Booking and memberships for a small fitness or yoga studio: PushPress, Punchpass, Gymdesk and OfferingTree
PushPress Pro has no contract, unlimited staff, an automatic waitlist and the lowest card rate on the plans we priced, for $159 a month, but its lead is narrow and late-cancel fees are charged by hand. Punchpass and Gymdesk scored higher, but we could not confirm the companies behind them as our rules require. No newcomer met our Rising Star requirements.
PushPress
Pro has unlimited staff and admins, a waitlist that moves the first person into a class automatically, late cancels and no-shows that count against the member’s plan, membership pauses and nightly retries of failed payments, at 2.89% + $0.30 a card payment, month to month.
Its lead over OfferingTree is narrow (4.51 to 4.48); Punchpass and Gymdesk scored higher but failed our operator check; late-cancel fees are charged by hand and email campaigns cost $329 a month more.
Why PushPress is our PickTeam behind PushPress? Get your award badge
No Rising Star selected
Two newer studio systems fit the job, but neither identifies a company we could verify. Others do not show memberships that bill automatically or service for US studios.
No newcomer released since November 15, 2024 met all our availability, fit, operator and safety requirements.
Who is this article for? The owner of a small independent yoga, Pilates or fitness studio in the US, with one location and a handful of instructors, who wants clients to book and pay on their own and memberships to renew automatically.
About 24 min read
What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean
The quick list
Prices read November 15, 2026, USD before tax, for a studio with 150 active clients and four staff logins. Card fees cost more than any subscription here, so compare the card rate as closely as the monthly price.
Published prices read November 15, 2026, USD before tax. PushPress Pro is $159 a month at 2.89% + $0.30; its Free plan charges 4.99% + $0.30. Gymdesk is $150 a month for 101 to 150 active members with Gymdesk Payments (2.9% + $0.30 a card payment, 3.5% for American Express, and $5 a month), or $175 with your own processor. Punchpass Flow is $99 a month or $1,045 a year, with Stripe’s standard 2.9% + 30¢ and no Punchpass fee. OfferingTree Studio Grow is $150 a month billed yearly or $180 monthly, at 3.4% + 30¢ online. Three-year costs with $12,000 a month in 120 card payments: Punchpass $16,959, Gymdesk $19,404, PushPress Pro $19,505, OfferingTree $21,384.
The comparison at a glance
Compare what each system costs over three years once card fees are counted, how it handles waitlists and late cancels, what the contract says and what you can take with you.
Order follows our verdict for this reader, not measured reliability. All tools remain selectable.
Hides matching answers for the selected tools. Unknowns and unverified claims stay visible.
| Feature | PushPress | Punchpass | Gymdesk | OfferingTree |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: no contract, unlimited staff, automatic waitlist, the lowest card rate on the plans we priced | Also consider: highest score of the four and lowest cost; operator address unconfirmed | Also consider: everything included in one price; company not independently confirmed | Also consider: built for yoga and Pilates studios, with a website and automatic late-cancel fees |
| Price for this studio | Pro $159/month; Free $0 | Flow $99/month or $1,045/year | $150/month for 101–150 active members with Gymdesk Payments; $175 with your own processor | Studio Grow $150/month billed yearly or $180 monthly |
| Three-year cost, card fees included | $19,505 on Pro; $22,853 on Free | $16,959 | $19,404 | $21,384 |
| Card fees | Pro 2.89% + $0.30; Free 4.99% + $0.30; Max 2.75% + $0.30 | Your own Stripe account at 2.9% + 30¢; no Punchpass fee | Gymdesk Payments 2.9% + $0.30 (3.5% for American Express) and $5/month | 3.4% + 30¢ online; 3.2% + 5¢ in person |
| Waitlist | First person moved in automatically | Autofill mode adds the first person automatically | Next person added automatically and emailed | First person added automatically; 60-minute default cut-off |
| Late cancels and no-shows | Count against the member’s plan; fees charged by hand | Late cancel charges the pass; penalty fees charged by staff | Cancellation window; sessions deducted for no-shows; no automatic late-cancel fee found | Automatic fees for clients on a pack or membership |
| Contract | Month to month; cancel at least 30 days before renewal; no refunds | Month to month; cancel in billing settings; yearly payment not refunded | Month to month; no setup fee or cancellation cost; fees not refunded | Monthly or yearly; yearly refundable within 14 days |
| Taking your data | Member export seen only in search results; data kept 30 days after notice | Reports as spreadsheets; contents not itemised | Members, attendance, payments, waivers and documents, self-serve | Contacts to CSV; memberships and visits not found |
Hosted studio systems for one location with 150 active clients, four staff logins and $12,000 a month in 120 card payments, treated as online or stored-card payments. Sources checked November 15, 2026; next review December 20, 2026, or sooner after a price, card-rate or contract change. Three-year costs include card fees, which are larger than any subscription here. PushPress’s lead over OfferingTree is narrow. Punchpass and Gymdesk scored higher, but we could not confirm a business address for Punchpass’s operator or an independent record of Gymdesk’s, which our rules require for a new Pick. No newcomer met our Rising Star requirements. Public-source research: no accounts, trials or payments.
All features and sources 13 criteria
Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.
Price and card fees
Show 5 criteria
| Feature | PushPress | Punchpass | Gymdesk | OfferingTree |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: no contract, unlimited staff, automatic waitlist, the lowest card rate on the plans we priced | Also consider: highest score of the four and lowest cost; operator address unconfirmed | Also consider: everything included in one price; company not independently confirmed | Also consider: built for yoga and Pilates studios, with a website and automatic late-cancel fees |
| Price for this studio | Pro $159/month; Free $0 | Flow $99/month or $1,045/year | $150/month for 101–150 active members with Gymdesk Payments; $175 with your own processor | Studio Grow $150/month billed yearly or $180 monthly |
| Three-year cost, card fees included | $19,505 on Pro; $22,853 on Free | $16,959 | $19,404 | $21,384 |
| Card fees | Pro 2.89% + $0.30; Free 4.99% + $0.30; Max 2.75% + $0.30 | Your own Stripe account at 2.9% + 30¢; no Punchpass fee | Gymdesk Payments 2.9% + $0.30 (3.5% for American Express) and $5/month | 3.4% + 30¢ online; 3.2% + 5¢ in person |
| Staff logins | Unlimited staff and admins | Unlimited instructors; 3 access levels | Unlimited staff accounts | 6 team members (Starter allows 3) |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for price and card fees
Prices read November 15, 2026, USD before tax, for a studio with 150 active clients, four staff logins and $12,000 a month in 120 card payments over three years: Gymdesk pricing and Gymdesk Payments; Punchpass pricing and payments; PushPress pricing; OfferingTree studio pricing and payment processing; Stripe US pricing. Promotions excluded.
Booking and attendance
Show 3 criteria
| Feature | PushPress | Punchpass | Gymdesk | OfferingTree |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Waitlist | First person moved in automatically | Autofill mode adds the first person automatically | Next person added automatically and emailed | First person added automatically; 60-minute default cut-off |
| Late cancels and no-shows | Count against the member’s plan; fees charged by hand | Late cancel charges the pass; penalty fees charged by staff | Cancellation window; sessions deducted for no-shows; no automatic late-cancel fee found | Automatic fees for clients on a pack or membership |
| Client booking | Members App; schedule embed by iframe | Free iPhone and Android apps; website integration | Free member app; booking widget by script or WordPress shortcode | Free client app; schedule embed; website builder included |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for booking and attendance
Gymdesk booking, booking settings and member app; Punchpass waitlists, late cancel and penalty fees; PushPress waitlist, late-cancel report, members app and embedding; OfferingTree waitlists, late-cancel fees, client app and embedding. Documented behaviour; we did not use these products.
Memberships and running the studio
Show 2 criteria
| Feature | PushPress | Punchpass | Gymdesk | OfferingTree |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Memberships and billing | Pause with no charges; nightly retry; trial purchase limits on Pro | Recurring memberships; failed-payment retries; new-customer specials; pause not found | Freeze pauses payments; retries on days 2, 4 and 7; trial memberships | Pause; failed-payment retries; intro offers |
| Email, pay and check-in | Plain mass email and text (campaigns in Grow, $329/month); payroll report and kiosk plan not shown | Emails; self check-in; payroll report not found | Bulk email; staff pay reports; check-in | Email marketing; staff pay reports; check-in screen |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for memberships and running the studio
Gymdesk freezing, billing setup, trial memberships, email marketing and staff payroll; Punchpass pricing and payments; PushPress pauses, payments guide, purchase limits and messaging; OfferingTree pausing, failed payments and studio pricing.
Contract, data and company
Show 3 criteria
| Feature | PushPress | Punchpass | Gymdesk | OfferingTree |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Contract | Month to month; cancel at least 30 days before renewal; no refunds | Month to month; cancel in billing settings; yearly payment not refunded | Month to month; no setup fee or cancellation cost; fees not refunded | Monthly or yearly; yearly refundable within 14 days |
| Taking your data | Member export seen only in search results; data kept 30 days after notice | Reports as spreadsheets; contents not itemised | Members, attendance, payments, waivers and documents, self-serve | Contacts to CSV; memberships and visits not found |
| Company | PushPress, Inc. (Delaware) | Trillo, Inc. (Vermont); business address not found | Martial Arts on Rails, LLC (Texas); a Five Elms Capital portfolio company, per its October 2026 press release | OfferingTree, Inc.; trademark and App Store say OfferingTree, SBC (Minnesota) |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for contract, data and company
Gymdesk pricing, terms, documentation terms and press release; Punchpass terms, cancelling and App Store; PushPress terms, Core and USPTO record; OfferingTree terms, privacy policy, cancelling, contacts export and USPTO record. Not legal advice; no export or cancellation was run.
What matters when choosing
PushPress Pro is our Practical Pick for a small studio that wants class booking, an automatic waitlist and memberships that bill themselves, with no contract. Pro costs $159 a month and takes card payments at 2.89% plus $0.30, the lowest card rate of the four on the plans we priced; staff, admins and members are unlimited, and every plan is month to month. Its help pages say the first person on the waitlist is moved into a class automatically, that late cancels and no-shows count against the member’s plan, that you can pause a membership with no charges while it is paused, and that failed payments are retried every night (read November 15, 2026). If your card sales are small, its Free plan has no monthly fee but charges 4.99% plus $0.30. PushPress pricing, waitlist, pauses, payments guide
Two things to know about this Pick. First, its lead is narrow: under the criteria and weights we fixed before scoring, PushPress scored 4.51 out of 5 against 4.48 for OfferingTree, the next-highest product we could label, and the gap rests on card fees. Second, Punchpass (4.56) and Gymdesk (4.51, 4.513 against PushPress’s 4.512 before rounding) scored higher, but our rules let a product become a new Pick only when we can name the company behind it, find an address for it and confirm it from a source independent of the company. We could do that for PushPress, through its US trademark registration, but not for those two (see their sections). PushPress’s own compromises: charging a late-cancel fee is a manual step, email campaigns need its $329-a-month Grow add-on, and it is built mainly for gyms, with CrossFit and martial arts first among the businesses it lists. Late-cancel report, trademark record
No Rising Star selected. On November 15, 2026 we searched launch sites, app stores, GitHub, maker forums and recent coverage for studio systems first released since November 15, 2024. ClassKeep and YogaTeacher fit the job, but neither identifies a company we could verify; Corebility and Trainera do not show memberships that bill automatically; Brimly and Lorari do not show service for US studios. ClassIQ, which looks new, says one gym has run it since January 2023, which puts it outside our two-year window. Details are under How we researched.
Also consider Punchpass, the highest score of the four and the cheapest. Flow costs $99 a month or $1,045 a year, Punchpass adds no fee to your card payments beyond the standard 2.9% plus 30¢ processing rate, and it is month to month. Its terms name Trillo, Inc., a Vermont corporation, but no Punchpass page we read gives a business address, and Vermont’s business register needs a browser our research tools do not use. Punchpass pricing, terms, payments
Also consider Gymdesk for everything in one price. For 101 to 150 active members it costs $150 a month with Gymdesk Payments (2.9% plus $0.30 a card payment, 3.5% for American Express, plus a $5 monthly account fee), with unlimited staff accounts, a member app, a booking widget, payroll reports and bulk email included. Its terms name Martial Arts on Rails, LLC with an address in Austin, Texas, but the only other record of that company we could read is Apple’s App Store listing, whose seller details come from the company itself. Gymdesk pricing, Gymdesk Payments
Also consider OfferingTree if you run a yoga or Pilates studio and want the website, email marketing and automatic late-cancel fees in one system. Studio Grow, the plan that allows more than three team members, costs $150 a month billed yearly or $180 monthly. Its own card rate, 3.4% plus 30 cents online, makes it the most expensive of the four for our studio over three years. OfferingTree says its AI provider is Anthropic, the company that makes Claude, which we use to research and write; see the disclosure under How we researched. OfferingTree studio pricing, payment processing
If you are comparing Mindbody, WellnessLiving, Momence, Arketa or Walla, ask for the card rate in writing before you sign. None of them published a complete price we could use for this studio. Card fees are the biggest cost in every system here: at $12,000 a month of sales in 120 payments, the standard 2.9% plus 30¢ comes to $13,824 over three years, more than any subscription in this comparison.
PushPress
Preferred Pick · no contract, unlimited staff, automatic waitlist
Choose PushPress for automatic class rules with no contract: its help pages describe a waitlist that moves the first person in automatically, late cancels and no-shows that count against the plan, membership pauses and nightly retries of failed payments, with unlimited staff (read November 15, 2026). Pro charges 2.89% + $0.30 a card payment. Its lead over OfferingTree is narrow.
Reasons to choose it
- Unlimited staff and admins; month to month
- Waitlist fills cancelled places automatically
- Lowest card rate of the four on the plans we priced; Free plan to start
What to watch
- Late-cancel fees are charged by hand, despite its pricing page
- Cancel at least 30 days before renewal; no refunds
- Email campaigns need Grow, $329 a month
PushPress, Inc. is a Delaware company; its US trademark registration for PUSHPRESS, renewed and active, lists the same company in Delaware. It makes gym software for businesses from CrossFit and martial arts to studio fitness. Its Free plan has no monthly fee and charges 4.99% plus $0.30 a card payment; Pro is $159 a month at 2.89% plus $0.30; Max is $229 at 2.75% plus $0.30. Staff, admins and members are unlimited on every plan, and “Core comes in three plans, all month-to-month with no contracts.” For our studio (150 active members, $12,000 a month in 120 card payments), Pro costs $19,505 over three years, $5,724 of it subscription, and Free $22,853. Pricing, Core, terms, trademark record, checked November 15, 2026
Choose PushPress if you want automatic class rules, no contract and room to start free. Its help pages say that when a booked member cancels, “the first person on the waitlist is moved into the class automatically. Staff don’t need to do anything”, that late cancels and no-shows count against the member’s plan, that you can pause a membership with no charges while paused, and that the system “runs a nightly retry” of failed payments. Pro adds per-person purchase limits, so a trial or intro offer can be bought once per person. Members book in the PushPress Members app, the schedule can be embedded in your website, and payments run through a Stripe account in your name. These are PushPress’s own descriptions; we did not use the product. Waitlist, members app, purchase limits, embedding, Stripe connection
Read the full PushPress analysis and sources
Why choose something else
- Late-cancel fees are manual. Its help centre says charging for a no-show or late cancel “is not automated within PushPress Core” and needs “explicit, manual administrative action”, although its pricing page lists “No-show/late cancel automation”. OfferingTree charges these fees automatically. Late-cancel report
- Email campaigns cost extra. Core sends plain mass emails and texts; designed campaigns and automated sequences are in Grow, a $329-a-month add-on. Messaging members, pricing
- Cancel a month ahead. Its plans are month to month, but its terms say that to stop automatic renewal “you must cancel such subscription (via your PushPress account) at least 30 days prior to the renewal date”, so in practice you pay for about one more month after deciding to leave. Terms
- Short exit window. Its terms keep your data available for no more than 30 days after notice of termination, and you get no refund if you stop. We could not confirm a member export from a current help page (the article we found has been removed), and its pricing grid did not show which plan includes the payroll report and kiosk check-in. Terms
- Its waitlist help is unfinished. The article still carries editor notes to verify details, so check the behaviour you need during setup. Waitlist
Used PushPress? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Punchpass
Also consider · highest score of the four, lowest cost; operator address unconfirmed
Choose Punchpass for a simple month-to-month system with no fee on your card payments beyond the standard processing rate. It scored highest, but we could not confirm a business address for Trillo, Inc., so it is not our Pick.
Reasons to choose it
- No Punchpass fee on card payments; your own Stripe account
- Autofill waitlist; late cancels charge the pass
- Lowest three-year cost of the four: $16,959
What to watch
- Business address of Trillo, Inc. not found
- Prices may change by website posting; data may be deleted 60 days after cancelling
- No membership pause or payroll report found
Punchpass was started in 2013 and its team is in Burlington, Vermont; its terms name “Trillo, Inc., a Vermont S-corporation”. Flow, the cheapest plan that sells recurring memberships and saves client cards, costs $99 a month or $1,045 a year, with unlimited classes, passes and instructors and three access levels for staff and instructor logins. The only fee it charges is the subscription: “There are NO added processing fees with Punchpass,” and you connect your own Stripe account. We costed it at $16,959 over three years, the lowest of the four. Pricing, payments, about, checked November 15, 2026
Choose Punchpass if you want the simplest month-to-month system with no markup on payments. Its help centre describes an autofill waitlist (“the first person on the waitlist is automatically added to the class”), a late-cancel setting that “charges the pass” when someone cancels after your window, fixed penalty fees you can charge to unlimited members, free iPhone and Android apps for you and your clients, self check-in, new-customer specials, emails and automatic retries of failed payments. You cancel from your billing settings. Waitlists, late cancel, penalty fees, cancelling
Read the full Punchpass analysis and sources
Why choose something else
- We could not confirm the operator’s address. That is why it is not our Pick. Apple lists Trillo, Inc. as the app’s provider, so the company appears real; a business address and an independent record of the company would settle it. App Store
- Prices and data. Its terms say fees “may change anytime through website posting or email notification”, that data may be deleted 60 days after you cancel, and that its liability is capped at one month’s fees. They allow refunds only if Punchpass stops providing the service, so a yearly payment is not refunded if you leave early. Terms
- Unknowns. Its export is described only as reports “in a convenient spreadsheet format”, and we found no membership pause or payroll report in the product.
Used Punchpass? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Gymdesk
Also consider · everything included; company not independently confirmed
Choose Gymdesk for a complete studio system, month to month: Gymdesk documents an automatic waitlist, a free member app, a booking widget, freezes, failed-payment retries, bulk email and staff pay reports, with unlimited staff accounts (read November 15, 2026). It scored above PushPress, but we found no independent record of its operator, so it is not our Pick.
Reasons to choose it
- Unlimited staff accounts and every feature on every plan
- Waitlist fills cancelled places automatically
- No setup fee, minimum term or cancellation cost (Gymdesk’s words)
What to watch
- No independent record of Martial Arts on Rails, LLC found
- No automatic late-cancel fee found; no-shows lose a session
- $200 a month from 151 active members; Amex costs 3.5%
Gymdesk is run by Martial Arts on Rails, LLC, which does business as Gymdesk; its terms put disputes under Texas law and print a business mailing address in Austin. Gymdesk says it was founded in 2016, and its October 2026 press release says it “is a Five Elms Capital portfolio company”. Its price depends on active members, not counting visitors, frozen or cancelled members and prospects. With Gymdesk Payments it is $75 a month for up to 50, $100 for 51 to 100, $150 for 101 to 150 and $200 for 151 to 250; with your own card processor each tier costs $25 to $40 more. Every plan includes “every feature we build”. For our studio we costed it at $19,404 over three years: $150 a month plus the $5 account fee, and $13,824 in card fees at 2.9% plus $0.30. Pricing, Gymdesk Payments, terms, press release, October 6, 2026, checked November 15, 2026
Choose Gymdesk if you want the most included in one price, with no contract. Its documentation describes a waitlist where “the next person is automatically added to the session and notified by email”, booking rules that set when cancellations are allowed and can “deduct sessions automatically for no-shows”, a free member app for booking, joining waitlists and checking in, a booking widget you add to your own site by script or WordPress shortcode, freezes that pause payments, automatic retries of failed payments after 2, 4 and 7 days, and trial memberships you can keep existing members out of. Bulk email is included on paid plans, and staff pay reports cover hourly and per-session rates (Gymdesk does not run payroll itself). It says you can export members, attendance history, payment records, waivers and documents yourself. These are Gymdesk’s own descriptions; we did not use the product. Booking, booking settings, member app, freezing, billing setup, trial memberships, email marketing, staff payroll
Read the full Gymdesk analysis and sources
Why choose something else
- We could not confirm the company independently. That is why it is not our Pick. Apple lists Martial Arts on Rails LLC as the developer of Gymdesk’s member app, but that comes from the company’s own enrolment; the trademark and Better Business Bureau pages we tried could not be read, and the GYMDESK trademark application is in the founder’s own name. App Store
- No automatic late-cancel fee. You can close cancellations at a set time and deduct a session for no-shows, but we found no setting that charges a fee for a late cancel. Booking settings
- The price steps at 151 members. The 151st active member moves you to $200 a month (with Gymdesk Payments), and American Express payments cost 3.5% plus $0.30. Pricing
- Built for gyms first. It began as Martial Arts on Rails. Its member app has 3.6 stars from 47 ratings on the App Store, and the waitlist does not refill if you raise a full class’s limit. Its pricing page says “no minimum term, no cancellation cost”; its documentation terms say fees paid “are non-refundable”. Booking, docs terms
Used Gymdesk? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
OfferingTree
Also consider · built for yoga and Pilates studios
Choose OfferingTree if you want the timetable, memberships, website, email marketing and automatic late-cancel fees in one system. Its own card rate, 3.4% + 30¢ online, makes it the most expensive of the four over three years.
Reasons to choose it
- Automatic late-cancel and no-show fees on Studio Grow
- Website builder and email marketing included
- Free client app; yearly plan refundable within 14 days
What to watch
- Card rate 3.4% + 30¢ online
- Export of contacts only; memberships and visits not found
- Its AI provider is Anthropic (see disclosure)
OfferingTree has served studios since 2016; its terms and privacy policy name OfferingTree, Inc., and the privacy policy gives a PO Box in Minneapolis, while its trademark record and App Store listing say OfferingTree, SBC. Studio Starter ($100 a month billed yearly, $120 monthly) allows three team members, so a studio with four logins needs Studio Grow: $150 a month billed yearly or $180 monthly, with six team members. OfferingTree adds no transaction fee on studio plans, but its own published card rate is 3.4% plus 30 cents online, so our studio’s three-year cost is $21,384. Studio pricing, payment processing, privacy policy, trademark record, checked November 15, 2026
Choose OfferingTree if you want one system for the timetable, memberships, website, email marketing and automatic late-cancel fees. On Studio Grow “you can automatically charge clients penalty fees when they late cancel or no-show”, and when someone cancels “the first person who registered for the waitlist is then added to the active roster”. Clients book in its free app, and you can embed the schedule on another website. You can cancel an annual plan and get a refund within 14 days of being charged. Late cancel and no-show fees, waitlists, client app, cancelling
Read the full OfferingTree analysis and sources
Why choose something else
- Higher card fees. At 3.4% plus 30 cents, our studio would pay $2,160 more in card fees over three years than at 2.9% plus 30¢. Its terms and privacy policy name Braintree as its processor, while its help pages describe Stripe. Payment processing, terms
- Limited export. We found an export of contacts to CSV, but not of memberships or visit history. Monthly plans are never refunded. Downloading contacts
- AI from Anthropic. Its AI Code of Ethics says its AI provider is Anthropic. AI features carried no weight in our scores. AI Code of Ethics
Used OfferingTree? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Which product are we missing?
Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.
Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.
Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.
No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.
What people are saying
Outside comment helped us check the makers’ claims, not score satisfaction. On Apple’s App Store, Gymdesk’s member app has 3.6 stars from 47 ratings (November 15, 2026). We could not read Capterra, G2 or BBB pages with our tools; search results showed Gymdesk at about 4.8 on Capterra with complaints about slower support, and PushPress at 4.8 from 198 reviews on G2 (a figure PushPress also shows on its own pricing page), with reviewers mentioning slow periods, price rises and slow help with urgent problems. These are unverified summaries, not a measure of how common the problems are. Gymdesk app, PushPress pricing
PushPress’s own help article on waitlists still carries unfinished editor notes, and its late-cancel help contradicts its pricing page, so check the behaviour you need in a trial. OfferingTree’s status history shows two minor incidents in October 2026. We found no lawsuits, regulator actions or data breaches involving any of the four makers. OfferingTree status
How we researched
This is public-source research. We did not sign up for, use or test any of these systems, and no maker supplied access or payment. On November 15, 2026 we read each product’s pricing, feature, help, legal and privacy pages, app-store listings, trademark records and independent coverage, and searched the press, review sites and court and regulator records for problems.
We chose products for one job: a small US studio with one room, 25 group classes a week, 150 active clients, four staff logins and $12,000 a month in 120 card payments, mostly online or on stored cards. To be compared a product had to be a hosted service a US studio can buy now, let clients book capacity-limited classes themselves, sell memberships that bill automatically and class packs, take card payments, and allow four staff logins. We fixed the criteria and weights before scoring: three-year cost including card fees (30%), booking and attendance rules (25%), memberships and payments (20%), running the studio (10%), and data, exit and continuity (15%). Every product starts at 5 and loses points only for gaps its own pages show; a fact no page states is left as unknown. Costs are three-year totals for the cheapest suitable plan with billing of a year or less, scored against the median ($17,388) of eleven priced products. Contract traps cost Pike13, Vagaro and ClassIQ half a point each.
We also scored, under the same weights:
- ClassIQ (4.40) costs $99 a month with Stripe’s rate “passed through without markup”, and describes an automatic waitlist, no-show strikes and late-cancel fees. Its terms also allow “a per-transaction application fee” and “a platform fee”, and onboarding is by demo, a few studios at a time. ClassIQ, terms
- Acuity Scheduling (4.20, Standard at $27 a month billed yearly or $34 monthly) is the cheapest here and sells memberships and packages through your own Stripe or Square account with no Acuity fee. But its waitlist texts people a link rather than booking them, a failed card cancels the client’s subscription, it cannot send newsletters, and its client app was withdrawn on February 20, 2026, leaving mobile web booking. Acuity pricing, waitlist, subscriptions, mass email, client app
- Square Appointments (4.06, Plus at $49 a month, with Square’s 2.9% plus 30¢ online card rate) books classes with a set number of spots and sells class packages, and Square’s separate subscriptions bill automatically. But Square says “Waitlist for class bookings is not available”, we found nothing linking a subscription to class booking, we found no automatic retry of a failed subscription payment (Square emails the client an invoice), and late-cancel fees are charged only when staff choose to enforce them. Square Appointments pricing, class booking, waitlist, subscriptions, subscription billing, cancellation policy
- Vagaro (4.15) costs $30 a month plus $10 for each extra calendar and lists you in its consumer marketplace, but its class waitlist notifies people rather than booking them, check-in and payroll are paid add-ons, and we could not tell which of its card rates applies to online payments (we used 3.5% plus 19¢). Vagaro pricing
- Pike13 (4.02, Essential at $139 a month) runs on an annual contract with an early-termination fee, and its terms do not name the company behind it. ClassKeep (4.24, $39 a month billed yearly) and YogaTeacher (4.60, $29 a month) are newer, cheaper services that do not identify a company we could verify. Products that do not identify their operator get no label from us.
Wix Bookings (with its Pricing Plans app) fits the job, but Wix showed us plan prices for a non-US location, so we have no US price; its waitlist notifies people in turn rather than booking them, and a failed recurring payment cancels the client’s plan unless you set a grace period. Wix waitlists, Wix recurring plans
Mindbody (“Starting at $79 USD/month per location”, no plan prices or US card rate published), WellnessLiving (Business, the first plan with more than one staff login, $199 a month or $179 a month on yearly billing, card rate not published), Momence (quote only; a worked example in its help centre implies 3.9% plus $0.30), Arketa (studio plans by demo), Walla ($299 a month per location on a comparison page, onboarding fees unpriced), bsport, TeamUp (no price shown for 101 to 200 active customers), Zen Planner ($229 a month, card rate “Custom pricing”), Wodify, Exercise.com, ABC Glofox, Xplor Mariana Tek (its Core plan for single locations is priced by demo) and Momoyoga fit the job, but none published a complete US price for this studio, so their totals are incomplete. Mindbody’s terms default to a 90-day first term renewing every 30 days with 30 days’ notice, and when a new client finds you through the Mindbody app, Mindbody charges you 20% of that client’s first purchase, capped at $30. Mindbody pricing, Mindbody terms, WellnessLiving pricing, Momence payments FAQ, Walla vs Arketa, TeamUp pricing, Zen Planner pricing
For the Rising Star, on November 15, 2026 we searched Product Hunt results, AlternativeTo, Hacker News and Indie Hackers, app stores, GitHub and recent coverage for studio systems first released on or after November 15, 2024. A newcomer had to be available now, fit the job on its own pages, name its operator, have no known serious problem, and not come from an established maker of this kind of software. ClassKeep (launched in 2026) names only “the ClassKeep team” on its legal pages, and its App Store privacy label says no data is collected while its privacy policy lists account and booking data. YogaTeacher’s operator, “Inhoose Media”, has no legal form or address we could find, and its customer stories are “illustrative composites”. Corebility charges class packs after class and sends invoices but shows no automatic membership billing; Trainera’s memberships expire and are renewed; Addagio’s memberships are “coming soon”; Brimly and Lorari serve Europe and Latin America. Walla debuted in 2020, so it is too old for the award.
| Tool | Public sources | What remains uncertain |
|---|---|---|
| PushPress | Pricing, Core page, terms; help articles on waitlist, late-cancel report, members app, embedding, pauses, payments, purchase limits, Flex Fees, messaging and Stripe; USPTO record. | Which plan includes the payroll report and kiosk; member export (help article removed). |
| Punchpass | Pricing, payments, terms, privacy policy, about page; help articles on waitlists, late cancels, cancelling; product updates; App Store listing. | Trillo, Inc.’s business address and an independent record of the company; exactly what the export contains. |
| Gymdesk | Pricing, terms, privacy policy, Gymdesk Payments FAQ; documentation on booking, booking settings, member app, freezing, billing setup, trials, email and payroll; App Store listing; October 2026 press release. | An independent record of Martial Arts on Rails, LLC (register pages unreadable); how its private-equity ownership changes prices or support. |
| OfferingTree | Studio pricing, payment processing, terms, privacy policy; help articles on waitlists, late-cancel fees, client app, embedding, pauses, failed payments, cancelling and contacts export; AI Code of Ethics; USPTO record; App Store listing; status history. | Inc. versus SBC; which processor applies; membership and visit-history export. |
None of this measures how each system performs in daily use, how reliable it is or how quickly support answers. Practical Picks is researched and written with Claude, made by Anthropic. OfferingTree says its AI provider is Anthropic; Square, Wix and Squarespace (which owns Acuity) each offer a Claude connector listed in Anthropic’s directory, though Squarespace’s covers its websites and stores rather than Acuity; Arketa advertises a Claude reporting integration; and Trainera says customers can connect Claude. ClassIQ lists Anthropic among the tools it uses to build and support its product. We have no relationship with Anthropic or any of these makers over this article, and AI features carried no weight. Next substantive review is due December 20, 2026, or sooner if a price, card rate or contract term changes. Found a changed price or term? Contact the editors.
Sources and evidence
Sources were checked November 15, 2026. Maker material establishes documented features, plans and terms, not measured performance. Store ratings are attributed experiences, not representative samples.
- Gymdesk: pricing; Gymdesk Payments FAQ; terms; documentation terms; privacy policy; booking; booking settings; member app; freezing; billing setup; trial memberships; email marketing; staff payroll; press release, October 6, 2026; App Store.
- Punchpass: pricing; payments; terms, updated May 9, 2025; privacy policy; about; waitlists; late cancel; penalty fees; cancelling; App Store.
- PushPress: pricing; Core; terms; waitlist; late-cancel report; members app FAQ; embedding; pauses; payments guide; purchase limits; Flex Fees; messaging members; Stripe connection; USPTO registration 4459020.
- OfferingTree: studio pricing; payment processing; terms; privacy policy; waitlists; late-cancel and no-show fees; client app; embedding the schedule; pausing memberships; failed payments; cancelling; downloading contacts; AI Code of Ethics; USPTO registration 5149489; App Store; status history.
- Card processing: Stripe US pricing (2.9% + 30¢ for domestic cards).
- Claude connections: Square MCP server, Wix MCP, Squarespace MCP; Anthropic directory listings for Square, Wix and Squarespace; OfferingTree AI Code of Ethics.
- Others scored or priced: Acuity pricing, waitlist, subscriptions, mass email and client app; Wix waitlists and recurring plans; Square Appointments pricing, class booking, waitlist, subscriptions, subscription billing and cancellation policy; ClassIQ and terms; Vagaro pricing; Mindbody pricing, terms and single-location guide; WellnessLiving pricing and terms; Momence pricing and payments FAQ; Arketa pricing; Walla pricing and comparison page; TeamUp pricing; Zen Planner pricing; ABC Glofox prices; Xplor Mariana Tek pricing.
This is a researched comparison, not a product review. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.