Donation forms for a small US nonprofit: Zeffy, Donorbox and Better Giving

Zeffy costs a small nonprofit nothing per gift but asks donors to fund it. Donorbox asks donors for nothing extra but costs about 5.5% of a card gift in fees. Better Giving asks donors for nothing extra but pays you by grant.

PRACTICAL PICKSPreferredPickOur Preferred PickNew online giving for a small US nonprofit$0

Zeffy

No platform fee and no processing fee for the nonprofit, even when a donor adds nothing for Zeffy, with recurring gifts, receipts and exports included.

Checkout suggests a contribution to Zeffy that you cannot edit or switch off; donors must set it to $0 themselves. Active recurring gifts cannot move in.

Why Zeffy is our Pick
Newcomer assessment

No Rising Star selected

Better Giving, the newer service we assessed most closely, has had public nonprofit pages since August 2024, more than two years ago. The other newer candidates did not identify who runs them or publish working terms, or come from an established nonprofit-software maker.

We found no donation form launched in the last two years that we can recommend for this job.

Who is this article for? People who run a small US nonprofit and are choosing online donation forms for new one-time and recurring gifts. Not tax, legal or charity-registration advice.

About 33 min read

What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean

The quick list

What one $100 card gift costs your nonprofit, and what each service asks your donors to add.

Nonprofit cost of one $100 US card gift, checked November 12, 2026. Our arithmetic from published rates; Donorbox and GiveForms assume Stripe’s nonprofit rate, which you must claim, and Better Giving uses the about 2.4% card fee its help center cites. Excludes donor contributions, tips, fee coverage, refunds, disputes and add-ons.

The comparison at a glance

Compare what one gift costs your nonprofit, what donors are asked to add, and what happens to refunds, payouts, recurring gifts and records.

Order follows our scores for a small US nonprofit taking new online gifts, not measured donor behaviour or payout speed. All tools remain selectable.

Online donation forms for a small US nonprofit
FeatureZeffyDonorboxBetter GivingGiveForms
Best fitPreferred Pick: new online giving at no cost to the nonprofitAlso consider: donors are not asked to fund the platformEvaluated alternative: no preselected platform ask, if you accept gifts arriving as grants from Better GivingFee coverage only, your own Stripe account and the longest notice of fee changes; sign-up starts with a demo
Nonprofit cost of a $100 card gift$0: no platform fee; Zeffy pays processing$5.45 (2.95% + Stripe nonprofit rate 2.2% + 30¢), unless the donor covers itAbout $2.40 in card fees (Better Giving cites about 2.4%), unless the donor covers them; $3.90 with the donor ask switched off$5.40 (2.9% + Stripe nonprofit rate 2.2% + 30¢), unless the donor covers it
What donors are asked to addA voluntary contribution to Zeffy, suggested amount already selected; donors can set $0An optional amount to cover fees; no platform tipAn optional contribution to Better Giving that it says is never preselected, plus optional fee coverageAn optional amount to cover fees; no platform tip
Can the nonprofit change that request?No: Zeffy sets the wording and suggested amountsYes: fee coverage on or off per campaignYes: switch the contribution ask off and pay a flat 1.5%Settings not documented publicly
A $100 donor who accepts the extra pays$100 plus the suggestion, which Zeffy says runs about 5% to 20% of the gift; users reported 15–17% defaultsAbout $105.75 if covering fees, by Donorbox’s formula$100 plus whatever the donor chooses; no amount preselected, by Better Giving’s accountNot published
Bringing active recurring gifts inNot possible: history imports, donors must restart$195 service for cooperating processors, 4–6 weeks; PayPal not supportedBetter Giving recreates Stripe-based gifts at no fee of its own; PayPal and quarterly gifts cannot move unchangedIncluded at no cost, by GiveForms’ account: it says it moves active recurring plans through Stripe tokenization from other platforms; no help center to check the details
Main reason to hesitateYou cannot edit or switch off the donor requestAbout 5.5% of each uncovered card giftDonors give to Better Giving, which controls the money, issues the receipts and pays you by grantAbout 5.4% of each uncovered card gift, and little public documentation

A small US nonprofit taking new online one-time and recurring gifts; not events, auctions, memberships or financial-account products. USD fees and prices rechecked November 12, 2026; other terms checked October 19, 2026 (Better Giving and GiveForms October 20); next review December 18, 2026, or sooner after a material change. Nonprofit costs assume one uncovered US card or bank gift, Stripe’s nonprofit rate for Donorbox and GiveForms, and no refunds, disputes or add-ons. Better Giving is scored on its own documentation; we found no independent review of its donation form. This is public-source research: no account, form, payment or donor data was used, and documentation does not establish donor behaviour, payment success, export completeness or tax treatment.

All features and sources 21 criteria

Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.

Cost and what donors see

Show 10 criteria
Cost and what donors see
FeatureZeffyDonorboxBetter GivingGiveForms
Best fitPreferred Pick: new online giving at no cost to the nonprofitAlso consider: donors are not asked to fund the platformEvaluated alternative: no preselected platform ask, if you accept gifts arriving as grants from Better GivingFee coverage only, your own Stripe account and the longest notice of fee changes; sign-up starts with a demo
Nonprofit cost of a $100 card gift$0: no platform fee; Zeffy pays processing$5.45 (2.95% + Stripe nonprofit rate 2.2% + 30¢), unless the donor covers itAbout $2.40 in card fees (Better Giving cites about 2.4%), unless the donor covers them; $3.90 with the donor ask switched off$5.40 (2.9% + Stripe nonprofit rate 2.2% + 30¢), unless the donor covers it
Nonprofit cost of a $100 bank (ACH) gift$0$3.75 (2.95%, capped at $25, + 0.8%, capped at $5)Bank processing fee deducted unless the donor covers it; rate not published$2.90 plus the bank processing fee, which its pricing page does not list
What donors are asked to addA voluntary contribution to Zeffy, suggested amount already selected; donors can set $0An optional amount to cover fees; no platform tipAn optional contribution to Better Giving that it says is never preselected, plus optional fee coverageAn optional amount to cover fees; no platform tip
Can the nonprofit change that request?No: Zeffy sets the wording and suggested amountsYes: fee coverage on or off per campaignYes: switch the contribution ask off and pay a flat 1.5%Settings not documented publicly
A $100 donor who accepts the extra pays$100 plus the suggestion, which Zeffy says runs about 5% to 20% of the gift; users reported 15–17% defaultsAbout $105.75 if covering fees, by Donorbox’s formula$100 plus whatever the donor chooses; no amount preselected, by Better Giving’s accountNot published
If you refund a giftDonor’s contribution to Zeffy is not refunded unless the donor asks ZeffyDonorbox platform fee and Stripe fee stay with youBetter Giving decides refunds; amounts already granted, plus processing and dispute fees, come out of later grantsIts pricing page says GiveForms returns its platform fee on a refund; its terms call fees non-refundable except as stated
Payment conditionsCards up to $4,999; Apple and Google Pay up to $1,000; ACH up to $20,000Stripe nonprofit rate must be claimed; American Express 3.5%; Apple Pay donors cannot cover feesUS 501(c)(3)s only; $50 minimum withdrawal; banks may charge about $1.13 per grantFees set in an order form; Stripe nonprofit rate must be claimed
What backs the fee promiseHelp-center commitment; US terms give 15 days’ notice of material changesFees as shown on the pricing page; Donorbox fees non-refundableNonprofit terms: no fee with the donor ask on, 1.5% with it off; terms can change on 7 days’ noticeTerms give 60 days’ notice of fee changes
Main reason to hesitateYou cannot edit or switch off the donor requestAbout 5.5% of each uncovered card giftDonors give to Better Giving, which controls the money, issues the receipts and pays you by grantAbout 5.4% of each uncovered card gift, and little public documentation
Sources for cost and what donors see

Fees and prices rechecked November 12, 2026; other details checked October 19, 2026 (Better Giving and GiveForms October 20). Totals are our arithmetic from published rates, not quotes; Better Giving does not publish its card rate, so its figure uses the about 2.4% its help center cites. Zeffy funding model, payment methods, contribution refunds, feedback board and NPO terms; Better Giving pricing, cost, voluntary donations, card fees and nonprofit terms; Donorbox fees, fee coverage, refunds and terms; GiveForms pricing and terms. Default contribution figures are user reports, not our observation; Better Giving’s “never preselected” is its own statement.

Eligibility, payouts and recurring gifts

Show 5 criteria
Eligibility, payouts and recurring gifts
FeatureZeffyDonorboxBetter GivingGiveForms
Who can sign upUS nonprofits with an EIN and an organizational bank account; 501(c)(3) not requiredOrganizations with a Stripe or PayPal account; processor checks applyUS 501(c)(3)s that pass a legitimacy and values review, usually in a couple of business daysOrganizations whose account GiveForms approves after a demo; no published criteria
PayoutsEvery Monday by default after a 1–3 business-day review; monthly or next-day if eligibleGifts go to your own Stripe or PayPal; Stripe pays out every 2 business days in the USPaid as grants: savings balance withdrawn on request (about 3 working days, says its help; processed monthly, say its terms) or monthly batchesGifts settle in your own Stripe or PayPal account; GiveForms says it never holds them
New recurring giftsWeekly to yearly; stops after 4–5 failed retries and must be restartedWeekly to yearly plans; donors manage their own plansWeekly, monthly or yearly by card or bank; failed-payment handling not publishedDonor portal to manage plans and update payment methods; frequencies and retries not published
Bringing active recurring gifts inNot possible: history imports, donors must restart$195 service for cooperating processors, 4–6 weeks; PayPal not supportedBetter Giving recreates Stripe-based gifts at no fee of its own; PayPal and quarterly gifts cannot move unchangedIncluded at no cost, by GiveForms’ account: it says it moves active recurring plans through Stripe tokenization from other platforms; no help center to check the details
Taking active recurring gifts with youNot documentedNot documented; gifts run through your own Stripe accountPromised: data in 5 business days and help moving recurring donors (product page, not the terms)Not documented; data exportable for 30 days after termination
Sources for eligibility, payouts and recurring gifts

Records, support and terms

Show 6 criteria
Records, support and terms
FeatureZeffyDonorboxBetter GivingGiveForms
Record exportsPayments, transactions, payouts, receipts and contacts as separate exportsDonations, supporters and recurring plans as CSV; filters and columns decide contentDonations CSV with donor names, amounts, dates and payment methods; API and ZapierExport tools, API, Salesforce and Zapier; contents not documented publicly
ReceiptsPer-payment confirmation; one January tax receipt for monthly donors when enabledCustomizable; sent from a Donorbox address with your reply-toIssued by Better Giving in its own name; you must not issue your ownBranded automatic receipts; donors can download them in a portal
SupportChat and email; hours not publishedEmail on Standard; 24/7 priority support is a Premium optionHelp-center chat and email; hours not publishedHuman support advertised; hours not published
Donor data termsGenerally the data controller; shares with ad networks and AI providers; says it does not sellActs as processor for nonprofits’ donor data; says it does not sell; session recording on its siteDonor contact details shared with you only for thanking and reporting, unless donors agree to moreSays donor data belongs to the nonprofit and is not sold or used for ads
Leaving30 days to retrieve data; Zeffy may refund pending payments instead of paying out30 days to export after terminationEither side may end the agreement at any time; gifts made before then are still granted30 days’ notice either way; 30 days to export after termination
Legal record found (October 19–20, 2026)Defendant in a 2025 Givebutter trademark suit; no ruling foundNone foundNone foundNone found
Sources for records, support and terms

Zeffy reports, support route, privacy and NPO terms; Better Giving Form 990 guide, help center, product page and nonprofit terms; Donorbox exports, receipts, contact, pricing, terms and privacy; GiveForms features, terms and privacy. Court status from the CourtListener index on October 19 for Zeffy and Donorbox; Better Giving and GiveForms were checked by news and web search only. Lawsuits are allegations, not findings.

What matters when choosing

Zeffy is our Practical Pick for a small US nonprofit setting up online donation forms for new one-time and recurring gifts. It charges the nonprofit nothing: no platform fee, and Zeffy pays the card and bank processing costs even when a donor adds nothing for Zeffy. On a $100 card gift, Donorbox Standard costs the nonprofit $5.45 in platform and processing fees at Stripe’s discounted nonprofit rate unless the donor covers them, and Givebutter is free only while its own tip request is switched on. The most important compromise is at checkout: Zeffy suggests a voluntary contribution to itself with an amount already selected, and your organization cannot change the wording or amount or switch the request off. A donor who wants to add nothing has to change it, for example by choosing “Other” and entering $0. Its lead is narrow: it scored 3.58 out of 5 against 3.37 for Donorbox, 3.33 for Better Giving and 3.30 for GiveForms, gaps of less than a third of a point. If you count price gaps less heavily than we did, Donorbox moves ahead (3.62 against 3.58) because it asks donors for nothing extra. Zeffy’s funding model, Donorbox fees, Givebutter Standard

We are not naming a Rising Star. Better Giving is the newer service we assessed most closely. It is a charity, recognized as tax-exempt in 2022, whose donation form asks donors for nothing extra unless they choose to add a contribution, which it says is never preselected; if you would rather not show that ask, it charges a flat 1.5%. It also moves Stripe-based recurring donors in at no fee of its own and promises on its website, though not in its terms, to help move them out if you leave. It scored 3.33, third overall, but its nonprofit help pages and terms were public by August and October 2024, more than two years ago, so it is not a newcomer by our two-year test, and the other newer services we found did not name who runs them or come from established fundraising-software makers. The trade-off with Better Giving is control: donors legally give to Better Giving, which pays you by grant, issues the tax receipts in its own name and limits how you may use donor details. Better Giving pricing, nonprofit terms

Disclosure: Practical Picks is researched and written with Claude, an AI assistant made by Anthropic. Zeffy advertises a connector to Claude; we gave that feature no weight, and we have no relationship with Anthropic or Zeffy.

Choose Donorbox instead if you do not want your donors asked to fund the platform. It asks them only whether they want to cover the fees, and gifts go straight to your own Stripe or PayPal account. You pay for that: about 5.5% of each card gift that donors do not cover. GiveForms (3.30) costs about the same per gift and offers stronger contract terms, including 60 days’ notice before its fees change, but it publishes little documentation and sign-up starts with a demo. Givebutter, just behind GiveForms at 3.30, is free only while its own tip request is on, rests on a fee credit with caps it does not publish, and faces two proposed class actions over how its tips and fees are presented; they were pending when we checked and are allegations, not findings. It is outside the chart, and the reasons are under How we researched.

Existing recurring donations change the decision. Zeffy cannot move active recurring gifts in: donors must start new ones. Donorbox charges $195 to move cooperating processors’ recurring donors onto Standard, Better Giving recreates Stripe-based gifts at no fee of its own, GiveForms says migration is included through Stripe tokenization but has no help center to check it against, and Givebutter documents a do-it-yourself transfer through Stripe; Donorbox, Better Giving and Givebutter cannot move PayPal recurring donors. Only Better Giving promises help taking recurring donors with you when you leave, and that promise is on its product page rather than in its terms, so ask before you commit. Zeffy recurring import, Donorbox migrations, Better Giving recurring moves, Givebutter migration

Our cost scores assume a US 501(c)(3) taking about 200 card gifts of $100 a year for three years, with donors covering no fees, at prices checked November 12, 2026; they are our arithmetic, not quotes. Whichever you choose, a volunteer should be able to tell apart the gift, any extra paid to the platform, fees, refunds and the bank deposit. We cannot tell you whether your organization or a particular gift qualifies for any tax treatment, or which charity registrations you need; ask a qualified adviser.

Zeffy

Preferred Pick · new online giving at no cost to you

$0No platform or processing fee · donors asked to contribute

Choose Zeffy to start online giving when you want every donated dollar to reach your nonprofit and can explain to donors that the contribution to Zeffy is optional.

Reasons to choose it

  • No platform or processing fee, even when donors add nothing
  • Weekly to yearly recurring gifts and January receipts for monthly donors
  • Separate exports for payments, transactions, payouts and receipts

What to watch

  • You cannot edit or switch off the suggested contribution
  • Active recurring gifts from another service must restart
  • Card gifts capped at $4,999; bank gifts up to $20,000

Zeffy says your nonprofit receives 100% of every payment and that it pays all card and bank processing fees itself, whether or not the donor contributes. Its only stated revenue is the voluntary contribution donors can add at checkout, which it says around 60% of donors choose to leave. In the US, a nonprofit needs an EIN and a bank account in the organization’s name; 501(c)(3) status is not required, and Zeffy’s US terms also accept other 501(c) organizations, state nonprofit corporations and fiscally sponsored projects. Funding model, eligibility, NPO terms, US Addendum

The price of that arrangement appears in front of your donors. Zeffy shows the contribution twice on its forms, preselects a suggested amount that falls as a percentage for larger gifts, and does not let organizations customize the wording or suggested amounts. Users on Zeffy’s own feedback board reported defaults of 17% and, at times, more, and in March 2026 a user said its Tap to Pay app still suggested 15%. Zeffy’s help center now says the suggestion generally runs from about 5% to 20% of the gift, falling as gifts grow, and that the nonprofit cannot remove it or set it to $0; we could not see the figure on a live form without making a payment. Zeffy’s March 11, 2026 response separated the contribution from the gift, labelled it “(optional)” and added a self-refund link to the confirmation email, but did not set the default to $0. Zeffy suggests wording you can add to your own form; we think you should use it. Funding model, feedback and vendor response, suggested donor wording, donor refunds

Read the full Zeffy analysis and sources

“Free” has conditions. Cards are accepted for payments up to $4,999, Apple Pay and Google Pay up to $1,000, and bank (ACH) payments up to $20,000. Zeffy says that in very rare cases, when an organization raises large card amounts with few donor contributions, it may set a temporary card limit and steer larger gifts to bank payment. Its no-fee promise appears in its help center; we did not find a clause fixing it in the US terms, which give 15 days’ notice of material changes and may require you to accept a material fee increase. Payment methods, if donors don’t contribute, NPO terms

Refunds and disputes have their own rules. You can refund card payments within 180 days; bank payments can be refunded only after 60 days. Refunding a gift does not refund the donor’s contribution to Zeffy, which the donor must request from Zeffy. Zeffy’s terms make you liable for any negative balance, and if an account closes with pending funds, Zeffy may refund those payments to donors instead of paying them out. Refunds, contribution refunds, NPO terms, sections 4.5 and 4.6

Recurring gifts can be weekly, every two weeks, monthly, quarterly or yearly, and donors manage them in a donor portal. After a failed payment, Stripe retries four to five times; if every retry fails, the gift stops and the donor must start a new one. When you issue tax receipts through Zeffy, monthly donors get one consolidated receipt each January. Historical records can be imported, but active recurring schedules from another service cannot continue. Recurring donations, recurring import

Payouts go out every Monday by default, after a fraud review that usually takes one to three business days; you can choose monthly, or next-day payouts if Zeffy offers them to your account. You cannot trigger a payout yourself. Exports separate payments (including manual entries), processed transactions, payouts, receipts and contacts, and large exports go to the email of whoever is logged in. Payouts, reports and exports

US organizations contract with Simplyk, Inc., a Delaware company; its terms state that it is registered in California as a charitable fundraising platform. Its privacy policy, last updated February 18, 2025, says that under European data-protection law Zeffy is generally the controller of the personal data it collects, lists advertising networks and AI service providers among the parties it shares data with, and says it does not sell personal data. Support is by chat and email; we found no published hours. Givebutter sued Zeffy’s operators in Delaware federal court in January 2025 under the Lanham Act; a court index showed no end date on October 19, and we have not found any ruling. If you leave, the terms give you 30 days to retrieve your data. NPO terms, privacy policy, support route

Choose something else if you need to control what donors are asked to add, already rely on active recurring gifts that would have to restart, or regularly take card gifts above $4,999.

Used Zeffy? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Donorbox

Also consider · no platform request to donors

$5.45Standard · 2.95% + Stripe 2.2% + 30¢ per $100 card gift

Choose Donorbox when you would rather pay a published fee than ask donors to fund your platform, and want gifts to land in your own Stripe or PayPal account.

Reasons to choose it

  • Donors see only an optional fee-coverage choice
  • Gifts go straight to your own Stripe or PayPal account
  • Acts as processor for your donor data; says it does not sell it

What to watch

  • About 5.5% of every card gift donors do not cover
  • Platform fee kept when you refund a gift
  • $195 to move recurring donors in; PayPal plans cannot move

Donorbox Standard has no monthly charge, but each donation-form gift carries a 2.95% Donorbox fee plus processing by your own connected Stripe or PayPal account. At Stripe’s US nonprofit card rate of 2.2% + 30¢, which your organization must claim from Stripe and which excludes American Express (3.5%), a $100 card gift costs you $5.45 and a $50 gift about $2.88. Without the discount, Stripe charges 2.9% + 30¢. For US bank (ACH) gifts, the Donorbox fee is capped at $25 and Stripe charges 0.8% capped at $5, so a $100 bank gift costs $3.75. These totals are our arithmetic from Donorbox’s published rates. Fees, pricing

What your donors see is a choice to cover those fees, not a request to tip Donorbox. Donorbox calculates the covered amount using the lowest nonprofit rates; by its published formula, a donor who covers fees on a $100 card gift pays about $105.75. Donors paying with Apple Pay and other one-click options cannot cover fees. Donorbox says most donors choose to cover; that is a vendor claim we could not check. Fee coverage, what coverage includes, Apple Pay limit

Read the full Donorbox analysis and sources

Donorbox says gifts flow directly to your Stripe or PayPal account and are never held by Donorbox. In the US, Stripe pays out automatically every two business days after a first payout of around seven days; PayPal transfers start when you request them. This is a useful operational difference, not protection against a processor’s own holds or reserves. Receiving funds

Refunds cost you money. The donor gets the whole gift back, Stripe’s fee is not returned, and the Donorbox platform fee on the refunded amount remains your responsibility. Donorbox’s terms let it pass processor chargeback fees through to you and make its own fees non-refundable. Refunds, terms, sections 6.3 and 6.4

Moving active recurring donors in costs $195 on Standard or Pro and is estimated to take four to six weeks. It depends on your current processor releasing payment details through Stripe; PayPal recurring gifts cannot be moved, and those donors must restart. That inbound service is not a promise about leaving. Migrations, Stripe migration steps

Donations, supporters and recurring plans export separately as CSV files, and filters and chosen columns decide what each file contains. Receipts are customizable but are sent from a Donorbox address, with your organization’s name and reply-to address. Exports, receipts

The operator is Rebel Idealist Inc. Its terms, last updated April 24, 2026, give you 30 days after termination to export your data and cap Donorbox’s liability at what you paid it in the previous 12 months. Its privacy policy, updated August 14, 2026, says Donorbox acts as a data processor for the donor information it handles for nonprofits, does not sell personal information, and uses session recording on its website. Standard-plan support is by email; Donorbox does not publish its hours, and 24/7 priority support is a Premium option. Terms, privacy, contact

Choose something else if the platform fee matters more to you than how the checkout is funded, or if most of your donors pay with Apple Pay and you rely on them covering fees.

Used Donorbox? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Better Giving

Evaluated alternative · no preselected platform ask

~$2.40Card fees about 2.4% unless covered · no platform fee while the optional ask is on

Consider Better Giving if you want donors asked for nothing extra by default and help moving recurring donors in and out, and you are comfortable receiving gifts as grants from another charity. We found no independent review of its donation form, so keep your own records.

Reasons to choose it

  • Optional contribution to Better Giving that it says is never preselected; or switch it off for 1.5%
  • Moves Stripe-based recurring donors in at no fee of its own
  • Promises data within five business days and help moving recurring donors if you leave

What to watch

  • Donors give to Better Giving, which controls the money and pays you by grant
  • Tax receipts come from Better Giving, not your organization
  • Donor details may be used only for thanking and reporting unless donors agree to more

Better Giving, Inc. is a US public charity that received its IRS tax exemption in September 2022. It runs a free fundraising platform with a donation form you can embed on your own site, recurring giving, peer-to-peer pages and automatic receipts, its nonprofit help articles date from August 2024 and its nonprofit terms from October 2024, and it announced its fundraiser pages in February 2025. Membership is open to US 501(c)(3) organizations after a review, which it says usually takes a couple of business days, of your registration and good standing and of your alignment with values it describes as progressive, including at least one UN Sustainable Development Goal. Nonprofit terms, effective October 23, 2026, eligibility, embedded form, IRS filings, launch announcement

What your donors see is an optional contribution to Better Giving, which its pricing page says is “opt-in and never pre-selected”; donors can choose zero, one of its preset percentages or their own amount. While that ask stays on the form, there is no platform fee. If you switch it off, Better Giving charges a flat 1.5% on each gift. Card and bank processing fees are deducted from each gift unless the donor covers them. Better Giving does not publish its processing rate; a 2024 help article puts card fees at about 2.4%, which would make an uncovered $100 card gift cost you about $2.40, or $3.90 with the ask switched off. Your bank may also charge about $1.13 to receive each grant. We have not seen the checkout, so “never preselected” is Better Giving’s statement. Pricing, voluntary donations, costs, card fees

Read the full Better Giving analysis and sources

The main compromise is how the money reaches you. Donors give to Better Giving, not to your organization; Better Giving keeps legal control of the gifts, and its terms let it choose another charity if yours loses its status, stops operating or breaches the terms. Unless you choose otherwise, gifts go into a money-market savings balance from which you request withdrawals of at least $50. Its help center says withdrawals usually arrive within about three working days, but its terms say requests are processed monthly. Gifts you mark for immediate grants are batched and paid at the start of the following month. Better Giving issues the tax receipts in its own name, you may not issue your own, and you report Better Giving as a single grantor on your Form 990. You see donor names and contact details, but the terms let you use them only to thank donors and report on your work unless donors agree to more. Nonprofit terms, sections 3 and 4, grants and savings, withdrawals, Form 990 guide

Recurring gifts can be weekly, monthly or yearly, by card or bank; Better Giving does not say what happens after a failed payment. If your current platform runs on Stripe and agrees to copy donors’ saved cards, Better Giving recreates each gift on the same amount and date at no fee of its own, after you have emailed your donors. PayPal donors and quarterly gifts cannot move unchanged, and past giving history does not come across. Its “Recurring-Donor Portability Guarantee” promises your data within five business days and active help moving recurring donors if you leave, although card-network rules may require donors to re-authorize. That promise appears on its product page, not in its terms. Moving recurring donors, product page

Its nonprofit terms, effective October 23, 2026, can change on seven days’ notice, and either side may end the agreement at any time; gifts made before then are still granted. If a gift already granted to you is refunded or disputed, Better Giving can deduct it, with processing and dispute fees, from later grants. Its liability is capped at the greater of what you paid it or $100, and disputes go to mediation or arbitration under Delaware law. The platform’s code is published on GitHub, was updated daily in October 2026 and has no published security advisories; the repository and help center still carry the names of Angel Protocol and Angel Giving, its earlier crypto-giving projects. Its 2024 Form 990 shows about $1.96 million in revenue and $454,000 in assets. Optional savings and investment allocations include a fund with 15% in Bitcoin and Ethereum, which you do not have to use. We found no lawsuits, regulatory actions or breaches on October 20, and no independent reviews of the donation form. Nonprofit terms, public code, IRS filings

Choose Better Giving if you want donors asked for nothing extra by default, want help moving recurring donors in and out, and are comfortable receiving gifts as grants from another charity. Choose something else if you need tax receipts in your own name, payouts within days, freedom to market to your donors, or if your organization is not a 501(c)(3) or may not fit its values review.

Used Better Giving? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

GiveForms

Evaluated alternative · fee coverage with stronger contract terms

$5.40Standard · 2.9% + Stripe 2.2% + 30¢ per $100 card gift

Consider GiveForms if you want Donorbox-style fee coverage, gifts in your own Stripe account and terms that give 60 days’ notice before fees change, and you do not mind starting with a demo.

Reasons to choose it

  • Donors are asked only whether to cover fees
  • Gifts settle in your own Stripe or PayPal account
  • 60 days’ notice of fee changes and 30 days to export after leaving

What to watch

  • About 5.4% of every card gift donors do not cover
  • Sign-up starts with a demo; fees are set in an order form
  • No public help center for recurring, export or receipt details

GiveForms, Inc., which says it was founded in 2018, charges 2.9% of each successful gift on its Standard plan (3.9% without its badge) on top of your own Stripe or PayPal processing, with no monthly fee or contract. At Stripe’s nonprofit card rate, an uncovered $100 card gift costs you $5.40 by our arithmetic, about the same as Donorbox. Donors are offered the option to cover fees, which GiveForms says about half choose; there is no request for a tip to GiveForms. Sign-up starts with a demo, and your fees are set in an order form. Pricing, terms, updated October 5, 2026, company profile

Gifts settle in your own Stripe or PayPal account, and GiveForms says it never holds or controls donation funds. Its terms give 60 days’ notice of fee changes and 30 days’ notice of material changes to the terms, let either side end the agreement on 30 days’ notice, keep your data available for export for 30 days after termination and cap its liability at the greater of 12 months’ fees or $1,000. Its privacy policy says donor data belongs to your organization and that GiveForms does not sell it or use it for advertising. Its terms call fees non-refundable except as stated, while its pricing page says it returns its platform fee when you refund a gift; ask which applies. Terms, privacy, updated October 5, 2026

Read the full GiveForms analysis and sources

GiveForms advertises a donor portal where donors manage recurring plans, update payment methods and download receipts, branded automatic emails and receipts, and integrations with Salesforce, Zapier and its own API, and its pricing page says active recurring plans move over through Stripe tokenization at no cost, including from Givebutter and Donorbox. We found no public help center, so we could not check recurring frequencies, what happens after a failed payment, how that migration works in practice, what its exports contain or what its receipts say. We found no lawsuits, regulatory actions or breaches on October 20. Features, pricing

Choose GiveForms if you want Donorbox-style fee coverage, gifts in your own Stripe account and contract terms that warn you before fees change, and you are willing to start with a demo. Choose something else if you want to read the documentation before you sign up or want the lowest cost per gift.

Used GiveForms? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Which product are we missing?

Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.

Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.

Suggest a product

Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.

No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.

What people are saying

User reports show where the friction is, not how often it happens. On Zeffy’s own feedback board, a 2024 request to make the contribution default to $0 drew more than 200 votes; nonprofit staff described donor complaints, contributions they refunded out of their own pockets, a cancelled campaign and screen-reader users who struggled with the dropdown. Zeffy closed the request in March 2026 with clearer labelling and self-refunds, not a $0 default. The board is vendor-hosted, so these are reports, not a measure of donor reaction. Feedback board

Truth in Advertising’s June 2026 alert describes a preselected 15% tip on a Givebutter campaign and links a consumer complaint; it is an advocacy group’s observation, and the class actions above remain unproven allegations. A March 2025 Reddit post by a Givebutter user described differences between fields in its API and manual exports; it is an old, unverified report, but a reason to check the exact export you need. Ad alert, user report, read September 6, 2026

In January 2026, iNaturalist explained in its community forum why PayPal recurring donors were asked to restart their gifts after it moved from Donorbox to another service, and at least one donor first questioned whether the request was genuine. It shows the friction of switching, not how many donors a nonprofit will lose. Forum discussion, read September 6, 2026

Our October 19 search for lawsuits, regulatory actions, breaches and outages found the two Givebutter suits and the 2025 Givebutter–Zeffy case, and nothing for Donorbox. Our October 20 search found nothing for Better Giving or GiveForms, and no independent reviews of Better Giving’s donation form. A search that finds nothing is not proof that nothing exists.

How we researched

This is public-source research. We did not create accounts, build forms, make or receive payments, contact vendors or export records. No vendor supplied access or payment. We first compared these services on September 6, 2026, rechecked the material claims on October 19 and 20, 2026, and reread every price and fee page on November 12, 2026. In October, Zeffy’s main website and feedback site, Donorbox’s help-center pages and the court dockets blocked our automated requests, and Every.org’s main website limited them. We read Zeffy’s help center instead, Donorbox’s same articles through its public help-center feed, Zeffy’s feedback board at its other public address and court metadata through a public index. The Reddit and iNaturalist posts are as read on September 6.

We first chose three services that a small US nonprofit can start using without a subscription and that use different funding models: a donor contribution to the platform (Zeffy), a platform fee (Donorbox) and a donor tip that can be switched off for a fee (Givebutter). We judged them on what one gift costs the nonprofit, what donors are asked to add and whether the nonprofit controls that request, recurring gifts and switching, payouts, records and receipts, and the terms behind each promise. We fixed those criteria and their weights before comparing the services, and we scored every service added later under the same weights. Giving the donor request as much weight as the nonprofit’s cost makes Donorbox the narrow leader, which is why we name it for nonprofits that do not want donors asked to fund the platform.

On November 12, 2026 we priced every donation-form service we could find that a small US nonprofit can use without a subscription, for the same job: about 200 card gifts of $100 a year for three years, a US 501(c)(3), donors covering no fees, and card processing at Stripe’s nonprofit rate where the service cites it. Fifteen services had a readable price and we scored all of them on the same five criteria. The chart shows the top four, Zeffy (3.58), Donorbox (3.37), Better Giving (3.33) and GiveForms (3.30), The others, with their totals: Givebutter (3.30, just behind GiveForms): free only while its optional donor tip is on; with tips off it charges a 3% platform fee plus 2.9% + 30¢ per card payment, $6.20 on a $100 gift. Its terms, effective October 1, 2026, describe fee coverage as a credit with monthly or aggregate caps that Givebutter does not publish and can change, and let it suspend an organization for “encouraging donors not to cover fees”. A June 1, 2026 Truth in Advertising alert reported a 15% tip already selected on one live campaign, and two proposed class actions allege that tips and fees were added without proper disclosure; both were pending when we checked and are allegations. Its events, auctions and donor-management tools are outside this decision, and it does not come first for any case within it, such as a nonprofit moving active recurring donors in, so it has no section or chart column. Standard pricing, terms, ad alert, case tracker. BetterWorld (3.14): a free plan with a suggested donor contribution, but card fees of $3.20 per $100 without a nonprofit rate. Give Lively (3.13): no platform fee, but a tip request nonprofits cannot switch off and card fees of about $2.50 per $100 unless donors cover them. Anedot (3.02): no monthly fee, with a 3.3% + 30¢ rate ($3.60 per $100) for 501(c)(3) organizations. RallyUp and Raisely (2.95 each): free plans supported by donor tips, with processing fees of about $2.50 per $100, and a 2.9% to 6.9% (RallyUp) or 4% (Raisely) platform fee if you switch the tip off. Donately (2.94): a 4% platform fee plus processing, $6.50 per $100. Glass Register (2.86): a new free form from the nonprofit-software maker Societ, whose terms let processing fees be deducted despite its “no card fees” promise. Donation Spring (2.85): a one-person Stripe widget that publishes no terms or privacy policy. Every.org (2.80): donors give through Every.org, which keeps a tip request you cannot switch off. Double (2.65): a 2.9% fee plus processing, with no company named and no working terms or privacy links. We could not score the cost of Fundraise Up, which no longer states its platform fee, or of Mightycause, whose home page shows no fee. The pages we read for Givelify (a mobile giving app at 2.9% + 30¢) and GoFundMe Charity do not show embeddable donation forms, recurring gifts or a fee table, so their fit is not shown and we did not score them. GiveWP needs your own WordPress site and a paid plan for recurring gifts, so it does not fit this reader. None of these reached Zeffy’s score.

For our Rising Star, on November 12, 2026 we searched Hacker News, GitHub and the pricing pages of the candidates we had already screened for donation services launched in the last two years, and rechecked the October 2026 Rising Star under that test. We found no newcomer that qualified. Better Giving, a charity recognized as tax-exempt in 2022, was our Rising Star in October. Its nonprofit help articles on membership, donor fees and recurring giving are dated August 2024 and its nonprofit terms October 25, 2024, so its donation platform was public before November 12, 2024; its February 2025 announcement was for fundraiser pages. Of the others, Donation Spring’s launch date is not established on its pages and it publishes no terms or privacy policy, so its “no data is stored internally” claim cannot be checked; Double holds donors’ payment and contact data yet names no company and links no working terms or privacy policy; Glass Register comes from an established nonprofit-software company; and Every.org (2019), GiveForms (2018) and Give Lively (2015) entered the market earlier. The rest of the search turned up a crypto tip jar, a fiscal-sponsorship app and hobby projects, which do not do this job.

ToolPublic sourcesWhat remains uncertain
ZeffyFunding-model, eligibility, payment-method, refund, payout, export and recurring help articles; NPO terms (US Addendum); privacy policy; vendor-hosted feedback board.The current suggested contribution at checkout, how donors respond to it, support hours, and leaving with active recurring gifts.
DonorboxPricing page and fee, fee-coverage, payout, refund, export, receipt and migration articles; April 2026 terms; August 2026 privacy policy.Whether donors are shown fee coverage selected by default, your actual Stripe rate, support hours, and leaving with active recurring gifts.
GivebutterStandard pricing, payout, verification, recurring, migration, export and receipt articles; October 2026 terms and privacy policy; TINA.org alert and case tracker; Summeril complaint.The tip shown on your own forms, the current credit caps, how the two suits end, and leaving with active recurring gifts.
Better GivingPricing and product pages; help-center articles on costs, the donor contribution, eligibility, grants, withdrawals, Form 990 reporting and moving recurring donors; nonprofit and donor terms effective October 23, 2026; public code repository; IRS filings via ProPublica; February 2025 launch announcement.Its card processing rate, whether the contribution is really never preselected, how fast withdrawals arrive, what happens after a failed recurring payment, and how its portability promise works in practice. We found no independent review of its donation form.
GiveFormsPricing and feature pages; October 2026 terms and privacy policy; company profile.Recurring frequencies and failed-payment handling, export contents, receipt wording, fee-coverage settings and which recurring donors it can move in. It publishes no help center.

Fees, plans and prices for every service in the table and above were reread on November 12, 2026.

None of this establishes how donors react, whether payments succeed, or how exports, receipts, payouts or support perform in practice. Next substantive review is due December 18, 2026, before year-end receipts, or sooner if a fee, term or case changes. Found a changed fee or term? Contact the editors.

Sources and evidence

Sources were checked October 19, 2026 unless another date is given; every fee and pricing page named for the services in the chart and for Givebutter was reread on November 12, 2026. Vendor material establishes documented offers and terms, not performance. Fee totals are our arithmetic from published rates.

We do not use any company’s competitor comparison tables as evidence about its competitors. This is a researched comparison, not a product review. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.