Browser 3D design for a first simple object: Tinkercad, Layerling, SketchForge-3D and SketchUp Free
Tinkercad is the easiest established place to build a first simple object from shapes and holes. Layerling is the newcomer to consider if you want no account and your designs kept on your own computer, and SketchForge-3D is a quieter alternative of the same kind.
Tinkercad
Place shapes, turn one into a hole and group them to cut it. Free STL, OBJ and GLTF downloads, from the most established beginner tool here.
Your designs live in an Autodesk account, and its 2019 terms give no clear permission for commercial use. Download a copy of anything you want to keep.
Why Tinkercad is our PickTeam behind Tinkercad? Get your award badge
Layerling
A free, open-source editor launched in September 2026 that works like Tinkercad, keeps designs in your browser and exports STL, 3MF, OBJ and STEP.
Clearing browser data deletes unsaved designs, so save project files. Very young and changing fast: check every export.
Why Layerling earned Rising StarWho is this article for? Adults making a first simple, original 3D object in a desktop browser for personal use, such as a small block with a recess to download or print. Not for commercial, confidential or safety-critical parts.
About 23 min read
What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean
The quick list
All four have a free way in. Compare how you build the block and its recess, which files the free tier downloads and where your designs are kept.
Prices checked November 12, 2026. Tinkercad is free, per Autodesk. Layerling and SketchForge-3D are free, open-source software. SketchUp Free is for noncommercial use; SketchUp Go costs $10.75 a month billed annually. Prices exclude tax.
The comparison at a glance
Compare how you build the object, which files the free tier downloads, where your designs live and what the terms allow.
Order follows our verdict for a first simple object made for personal use, not measured ease, accuracy or reliability. All tools remain selectable.
Hides matching answers for the selected tools. Unknowns and unverified claims stay visible.
| Feature | Tinkercad | Layerling | SketchForge-3D | SketchUp Free |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: a first object built from shapes and holes | Rising Star: no account, designs kept on your computer | The same shapes-and-holes method as Layerling, with no 3MF export and less documentation and coverage | Noncommercial practice drawing faces and pushing them to depth |
| Cost for this job | Free, per Autodesk | Free and open source (AGPL-3.0) | Free and open source (AGPL-3.0) | Free for noncommercial use; Go from $10.75/month billed yearly |
| How you make the block and recess | Place shapes, turn one into a hole, union-group to cut | Same shapes-and-holes method, plus fillets, chamfers and sketches | Drop a shape, make another a hole and group them; chamfers, fillets and an intersect option | Draw a face, Push/Pull it up, push a second outline down |
| Free 3D file downloads | STL, OBJ, GLTF | STL, 3MF, OBJ, STEP | STL, OBJ, STEP | STL only (PNG with watermark) |
| Where your designs live | Your Autodesk account; no project-file download found | Your browser’s storage, plus .lyl project files you save | Your browser’s storage; its README mentions .skf project files | Trimble Connect, with native SKP download |
| Personal and commercial use | Personal use under its terms; commercial permission not established | No use restriction found; AGPL covers the software | No use restriction found; AGPL covers the software | Noncommercial, non-production only |
| Main caution | Account-only: a September 2026 sign-in incident blocked some users’ projects for about 16 hours | Clearing site data deletes unsaved designs; 266 releases in about eight weeks | No code changes since September 18; we did not read a privacy policy for its hosted demo | No solid subtract, Outliner or support on Free |
Desktop-browser tools for a first simple, original object made for personal use. Sources checked October 19 and November 12, 2026; Tinkercad’s grouping help and special terms were last read September 6. Next review December 18, 2026, or earlier after a material change. This is public-source research: documentation does not establish dimensional accuracy, printability, export reliability or security. Installed desktop software, code-based modeling and AI model generation are out of scope.
All features and sources 19 criteria
Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.
Building the first object
Show 6 criteria
| Feature | Tinkercad | Layerling | SketchForge-3D | SketchUp Free |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Preferred Pick: a first object built from shapes and holes | Rising Star: no account, designs kept on your computer | The same shapes-and-holes method as Layerling, with no 3MF export and less documentation and coverage | Noncommercial practice drawing faces and pushing them to depth |
| How you make the block and recess | Place shapes, turn one into a hole, union-group to cut | Same shapes-and-holes method, plus fillets, chamfers and sketches | Drop a shape, make another a hole and group them; chamfers, fillets and an intersect option | Draw a face, Push/Pull it up, push a second outline down |
| Setting exact sizes | Ruler and typed dimensions | Typed sizes and positions; millimetres or inches | Resize and align controls; typed values are described by Hackaday, units not stated | Model units; typed Push/Pull distance |
| Changing it later | Ungroup to edit parts; bundle groups keep parts separate | Edit group, undo and a history slider | Chamfers and fillets can be removed again; other editing is not described in the pages we read | Components; Outliner needs a subscription |
| Extra modeling tools on the free tier | Intersect groups and alignment | Fillet, chamfer, hollow, split, threads, sketches | Chamfer, fillet, intersect, sketch extrude and revolve | Outer Shell is the only solid tool |
| Track record and help | Autodesk product; Autodesk claims 86 million users and publishes extensive help | Launched September 2026; user guide and independent videos | Repository dates from June 2026; Hackaday coverage in August; about 1,200 stars and 8 contributors | Trimble product with a large help center; no support for Free users |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for building the first object
Checked October 19 and November 12, 2026. Tinkercad 3D design overview and Union Group help (read November 12), grouping help (read September 6), Google Workspace listing and a university makerspace guide; Layerling home page, README and releases; SketchForge-3D README and Hackaday, August 1, 2026; SketchUp web features, Push/Pull and Free plan. Documented features, not tested results. Numeric controls do not certify accuracy.
Getting a file out
Show 5 criteria
| Feature | Tinkercad | Layerling | SketchForge-3D | SketchUp Free |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cost for this job | Free, per Autodesk | Free and open source (AGPL-3.0) | Free and open source (AGPL-3.0) | Free for noncommercial use; Go from $10.75/month billed yearly |
| Free 3D file downloads | STL, OBJ, GLTF | STL, 3MF, OBJ, STEP | STL, OBJ, STEP | STL only (PNG with watermark) |
| Editable project file | None found; edit the online design | .lyl file with history and groups | .skf project files, per its README | Native SKP download |
| Export caveat | Help says exports merge into one part; a September 2025 update says ungrouped shapes stay separate | Reports of non-manifold parts and malformed sketch surfaces were open on November 12; check the file in your slicer | Its README lists STL import and export edge cases as an area needing help; check the file in your slicer | Help pages differ on PDF; feature table lists STL only |
| Paid upgrade relevant here | None needed | None needed | None needed | Subscription adds OBJ, DAE, FBX and more |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for getting a file out
Tinkercad export help (read November 12), export update, read through search-engine copies in October, and Hackaday; Layerling README and issues; SketchForge-3D README; SketchUp web features, file management, saving and plans. Export formats do not establish file quality or printability.
Account, storage and rights
Show 8 criteria
| Feature | Tinkercad | Layerling | SketchForge-3D | SketchUp Free |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Account needed | Yes, Tinkercad sign-in | No | No login, per its README | Trimble ID |
| Where your designs live | Your Autodesk account; no project-file download found | Your browser’s storage, plus .lyl project files you save | Your browser’s storage; its README mentions .skf project files | Trimble Connect, with native SKP download |
| Recorded service problems in 2026 | September 10–11: some Google sign-in users could not reach existing projects | No outage recorded; a moderate advisory on October 23 affects only self-hosted copies | None to record; it runs in your browser | January 22: sharing outage of 1 hour 15 minutes |
| Default visibility | Private until you make it public, per Tinkercad | Nothing uploaded, per its privacy policy | Nothing uploaded to a cloud service, per its README | Private invite links or public links |
| Personal and commercial use | Personal use under its terms; commercial permission not established | No use restriction found; AGPL covers the software | No use restriction found; AGPL covers the software | Noncommercial, non-production only |
| Privacy terms in brief | No ads or data sales, per Tinkercad; Autodesk statement January 2026 | No cookies or analytics, per its September 2026 policy | No login and no cloud project storage, per its README; hosted demo’s policy not read | Advertising, profiling and machine-learning analysis of use (September 2026) |
| Who runs it | Autodesk, Inc. | An individual developer in Germany; fork of SketchForge-3D | An individual developer, identified by a lasting public GitHub account | Trimble Inc. |
| Main caution | Account-only: a September 2026 sign-in incident blocked some users’ projects for about 16 hours | Clearing site data deletes unsaved designs; 266 releases in about eight weeks | No code changes since September 18; we did not read a privacy policy for its hosted demo | No solid subtract, Outliner or support on Free |
These selected tools have matching answers in this group. Turn off “Show differences only” to see them.
Sources for account, storage and rights
Tinkercad status record, product privacy and terms (read November 12) and Autodesk privacy statement; Layerling privacy policy and legal notice, in German, security advisories and home page; SketchForge-3D repository; SketchUp creating models, link sharing, status record, offering terms and privacy notice. Personal original practice only; not commercial clearance or a security assessment.
What matters when choosing
Tinkercad is our Practical Pick for an adult making a first simple object, such as a small block with a recess, in a desktop browser for personal use. You build by placing ready-made shapes, turning some of them into holes and grouping them, so the recess is simply a hole shape grouped with the body. Autodesk lists Tinkercad as free of charge, and its help center lists free STL, OBJ and GLTF downloads. It is also the most established beginner tool here: Autodesk says 86 million people use it. The most important compromise is that your work lives in an Autodesk account rather than on your computer. On September 10 and 11, 2026, Autodesk’s status page reported that some users signing in with Google could not reach their existing projects for about 16 hours. Export a copy of anything you want to keep. Google Workspace listing, export help, Autodesk status record
Layerling is our Rising Star for the same first object when you would rather not create an account and want your designs to stay on your own computer. It launched in September 2026 as a free, open-source fork of another new project, SketchForge-3D. It works like Tinkercad, with shapes, holes, groups and bundles, and adds fillets, chamfers, sketches and threads. It exports STL, 3MF, OBJ and STEP files and saves whole projects as a file. Its privacy policy says your designs stay in your browser and nothing is uploaded. That same design is its main risk: clearing your browser’s site data deletes any design you have not saved as a file. It is also very young. It has published 266 releases in about eight weeks, mostly from one developer. Export bugs reported in October were fixed within days, but reports of non-manifold parts and malformed sketch surfaces were still open on November 12, so check every export in your slicer. Layerling README, privacy policy, in German, release history
SketchForge-3D is a quieter project of the same kind. Layerling began as a fork of it. It offers the same shapes-and-holes method with no login and designs kept in your browser, and exports STL, OBJ and STEP. It scored below Layerling because it has no 3MF export and less documentation and independent coverage. We did not read a privacy policy for its hosted demo, so its handling of your data rests on its README. SketchForge-3D README, Hackaday, August 1, 2026
SketchUp Free suits noncommercial practice when you think in outlines rather than building blocks. You draw a face and push or pull it to a typed distance, which cuts a recess cleanly. Its free tier exports STL only, with native SKP downloads and saved revisions in Trimble’s cloud. It requires a Trimble ID, and Trimble’s terms limit free versions to noncommercial, non-production use. We did not choose Vectary, a scene-presentation tool whose pricing page does not say whether its Free plan downloads 3D files, or Onshape, a professional CAD tool whose free plan makes every document public; both are covered under “How we researched”. SketchUp Free, SketchUp for Web features, Trimble offering terms
This comparison is for an original, noncritical object made for personal practice. It does not establish dimensional accuracy, printability or fitness for a part whose failure could cause harm, and it is not a recommendation for confidential or commercial work. If your object must change size from a formula or live in code, see our separate comparison of code-first parametric CAD.
Disclosure: Practical Picks articles are researched and written with AI, currently Anthropic’s Claude. Layerling and SketchForge-3D offer an optional local connection for AI clients, including Claude, and Layerling’s developer has used Claude in building it. We have no relationship with either developer or with Anthropic over these products, and the AI connection carried no weight in our judgment.
Tinkercad
Preferred Pick · a first object from shapes and holes
Choose Tinkercad for a first simple object you can describe as a few shapes with a hole cut out. Download a copy of anything you want to keep, because your designs live in your Autodesk account.
Reasons to choose it
- Build by placing shapes and turning some into holes
- Free STL, OBJ and GLTF downloads
- The most established beginner tool here, with extensive help
What to watch
- Designs live in your account; no editable project-file download found
- A September 2026 sign-in incident blocked some users’ projects for about 16 hours
- No clear permission for commercial use in its 2019 terms
Tinkercad’s approach suits a beginner who can describe the object as a few simple shapes. You place a box, set its size with the ruler or typed dimensions, place a second shape where the recess belongs and turn it into a hole. Grouping the two with a union group cuts the hole out of the body; ungrouping gives you the parts back to change. A newer bundle group holds parts together without merging them. Autodesk lists Tinkercad as free of charge and says 86 million people use it; we treat that figure as Autodesk’s claim, not a measure of quality. Google Workspace listing, updated November 21, 2024, Union Group help, grouping help, university makerspace guide
The most important compromise is where your work lives. Designs are kept in your Tinkercad account, and we found no download of an editable project file. On September 10 and 11, 2026, Autodesk’s status page recorded about 16 hours in which some users signing in with Google were asked to create new accounts and could not reach their existing project data; Autodesk marked it resolved on September 11. One incident does not measure reliability, but it shows what an account-only tool depends on. Autodesk status record
Read the full Tinkercad analysis and sources
Downloading the finished object
Tinkercad’s export help lists OBJ, STL and GLTF downloads of the whole design or selected shapes. The same help page still says exported shapes become a single part that cannot be ungrouped after you import them back. Tinkercad’s September 2025 blog post on export says shapes you leave ungrouped now stay separate in the exported file, and October 2025 coverage by Hackaday describes bundle groups keeping their part structure on export. We read the export help directly on November 12, 2026; the September 2025 blog post and the Hackaday article were read earlier, the post through a search-engine copy. Either way, the downloaded mesh does not carry Tinkercad’s editable hole shapes, so keep the online design if you expect to change the recess later. Export help, Tinkercad export update, Hackaday, October 22, 2025
Personal practice, not a commercial clearance
Tinkercad’s privacy page says other users cannot see your designs until you make them public, and that Tinkercad does not sell user data or carry advertising. These are Autodesk’s statements, read again on November 12, 2026, not an independent privacy audit. Autodesk’s general privacy statement, effective January 1, 2026, covers account, usage and device information. Tinkercad privacy, Autodesk privacy statement
Tinkercad’s service terms, still dated December 2019, keep your ownership of what you make but give Autodesk broad rights to use content for its services, and the linked special terms give other users rights in content you share publicly. We found no clear permission to sell what you make, so our Pick covers personal, original practice. Read the terms yourself before using Tinkercad for paid work. Terms, read November 12, special terms, read September 6
Used Tinkercad? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Layerling
Rising Star · a newcomer worth considering
Why Rising Star? Launched in September 2026, it needs no account, keeps designs on your own device and exports the most file formats here, and its documentation, independent coverage and quick fixes support the simple-object job. Its youth and browser-only storage are the limits. This is not our broader Ready to Rock endorsement.
Consider Layerling when you want Tinkercad’s way of working without an account or a cloud copy. Save every design as a project file and check each export in your slicer.
Reasons to choose it
- No account; designs stay in your browser, per its privacy policy
- Free STL, 3MF, OBJ and STEP downloads
- Adds fillets, chamfers, sketches and threads
What to watch
- Clearing browser site data deletes designs you have not saved as files
- Launched September 2026, with 266 releases in about eight weeks
- Mostly one developer; reports of faulty exports were still open in November
Layerling is a newcomer built to work the way Tinkercad users already expect: put a shape on the plate, size it, turn a second shape into a hole, group the two and export. The project says you can type sizes and positions, work in millimetres or inches and edit a group’s parts again later. It adds tools Tinkercad lacks, including fillets, chamfers, hollowing, sketches and threads. It needs no account, and its September 17, 2026 privacy policy says designs and settings are kept in your browser’s local storage, are not sent to the operator or third parties, and that the site sets no cookies and runs no analytics. These are the project’s own descriptions; the hosted site at layerling.com is free and carries no advertising. Layerling, README, privacy policy, in German, legal notice, in German
Keeping designs in the browser is also the main risk. If you clear the site’s data or switch to another computer or browser, the designs are not there. Layerling lets you save a whole project, with history and groups, as a .lyl file and back up all designs in one file; treat that as essential, not optional. A Czech technology site that described the project on October 12, 2026 gave the same warning. README, Chiptron, October 12, 2026
Read the full Layerling analysis and sources
Why it is our Rising Star
Layerling’s repository was created on September 16, 2026, and version 1.0.0 followed the next day. It forked SketchForge-3D, a local-first browser editor whose repository dates from June 2026. All3DP covered Layerling’s launch in September 2026, Chiptron described it in October, and several independent YouTube creators have published walkthroughs. In about eight weeks it gathered about 440 GitHub stars and 33 contributors. It is licensed under the AGPL-3.0, so anyone can run their own copy, and it can be installed to start without an internet connection. Repository and releases, SketchForge-3D, All3DP launch coverage, Chiptron
Its export menu is the most generous here: STL, 3MF and OBJ for slicers, plus STEP for a full CAD program, all free. The useful difference from Tinkercad is real for a reader who wants no account and local files. So is the change rate. Layerling published version 1.160.1 on November 12, 2026, its 266th release, and most of its commits come from one developer. On October 18 a user reported that an ungrouped hole could disappear from an exported file when its body touched another body. The developer reproduced it and released a fix the same day. On November 12, open reports included non-manifold parts from built-in operations and malformed surfaces from sketch extrusions, which is why you should check every exported file in your slicer. A moderate security advisory published on October 23 concerns only copies you host yourself, not layerling.com. This is a Rising Star recommendation for a simple object with saved backups, not our broader Ready to Rock endorsement. Export-hole issue, an earlier export fix confirmed by its reporter, security advisories
Used Layerling? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
SketchForge-3D
Same method as Layerling · no account, designs in your browser
Consider SketchForge-3D if you want Tinkercad’s shapes-and-holes method with no account and your designs kept in your browser. Layerling covers the same ground with 3MF export and more documentation and independent coverage, so check the file in your slicer either way.
Reasons to choose it
- No login; designs stay in your browser, per its README
- Free STL, OBJ and STEP downloads
- Chamfers, fillets and sketch extrusions
What to watch
- No code changes since September 18, 2026
- We did not read a privacy policy for its hosted demo
- Clearing browser site data deletes designs you have not saved
SketchForge-3D is the open-source project Layerling was forked from. Its README describes the Tinkercad-like loop: drop a shape, resize it, make another shape a hole, group the result and export. It adds chamfers and fillets that can be taken off again, a boolean intersection and, according to Hackaday, sketches that you extrude or revolve. The README says there is no login and no server project storage: designs live in your browser, and exports download through the browser. It is licensed under the AGPL-3.0. README, Hackaday, August 1, 2026
Free exports are STL, OBJ and STEP, and the README mentions .skf project files. It recommends running its own copy with Docker for classrooms and offers macOS installers, and Hackaday points to an online demo, which is the way most readers would try it. We did not read a privacy policy for that hosted demo, so its handling of your data rests on the README’s statement that models are not uploaded. README
Read the full SketchForge-3D analysis and sources
Why it is not the Rising Star
The repository dates from June 2026, Hackaday covered it in August, and it has about 1,200 GitHub stars, 8 contributors and 114 commits. Its last commit was on September 18, 2026, about eight weeks before our check, so it is not abandoned but it has been quiet while its fork moved on. Layerling has more tools, 3MF export, more releases and more independent coverage, and it scored higher. Clearing browser site data deletes designs you have not saved, as with Layerling, and the README lists STL import and export edge cases as an area that still needs help. Repository, releases
Used SketchForge-3D? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
SketchUp Free
Noncommercial practice from outlines
Choose SketchUp Free if you would rather draw an outline and push it to an exact depth, and your project is personal. It keeps native SKP files and saved revisions, but Free exports only STL.
Reasons to choose it
- Push/Pull to a typed distance makes a clean recess
- Native SKP download, autosave and saved revisions
- Private invite links or public links for sharing
What to watch
- Noncommercial use only; no support for Free users
- Free exports STL only and lacks solid subtract
- Trimble may end free access at any time with notice
SketchUp’s Push/Pull tool turns a flat face into a solid or cuts volume away, and you can type an exact distance. For the block, you draw the outline, pull it up to height, draw the recess outline on the top face and push it down. That suits someone who thinks in outlines and measurements. SketchUp for Web runs in a browser without an installation, but it needs a Trimble ID. Push/Pull, updated September 29, 2026, creating models, updated October 9, 2026
SketchUp’s feature table shows what Free leaves out. Of the solid tools it includes only Outer Shell, so union and subtract need a subscription, as do the Outliner and editing styles. Free exports STL files only, and PNG downloads carry a watermark. A separate file-format page also lists PDF export for Free; we rely on the feature table. Free users get one Trimble Connect project, up to five collaborators and 10 GB of storage. SketchUp for Web features, September 29, 2026, file management
Read the full SketchUp Free analysis and sources
Native files and saved revisions
SketchUp saves web models to Trimble Connect. After your first save it autosaves every five minutes, keeps a local backup in the browser in case of a crash, and creates a new version with each save. You can download your model as a native SKP file as well as PNG and STL, which keeps an editable copy on your computer. Saving models, September 29, 2026
Sharing works only for models saved to Trimble Connect. You can create a private link for invited people or a public link anyone can open. Trimble’s status page recorded a sharing outage of one hour and 15 minutes on January 22, 2026. Link sharing, Trimble status record
Free means noncommercial and unsupported
SketchUp says Free is not for commercial use and that support is not available to Free users. Trimble’s offering terms, updated to version 4.1 on October 13, 2026, limit free versions to non-production, noncommercial use, provide them as-is, cap Trimble’s liability at US$50 and allow Trimble to end access at any time with notice. The paid web plan, SketchUp Go, costs $10.75 a month billed annually, checked October 19; we did not evaluate whether its terms cover your commercial use. Annual plans can be refunded within 14 days of purchase or renewal; monthly renewals cannot. SketchUp Free, offering terms, plans and pricing, refunds and cancellations
Trimble’s privacy notice, updated September 24, 2026, lists online advertising, behavior analysis, marketing and profiling among its purposes. It also says Trimble uses machine learning to analyze how people use its products, including content sent through or stored on its services. It offers an opt-out of sharing for targeted advertising. None of this makes SketchUp unsuitable for a personal practice object, but it describes more marketing use than Tinkercad’s product privacy page or Layerling’s policy. Trimble privacy notice
Used SketchUp Free? Share your experience to help other readers choose.
Which product are we missing?
Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.
Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.
Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.
No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.
What people are saying
A September 2025 Tinkercad discussion shows users confused by the new bundle and union groups and by how holes export, with replies that disagree. It supports checking an exported file, not a conclusion that grouping is broken. The discussion was read on September 6, 2026.
Early Layerling reports are mostly from people moving from Tinkercad. In an October 16, 2026 IntoFPV forum thread, the opening poster praised its fillets, noted that moving a design between computers needs a backup, and expected bugs in new software; another member praised the no-login design. On GitHub, a user who reported overlapping parts exporting as hollow confirmed the fix worked the next day. These are a few enthusiastic early adopters, not evidence of reliability.
An April 2022 SketchUp forum thread reported an STL export error on a large model that the author resolved by purging unused items; it is historical troubleshooting, not evidence about today’s Free version.
Our October 19 search for newer complaints, security incidents, lawsuits, regulatory actions and ownership changes involving these tools found the two service interruptions described above, and our November 12 recheck of the status and advisory pages found nothing that changed these conclusions. A search that finds nothing is not proof that nothing exists.
How we researched
This is public-source research. We did not create accounts, sign in, build or export a model, install anything or print a part. No vendor or project supplied access, payment or input, and we use no affiliate links. We first compared Tinkercad, SketchUp Free and Vectary on September 6, 2026, rechecked every material claim on October 19 and checked prices, plans, free-tier downloads, terms, privacy policies, release records and security advisories again on November 12, 2026. We read vendor help centers, pricing pages, terms and privacy policies, status pages, GitHub repository records and independent coverage. Tinkercad’s export help, privacy page and terms, which we could read only through search-engine copies in October, were read directly on November 12; its grouping help and special terms are still from September 6.
We wrote this for an adult making a first, simple, original object in a desktop browser for personal use, such as a small block with a recess. We fixed five criteria and their weights before comparing: how directly a beginner can build the object (25%), which useful files the free tier can download (20%), where designs live and how well you can recover them (20%), terms and privacy for personal use (15%), and learning support and track record (20%). Price carries no weight of its own here, because every tool we could score has a free way in. On that basis Tinkercad scored 4.05 out of 5, Layerling 3.78, SketchForge-3D 3.50 and SketchUp Free 3.35, the four tools in the chart. Giving much more weight to free downloads and privacy, and less to track record, favors Layerling, which is why it is our Rising Star for readers who want no account. We did not evaluate full parametric CAD, code-based modeling, AI generation of models from text or images, or installed desktop software.
We also searched again for new entrants through launch coverage, GitHub, maker forums and recent lists of Tinkercad alternatives. Layerling still meets our Rising Star threshold: its first release came in September 2026, it runs in a browser on Windows and macOS, its only security advisory is a moderate one about self-hosted copies, and it keeps its lead over every other newcomer. SketchForge-3D, its parent project, scored below it, as described above. MakerNest CAD, a free browser editor in public beta with STL, OBJ, GLB and PLY export, scored 2.78 but is not a qualified newcomer: we found no date for its first release, no independent coverage and no privacy policy for the editor, only marketplace terms from January 2025 naming MakerNest Ltd, and its source code is not published.
Other established options were looked at. Onshape Free is a professional browser CAD tool whose help lists STL, STEP, OBJ and 3MF export without saying which plans include each. Its free plan is for noncommercial work, offers public storage only and gives other users a licence to your public documents; it scored 3.25, just behind SketchUp Free. Vectary, which edits meshes and builds interactive scenes, scored 3.08: it sets real-world units only at import, export or AR, and its pricing page does not say which plans download 3D files, although its help lists the formats. Its pricing page shows the Starter plan at a limited-time $15 a month billed monthly and does not show the regular price; it is not in the chart. Womp, a browser modeling service whose free plan lists 3D export (its FAQ names OBJ, STL, PLY and GLTF among others) and whose public beta began in May 2024, scored 2.98 and is not new enough to be a newcomer. SelfCAD is an established browser CAD tool with a free plan, but none of the pages we could read names the 3D formats it downloads, so we did not score it. Its best case could place it among our top four, so the third and fourth places in the chart are provisional until we can read those pages. New products from established companies, such as Vectary’s Canvas or Adobe’s 3D design beta, were treated as alternatives, not newcomers.
| Tool | Public sources | What remains uncertain |
|---|---|---|
| Tinkercad | Autodesk app listing, export and Union Group help, terms and privacy page (read November 12), grouping help and special terms (read September 6), September 2025 export post (via search copy), Autodesk status record, Hackaday, a university makerspace guide. | How export handles grouped and ungrouped shapes today, commercial-use permission. |
| Layerling | Home page, README, user guide, privacy policy and legal notice, GitHub releases, issues and advisories, SketchForge-3D repository, Chiptron, All3DP, a forum thread. | Long-term maintenance by one main developer, behavior after rapid releases, how many users lose designs to cleared browser storage. |
| SketchUp Free | Free plan, feature, Push/Pull, file, saving, sharing and refund help pages (August to October 2026), plans page, Trimble offering terms and privacy notice, Trimble status record. | Conflicting help pages on PDF export, whether Free remains available on the same terms, how often its sharing and storage services fail. |
| SketchForge-3D | README, repository and releases, Hackaday. | Privacy policy of the hosted demo, whether .skf files are available there, maintenance after September 18. |
None of this establishes dimensional accuracy, printability, export reliability or security in practice. Next substantive review is due December 18, 2026, or sooner after a major change to free-tier exports, terms or Layerling’s maintenance. Found a changed plan or term? Contact the editors.
Sources and evidence
Sources were checked October 19 and November 12, 2026 unless another date is given. Vendor and project material establishes documented features and terms, not successful operation. Community posts are attributed experiences, not representative samples.
- Tinkercad (Autodesk): Google Workspace listing, updated November 21, 2024; 3D design overview, read November 12; Union Group, read November 12; grouping, last read September 6; export help, read November 12; September 2025 export update, through a search-engine copy in October; status record, September 10–11, 2026; product privacy, read November 12; terms, December 2019, read November 12; special terms, last read September 6; Autodesk privacy statement, January 1, 2026. Independent: Hackaday, October 22, 2025; university makerspace guide.
- Layerling: home page; user guide; README and licence; releases; privacy policy, September 17, 2026, in German; legal notice, in German; issues 566 and 493; upstream SketchForge-3D. Independent: All3DP, September 2026, through a search-engine copy; Chiptron, October 12, 2026.
- SketchForge-3D: repository and README; releases. Independent: Hackaday, August 1, 2026.
- SketchUp Free (Trimble): Free plan, August 21, 2026; web features, September 29, 2026; creating models, October 9, 2026; Push/Pull, file management, saving and link sharing, all September 29, 2026; refunds and cancellations, September 17, 2026; plans and pricing; offering terms, version 4.1, October 13, 2026; privacy notice, September 24, 2026; status record, January 22, 2026.
- Others looked at (November 12, 2026): Onshape Free plan, Onshape pricing, Onshape export help and terms of use; MakerNest CAD and terms; Vectary pricing and export options; SelfCAD pricing, manual and feature guides; Womp pricing and FAQ.
- Community evidence: Tinkercad grouping discussion, read September 6; IntoFPV Layerling thread, October 16, 2026; SketchUp export thread, April 2022.
This is a researched comparison, not a product review. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.