Practical Picks PP-257 local formatter comparison Historical record, labelled October 19, 2026: this earlier hands-on check was made on October 1, 2026, before Practical Picks adopted its research-only method on October 3, 2026. It is kept as dated, bounded evidence of what these versions did on one small synthetic fixture. It is not current testing and did not decide the article's current Pick. Versions have changed since: on October 19, 2026 Prettier 3.9.10 and Oxfmt 0.74.0 were current; prettier-plugin-tailwindcss 0.8.1, @ianvs/prettier-plugin-sort-imports 4.7.1 and @biomejs/biome 2.5.15 were still the latest releases. See the article for current findings. Observed 2026-10-01 UTC on Linux x86-64; Node 22.23.3. Synthetic fixture only. No editor extension, CI runner, speed or production project tested. Download pp257-fixture-v1.zip from /assets/pp257/pp257-fixture-v1.zip. SHA-256: e0d1bf6db74f31ee909abf2d8bc0a3d49adbfc9c790073355ad77fb263c44c23 Extract it into an isolated folder and run: npm ci --ignore-scripts --no-audit --no-fund node run.mjs Pinned packages in package.json and package-lock.json: prettier 3.9.9 prettier-plugin-tailwindcss 0.8.1 @ianvs/prettier-plugin-sort-imports 4.7.1 @biomejs/biome 2.5.15 oxfmt 0.71.0 tailwindcss 4.1.13 (fixture stylesheet dependency) Fixture input.tsx begins: import { zebra } from "./zebra"; import "./register-b"; import { alpha } from "./alpha"; import "./register-a"; Its class string is: text-white p-4 bg-blue-600 flex rounded-lg Configuration: Prettier: plugins ["@ianvs/prettier-plugin-sort-imports", "prettier-plugin-tailwindcss"], tailwindStylesheet "./style.css". Biome: assist/source/organizeImports "on"; generated.tsx excluded. Oxfmt: sortImports true; sortTailwindcss stylesheet "./style.css"; generated.tsx excluded. Command patterns run on fresh copies: prettier FILE --check ; prettier --write FILE ; prettier --write FILE ; prettier FILE --check biome check FILE ; biome check --write FILE ; biome check --write FILE ; biome check FILE oxfmt FILE --check ; oxfmt FILE ; oxfmt FILE ; oxfmt FILE --check Each also checks invalid.tsx and explicitly named ignored generated.tsx. Observed check/write/check exits: Prettier: 1 / 0 / 0 / 0. Second write byte-identical. Invalid: 2, parser error. Explicit ignored file: 0 with generic all-matched message. Biome: 1 / 0 / 0 / 0. Second write byte-identical. Invalid: 1, parse error. Explicit ignored file: 1, no files processed. Oxfmt: 1 / 0 / 0 / 0. Second write byte-identical. Invalid: 2, unexpected token. Explicit ignored file: 2, no target file. Output differences: Prettier and Oxfmt class order: flex rounded-lg bg-blue-600 p-4 text-white. Biome class order: unchanged. Prettier and Biome sorted contiguous value imports within each side-effect-import partition. Oxfmt moved value imports across bare side-effect imports under sortImports: true. Behavior fixture: behavior.mjs imports zebra, then register-b, then alpha, then register-a. Before formatting: exit 0, "zebra,register-b,alpha,register-a" then "3". Prettier after formatting: same output, exit 0. Biome after formatting: same output, exit 0. Oxfmt after formatting: alpha moved above zebra; exit 1 at alpha.mjs:1, TypeError: Cannot read properties of undefined (reading 'push') This is an observed module-initialization failure in the synthetic fixture, not a claim about the frequency of Oxfmt failures in real projects. The ZIP contains exact synthetic sources, configurations, lockfile and runner. The .tsx.txt and .ts.txt suffixes keep intentionally invalid fixture files out of the publication project's build; the runner copies them to temporary source paths for each test and removes those copies after testing.