editor, image size
Read the full Midjourney analysis and sources
Visibility changes the decision. Editor creations made with the V8.X edit model, including edits of images you upload, appear on midjourney.com for other members unless Stealth is on; older V7 instructions described edits of uploads as private. Even with Stealth, work in a public Discord channel is visible there, and trashed creations can still be found by their links. Content you made private stays private after you downgrade. Editor visibility, Stealth Mode
The terms, effective May 27, 2026, say you own what you create to the extent the law allows, subject to the rights of others, and that ownership survives a downgrade or cancellation. They also grant Midjourney a perpetual, irrevocable license to reproduce and distribute both what you upload and what you create, surviving termination. By default your content is public and other members can remix it; Stealth is a “best efforts” commitment. We found no statement in the terms about what Midjourney trains its models on. Terms, section 4
Disney and Universal sued Midjourney for copyright infringement in federal court in California in June 2025, and Warner Bros. Discovery followed in September 2025; the court consolidated the cases in November 2025. A case tracker lists discovery activity through October 6, 2026 and a July 2026 Midjourney motion against one of the claims, with no ruling listed. We found no decision on the merits. These are allegations, and they say nothing by themselves about whether your illustration infringes. Case 2:25-cv-05275, case tracker
Used Midjourney? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Which product are we missing?
Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.
Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.
Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.
No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.
What people are saying
Public user reports are a check on vendor claims, not a measured satisfaction score. In a March 2026 Adobe community thread, a subscriber expected unlimited Nano Banana images during a promotion and found credits being deducted; a volunteer expert replied that partner models charge per generation while Firefly’s own models are unlimited. That matches Adobe’s plan page and supports reading the credit rules before relying on a promotion. Adobe community thread, March 21, 2026
The discussions we read on September 7, 2026 raise the same kind of question for each service: confusion over which Firefly models spend credits, objections to Midjourney reserving Stealth for its $60 plan, and an Ideogram subscriber asking what slow credits cover. Some answers describe older plan conditions, such as Ideogram’s earlier 1,000-credit allowance. This is a small, self-selected sample; it supplied checks against the documentation, not a satisfaction measure or failure rate. Firefly credit thread, Midjourney Stealth thread, Ideogram slow-credit thread
How we researched
This is public-source research. We did not create accounts, sign in, subscribe, upload references, generate images, download output or try a cancellation. No vendor supplied access or payment, and the article carries no affiliate links. We first compared these services on September 7, 2026 and rechecked the material claims on October 19, 2026: prices, plan allowances, default visibility, training and licensing terms, output sizes and shapes, editing controls and cancellation terms. Adobe’s help pages blocked our automated check on October 19, so those details come from Adobe’s help text as indexed by search or from our September 7 reading; Adobe’s plan page, FAQ, approach page and subscription terms loaded directly. Midjourney’s help articles were read through the public help-center interface, and Ideogram’s through its documentation’s Markdown pages.
We chose the three services for an adult making original decorative website artwork in a browser: a design-software publisher’s own models, a service known for typography in images and an independent service built around style. We judged them on revision and series controls, cost for private work, rights and training terms, default visibility and the commitment you take on. We fixed those criteria and their weights before comparing the services. Giving more weight to revision controls or less to training terms narrows Firefly’s lead over Ideogram without reversing it in our judgment; a reader who needs editable lettering or very wide headers is better served by Ideogram. We compare browser image workflows rather than general chat features; developer image APIs and locally installed models are outside this comparison. Several of the models behind chat assistants, including GPT Image and Nano Banana, can also be used inside Firefly and Ideogram for credits. If you need editable vector files, see our vector illustration comparison.
Our October 19 search considered Reve and Lovart, both launched in 2025. Reve’s terms identify Reve AI, Inc., allow output ownership subject to other people’s rights, and let paid users opt out of future model training; its current price and private-generation settings remain unconfirmed. Lovart’s terms say users own their output but grant it a broad content license. Neither its terms nor privacy policy names a responsible legal entity, and its private-generation defaults are unclear. We selected no Rising Star for private website illustrations. Recraft and Krea predate the newcomer window; Leonardo is also older and owned by Canva. NightCafe’s release date and legal terms could not be verified. Recraft offers paid private generations and commercial rights, while Krea documents style references and image editing. Canva, Bing Image Creator, ChatGPT Images, Gemini, Meta AI and Grok were also considered; their available documentation did not establish all the private revision controls, rights and allowances needed for this comparison. Reve terms, Reve privacy, Lovart terms, Lovart privacy, Recraft pricing, Krea pricing, read October 29, 2026.
Our October 19 adverse search covered lawsuits, regulator actions, breaches, outages, ownership changes and layoffs for the three compared services and found nothing that changed these conclusions. We could not repeat that search on October 29; an earlier search that found nothing is not proof that nothing exists.
| Tool | Public sources | What remains uncertain |
|---|---|---|
| Adobe Firefly | Plan page, FAQ, generative-AI approach page and subscription terms read October 19; style reference, Expand, partner-model, gallery and technical help through search indexing or September 7 reading; FTC record and Adobe statement. | Current download maximum for each model, default visibility beyond vendor statements, partner-model rights and the plan changes expected around Adobe MAX. |
| Ideogram | Plans, models, image settings, Studio, download, sharing, cancellation and refund documentation; text-layer page; terms and privacy policy; independent pricing captures. | Whether personal-plan content trains its models, how many usable images 2,400 credits yields, Layerize Text accuracy and the contracting entity’s name. |
| Newer alternatives | Reve terms and privacy policy; Lovart pricing, terms and privacy policy read October 29, 2026. | Reve’s suitable price and private-generation settings; Lovart’s responsible legal entity and private-generation defaults. Neither has an endorsement here. |
| Midjourney | Plan, Style Reference, Editor, Stealth, image-size and terms articles through the help-center interface; court docket and case tracker. | How Midjourney uses uploaded content beyond the license, the outcome of the studio lawsuits and whether Stealth holds in every workflow. |
None of this establishes image quality, style consistency, spelling accuracy, speed or the rights position of any output. Next substantive review is due December 1, 2026, after Adobe’s November conference and current promotions, or sooner if a plan, model or policy changes materially. Found a changed price or term? Contact the editors.
Sources and evidence
Sources were checked October 19, 2026 unless another date is given. On October 29 we also read Ideogram’s pricing, terms, privacy and cancellation instructions; its quoted prices and five-day cancellation rule remain unchanged. Vendor material establishes documented offers, features and terms, not output quality or how a service treats data in practice. Community posts are attributed experiences, not representative samples.
- Adobe: Firefly plans; Firefly FAQ; approach to generative AI; subscription terms, effective August 1, 2026; statement on the DOJ settlement, March 13, 2026. Help pages that blocked automated retrieval, confirmed through search indexing on October 19: partner models, Generative Expand, generation history, submit your work, technical requirements. Last read September 7: style reference, aspect ratios. Adobe community forum: visibility answer, October 27, 2025.
- FTC: United States v. Adobe Inc., matter 222 3055, page last updated July 25, 2024. TechCrunch: Firefly Image 5, October 28, 2025.
- Ideogram documentation: plans and credits, verified October 15, 2026; models; image settings; Studio; download; share and publish; cancelling; refunds. Ideogram site: pricing; Layerize Text; terms, revised August 14, 2024; privacy policy, revised January 15, 2025. Independent pricing captures: PricingSaaS, October 2026; UsagePricing, August 25 and October 5, 2026.
- Midjourney help center: comparing plans, May 18, 2026; Style Reference, September 1, 2026; Editor, September 2, 2026; Stealth Mode; image size; aspect ratio; terms of service, effective May 27, 2026.
- Court records: Disney Enterprises et al. v. Midjourney, C.D. Cal. 2:25-cv-05275, a docket mirror that blocked automated retrieval on October 19; case tracker, ChatGPT Is Eating the World, a secondary source for filings through October 6, 2026.
- Community evidence: Adobe community thread, March 21, 2026. Read September 7: Reddit threads on Firefly credits, Midjourney Stealth pricing and Ideogram slow credits.
This is a researched comparison, not a product review. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.