Practical Picks PP-291: earlier hands-on check record, October 3, 2026 Observed 2026-10-03 UTC, Linux x86-64. Four invented PNG images; no real photos. Historical record. This small check ran on October 3, 2026, before Practical Picks adopted its research-only method later that day. It is kept as dated, bounded evidence. It is not current testing, and it did not decide the article's recommendations, which since October 20, 2026 rest on public sources. It covered only Czkawka CLI 12.0.2 and PhotoDedupe 1.0.7, not Krokiet, digiKam or dupeGuru. Practical Picks no longer runs product checks; the replay instructions below describe how this historical record was produced. Note, October 20, 2026: the Czkawka CLI guide still documents the behaviour observed here. The dry run (-Q) changes nothing, a selected delete method (-D) deletes permanently unless -y is added, and exit code 11 means matches were found. PhotoDedupe's README still says it only lists paths and that duplicates should not be deleted without manual inspection. Download these eight files, keeping fixtures/ next to replay.py: /assets/pp291/acquire.sh ; /assets/pp291/replay.py ; /assets/pp291/replay-results.json ; /assets/pp291/fixtures/original.png ; /assets/pp291/fixtures/exact-copy.png ; /assets/pp291/fixtures/same-pixels-metadata.png ; /assets/pp291/fixtures/near-lookalike.png ; and this method.txt. The replay checks all fixture SHA-256 digests before scanning. The raw JSON retains exact arguments, stdout, stderr, exits, binary digests and recovery assertions. On Linux x86-64, with curl, tar, sha256sum and Python 3, use an empty task-local directory. From the downloaded directory: bash acquire.sh "$PWD/pp291-tools" python3 replay.py "$PWD/pp291-tools/czkawka_cli" "$PWD/pp291-tools/photodedupe_1_0_7_linux_x86/photodedupe" "$PWD/pp291-replay-results.json" The acquisition script downloads Czkawka CLI 12.0.2 from https://github.com/qarmin/czkawka/releases/download/12.0.2/linux_czkawka_cli_x86_64 and PhotoDedupe 1.0.7 from https://github.com/InexplicableMagic/photodedupe/releases/download/v1.0.7/photodedupe_1_0_7_linux_x86.tar.gz . It compares their SHA-256 digests with our observed values 61e7e8ac3f42338957ddc0739df653b9df6ff2958cab3b4cce14663b39c40843 and ba7fc6a19b25f1a2f123cebec280efae1c130b138eec9574f8143dda99ab2c47. These are our acquisition checks, not publisher signatures. The fresh downloaded and extracted task-local tree was 66 MB. No system install occurs. Fixtures: original.png is invented 256x256 colored art. exact-copy.png has identical bytes. same-pixels-metadata.png decodes to identical RGB pixels but includes a synthetic PNG Description text chunk and has different bytes. near-lookalike.png has a conspicuous extra rectangle and is a control, not a claimed duplicate. We verified decoded-pixel equivalence with Pillow in research; replay needs only Python's standard library and the provided PNG bytes. Replay makes two separate temporary copies and sets HOME, XDG_CACHE_HOME and XDG_DATA_HOME inside its temporary directory. Czkawka commands use `dup -m 1 -s HASH -H -x IMAGE` and `image -m 1 -H -x IMAGE`. The 1-byte floor is required because tiny synthetic PNGs fall below its default minimum. Byte mode listed only original and exact copy. Similar-image mode also listed the metadata variant, and did not list the altered control. Exit 11 meant findings, as documented by Czkawka; it was not a failed scan. `image ... -D AEN -Q` previewed two would-delete paths and changed no file. `image ... -D AEN -y` moved the same two from a disposable copy into task-local OS trash. Replay checked Trash/files and Trash/info, then manually moved them back and verified all four original digests. SAFETY: `-y` is Czkawka's opt-in move-to-trash switch. Once a delete method such as `-D AEN` is selected, omitting `-y` performs permanent deletion by default. Do not copy a destructive command without `-Q` preview, `-y`, and a separate backup. AEN keeps the newest by timestamp, not necessarily the best image. OS trash may fail on network or other filesystems. Our manual restoration is not a native undo command. PhotoDedupe listed the same three-image candidate group. `--duplicates` emitted two file paths. Replay moved those paths to a separate task-local quarantine with Python, then moved them back and matched all four digests. PhotoDedupe itself did not quarantine, trash, or undo anything. Its documentation warns fuzzy matches need manual inspection; do not pipe its output to an unreviewed delete command. This was one tiny invented PNG set. It does not measure false-positive rates, different encodings/resolutions, HEIC/RAW, large libraries, alternate thresholds, removable/network trash, or real photo value. No real photo, personal metadata, account or cloud service was used. Both tested local binaries cost $0 and needed no account. Review each candidate visually and preserve originals before any real cleanup.