Practical Picks PP-243: earlier synthetic PDF page-change check (historical record) Run 2026-10-01, before Practical Picks adopted its research-only method on 2026-10-03. Kept as dated, bounded evidence. It was not repeated in the 2026-10-19 review and did not decide the current recommendation. Private release candidate, not a public approval. Environment Headless Chromium 151.0.7922.34 through Playwright 1.62.1 on Linux. Unregistered, public browser routes. No purchase, account, sensitive file, or vendor contact. Fixture generated by research/PP-243/make-fixture.mjs: three-pages.pdf, 1,129 bytes, PDF 1.4, 3 Letter pages, no initial rotation, selectable Helvetica text: page 1 ALPHA page one; page 2 BRAVO page two; page 3 CHARLIE page three. Matched task A: rotate original page 2 right by 90 degrees, reverse all pages, save and download. PDF24 used Assemble PDF's per-page Rotate right and Reverse the page order controls. iLovePDF used Organize PDF's page 2 Rotate and Order pages by number descending control. Result checked with pdfinfo -f 1 -l 3 and pdftotext -layout: PDF24: 3 pages; rotations 0, 90, 0; text CHARLIE / BRAVO / ALPHA. iLovePDF: 3 pages; rotations 0, 90, 0; text CHARLIE / BRAVO / ALPHA. The full unique line on each page remained extractable. Visual fidelity beyond the small generated fixture was not tested. Matched task B: start fresh with the original, delete original page 2, save and download. Both routes produced 2 pages with extractable ALPHA / CHARLIE. Browser network observation PDF24: POST requests to a filetools*.pdf24.org /client.php processing host after save. The page also made analytics and advertising requests, including PDF24 Matomo, Google Analytics and ad services. The request trace supports server processing; it does not establish deletion, security, or what data every ad and analytics destination received. iLovePDF: POST to api*.ilovepdf.com /v1/upload and /v1/process. Google Analytics POST requests were also seen. The request trace is not a privacy audit. Upload bodies were not retained. No claim that PDF bytes went to analytics or advertising destinations is made. Source and reproduction files research/PP-243/make-fixture.mjs generates the PDF. research/PP-243/test-routes.mjs runs the four browser export paths. research/PP-243/verify-outputs.mjs asserts the count, per-page rotation, and exact extracted text for all four downloads. research/PP-243/three-pages.pdf, pdf24-output.pdf, ilovepdf-output.pdf, pdf24-delete.pdf and ilovepdf-delete.pdf are the non-sensitive test files. Check the exported PDFs with pdfinfo and pdftotext from Poppler. Limits No large or malformed files, scans, annotations, links, form fields, bookmarks, digital signatures, accessibility tags, real devices, account gates, payment paths, deletion timing, or long-term availability tested.