Keeping sourced family-history records on your computer: RootsMagic, Charted Roots, Gramps, Ancestris and Heredis
RootsMagic is the practical choice on Windows or a Mac: free to start, $39.95 to own and strong on sources. Gramps costs nothing and keeps records in an open format, but expect a steep learning curve.
RootsMagic 12
Reusable sources and citations, a proof label on every fact and the same features on Windows and Mac. Start with the free edition, then pay once.
Version 12 arrived October 8, 2026 and has needed several updates: install the latest and keep a copy of any file you convert. Media backups need the paid edition.
Why RootsMagic is our PickTeam behind RootsMagic 12? Get your award badge
Charted Roots
A free plugin for the Obsidian note app, first released in November 2025, that records citation quality fact by fact and keeps your tree as plain files on your computer.
One volunteer maintains it, with no release or reply to new bug reports since late June 2026, so test it on a copy and back up the folder yourself.
Why Charted Roots earned Rising StarWho is this article for? Adults keeping family-history records with sources on their own Windows, Mac or Linux computer, without publishing an online tree. Not DNA testing, legal proof or record-subscription services.
About 34 min read
What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean
The quick list
One person keeping sourced records on a home computer. Compare the price to own each program, then what its backups include and what it sends online.
Prices for one person, in US dollars as displayed on November 12, 2026, before tax. Excludes later major-version upgrades and optional online record services.
The comparison at a glance
Compare what each program costs to own, how it records sources and doubt, what its backups include and what can leave your computer.
Order follows our verdict for sourced records on a home computer, not measured accuracy or ease of use. The chart shows our four highest-scoring programs and our Rising Star. All tools remain selectable.
Hides matching answers for the selected tools. Unknowns and unverified claims stay visible.
| Feature | RootsMagic | Charted Roots | Gramps | Ancestris | Heredis |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: sourced records on Windows or a Mac | Rising Star: evidence tools in plain files, for Obsidian users | Free software, an open file format or Linux, if you will learn it | Evaluated: free, with your tree kept as a GEDCOM file | Evaluated: guided entry on Windows or a Mac |
| Price to own, one person | Essentials free; full edition $39.95 once | Free; Obsidian, which it needs, is also free | Free | Free | $39.99 for Windows or $69.99 for Mac, bought separately; free demo up to 50 people |
| Computers supported | Windows 10/11; macOS 12 or later, with the same features | Wherever Obsidian runs: Windows, Mac (Intel and Apple silicon) and Linux | Windows 8/10/11 64-bit; Intel and Apple silicon Mac; Linux | Windows, Mac and Linux, with Java installed separately | Windows 10/11 or macOS, each a separate purchase |
| Recording doubt | Proof label on each fact: proven, disproven, disputed or proposed | Citation quality 0 to 3; source, information and evidence classified Mills-style; conflict detection (vendor) | Confidence on each citation, from very low to very high | Citation quality on a 0 to 3 scale | A certainty or quality level for each source |
| Pictures and documents in backups | Off by default; including them needs the paid edition | Ordinary files in your vault folder; the plugin has no backup command | Off by default, can be included; timed backups leave them out | A “Save as” copy can include media files | “Save a copy” makes a folder with the data and its media |
| What can leave your computer | Update checks; optional Ancestry, FamilySearch and Dropbox; AI prompts you copy yourself | Nothing by default; place lookups and maps send only the place searched for to public map services | No account; full network behavior not established | An anonymous connection to the Ancestris server at start and close; update checks; maps and place lookups | Licence activation, searches and maps; optional AI reading assistant paid by credits |
| Learning curve | Guided source entry; version 12 source changes disputed by experienced users | Its own FAQ warns of a steep learning curve if you are new to Obsidian; some data is edited as note properties | Steep for newcomers, by its own community’s account | Needs Java, and sources are entered GEDCOM-style; no independent reports read | Quick-entry window and pre-filled forms (vendor); no independent reports read |
Desktop records for one person, not a public online tree, DNA service or record subscription. Checked October 19, 2026; Charted Roots, Ancestris and Heredis added October 20, 2026; prices and maintenance rechecked November 12, 2026; next review December 18, 2026. Prices in US dollars as displayed, before tax, excluding sales except where noted. Documentation and user reports, not product tests: a listed feature does not show that a backup restores or a transfer keeps every citation. No privacy or security winner. Optional online services carry their own terms.
All features and sources 16 criteria
Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.
Price, platforms and licence
Show 7 criteria
| Feature | RootsMagic | Charted Roots | Gramps | Ancestris | Heredis |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: sourced records on Windows or a Mac | Rising Star: evidence tools in plain files, for Obsidian users | Free software, an open file format or Linux, if you will learn it | Evaluated: free, with your tree kept as a GEDCOM file | Evaluated: guided entry on Windows or a Mac |
| Price to own, one person | Essentials free; full edition $39.95 once | Free; Obsidian, which it needs, is also free | Free | Free | $39.99 for Windows or $69.99 for Mac, bought separately; free demo up to 50 people |
| Computers supported | Windows 10/11; macOS 12 or later, with the same features | Wherever Obsidian runs: Windows, Mac (Intel and Apple silicon) and Linux | Windows 8/10/11 64-bit; Intel and Apple silicon Mac; Linux | Windows, Mac and Linux, with Java installed separately | Windows 10/11 or macOS, each a separate purchase |
| Account or activation | Key unlocks the full edition; registration optional | No account; you switch on community plugins in Obsidian first | None in the download instructions | None; a forum login is only for support | Internet connection needed to activate the licence (Windows and Mac terms read) |
| Licence terms | Version 12 key; later major versions are optional paid upgrades; device limit not published | MIT licence; Obsidian free for personal and commercial use | GPL-2.0-or-later; no warranty | Free for life, with free updates (licence text not read) | One user on up to three computers of one system, Windows or Mac; yearly new versions sold as upgrades |
| Refunds | 30 days; downloads need a signed certificate that the software is removed | Not applicable | Not applicable | Not applicable | Not established in the pages we read |
| Support and release record | Company support for paid users; version 12 launch bugs fixed within 8 days, though citation and crash reports kept appearing in November | One volunteer maintainer; four data-loss bugs fixed by June 2026, then no release or reply to new bug reports since late June | Volunteer forum; maintenance releases every few months | Volunteer association and forum; version 13 stable since December 2025 | Company founded 1994; a new major version each year (2027 edition current) |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for price, platforms and licence
In US dollars as displayed and before tax: RootsMagic and Heredis prices read November 12, 2026, others checked October 19 and 20, 2026; Charted Roots maintenance rechecked November 12, 2026. RootsMagic purchase page, registration, returns and update notes for 12.1.0 and 12.1.1; Charted Roots directory listing, repository and issue tracker, with Obsidian’s licence overview and download page; Gramps download page, releases and license; Ancestris home and downloads and installation guide; Heredis home and prices, Windows edition terms and Mac edition terms.
Recording evidence and doubt
Show 5 criteria
| Feature | RootsMagic | Charted Roots | Gramps | Ancestris | Heredis |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sources and citations | Reusable sources and citations; 18 Evidence Explained templates; custom templates paid | Source notes and citation notes with page references; facts linked to the sources that support them | Separate sources, citations, repositories and notes | Sources held in repositories; citations with page and quality | Repositories, sources and citations; one event shared by everyone in a record |
| Recording doubt | Proof label on each fact: proven, disproven, disputed or proposed | Citation quality 0 to 3; source, information and evidence classified Mills-style; conflict detection (vendor) | Confidence on each citation, from very low to very high | Citation quality on a 0 to 3 scale | A certainty or quality level for each source |
| Relationships and roles | Adoptive and foster links; shared events for witnesses (paid) | Each person’s role in a source, such as principal or witness; organizations | People, families and events in separate records | Not established in the pages we read | Witnesses; shared events linking several people |
| Research tracking | Tasks and research logs linked to records (paid) | Research gaps report, a research level for each person, negative findings | Notes on any record; no task tool confirmed in our sources | Research notepad | Research journal |
| Learning curve | Guided source entry; version 12 source changes disputed by experienced users | Its own FAQ warns of a steep learning curve if you are new to Obsidian; some data is edited as note properties | Steep for newcomers, by its own community’s account | Needs Java, and sources are entered GEDCOM-style; no independent reports read | Quick-entry window and pre-filled forms (vendor); no independent reports read |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for recording evidence and doubt
Documentation and user reports, not app use. RootsMagic edition feature list and what’s new in 12; Charted Roots evidence and sources and FAQ; Gramps citation editor and schema; Ancestris documenting sources and research notepad; Heredis feature list. Learning-curve row: RootsMagic sources thread, Gramps forum and the Charted Roots FAQ. Source fields record claims and your reasoning; they do not verify the history.
Backups, formats and online conditions
Show 4 criteria
| Feature | RootsMagic | Charted Roots | Gramps | Ancestris | Heredis |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pictures and documents in backups | Off by default; including them needs the paid edition | Ordinary files in your vault folder; the plugin has no backup command | Off by default, can be included; timed backups leave them out | A “Save as” copy can include media files | “Save a copy” makes a folder with the data and its media |
| Backup routine | Manual; prompt on exit; local folder or Dropbox | Copy the vault folder yourself; no schedule | Manual, on exit, or every 15 minutes to once a day | Full or filtered copy with “Save as”; no schedule found | Save a copy or sync to a USB drive; timed saves are not backups |
| File formats | Single-file database; GEDCOM 5.5 export with privacy options | Markdown notes with YAML properties; GEDCOM 5.5.1 export with citation page and quality; Gramps XML | Published Gramps XML and XML package; GEDCOM | Your tree is stored as a GEDCOM file; copies can be encrypted | Heredis file in an .hmw folder; GEDCOM import and export; GEDCOM 7 import |
| What can leave your computer | Update checks; optional Ancestry, FamilySearch and Dropbox; AI prompts you copy yourself | Nothing by default; place lookups and maps send only the place searched for to public map services | No account; full network behavior not established | An anonymous connection to the Ancestris server at start and close; update checks; maps and place lookups | Licence activation, searches and maps; optional AI reading assistant paid by credits |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for backups, formats and online conditions
RootsMagic backup, export, feature list, AI Prompt Builder and Ancestry change; Charted Roots import and export and privacy and security; Gramps backups and formats; Ancestris Save as and privacy policy; Heredis saving a copy, recording a file and new features. No backup, restore or transfer was tested. Keep original records and an independent copy of every scan.
What matters when choosing
RootsMagic 12 is our Practical Pick for someone keeping family-history records with sources on a Windows PC or a Mac, without publishing an online tree. You enter a source once and reuse it, attach citations to facts and people, and label each conclusion as proven, disproven, disputed or proposed. The free Essentials edition includes those core tools with no time limit. The full edition costs $39.95 once and adds research logs, media in backups, custom source templates and free support. Windows and Mac versions now have the same features. The most important compromise is timing: version 12 arrived on October 8, 2026, and its first week brought crash reports and an import bug that RootsMagic fixed in updates 12.1.0 and 12.1.1, with citation and Mac crash reports still appearing in November. Install the latest update and keep a copy of any file you convert. Its lead is narrow: for the $39.95 full edition it scored 3.85 out of 5 against 3.75 for Gramps, a gap smaller than one point on our most heavily weighted criterion, and it stays ahead of Gramps whether price counts for more or for less. Edition feature list, purchase page, 12.1.1 notes
Charted Roots is our Rising Star for someone who already uses the Obsidian note app, or will learn it, and wants evidence tools in plain files. It is a free plugin, first released in November 2025, that keeps every person, source and citation as a text note in a folder on your computer. Its documentation describes citations with a page reference and a quality rating from 0 to 3, sources linked to each fact they support, and a report of facts still unsourced, which put its evidence tools level with RootsMagic’s on our fixed weights. It scored 3.55, below our top four, and narrowly ahead of TreeMonk (3.50), the other newer program that met our conditions; the gap is smaller than one point on our most heavily weighted criterion. The main limit is upkeep: one volunteer maintains it, four bugs that could lose data were fixed in spring 2026, and there has been no release since June 26 and no maintainer reply on the bug reports we read. Directory listing, evidence and sources, issue tracker
Disclosure: Practical Picks articles are researched and written with AI, currently Anthropic’s Claude. RootsMagic names Claude among the AI services its prompts can be pasted into, and Family Historian names Claude as a compatible assistant for its optional AI Connector. Charted Roots runs inside Obsidian, whose chief executive publishes agent skills for Claude Code, and Charted Roots’ own help lists Claude among outside tools for transcribing record images. We have no relationship with any of these makers or with Anthropic over these products, and AI features carried no weight in our judgment.
If you want free software, an open file format or a Linux computer, choose Gramps, as long as you are ready to learn it. It records sources, citations and repositories separately, lets you grade each citation’s confidence, and can back up to an open XML format on a schedule. Its own community acknowledges a steep learning curve for newcomers, and help comes from volunteers in a forum. Family Historian 8, a Windows-only program built around entering several facts from one document, scored 3.37, below our top four; its details are under “How we researched”. Gramps download, Gramps citations
We also scored two established programs we had not compared before. Ancestris (3.65) is free on Windows, Mac and Linux and keeps your tree as a GEDCOM file, but needs Java installed separately. Heredis (3.63) offers guided entry on Windows or a Mac, with a separate licence for each. Neither outscored RootsMagic or Gramps, and the two are level if price counts for less. Ancestris, Heredis
A useful record keeps more than a name in a diagram. Consider an invented example: two permitted documents give different years for the same event. You want to keep both sources and your reason for preferring one, rather than silently overwriting the older entry. Each program in our chart can store that disagreement. None of them can settle it by drawing a relationship or suggesting a match.
Our prices are for one person on one computer, in US dollars as each vendor displayed them on November 12, 2026, before tax, and they exclude sales and later major-version upgrades. Two conditions would change our recommendation: a Linux computer or a firm preference for an open, documented file format (choose Gramps), or further serious defects in RootsMagic 12 that are not fixed promptly. Before moving an existing tree into any of these programs, keep the original file and its media untouched, and check a few families, citations and pictures after the move.
RootsMagic
Preferred Pick · Windows or Mac
Choose RootsMagic to keep sourced family records on Windows or a Mac: start with the free edition, then pay once for research logs and media backups.
Reasons to choose it
- Reusable sources and citations, with proof and quality labels
- Same features on Windows and Mac, bought once
- Documented backups and export options for living people and private notes
What to watch
- Version 12 launched with crash and import bugs and has had several updates since; install the latest
- Media backups, research logs and free support need the paid edition
- No Linux version; per-key device limit not published
RootsMagic keeps a master list of sources that you reuse across people and facts, and you can see every person or fact that cites a source. Both editions include 18 source templates based on Evidence Explained (fourth edition), quality terms for sources, information and evidence, and a proof label for each fact. You can record adoptive and foster relationships and add notes to facts, people, couples and places. The paid edition adds tasks and research logs linked to people, sources and places, custom source templates, shared events for witnesses, and private facts and notes that you can keep out of reports and exports. Edition feature list
The full edition costs $39.95 as a one-time purchase, with free updates within version 12; later major versions are optional paid upgrades. RootsMagic Essentials is free with no time limit, but free technical support comes only with the paid edition. The purchase page lists Windows 10 or 11 and macOS 12 or later, and RootsMagic says both now have identical features. A key beginning with RM12 unlocks the full edition, and registering it is optional; registration brings support, key lookup and upgrade discounts. We could not find a published statement of how many computers one key may be used on. Purchase page, what’s new in 12, registration help
Read the full RootsMagic analysis and sources
Version 12 changed how sources are entered. The 18 Evidence Explained templates replaced a list of more than 400; templates you already used keep working as your own, and older ones can be exported from version 11 and imported. In the first week, users reported “access violation” errors when adding a child or spouse, and experienced users objected to parts of the new citation workflow. Update 12.1.0 on October 15 fixed crashes when adding children and reworked the citation editor. Update 12.1.1 the next day fixed a bug that corrupted files imported from RootsMagic 4 to 7; anyone who imported such a file should delete the version 12 copy and import the original again. Files from versions 8 to 11 were not affected. By November 12 the community forum referred to version 12.1.3.0, and recent threads still reported citation-editing problems and, from one Mac user, frequent shutdowns; we did not read the notes for the updates after 12.1.1. 12.1.0 notes, 12.1.1 notes, what’s new in 12, November forum thread
RootsMagic saves changes as you work, so closing without a backup does not undo them. Its Backup command saves the open database to a local folder or, after you sign in, to Dropbox. Pictures and documents are left out unless you tick “Backup media files”, and that option is a paid-edition feature. It prompts for a backup only when you exit the program, not when you close a database, and we found no scheduled-backup option in its help. Version 12 can add the date and time to backup file names. Keep your own copy of original scans as well. Backup help, edition feature list
GEDCOM export lets you choose people, notes, sources, tasks, media links and RootsMagic-specific details, and offers to hide living people’s names and facts, private facts and bracketed private notes. RootsMagic’s own help warns that another program may interpret its facts and formatting differently and that the export carries media links, not the files themselves. Export help
Some features go online. Both editions check automatically for updates. Ancestry and FamilySearch exchanges are optional, and they depend on those partners: when Ancestry switched off its old interface on May 5, 2026, RootsMagic 10 and earlier could no longer sync with Ancestry trees. The paid AI Prompt Builder fills a prompt with details from your tree for you to copy into an AI service; RootsMagic says the program never sends anything to an AI itself. Pasting family details into such a service is a separate decision under that service’s terms. RootsMagic, Inc.’s privacy policy covers purchases, registration, newsletters and Zendesk support; it is not a description of the desktop program’s network traffic. Edition feature list, Ancestry change, AI Prompt Builder, version 12 announcement, privacy policy
RootsMagic offers a 30-day money-back guarantee. For downloads it requires a signed certificate confirming you have uninstalled the software, returned within 30 days; shipping on USB orders is not refunded. Trying the free Essentials edition first is the simpler test. Returns policy
Used RootsMagic? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Charted Roots
Rising Star · a newcomer worth considering
Why Rising Star? First released in November 2025, Charted Roots scored highest of the newer programs we could include, on our fixed weights, because its documented tools for recording sources and doubt match those of our Pick, and it keeps everything in plain files on your computer. Its thin track record, quiet maintenance since June and Obsidian learning curve are the trade-offs. This is not our broader Ready to Rock endorsement.
Consider Charted Roots if you already use Obsidian, or will learn it, and want citation quality, fact-by-fact sourcing and research-gap reports kept in plain files you can read without any genealogy program. Test it on a copy, keep your original GEDCOM file and back up the vault folder yourself.
Reasons to choose it
- Citations with page and a 0 to 3 quality rating, linked to each fact
- Records are Markdown notes in a folder you choose; nothing is sent by default
- GEDCOM export carries citation pages and quality, with options for living people
What to watch
- Steep start if you are new to Obsidian; some data is edited as note properties
- One volunteer maintainer: no release or reply to new bug reports since late June 2026
- No backup command; four data-loss bugs were fixed in spring 2026
Charted Roots is a free plugin for Obsidian, a free note-taking app for Windows, Mac and Linux made by Dynalist Inc. John Banister first released it in November 2025 under the name Canvas Roots. The current version, 0.22.76, came out on June 26, 2026, and Obsidian’s community directory lists it with about 78,000 downloads. It is MIT-licensed. Each person, place, source and citation is a Markdown note with properties at the top, kept in an ordinary folder you choose (Obsidian calls it a vault), so your records stay readable in any text editor without the plugin. Obsidian is free for personal and commercial use and needs no account. Directory listing, repository, Obsidian licence, Obsidian download
Its evidence tools earned the award. According to its documentation, a source note records the type, date, repository, collection and a transcription. A citation note links one source to one fact about one person, with a page reference and a quality rating from 0 (unreliable) to 3 (primary evidence). You can list the sources behind ten kinds of fact, such as a birth date or parents, and see which facts are still unsourced. It also classifies sources, information and evidence on the three axes described by Elizabeth Shown Mills, records each person’s role in a source, such as a witness, and produces a research-gaps report. In the conflicting-date example, both citations stay attached to the fact with their own quality ratings. These are the maker’s descriptions; we found no independent review. Evidence and sources
Read the full Charted Roots analysis and sources
It imports GEDCOM 5.5.1, GEDCOM X, Gramps XML (with the media from a Gramps package) and CSV files. GEDCOM export writes citation pages and quality ratings back out and can leave out or anonymize people who may be living. By default the plugin makes no network requests: place lookups and the map send only the place you search for to public services such as Wikidata and OpenStreetMap, and there is no account or telemetry. Import and export, privacy and security
It is not easy to start. Its own FAQ says the learning curve is steep for anyone new to Obsidian, and it suits people comfortable editing note properties. The documentation warns that Obsidian’s property panel flags some advanced fields as a “type mismatch”, and that accepting the panel’s offer to update them corrupts that data. Wizards help with imports and new families, and the developer says it has been tested with trees of more than 500 people. There is no backup command: your records and pictures are ordinary files in the vault, so you copy that folder yourself. FAQ, evidence and sources
The maintenance record is the main limit. Between April and early June 2026 the maintainer found and fixed four bugs that could lose or scramble data, including one that wiped fact-level sources when a person was saved and one that re-paired children’s names with the wrong notes. Each fix came with a repair tool or an automatic correction. Version 1.0 has not been reached. Since the June 26 release there has been no new version, and bug reports filed since then have no reply, including reports that a GEDCOM import garbled accented letters and that dates entered in the family chart went into the wrong fields. That was still so on November 12: the last release and the last code change are dated June 26, and the newest report, a GEDCOM import failing on files with a byte-order mark, was filed the day before. If you try it, import a copy of your GEDCOM file, keep the original and back up the vault regularly. Road to 1.0, issue tracker, import report, chart report
Obsidian runs community plugins only after you switch off its Restricted mode, and it says plugins inherit the app’s access to your files and the internet. It scans each plugin version and rates Charted Roots’ health “Excellent” and its review “Satisfactory”. In April 2026 Elastic Security Labs reported attackers persuading people to open a shared vault and turn on community plugins, which then ran the attackers’ commands; it found no Obsidian vulnerability. Install plugins only from Obsidian’s directory and do not open a vault someone else sends you. Obsidian’s current installer uses Electron 43, which receives upstream security fixes until January 2027; the app updates it only when you reinstall from the download page. Plugin security, Elastic report, Obsidian changelog, Electron support dates
Used Charted Roots? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Gramps
Also consider · free, open format or Linux
Choose Gramps if you want free software, an open file format or Linux support, and you are prepared to spend time learning it.
Reasons to choose it
- Free under the GPL, with no account or activation step
- Each citation carries a confidence level
- XML backups can include media and can run on a timer
What to watch
- Its own community calls the learning curve steep
- Volunteer forum help, not a support desk
- Timed backups leave pictures and documents out
Gramps is free, open-source software from the volunteer Gramps Development Team, licensed under GPL-2.0-or-later. The current release is 6.0.8, from April 9, 2026; version 6.1 is in beta. The project offers a 64-bit installer for Windows 8, 10 and 11, Intel and Apple silicon Mac packages, and recommends Flatpak or Snap packages on Linux. Its download instructions involve no account or activation. An app named Gramps on Apple’s App Store is not affiliated with the project. Download page, 6.0.8 release, project metadata
Gramps keeps sources, citations, repositories and notes as separate records, and each citation carries a page or volume reference, a date and a confidence level from very low to very high. That suits the conflicting-date example: both citations can stay attached with different confidence. The cost is effort. A long-time Gramps user on the project’s forum wrote in March 2025 that people new to genealogy “should probably start with one of the commercial packages”, and a member of the forum’s staff acknowledged a “very steep learning curve for novices” after Computeractive called Gramps free but complicated. Other users say they managed the basics without reading the manual. Citation editor, forum thread, Computeractive discussion
Read the full Gramps analysis and sources
Its backup routine is the most complete of the programs here. Make Backup writes a Gramps XML file to a folder you choose; media is excluded by default but can be included. Gramps can also back up the open tree when you exit, or on a timer from every 15 minutes to once a day, although those automatic backups leave media out. The manual recommends an unfiltered XML export copied somewhere else, “preferably in a different building”, rather than copying the database folder. Manage Family Trees manual
The XML format is published as a schema with separate records for people, families, events, citations, sources, repositories, media and notes, and Gramps also imports and exports GEDCOM. A documented format makes later moves easier, but no exchange format guarantees that another program will keep every field. Schema, command manual
Some features depend on optional components. The README says the geography view needs a mapping library, some reports need Graphviz, and third-party addons are not part of the official core. Help comes from volunteers and the forum, not a support desk. Maintenance releases have arrived every few months, from 6.0.5 in September 2025 to 6.0.8 in April 2026. README, releases
The licence permits use and modification under its terms and disclaims warranty; it gives no right to publish documents or information about other people. We did not find a complete statement of the desktop program’s network behavior, so do not read its local storage as a guarantee that nothing is ever transmitted. License
Used Gramps? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Ancestris
Evaluated · free, tree kept as a GEDCOM file
Ancestris suits someone who wants a free program on Windows, Mac or Linux that stores the tree itself as a GEDCOM file, and who is willing to install Java and learn GEDCOM-style entry.
Reasons to choose it
- Free, with no account; version 13 stable since December 2025
- Your tree is a GEDCOM file other programs can read
- Citations carry page and a 0 to 3 quality rating
What to watch
- Java must be installed separately
- Connects anonymously to its own server at start and close
- Volunteer forum support; no independent reports read
Ancestris is free genealogy software from a volunteer association. Its site says the software is 28 years old; version 13 has been the stable release since December 2025, with a daily-updated version 14 alongside. It runs on Windows, Mac and Linux but needs Java installed separately, and its guide says most start-up problems come from the Java installation. No account is needed; a forum login is only for support. Home and downloads, installation guide, privacy policy
Its distinctive choice is the file. Ancestris stores your tree only in GEDCOM files in folders you choose, so other genealogy programs can open the same file. Sources sit inside repositories, and each citation can carry the page and a quality rating from 0 to 3, the GEDCOM standard’s scale. A research notepad replaces loose notes. “Save as” makes a full or filtered copy, optionally with media files and encryption; we found no scheduled backup in the pages we read. Documenting sources, research notepad, Save as
Read the full Ancestris analysis and sources
Its privacy policy says it connects to the Ancestris server at start-up and on closing, storing only anonymous connection information for traffic statistics. It also checks for updates and uses OpenStreetMap and GeoNames for maps and place names, and an optional comparison feature shares overlapping names, dates and places with another user only when you choose. Entry follows the GEDCOM structure closely; the guide advises creating a repository before its source. We read no independent reports on how easy it is to learn. It scored 3.65 on our weights, third overall, without a label: free, with an open file, but held back by the Java setup and its learning demands. Privacy policy, documenting sources
Used Ancestris? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Heredis
Evaluated · guided entry on Windows or Mac
Heredis suits someone who wants guided, form-based entry from a long-established company and works on one kind of computer, since Windows and Mac licences are sold separately.
Reasons to choose it
- Repositories, sources and citations, with a quality level for each source
- “Save a copy” keeps the data and its media together
- Free demo for trees of up to 50 people
What to watch
- Separate purchases for Windows and Mac; licence activation online
- AI reading assistant needs paid credits
- No independent reports read; refund terms not established
Heredis 2027 comes from Heredis, an employee-owned French company in Montpellier that has made the program since 1994 and releases a new version each year. The Windows edition costs $39.99 and the Mac edition $69.99, as separate purchases. The Windows licence covers one user on up to three Windows 10 or 11 computers and needs an internet connection to activate; the Mac licence has the same terms for up to three Macs running macOS 14 or later and is sold in English, German and Spanish only. A free demo is limited to 50 people. Home and prices, Windows edition, Mac edition, company
Heredis records repositories, sources and citations, and lets you set a level of certainty or quality for each source. One event can be shared by everyone named in a record such as a census, witnesses can be added, and a research journal keeps track of what you meant to search next. It imports and exports GEDCOM and can import GEDCOM 7. Version 2027 adds an AI reading assistant that transcribes records; it needs purchased credits, and Heredis says it uses an AI service developed in France. Feature list, new features
Read the full Heredis analysis and sources
“Save a copy” creates a new folder holding your data and its media, and Heredis can sync the file to a USB drive. Timed automatic saves overwrite the working file and are not backups, and Heredis warns against running a file from a cloud-synced folder. Those help pages were last updated in 2021 and 2022. We found no refund terms and no independent reports on the 2027 version. It scored 3.63, fourth overall, without a label: separate licences for each system and online activation hold it back for a reader who may change computers. Saving a copy, recording a file
Used Heredis? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Which product are we missing?
Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.
Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.
Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.
No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.
What people are saying
User reports show how people experience these programs, not how often problems occur. RootsMagic’s community forum filled with version 12 reports in its first week. Several threads described “access violation” errors when adding a child or spouse, and staff at first could not reproduce them reliably; after the October 15 update, users in those threads reported that the errors had stopped. Experienced users also debated the new source workflow, especially citation names that are no longer rebuilt automatically. One said 12.1.1 made it work “almost” as before. Access violation thread, adding children, sources and citations
Gramps users on the project’s forum describe the reverse trade-off: a steep start, followed by flexibility that long-term users value for large, carefully sourced trees. Some people who tried it on Windows gave up on setup or appearance. Forum thread
Moving between programs is a recurring concern. A June 2025 Gramps discussion describes citations arriving in an unwanted field after a FamilySearch-to-RootsMagic-to-Gramps transfer, and an older RootsMagic discussion raises similar exchange questions. A Family Historian trial user, in a thread we read on September 6, 2026, liked the program but could not find a spreadsheet census import. We found no independent reports on Family Historian 8 yet; its main user forum did not load for our automated check. None of these accounts establishes a failure rate. Gramps transfer discussion, RootsMagic exchange discussion, Family Historian trial user
We found no independent reviews of Charted Roots, Ancestris or Heredis 2027 when we added them on October 20, 2026. Charted Roots’ issue tracker holds the unanswered bug reports described in its section, and a TreeMonk user’s round-trip test in August 2026 showed its GEDCOM export leaving out every source and citation until version 1.10.0 fixed it. Charted Roots issues, TreeMonk export report
How we researched
This is public-source research. We did not install these programs, create accounts, buy licences, enter family information, or test backups, restores, imports or exports. No vendor supplied access or payment for this work. We first compared these programs on September 6, 2026 and rechecked every material claim on October 19, 2026. Two of the first three had released new major versions in between, RootsMagic 12 on October 8 and Family Historian 8 on October 5, so we replaced claims about the earlier versions with current documentation. Gramps’ manual, which our tools could not read in September, was readable this time, so we could check its backup and citation features directly. On October 20, 2026 we searched again for newer programs and scored more established ones under the same weights. On November 12, 2026 we read prices, release records and maintenance pages again and searched for newcomers once more.
We first chose three programs for one adult keeping sourced family records on a home computer: a widely used commercial program for Windows and Mac, an open-source program for all three desktop systems, and a Windows program known for source-driven entry. We judged them on how well they record evidence and doubt, ease of everyday entry, control over backups and what leaves the computer, platform and setup, cost and licence terms, and continuity and support. We fixed those criteria and their weights before comparing the programs. Giving no weight to ease of learning and more to file control favors Gramps; giving more weight to release stability does not change our Pick, because RootsMagic and Gramps score alike there. For cost, we priced every program that fits this job for one person on a Windows computer over three years, using the cheapest edition that covers sourced records and the features we scored. We scored RootsMagic as its $39.95 full edition, because the research logs and media backups we credited are full-edition features; its free Essentials edition would price at nothing but lacks them, and counting it instead does not change our Pick. The free editions of Family Historian and Ancestral Quest do not count, because their pages do not show that they cover everything this job needs, and neither does Heredis’s 50-person demo. Ancestris (3.65) and Heredis (3.63) placed third and fourth overall, so they join the chart without a label; each program below them has a paragraph of its own further down. These scores rest mainly on vendor pages and carry low confidence. We did not evaluate some smaller programs, such as Brother’s Keeper and Ahnenblatt. Online-tree services remain outside this comparison.
On October 20, 2026 we searched for newer programs through GitHub, Obsidian’s plugin directory, Product Hunt, FamilySearch’s list of GEDCOM 7 adopters and recent coverage, and on November 12 through GitHub and Hacker News. We tested each against our Rising Star conditions: a first release within the past two years from a maker not already established in genealogy software, available now on both Windows and Mac, documented to keep sourced records, and no unresolved safety problem. Two qualified. Charted Roots scored 3.55 and TreeMonk 3.50. Charted Roots won on its evidence tools and its Windows and Mac support through Obsidian, by less than one point on our heaviest criterion. Others fell short: Swarm runs only on Macs, Cognatio only on Windows and Linux, Dóru’s maker calls its Windows build experimental, DreViGen and Vitni have no release for Windows or Mac, Family Weaver and Genea do not document source records, and several new family-tree apps keep records on their makers’ servers or need you to run a server. We did not read the page of Heirloom, a newer program described as a local-first genealogy app with source records, so we cannot say whether it qualifies. Our October 19 adverse search covered breaches, lawsuits, acquisitions, security advisories and recent user reports for each program and company and found nothing beyond the version 12 launch problems described above. On October 20 we checked Charted Roots, TreeMonk, Ancestris and Heredis for published advisories and recent issue reports, and on November 12 we checked Charted Roots and TreeMonk again; we found none beyond those described here. A search that finds nothing is not proof that nothing exists.
TreeMonk is a free desktop program for noncommercial use, first released in summer 2026 by a single developer, and it scored 3.50: eligible for our Rising Star, but narrowly behind Charted Roots. Its maker documents sources with page and transcription, citations with quality ratings and a research log; version 1.10.8, released on November 7, 2026, added a GEDCOM package that carries pictures and moved the program to Electron 43, which still receives security fixes. Windows users can install it from the Microsoft Store. The Mac version is an Apple-silicon download that Apple has not notarized, and the project’s README says no official Mac build is published. A user’s round-trip test in August 2026 showed its GEDCOM export leaving out every source and citation until version 1.10.0 fixed it. TreeMonk site, releases, repository, export report
Family Historian 8 from Calico Pie Limited, a UK company, was released on October 5, 2026 and scored 3.37. It suits a Windows user who likes to enter several facts from one document and edit through diagrams: source-driven entry, source templates, a citation assessment field, facts flagged tentative, preferred or rejected, witnesses and, new in version 8, non-family relationships. It runs only on 64-bit Windows 10 or 11 and has no Mac version. As displayed on November 12, a perpetual version 8 licence costs $69.95 for two installations on devices you own, and a subscription costs $6.95 a month or $32.15 a year, renews automatically and always includes the latest version. If a subscription lapses you can still edit in the free edition, which its page describes as having basic features only. Even the free trial needs an online account. The licence agreement Calico Pie publishes is still the version 7 text, which requires activation within your account, lets the program contact Calico Pie’s servers and ends activated licences if you ask Calico Pie to delete your account. Optional record matching sends names, dates and places to Findmypast or MyHeritage, and the optional AI Connector lets an outside AI assistant read your project and, if you allow it, change it. Even a full backup leaves out pictures and documents linked from outside the project folder; a GEDZIP export with media includes every linked file. The store does not refund a perpetual licence or subscription once the key is emailed, except in narrow technical cases within 21 days, so use the 30-day trial first. We found no independent reports on version 8. Notice board, pricing, perpetual licence, free edition, system requirements, feature list, free trial, licence agreement, backup help, AI Connector help, store terms, privacy policy
Family Tree Maker 2024 from Software MacKiev runs on Windows and Mac; its US store showed $80 for the download on November 12, 2026, plus $20 for a Family Pack that covers three computers in your home. Family Tree magazine’s review of the 2024 PC version (September 22, 2025) listed £80 and no free trial. It scored 3.43, below TreeMonk. US store, Family Tree magazine review
My Family Tree from Chronoplex Software is a Windows-only genealogy program. We could not find its price on the page we read, so it has no cost score and no total this time. My Family Tree
Ancestral Quest 16 from Incline Software costs $34.95 as a Windows download on its order page (the Mac edition was $44.95 when we checked in October), and a free Ancestral Quest Basics edition exists. It scored 3.28. Order page
GEDKeeper is free on Windows and Linux and has no Mac version; its latest releases, 3.15.0 and 2.39.0, are dated May 14, 2026. It scored 3.28. GEDKeeper
Legacy Family Tree 10 is free and runs only on Windows (Mac and Linux readers need a Windows emulator); its current version, 10.0.0.271, is dated October 30, 2025. It scored 3.23. Download page
Family Tree Builder is MyHeritage’s free program, built around MyHeritage’s online matching; the download page we read does not state its platforms. It scored 3.15. Family Tree Builder
MacFamilyTree 11 from Synium Software runs only on a Mac, so it falls outside our Windows-computer cost comparison; on our October 20 weights it scored 3.18, below our top four. MacFamilyTree
Reunion 14 from Leister Productions also runs only on a Mac and falls outside the cost comparison; on our October 20 weights it scored 3.05. Reunion
Centurial, an evidence-based Windows program, is excluded because its last release was in February 2022 and its maker put development on hold. Centurial release history
| Tool | Public sources | What remains uncertain |
|---|---|---|
| RootsMagic | Version 12 feature list, purchase and returns pages, backup, export, registration and AI prompt help, update notes, blog posts, privacy policy, community threads. | How many computers one key covers, the full licence text, the notes for updates after 12.1.1, and whether version 12 settles down. |
| Gramps | Download page, 6.0 manual on backups, citations and preferences, release records, schema, README, licence, forum threads. | Full network behavior, minimum Mac version, and how hard a given reader will find the interface. |
| Family Historian | Version 8 announcement, pricing and product pages, system requirements, trial page, backup, GEDCOM and AI Connector help, licence agreement, store terms and privacy policy. | The version 8 licence text, whether the annual price is introductory, tax at checkout and independent reports on version 8. |
| Charted Roots | Obsidian directory listing, repository, release and discussion pages, help on evidence, import and export, privacy and common questions, issue tracker; Obsidian’s licence, download, plugin-security and changelog pages; Elastic Security Labs report. | Whether maintenance resumes, how it copes with a large tree, and independent reviews, which we did not find. |
| Ancestris | Home and download page, installation guide, pages on sources, research notepad, Save as and privacy. | Licence text, any scheduled backup, and how hard a given reader will find it. |
| Heredis | Home and price page, Windows and Mac edition terms, feature list, new-features page, help on saving and recording, company page. | Refunds, what the AI service keeps, and independent reports on version 2027. |
None of this establishes that a backup restores correctly, that a transfer keeps every citation, or that any program is secure in use. Next substantive review is due December 18, 2026, or sooner if a material term changes. Found a changed price or term? Contact the editors.
Sources and evidence
Sources were checked October 19, 2026 unless another date is given; prices and release records for RootsMagic, Family Historian, Heredis and the programs below them, and the release and maintenance pages of Charted Roots and TreeMonk, were read again on November 12, 2026. Vendor and project documentation establishes documented features and terms, not successful operation. Forum and community posts are attributed experiences, not representative samples.
- RootsMagic, version 12: feature list; purchase; what’s new and help version; backup; GEDCOM export; registration; AI Prompt Builder; returns; privacy; blog posts on the version 12 release, October 8, 2026 and the Ancestry interface change, May 5, 2026; update notes for 12.1.0, October 15 and 12.1.1, October 16.
- Gramps: download, page edited June 14, 2026; 6.0 manual on managing family trees and backups, citations and preferences; 6.0.8 release and release list; metadata; command manual; schema; README; license.
- Family Historian, version 8: notice board; what’s new; pricing; perpetual licence; subscriptions, monthly and annual; free edition; system requirements; free trial; feature list; help on backups, uncertain data, GEDCOM and the AI Connector; licence agreement, version 7 text; store terms; privacy.
- Charted Roots, checked October 20, 2026: Obsidian directory listing; repository; help pages on evidence and sources, edited May 2, 2026, import and export, edited June 15, 2026, privacy and security, edited June 19, 2026 and the FAQ, edited June 1, 2026; the maintainer’s Road to 1.0 announcement, April 21, 2026, updated to June 2; issue tracker, including reports 787 and 803; security advisories, none published. Obsidian: licence overview, updated February 20, 2025, terms of service, download, version 1.14.4, plugin security and changelog; Electron’s support schedule; Elastic Security Labs, Obsidian plugin abuse, April 14, 2026.
- Ancestris, checked October 20, 2026: home and downloads; user guide on installation, documenting sources, the research notepad, Save as and privacy.
- Heredis, checked October 20, 2026: home and prices; Windows edition and its conditions; company; feature list; new features in 2027; help on saving a copy, updated June 14, 2022 and recording a file, updated August 18, 2021.
- Other established programs scored October 20, 2026: Family Tree Maker and Family Tree magazine’s review of the 2024 PC version, September 22, 2025; My Family Tree; Ancestral Quest order page; GEDKeeper; Legacy Family Tree download; MacFamilyTree and its buying page; Family Tree Builder; Reunion; Centurial release history.
- Newer programs screened October 20, 2026: TreeMonk repository, releases, website and export report; GitHub’s genealogy-software topic (including Swarm); Cognatio; Dóru; DreViGen; Vitni; Family Weaver; Genea; FamilySearch’s GEDCOM 7 implementation list.
- Read November 12, 2026: RootsMagic purchase page, edition feature list, privacy policy and a forum thread on version 12.1.3.0; Family Historian monthly subscription, annual subscription, free edition and licence agreement; Heredis Mac edition; Gramps release list; Charted Roots releases, commits, issues, security advisories, none published and Electron’s support schedule; TreeMonk site, releases and issues; Family Tree Maker US store, Ancestral Quest order page, GEDKeeper, Legacy download page; newcomer checks on Dóru, Swarm, Vitni, DreViGen, GitHub’s genealogy topic and Hacker News searches for genealogy and family tree app.
- Community evidence: RootsMagic forum threads on access violations, adding children and sources and citations, October 2026; Gramps forum threads on starting with Gramps, March 2025 and Computeractive’s description, December 2024. Read September 6, 2026: Gramps transfer discussion, June 2025; RootsMagic exchange discussion, February 2023; Family Historian trial user, November 2024.
This is a researched comparison, not a product review. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.