Painting original artwork on a desktop computer: Krita, GIMP, Rebelle, Clip Studio Paint and Corel Painter

Krita gives you a complete painting toolkit on all three desktop systems for no software fee. Rebelle is worth paying for when you want paint that runs, mixes and dries like the real thing; GIMP and Clip Studio Paint are the other strong options we scored.

PRACTICAL PICKSPreferredPickOur Preferred PickA full painting toolkit, no software fee$0

Krita

Customizable brush engines, stroke smoothing, perspective assistants, painting layers and color management on Windows, Mac and Linux, with no account and commercial use of your artwork allowed.

No physical paint simulation. PSD exchange drops transform masks, and pen feel depends on your tablet driver and computer.

Why Krita is our Pick
Newcomer assessment

No Rising Star selected

On October 23, 2026 we screened painting apps released in the past two years. The two strongest are early builds that do not run on a Mac yet, and one is still labelled alpha.

Procreate for Mac is announced but not released, and Canva’s free Affinity relaunches long-established apps. We will look again at the next review.

Who is this article for? Adults painting original artwork on a Windows, Mac or Linux computer with a pen tablet, for personal projects or paid work, who want a working file they can keep editing.

About 32 min read

What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean

The quick list

Krita and GIMP are free; Rebelle, Clip Studio Paint and Painter are paid. Compare the brush tools, what a paid edition adds and whether you may sell what you paint.

Krita (checked October 19, 2026) and GIMP (checked October 23, 2026) are free downloads. Rebelle prices are US list prices from Escape Motions’ public price feed on October 19, 2026, before tax. Clip Studio Paint PRO Ver. 5.0 was $63.00 one-time on October 23, 2026, a price Celsys says includes tax. Painter’s page showed $429.00 for a perpetual license and $199.00 for a 365-day subscription on October 23, 2026. Prices exclude currency conversion and promotions.

The comparison at a glance

Compare the brush and layer tools, what a paid edition adds, whether you may sell your work and what survives outside the native file.

Order follows our weighted totals for original desktop painting, not measured realism or brush speed. All tools remain selectable.

Desktop painting software for original raster artwork
FeatureKritaGIMPRebelleClip Studio PaintCorel Painter
Best fitPreferred Pick: a full painting toolkit on Windows, Mac or Linux without a software feeSecond-highest score: a free general image editor with painting tools on all three systemsAlso consider: paint that runs, mixes and dries like watercolor, oil or acrylicFourth-highest score: an illustration and comics toolkit for a one-time priceIts own brush system, for personal work; not recommended for paid commissions
Price (US list)Free download; optional paid store copies (October 19, 2026)Free download (October 23, 2026)8: $89.99; 8 Pro: $149.99 (public price feed, October 19, 2026)PRO Ver. 5.0: $63.00 one-time, tax included (October 23, 2026)Full: $429.00; 365-day subscription $199.00 (October 23, 2026)
Weighted total / 54.333.953.803.742.85
What a paid edition addsNo paid painting tier foundNo paid tierPro: pigment mixing, bristle brushes, RealShader, color management, PSD filesEX ($277.00) is the larger edition; features released after Ver. 5.0 need the Update Pass or a planOne full edition, sold as a perpetual license or subscription
Selling artwork you makeLicense page: artists may use Krita commerciallyFree software under the GNU GPL; we found no limit on selling your imagesAllowed on a private individual’s standalone license; animation has separate termsSupport FAQ: images may be used commercially, with no credit neededSpecific terms grant non-commercial use only; paid-work eligibility unresolved
Desktop systems listedWindows 8.1+, macOS 10.15+, Linux; no iPadWindows, macOS and LinuxWindows 10 (64-bit), macOS 10.15+; native Apple SiliconWindows 10 or 11 (64-bit), macOS 14, 15 or 26; no LinuxWindows 10 or 11 (64-bit), macOS 13 to 15
Working file and PSDKRA; PSD keeps groups, transparency masks and layer effects, not transform masksXCF; PSD and other formats through Export; how much a layered PSD keeps was not documented in what we readREB; PSD (Pro only) keeps layers but only color and transparency, not paint stateCLIP; Save Duplicate writes PSD or PSB with layers and an embedded color profileRIFF; PSD rasterizes shapes and text and moves masks into channels
Current version5.3.4.1, October 7, 2026; Qt6-based 6.0 series is more experimental3.2.6, September 10, 20268.3.4; Rebelle 8 left early access October 2, 2025Ver. 5.1.5, October 5, 2026; a one-time Ver. 5.0 license gets 5.0.x bug fixesPainter 2023; no newer version announced

Original raster painting on a desktop computer, not photo correction, vector illustration or animation. Public-source research checked October 19, 2026, with costs, GIMP and Clip Studio Paint checked October 23, 2026: no installs, tablet use, painting or file exchange by us. Krita and GIMP are free; Rebelle, Clip Studio Paint and Painter prices are US list prices. Weighted totals use our fixed weights and cost rule v1. Keep the native working file and export a flattened copy for sharing. Next substantive review: January 15, 2027, or sooner after a new major version, a price change or news about Painter’s future.

All features and sources 23 criteria

Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.

Painting tools

Show 7 criteria
Painting tools
FeatureKritaGIMPRebelleClip Studio PaintCorel Painter
Best fitPreferred Pick: a full painting toolkit on Windows, Mac or Linux without a software feeSecond-highest score: a free general image editor with painting tools on all three systemsAlso consider: paint that runs, mixes and dries like watercolor, oil or acrylicFourth-highest score: an illustration and comics toolkit for a one-time priceIts own brush system, for personal work; not recommended for paid commissions
Brush toolsMore than nine customizable engines, including Color Smudge, Particle and Filter; three smoothing methodsFourteen paint tools, including Paintbrush, Ink and MyPaint Brush; pressure dynamics and Smooth StrokeBrush creator; more than 260 presets; line stabilizationPressure, tilt and velocity dynamics; high stroke stabilization; color blending optionsDetailed brush customization; pressure, tilt, bearing and rotation listed
Traditional-media behaviorColor smudge blending; no physical paint simulation documentedNo physical paint simulation documentedWatercolor flow; wet, dry and blow controls; canvas tilt; impastoWatercolor-edge styles and color blending; no physical paint simulation documentedFluid, Thick Paint, watercolor and particle brushes; mixer
Drawing aidsPerspective, ellipse and fisheye assistants; wraparound mode for seamless texturesNo perspective or ellipse assistants documented in what we readRulers, perspective, symmetry and reference imagesPerspective tools; posable 3D figures and hand models as drawing referencesPerspective guides, grid and mirror painting
Layers and masksPaint, vector, filter, group and file layers; transparency, transform and selection masksLayers; 3.2 added link and vector layers; full mask scope not assessedLayers with masks, clipping and filter layersRaster and vector layers; full mask scope not assessedLayers documented; full mask scope not assessed
Color managementICC (LCMS) and OpenColorIO; HDR and EXRNot assessedPro only, with soft proofing and gamut warningColor profile setting; Lab color slider; CMYK when saving PSD or TIFFNot assessed
What a paid edition addsNo paid painting tier foundNo paid tierPro: pigment mixing, bristle brushes, RealShader, color management, PSD filesEX ($277.00) is the larger edition; features released after Ver. 5.0 need the Update Pass or a planOne full edition, sold as a perpetual license or subscription
Sources for painting tools

Checked October 19, 2026: Krita features and image manual; Rebelle edition comparison; Painter product page. Checked October 23, 2026: GIMP paint tools, paintbrush options and 3.2 release notes; Clip Studio Paint features and release notes. Simulation and realism descriptions are vendor documentation, not measured behavior. “Not assessed” means we did not establish it, not that it is absent.

Price, license and setup

Show 11 criteria
Price, license and setup
FeatureKritaGIMPRebelleClip Studio PaintCorel Painter
Price (US list)Free download; optional paid store copies (October 19, 2026)Free download (October 23, 2026)8: $89.99; 8 Pro: $149.99 (public price feed, October 19, 2026)PRO Ver. 5.0: $63.00 one-time, tax included (October 23, 2026)Full: $429.00; 365-day subscription $199.00 (October 23, 2026)
Three-year cost, one person (USD)$0$0$89.99 (Rebelle 8)$63.00$429.00
Cost score / 5 (rule v1)5.005.003.503.851.21
Weighted total / 54.333.953.803.742.85
Selling artwork you makeLicense page: artists may use Krita commerciallyFree software under the GNU GPL; we found no limit on selling your imagesAllowed on a private individual’s standalone license; animation has separate termsSupport FAQ: images may be used commercially, with no credit neededSpecific terms grant non-commercial use only; paid-work eligibility unresolved
Updates and renewalFree updates; store copies update automaticallyFree updates12 months of new features; keep the last version released in that window; no automatic renewal; 2 years of critical fixes for the designated long-term-support versionVer. 5.0 bug fixes included; new features need the Update Pass ($10.99 a year, renews automatically) or a planPerpetual license covers only that version; subscriptions renew unless you give 30 days’ notice; payments non-refundable except where law requires
Computers per licenseNo registration or license limitNo license limitPrivate individual: 3 computers, 1 in use at a time; company: 1 shared computerOne computer; you can move the license to anotherUp to 2 devices, 1 in use at a time
Desktop systems listedWindows 8.1+, macOS 10.15+, Linux; no iPadWindows, macOS and LinuxWindows 10 (64-bit), macOS 10.15+; native Apple SiliconWindows 10 or 11 (64-bit), macOS 14, 15 or 26; no LinuxWindows 10 or 11 (64-bit), macOS 13 to 15
Memory listed4 GB minimum, 16 GB recommendedNot assessed4 GB minimum, 16 GB recommended; OpenGL 3.3 for Pro2 GB minimum, 8 GB recommended; OpenGL 3.3 graphics8 GB minimum, 16 GB recommended
Activation and accountNo registration; works without the internetNo accountInternet activation; starting a trial creates a community accountActivated by signing in to a Clip Studio account; works offline for 15 days at a timeInternet activation and registration
Data the vendor describes collectingOptional news feed, said to involve no tracking; store copies check for updatesNot assessedOnline use: registration details, IP and MAC address, home directory, version and OS; usage analytics can be switched offLicense checks send the serial number or activation code and device hardware details; Celsys says it collects no personally identifiable information for thisInstallation and registration data, license checks; usage collection depends on settings
Sources for price, license and setup

Krita download and license; GIMP downloads and about; Rebelle offer, with prices from the public feed that page uses, EULA, update FAQ, terms of use and privacy policy; Clip Studio Paint pricing, Ver. 5.0 FAQ, commercial-use FAQ, EULA and system requirements; Painter offer, general EULA, specific terms and privacy statement. Dollar prices are list prices; Clip Studio says its prices include tax, the others are before tax. Cost scores use our cost rule v1 over three years; see “How we researched”. Listed requirements do not establish tablet responsiveness.

Working files and maintenance

Show 5 criteria
Working files and maintenance
FeatureKritaGIMPRebelleClip Studio PaintCorel Painter
Working file and PSDKRA; PSD keeps groups, transparency masks and layer effects, not transform masksXCF; PSD and other formats through Export; how much a layered PSD keeps was not documented in what we readREB; PSD (Pro only) keeps layers but only color and transparency, not paint stateCLIP; Save Duplicate writes PSD or PSB with layers and an embedded color profileRIFF; PSD rasterizes shapes and text and moves masks into channels
Flattened outputPNG and other image formatsPNG, JPEG and other formats through ExportPNG with transparency (hide the canvas layer), JPG, TIF, BMP, WebPPNG, JPEG, WebP, TIFF, BMP and TargaJPEG, GIF (optional transparency) and TIF documented
Current version5.3.4.1, October 7, 2026; Qt6-based 6.0 series is more experimental3.2.6, September 10, 20268.3.4; Rebelle 8 left early access October 2, 2025Ver. 5.1.5, October 5, 2026; a one-time Ver. 5.0 license gets 5.0.x bug fixesPainter 2023; no newer version announced
Who maintains itKrita project: a small sponsored team and volunteers; trademark held by Stichting Krita FoundationGIMP project: community developers, under the GNU GPLEscape Motions, s.r.o., SlovakiaCELSYS, Inc., TokyoCorel Corporation, independent and backed by Vector Capital since May 5, 2026
Change to plan forStay on 5.3 for production work while 6.0 maturesKeep it updated: 3.2.6 fixed many security flaws in file importersRenewal needed for new features after 12 months; renewal prices not publicFeatures released after Ver. 5.0 cost extra; the license needs a sign-in at least every 15 daysOwnership changed in May 2026; Corel’s announcement does not mention Painter; newer macOS not listed
Sources for working files and maintenance

Krita image manual, 5.3.4 release notes, October 2026 report and FAQ; GIMP save documentation and 3.2.6 release notes; Rebelle saving manual, release news and changelog; Clip Studio Paint saving and exporting manuals; Painter file-format help and Corel’s May 2026 announcement. A native working file and a usable flattened copy are different requirements.

What matters when choosing

Krita is our Practical Pick for an adult painting original artwork on a Windows, Mac or Linux computer with a pen tablet, who wants a full painting toolkit and a working file they can keep editing. It costs nothing. Its feature page documents more than nine customizable brush engines (Color Smudge among them); three stroke-smoothing methods; perspective and ellipse assistants; paint, vector, filter, group and file layers; and ICC and OCIO color management. Its license page says artists may use it commercially, that no registration is needed and that it works without the internet. We verified that the current stable release is 5.3.4.1, dated October 7, 2026. The most important compromise is that Krita blends digital color rather than simulating wet paint: it will not make watercolor run or oil paint build up the way Rebelle does. Features, license, download

Two practical conditions come with the recommendation. Use the 5.3 series for real work: the project releases a Qt6-based 6.0 series alongside it and calls that series more experimental. And keep your painting as a KRA file. Krita can save groups, transparency masks and layer effects to PSD, but not transform masks, so a PSD copy is for handing work on, not for keeping it. How a brush feels with your pen depends on your tablet, its driver and your computer, which no public source can settle for you; try it with your own hardware before committing to a large project. 5.3.4 release notes, working with images

If you want paint that runs, mixes and dries like the real thing, consider Rebelle. Both editions simulate watercolor flow, wet and dry paint, blowing paint and canvas tilt; Rebelle 8 Pro adds pigment mixing, bristle brushes, lighting through RealShader, color management and PSD files. Escape Motions’ public price feed listed $89.99 for Rebelle 8 and $149.99 for Pro on October 19, 2026, each a perpetual license with twelve months of new features. It runs on Windows and macOS only and needs internet activation. We do not recommend Corel Painter to new buyers on current evidence. Its brush system is the reason people choose it, but the version on sale is still Painter 2023, its page listed $429.00 for a perpetual license on October 23, 2026, and Corel’s current license terms for Painter grant use “solely” for private, personal, individual work-related and non-commercial purposes. Rebelle editions, Painter, Corel specific terms

Two widely used programs we added on October 23 also score well. GIMP, a free image editor for Windows, Mac and Linux, has the second-highest weighted total (3.95 against Krita’s 4.33) because it costs nothing and runs everywhere; it has pressure dynamics and stroke smoothing but fewer painting aids than Krita. Clip Studio Paint PRO (3.74) suits illustration and comics, costs $63.00 once for one computer and needs a Clip Studio account sign-in at least every 15 days. Krita’s lead does not depend on how we weigh price: it is free and scores highest on the other criteria too. We did not name a Rising Star. The newest painting apps we found are early builds that do not run on a Mac yet, and Procreate for Mac is announced but not released. GIMP, Clip Studio Paint pricing

These are researched judgments from public documentation, license terms, release records and independent reports, checked October 19, 2026, with prices, GIMP and Clip Studio Paint checked October 23, 2026. We did not install any program, connect a tablet or paint anything. Three conditions would change our recommendation: you want physical paint behavior more than a general toolkit (choose Rebelle, and check whether you need Pro); you already own Painter and love its brushes for personal work (staying is reasonable); or you must exchange fully editable layered files with Photoshop users (check the PSD limits of all three before choosing). Whichever you choose, keep the native working file and export a flattened copy for sharing.

Krita

Preferred Pick · a full painting toolkit, no software fee

$0GPL · Windows, Mac and Linux

Choose Krita to paint original artwork on any of the three desktop systems with customizable brushes, painting layers and color management, at no cost and with commercial use allowed. Stay on the 5.3 series and keep your work as KRA.

Reasons to choose it

  • More than nine customizable brush engines, stroke smoothing and perspective assistants
  • No account, registration or internet connection needed
  • License page allows commercial use of your artwork

What to watch

  • No physical paint simulation: color blends, but does not run or dry
  • PSD exchange does not carry transform masks
  • Pen feel depends on your tablet driver and computer

Krita is a free, open-source painting program for Windows, macOS and Linux. Its feature page documents more than nine brush engines, among them Color Smudge, Shape, Particle and Filter; three stroke-smoothing methods and a Dynamic Brush tool; vanishing-point, ellipse and fisheye drawing assistants; and a wraparound mode for painting seamless textures. Layers can be paint, vector, filter, group or file layers, and color management uses ICC profiles through LCMS and OpenColorIO, including HDR and EXR files. Brush and texture packs can be imported and bundled. Its animation tools are a bonus, not the reason to choose it here. Features

Choose another tool if the behavior of physical paint is what you want to work with. Krita’s color smudge engines blend color, but nothing in its documentation simulates water flowing across paper, paint drying or pigments mixing the way Rebelle’s media engine does. Its other limits are exchange and hardware: PSD does not carry transform masks, and responsiveness on a large layered canvas depends on your computer and tablet driver rather than on any listed requirement. Working with images

Read the full Krita analysis and sources

Which release to use

We verified that the download page offers Krita 5.3.4.1, released October 7, 2026, for Windows 8.1 or later, macOS 10.15 or later and Linux. It lists 4 GB of RAM as the minimum, recommends 16 GB, and needs OpenGL 3.0 or Direct3D 11. It says iPads and iPhones are not supported; Android tablet builds of 5.3.4 are offered as a beta. Paid copies on Steam, the Microsoft Store, the Epic Games Store and the Mac App Store support development and update automatically; we found no painting feature reserved for them. Download and requirements

Krita 5.3.4 and 6.0.4 were released together on September 15, 2026. The release notes describe 5.3.4, built on Qt5, as suitable for productive work, and 6.0.4, built on Qt6, as more experimental; 5.3.4 also raised the macOS minimum to 10.15 and both series dropped 32-bit Windows builds. On Linux, the notes say Krita is tested only against KDE Plasma’s KWin on Wayland. The October hotfix, 5.3.4.1, repaired assigning display profiles, which matters if you calibrate your monitor. 5.3.4 release notes, October 2026 report

Releases have been regular: 5.3.3 on July 29 and 5.3.4 on September 15, 2026, each with crash and stability fixes. The project describes itself as a small sponsored team plus volunteers and asks users to fund it through donations. That is a continuity consideration, not a warning sign; the license means the software and your KRA files do not depend on a company staying in business. Release posts, October 2026 report

Keep KRA for continued editing

Krita’s manual says it can load and save groups, transparency masks and layer effects through PSD, but not transform masks. Its own file is a compressed archive whose layers can be recovered with an archive tool if a file is damaged, and it documents incremental versions (filename_XXX.kra) and incremental backups. Save incremental versions while you work, and export a PSD only when someone else needs layers. Working with images

For a handoff, agree on what the recipient needs to change. If they only need the finished appearance, a flattened PNG may be enough. If they must adjust the construction, list the layers and effects they need and check them in the receiving program before you rely on PSD.

License, account and data

Krita’s license page says that what you create is your property, that artists may use Krita commercially, that no registration is needed and that it does not need the internet to work. It names two exceptions: the optional news feed on the start screen, which it says involves no tracking, and Steam or Microsoft Store copies, which check for updates. The GNU GPL covers the program, not your paintings. Krita’s FAQ says the Stichting Krita Foundation owns the trademark and contributors own the source-code copyright. Krita’s separate privacy-statement page returned no substantive text to our check, so the license page is the project’s fullest statement on data. These are published statements, not a network audit. License, FAQ

Used Krita? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

GIMP

Second-highest score · free, on all three systems

$0GPL · Windows, Mac and Linux

Consider GIMP if you already use it for photos or want a free editor on Linux that can also paint. Krita does more for painting: GIMP has pressure dynamics and stroke smoothing but no drawing assistants or paint simulation.

Reasons to choose it

  • Fourteen paint tools, including Ink and MyPaint Brush, with pressure dynamics and Smooth Stroke
  • Free on Windows, macOS and Linux, with no account
  • Regular releases: 3.2.6 on September 10, 2026

What to watch

  • Built mainly for photo retouching and image composition
  • No perspective or ellipse drawing assistants in what we read
  • Keep it updated: recent releases fixed many file-import security flaws

GIMP is a free image editor for Windows, macOS and Linux, developed by a community project under the GNU General Public License. It describes itself as a program for photo retouching, image composition and image authoring, so painting is one of several jobs it covers. Its manual lists fourteen paint tools, five of which paint with a brush: Pencil, Paintbrush, Airbrush, Ink and MyPaint Brush. Each brush tool has pressure-driven Dynamics, Apply Jitter and a Smooth Stroke option that steadies a line. GIMP 3.2, released March 14, 2026, added 20 brushes to the MyPaint Brush tool and made it follow canvas zoom and rotation; 3.2.6, released September 10, 2026, added pen rotation as a dynamics input. About GIMP, paint tools, paintbrush options, GIMP 3.2, GIMP 3.2.6

Choose GIMP if you already use it for photos, or want one free program on Linux for both editing and painting. Choose Krita for painting itself: in what we read, GIMP documents no perspective or ellipse drawing assistants and no paint simulation, and its brush engines are fewer. Its second-highest score comes mainly from costing nothing and running on all three systems, not from its painting tools, which we scored a point below Krita’s.

Read the full GIMP analysis and sources

Files and maintenance

GIMP’s Save command writes only its own XCF format; PNG, JPEG, PSD and other formats go through Export. Version 3.2 imports more PSD layer styles, but we did not find documentation of how much of a layered painting survives a PSD export, so check it before you rely on it for a handoff. Releases are regular: 3.2 in March, 3.2.4 in April and 3.2.6 in September 2026. The 3.2.6 notes list a long run of security fixes in GIMP’s file importers, and third-party databases list further 2026 importer flaws whose status we could not confirm; install updates and open files only from people you trust. GIMP needs no account. Save documentation, downloads, release news

Used GIMP? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Rebelle

Also consider · watercolor and oil behavior

$89.99Pro $149.99 · perpetual, 1 year of updates

Consider Rebelle when you want paint that flows, mixes and dries like traditional media. Decide on the edition first: pigment mixing, bristle brushes, color management and PSD files are Pro features.

Reasons to choose it

  • Watercolor, wet and dry paint, blowing and canvas tilt in both editions
  • Perpetual license with no automatic renewal
  • Commercial use allowed on an individual’s license

What to watch

  • Windows and macOS only; internet activation
  • PSD needs Pro and keeps only color and transparency, not paint state
  • New features after 12 months require a paid renewal

Rebelle, from Escape Motions, is built around simulating traditional media. Both Rebelle 8 and Rebelle 8 Pro list watercolor simulation, oil and acrylic impasto, mixed-media interaction, wet, dry and blow controls, canvas tilt, a brush creator, more than 260 brush presets, line stabilization, rulers, perspective and symmetry tools and reference images. Pro adds bristle brushes, pigment color mixing, RealShader lighting with soft shadows, metallic materials, color management with soft proofing, PSD import and export, large NanoPixel exports and heightmap export. “Realistic” is the vendor’s description, not something we measured. Edition comparison

Choose Krita instead if you mainly want clean graphic shapes, a Linux version or no software fee. Choose carefully between editions: the pigment mixing and bristle brushes shown in much of Rebelle’s marketing belong to Pro, and so does any PSD file. In August 2026, TechRadar’s reviewer praised its brushes but reported awkward trackpad canvas movement and occasional waits while strokes rendered on his MacBook; that is one reviewer’s setup, not a measured result. Edition comparison, TechRadar review

Read the full Rebelle analysis and sources

Price and requirements

The product page loads its prices by script. Escape Motions’ public price feed, which supplies those prices, listed $89.99 for Rebelle 8 and $149.99 for Rebelle 8 Pro in US dollars on October 19, 2026, the same as the prices we saw displayed on September 6. These are list prices before tax, not checkout totals. The page also advertises a 40% educational discount and up to 30% off a first order for newsletter subscribers. Current offer

The listed minimum is Windows 10 (64-bit) or macOS 10.15, 4 GB of RAM and a graphics card with 1 GB of memory, with OpenGL 3.3 required for Pro; 16 GB and macOS 11 or later are recommended, and Apple Silicon is supported natively. Activation needs an internet connection. Rebelle 8 left early access on October 2, 2025; 8.2 followed in December 2025 and 8.3 on July 30, 2026. The download page lists 8.3.4 as current, with fixes for slider lag on Windows Ink tablets, several crashes and bristle brushes failing to load after an upgrade to Pro. Requirements, release news, download and changelog

Perpetual use has an update boundary

For a private individual, the license allows installation on three Windows or Mac computers you own or control, with no more than one in use at a time; a company’s license covers one shared computer. A private individual’s standalone license allows commercial, for-profit use; animation, including still frames exported for later assembly, falls under separate animation terms. The trial is for personal, non-commercial evaluation. EULA

The purchase includes twelve months of updates. After that you keep the last version released in your update window and can choose whether to buy another year; Escape Motions says there are no automatic renewals. A designated long-term-support version gets critical bug fixes and security updates for two years from its release, not two years of new features. Renewal prices are shown only in its shop to signed-in customers, so we could not establish them. EULA, update FAQ

The wet painting stays in REB

The Rebelle 8 manual says only the REB file contains all artwork information. It marks PSD opening and saving as Pro features, and says PSD, PNG, TIF and BMP files save only color and transparency information, although individual layers are saved in REB and PSD. Hide the canvas layer to save a PNG with transparency. A PSD from Rebelle Pro therefore keeps your layers but not the paint’s wet state or media behavior; another program cannot carry on the watercolor where Rebelle left off. Version 8.3.0 fixed the paper layer and texture in exported PSD files. Saving paintings, changelog

Operator and data

Escape Motions, s.r.o. is based in Slovakia. Its privacy policy, last modified March 3, 2026, says that when the software is used online it collects registration details, IP address, home directory, MAC address, software version and operating system to enforce the license, and that usage analytics can be switched on or off in the software. Purchase and trial data are kept for up to three years from the latest purchase. Starting a trial creates a community account, which is deleted if not activated within 30 days. Painting locally is therefore not a promise that no data leaves your computer. Privacy, terms of use

Used Rebelle? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Clip Studio Paint

Fourth-highest score · illustration and comics

$63PRO Ver. 5.0 · one-time, one computer

Consider Clip Studio Paint if you draw illustrations or comics and want strong line stabilization, 3D posing references and layered PSD export for a one-time $63. Check that Ver. 5.0 has what you need: later features cost extra.

Reasons to choose it

  • Pressure, tilt and velocity brush dynamics with high stroke stabilization
  • Posable 3D figures and hand models as drawing references
  • Saves layered PSD or PSB copies; commercial use of your images allowed

What to watch

  • Windows and macOS only; one computer per one-time license
  • Needs a Clip Studio account sign-in at least every 15 days
  • Features released after Ver. 5.0 need the Update Pass or a plan

Clip Studio Paint, from CELSYS, Inc. of Tokyo, is built for illustration, comics and webtoons. Its feature page and release notes describe brushes that respond to pressure, tilt and speed, strong stroke stabilization, watercolor-edge styles, a color-profile setting and a Lab color slider, plus posable 3D figures and hand models to draw from. We found no physical paint simulation in what we read. Its support FAQ says images you create “can be used for both private and/or commercial use”, with no credit needed. Features, release notes, commercial use

Choose it if you draw characters, comics or line-heavy illustration and want a paid tool for a modest one-time price. Choose Krita instead if you use Linux, want no account, or need its painting assistants and color management. Choose Rebelle if wet paint behavior is the point.

Read the full Clip Studio Paint analysis and sources

Price, license and setup

On October 23, 2026, the PRO edition’s Ver. 5.0 one-time license was US$63.00 and EX was $277.00; Celsys says these prices include tax. A one-time Ver. 5.0 license gets bug-fix updates within 5.0.x; features added later need the Update Pass, $10.99 a year for PRO, which renews automatically, or a monthly or annual plan. The current release, 5.1.5 of October 5, 2026, is for plan and Update Pass holders. Pricing, Ver. 5.0 FAQ

A one-time license covers one computer, which you can change by transferring it. It is activated by signing in to a Clip Studio account, and the Windows and macOS app “can be used offline for 15 days”, so plan to connect at least that often. The license agreement says license checks send the serial number or activation code and hardware details of your device, and that Celsys collects no personally identifiable information for this. It runs on 64-bit Windows 10 or 11 and macOS 14, 15 and 26, with 2 GB of memory minimum and 8 GB recommended; there is no Linux version. Ver. 5.0 FAQ, license agreement, system requirements

Files

Clip Studio’s manual says to keep layers by saving in its CLIP format, and to use Save Duplicate to write a layered PSD or PSB for another program, with options for which layers to export and whether to embed the color profile. Export (Single Layer) produces flattened PNG, JPEG, WebP, TIFF and other files. A CLIP file saved in Ver. 5.0 opens in older versions, but parts that use new features may not be editable there. Saving, exporting, Ver. 5.0 FAQ

Used Clip Studio Paint? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Corel Painter

Its brush system, personal work only

$429Perpetual 2023 license · $199 a year by subscription

We do not recommend Painter to new buyers. If you already own it and love its brushes for personal work, staying is reasonable; do not rely on it for paid commissions until the license question is resolved.

Reasons to choose it

  • Fluid, Thick Paint, watercolor and particle brushes with deep customization
  • Pressure, tilt, bearing and rotation support listed
  • Mixer, paper textures and composition aids

What to watch

  • License terms grant non-commercial use only
  • Still Painter 2023, with no new version announced
  • Activation needs internet and registration; macOS 15 is the newest listed

Painter’s product page describes Fluid, Thick Paint, watercolor and particle brushes with detailed customization, a mixer, color harmonies, paper textures, and perspective, grid and mirror aids. It lists support for pen pressure, tilt, bearing and rotation and names Wintab-compatible tablets. Whether a particular pen supplies those inputs, and how a brush responds, is not something public sources establish. Product and requirements

That brush system is the reason to consider Painter if you already know you want it. It is a weak reason for a new painter to spend $429 before trying a free environment, and three facts weigh against it for new buyers: the version on sale is still Painter 2023, its license terms grant non-commercial use only, and we found no public commitment from its owner to a new version. If you already own Painter and use it for personal work, none of this forces a change.

Read the full Corel Painter analysis and sources

Price, platform and terms

On October 23, 2026, Painter’s page listed $429.00 for a perpetual license, $19.99 for a 30-day subscription and $199.00 for a 365-day subscription. The same panel also says “$9.08 monthly (billed annually)”, which does not match $199.00 a year; we use the higher figure. Over three years the perpetual license is the cheapest way to keep painting. A third-party pricing tracker recorded a temporary $180 discount in mid-September. The page shows a 30-day money-back badge, while Corel’s license agreement calls payments non-refundable except where law requires; ask before you buy if that matters to you. The page lists Windows 10 or 11 (64-bit) and macOS 13 to 15, 8 GB of RAM minimum and 16 GB recommended, and says activation requires an internet connection and registration. Do not assume a newer macOS is supported because it is not listed. Current offer and requirements, PricingSaaS change record, patches and updates

Corel’s general license agreement, updated April 1, 2026, says a perpetual license covers only the version you bought and that amounts paid are non-refundable, without prejudice to mandatory law. A subscription renews automatically unless you notify Corel at least 30 days before it expires. Corel may “sunset” software with written notice, after which a perpetual version keeps working but support ends. General EULA

Read the license before commercial work

Corel’s specific terms list Painter and grant use “solely for Your private, personal, individual work-related and non-commercial purposes”. They allow installation on up to two devices with one in use at a time, and up to five licenses per person, beyond which an organization needs a business license. Painter’s marketing calls it professional digital art software. We could not establish which license a reader would need for paid client work, so we do not recommend it for commissions. This is an unresolved eligibility question, not a finding that all commercial use is prohibited. Specific terms, general EULA

Ownership and continuity

On May 5, 2026, Corel announced that it had relaunched as an independent company after Vector Capital completed its acquisition of Corel’s creativity and productivity software; the Parallels business stayed with KKR. Corel’s announcement names CorelDRAW, PaintShop Pro, VideoStudio, WinZip and other brands but not Painter. Heise’s March 2026 report of the deal lists Painter among the products going to Vector Capital, and Painter’s terms and privacy statement still name Corel Corporation. The announcement sets out priorities such as AI integration but no product roadmap. Painter’s own patches page lists only a macOS 13 Ventura update for Painter 2023; we found no dated Painter release in the past 12 months. Painter’s continued sale establishes that it is available, not that a new version is coming. Corel announcement, heise

Native detail does not all travel through PSD

Painter’s help identifies RIFF as its own format, which “maintains all layers”, and recommends always saving working files in it. For PSD, shapes and text are rasterized and masks are placed in channels. We did not use older manuals to infer how every Painter media layer converts. Corel’s privacy statement, last updated April 2026, covers installation and registration data, license verification and usage collection that depends on your settings. File formats, privacy

Used Corel Painter? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Which product are we missing?

Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.

Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.

Suggest a product

Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.

No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.

What people are saying

Public discussion is a check on vendor claims, not a measured reliability score. A March 2026 Krita discussion, read September 6, reports choppy strokes and interface lag with Huion pens in early 5.3 builds; one later reply describes better results with a different package. Krita has since shipped 5.3.3 and 5.3.4, but neither the thread nor the release notes establish whether that problem is resolved on every setup.

TechRadar’s August 22, 2026 review of Rebelle 8 praises its brush options but reports one project open at a time, awkward trackpad canvas movement and occasional rendering waits on the reviewer’s MacBook. TechRadar earns affiliate revenue, and this is one reviewer’s configuration, not our test.

Painter users, in a late-2025 discussion read September 6, disagree about whether its brushes justify staying with it; some speculate it has been abandoned, another prefers it to Rebelle. A July 2026 Creative Bloq roundup also questions Painter’s maintenance while valuing its brush control. None of these establishes a discontinuation. TechRadar and Creative Bloq share a publisher, so they are not independent of each other. Our October 19 search for security issues, legal action, ownership changes and recurring complaints involving the three programs and their companies found nothing beyond what this article reports that changed our conclusions; a search that finds nothing is not proof that nothing exists.

How we researched

This is public-source research. We did not install or run any program, connect a tablet, paint, create an account, start a trial or buy a license. No company supplied access, payment or input, and we use no affiliate links. We first compared these three programs on September 6, 2026 and rechecked every material claim on October 19, 2026: versions and release records, prices and edition gates, system requirements, license and update terms, file-format documentation, privacy statements and ownership. On October 23, 2026 we added GIMP and Clip Studio Paint, evaluated three other widely used programs, rescored cost under a new rule and searched again for newer painting apps. Rebelle’s product page loads prices by script, so we read them from the public price feed the page uses; Painter’s page displayed its prices on October 23. Reddit discussions could not be retrieved again, so they are as read on September 6.

We wrote this for an adult painting original raster artwork on a desktop computer with a pen tablet, for personal projects or paid work, who wants a working file they can keep editing. It does not cover photo correction, vector illustration or animation. We fixed five criteria and their weights before comparing: painting tools (30%), cost (25%), platforms and setup (15%), working files and exchange (15%) and continuity (15%). Since October 23 the cost score follows our cost rule v1: three years of the cheapest suitable plan for one person, compared with the median price of the programs that fit this job. Seven programs fit (Krita, GIMP, Affinity, FireAlpaca, Clip Studio Paint, Rebelle and Photoshop); four are free, so the rule uses the median of the three paid ones, $89.99. Rebelle 8 then scores 3.50 of 5 on cost, Clip Studio Paint PRO 3.85, Painter 1.21 and Photoshop 1. Before this change the criterion also counted license terms, such as Painter’s non-commercial grant; we still report those terms, but they no longer change the score. Painter is outside that price comparison because we found no Painter release in the past 12 months.

Weighted totals out of 5: Krita 4.33, GIMP 3.95, Rebelle 3.80, Clip Studio Paint 3.74, Affinity 3.65, FireAlpaca 3.65 and Corel Painter 2.85. Krita’s lead over GIMP (0.38) is larger than one step on the heaviest criterion. Affinity, now free on Windows and macOS with a Canva account, has pressure-sensitive raster brushes but is built mainly for photo, vector and layout work. FireAlpaca, free on Windows and macOS with ads, is a lighter painting program whose layered PSD export we could not confirm. Adobe Photoshop’s total falls somewhere between 2.80 and 3.85: Adobe’s pages could not be read by our tools, and its price, $19.99 a month for the Photography plan on an annual commitment, comes from our photo-editor comparison’s October 19 check. It cannot overtake Krita, but it could rank above Clip Studio Paint. The fourth place is close: if price counted for more, Affinity and FireAlpaca would pass Clip Studio Paint. We also set aside MediBang Paint, ArtRage and MyPaint, whose latest desktop releases are from 2023, March 2025 and 2020. Adding a 30% criterion for physical paint simulation still makes Rebelle the stronger choice for that use, which is why it keeps its label. Affinity, FireAlpaca, Photoshop plan price, MediBang Paint release history, ArtRage Vitae, MyPaint releases

We searched for new entrants on October 19 and again on October 23, 2026, through trade press, launch and maker communities, open-source and indie storefronts, alternative-software listings and current recommendation lists. No candidate met our Rising Star conditions. Kala Paint, a one-time-purchase painting app first sold in 2026, is still labelled alpha and runs only on Windows. Our Paint, a small open-source painter with pigment mixing, is before version 1.0 and has no Mac version. Procreate for Mac is announced but not released. Canva’s free Affinity is a relaunch of long-established apps from an established maker, so it is not a newcomer. We will look again at the next review.

ToolPublic sourcesWhat remains uncertain
KritaFeature page, download page, 5.3.3 and 5.3.4 release notes, October 2026 report, image manual, license page, FAQ.Pen behavior and large-canvas performance on a given tablet and computer; whether early 5.3 Huion reports are resolved; long-term funding.
RebelleEdition comparison, public price feed, EULA, update FAQ, release news and changelog, Rebelle 8 manual, terms of use, privacy policy, TechRadar review.Renewal prices; checkout totals by region; how closely the simulation matches real media; whether the base edition can exchange layered files at all.
GIMPAbout and download pages, manual (paint tools, paintbrush, save), 3.2 and 3.2.6 release notes.How much a layered painting keeps in PSD; pen behavior; status of importer flaws reported after 3.2.6.
Clip Studio PaintPricing page, Ver. 5.0 FAQ, commercial-use FAQ, license agreement, system requirements, features page, release notes, saving and exporting manuals.Pen behavior; how the 15-day sign-in check works on a computer kept offline; future one-time prices.
Corel PainterProduct page and patches page, file-format help, general EULA, specific terms, privacy statement, Corel’s May 2026 announcement, heise report, pricing-tracker record.Which annual subscription price applies ($199.00 or $9.08 a month billed annually); which license covers paid client work; support for newer macOS versions; whether a new version is planned.

None of this establishes brush feel, latency, realism or stability on your hardware. Next substantive review is due January 15, 2027, or sooner after a new major version, a price change or news about Painter’s future. Found a changed price or term? Contact the editors.

Sources and evidence

Sources were checked October 19, 2026 unless another date is given. Vendor material establishes documented features, offers and terms, not how a program performs. Community posts and reviews are attributed experiences, not representative samples.

This is a researched comparison, not a product review. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.