Affiliate-program software for a small subscription business: FirstPromoter, Rewardful and iDevAffiliate

FirstPromoter and Rewardful both start at $49 a month. FirstPromoter's entry plan does more to run the program and connects to more billing services; Rewardful is the one to choose if you want the platform to pay your partners.

PRACTICAL PICKSPreferredPickOur Preferred PickA small subscription business$49/mo

FirstPromoter Starter

Branded partner dashboard, unlimited team members, partner tax-form collection and CSV or JSON exports on the entry plan, with direct connections to five billing services.

Covers up to $5,000 a month in affiliate revenue, then Business at $99. One-click PayPal needs Business; a managed payout service needs Enterprise.

Why FirstPromoter is our Pick
Newcomer assessment

No Rising Star selected

We found relevant younger affiliate tools, but their first public release or the identity of the operator handling partner data still needs confirmation.

None has enough evidence for a newcomer recommendation yet.

Who is this article for? Owners and marketers at a small subscription software business that want to run their own affiliate program with recurring commissions, rather than join an affiliate network. Not tax or legal advice.

About 21 min read

What Preferred Pick, Rising Star and Ready to Rock mean

The quick list

Choose FirstPromoter for a small subscription business; Rewardful is the alternative when you want partners paid for you. Compare the entry plans below.

Monthly list prices checked October 31, 2026. All three state US dollars. We could not confirm comparable current prices for every alternative. Prices exclude commissions, payment-provider and optional managed-payout fees, taxes and usage overages.

The comparison at a glance

Compare entry-plan limits, billing connections, how partners get paid and what you keep when you leave.

FirstPromoter is our recommendation for a small subscription business; Rewardful suits managed payouts and iDevAffiliate lists 5,000 affiliates and 50,000 clicks a month. All tools remain selectable.

Affiliate-program software for a small subscription business
FeatureFirstPromoterRewardfuliDevAffiliate
Best fitPreferred Pick: a subscription business up to $5,000/month in affiliate revenue, on Stripe or another supported billing serviceWhen you want partners paid for you, or $5,000–$7,500/month in affiliate revenue on StripeHosted alternative: 5,000 affiliates and 50,000 clicks/month
Entry plan, monthlyStarter $49/month (USD)Starter $49/month (USD)Essential $42/month (USD)
Entry-plan limitsUp to $5,000/month affiliate revenue; 1,000 affiliates; 3 campaignsUp to $7,500/month affiliate revenue; unlimited affiliates; 1 campaign5,000 affiliates; 50,000 clicks/month; unlimited commissions
Billing connectionsStripe, Paddle (Billing and Classic), Chargebee, Recurly, Braintree; others through APIStripe; Paddle Classic only, per its 2023 Paddle guideIntegration wizard lists Stripe, membership and subscription systems
Refunds and commissionsNegative commission when the billing connection or API reports a refund or chargebackStripe refunds recalculate the commission, full or partialRecurring billing described; specific Stripe refund handling unconfirmed
Standard way partners get paidExport a CSV for PayPal, Wise, bank or crypto, pay, then mark paidExport a PayPal or Wise CSV, pay, then mark paidProvider payment methods listed; exact Essential workflow unconfirmed
Platform pays partners for youEnterprise 2 or higher, SaaS only, after review; via Dots; no current merchant fee statedOptional on every plan; 3% merchant fee plus affiliate withdrawal feesManaged-service fees and entitlements not established
ExportsReports in CSV and JSON on every plan; activity log from Enterprise Plan 3Due-payout CSV; full export by support requestExportable reports described; full migration export scope unconfirmed

Merchant-run affiliate programs for a small subscription software business. Incumbent research checked October 19, 2026; prices and selected terms October 31: no accounts, tracking, refunds, exports or payouts by us. We could not confirm comparable current prices for every alternative. FirstPromoter remains our recommendation for a small subscription business; iDevAffiliate lists 5,000 affiliates and 50,000 clicks a month but less specific billing and exit documentation. Prices are normal list prices before commissions, provider fees, managed-payout fees, taxes and overages. Next substantive review December 18, 2026, or earlier after a price, payout or term change.

All features and sources 22 criteria

Open the groups that matter to you. They compare the same selected tools. “Planned” means future work, not an available feature. Sources include the published conditions.

Plans and program fit

Show 8 criteria
Plans and program fit
FeatureFirstPromoterRewardfuliDevAffiliate
Best fitPreferred Pick: a subscription business up to $5,000/month in affiliate revenue, on Stripe or another supported billing serviceWhen you want partners paid for you, or $5,000–$7,500/month in affiliate revenue on StripeHosted alternative: 5,000 affiliates and 50,000 clicks/month
Entry plan, monthlyStarter $49/month (USD)Starter $49/month (USD)Essential $42/month (USD)
Entry plan, yearly$490/year$490/yearNo annual cloud discount listed; $504 for twelve monthly payments
Entry-plan limitsUp to $5,000/month affiliate revenue; 1,000 affiliates; 3 campaignsUp to $7,500/month affiliate revenue; unlimited affiliates; 1 campaign5,000 affiliates; 50,000 clicks/month; unlimited commissions
Next plan upBusiness $99/month: up to $15,000; unlimited affiliates; one-click PayPal, custom domain, embedded dashboardGrowth $99/month: up to $15,000; branded portal, custom domain, unlimited campaignsProfessional $59 USD/month: API/webhooks, custom subdomain, 25,000 affiliates, 125,000 clicks/month
Team members on entry planUnlimitedUp to 2Not established
Partner dashboard brandingLogo and colors on every plan; custom domain from BusinessBranded portal and custom domain from GrowthCustom subdomain from Professional; exact Essential branding controls unconfirmed
Free trial14 days, no card14 days7 days
Sources for plans and program fit

Plans checked October 31, 2026: FirstPromoter plans and terms, section 10; Rewardful plans; iDevAffiliate plans. Vendor plan descriptions, not tested features. Affiliate revenue is revenue from referred customers, not total company revenue. Taxes, provider fees and usage overages are extra.

Tracking and billing

Show 4 criteria
Tracking and billing
FeatureFirstPromoterRewardfuliDevAffiliate
Billing connectionsStripe, Paddle (Billing and Classic), Chargebee, Recurly, Braintree; others through APIStripe; Paddle Classic only, per its 2023 Paddle guideIntegration wizard lists Stripe, membership and subscription systems
AttributionLast click by default; first-click option; cookies up to 9,999 daysFirst or last touch; coupon trackingEmail-address and coupon tracking; first/last-click rule unconfirmed
Refunds and commissionsNegative commission when the billing connection or API reports a refund or chargebackStripe refunds recalculate the commission, full or partialRecurring billing described; specific Stripe refund handling unconfirmed
Moving your program inHistorical Stripe import, per pricing pageSupport imports affiliates, referred customers and link tokens; not historical commissionsImport scope not established
Sources for tracking and billing

FirstPromoter integrations, Paddle, campaign settings and refund settings; Rewardful Stripe flow, Paddle guide and import; iDevAffiliate product and integration wizard, checked October 31, 2026. Refund adjustments depend on the billing service reporting the refund.

Paying partners

Show 5 criteria
Paying partners
FeatureFirstPromoterRewardfuliDevAffiliate
Standard way partners get paidExport a CSV for PayPal, Wise, bank or crypto, pay, then mark paidExport a PayPal or Wise CSV, pay, then mark paidProvider payment methods listed; exact Essential workflow unconfirmed
One-click payoutsPayPal from Business, with PayPal Payouts API; Stripe payouts to affiliates’ own Stripe accounts (plan requirement unconfirmed)PayPal on Enterprise only, from $149/monthPayment automation advertised; plan entitlements unconfirmed
Platform pays partners for youEnterprise 2 or higher, SaaS only, after review; via Dots; no current merchant fee statedOptional on every plan; 3% merchant fee plus affiliate withdrawal feesManaged-service fees and entitlements not established
Partner tax formsW-9 and W-8BEN collection on every planCollected within Managed PayoutsTax-ready reporting described; form collection not established
Once money is sentManaged payments cannot be refundedFunded managed payments cannot be cancelledPayment reversal and provider terms not established
Sources for paying partners

FirstPromoter payout methods, Stripe Payouts, managed payouts and plans; Rewardful payouts, Managed Payouts and merchant terms; iDevAffiliate payment-method descriptions, checked October 31, 2026. Marking a payout paid does not prove a transfer arrived. Partner country eligibility and tax obligations were not evaluated.

Exit, terms and data

Show 5 criteria
Exit, terms and data
FeatureFirstPromoterRewardfuliDevAffiliate
ExportsReports in CSV and JSON on every plan; activity log from Enterprise Plan 3Due-payout CSV; full export by support requestExportable reports described; full migration export scope unconfirmed
Cancellation and refundsEnd of paid period; payments non-refundableEnd of paid period; fees nonrefundable, 30-day exception at Rewardful’s discretionNo contracts advertised; cancellation and refund terms unconfirmed
Your data after cancellingNo published deletion timetable; purpose-based retentionAccount content forfeited and not recoverablePost-close retention not established
Data handling to checkOptional AI assistant, off by default, sends account data to Anthropic or OpenAIController for Managed Payouts data; processor for platform dataPrivacy and processing terms not established in this comparison
Operator and ownershipIgil Webs SRL, Romania; sold to SpringWater Capital, September 2025Rewardful Inc.; part of saas.group since 2021Legal operator and ownership not established in this comparison
Sources for exit, terms and data

Billing terms checked October 31, 2026; other evidence October 19. FirstPromoter activity logs, terms, privacy policy and sale report; Rewardful export, terms, merchant terms, privacy and saas.group; iDevAffiliate plans and reporting description, checked October 31, 2026. Rewardful’s full-export guidance dates from 2018. Missing evidence does not mean a feature is unavailable.

What matters when choosing

FirstPromoter Starter is our Practical Pick for a small subscription software business that wants to run its own affiliate program with recurring commissions. It costs $49 a month, or $490 a year, for up to $5,000 a month in revenue from referred customers, up to 1,000 affiliates and three campaigns. Rewardful’s entry plan costs the same, but FirstPromoter’s entry plan includes more of what running a program takes: a partner dashboard with your logo and colors, unlimited team members, W-9 and W-8BEN collection from partners, and report exports in CSV or JSON. It also connects directly to five billing services (Stripe, Paddle, Chargebee, Recurly and Braintree), so the program does not have to move if your billing does. The main compromise is the ceiling: above $5,000 a month in affiliate revenue the account moves to Business at $99, which is also the plan for one-click PayPal payouts and a custom dashboard domain. FirstPromoter plans, billing integrations

Choose Rewardful if you want the software company to pay your partners for you. Rewardful Starter is also $49 a month, covers up to $7,500 a month in affiliate revenue with unlimited affiliates, and offers its optional Managed Payouts service on every plan: you fund one payment, Rewardful distributes it to affiliates and collects their tax details, and you pay a 3% processing fee. FirstPromoter limits its comparable service to its Enterprise tier. Rewardful Starter has no branded portal, one campaign and two team seats, its Paddle connection covers only the older Paddle Classic, and a full data export needs a support request. Rewardful plans, Managed Payouts, Rewardful and Paddle, FirstPromoter managed payouts

iDevAffiliate offers a hosted $42 USD monthly plan for up to 5,000 affiliates and 50,000 clicks a month, but its public documentation is less specific about subscription refunds and what you can take with you when you leave. Choose FirstPromoter for clearer subscription-billing and export documentation. iDevAffiliate plans, integration wizard, checked October 31, 2026.

Tracking software calculates what you owe; on its standard route it does not send the money. With FirstPromoter and Rewardful, the ordinary process is to export a payout file, pay through PayPal, Wise, your bank or another provider, and then mark the payout as paid. A refund reduces a commission only when your billing service reports it. If you have already paid that commission, FirstPromoter describes a negative balance for you to recover, not a return of the money; we could not establish how Rewardful treats a refund after payout. Payments sent through Rewardful’s or FirstPromoter’s managed services cannot be cancelled or refunded once made. FirstPromoter payouts, Rewardful payouts, Rewardful merchant terms, FirstPromoter refund handling

FirstPromoter and Rewardful still list $49 a month or $490 a year in US dollars, checked October 31, 2026. iDevAffiliate lists $42 a month in US dollars. We could not confirm comparable current prices for every alternative. Subscription prices exclude commissions, payment-provider fees, optional managed-payout fees, taxes and usage overages. “Affiliate revenue” means revenue from referred customers, not your total revenue. Three conditions would change our recommendation: you want the platform to pay partners and handle their tax details (choose Rewardful with Managed Payouts), your affiliate revenue sits between $5,000 and $7,500 a month on Stripe (Rewardful stays at $49), or you sell through a store platform or need product-based commissions (see Tapfiliate in our research notes below). Before inviting partners, run one referral through your real checkout, a renewal and a partial refund, and check that the balance matches your billing records. This is a software comparison, not tax or legal advice about paying affiliates.

Disclosure: Practical Picks articles are researched and written with AI, currently Anthropic’s Claude. FirstPromoter documents connecting Claude to its MCP server, and Rewardful promotes a skill for Claude. We have no relationship with FirstPromoter, Rewardful or Anthropic over this article, and these Claude links carried no weight in our judgment. FirstPromoter MCP, Rewardful

FirstPromoter

Preferred Pick · a small subscription business

$49/moStarter · up to $5,000/mo affiliate revenue

Choose FirstPromoter Starter to run a subscription business’s affiliate program on Stripe or another supported billing service, while affiliate revenue stays under $5,000 a month. It includes a branded partner dashboard, tax-form collection and self-serve exports on its entry plan.

Reasons to choose it

  • Connects directly to Stripe, Paddle, Chargebee, Recurly and Braintree
  • Branded partner dashboard, unlimited team members and three campaigns on Starter
  • W-9 and W-8BEN collection and CSV or JSON report exports on every plan

What to watch

  • Above $5,000 a month in affiliate revenue, Business at $99 applies
  • One-click PayPal payouts need Business; a managed payout service needs Enterprise
  • Sold to new owners in September 2025

FirstPromoter Starter costs $49 a month or $490 a year in US dollars and covers up to $5,000 a month in revenue from referred customers, up to 1,000 affiliates and three campaigns, with unlimited team members and a 14-day trial that needs no card. Its pricing page lists these on Starter: referral links on your own domain, coupon tracking, first- or last-click attribution with cookies of up to 9,999 days, recurring commissions, a partner dashboard with your logo and colors, W-9 and W-8BEN collection, and CSV and JSON report exports. Passing the revenue limit moves the account to the next tier; it does not stop tracking. These are FirstPromoter’s descriptions of the plan, not results we observed. Plans and features, checked October 31, 2026, currency, terms section 10

Choose Rewardful instead if you want the software company to pay affiliates for you. FirstPromoter’s managed payout service requires an Enterprise tier, an account review and a separate agreement, and it is offered only to software-as-a-service companies. One-click PayPal payouts, a custom dashboard domain and a dashboard embedded in your own app all need Business at $99 a month. Plans, managed payouts, August 21, 2026, embedded dashboard

Read the full FirstPromoter analysis and sources

FirstPromoter says Stripe, Paddle, Chargebee, Recurly and Braintree connect directly and that other billing systems connect through its API, which reports sales, refunds, upgrades and cancellations. Its Paddle page says the connection works with both Paddle Billing and Paddle Classic, and its pricing page says historical Stripe data can be imported when you migrate. Campaigns use last-click attribution by default, with a first-click option. Refunds and chargebacks become negative commissions when the billing connection or API reports them; a missing event remains an integration problem for you to find. Integrations, Paddle integration, campaign settings, May 6, 2026, refund and fraud settings, May 21, 2026

Its payout guide describes three routes: one-click payouts through a PayPal or Stripe connection, a bulk CSV you upload to your provider, or individual payments you make yourself and then mark paid. One-click PayPal needs Business or higher, a PayPal Business account and PayPal’s Payouts API, which PayPal can take weeks to enable. Stripe Payouts, described as new in July 2026, sends money from your Stripe balance to affiliates who connect their own Stripe accounts; a payout fails if your balance is short. The pricing page lists Stripe among payout methods on every plan, but we could not confirm whether the automated Stripe route has a plan requirement. We found no FirstPromoter statement about payment providers’ own fees, so budget for them separately. Payout methods, July 13, 2026, Stripe Payouts, July 1, 2026

The managed service currently requires Enterprise 2 or higher. You pay one monthly invoice and FirstPromoter pays affiliates through Dots, typically 7 to 10 days after it receives your payment. The guide states no current merchant fee; affiliates pay withdrawal fees, and FirstPromoter says it cannot refund a payment once made. The terms place managed payouts under separate agreements with FP Partners LLC, which we did not read. Managed payouts, terms, section 15

Leaving is partly documented. Report exports are on every plan, but the activity log, an audit trail of who changed what, requires Enterprise Plan 3 or higher. Cancellation takes effect at the end of the paid period and payments are non-refundable. We found no published deletion timetable; the privacy policy, updated July 4, 2026, ties retention to the purpose of processing. Its optional AI assistant is off by default. When an account turns it on, the terms say messages and the account data needed to answer go to Anthropic, with OpenAI as a fallback, both processing in the United States, and that this data is not used to train their models. Activity logs, terms, sections 9 and 13, June 25, 2026, privacy policy

The terms name Igil Webs SRL in Romania as the platform’s owner. In September 2025 the sell-side adviser to the founder reported that FirstPromoter had been sold to SpringWater Capital. We found no announced product or pricing change linked to the sale, and an ownership change says nothing either way about future support. Terms, L40° interview, September 24, 2025

Used FirstPromoter? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Rewardful

Also consider · partners paid for you

$49/moStarter · up to $7,500/mo affiliate revenue

Choose Rewardful when you bill through Stripe and want the platform to pay partners and collect their tax details, for a 3% fee on payouts, without moving to an enterprise plan.

Reasons to choose it

  • Optional Managed Payouts on every plan
  • Higher entry ceiling and unlimited affiliates for $49
  • Stripe refunds recalculate commissions, full or partial

What to watch

  • Paddle Classic only; no Chargebee, Recurly or Braintree documentation
  • No branded portal, one campaign and two team seats on Starter
  • Full export by support request; content forfeited after cancelling

Rewardful Starter costs $49 a month or $490 a year in US dollars and covers up to $7,500 a month in affiliate-attributed revenue, with unlimited affiliates, one campaign, up to two team members and a 14-day trial. Growth at $99 a month adds a branded affiliate portal, a custom domain and unlimited campaigns, up to $15,000. Every plan lists first- or last-touch attribution, coupon tracking, REST API access and no transaction fee on affiliate revenue. Plans, checked October 31, 2026

Its distinctive option is Managed Payouts, available on every plan. You fund one payment from a bank account connected through Stripe’s ACH debit; Rewardful then distributes the money, affiliates withdraw it by bank transfer, PayPal, Wise or other methods depending on their location, and Rewardful collects the tax and identity information their country requires. You pay a 3% processing fee, affiliates pay their own withdrawal fees, and retrying a failed payout can cost extra. The merchant terms say funded commission payments cannot be cancelled and that Rewardful is not responsible for late or erroneous payments. We could not establish whether a bank account outside the United States can fund payouts. Managed Payouts FAQ, August 5, 2025, merchant terms, April 9, 2025

Read the full Rewardful analysis and sources

Stripe is Rewardful’s main connection. It reads Stripe events, recalculates a commission after a full or partial refund, and writes reference data back to Stripe. A customer who converts outside tracking, for example on another device, can be assigned to an affiliate by hand. Its Paddle guide, dated October 31, 2023 and still published, says Rewardful supports only Paddle Classic, not the newer Paddle Billing, and cannot run Stripe and Paddle Classic together. We found no Rewardful documentation of Chargebee, Recurly or Braintree connections. Stripe commission flow, May 15, 2026, Paddle guide

Without Managed Payouts, Rewardful emails you on the first of the month when commissions are due. You download a CSV formatted for PayPal mass payments or Wise batch payments, send the money yourself and mark the payouts paid; Rewardful says it has no access to your funds. One-click PayPal payouts require Enterprise, from $149 a month. Under the merchant terms, affiliate earnings left unwithdrawn in Managed Payouts for 24 months incur an 8.33% monthly administrative fee, charged to the affiliate. Paying commissions, February 3, 2026, plans, merchant terms

Plan the exit before you start. Rewardful’s full-data export is a support request, described in a help article from 2018. Under the general terms, you cancel by email, cancellation takes effect at the end of the paid period, and the account’s content is forfeited and cannot be recovered afterward. The merchant terms make fees nonrefundable, with an exception within the first 30 days at Rewardful’s discretion. The pricing page no longer shows the 30-day refund answer we cited in September. Moving to Rewardful, its support team imports affiliates, referred customers and link tokens, but not historical commissions. Export, June 24, 2018, general terms, April 9, 2025, merchant terms, import, August 29, 2024

The privacy policy effective September 2, 2026 says Rewardful processes platform data on its customers’ behalf but acts as the controller for data in Managed Payouts, so read it before moving partner records into that service. Retention periods are available on request. Rewardful Inc. has been part of saas.group since an acquisition announced in November 2021. Privacy, acquisition announcement

Used Rewardful? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

iDevAffiliate

Hosted alternative · $42 USD monthly

$42/moEssential · 5,000 affiliates, 50,000 clicks/mo

Consider iDevAffiliate when 5,000 affiliates and 50,000 clicks a month cover your needs and its integration wizard covers your billing setup. FirstPromoter has clearer subscription and export documentation.

Reasons to choose it

  • Hosted plan; no server required
  • Up to 5,000 affiliates and 50,000 clicks a month
  • Integration wizard lists Stripe and subscription systems

What to watch

  • Exact Stripe renewal and refund behavior unconfirmed
  • Developer API/webhooks and custom subdomain need Professional at $59 USD
  • Complete exports, cancellation and retention terms unconfirmed

iDevAffiliate Essential is a hosted affiliate-program service at $42 USD a month, with up to 5,000 affiliates, 50,000 clicks a month and unlimited commissions. The pricing page offers a seven-day trial, a live 30-minute onboarding session, no contract and no transaction fees. No annual cloud discount is listed. You do not need to run a server; its separate $499 self-hosted licence is a different purchase. Plans, checked October 31, 2026

Its integration wizard lists Stripe alongside subscription and membership systems. The maker describes email-based attribution for repeat purchases and recurring billing, coupon commissions, percentage or flat-rate rewards and performance bonuses. Those are documented capabilities, not a test of renewal or refund accuracy. We could not establish the exact automatic refund-reconciliation behavior for a Stripe subscription. Professional at $59 USD a month adds developer API/webhooks, a custom subdomain and higher allowances. Integrations, product description, checked October 31, 2026.

Read the full iDevAffiliate analysis and sources

Choose it when its 5,000-affiliate and 50,000-click allowances fit and its integration wizard covers your billing setup. The maker lists payment methods including PayPal, Stripe, Wise and bank transfers, but we could not establish Essential’s exact automation entitlements, provider fees or tax-form collection. Its product page describes exportable reports, while complete migration exports, cancellation/refund terms and post-close retention remain unconfirmed. FirstPromoter is the better documented choice for this subscription-business job. Confirm those details before moving partner records. Product and reporting, plans, checked October 31, 2026.

Used iDevAffiliate? Share your experience to help other readers choose.

Which product are we missing?

Know a product that belongs in this article? Tell us what it does differently and why it deserves a closer look. Newcomers welcome.

Readers and product teams can suggest candidates. Suggestions inform our research; they do not guarantee inclusion or a recommendation.

Suggest a product

Opens an email draft with this article attached as a link. Nothing is sent until you send it.

No email app? Send the product name, website, and this article’s title to admin@practicalpicks.guide.

What people are saying

Public user reports are a check on vendor claims, not a measure of tracking accuracy. A February 2026 startup discussion we read on September 7 included vendor participation, contrasting opinions and tracking complaints that it did not substantiate; it helped us decide which questions to ask about tracking and migration, not how to rank reliability. Our October 19 searches mostly returned comparison pages written by these vendors or their competitors, which we did not use as evidence, and no newer independent user reports. Our October 19 search for complaints, outages, breaches, lawsuits and regulator actions involving FirstPromoter, Rewardful and Tapfiliate since September found nothing that changed those assessments; a search that finds nothing is not proof that nothing exists. Public discussion

How we researched

This is public-source research. We did not create accounts, sign in, install tracking scripts, connect billing, process refunds, export data or send payouts, and no vendor supplied access or payment for this work. We first compared FirstPromoter, Rewardful and Tapfiliate on September 7, 2026 and rechecked their material claims on October 19, 2026: prices, plan limits, billing connections, refund handling, payout routes and fees, managed-payout terms, exports, cancellation, privacy and ownership. We added iDevAffiliate from its public plans, product description and integration wizard on October 31. FirstPromoter’s privacy policy is hosted by Iubenda and linked from FirstPromoter’s privacy page.

We chose the three tools for a small software business running its own affiliate program: two tools built around subscription billing and a hosted alternative with a lower monthly list price. We judged them on billing connections and commission accuracy, how partners get paid, cost at small scale, exit and records, and the partner-facing program. We fixed those criteria and their weights before comparing the tools. FirstPromoter remains our recommendation for that reader; choose Rewardful when a managed payout service matters more than FirstPromoter’s entry-plan features. We do not claim measured tracking accuracy or guaranteed transfers.

On October 31, 2026, we revisited newer affiliate tools using product announcements, documentation, changelogs and legal pages. No Rising Star selected: we could not establish a qualifying first public release and the other evidence needed for a newcomer recommendation. Public launch directories and independent review pages were not readable. A product’s age or lack of independent reviews alone does not tell us whether it works well.

Tapfiliate remains relevant for stores using Shopify, WooCommerce, BigCommerce or product-based commission rules. Launch lists $89 a month for one program, 50 affiliates, 5,000 clicks and 500 conversions; Scale lists $179 and adds product rules and Trolley automation. Launch overages are $1.50 per 1,000 clicks and $15 per 1,000 conversions. Its own hands-free payout service was still announced as coming soon on October 31; today you settle commissions and pay through your provider. A refund after payout leaves a negative balance to recover; its Stripe connection tracks conversions and does not pay affiliates. Current terms keep access through the paid period, make subscriptions non-refundable apart from billing errors reported within 30 days or vendor termination without breach, and allow content deletion after closure. Export first. Plans, payout guide, terms, checked October 31, 2026.

We also considered Post Affiliate Pro, LeadDyno, Refersion, PartnerStack and GoAffPro. Post Affiliate Pro’s entry offer carries an expired promotional date; LeadDyno’s annual-discount statements conflict; Refersion adds a percentage of referred sales to its subscription charge. PartnerStack requires a quote. GoAffPro offers a free store-focused plan and custom setup, but its documentation did not establish standalone subscription-renewal tracking for this job. Post Affiliate Pro plans, LeadDyno plans, Refersion plans, PartnerStack plans, GoAffPro setup, checked October 31, 2026.

ToolPublic sourcesWhat remains uncertain
FirstPromoterOctober 2026 plans, integrations and Paddle page, payout, Stripe Payouts, managed payout, campaign, refund, embed and activity-log help, June 2026 terms, July 2026 privacy policy, September 2025 sale report.Plan requirement for Stripe Payouts, managed-service contract and Enterprise tier prices, deletion timing, plans under new ownership.
RewardfulOctober 2026 plans, Managed Payouts, payout, Stripe, Paddle, export and import help, April 2025 terms, September 2026 privacy policy, 2021 acquisition notice.Paddle Billing support after 2023, treatment of a refund after payout, non-US funding for managed payouts, export contents and timing, how the discretionary refund is applied.
TapfiliateOctober 31 plans and terms; October 19 payout, payment-method, commission and account-lifecycle help, privacy policy, 2023 group announcement.Currency and exact annual invoice, refund handling per integration, hands-free payout launch, deletion after closure.
iDevAffiliateOctober 31 cloud plans, product description and integration wizard.Stripe renewal/refund behavior, payout entitlements and fees, complete export, cancellation and retention terms.
Other alternatives and newer toolsProduct, pricing, release and legal pages checked October 31; Polar integration documentation.First public release dates, operator details, some current prices and independent adverse evidence remain unconfirmed.

None of this establishes attribution accuracy, correct refund adjustments, successful transfers, partner eligibility in a given country or security in practice. The next substantive review is due December 18, 2026, or sooner if a price, payout service or term changes. Found a changed fee or term? Contact the editors.

Sources and evidence

Sources were checked October 19, 2026 unless another date is given. Pricing, selected billing terms and newcomer documentation were checked October 31, 2026; the remaining incumbent evidence retains its earlier date. Vendor material establishes documented offers and contract terms, not tracking accuracy or successful payment.

This is a researched comparison, not a product review. No vendor supplied an account or took part in this comparison, and product links are ordinary source links with no affiliate arrangement. Method: evidence standard, editorial picks.