Desktop book readers for highlights you can use later: Zotero, calibre, Readest and yh-InkLight
Zotero gets your highlights and notes out of the reader most reliably, and it is free. calibre has the better reading tools, but a heavier 2026 security record.
Zotero
EPUBs and PDFs in one free reader. Highlights and comments become notes that link back to each passage and export as Markdown; PDFs export with annotations embedded.
A research library first, with plainer reading controls; EPUB notes stay in its database until you export them. Its lead over calibre is less than one scoring step.
Why Zotero is our PickTeam behind Zotero? Get your award badge
Readest
A free, open-source reader first released in November 2024. It reads EPUBs and PDFs on Windows, macOS and Linux, and exports a book’s highlights and notes as Markdown, plain text or re-importable JSON, with links back to each passage.
It published 13 security advisories in 2026, three of them critical and all fixed by version 0.12.10, and signing in uploads your book files to its cloud unless you turn that off.
Why Readest earned Rising StarWho is this article for? People reading their own DRM-free EPUBs, and some PDFs, on a computer who need to find passages again and keep highlights and notes they can use outside the reader.
About 31 min read
What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean
The quick list
All four are free for reading your own files. Compare how each gets highlights and notes out of the app, where it keeps them and its 2026 security record.
All four readers cost nothing to read legitimately owned, DRM-free files, checked November 12, 2026. Optional costs: Zotero file storage beyond 300 MB from US$20 a year; Readest sync beyond 500 MB, or through your own storage, from US$4.99 a month or a US$19.99 one-time unlock; yh-InkLight needs the Obsidian app, which is free for personal use. Prices exclude tax and are not checkouts.
The comparison at a glance
Compare how each reader gets highlights and notes out, which files it reads, what it costs and its 2026 security record.
Order follows our verdict for keeping usable notes from books you own, not measured reading quality. All tools remain selectable.
Hides matching answers for the selected tools. Unknowns and unverified claims stay visible.
| Feature | Zotero | calibre viewer | Readest | yh-InkLight |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: EPUB and PDF reading whose highlights become notes you can export | Also consider: an EPUB library where reading tools matter most | Rising Star: EPUB and PDF reading with a Markdown note file per book, on desktop and phone | EPUB, PDF and Markdown reading inside Obsidian, with notes kept as Markdown in your vault |
| Cost to read your own files, checked November 12, 2026 | Free; optional file storage from US$20 a year | Free | Free; Readest Cloud sync free up to 500 MB; syncing through your own storage needs Plus (US$4.99 a month) or a US$19.99 one-time unlock | Free; needs the Obsidian app, which is free for personal use |
| Desktop platforms | Windows, macOS, Linux | Windows, macOS, Linux | Windows, macOS, Linux; also iPhone, Android and web | Windows, macOS, Linux through Obsidian 1.7.2 or later; phone use not yet tested on real devices |
| Getting notes out | Build a note from a book’s annotations, then export it as Markdown with links back; PDFs export with annotations embedded | Plain text, Markdown or HTML for one book or the whole library; a calibre highlights file from the viewer | Markdown, plain text or re-importable JSON for one book, with links back to each passage and custom templates; Readwise and Notion export | Markdown summaries and generated reading notes in your vault, each with a link back to the passage; annotations also kept as sidecar JSON files |
| 2026 security record | No Zotero advisories found; Firefox ESR platform updated in each release | 29 advisories, two critical; several triggered by opening or importing a crafted book; those published through September fixed by 9.15, nine more since in the Content server and conversion code | 13 advisories, three critical, most published October 15; crafted-EPUB and crafted-PDF code execution fixed in 0.11.16 and 0.12.6; all fixed by 0.12.10 | No advisories found in what we read; its repository security page was not read |
| What to watch | EPUB notes cannot be written into the EPUB file; export is a two-step job | No in-app PDF annotation; heavy 2026 security fixing; optional AI features divided users | Heavy 2026 security fixing; book files upload by default once you sign in; before version 1.0 | Needs Obsidian; installed through BRAT or by hand until the Community directory approves it; one developer; phone use still untested |
Desktop reading of legitimately owned, DRM-free EPUB and PDF files. Public-source research checked October 19, 2026, and October 20 for Readest, with prices, current releases and security advisories rechecked November 12, 2026: we did not install, open books in, or export from any of these applications. Zotero ranks first under criteria and weights fixed before scoring, by a narrow margin; calibre draws level if reading tools count for more and maintenance for less. Readest is our Rising Star, the highest-scoring newer reader, by a narrow margin over the next newcomer. Keep your original book files and an exported copy of your notes outside any reader. Next substantive review: December 18, 2026.
All features and sources 14 criteria
Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.
Reading and finding passages
Show 5 criteria
| Feature | Zotero | calibre viewer | Readest | yh-InkLight |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: EPUB and PDF reading whose highlights become notes you can export | Also consider: an EPUB library where reading tools matter most | Rising Star: EPUB and PDF reading with a Markdown note file per book, on desktop and phone | EPUB, PDF and Markdown reading inside Obsidian, with notes kept as Markdown in your vault |
| Files it reads | EPUB, PDF and saved web pages | EPUB and other e-book formats; built for e-books, not PDFs | EPUB, PDF, MOBI/AZW3, FB2, CBZ and TXT | EPUB, PDF and Markdown files in your Obsidian vault |
| Highlights and notes | EPUB highlights and underlines with comments; more annotation types in PDFs | Highlights in several styles with attached notes | Highlights, underlines and notes in EPUBs and PDFs; excerpts and drawing | Highlights with comments, tags and colours in EPUBs, PDFs and Markdown; PDF highlights as overlays |
| Finding passages again | Annotation sidebar; Zotero 10 searches annotation text across your library | Search including regex and nearby words; paragraph reference numbers; library-wide annotation browser | Search by text, whole words, regular expression or nearby words; contents with your current position; per-book notebook | Search inside an EPUB; one annotation sidebar you can search and filter by colour, type and tag; reading library with progress |
| Desktop platforms | Windows, macOS, Linux | Windows, macOS, Linux | Windows, macOS, Linux; also iPhone, Android and web | Windows, macOS, Linux through Obsidian 1.7.2 or later; phone use not yet tested on real devices |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for reading and finding passages
Checked October 19, 2026 (Readest October 20; current releases November 12): Zotero EPUB support, Zotero 10 and downloads; calibre viewer manual and downloads; Readest, checked October 20, overview and reading guide; yh-InkLight, checked November 12, yh-InkLight plugin page and Obsidian pricing. Format support does not prove that a particular book renders well.
Getting your notes out
Show 3 criteria
| Feature | Zotero | calibre viewer | Readest | yh-InkLight |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Getting notes out | Build a note from a book’s annotations, then export it as Markdown with links back; PDFs export with annotations embedded | Plain text, Markdown or HTML for one book or the whole library; a calibre highlights file from the viewer | Markdown, plain text or re-importable JSON for one book, with links back to each passage and custom templates; Readwise and Notion export | Markdown summaries and generated reading notes in your vault, each with a link back to the passage; annotations also kept as sidecar JSON files |
| Bringing notes back in | Annotations stay in the Zotero database; PDF annotations can travel inside the PDF | No annotation import documented in the manual | Its own JSON export imports back into a book; imports from Moon+ Reader and ReadEra | Sidecar JSON files stay in your vault; no import from other readers documented |
| Moving between computers | Optional sync; 300 MB of file storage free, more paid, or your own WebDAV | Annotation sync with a calibre Content server you configure | Readest Cloud, 500 MB free; WebDAV, Google Drive, OneDrive, iCloud or S3 only with a paid plan or unlock | Whatever moves your vault between devices; the plugin has no sync service or account of its own |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for getting your notes out
Zotero Markdown note export, reader and annotation storage and storage plans; calibre export formats in its source code, HTML export in 9.11 and viewer manual; Readest note export, sync and pricing, checked October 20; yh-InkLight, checked November 12, yh-InkLight plugin page. These are documented routes, not exports we ran.
Cost, privacy and risk
Show 6 criteria
| Feature | Zotero | calibre viewer | Readest | yh-InkLight |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cost to read your own files, checked November 12, 2026 | Free; optional file storage from US$20 a year | Free | Free; Readest Cloud sync free up to 500 MB; syncing through your own storage needs Plus (US$4.99 a month) or a US$19.99 one-time unlock | Free; needs the Obsidian app, which is free for personal use |
| Published data practices | Works without an account; sync is optional and off by default; Read Aloud sends text to Zotero or, for Premium voices, Inworld AI or Google | The app uses no statistics service; EPUB bookmarks are written into the book file by default | Works without an account; signing in turns on Readest Cloud, which uploads imported book files by default; privacy policy (June 6, 2025) does not describe that cloud | No account or subscription; annotations stay in your vault; layout settings and cover images are cached on the device; no outside service |
| 2026 security record | No Zotero advisories found; Firefox ESR platform updated in each release | 29 advisories, two critical; several triggered by opening or importing a crafted book; those published through September fixed by 9.15, nine more since in the Content server and conversion code | 13 advisories, three critical, most published October 15; crafted-EPUB and crafted-PDF code execution fixed in 0.11.16 and 0.12.6; all fixed by 0.12.10 | No advisories found in what we read; its repository security page was not read |
| Who makes it | Digital Scholar, a nonprofit; open source (AGPL) | Kovid Goyal and contributors; open source (GPL) | Bilingify LLC; open source (AGPL) | One developer (angelwdx); open source (MIT); runs inside Obsidian |
| Current release, checked November 12, 2026 | 10.0.9, November 10, 2026 | 9.18, November 6, 2026 | 0.12.20, November 5, 2026 | 0.23.8, as listed on the obsidianstats.com plugin page on November 12, 2026 |
| What to watch | EPUB notes cannot be written into the EPUB file; export is a two-step job | No in-app PDF annotation; heavy 2026 security fixing; optional AI features divided users | Heavy 2026 security fixing; book files upload by default once you sign in; before version 1.0 | Needs Obsidian; installed through BRAT or by hand until the Community directory approves it; one developer; phone use still untested |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for cost, privacy and risk
Zotero privacy and changelog; calibre privacy, security advisories and release notes; Readest privacy policy, sync, security advisories, releases and App Store seller listing, checked October 20; yh-InkLight, checked November 12, yh-InkLight plugin page and Obsidian pricing; Zotero storage plans, calibre release notes and advisories and Readest pricing and releases were checked again on November 12, 2026. Prices are published US-dollar offers, not checkouts. Advisory counts are the projects’ own published advisories.
What matters when choosing
Zotero is our Practical Pick for reading your own DRM-free EPUBs and PDFs on a computer when the highlights and notes need to end up somewhere else, such as your writing or a notes app. It is free on Windows, macOS and Linux, opens EPUBs and PDFs in the same reader, and turns a book’s highlights and comments into a note that keeps a link back to each passage. That note exports as Markdown, and a PDF can be exported with its annotations written into the file, where other PDF readers can see them. It works without an account, and sync is off until you turn it on. Its maker is a nonprofit, and we found no security advisories for Zotero itself in 2026. Of the two leading readers, it is the only one that also gets PDF notes out. Its lead is narrow, though: under criteria and weights we fixed before scoring, Zotero finished 0.225 points ahead of calibre on a five-point scale, less than one full point on our heaviest criterion, and the Markdown export it relies on is described in a 2021 announcement by Zotero’s team rather than in its current user guide. Zotero 7 EPUB support, Markdown note export, reader and annotation storage, privacy
The most important compromise is that Zotero is a research library first and a book reader second. Your annotations live in Zotero’s database, not in the EPUB, and getting them out is two steps: create a note from a book’s annotations, then export the note. You cannot write EPUB highlights back into the EPUB file. If you only want to read novels comfortably, its reading controls are plainer than calibre’s or Thorium’s.
Readest is our Rising Star for readers who also read on a phone and want each book’s notes as a Markdown file. First released in November 2024, it is a free, open-source reader for Windows, macOS and Linux, with phone apps, that reads EPUBs and PDFs in one place and, according to its documentation, exports a book’s highlights and notes as Markdown, plain text or JSON it can import again, each with a link back to the passage. It scored highest of the newer readers we found, though only narrowly ahead of the next. Its limits are a heavy 2026 security record, 13 advisories with three rated critical, all fixed by version 0.12.10, and a cloud that uploads your book files by default once you sign in. Note export, security advisories, sync
Also consider the calibre viewer if your books already live in a calibre library and reading tools matter most to you. It has the strongest search and navigation here, and it exports highlights and notes for one book or a whole library as plain text, Markdown or a standalone HTML page. It finished second, and most of the gap comes from calibre’s 2026 security record: 29 published advisories, several of which could be triggered by opening or importing a crafted book. Those published through September were fixed by version 9.15, and nine more followed in October and November, mostly in the Content server and format conversion that reading does not use. Install the current 9.18, because some Linux distribution packages still lag. If you give reading tools more weight and maintenance less, calibre draws level or moves ahead. calibre does not annotate PDFs in its own viewer. Disclosure: Practical Picks articles are researched and written with AI, currently Anthropic’s Claude. calibre 9.14 added Claude among its optional AI back ends. We have no relationship with the calibre project or with Anthropic over this product, and AI features carried no weight in our judgment. calibre release notes
yh-InkLight is the fourth reader in our top four, for people who already keep their notes in Obsidian. It is a free, open-source plugin that reads EPUBs and PDFs inside Obsidian and keeps your highlights as Markdown summaries and plain files in your vault, with links back to each passage. Its limits are that it needs Obsidian, one developer maintains it, and we could not read a security record for it. yh-InkLight plugin page
These are researched judgments from documentation, release records, security advisories and public reports checked October 19, 2026, and October 20 for Readest; prices, current releases and advisory counts were checked again on November 12. We did not install any reader, open a book in it or run an export. Two conditions would change our recommendation: books kept in a calibre library and read for long stretches (choose calibre), or notes you already keep in Obsidian (consider yh-InkLight). Whichever you choose, keep your original book files outside the reader, and export your notes at least once before you depend on them, then open the export in another app to check that each note says where it came from.
Zotero
Preferred Pick · notes that leave the reader
Choose Zotero when your highlights and notes need to end up in your writing or another app. Build a note from each book’s annotations and export it as Markdown; export PDFs with their annotations embedded.
Reasons to choose it
- EPUBs and PDFs in one reader, free on Windows, macOS and Linux
- Annotations become notes with links back, exportable as Markdown
- No account needed; sync is off by default
What to watch
- EPUB highlights cannot be written into the EPUB file
- Getting notes out takes two steps
- A research library first, with plainer reading controls
Zotero is a free, open-source research library from Digital Scholar, a nonprofit. Since Zotero 7 in August 2024, EPUBs open in its built-in reader alongside PDFs, and you can highlight, underline and add comments to passages, then add those annotations to a note “just as you’ve been able to for PDFs”. Version 10.0.9, released November 10, 2026, is current for Windows, macOS and Linux. You can use it without an account; the privacy policy says syncing is optional and disabled by default. Read Aloud is the exception to keeping text local: standard voices are processed on Zotero’s servers, and Premium voices send the document text to Inworld AI or Google, per the policy updated May 18, 2026. Zotero 7 announcement, changelog, downloads, privacy
Its useful difference is the route out. A note built from a book’s annotations carries each highlighted passage, your comment and a link back to its place in the book, and Zotero has exported notes as Markdown without plugins since a feature its team announced in December 2021. That announcement lists limits: embedded images are left out, and some links point to a page rather than to the exact annotation. For PDFs there is a second route: Zotero stores annotations in its database, and exporting a PDF writes them into the file so another PDF reader can see them. Its strongest reason not to choose it is the same database: EPUB annotations cannot be written into the EPUB, so the note export is your copy. Markdown note export announcement, annotations in the database
Read the full Zotero analysis and sources
Zotero 10, released August 17, 2026, added searches across annotation text, colour and type, and more precise return to your place in an EPUB after you close it. Annotations appear in a sidebar beside the book. Zotero is built for collecting and citing sources, so expect a library window full of research features you may never use, and fewer typography and page-layout controls than a dedicated e-book reader. Zotero 10 announcement, changelog
Local use costs nothing. If you sync attachment files through Zotero, 300 MB is free; annual plans are US$20 for 2 GB, US$60 for 6 GB and US$120 for unlimited storage, checked November 12, 2026. You can sync files through your own WebDAV server instead. Notes sync with your library data and do not count against file storage. Storage plans, notes
We found no security advisories for Zotero’s own code in 2026. Zotero runs on Mozilla’s Firefox platform, and its release notes regularly record security updates to that platform, in 10.0.6, and 10.0.7 and 10.0.8 list further security fixes to a certificate list and to how plugins register protocol handlers. Plugins are separate software from separate developers; judge any plugin on its own record. Zotero also appears in our reference manager comparison, which covers citations rather than reading. Changelog, GitHub security page
Used Zotero? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
calibre viewer
Also consider · reading tools come first
Choose the calibre viewer if your books live in a calibre library and search and navigation matter most. Install calibre’s own current build, not an older distribution package.
Reasons to choose it
- The strongest search and passage navigation here
- Exports notes for one book or a whole library as text, Markdown or HTML
- The app uses no statistics service
What to watch
- 29 security advisories in 2026, two critical; the nine since October are in the Content server and conversion code
- Built for e-books, not PDF annotation
- Writes EPUB bookmarks into the book file by default
calibre is a free, open-source e-book library for Windows, macOS and Linux, and its viewer is the most capable reading tool here for finding passages again. Its manual documents four search modes, including regular expressions and words near each other; a reference mode that numbers every paragraph so you can cite and return to it; highlights in several styles with attached notes; a chapter-sorted highlights panel; and a browser that lists annotations across your whole library. Version 9.18, released November 6, 2026, is current. Viewer manual, release notes, downloads
Its export is among the most direct here. From the viewer or the library-wide annotations browser you can export plain text, Markdown or, since 9.11 in July 2026, a standalone HTML page with search and filtering; the viewer also saves a calibre highlights file. Its strongest reason not to choose it is the 2026 security record. calibre published 29 security advisories between February and November 2026, two rated critical. Several could be triggered by opening or importing a crafted book, including one that ran code from book metadata (CVE-2026-53511, fixed in 9.10) and a viewer flaw that let a book contact outside addresses (CVE-2026-33205, fixed in 9.6). Export formats in calibre’s code, advisory list, CVE-2026-53511, CVE-2026-33205
Read the full calibre viewer analysis and sources
Each advisory names a fixed release, and those published through September are all fixed in 9.15 and later; nine more followed on October 23 and November 6, one rated High (a code-execution flaw that needs a Content server login), and we did not check each one’s fixed version. Install calibre’s own current build rather than an older distribution package: on October 19, Debian’s security tracker still listed its stable package, calibre 8.5, as vulnerable to CVE-2026-53511. Most of the other advisories concern format conversion and the optional Content server, which you do not need for reading. Debian security tracker
calibre is built for e-books, not PDFs. Its viewer manual does not describe PDF reading; community answers from 2022 say the viewer converts a PDF in the background when set to open one, and that calibre otherwise hands PDFs to your system’s PDF reader. If PDF notes matter, use Zotero or a PDF tool. Two more details: for EPUBs, the viewer saves bookmarks inside the book file unless you turn that off, and annotation sync between computers needs a calibre Content server you set up. Viewer manual, MobileRead discussion, August 2022
calibre’s privacy policy says the software uses no statistics service. Since late 2025 it has offered optional AI features, which do nothing until you configure a provider; the December 2025 “Discuss with AI” feature upset some users, and at least two forks with AI removed have appeared. Privacy policy, LWN, December 15, 2025
Used calibre viewer? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Readest
Rising Star · a newcomer worth considering
Why Rising Star? First released in November 2024, Readest scored highest of the newer readers we found for this job: one free, open-source app for EPUBs and PDFs on Windows, macOS and Linux, with per-book exports as Markdown, plain text or re-importable JSON that link back to each passage, according to its documentation. Its heavy 2026 security fixing and its default cloud upload once you sign in are the trade-offs, and its lead over the next newcomer is narrow. This is not our broader Ready to Rock endorsement.
Consider Readest if you also read on a phone or tablet and want each book’s highlights and notes as a Markdown file. Keep it updated, and check its Books sync setting after you sign in if your book files should stay on your own devices.
Reasons to choose it
- Exports a book’s notes as Markdown, plain text or re-importable JSON, with links back
- EPUB and PDF in one free app on Windows, macOS, Linux, iPhone and Android
- Search by regular expression or by words near each other
What to watch
- 13 security advisories in 2026, three critical, all fixed by 0.12.10
- Signing in uploads your book files to its cloud by default
- First released November 2024; still before version 1.0
Readest is a free, open-source reader (AGPL) whose App Store seller is Bilingify LLC. Its first GitHub release, 0.7.9, came in November 2024. It runs on Windows, macOS and Linux, with apps for iPhone, Android and the web, and reads EPUB, PDF, MOBI, AZW3, FB2, CBZ and TXT. Version 0.12.20, released November 5, 2026, is current. Since June 2026 a new version has arrived every one to three weeks, and it is still before version 1.0. Overview, releases, first release, App Store listing
Choose it if you read on a phone as well as a computer and want each book’s notes as a file you can keep. Its guide documents highlights, underlines and notes in EPUBs and PDFs, and export of one book’s annotations as Markdown, plain text or a JSON file that imports back into a book. The Markdown is laid out as a note: chapter headings, each highlight as a quotation, your note beneath it and a link back to the passage. You choose what goes in, and a custom template can change the layout. It can also send highlights to Readwise or Notion. For finding passages again, its search matches plain text, whole words, regular expressions or words near each other. These features come from Readest’s own documentation; we found no recent independent review. Reading and note export
Read the full Readest analysis and sources
Its strongest reason not to choose it is its security record. On October 15, 2026, Readest published most of its 13 security advisories (the count was unchanged on November 12); three are rated critical and eight high. Two matter most for this job: a crafted EPUB could run code on your computer before 0.11.16 (CVE-2026-82642), and a crafted PDF could do the same through the bundled PDF.js library before 0.12.6. Every advisory covers only versions older than 0.12.10, so the current version is not affected; an older copy may be. Keep it updated. Advisories, CVE-2026-82642, PDF advisory
Reading and exporting need no account. Signing in turns on Readest Cloud, 500 MB free, and its sync guide says the Books category, on by default, uploads the books you import; you can switch it off under Manage Sync. Syncing through your own WebDAV, Google Drive, OneDrive, iCloud or S3 storage instead needs a Plus plan at US$4.99 a month or a one-time Full Customization unlock at US$19.99, checked November 12, 2026. That requirement arrived in July 2026, days after WebDAV sync shipped free, and the maintainer said it was intentional. The privacy policy, dated June 6, 2025, says your books and notes stay on your device unless you use optional syncing, but it does not describe Readest Cloud, and neither it nor the terms names a company. Sync guide, pricing, issue 5033, privacy policy, terms
Used Readest? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
yh-InkLight
Top four · notes kept inside Obsidian
Consider yh-InkLight if you already keep your notes in Obsidian and want to read EPUBs and PDFs there, with highlights collected as Markdown notes that link back to the passage. It is installed through BRAT or by hand, and one developer maintains it.
Reasons to choose it
- Reads EPUBs and PDFs and annotates Markdown, PDF and EPUB files in one sidebar
- Highlights and notes are saved as Markdown summaries and plain JSON files in your vault, with links back
- MIT licence; no account, subscription or outside service
What to watch
- Needs Obsidian, and phone use has not been tested on real devices
- Installed through BRAT or by hand; submitted to the Community directory, not yet listed there
- One developer; we did not read its security page
yh-InkLight is a free, open-source (MIT) plugin for Obsidian, the note-taking app, published under the name angelwdx. It reads EPUBs and PDFs, and annotates Markdown, PDF and EPUB files, inside Obsidian. EPUBs open in the engine bundled with the plugin, with paged or scrolling layout, search within the book and control of fonts, spacing and themes; PDF highlights appear as overlays on the page. It needs Obsidian 1.7.2 or later, so it runs on Windows, macOS and Linux wherever Obsidian does. Version 0.23.8 is the latest listed. Its page says it has been submitted to Obsidian’s Community directory and that availability there depends on review, so today you install it through the BRAT plugin or by copying three files by hand. Plugin page, November 12, 2026, source repository
Choose it if you already keep your notes in Obsidian and want your reading marked up there. Highlights can carry comments, tags and colours you set, and one sidebar lists the annotations from Markdown, PDF and EPUB files together, with search and filters by colour, type and tag. The plugin writes Markdown summaries and a reading note for each book into your vault, keeps your own handwritten text outside its managed section, and each exported annotation carries a link that returns you to the passage, PDF page or EPUB location. Highlights are kept in separate JSON files beside your vault’s notes, so the original book or PDF is never changed. Plugin page
Read the full yh-InkLight analysis and sources
Its strongest reasons not to choose it are that it depends on Obsidian and on one developer. Obsidian is free for personal use, and paying for a commercial licence is not required, checked November 12, 2026. Because the highlights stay out of the PDF file, they do not travel inside the PDF to other readers, and we found no import from other readers. The maker says phone use has not yet been checked on real Android and iOS devices. We found no independent review, and we did not read the plugin’s GitHub security page, so we cannot say how it handles vulnerability reports. Obsidian pricing
It needs no account or subscription, and its page says annotation storage does not depend on any outside service; layout settings and cover images are cached on the device. Moving between computers is whatever moves your vault. Back up the .obsidian-annotations folder with your vault, because deleting it deletes the stored highlights. Plugin page
Used yh-InkLight? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Which product are we missing?
Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.
Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.
Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.
No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.
What people are saying
Public discussion is a check on project claims, not a measured reliability score. calibre’s December 2025 AI features drew objections from users on its MobileRead forum; the maintainer said they do nothing unless enabled and will not be removed, and at least two forks stripped them out. A 2022 MobileRead thread explains that calibre converts PDFs for its viewer, which is why users point it to their system PDF reader. LWN, December 15, 2025, MobileRead, August 2022
Zotero users asked for Markdown templates and finer control when the note export was announced. A 2023 to 2024 forum thread about EPUB annotation links ended with a Zotero developer saying the original problem was fixed before Zotero 7 and that a later report involved a third-party plugin’s link format. Thorium’s issue 3053, opened July 2025 and still open, asks to bring annotation import and export together because users confused the menus. Readest users objected in July 2026 when WebDAV and Google Drive sync, shipped free days earlier, moved behind a subscription; the maintainer said the change was intentional and closed the report. An open October 2026 Readest report says a book opened on a newly signed-in device was uploaded although book sync had been switched off on another device; on October 18 the maintainer was still asking for details. A Koodo Reader user asked in 2025 to export PDFs with their highlights; the developer replied that Koodo stores PDF highlights separately from the file. A 2023 Mac discussion about Books opening PDFs outside the app matches Apple’s current documentation. Zotero Markdown export thread, Zotero EPUB links thread, Thorium issue 3053, Readest issue 5033, Readest issue 6881, Koodo Reader issue 1543, Mac discussion, April 2023
Our October 19 search for vulnerabilities, lawsuits, regulator actions, insolvency and shutdowns involving these five readers and their makers found nothing beyond the items in this article that changed our conclusions. An October 20 search for Readest and Bilingify LLC found its security advisories and no lawsuit, breach report or regulator action. A search that finds nothing is not proof that nothing exists.
How we researched
This is public-source research. We did not install any reader, create an account, open a book in an app, make a highlight or run an export. No developer supplied access, payment or input, and we use no affiliate links. We first compared four readers on September 6, 2026, and on October 19, 2026 we rechecked every material claim: releases, prices, export routes, storage, privacy terms, ownership, security advisories and outside reports. On October 20, 2026 we searched again for newer readers and added Readest as our Rising Star. On November 12, 2026 we rechecked prices, current releases and security advisories for the readers in this comparison and searched for newer readers once more. Sources include project documentation and release notes, GitHub security advisories and issue records, Debian’s security tracker, Apple’s support guides and security notes, LWN and user forums. Some vendor help pages blocked automated retrieval, and we read the project’s GitHub records instead.
We wrote this for someone reading their own DRM-free EPUBs, and some PDFs, on a computer, who needs to find passages again and keep highlights and notes in a form they can use outside the reader. Two conditions were mandatory: the app must open a local EPUB without uploading it to a cloud service, and it must document EPUB highlights with attached notes. We then fixed five criteria and their weights before scoring: getting annotations out (30%), reading and finding passages (20%), platforms and cost (15%), data control and privacy (15%), and maintenance and security record (20%). Zotero scored highest and calibre second, a narrow 0.225 apart; the gap comes mainly from calibre’s 2026 security record. Giving reading tools more weight and maintenance less puts calibre level or ahead. AI features carried no weight.
We added Zotero and Koodo Reader in an earlier revision because both are widely used for this job. On November 12 Koodo Reader scored 3.64 and Apple Books 2.53, so neither has its own section. Koodo Reader documents the widest choice of note export formats, one-click export as CSV, Markdown, HTML, TXT or PDF and, since version 2.4.6, JSON, and version 2.4.7 (November 8, 2026) added a single export of a book with its notes and highlights. It lost points on its security record: a malicious EPUB could run commands on your computer until version 2.3.1 in mid-2026 (CVE-2026-55408), two further high-severity advisories followed in September and October, and its app sandbox was switched on by default only in 2.4.6, on October 7, 2026. Its macOS build is not notarized by Apple. Reading and local export are free on desktop; syncing through cloud drives is a Pro feature at US$4.99 a year, checked November 12, 2026. Apple Books comes with macOS and is free; it shares one note at a time, we found no documented bulk export, it sends PDFs to Preview, and it runs only on Macs. Koodo Reader changelog, Koodo Reader pricing, Apple Books
Thorium Reader scored 3.70 and ranks fifth, so it has no section. Its maker, EDRLab, a French nonprofit association, documents the most accessibility work here: version 3.5 improved screen-reader support in the library and the book view and added finer control of read-aloud highlighting and speed, and it reads fixed-layout EPUBs, DAISY books and audiobooks. EPUB notes export as Readium Annotations JSON, which it can import again, and as HTML. Its limit for this job is PDFs: version 3.5 exports only PDF bookmarks. It sends a statistics message at each start with no opt-out, per its desktop privacy policy (November 22, 2022); a change adding Google Analytics was merged on September 1, 2026 and reverted before 3.5.1, which is still the latest release (checked November 12, 2026). Version 3.3 (December 2025) fixed a critical malicious-EPUB flaw and 3.5 a script-injection flaw in annotation links. We also scored the five leading readers for someone who reads with a screen reader or fixed-layout EPUBs, changing only what each maker documents about screen-reader support, read-aloud and fixed-layout books, with the same criteria and weights: Zotero still scored highest at 4.25, ahead of calibre at 4.03 and Thorium Reader and Readest at 3.90. If you read only EPUBs and do not need PDF notes out, Thorium Reader scored 4.20 against Zotero’s 4.10 in the same test. We tested no reader with assistive technology, and only Thorium’s maker documents screen-reader support on the pages we read, so check that before you choose. Thorium 3.5 release notes, 3.5.0 changelog, desktop privacy policy, 3.3 security release, releases
We excluded readers that fail the mandatory conditions or serve another job: SumatraPDF annotates PDFs only; Kindle and Google Play Books are built around their stores and handle your own files through their cloud services; Foliate is built for Linux, where the readers here are also available; KOReader is built for e-ink devices and, on a computer, Linux; the pages we read for FBReader do not describe highlights with notes; self-hosted library servers are a different setup. Saved web articles are covered in our read-later comparison. Adobe Digital Editions is free for Windows and Mac and documents highlights and notes, but we found no way to export them, and it scored 2.36. Neat Reader reads EPUBs on Windows and Mac and says notes export to note software, but its free desktop app holds at most ten books and its Premium plan costs US$19.99 a year, checked November 12, 2026; with its note formats unstated it scored below the top four. MarginNote 5, a Mac and iPhone study app, needs its US$16.99-a-year Max plan on a Mac, and the pages we read describe reading PDFs and EPUBs into study cards rather than EPUB highlights with notes or a Markdown export, so we did not score it; in October it scored about 2.7 with low confidence.
On October 20 and again on November 12, 2026 we searched for newer readers for this job, using GitHub project listings and searches, Hacker News launch posts, alternatives directories, Apple’s App Store, Obsidian’s plugin directory, recent coverage and the candidates screened earlier. We counted a reader as newer if its first public release fell within the last 24 months (on or after November 12, 2024) and it does not come from an established e-book software company, and we scored every newer reader that is available now on both Windows and macOS, documents highlights with notes and a way to get them out, and has no unresolved safety problem, with the same weights as the readers above. Readest scored highest, 3.80 against Zotero’s 4.15, and is our Rising Star because it pairs EPUB and PDF reading in a standalone app with documented Markdown, text and JSON note export, on desktop and phone; its security record, its default cloud upload after sign-in and a July 2026 change that moved own-storage sync behind a paid plan count against it in those scores. Readest’s first App Store release was on November 26, 2024 and its first GitHub release on November 30, 2024, so it is inside the 24-month window. Its lead is narrow. The next newcomer, yh-InkLight, an Obsidian plugin for reading and annotating EPUBs and PDFs, scored 3.79 and ranks fourth overall, so it has its own section. Theorem, a free open-source reader whose maker says it writes each highlight straight into an Obsidian or Logseq folder as Markdown, was announced on Hacker News on October 15, 2026, but we could not confirm its first release date, so we did not yet consider it for the award. Weave EPUB Reader scored 3.59, EPUB Reader and Highlighter and EPUB Marginalia 3.49 each, Modu Reader 3.43, ReadAny 3.41 and NeoRead (formerly Reader by cynicalight) 3.23; they scored lower mainly because each is run by one developer or a very small team, we found no named open-source licence for several of them, and two of the plugins document no in-book search. Others did not qualify: Anx Reader, scored 3.38, was first released in April 2024, outside the 24-month window; Octavo has no macOS download, Folio runs only on Windows, and MoYin Reader offers macOS only as source code to build yourself; Librum and Alexandria have had no release or code change in more than a year; Repose runs only on Windows and Leafmark only on iPhone and iPad; arcalibre, an AI-free calibre snapshot, is described as pre-alpha; GoRead and Flow do not document how highlights and notes leave the app; and AeroRead has only a one-paragraph launch listing. We will look again at the next review.
| Tool | Public sources | What remains uncertain |
|---|---|---|
| Zotero | Zotero 7 and 10 announcements, changelog, reader and notes documentation, team forum announcement of Markdown export, privacy policy, storage plans, GitHub security page. | How complete EPUB note exports are for long books, how well its EPUB layout suits long reading sessions. |
| calibre viewer | Viewer manual, release notes and changelog, export code, privacy policy, GitHub security advisories, Debian security tracker, LWN, MobileRead. | Whether further advisories follow at 2026’s pace, which distribution packages carry the fixes. |
| Thorium Reader | 3.5 release notes, 3.5.0 and 3.5.1 changelogs, GitHub releases, privacy policy, maintainer discussion, EDRLab pages, issue 3053. | When PDF highlights become exportable, whether telemetry changes in a later release. |
| Koodo Reader | README, changelog (2.4.7), documentation and privacy statement, pricing, GitHub security advisories, issue 1543. | What its exports contain and how complete they are, whether the new sandbox holds, its terms of service. |
| yh-InkLight | obsidianstats.com plugin page (README, changelog, statistics), Obsidian pricing page. | Its first release date and release history, its security page, how it behaves with your own books, phone use. |
| Readest | Maker overview, reading and sync guides, pricing, privacy policy and terms, GitHub releases (0.12.20) and security advisories, OSV, issues 5033 and 6881, App Store listing. | How complete its exports are for long books and PDFs, whether its pace of security fixes settles, who runs its cloud beyond the seller’s name. |
| Apple Books | Apple’s Mac guides for import, reading, highlights and sharing, Books privacy notice, Apple security release notes. | Whether any bulk export exists that Apple does not document. |
None of this establishes how any reader performs with your books. Next substantive review is due December 18, 2026, or sooner after a major release or security advisory. Found a changed release or behavior? Contact the editors.
Sources and evidence
Sources were checked October 19, 2026 unless another date is given; prices, current releases and advisory counts were checked again on November 12, 2026. Project and vendor material establishes documented features and published terms, not behavior with your files. Security advisories are the projects’ own published records. Community posts are attributed reports, not representative samples.
- Zotero: Zotero 7 announcement, EPUB support; Zotero 10 announcement; changelog, 10.0.9, November 10, 2026; reader and annotation storage, updated May 5, 2026; notes; Markdown note export announcement, December 16, 2021; privacy; storage plans, checked November 12, 2026; downloads; GitHub security page; EPUB annotation links thread, 2023 to 2024.
- calibre: viewer manual, 9.16.0; release notes, 9.18, November 6, 2026; annotation export code; downloads; privacy policy, March 4, 2025; security advisories, 29 listed on November 12, 2026, including CVE-2026-53511, CVE-2026-33205 and the PalmDoc advisory credited to Calif.io and Anthropic; Debian security tracker; LWN, December 15, 2025; MobileRead, August 2022.
- Thorium Reader: 3.5 release notes, August 31, 2026; 3.5.0 changelog; 3.5.1 changelog; releases; 3.3 security release, December 9, 2025; EDRLab software; accessibility documentation; desktop privacy policy, November 22, 2022; maintainer response on statistics, March 2026; EDRLab; terms; issue 3053.
- Readest, checked October 20, 2026 (releases and pricing again November 12): overview; reading and note export guide; sync guide; pricing, checked November 12, 2026; privacy policy, June 6, 2025; terms, November 29, 2024; releases, 0.12.20, November 5, 2026; first GitHub release, 0.7.9; security advisories, including CVE-2026-82642 on OSV, the PDF.js advisory and local file read and write; issue 5033; issue 6881; App Store listing, seller Bilingify LLC.
- yh-InkLight, checked November 12, 2026: plugin page; source repository; Obsidian pricing.
- Koodo Reader: README; changelog, 2.4.7, November 8, 2026; documentation and privacy statement; pricing, checked November 12, 2026; security advisories, including CVE-2026-55408, EPUB metadata advisory, October 2026 and installer advisory, September 2026; issue 1543.
- Apple Books: Mac import; reading controls; highlights and notes; sharing notes and quotes; Books privacy; security releases; Mac discussion, April 2023, last read September 6, 2026.
- Other readers, checked November 12, 2026: Theorem (the maker’s own page); Neat Reader Premium; Adobe Digital Editions; MarginNote pricing; Anx Reader releases; Readest oldest releases; Apple Books.
This is a researched comparison, not a product review. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.