# PP-284 earlier hands-on check record, October 3, 2026: how the zone-file checks were run

Historical record. This check ran on October 3, 2026, before Practical Picks adopted its research-only method later that day. It is kept as dated evidence and does not describe current testing; the comparison now rests on public sources. See the notes added October 19, 2026 on the [record index](index.html).

Run October 3, 2026 on Ubuntu 24.04 amd64. The [five fixtures](valid.zone), [replay wrapper](replay.sh), [package runner](run-smoke.py), [current validns builder](build-current-validns.py), and [current validns runner](run-current-validns.py) are public together. Individual changed fixtures: [bad A syntax](syntax.zone), [missing MX address](missing-mx.zone), [CNAME conflict](cname-conflict.zone), and [missing child glue](missing-glue.zone). Captured outputs: [initial `-p all` policy](smoke-policy-all.json), [calibrated package matrix](smoke-results.json), and [current validns matrix](current-validns-results.json).

On a comparable Ubuntu 24.04 amd64 host with `apt-get`, `dpkg-deb`, Python 3, GCC, curl, tar and SHA-256 tools, download this directory's fixtures and scripts together, then run:

```bash
PP284_WORKDIR="$PWD/pp284-work" bash replay.sh
```

The wrapper downloads exact Ubuntu package versions with `apt-get download`, extracts `.deb` files into that task directory with `dpkg-deb -x`, downloads the official [DNS-OARC validns v0.11.0 source archive](https://codeberg.org/DNS-OARC/validns/archive/v0.11.0.tar.gz), checks SHA-256 `56162037254d488136081f1c5e56f9946bdda5100d3da4873fd58691c9188ce7`, and builds the 60 upstream listed C files with local Judy/OpenSSL development files. It runs the original `validns -p all` setup, the calibrated package matrix, and the current validns matrix. Results stay under `PP284_WORKDIR`. The scripts accept any task-local `PP284_WORKDIR`; no private ops path is required. The test uses host runtime libraries already present on that Ubuntu host. It performs no package installation, DNS query, zone upload, or system change.

Our download total was about 4.1 MB and task-local extraction/build footprint about 25 MB. A fresh replay should budget under 100 MB for downloads plus extraction, but package availability and host runtime libraries can change. A direct GCC source build is the bounded binary we tested; this does not certify upstream packaging or the full validns test suite. Absolute paths in the retained JSON record where our original run occurred; replayed paths will differ.

To obtain all linked files without cloning this repository, save each script and `.zone` file shown above in the same directory. Their raw URLs on Practical Picks are under `/assets/pp284/`. `replay.sh` does not need the previously captured JSON files to execute.
