Proofreading a short English article: Harper, Grammarly and two alternatives

Harper, a free checker that never sends your text anywhere, narrowly leads Grammarly Free. Grammarly works in more places, including Word, and reviewers say Harper misses errors it would flag, but Grammarly trains on your writing unless you opt out.

PRACTICAL PICKSPreferredPickOur Preferred PickA free, private check of a short article$0

Harper

Catches typos, repeated words and common grammar slips on your own device, with no account, no price and a licence that allows client work.

Narrow lead: 0.05 ahead of Grammarly Free on our five-point scale, and independent accounts say it misses subtler errors. No Word add-in.

Why Harper is our Pick
PRACTICAL PICKSRisingStarOur Rising StarA private desktop editor for a finished articleFree

Lexicon

A free, open-source writing app for Windows and macOS, first released in July 2026, that checks spelling and grammar on your own computer and lets you apply or dismiss each suggestion.

No independent test has measured what it catches, its installers are not code-signed so Windows and macOS warn you, and it is a separate editor with no Google Docs support rather than a checker inside your usual writing app.

Why Lexicon earned Rising Star

Who is this article for? People who have finished a short English article, such as a blog post, newsletter or web article, and want spelling, grammar and punctuation errors caught while deciding on each change. Not fact-checking or AI-generated rewriting.

About 29 min read

What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean

The quick list

Prices checked October 19 and November 12, 2026. Compare what the free plan covers for a short article, then where your text goes and whether you may use it for work.

Normal prices for one person, excluding tax. Harper, Lexicon and grammai are free with no paid plan. Grammarly Free covers spelling, grammar and punctuation; its Pro price, in US dollars, was checked October 19, 2026.

The comparison at a glance

Compare what each checker is known to catch, what its free plan covers, where your text is processed and whether you may use it for work.

Order follows our scores for proofreading a short article, not a measured accuracy ranking. All tools remain selectable.

Proofreading tools for a short English article
FeatureHarperGrammarlyLexicongrammai
Best fitPreferred Pick: free, private check for typos and common grammar slipsAlso consider: widest app coverage, including WordRising Star: free private desktop editor with local proofreadingFree on-device checker for Chrome, in public beta
Independent evidence on catching errorsHands-on reports, 2025–2026: catches typos and common slips, misses subtler errors2026 peer-reviewed study: corrections accurate, about half of learner errors missedNo independent test found; its own benchmark page is not countedNo independent test found
Free checking for a short articleEverything, no accountSpelling, grammar and punctuation; account neededEverything; no account, no paid planEverything; no account, no paid plan
Paid plan, normal priceNone; freePro $30/month, $60/quarter or $144/yearNone; freeNone; free
Where your text is processedOn your device onlySuperhuman’s serversOn your device; a model download comes from Hugging FaceOn your device; optional AI features go through your own account
Your text and AI trainingNo model to trainUsed by default; switch off in settingsNo text leaves your device, per its READMENo model to train for checks; optional AI follows your provider’s terms
Use for work or client articlesYes: Apache-2.0 licenceNo personal-use limit; companies limited to internal business useYes: MIT licence, “personally or commercially”Yes: GPL-3.0 licence
Browser extensionChrome, Edge, FirefoxChrome, Safari, Firefox, EdgeBeta for Chrome and Firefox, loaded in developer mode; needs the beta desktop appChrome and Chromium browsers

Proofreading a finished short English article: spelling, grammar and punctuation, with optional style suggestions. Sources checked October 19, 2026, with prices and newer tools rechecked November 12, 2026; next review December 18, 2026, or sooner if a price, training default or court matter changes. This is public-source research: we did not install any tool or submit any text. No source measures how many errors each tool catches in a polished article, so read your article once more after any checker. Fact-checking, generated rewrites, AI detection and plagiarism checks are outside this comparison.

All features and sources 20 criteria

Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.

Checking and control

Show 8 criteria
Checking and control
FeatureHarperGrammarlyLexicongrammai
Best fitPreferred Pick: free, private check for typos and common grammar slipsAlso consider: widest app coverage, including WordRising Star: free private desktop editor with local proofreadingFree on-device checker for Chrome, in public beta
Independent evidence on catching errorsHands-on reports, 2025–2026: catches typos and common slips, misses subtler errors2026 peer-reviewed study: corrections accurate, about half of learner errors missedNo independent test found; its own benchmark page is not countedNo independent test found
Free checking for a short articleEverything, no accountSpelling, grammar and punctuation; account neededEverything; no account, no paid planEverything; no account, no paid plan
Reviewing each suggestionAccept or dismiss; switch off any ruleAccept or dismiss cards, with explanationsApply, dismiss, accept all or dismiss all; dismissed stay dismissedHover, click, then accept or dismiss; undo; per-site controls
English varietiesUS, UK, Canada, Australia, IndiaUS, UK, Canada, Australia, India; converting to US spelling pausedEnglish variants among 45+ languages and dialectsAmerican or British spelling; also German
Custom wordsLocal dictionary; import a word listPersonal dictionary, freePersonal dictionaryPersonal dictionary
Style suggestionsA few phrasing rules; no tone or clarity rewritesClarity and tone with ProStyle, readability and tone checks; optional local AI rewritesOptional AI rewrites and tone changes through your own Claude Code or Codex
Generative AI features (not scored)None; no AI model in the loopAgents, rewriting and a humanizer; 100 prompts a month freeLocal rewrite and tone tools with a downloaded model or your own OllamaRewrites, translation and context checks through your own Claude Code or Codex
Sources for checking and control

Checked October 19, 2026; Lexicon and grammai November 12, 2026. Harper website and hands-on report; Grammarly plans, dialects, dictionary and 2026 accuracy study; Lexicon project page and website; grammai project page and Chrome Web Store listing. Generative AI features are listed for context and carried no weight. Not documented means we could not confirm it, not that it is missing.

Where it works

Show 5 criteria
Where it works
FeatureHarperGrammarlyLexicongrammai
Browser extensionChrome, Edge, FirefoxChrome, Safari, Firefox, EdgeBeta for Chrome and Firefox, loaded in developer mode; needs the beta desktop appChrome and Chromium browsers
Google DocsThrough the extension; two open bug reportsThrough the extensionNot supportedNot documented
Microsoft WordNo add-inAdd-in for Windows and MacImports Word files; exports DOCX with tracked suggestionsNo add-in
Desktop apps and pluginsmacOS app; WordPress, Obsidian and code-editor pluginsWindows and Mac appsWindows and macOS installers, not code-signed; Linux .debNone; the optional AI helper installs on macOS only
Getting your text backChecks text where you write itDocs export to PDF or Word drops images, citations and commentsExport to PDF, EPUB, HTML, DOCX, Markdown or textChecks text where you write it
Sources for where it works

Harper integrations and Google Docs issues 2992 and 3122; Grammarly Google Docs and Docs guide; Lexicon website and releases; grammai project page and Chrome Web Store listing. Listed integrations were not installed or tested.

Cost, text handling and terms

Show 7 criteria
Cost, text handling and terms
FeatureHarperGrammarlyLexicongrammai
Paid plan, normal priceNone; freePro $30/month, $60/quarter or $144/yearNone; freeNone; free
Refunds and cancellingNot applicableNo refunds; access until the period endsNot applicableNot applicable
Where your text is processedOn your device onlySuperhuman’s serversOn your device; a model download comes from Hugging FaceOn your device; optional AI features go through your own account
Your text and AI trainingNo model to trainUsed by default; switch off in settingsNo text leaves your device, per its READMENo model to train for checks; optional AI follows your provider’s terms
Use for work or client articlesYes: Apache-2.0 licenceNo personal-use limit; companies limited to internal business useYes: MIT licence, “personally or commercially”Yes: GPL-3.0 licence
Who runs itAutomattic Inc.; open-source projectSuperhuman Platform Inc.Aashish Harishchandre; open-source projectZASolution, Germany; open-source project
Public record to know aboutAutomattic: 2025 layoffs, September 2026 board dispute, WP Engine lawsuitExpert Review class action, paused for mediation until October 15, 2026First release July 2026; no published security advisory; none material foundFirst public beta October 18, 2026; 24 users; none material found
Sources for cost, text handling and terms

Grammarly terms, privacy, training control and complaint; Lexicon README, website and security advisories; grammai project page, releases and Chrome Web Store listing; Harper licence and Automattic reporting by TechCrunch. Prices exclude tax. Policies are documented commitments, not audited practice. Court matters are allegations, not findings about proofreading.

What matters when choosing

Harper is our Practical Pick for checking a short English article for typos and common grammar mistakes, especially if you would rather your text never left your computer. It is free, needs no account and runs entirely on your device, in Chrome, Edge and Firefox, in a macOS app, and in WordPress and Obsidian plugins. You accept or dismiss each suggestion, you can switch off any rule that does not suit your writing, and its Apache-2.0 licence allows any use, including client work. Harper, source code and licence

The compromise is how much it catches. Hands-on reports from It’s FOSS (July 2025), XDA Developers (August 2025) and MakeUseOf (January 2026) agree that Harper finds typos, repeated words and common slips, but misses subtler errors that established cloud checkers flag. One of those tests also found two correctly spelled names marked as mistakes. No independent test has measured how often it misses an error, so read your article through once more after Harper has finished. It’s FOSS, XDA Developers, MakeUseOf

Harper (3.95) leads Grammarly (3.90) by 0.05 on our five-point scale, a narrow lead. Both are free for this job (Grammarly on its free plan), so the lead does not depend on how much weight price gets. It rests on Harper’s score for catching errors, which comes from a few hands-on reports rather than a measured test; one half-step lower there would put Grammarly first. If you write in Microsoft Word or Google Docs, or if catching as many errors as possible matters more to you than keeping your text on your device, choose Grammarly Free instead. It works in more places, including a Word add-in and Windows and Mac apps, and its free plan covers spelling, grammar and punctuation. Grammarly uses your writing to train its models unless you switch off its Product Improvement and Training setting. Grammarly plans, training control

Harper is also new to ordinary writers. Its code dates from October 2023, and its browser checker reached the public in 2025. Its creator now works at Automattic, the company behind WordPress.com, which cut 16% of its staff in April 2025 and whose board briefly removed its chief executive in September 2026. An installed copy of Harper does not depend on an Automattic server, but the pace of fixes does depend on Automattic’s support. TechCrunch, April 2025, TechCrunch, September 9, 2026, CMSWire, September 12, 2026

Lexicon (3.70) is our Rising Star for checking a finished article in a private desktop editor. It is a free, open-source writing app for Windows and macOS from one developer, Aashish Harishchandre, first released in July 2026. You paste or import your article, it underlines spelling and grammar mistakes with a checker that runs on your own computer, and you apply or dismiss each suggestion; there is no account and, by its README, your writing is not sent to any server. Its licence allows personal or commercial use. No independent test has measured what it catches, its installers are not code-signed so Windows and macOS warn you, it is a separate editor rather than a checker inside your usual writing app, and it is still a version 0.10 release. Its lead over the next newcomer, grammai (3.63), is less than one scoring step. Lexicon project page, Lexicon website, releases

Four other tools finished just behind and suit narrower readers. ProWritingAid (3.38), at $120 a year, gives separate reports on repetition and readability, and its policy says your text is never used for training, but its free plan checks only 500 words at a time. Grammit (3.33), our previous Rising Star, is a free Chrome extension that can run its AI model on your computer, but it publishes no terms of service. QuillBot (3.10) and LanguageTool (3.13) are hosted checkers whose terms limit, or leave unclear, whether you may use them for work. The reasons, and everything else we assessed, are in “How we researched”.

None of these tools checks your facts, quotations or attributions (Lexicon and Grammit have AI features that can change more than a grammar slip, so read each suggestion), and none promises to preserve your meaning. Generated rewrites, paraphrasers, AI detectors and plagiarism checks are outside this comparison and carried no weight. Prices were checked on November 12, 2026 (Grammarly’s Pro prices on October 19; QuillBot’s on October 7 from an archive capture, because quillbot.com blocked our access); prices exclude tax.

Disclosure: Practical Picks is researched and written with Claude, an AI assistant made by Anthropic. grammai, which we recommend to some readers, advertises optional rewrites through your own Claude Code account; we gave that feature no weight, and we have no relationship with Anthropic or grammai’s developer.

Harper

Preferred Pick · a free, private check of a short article

$0Free · open source, no account

Choose Harper to catch typos, repeated words and common grammar slips without sending your article anywhere. Read the article once more afterwards: independent accounts say it misses subtler errors.

Reasons to choose it

  • Runs entirely on your device; no account or telemetry, per Harper
  • Accept or dismiss each suggestion and switch off any rule
  • Free for any use, including client work, under Apache-2.0

What to watch

  • Hands-on reports say it misses subtler errors cloud checkers flag
  • No Word add-in or Windows app; Google Docs has open bug reports
  • Developed at Automattic, which had layoffs and a 2026 board dispute

Harper is a grammar checker that runs on your own device. Its website says every check happens locally, with “no cloud round-trips, no telemetry, no LLM in the loop”, and its source code is public under the Apache-2.0 licence, so that claim can be inspected rather than taken on trust. There is no account, no price and no usage limit. It checks English only, with US, British, Canadian, Australian and Indian settings. Harper, GitHub repository

For an article, the controls are what you want from a proofreader. MakeUseOf describes each underline opening a short explanation with a one-click fix or “Dismiss”, a local dictionary you can fill by importing a plain word list, and a searchable list of rules, any of which you can switch off. Harper’s site says it will never intentionally suggest an edit that might change your meaning; that is the developer’s stated aim, not something any outside test has checked. MakeUseOf, January 16, 2026, Harper FAQ

Read the full Harper analysis and sources

Choose something else if you need the most thorough check. Harper works by rules rather than an AI model, and every independent account we found says it misses things. It’s FOSS, which uses LanguageTool and links to it as a partner, found that Harper missed a run-together typo and, in a deliberately broken sentence, flagged two correctly spelled brand names while LanguageTool pointed to the grammar problems. XDA’s editor found it missed “some glaring issues, such as miss-capitalized letters”. MakeUseOf found it “nailed the obvious mistakes” but may miss subtler ones. These are short hands-on accounts of 2025 and early 2026 versions; Harper has shipped frequent releases since, the latest on November 6, 2026. It’s FOSS, July 22, 2025, XDA Developers, August 12, 2025, releases

Check where you write before relying on it. Harper offers Chrome, Edge and Firefox extensions, a macOS app, and plugins for WordPress, Obsidian and several code editors. There is no Word add-in or Windows app. Google Docs works through the browser extension, but two bug reports about it remain open: one says Harper flags a capitalization error at the start of wrapped lines, the other that highlights flicker as you type. Its site also says it will not run in Gmail unless Gmail’s own checker is turned off. Harper’s November 6, 2026 release notes say the newest release fixed more Google Docs problems, such as sentences that span pages and tables; we did not recheck the two reports above after it. Integrations, GitHub issue 2992, GitHub issue 3122, v3.1.0 release notes

Harper was created by Elijah Potter and is now developed at Automattic, with outside contributors. Automattic has been in a lawsuit with the hosting company WP Engine since October 2024, cut 16% of its staff in April 2025 and, on September 9, 2026, its board placed chief executive Matt Mullenweg on leave against his wishes; three days later Automattic said he was back as chairman and chief executive. None of this concerns Harper directly. Because the code is open and runs locally, a copy you have installed would keep working without Automattic, but updates and fixes depend on its continued support. GitHub listed no published security advisories for Harper on October 19, 2026. TechCrunch, April 2, 2025, TechCrunch, September 9, 2026, CMSWire, September 12, 2026, security advisories

Used Harper? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Grammarly

Also consider · Word users and the widest checking

FreePro · $30/mo or $144/yr

Choose Grammarly Free if you write in Word or across many apps and want a mainstream checker. Switch off its training setting if you do not want your writing used to train its models.

Reasons to choose it

  • Free plan covers spelling, grammar and punctuation
  • Works in Google Docs, Word, Windows, Mac and mobile
  • 2026 study found its offered corrections highly accurate

What to watch

  • Uses your writing for training unless you switch it off
  • Pro is $30 billed monthly, with no refunds
  • Owner faces a class action over a discontinued AI feature

Grammarly Free costs $0 a month and covers spelling, grammar and punctuation and shows your tone; Pro adds full-sentence rewrites, tone changes and more suggestions. Pro costs $30 billed monthly, $60 quarterly or $144 a year in US dollars, according to the plan data on Grammarly’s US plans page when we read it on October 19; the $12 headline is the annual price per month. Paid plans renew automatically, cancellation keeps access to the end of the billing period, and the terms say payments are not refunded. Plans, terms, October 29, 2025

It fits the most writing setups of any tool here. The browser extension works in Google Docs, there is an add-in for Word and Outlook, and there are Windows, Mac and mobile apps. Suggestion cards can be accepted or dismissed, with an explanation one click away, and the personal dictionary is free. You can choose US, British, Canadian, Australian or Indian English, but the help page says suggestions that convert other spellings to American English are temporarily unavailable. Google Docs help, edited August 7, 2026, dictionary, edited September 18, 2026, dialects, edited February 16, 2026

Read the full Grammarly analysis and sources

The best independent evidence on accuracy here concerns Grammarly. A study in the Journal of Second Language Writing (2026) compared Grammarly with two human annotators on 53 argumentative essays by second-language writers. It found the corrections Grammarly offered were highly accurate, but that it missed almost half (recall 51%) of the sentence-level problems the annotators found. That is evidence about learner essays, not about polished articles, and it does not compare Grammarly with the other tools here. Koltovskaia, Saeli and Rahmati, 2026

Your text is processed on Superhuman’s servers. Grammarly says its Product Improvement and Training setting is on by default for individual accounts, which lets it use your content to train its models; you can switch it off in your account’s privacy settings. The privacy policy says Superhuman restricts its outside AI providers from training on your content. The terms set no personal-use limit for individuals; companies may use the service for internal business purposes. Training control, edited January 23, 2026, privacy policy, July 6, 2026, terms

If you use Grammarly’s own Docs editor, keep your original. Its guide says export to PDF or Word drops images, charts, citations, comments and some other elements, and new documents may need generative AI switched on. Docs guide, edited September 23, 2026

Grammarly’s owner faces a proposed class action over a discontinued feature. In March 2026 the journalist Julia Angwin sued Superhuman Platform, Inc. in federal court in Manhattan, alleging that Grammarly’s “Expert Review” presented AI editing advice under the names of real writers without their consent. Superhuman disabled the feature and says the claims are without merit. According to the court docket, Superhuman moved to compel individual arbitration and to dismiss the case in June 2026, and the court then paused the case until October 15, 2026 so the parties could try mediation. We could not establish what has happened since. These are allegations, not findings, and they concern a writing-advice feature, not ordinary proofreading. Grammarly’s terms include an arbitration agreement and class-action waiver that new users can opt out of within 30 days. Complaint, case 1:26-cv-02005, WIRED, March 11, 2026, docket summary

Used Grammarly? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Lexicon

Rising Star · a private desktop editor for a finished article

FreeFree · open source, no account

Try Lexicon if you will paste or import your finished article into a separate editor and want a checker that keeps your text on your own computer. Read each suggestion before you apply it, and read the article once more afterwards: no independent test has measured what it catches.

Reasons to choose it

  • Checks spelling and grammar on your computer, with no account
  • Apply, dismiss, accept all or dismiss all, with a personal dictionary
  • Free for personal or commercial use under the MIT licence

What to watch

  • No independent test of how many errors it catches
  • Installers are not code-signed, so Windows and macOS warn you
  • A separate editor: no Google Docs support, and the browser extension is a beta

Lexicon is a free, open-source writing app from Aashish Harishchandre, released under the MIT licence. Its installers cover Windows (x64, ARM64 and x86), macOS (Intel and Apple Silicon) and Linux. The first release on GitHub is dated July 19, 2026; the current stable version, 0.10.3, came out on August 8, and the code last changed on October 20, 2026. Lexicon project page, releases, Lexicon website

Choose it if you are happy to paste or import your finished article into a separate editor and want the check to stay on your computer. Its README says proofreading runs locally with the LanguageTool engine, which draws squiggles under spelling and grammar mistakes and shows suggestion cards that stay in step with the editor. You can apply a fix, dismiss it, accept all or dismiss all, dismissed suggestions stay dismissed when you re-check, and a personal dictionary keeps names and jargon from being flagged. It offers 45-plus languages and dialects, English variants included. You can import text, Markdown, HTML and Word files and export PDF, EPUB, HTML, Markdown or DOCX with the suggestions as tracked changes. README, Lexicon website

Read the full Lexicon analysis and sources

Your text stays on your device. The README says “Your writing is not sent to any servers” and names two network uses: update checks and an optional model download from Hugging Face; neither sends your writing. The proofreading itself does not need that model. The AI rewrite and tone tools it adds carried no weight here. The code is published, its site says you may use it “personally or commercially”, and GitHub listed no published security advisories for it on November 12, 2026. README, security advisories

Its limits are real. No independent test has measured how many errors it catches, and the benchmark page on its own website is the maker’s, so we did not count it. The Windows and macOS installers are not code-signed, so Windows SmartScreen and macOS Gatekeeper warn you and the README walks you through the steps; the macOS build is called pre-release. It is a separate editor: there is no Google Docs support, and the browser extension is a beta that you load in developer mode and that does not work with the stable app. Its desktop builds start with your computer by default and check for updates in the background. It is a one-developer project with a short public history. Lexicon website, README

Used Lexicon? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

grammai

Evaluated alternative · a free on-device checker in Chrome, in public beta

FreeFree · Chrome extension, GPL-3.0

Consider grammai if you write in web text fields in Chrome and want a free checker that runs on your device, and you accept a very new public beta. Review each suggestion and read the article once more afterwards.

Reasons to choose it

  • English spelling and grammar checks run on your device, with no account
  • Hover, click, then accept or dismiss, with undo and per-site controls
  • Free for any use under the GPL-3.0 licence

What to watch

  • Public beta since October 18, 2026, with 24 users and no ratings
  • Chrome and Chromium browsers only; no Word or documented Google Docs support
  • No independent test of how many errors it catches

grammai is a free Chrome extension, also for other Chromium browsers, from an independent developer (ZASolution, in Germany), released under the GPL-3.0 licence. Its first public beta, version 0.6.6, was released on October 18, 2026, and on November 12 its Chrome Web Store page showed 24 users and no ratings. grammai project page, releases, Chrome Web Store listing

Choose it if you write in web text fields in Chrome and want a free checker that runs on your device and you accept a very new beta. Its listing says English and German spelling and grammar checks run on your device, using engines and dictionaries included in the extension, with no account. Mistakes are underlined; you hover to highlight one, click to review it, then accept or dismiss, and undo restores the last edit. It offers American or British English spelling, a personal dictionary and per-site controls. Chrome Web Store listing, README

Read the full grammai analysis and sources

Its rewrites, translation and extra context checks are optional and work through your own signed-in Claude Code or Codex account; the helper they need currently installs only on macOS, and those features carried no weight here. If you use them, your text goes to your own provider under its terms. README

Its limits: it is weeks old, no independent test has measured what it catches, it is limited to Chrome and Chromium browsers, and we found no Word add-in or documented Google Docs support. We read its listing and README but not its privacy policy.

Used grammai? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Which product are we missing?

Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.

Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.

Suggest a product

Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.

No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.

What people are saying

User reports show what goes wrong in practice; they are not a measure of accuracy. Chrome Web Store figures on October 19, 2026 show how widely each extension is used: Grammarly 41 million users (4.1 stars, 43,200 ratings), QuillBot 6 million (4.2, 6,100), LanguageTool 2 million (3.1, 12,600), ProWritingAid 200,000 (4.4, 7,000) and Harper 60,000 (4.2, 130). On November 12, Grammit showed 2,000 users (4.3, 14 ratings) and grammai 24 users with no ratings; Lexicon is not in the store, and its project page showed 224 GitHub stars. Store ratings are self-selected and do not say why people rated as they did.

When Harper drew wide attention on Hacker News in June 2025, commenters welcomed a checker without an AI model, and others posted deliberately ungrammatical sentences it did not flag. That matches the published hands-on accounts above. Hacker News, June 20, 2025

In September 2026 we read individual August 2026 ProWritingAid reviews on Trustpilot, which included complaints about contextual suggestions and a monthly refund, and praise for support that fixed an integration problem. Most concerned fiction or long manuscripts. Trustpilot blocked our automated check on October 19. ProWritingAid reviews

A Grammarly user’s question, read in September 2026, distinguished downloadable score reports in the Classic editor from the newer Docs editor; it does not show that Docs lacks ordinary PDF export, which the current guide documents. Reddit discussion

How we researched

This is public-source research. We did not create accounts, install extensions, submit any text to a checker or test any tool. No vendor supplied access or payment for this work. We first compared Grammarly, ProWritingAid and LanguageTool on September 6, 2026, rechecked every price, plan limit, term and policy on October 19, 2026, and on November 12, 2026 read every product’s current price and plan limits again and repeated the search for new tools. Where a page blocked automated retrieval, we used an Internet Archive capture or the vendor’s public help-center data and say so beside the claim; quillbot.com blocked us again on November 12.

We wrote this for someone who has finished a short English article and wants spelling, grammar and punctuation errors caught, with optional style suggestions, while deciding on each change. Before scoring, we checked that every widely used option for that reader was either included or excluded for a stated reason. That check added QuillBot, whose extension has 6 million Chrome users and which LanguageTool itself recommends to free users. We left out Microsoft Editor’s browser extension, which Microsoft retired on October 31, 2025, and the checkers built into Word, Google Docs and browsers, which you already have before choosing a separate tool. General AI chat assistants and DeepL Write return a rewritten version rather than reviewing errors in your document, and Hemingway Editor is built around readability, with grammar checks in its paid AI plan. Microsoft Editor retirement

We priced the same job for every tool: a finished article of about 1,500 words each month for three years, checked as a whole rather than in pieces, on a free plan if the plan’s published limits cover that and otherwise on the cheapest plan billed for 12 months or less. On that job ten of the eighteen tools we priced are free, including Harper, Grammarly Free, Lexicon and grammai, and the rest cost from about $70 to $145 a year. A plan that publishes no figure for its free allowance, or limits a check to a few hundred words, was priced on its paid plan. Prices are in US dollars, exclude tax and are held at today’s figures.

We fixed six criteria and their weights before scoring: independent evidence on catching errors (25%), control over each suggestion (20%), cost for a short article (20%), what happens to your text (15%), whether you may use it for work (10%) and fit with where you write (10%). Accuracy counted even when an AI model produces the suggestions, but only independent evidence counted: vendor claims and tests published by a vendor’s sister company were not used. A tool with no independent evidence scores 2 on that criterion, the same for every tool. AI writing, paraphrasing and detection features carried no weight. Harper leads Grammarly by 0.05 on our five-point scale at every price weighting we tried, because both are free. If Harper’s error-catching evidence were one step weaker, Grammarly would lead. Giving more weight to app coverage, or none to text handling and work use, also puts Grammarly first, and Grammarly would win for readers who write in Word or Google Docs.

On November 12, 2026 we repeated the search for new tools, using Hacker News, GitHub’s grammar-checker pages, recent coverage and the vendors’ own pages, and re-tested last month’s candidates against the rule that a Rising Star’s first public release must be within the past 24 months. Lexicon (3.70), released in July 2026, scored highest of the eligible newcomers, ahead of grammai (3.63), Grammit (3.33), the open-source OpenGrammar (3.28), GemType (3.05) and Revise (3.05). Lexicon’s lead over grammai is less than one scoring step and rests on low-confidence scores. We set aside Proofly and PrivateProof Pro, which depend on a Chrome proofreading feature that Google still offers only behind a developer setting; Refine, which is for Mac only; tools that return a rewritten version rather than individual corrections, such as the proofreading mode of Kagi Translate; editGPT and grammarchecker.cc, whose operators we could not identify; Paperpal and Trinka, which come from established editing companies; Wordtune, launched in 2020; and extensions that run on Harper’s own engine, which would repeat our Pick.

Four tools we charted before finished outside the top four. Grammit (3.33) is a free Chrome extension from Blaze Today Inc., the maker of Text Blaze, released in August 2025 and last updated on October 2, 2026. It underlines mistakes as you write and, according to its store listing, lets you apply each correction on its own. Its Local mode checks text on your device with the AI model built into Chrome, which needs a capable computer; its privacy policy says the Cloud mode neither stores your writing nor trains on it, and does not say which mode is the default. No independent test has measured what it catches, it works only in Chrome with no Word or Google Docs support documented, its maker publishes no terms of service, and its developer’s own example shows its AI can change a wrong name in a factual statement. Grammit, privacy policy, Chrome Web Store listing, launch announcement, August 2025

ProWritingAid (3.38) suits a reader who wants separate reports on repetition and readability. Its free plan includes grammar, spelling and punctuation checks but gives suggestions on only 500 words at a time, so a 1,500-word article needs three passes; Premium costs $30 billed monthly, $120 a year or $399 for a lifetime licence, and the checkout links on the pricing page are in US dollars. Its privacy policy, last modified March 4, 2026, says checked text is deleted once checking finishes and is not used to improve the service, a help page says it never uses your writing to train its AI models, and its terms contain no personal-use restriction that we found. Yearly and lifetime plans are refundable only within three days, and monthly plans not at all. Its marketing now centers on fiction writers. Pricing and FAQ, privacy policy, AI help, updated July 12, 2026, terms, September 9, 2025

LanguageTool (3.13) does not train on your text, but its individual Free and Premium plans are restricted to “personal, non-commercial purposes”; its terms allow commercial use on Team plans at €56.90 per user a year, and we found no exception for individual plans. Its free website checks 2,000 characters at a time, roughly 300 to 350 words, and since February 2026 its browser extension works only for Premium subscribers after a 14-day trial. Its plans page now shows US-dollar prices: Premium is $69.90 a year, $49.90 a quarter or $24.90 a month, with a 14-day money-back guarantee; its help center lists €59.89 a year. Its owner, Learneo, also owns QuillBot. Plans, service terms, effective August 21, 2026, extension announcement, prices help, edited March 24, 2026

QuillBot (3.10) offers a free grammar checker without signing up and says you can run unlimited checks, but it uses your text to train its models and stores it by default; opt-outs exist in recent extension versions and for account holders. Its parent company Learneo’s general terms limit use to “personal, non-commercial purposes” unless a service’s own terms permit more, and QuillBot’s own terms did not load for us, so whether you may use it for client articles is unresolved. Premium costs $99.95 a year; the plans page we read showed several monthly prices, from $19.95 to $24.95. We read quillbot.com through Internet Archive captures of October 2 and 7 because it blocked automated access. In March 2026 a federal jury awarded Post University $75 million against Learneo over copyright information on Course Hero, another Learneo service; it does not concern QuillBot’s checker, and Learneo denies the allegations and has said it will appeal. Grammar checker, capture October 2, 2026, Premium, capture October 7, 2026, data use, edited June 10, 2026, Learneo terms, updated August 21, 2026, Plagiarism Today, March 9, 2026

Other tools we scored, all outside the top four: OpenGrammar (3.28), an open-source Chrome extension you load in developer mode, free for spelling and style but needing your own AI key or a local model for grammar; Trinka (3.08), whose free plan allows 5,000 words a month; GemType (3.05), which sends your text to Google’s free AI service under your own key; Revise (3.05), an AI document editor that shows corrections as tracked changes, at $8 a month for the plan that covers this job; Wordtune (3.00), whose free plan has unlimited spelling and grammar checks; Linguix (2.79), at $140 a year, whose free plan lists only “Basic” grammar and spelling; Sapling (2.88), at $144 a year; Paperpal (2.83), at $144 a year; Ginger (2.79), at about $90 a year; and editGPT (2.72), at $96 a year. For Trinka, Linguix, Sapling, Paperpal, Ginger and editGPT we read only the pricing pages, so their scores for text handling and work use are provisional, and none could reach the top four even with a free plan.

Our adverse-evidence search on October 19 covered news, court, insolvency, regulator and security records for each product, its operator and its owner; on October 20 the same for Grammit, Revise and their makers, and on November 12 for Lexicon and grammai we checked their published security advisories and release history. Court records came from the complaint and a docket-summary site; CourtListener limits automated requests from our system, so we did not use it.

ToolPublic sourcesWhat remains uncertain
HarperWebsite, source repository, releases, Google Docs bug reports, extension store listings, three hands-on articles, Automattic news.How many ordinary errors it misses; how well Google Docs support works after the September and November fixes.
GrammarlyUS plans page data, terms, privacy policy, training, dictionary, dialect and Docs help, a 2026 peer-reviewed accuracy study, complaint and docket summary.Accuracy on polished native-speaker writing; the lawsuit’s status after October 15, 2026.
LexiconProject page and README, website, release history, security advisories.How many errors it catches; how its bundled checker behaves in the app; the future of a one-developer project.
grammaiProject page and README, Chrome Web Store listing, release page.How many errors it catches; its privacy policy; how it matures after the first beta.
Grammit, ProWritingAid, QuillBot, LanguageToolPricing and plans pages, privacy policies, terms, help-center articles, Archive captures for QuillBot, Learneo terms.Accuracy; QuillBot’s own terms and current price; whether Grammit’s maker will keep it free.

None of this establishes how accurately any tool proofreads your article, how its integrations behave on your device, or that a policy is carried out as written. Next substantive review is due December 18, 2026, or sooner if a price, a training default or the Grammarly case changes. Found a changed price or term? Contact the editors.

Sources and evidence

Sources were checked October 19, 2026 unless another date is given; the Lexicon and grammai pages and the pricing pages named below were read on November 12, 2026. Vendor pages establish what a company offers and promises, not how its tool performs. Help-center dates are each article’s last edit date.

This is a researched comparison, not a product review. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.